When Gigi Hadid performed “Larger Than Life” on Lip Sync Battle , she brought in Nick Carter and A.J. McLean to help her out — but Wilmer Valderrama forgoes bringing a Backstreet Boy on stage during his rendition of “Everybody (Backstreet’s Back)” in favor of becoming one himself.

Valderrama, who’s currently appearing in a guest arc onGrey’s Anatomy, is competing against Jane the Virgin star Gina Rodriguez on the upcoming battle. Watch a preview of his performance — which has the same horror theme as BSB’s music video for the 1998 track — above, and see Lip Sync Battle when it airs Thursdays at 10 p.m. ET on Spike.