There’s a huge roster of DC Comics characters currently airing on The CW thanks to the shows Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl, and Legends of Tomorrow. But which show is the best? Here’s our official rankings!

5. Vixen

Vixen’s the only animated show on the list, but it’s rightfully still included. It may only be available on CW Seed, but it’s part of the same universe we all know and love. Mari McCabe receives some well-deserved attention in short episodes, and has impressed us in the two seasons we’ve watched her in. The series is full of cameos from other heroes, but gives Vixen plenty of time to shine.

4. Supergirl

She’s only just debuted on The CW, but the change is instantly noticeable. Supergirl‘s first series was a little rocky at first, but was great once it found its footing. The second season has come on in leaps and bounds, especially with the inclusion of Tyler Hoechlin as Superman himself. It’s a light hearted action adventure that isn’t afraid to step outside of it’s comfort zone every so often. Supergirl is on the rise.

3. Legends of Tomorrow

The time travelling team’s first series was a little rough in places, but undoubtedly fun. It’s undeniable that some of the best moments in the show are the conversations between characters and the development of their own stories. But sure, the costumes are pretty cool too. Speaking of which, we love the inclusion of classic DC Comics Justice Society of America characters into the second season. Seeing Golden Age heroes like Hourman, Obsidian and Citizen Steel is enough to place Legends of Tomorrow at 3rd.

2. The Flash

With Flashpoint becoming a huge part of the show, we lost our minds. Whilst it’s not an exact translation from the DC Comics of the same name, the concept itself was done pretty well for television. The second season occasionally misses a beat, but it doesn’t stop itself from having fun and bringing a whole host of characters to life. The story is progressing to a better place each episode, our only gripe is the fact we have another villainous speedster who Barry must try and be faster than. Again. Other than that, it’s one of the strongest superhero shows out there.

1. Arrow

After the near disastrous Season 4, the fifth season aimed to take the show back to its roots. And boy, oh boy – it’s become incredible. A grounded gritty superhero show is what we were first sold on. And now, it’s returned back to that with a vengeance. With a whole team of vigilantes behind him, Oliver Queen consistently shows us week after week why Arrow is the best DC show on The CW. With twists and turns around every corner – we can’t help but fall in love with the series all over again.

Although could something else top Arrow from the list? Geoff Johns recently teased that another DC show would be coming to small screen. If it’s destined to premiere on The CW, then we’ll be sure to update these rankings!