Open Heart theory (possibility about who dies) (it’s very dark)

Warning: Tw suicide mention

So me and @urfavsidecharacter realized this that one of the people in our group is going to commit suicide. We narrowed down to who might be the most likely to do it and why. First of all…why suicide? In this chapter, we got the option to choose whether to tell our friends about the hospital closing down or not. I have a feeling that it’s going to matter a lot in the future otherwise why would pb mention it.

Now back to the question. Suicide is very likely because it fits. We’ll have two options from here.

1. We won’t tell our friends, and that person…and when they realise it on their own, It’s too late and too much to handle and they can’t do anything now.

2. We will tell our friends and that person and they will be very stressed about it and crack under the pressure.

Either way the result is going to be the same (which is very pb-like) and MC will be to blame.

Now who will be the one? The person most likely to do it is Sienna (this is very devastating). Sienna has been very down since book 1. She had a lot of problems going on and is the person who is most probably the least brightest among the group (I think it was hinted in book 1 during the competition, Not sure about this though, she’s still very smart), Which means that if the hospital were to shut down, there would be waves of unemployed doctors and other hospitals would only take the best. During the bar scene Sienna replied with this which is pretty dark.

“She’s not a quitter” “I wish I could say the same about myself” This hints a LOT.

Also I think Mitch (Sienna’s intern) Is not a good person. Maybe a bully. When he was first introduced he said something like “You? My attending?”. When we asked Sienna about his intern she hesitated a bit. Maybe she’s trying to hide it.

Pb also said previously that MC’s group will never be the same after book 2, Which makes the suicide route MUCH more likely. (Another possibility, MC’s group will think that she didn’t care about them or lied to them, Depending on what you chose)

Pb also said that they want this book to be more realistic and wants us to deal with heartbreak and loss. We’ve been so distracted with other things that we never thought that this could mean…this.