A few months ago, we picked who we'd like to star in the rumored Mass Effect movie. Now we're hearing rumblings of a Hollywood take on Rockstar's western epic Red Dead Redemption. Rumors would place Brad Pitt in the role of John Marsten, but we have our own picks for RDR on the big screen. Take a look.

John Marston - Viggo Mortensen or Sean Bean (take your pick)

Bonnie MacFarlane - Naomi Watts (King Kong, Mulholland Drive)

Nigel West Dickens - Brian Doyle Murray (Ghostbusters, Caddyshack, Groundhog Day, pretty much everything else his brother was in)

Edgar Ross - John Doman (The Wire)

Bill Williamson - Merle Haggard

Dutch van der Linde - Powers Boothe (Deadwood, Sin City, Tombstone)

Landon Ricketts - Sam Elliott (The Big Lebowski, Ghost Rider, a million westerns)

Irish - Sam Rockwell (Moon, Confessions of a Dangerous Mind, Iron Man 2)

Seth - Mackenzie Crook (The Office, Pirates of the Caribbean)

Colonel Allende - David Zayas (Dexter, Oz, The Expendables)

Luisa - Paz Vega (Spanglish)

Marston's Horse - Sarah Jessica Parker