The 54 emails reviewed by The Morning Call include a list of recipients and time stamps that show they were received and forwarded on multiple dates in 2008 and 2009. The sexually explicit emails originated in each case with one of several men who emailed McCaffery, who then forwarded the email to former Philadelphia police officers. (McCaffery was a police officer for 20 years before becoming a judge in 1993.) One of the former officers, then working in the attorney general's office, forwarded the email to more than a dozen people.