trance_muzak wrote: Someone needs to get back to maintaining this list. It could be a very useful tool. Unfortunately, it is missing some obvious inclusions, includes some bad cards, and features absolutely nothing from that last couple of years. If this is going to be a "sticky", let's keep it up to date!

Or just unsticky it, as the list is terrible, and let someone else write another one.

Tolarian Academy and Tinker are now staples?

Skaarg Pits is listed, but Kessig Wolf Run is not?

He lists and links to Urborg, but I think he means Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth

Aether Vial fits in very few decks in EDH.

Darksteel Colossus sees very little play in any playgroup I've seen.

Muse Vessel... This is not a staple.

Planar Portal, maybe a staple in budget Azusa decks? I'v seen it in maybe 2 budget decks?

Sundering Titan is banned...

Civic Wayfinder but not Wood elves?

Gifts Ungiven?

Both Akroma's are just big dumb beaters, hardly staples.

Kagemaro, First to Suffer? What playgroups is this a staple in...

Woodland Guidance? Thicket Elemental? Moments Peace? Hibernation’s End? Elven Caache? None of these are staples.

This list is no more than a list of cards someone thinks are good in EDH. They are not staples, there is no data to back them up, its just a list of 'good' cards, half of which aren't great in edh and definitely not stapled, many of which are banned in EDH.