With the recent news that four players from Big Brother 18 will be joining the Season 31 cast for MTV’s Challenge, the concept of more players from the franchise joining the fold becomes tantalizing. It’s almost like the fan-fiction of tons of reality fans are finally coming together. We get to see the combination of two major franchises, one being a gigantic network show, and the other being a classic cable syndicate.

So I decided to try my hand at finding the Big Brother players from recent seasons who would integrate the best into the show. I’m looking for the people would bring it from a physical standpoint, and the ones that will bring it in the house. My focus is on the recent seasons in order to narrow the roster of people to choose from, and I figure that the social media generation is who MTV is more geared towards casting anyway. I am also not including the people cast for Season 31 already. Victor Arroyo would definitely make the list if I did, Corey Brooks is a maybe, and Natalie Negrotti/Michelle Meyer would be definite no’s.

Let’s go.

Paulie Calafiore — Big Brother 18