We develop and test a theory to address a puzzling pattern that has been discussed widely since the 2016 U.S. presidential election and reproduced here in a post-election survey: how can a constituency of voters find a candidate “authentically appealing” (i.e., view him positively as authentic) even though he is a “lying demagogue” (someone who deliberately tells lies and appeals to non-normative private prejudices)? Key to the theory are two points: (1) “common-knowledge” lies may be understood as flagrant violations of the norm of truth-telling; and (2) when a political system is suffering from a “crisis of legitimacy” (Lipset 1959) with respect to at least one political constituency, members of that constituency will be motivated to see a flagrant violator of established norms as an authentic champion of its interests. Two online vignette experiments on a simulated college election support our theory. These results demonstrate that mere partisanship is insufficient to explain sharp differences in how lying demagoguery is perceived, and that several oft-discussed factors—information access, culture, language, and gender—are not necessary for explaining such differences. Rather, for the lying demagogue to have authentic appeal, it is sufficient that one side of a social divide regards the political system as flawed or illegitimate.

References

Abrams, Dominic, de Moura, Georgina Randsley, Marques, José M., Hutchison, Paul. 2008 . “Innovation Credit: When Can Leaders Oppose Their Group’s Norms?” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95(3): 662 – 78 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Adut, Ari . 2008 . On Scandal: Moral Disturbances in Society, Politics, and Art. Cambridge, UK : Cambridge University Press .

Google Scholar

Allcott, Hunt, Gentzkow, Matthew. 2017 . “Social Media and Fake News in the 2016 Election.” Working Paper 23089. National Bureau of Economic Research (http://www.nber.org/papers/w23089).

Google Scholar

Baker, Peter, Shear, Michael D. 2017 . “Trump Shifts Rationale for Firing Comey, Calling Him a ‘Showboat.’” The New York Times, May 11 , sec. Politics (https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/11/us/politics/trump-comey-showboat-fbi.html).

Google Scholar

Bartneck, Christoph, Duenser, Andreas, Moltchanova, Elena, Zawieska, Karolina. 2015 . “Comparing the Similarity of Responses Received from Studies in Amazon’s Mechanical Turk to Studies Conducted Online and with Direct Recruitment.” PloS One 10(4):e0121595 (https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0121595).

Google Scholar

Benkler, Yochai, Faris, Robert, Roberts, Hal, Zuckerman, Ethan. 2017 . “Study: Breitbart-Led Right-Wing Media Ecosystem Altered Broader Media Agenda.” March 3 , Columbia Journalism Review. Retrieved July 11 (https://www.cjr.org/analysis/breitbart-media-trump-harvard-study.php).

Google Scholar

Berinsky, Adam J. 2017 . “Rumors and Health Care Reform: Experiments in Political Misinformation.” British Journal of Political Science 47(2): 241 – 62 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Berinsky, Adam J., Huber, Gregory A., Lenz, Gabriel S. 2012 . “Evaluating Online Labor Markets for Experimental Research: Amazon.com’s Mechanical Turk.” Political Analysis 20(3): 351 – 68 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Bonikowski, Bart, DiMaggio, Paul. 2016 . “Varieties of American Popular Nationalism.” American Sociological Review 81(5): 949 – 80 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Bonikowski, Bart, Gidron, Noam. 2016 a. “The Populist Style in American Politics: Presidential Campaign Discourse, 1952–1996.” Social Forces 94(4): 1593 – 1621 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Bonikowski, Bart, Gidron, Noam. 2016 b. “Multiple Traditions in Populism Research: Toward a Theoretical Synthesis.” Comparative Politics Newsletter 26(2): 7 – 15 .

Google Scholar

Buhrmester, Michael, Kwang, Tracy, Gosling, Samuel D. 2011 . “Amazon’s Mechanical Turk: A New Source of Inexpensive, Yet High-Quality, Data?” Perspectives on Psychological Science 6(1): 3 – 5 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Carroll, Glenn R., Wheaton, Dennis Ray. 2009 . “The Organizational Construction of Authenticity: An Examination of Contemporary Food and Dining in the U.S.” Research in Organizational Behavior 29( January ): 255 – 82 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Centola, Damon, Willer, Robb, Macy, Michael. 2005 . “The Emperor’s Dilemma: A Computational Model of Self-Enforcing Norms.” American Journal of Sociology 110(4): 1009 – 40 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Chang, Jin Wook, Turan, Nazlı, Chow, Rosalind M. 2015 . “A Desire for Deviance: The Influence of Leader Normativeness and Inter-Group Competition on Group Member Support.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 56( January ): 36–49 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Choe, Sang-Hun, Goldman, Russell. 2017 . “South Korea’s Next President: A Look at the Leading Candidates.” The New York Times, May 3 , sec. Asia Pacific (https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/03/world/asia/south-korea-election-moon-jae-in-ahn-cheol-soo-hong-joon-pyo-trump.html).

Google Scholar

Cramer, Katherine J. 2016 . The Politics of Resentment: Rural Consciousness in Wisconsin and the Rise of Scott Walker. Chicago : University of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Davis, Michael L., Ferrantino, Michael. 1996 . “Towards a Positive Theory of Political Rhetoric: Why Do Politicians Lie?” Public Choice 88(1–2): 1 – 13 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Duncan, Jericka . 2015 . “Will Dartmouth’s Hard Alcohol Ban Make Students Safer?” CBS News. Retrieved July 10 , 2017 (http://www.cbsnews.com/news/will-dartmouths-hard-alcohol-ban-make-students-safer/).

Google Scholar

Fay, Michael P., Proschan, Michael A. 2000 . “Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney or T-Test? On Assumptions for Hypothesis Tests and Multiple Interpretations of Decision Rules.” Statistics Surveys 4: 1 – 39 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Frankfurt, Harry G. 2005 . On Bullshit. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Gest, Justin . 2016 . The New Minority: White Working Class Politics in an Age of Immigration and Inequality. New York : Oxford University Press .

Google Scholar

Goffman, Erving . 1956 . The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York : Random House .

Google Scholar

Golshan, Tara . 2016 . “You Have to See Donald Trump’s Counter-Debate to Believe What Happened There.” Vox. January 28 (https://www.vox.com/2016/1/28/10866252/trump-counter-debate-so-much-america).

Google Scholar

Grazian, David . 2005 . Blue Chicago: The Search for Authenticity in Urban Blues Clubs. Chicago : University of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar

Gusfield, Joseph R. 1986 . Symbolic Crusade: Status Politics and the American Temperance Movement. Champaign : University of Illinois Press .

Google Scholar

Gustainis, J. Justin . 1990 . “Demagoguery and Political Rhetoric: A Review of the Literature.” Rhetoric Society Quarterly 20(2): 155 – 61 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Hahl, Oliver . 2016 . “Turning Back the Clock in Baseball: The Increased Prominence of Extrinsic Rewards and Demand for Authenticity.” Organization Science 27(4): 929 – 53 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Hahl, Oliver, Zuckerman, Ezra W. 2014 . “The Denigration of Heroes? How the Status Attainment Process Shapes Attributions of Considerateness and Authenticity.” American Journal of Sociology 120(2): 504 – 554 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Hahl, Oliver, Zuckerman, Ezra W., Kim, Minjae. 2017 . “Why Elites Love Authentic Lowbrow Culture: Overcoming High-Status Denigration with Outsider Art.” American Sociological Review 82(4): 828 – 56 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Haidt, Jonathan . 2012 . The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion, reprint ed. New York : Vintage .

Google Scholar

Hochschild, Arlie Russell . 2016 . Strangers in Their Own Land: Anger and Mourning on the American Right. New York : The New Press .

Google Scholar

Hochschild, Arlie, Hout, Michael. 2017 . “Was Trump a Meteor or a Volcano? Racial Resentment, Immigration, and the Environment Built Up as Strong Predictors of Whites’ Votes Before the 2016 Election.” Working paper, New York University Population Center .

Google Scholar

Hofstadter, Richard . 1955 . The Age of Reform. New York : Vintage .

Google Scholar

Jacobs, Jennifer, Hahn, Henry. 2015 . “In Iowa, Star of ‘Summer of Trump’ Makes Grand Promises.” Des Moines Register. Retrieved August 21 (http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/elections/presidential/caucus/2015/08/25/-iowa-trump-says-he-holds-grudges/32362509/).

Google Scholar

Jones, Ben . 2016 . “Authenticity in Political Discourse.” Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 19(2): 489 – 504 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Judis, John B. 2016 . The Populist Explosion: How the Great Recession Transformed American and European Politics. New York : Columbia Global Reports .

Google Scholar

Kessler, Glenn . 2016 . “Recalling Hillary Clinton’s Claim of ‘Landing under Sniper Fire’ in Bosnia.” Washington Post, May 23 , sec. Fact Checker (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2016/05/23/recalling-hillary-clintons-claim-of-landing-under-sniper-fire-in-bosnia/).

Google Scholar

Kim, Minjae . 2017 . “A Man Is Known by His Cup: Signaling Commitment via Costly Conformity.” Working paper, Massachusetts Institute of Technology .

Google Scholar

Kim, Minjae, Zuckerman Sivan, Ezra W. 2017 . “Faking It Is Hard to Do: Entrepreneurial Norm Enforcement and Suspicions of Deviance.” Sociological Science 4( October ): 580 – 610 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Kruse, Michael . 2017 . “How Gotham Gave Us Trump: Ever Wonder How a Lifelong Urbanite Can Resent Cities as Much as Donald Trump Does? First You Have to Understand ’70s and ’80s New York.” Politico July/August (http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/06/30/donald-trump-new-york-city-crime-1970s-1980s-215316).

Google Scholar

Kunda, Ziva . 1990 . “The Case for Motivated Reasoning.” Psychological Bulletin 108(3): 480 – 98 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Kuran, Timur . 1995 . Private Truths, Public Lies: The Social Consequences of Preference Falsification, reprint ed. Cambridge, MA : Harvard University Press .

Google Scholar

Lamont, Michèle, Molnár, Virág. 2002 . “The Study of Boundaries in the Social Sciences.” Annual Review of Sociology 28(1): 167 – 95 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Lareau, Annette . 2003 . Unequal Childhoods: Class, Race, and Family Life, 2nd Edition with an Update a Decade Later. Berkeley : University of California Press .

Google Scholar

Lehman, David W., Kovács, Balázs, Carroll, Glenn R. 2014 . “Conflicting Social Codes and Organizations: Hygiene and Authenticity in Consumer Evaluations of Restaurants.” Management Science 60(10): 2602 – 17 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Levine, Emma E., Schweitzer, Maurice E. 2015 . “Prosocial Lies: When Deception Breeds Trust.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 126( January ): 88 – 106 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Lipset, Seymour Martin . 1959 . “Some Social Requisites of Democracy: Economic Development and Political Legitimacy.” American Political Science Review 53(1): 69 – 105 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Lipset, Seymour Martin . 1960 . Political Man: The Social Bases of Politics, expanded ed. Baltimore, MD : The Johns Hopkins University Press .

Google Scholar

Mason, Winter, Suri, Siddharth. 2012 . “Conducting Behavioral Research on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk.” Behavior Research Methods 44(1): 1 – 23 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Mast, Jason L. 2017 . “Legitimacy Troubles and the Performance of Power in the 2016 US Presidential Election.” American Journal of Cultural Sociology 5(3): 460 – 80 .

Google Scholar Crossref

McElwee, Sean, McDaniel, Jason. 2017 . “Fear of Diversity Made People More Likely to Vote Trump.” The Nation, March 14 (https://www.thenation.com/article/fear-of-diversity-made-people-more-likely-to-vote-trump/).

Google Scholar

McGraw, Kathleen M. 1998 . “Manipulating Public Opinion with Moral Justification.” ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 560(1): 129 – 42 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

McGraw, Kathleen M., Lodge, Milton, Jones, Jeffrey M. 2002 . “The Pandering Politicians of Suspicious Minds.” Journal of Politics 64(2): 362 – 83 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

McVeigh, Rory . 1999 . “Structural Incentives for Conservative Mobilization: Power Devaluation and the Rise of the Ku Klux Klan, 1915–1925.” Social Forces 77: 1461 – 96 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

McVeigh, Rory . 2009 . The Rise of the Ku Klux Klan: Right-Wing Movements and National Politics. Minneapolis : University of Minnesota Press .

Google Scholar

Mearsheimer, John J. 2010 . Why Leaders Lie: The Truth About Lying in International Politics. Oxford, UK : Oxford University Press .

Google Scholar

Mercieca, Jennifer . 2015 . “The Rhetorical Brilliance of Trump the Demagogue.” The Conversation, December 11 (https://theconversation.com/the-rhetorical-brilliance-of-trump-the-demagogue-51984).

Google Scholar

Morgan, Stephen L., Lee, Jiwon. 2017 . “The White Working Class and Voter Turnout in U.S. Presidential Elections, 2004 to 2016.” Sociological Science 4(27): 656 – 85 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Morton, Thomas A., Postmes, Tom, Jetten, Jolanda. 2007 . “Playing the Game: When Group Success Is More Important than Downgrading Deviants.” European Journal of Social Psychology 37(4): 599 – 616 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Müller, Jan-Werner . 2016 . What Is Populism? Philadelphia : University of Pennsylvania Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Nyhan, Brendan . 2015 . “Scandal Potential: How Political Context and News Congestion Affect the President’s Vulnerability to Media Scandal.” British Journal of Political Science 45(2): 435 – 66 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Nyhan, Brendan, Porter, Ethan, Reifler, Jason, Wood, Thomas. 2017 . “Taking Corrections Literally but Not Seriously? The Effects of Information on Factual Beliefs and Candidate Favorability.” SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2995128 . Rochester, NY : Social Science Research Network (https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2995128).

Google Scholar

Nyhan, Brendan, Reifler, Jason. 2010 . “When Corrections Fail: The Persistence of Political Misperceptions.” Political Behavior 32(2): 303 – 330 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Nyhan, Brendan, Reifler, Jason. 2017 . “The Roles of Information Deficits and Identity Threat in the Prevalence of Misperceptions.” Working paper, Dartmouth College, Hanover, New Hampshire .

Google Scholar

Orwell, George . 1949 . 1984. New York : Signet Classic .

Google Scholar

Parigi, Paolo, Santana, Jessica J., Cook, Karen S. 2017 . “Online Field Experiments: Studying Social Interactions in Context.” Social Psychology Quarterly 80(1): 1 – 19 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Pettigrew, Thomas F. 2017 . “Social Psychological Perspectives on Trump Supporters.” Journal of Social and Political Psychology 5(1): 107 – 116 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Phillips, Damon J., Turco, Catherine J., Zuckerman, Ezra W. 2013 . “Betrayal as Market Barrier: Identity-Based Limits to Diversification among High-Status Corporate Law Firms.” American Journal of Sociology 118(4): 1023 – 54 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Prentice, Deborah A., Miller, Dale T. 1993 . “Pluralistic Ignorance and Alcohol Use on Campus: Some Consequences of Misperceiving the Social Norm.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 64(2): 243 – 56 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Ranulf, Svend . 1964 . Moral Indignation and Middle Class Psychology: A Sociological Study, 1st Schocken pbk. ed. New York : Schocken Books .

Google Scholar

Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 2011 . Framed by Gender: How Gender Inequality Persists in the Modern World. New York : Oxford University Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Ridgeway, Cecilia L., Correll, Shelley J. 2006 . “Consensus and the Creation of Status Beliefs.” Social Forces 85(1): 431 – 53 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Rosenberg, Matthew, Schmitt, Eric. 2017 . “Trump Revealed Highly Classified Intelligence to Russia, in Break with Ally, Officials Say.” The New York Times, May 15 , sec. Politics (https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/15/us/politics/trump-russia-classified-information-isis.html).

Google Scholar

Sagiv, Tamar . 2014 . “Reinvesting Dance with Meaning: Authenticity and Ingenuity in the Artistic Dance Field.” Pp. 155 – 81 in Handbook of Organizational and Entrepreneurial Ingenuity, edited by Honig, B., Lampel, J., Drori, I. Northampton, MA : Edward Elgar Publishing .

Google Scholar Crossref

Skocpol, Theda, Williamson, Vanessa. 2013 . The Tea Party and the Remaking of Republican Conservatism, reprint ed. New York : Oxford University Press .

Google Scholar

Swaim, Barton . 2016 . “Donald Trump Tries to Kill Political Correctness — and Ends up Saving It.” Washington Post, November 1 , Online. Retrieved November 29 , 2017 (https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/donald-trump-has-made-political-correctness-credible-again/2016/11/01/0f397c0c-9fb1-11e6-a44d-cc2898cfab06_story.html).

Google Scholar

Swire, Briony, Berinsky, Adam J., Lewandowsky, Stephan, Ecker, Ullrich K. H. 2017 . “Processing Political Misinformation: Comprehending the Trump Phenomenon.” Open Science 4(3): 160802 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Tajfel, Henri, Billig, M. G., Bundy, R. P., Flament, Claude. 1971 . “Social Categorization and Intergroup Behaviour.” European Journal of Social Psychology 1(2): 149 – 78 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Valdesolo, Piercarlo, DeSteno, David. 2007 . “Moral Hypocrisy: Social Groups and the Flexibility of Virtue.” Psychological Science 18(8): 689 – 90 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Vance, J. D. 2016 . Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis, reprint ed. New York : Harper .

Google Scholar

Vaughan, Diane . 1996 . The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA. Chicago : University of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar

Wedeen, Lisa . 1999 . Ambiguities of Domination: Politics, Rhetoric, and Symbols in Contemporary Syria. Chicago : University of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar

Westen, Drew, Blagov, Pavel S., Harenski, Keith, Kilts, Clint, Hamann, Stephan. 2006 . “Neural Bases of Motivated Reasoning: An fMRI Study of Emotional Constraints on Partisan Political Judgment in the 2004 U.S. Presidential Election.” Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 18(11): 1947 – 58 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Wilcoxon, Frank . 1945 . “Individual Comparisons by Ranking Methods.” Biometrics Bulletin 1(6): 80 – 83 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Willer, Robb, Feinberg, Matthew, Wetts, Rachel. 2016 . “Threats to Racial Status Promote Tea Party Support among White Americans.” SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2770186. Rochester, NY : Social Science Research Network (https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2770186).

Google Scholar

Willer, Robb, Kuwabara, Ko, Macy, Michael W. 2009 . “The False Enforcement of Unpopular Norms.” American Journal of Sociology 115(2): 451 – 90 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Williams, Joan C. 2017 . White Working Class: Overcoming Class Cluelessness in America. Cambridge, MA : Harvard Business Review Press .

Google Scholar

Wood, Thomas . 2017 . “Analysis | Racism Motivated Trump Voters More than Authoritarianism.” Washington Post, April 17 (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2017/04/17/racism-motivated-trump-voters-more-than-authoritarianism-or-income-inequality/).

Google Scholar

Wood, Thomas, Porter, Ethan. 2016 . “The Elusive Backfire Effect: Mass Attitudes’ Steadfast Factual Adherence.” SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2819073. Rochester, NY : Social Science Research Network (https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2819073).

Google Scholar

Yamagishi, Toshio, Kiyonari, Toko. 2000 . “The Group as the Container of Generalized Reciprocity.” Social Psychology Quarterly 63(2): 116 – 32 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Yglesias, Matthew . 2017 . “The Bullshitter-in-Chief.” Vox. May 30 (https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/5/30/15631710/trump-bullshit).

Google Scholar

Zito, Salena . 2016 . “Taking Trump Seriously, Not Literally.” The Atlantic, September 23 (https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/09/trump-makes-his-case-in-pittsburgh/501335/).

Google Scholar