Best Overall: Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

This crib mattress from Newton tops our list as it checks all the boxes for safety, comfort, and durability. Made with the company’s Breath-Thru technology, it helps air circulate through the mattress, both to prevent the risk of suffocation and to help regulate the temperature and keep baby as comfortable as possible. It doesn’t contain any metal springs, polyurethane foam or, glue, but rather it’s made up of 90 percent air. It’s non-toxic, hypoallergenic, and the fabric cover comes off for easy washing (extra covers are available for purchase separately).

Customers give this award-winning mattress the highest marks, saying they sleep much easier knowing just how safe this mattress is for their babies. While a bit on the expensive side, most online reviewers say it’s worth every penny.