May’s cancellation bloodbath may be brutal, but there is a bright side: TVLine has dreamed up new roles for the stars of recently axed series such as Lucifer, The Brave, Quantico, Scorpion and many more.

With next season’s Arrowverse crossover set to introduce the city of Gotham and Batwoman, we’ve cast the iconic comic book character with a familiar face. Casting directors and producers: Feel free to also take note of our picks for Jughead’s mom on Riverdale, Abby’s replacement on NCIS and the Whisperers’ leader on The Walking Dead. (We promise to only briefly gloat about calling them.)

Our suggestions also include parts for fan faves like Lucy Hale (Life Sentence), Jason Ritter (Kevin (Probably) Saves the World) and Serinda Swan (Marvel’s Inhumans).

Scroll through the gallery above (or click here for direct access) to review our picks, then hit the comments to share the beloved faces you want back on TV ASAP.