Questions linger over details, deadlines as Pa. Senate re-attempts redistricting overhaul

"This is the only option we have, The House isn't doing anything."

Katie Meyer Bio Recent Stories



Katie is a native New Yorker, though she originally hails from Troy, a little farther up the Hudson River. She can attest that the bagels are still pretty good there.



WITF's Capitol Bureau Chief Desk is partially funded through generous gifts made in the memory of Tony May through the Anthony J. May Memorial Fund.



For more information about Tony May, click here. Katie Meyer was WITF’s Capitol Bureau Chief from 2016-2020. While at WITF, she covered all things state politics for public radio stations throughout Pennsylvania. Katie came to Harrisburg by way of New York City, where she worked at Fordham University’s public radio station, WFUV, as an anchor, general assignment reporter, and co-host of an original podcast. A 2016 graduate of Fordham, she earned several awards for her work at WFUV, including four 2016 Gracies.Katie is a native New Yorker, though she originally hails from Troy, a little farther up the Hudson River. She can attest that the bagels are still pretty good there.

(Harrisburg) – Thanks to a bipartisan vote from the Senate State Government Committee on Tuesday, a bill aimed at changing how Pennsylvania draws House, Senate, and congressional maps is getting another shot.

It’s a long way from passing, though.

The measure still has a lot of holes, and there’s little agreement on whether it can get approval in time for legislative reapportionment in 2022.

The constitutional amendment is a collaboration between Lehigh County Democrat Lisa Boscola and Dauphin County Republican Mike Folmer.

The senators tried to pass a similar bill last session. It would create an eleven-member commission to draw House, Senate, and congressional maps, made up of four Republicans, four Democrats, and three independents. The partisans would be picked by the minority and majority parties in the state legislature; the governor would choose the independents.

The bill leaves open the process for finding candidates.

Katie Meyer / WITF

Boscola said there is no consensus on that; she wanted random selection from a pool of applicants, but Folmer said he feels that takes too much power from the legislature.

But, she said, wanted to get things moving.

“This is the only option we have,” she told the Senate committee. “The House isn’t doing anything.”

There’s also disagreement about the timeline of the bill.

Amendments must pass in two consecutive two-year sessions, and then be approved in a voter referendum.

Boscola insisted it’s possible to get everything done before districts are redrawn in 2022. She argued that if the first iteration of the bill passes by June of 2020 and the second is approved by February 2021, that will allow enough time to get the proposal on voters’ ballots for the May 2021 primary. If they vote yes, the state will have to implement the new redistricting measures and redraw the maps in time for elections in 2022.

“The timeline is tight,” Boscola said.

But Carol Kuniholm, with advocacy group Fair Districts PA, said she thinks it’s more than tight–at least using Boscola’s approach.

“It would not be possible for a bill to go to referendum in May 2021 and then for a commission to be in place, and have lines drawn, and have public meetings by the end of 2021,” she said. “That’s just simply impossible.”

Instead, Kuniholm is pushing for what she calls the “two-bill-one-commission solution.”

It would create a new congressional commission this legislative session, because that portion of the overhaul can be passed as a simple bill rather than an amendment. Then, she said, an amendment could be passed to fold in House and Senate reapportionment once the process is already established.

Those bills are awaiting introduction in the House–a chamber that, as Boscola noted, has had little success passing redistricting bills.

A spokesman for House GOP leaders said they’re still working to “find a consensus on the issue among members.” But he added that overall, there is isn’t much action on redistricting at this point in the session.

State House and Senate maps are currently drawn by a commission of lawmakers, and congressional ones are approved by the legislature and governor.

Detractors say the process is too partisan and creates opportunities for the majority party to manipulate district lines to enshrine advantages in the maps.

Reapportionment happens every ten years after the US census. If lawmakers can’t find a way change the process within the next two years, they won’t get their next chance until 2032.

Last year, the state Supreme Court redrew the congressional map after ruling it was an unconstitutional gerrymander that favored Republicans.