Rated 5 out of 5 by BethTen from a pretty solid eyeshadow This is my first time buying eyeshadow from Urban Decay, so it's a bit of an understatement to say that I was pretty pumped to receive this in the mail. Fortunately, I wasn't disappointed. The packaging was great, the color is even more gorgeous in person, and I didn't have a hard time applying/blending it. The only thing I noticed is that it was not as pigmented as I expected it to be--it's a bit more on the lighter side. However, with primer, I found that it was pretty easy to add a few more layers of color on to be as dark as I wanted it to be. (Fun fact: If you're a fan of My Chemical Romance, Gash is the exact same eyeshadow that Gerard Way wore numerous times on stage/in photo shoots during 2004/2005)

Rated 5 out of 5 by isthisnametaken from Plague barely has a shift. :( UD's eyeshadows are what got me hooked on their brand, so in general, I love them. However, I'm specifically reviewing Plague. While it's a pretty color, it's not the red purple/blue duotone I was expecting and hoping for. The shift is very subtle, and I like duotones specifically because dramatic shifts allow me to do a simple lid wash that looks like I blended two colors together perfectly. This does not do that. The texture is also super thin and dry (if that makes sense). It's not the buttery texture that I'm used to. However, I didn't return it; I'm planning on trying it again wet to try to coax more of a shift out of it.

Rated 5 out of 5 by BunniAlive from Gash is back! I am SO HAPPY to see vintage UD products brought back. I ordered Gash first, partially because I love a good red shadow, and partially because it reminds me of high school. The color is amazing, and the new shadow formula makes this throwback shade a dream to work with. I really want to get Rust (yellow orange with gold shift) to pair with Gash for autumn eyes, and UV-B was amaaazing, I can't wait to try that on in the new formulation as well. These hold up with the rest of UD eye shadows, and they pop perfectly into my palette too! If you're new to Urban Decay, it's worth checking out some of these classic shadows while they're available. Roadstripe is a winner- I use it over a matte black shadow for dark-faerie-princess realness.