Pretty Little Liars has been on T.V. for so many years that it’s hard to keep track of which mysteries are which, who knows what, and what is where. As the great Hanna Marin once said, “The truth is like a big bowl of spaghetti that’s all tangled. Have you ever untangled spaghetti?” Yeah, exactly.

What makes the series even more frustrating (and ridiculously addicting) is the fact that every single character is a liar. Every. Single. One. Even I. Marlene King, the show’s creator has admitted to lying on Twitter, tangling the PLL truth-spaghetti ten times more!

Sometimes, it’s fairly obvious when one of the characters of Pretty Little Liars being extra cryptic in order to hide a secret. Each line is so packed with meaning that drama can go from 0 to A real quick. You know what else contains very dramatic lines packed with meaning? Emo song lyrics.

We’ve gathered a selection of some of the best PLL quotes and emo song lyrics — see if you can tell them apart. The answers are at the bottom of each page. Good luck, and remember: hAve fun!

1. “Knowing the right question is better than knowing all the right answers.”

2. “Sometimes I get the feeling she’s watching over me.”

3. “She’s gone, but she’s everywhere.”

4. “Bad idea to wake a sleepwalker.”

5. “There’s just too much that time cannot erase.”

Answers:

1. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Caleb

2. Emo Song Lyric: My Chemical Romance

3. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Spencer

4. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Ezra

5. Emo Song Lyric: Evanescence

6. “Once you know something, you can’t unknow it.”

7. “You didn’t even know me when you knew me.”

8. “I try to picture me without you, but I can’t.”

9. “When you love someone. It’s worth fighting for, no matter what the odds.”

10. “Ever wonder what goes on when your back is turned?”

Answers:

6. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Alison

7. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Alison

8. Emo Song Lyric: Fall Out Boy

9. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Aria

10. Pretty Little Liars Quote: A11. “Well, if you wanted honesty, that’s all you had to say. I never want to let you down or have you go, it’s better off this way.”

12. “You know what they say about hope? It breeds eternal misery”

13. “Second chances they don’t ever matter, people never change.”

14. “Girls don’t like boys. Girls like cars and money.”

15. “Rich girls steal, pretty girls lie, smart girls play dumb and the dumb girls spend their days trying to be all of the above.”

Answers:

11. Emo Song Lyric: My Chemical Romance

12. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Spencer

13. Emo Song Lyric: Paramore

14. Emo Song Lyric: Good Charlotte

15. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Caleb

16. “Hope dangles on a string, like slow spinning redemption.”

17. “People leave, people die, that’s the only sure thing in the world.”

18. “We’ve all made mistakes. Remember, I’m still paying for yours.”

19. “What will it take to show you that it’s not the life it seems?”

20. “How do you keep going when the worst thing has happened? What do you have to change inside to survive? Who do you have to become? … You don’t know who I am anymore. And you can’t count on me.”

Answers:

16. Emo Song Lyric: Dashboard Confessional

17. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Mike

18. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Jenna

19. Emo Song Lyric: My Chemical Romance

20. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Spencer

21. “Pretending not to love you was the hardest thing I’ve ever done.”

22. “But you’re just a line in a song.”

23. “Friends share secrets, that’s what keeps us close.”

24. “Dead girls can’t smile.”

25. “There’s nothing simple about lying.”

Answers:

21. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Toby

22. Emo Song Lyric: Fall Out Boy

23. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Alison

24. Pretty Little Liars Quote: A

25. Pretty Little Liars Quote: Emily