Rated 5 out of 5 by KarlaIJWW from Great product Brilliant color payoff and very easy to blend! Would recommend setting with a shadow as they never set fully, but still an inexpensive and reliable color base that I've fallen in love with. I wish people wouldn't leave low reviews because they didn't realize they needed to sharpen it, the pencil works fine and you receive a lot of product if you know how to properly sharpen it. I do wish that the discontinued colors would come back, I always loved this pencil because of its wide and colorful shade range, and seeing it slim down to just bare neutrals is a little disappointing. However that's just a personal note. I would definitely recommend these :-)

Rated 2 out of 5 by Anonymous2029 from You have to sharpen it?!? Honestly I didn’t know I had to sharpen it because the packaging didn’t look like it had to be sharpened. I’m honestly annoyed by that. I don’t understand who decided that was a good idea. I don’t like sharpen things because it never turns out good

Rated 1 out of 5 by Jendoll from Far from professional makeup Literally the worst eye pencil/crayon I have ever purchased. Sure, it glides on smoothly - but it also doesn't stay put. I've been fighting it running down my lashes and onto the lenses of my glasses for the past 8 hours. Within 3 hours of application, I had circles around my eyes like a raccoon. This product needs a LOT of improvement.

Rated 1 out of 5 by RC5ma from Not retractable The pencil is not retractable and not worth the price. Deceiving packaging.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Classylady from Purple Velvet is my fav I am surprised by the negative reviews. I love these jumbo eyeliners. And yes, you need to sharpen them, but it is so easy. And they last. The retractable ones break off so I love the fact that we sharpen these. Whenever I wear this eyeliner, people say my eyes look stunning. The fact that the pencil is thicker, it goes on my eyes so easily, much better than a thin eyeliner.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Glitterguru from Smallest amount of product ever Not only does this crease in about an hour, it's the smallest amount of product ever!! This Nick stick, but only the top has the pigment. Nope this stick does not roll up with more product. It's cheap, but still. I thought I was buying more than a cm of shadow...

Rated 2 out of 5 by chaisegirl from Love the color and texture, but... LIke many other reviewers, I didn't realize this product had to be sharpened. It's not indicated anywhere on the packaging, or shelf display. PLUS, it's made of plastic. Sharpening a plastic pencil just doesn't make sense (as so many others have already mentioned). I'm VERY upset that I spent my money on something I didn't want. And I would like you to correct the display/packaging problems so other people don't have the same issue. DO YOU HAVE a comparable pencil that's retractable?