You always remember your first.

And New Girl will be flashing back to Jess (Zooey Deschanel), Nick (Jake Johnson) and the rest of the gang's respective first times in the Fox hit's April 30 episode "Virgins." And while some girls lose their V-card to a less-than-ideal partner, Jess was rather lucky in that department as she lands Teen Wolf fan favorite Dylan O'Brien!

We've got your exclusive first look at O'Brien's guest appearance as Jess' blast from the past, as well as Nick's latest flashback look (We're thinking he was definitely called "brace face" at least once in his life!)...