So I went back 3 night’s to try and figure out a connection to Spencer’s video footage of Melissa. This would take us to episode 5.08.

Aria was visiting Rhonda in Radley, who mentioned the woman with the beige purse that would sign Bethany out and take her on trips.

Hanna was being harassed by Zack.

Emily was being visited by Sydney, who slipped up about New York.

Alison was at the Marin house with Ashley because Hanna was upset about her being there.

Spencer was only heard on a phone call with Aria that night. The two were talking about how Aria got into trouble for giving Rhonda a sugary drink. The only males seen during this particular night were Caleb and Zack. Therefore, we rule both of them out as being the guy in the surveillance video because both were occupied.

At the end of this episode (5.08) we see ‘A’ looking at a riding hat. We noticed that this is the same hat Spencer took from the stables (Melissa’s) when she was hit in the eye. Meaning that the tape recording that Spencer hid in her red chair wasn’t what Melissa gave to the guy in the video footage like Spencer assumed. The Ali fake story recording was stolen 2 nights from the day Ali was to ID Cyrus.

Here’s the rundown of what could have been pulled off by 3 people:

Hanna was inside her car eating when Zack 'the Creep’ slipped in due to a note that was signed by Hanna but wasn’t written by Hanna. Although this was not signed by A, we can all assume that 'A’ was behind this stunt. Zack told Caleb that Hanna slipped the note into his pocket, meaning someone put the note there the night before when Hanna went for a sandwich or possibly the same night he got into her car. Emily and Spencer were at the stables during this time and were locked in by a black hoodie. Alison was at the Marin house when another black hoodie broke into the home. Alison told the liars that this was Noel Kahn and I assumed it to be Cyrus, but I was wrong because why would Cyrus be wearing A-Team clothing? The person who broke into the Marin home wasn’t Cyrus at all, he was seen lurking outside the property due to Ali possibly calling him, meaning I don’t think a neighbor could identify him if he was covered in black head to toe with his face covered because 'A’ wears a mask that covers his face now. Aria was at her home preparing the invitations for Ella’s dinner party.

Once Spencer and Emily made it home, Toby came by due to Spencer calling him and telling him about Melissa’s helmet that was at the stables. Spencer brought this helmet home (check the above pics) and placed it on her desk. Ali went back to her house to get some things to stay at the Marin’s and Emily and Spencer were there to find out what happened at Ashley’s home. When Spencer left her house, this was the perfect opportunity for 'A’ to go up and get the recording.

Now, to figure out who could have been the male in Spencer’s video footage talking to Melissa. I already ruled out both Caleb and Zack because both guys were occupied at the particular time. It wasn’t Cyrus because looking at the close-up of the video the guy is a clean shaved male no hair from what I can tell. Which leaves me with three possible suspects:

Ezra - who was supposed to be in New York at the the time, also he wears his baseball cap when he’s being a bada$$.

- who was supposed to be in New York at the the time, also he wears his baseball cap when he’s being a bada$$. Noel - who had a recording of his own, that he was shown with the same night of the break in at the Marin house but the recording wasn’t the same recording that was stolen from Spencer’s room.

- who had a recording of his own, that he was shown with the same night of the break in at the Marin house but the recording wasn’t the same recording that was stolen from Spencer’s room. Jason - who recently moved out his home to a new place.

But I’m leaning more to the person that Melissa was talking to as being Noel Kahn. He had a device in a package and that’s probably what Melissa gave him, when he was seen in his car out on the street on the same night as the break in, meaning I rule him out as being the culprit who broke into the Marin home.

Therefore, I narrowed down the a likely 'A’ suspect that went into the Hastings house to get the recording as Toby Cavanaugh.

Why? Because Spencer told him about the helmet that she got from the stables and he’s been in Spencer’s room several times, I’m pretty sure he stumbled across a few things of interest. Also, I still believe he is working with Mona and I think he was the car that pulled up when Jenna, Mona, and Sydney were at the park.

Also, I mentioned this was the acts of 3 people:

At the end of 5.10 we see 'A’ folding 3 black hoodies, Mona and 2 girls at the park = 3 girls. Also, the story Mona told Spencer in 2.25, that number she claimed Ali gave her was Toby’s, we spotted this in the 3.24 finale.

So I believe that Mona locked Spencer and Emily in the stables, Jenna put the note in Zack’s pocket, Sydney broke into the Marin home, and Toby got the recording from the Hastings house.