A new injustice has now come from the Appeal Court ruling that the detention of Serdar Mohammed, a suspected Afghan bombmaker, for 110 days without charge was illegal under that legislation. The case dates back to the time when our soldiers were doing their duty in Afghanistan, literally at risk to life and limb. It was war, and if the choice was between risking some injustice to a suspected Afghan bomb maker or risking the life of a British soldier, I know which risk I would have taken. However, Sapna Malik, a partner at the law firm Leigh Day which brought the case, called it "upholding" the law. I would have called it Mr Malik laughing all the way to the bank, as there may be anything up to 80 cases more in prospect.