Strand Cap-Toe Oxford is rated 4.6 out of 5 by 945 .

Rated 5 out of 5 by Erik_M from Great business and casual shoe This is my second pair of EA shoes I bought. Like the Fifth Avenue I bought them in NY, but these in Walnut. As the Fifth Avenues, they are perfect to wear, look stunning and are extremely comfortable. I most of the time wear them with blue Jeans and they are my go to shoes when I am not 100% sure if I should go formal or casual.

Rated 1 out of 5 by DC from Two different shoes First time purchase of AE. I am a big fan of cordovan and many pairs bought from English makers. I am British and live in the UK. Purchasing shoes was straightforward and certainly shipping was very smooth. The shoes per se are very nice in style , construction etc. However, it is clear that the two shoes sent to me are completely different colours ! One is the dark brown advertised - but the other is a reddish colour - not in patches which is expected from cordovan but uniformly red and quite obvious. I thought for one moment that I had been sent one shoe in chili but the colour reference is the same on both shoes. Remarkable absence of quality control really . Of course the hassle of sending the shoes back is too much to contemplate and I guess I will need to try and get a shoemaker here to try and darken the red shoe - but I would be surprised if that were possible. With taxes I paid well over $1,000 for the shoes - this is the cost of buying shoes from the US by mail. Never again !

Rated 1 out of 5 by Hajduk from Sizing off 10.5 E fits more like a 12 or larger Hi, Full disclosure, I special ordered a pair of Walnut Strands with combination sole from a store in a nearby city here in Canada. Was far cheaper than ordering directly from AE and ship to Canada. I saved around $250 Can not ordering directly from AE. I was excited to receive them. They are gorgeous shoes and the quality of the work was very good. But then I tried them on. They are huge. I used AE's online tool to find the best size and it said 10.5, hey my size, perfect. I thought an insole would help a bit. No, it exaggerated the length but now the heel and midsole area fit exceptionally well. The size on the box reads 10.5 E and the tongue on the shoe reads the same. The vast majority of my shoes for the past quarter century have been 10.5, with the occasional 10 or 11, once there was a 13 (Puma sneaker, go figure). On a Brannock device I'm a 10.5 E (actually between and E and D). I measured a shoe, out sole, toe to heel is just over 12.5 inches and internally just over 12 inches. This is quite larger than my other 10.5 shoes. I'd really like to order more AE shoes but now I really do not know my size in AE shoes. The nearest AE store is in Seattle and that is at least 2 hour drive south of Vancouver, BC. Great shoes but sizing (at least for these Walnut Strands) is way off.