Some babies face herpes risk as N.J. lacks circumcision safety rules

Bob Jordan | Asbury Park (N.J.) Press

Show Caption Hide Caption Investigation: No Lakewood safety rule for controversial circumcisions Male infants may be exposed each year to a deadly form of herpes from an ultra-Orthodox circumcision ritual that mandates rabbis use their mouths to suck blood from the fresh cut.

TRENTON, N.J. — Potentially thousands of male newborns in a New Jersey community may be exposed each year to a deadly form of herpes from an ultra-Orthodox circumcision ritual that mandates rabbis use their mouths to suck blood from the fresh cut.

But there is no safety protocol in place to assess and mitigate risks associated with the mouth-to-genital contact — despite four deaths statewide of infants between 1999 and 2015 where herpes simplex virus was found as an underlying cause, an Asbury Park Press investigation found.

The ritual is prevalent among the booming Orthodox population in Lakewood, N.J. There were 4,464 births to township women in 2015 — a birth rate that is four times higher than the state rate.

July 2017: More couples face welfare fraud charges in New Jersey

New York, where officials have linked metzitzah b'peh (sucking with the mouth) circumcisions to at least 24 cases of infant herpes since 2000, bans mohels from practicing, pending a herpes test, if they're believed to be responsible for passing the disease to infants. New Jersey doesn't have any similar rules.

A mohel, who is the rabbi performing the ritual, briefly places his mouth over the cut after removal of the foreskin of the penis and sucks out a small amount of blood, ceremonially purifying the area.

Medical experts say the procedure is risky because the oral contact puts babies at risk of getting harmful herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) viruses.

Many adults carry HSV-1 in their bodies. They may have no symptoms or only mild symptoms, such as cold sores. Unlike adults, babies are too young to fight the virus — they could suffer brain damage, develop a lifelong disability or in some cases die.

Faith and medicine

Despite the risk — discovering neonatal herpes in males who undergo the ritual is 3.4 times more frequent than for other male babies, according to a federal study — metzitzah b'peh is another case of conflict between faith and safe medical practices.

The issue has prompted state Sen. Robert Singer, a Republican who lives in Lakewood, to consider legislation to test rabbis for herpes.

But there is no medical oversight in New Jersey, and leaders of Lakewood’s Orthodox community say they would consider restrictions on the centuries-old ritual as an infringement on religious freedom.

Lakewood is home to Beth Medrash Govoha, the largest Orthodox Jewish college or seminary in the U.S. The growth of the yeshiva over the years spurred a boost in the population, which went from 45,000 in 1990 to more than 100,000 now, making it New Jersey's fifth-largest municipality.

Establishing a protocol governing oral suction circumcisions in Lakewood might be difficult if not impossible, said Dr. Paul Offit, a professor of vaccinology and pediatrics at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, who said he's in favor of banning the ritual entirely.

July 2017: New Jersey welfare fraud arrests spark anti-Semitic sentiment

"There's a tangled relationship between religion and America,'' said Offit, author of Bad Faith: When Religious Belief Undermines Modern Medicine."

"There's a politically powerful Orthodox community in Lakewood that I'm sure would push back against anything that would impact their freedom to have the ritual circumcisions," Offit said.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in a 2012 report said circumcisions should be performed under sterile conditions, and direct oral contact should be avoided as much as possible.

While neonatal herpes is not among the diseases that needs to be reported to local health departments, the Asbury Park Press found the four instances in New Jersey by examining CDC death records. Nationally, there were 284 such deaths of infants between 1999 and 2015.

New York's example

New York City officials say of the 24 cases since 2000 of infant herpes they've linked to metzitzah b'peh, two of those babies died and two more suffered brain damage. The city in March began barring mohels who test positive for herpes and who may have passed the virus to an infant.

In Rockland County, N.Y., where ultra-religious Jewish communities were established during the 1950s, health officials say they worked with Orthodox leaders to launch a protocol four years ago after seven cases of neonatal herpes emerged. DNA testing is used to try to link a baby with the source of infection.

There's no need for New Jersey to follow suit, said Rabbi Avi Schnall, director of the Lakewood office of Agudath Israel of America, a non-profit that advocates for civil and religious rights for Jews.

"There has never been any correlation between (the circumcisions) to herpes here,'' said Schnaal. "There are some in the community who would not consider metzitzah b'peh a required part of the ceremony, but there are others who believe it’s an integral part, and the religious right of those people should be defended.''

State officials wouldn't provide more information about the four infant deaths — such as locations, circumstances or genders — citing a law that limits public disclosure of vital records.

Singer said the investigation raises concerns about the dearth of reporting on neonatal herpes and the lack of oversight of mohels.

June 2017: How did massive N.J. welfare fraud scheme work?

"Even if it’s just one case (of neonatal herpes), we should know about it and where it’s coming from," Singer said. "It should be a disease reportable to health departments."

Singer said he's also interested in exploring whether it would be wise to have "mohels tested maybe once a year.''

Schnall, from Agudath Israel of America, said testing mohels "risks encroaching the separation of church and state."

In New York, former mayor Michael Bloomberg's requirement for mohels to provide a health department pamphlet to parents describing the risks of HSV as well as obtain written consent acknowledging those risks, encroached on separation of church and state Schnaal said. Mayor Bill de Blasio removed the requirement when he took office in 2014.

“If the government wants to produce pamphlets or provide education on this, by all means. But to regulate the ritual and require of the parents or mohels that they need to do X, Y and Z, that’s different entirely,’’ Schnall said.

The demand among Lakewood residents for the oral suction circumcision for their babies is high, said Dr. Jeffrey Mazlin, an ­OB-GYN and part-time mohel based in New York.

“I know metzitzah b’pehis done by mohels a lot in Lakewood," said Mazlin, who doesn't perform the procedure. “My own thoughts are it’s potentially dangerous and the mohel has to make sure he doesn’t have any open sores if they’re performing it."

Several mohels who advertise their services in Lakewood declined to discuss how frequently they perform the ritual that’s said to be 4,000 years old.

June 2017: 14 arrested in New Jersey welfare fraud investigation

"My understanding is that it takes place with 90% of the babies in Lakewood,'' Offit said.

Offit said state lawmakers should rally behind Singer to help improve tracking of neonatal herpes, which is also not a reportable disease nationally or in most states.

"I think it’s really important to change the reporting. Children are being put at risk unnecessarily,'' Offit said. "This is a time when it’s reasonable for the state to stand up and protect its children.''

Like Offit, Rabbi Moshe Tendler, a professor of medical ethics at Yeshiva University, New York, said the ritual should be abandoned.

"Oral suction of the incision is not required by halacha (the collective body of Jewish religious laws)," Tendler said from Israel in a telephone interview.

‘’The medical facts are not in dispute, not by anyone who has an understanding of infection and contamination,'' he said. "Nowadays almost every mohel uses an ointment, a bacitracin, which most likely protects against most bacteria, but maybe some mohel don’t use it. In any case, it’s still unwise medically to do (the ritual).’’

Follow Bob Jordan on Twitter: @BobJordanAPP