So Who From State Will Testify Against Bradley Manning? A List.

The trial United States v. Pfc. Bradley Manning is being conducted in as much secrecy as the government thinks it can get away with. While the Center for Constitutional Rights has filed a petition requesting the Army Court of Criminal Appeals “to order the Judge to grant the public and press access to the government’s motion papers, the court’s own orders, and transcripts of proceedings,” none of these have been made.

Except of course for Alexa O’Brien, who has amazingly sat in the limited public access area and personally written down every word said that she was allowed to listen to, effectively creating a de facto transcript.

It is heavy legal reading, but worth your time simply to see what lengths the government is going to hang one man. Manning’s actions took place years ago, and whatever he released has been on the internet for years. Any punishment will thus have no real effect, except to commit revenge. So it is in 2013 America.





Who Speaks?

Deep inside the transcript is a list of upcoming government witnesses. As a public service, we present the names below as they appear, with Alexa’s comments. State Department people in BOLD that I added.

In the government’s 15 March 2013 classified filing Supplement to Prosecution Response to Scheduling Order of 39(a) Session from Closure and Motion to Close Courtroom for Specified Testimony, the government describes the classified information it moves to elicit in closed session for the following witnesses: (1) Brigadier General Retired Robert Carr, DIA (2) Colonel Julian Chestnut, DIA (3) Classified Witness Entirety (4) Ms. Elizabeth Dibble, Department of State, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Near Eastern Affairs (5) John Doe (Entire) (6) Rear Admiral Kevin Donegan, Naval Warfare Integration, Pentagon (7) Mr. John Feeley, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary, Bureau of Western Hemisphere Affairs, Department of State (8) Ambassador Patrick F. Kennedy, Under Secretary for Management, Department of State [Diplomatic Security Services which partnered with the Departments of Defense and Justice in the investigation of Julian Assange, WikiLeaks, and Manning report to Ambassador Patrick Kennedy. Bureau of Intelligence and Research, which created the “August 2011 draft damage assessment” also reports to Kennedy. Kennedy is the Original Classification Authority for the US State Department cables. He also testified to Congress in late November, early December of 2010, and in March 2011 about WikiLeaks. He is also responsible for the WikiLeaks Mitigation Team at the Department of State.] (9) Mr. John Kirchhofer, DIA (10) Ambassador Michael Kozak, Department of State (11) Classified Witness Entirety (12) Mr. Daniel Lewis, DIA (13) Mr. Randall Mcgrovey [sp.?], DIA (14) Mr. James McCarl, Joint IED Defeat Organization (JIEDDO) (15) Major General Kenneth F. McKenzie, USMC Headquarters Staff (16) Mr. James Moore, Department of State (17) Major General Michael [last name like, “Ma-guy”] McGuy, Joints Staff Pentagon (18) SSA [Supervisory Special Agent] Alexander Pott [sp.], FBI (19) Ambassador David Pearce, Department of State (20) Mr. Adam Pearson, JIEDDO (21) Mr. H. Dean Pittman, Department of State (22) Classified Witness in Entirety (23) Ambassador Stephen Seche, Department of State (24) Mr. David Shaver, US Department of Treasury (25) Mr. Catherine Stobel [sp.], CIA (26) Ambassador Don Yamamoto, Department of State (27) Ambassador Marie Yovanovitch, Department of State; and (28) Mr. Joseph Yun, Department of State





So Who Are These People?

Of course we have no idea whether any of the unnamed “classified” witnesses are from State, though it is doubtful.

Most/all of the State Department people listed head up various bureaus at State. These bureaus are the bureaucratic structures that handle say “East Asian Affairs” or “European Affairs.” Just guessing here, but the government is probably calling them to testify on behalf of their world region about all the horrible, terrible things that have happened since Manning released the documents. None of us will be allowed to hear what they have to say, but it would be safe to assume the court will listen to a lot of drama and smoke and LIONS and TIGERS and BEARS! horror-speak and very little substantive comment.





The most interesting State witness is Patrick F. Kennedy, the Under Secretary of State for Management. Kennedy keeps popping up on this blog, in the press and in front of Congress (he was the real point man on Benghazi.) He has been around State for a very long time, and basically runs the place administratively in Washington while various important people fly around the world doing their diplomacy.

Kennedy is officially the “original classifying authority,” the person at State who is titularly responsible for every classification decision. He may just offer up some boring testimony confirming that all the documents manning leaked labeled “Secret” were indeed classified Secret.

Or maybe not. Kennedy also oversaw State’s internal report on the Wikileaks impact and ran the working group that was supposed to identify people at risk because their names appeared in the State Department cables online. Notice how every weird, bad or naughty thing that State does somehow involves Pat Kennedy?It would be worth serious coin to listen in on Kennedy’s testimony but alas, because this is America now, the trial is largely off limits.









Bonus: Some earlier State Department personnel testimony about State’s internal processes surrounding the Wikileaks disclosures. Nothing earth shaking, but some interesting inside baseball stuff from Ops Center coordinator Rena Bitter about how the bureaucracy processed the new information. Short version: most of the effort was spent informing Department big shots of potentially embarrassing stuff the media caught. The Defense seems to be establishing that there was not much real-world impact from the disclosures.

















Copyright © 2020. All rights reserved. The views expressed here are solely those of the author(s) in their private capacity.