Tupelo Cap-Toe Oxford is rated 3.5 out of 5 by 24 .

Rated 5 out of 5 by Paul48130 from Soft Soled Comfort I've long admired A&E shoes and am glad that I finally purchased these as an introductory pair. The quality is definitely there, the leather is well crafted and the stitching is well done; the reality is these are a very nice looking pair of shoes. I also really like the soft outer sole with the semi-rugged tread, they offer a outdoors touch to a classic shoe; the real benefit is the comfort, these shoes are super comfortable for all day wear. A word about sizing, I wear a true size 11 with a somewhat narrow foot with a high arch, these fit very comfortably. Bottom line is that these were a great purchase.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Anonymous from Perfect fit . . . expensive look. I now have 4 pair of Allen Edmonds shoes including these Tupelo's They look great with jeans and are lighter weight than I expected. Perfect for all around use - and certainly can be used for inclement weather etc . . .

Rated 1 out of 5 by Bcjoe241 from Received shoes that had scratches and scuffs. I had originally purchased factory seconds of the Tupelo cap toe in tan. Upon receiving them they were in pretty good condition so I ordered a pair of “new” Tupelo’s. I was very surprised and disappointed in the shoes. There were scuffs indented in the leather and the quality of the shoes were worse then the factory seconds that I purchased. Sending back for a refund.