The current building hosts both a grand Sanctuary and The Little Synagogue, the latter a reproduction of a colonial-era chapel used for events like smaller weddings, Berith Milah (ritual circumcision), and baby naming. Furthermore, it features items from all of the former Congregation buildings. The Tevah (podium), Tables of the Law, and straight-backed pews are from the first Mill Street Synagogue (1730), while the Ner Tamid (Eternal Light) is from the second Mill Street Synagogue (1818). The two upholstered benches beside the Hekhal (Ark) are from the Crosby Street Synagogue (1834), while the additional Ner Tamid, beside the Davis Memorial Lamp in the northeastern corner, is from the 19th Street Synagogue (1860).