The New York Giants addressed a need in free agency that held their offense back in 2016. The blocking from the tight end corps left much to be desired and the Giants felt that adding a tight end that specializes in that area was a must, so they went out and signed Rhett Ellison.

There are both positives and negatives to the Giants’ newest addition, so let’s take a look at how the transaction graded out:

As mentioned above, the Giants offense suffered from a lack of production when it came to using their tight ends in run blocking situations. Granted, the majority of the group is young and can still develop into solid blockers, but they struggled for the better part of the season.

Ellison brings a particular skill set that will aid the Giants offensive line in run blocking situations. Ever since he was drafted in the fourth round of the 2012 NFL Draft, he has been known for his proficient blocking.

There are even times that he has been used as a fullback, but in Ben McAdoo’s offense, it doesn’t seem like there is a significant role for that type of back. Ellison’s versatility, skill set and passion for the game certainly make this a strong signing.

However, even with Ellison’s attributes, there are some questions surrounding the contract he signed with the Giants. While the full details of the agreement have yet to be released, it seems that the Giants may have slightly overpaid for the 28-year-old.

The Giants signed Ellison to a four-year, $18 million contract with $8 million guaranteed. For a tight end that will be used primarily for blocking and one that played just 260 snaps in 2016, that seems a little steep.

The contract becomes even more in question when considering the fact that the Giants have been priced out of just about every market due to their limitations in salary cap space.

Pro Football Focus graded each signing in free agency and they, too, believe the Giants overpaid. They figure Ellison has earned a contract of four years, $8.3 million with $2.3 million guaranteed, which is considerably lower than what the Giants gave him.

While that may be a bit critical, it doesn’t hide the fact that the Giants slightly overpaid for Ellison.

With all things considered, the Giants signing Ellison was a strong move. He will most definitely help out the run game and could even surprise some as a receiver. Despite the contract, if Ellison can stay healthy and provide sufficient blocking, this is a win for the Giants.

Grade: B