Well, at least we can cross him off our list of suspects.

On tonight's episode of Scream -- the very last before this season's long-awaited finale -- Mayor Maddox got a pitchfork to the stomach after being lured to the abandoned pig farm. But when the killer once again managed to escape, Sheriff Acosta arrested the only other people on the scene: Emma and Audrey, who'd gone into the barn, found Brooke's bleeding dad and picked up a pair of farm tools to defend themselves in case the killer was still on the scene.

Our thought bubble after they got cuffed: Man, this is some BS.

After all, the two are obviously innocent -- but are they TOTALLY innocent? Could one of them still have something to do with this season's massacre? Both Emma and Audrey -- along with many of Lakewood's finest -- seemingly can't be the killer: They've either come face-to-face with the madman or were accounted for when he struck. But does that really mean they're guiltless? Could one of them be working with the killer, meaning the murders are being carried out by a toxic team?

Audrey, for one, has sworn up and down that she didn't assist Piper in last season's slaughter-fest, insisting that she merely brought the psycho podcaster to Lakewood so they could work on a Brandon James documentary. But those letters she exchanged with Miss Shaw told a different story, spewing venom at Emma and calling her former BFF a "stupid, stuck-up bitch" who needed to be “taken down.” Brandon James documentary, Audrey? REALLY?

Meanwhile, Emma went away for therapy after her half-sister killed just about everyone and, since her return, has dealt with a serious case of PTSD. A slew of Facebook fans (we're watching you, Scream Team!) have suggested that Miss Duval's sightings of the killer were merely hallucinations; others have wondered if Emma developed a split personality and is, in fact, helping to carry out the murders and not even realizing it. And lest we forget, those emails that were supposedly sent by the dearly departed Riley did come from Emma's IP address...

So could Audrey or Emma really be guilty after all? Or is one of the other residents of Lakewood the killer? Keeping the aforementioned two in mind, here are our other top suspects -- check them out, then take our poll and cast your ballot for who you think is the slasher. Or, if you think a duo is carrying out the murders, vote for the mastermind and then head to social media to explain who you believe is their, um, better half -- and be sure to let us know if you noticed any other Season 2 clues. Then get ready: Next Tuesday, at 10/9c, the identity of this year's Scream killer WILL. BE. REVEALED.