Season 29 of CBS’s Survivor premieres Sept. 24, and as fans wait to see what antics the new Blood vs. Water castaways will bring to San Juan del Sur, one thing is for certain: When it comes to crazy moments and tribal councils, they have a lot to live up to.

During June 2014 filming of Survivor‘s upcoming season, Us Weekly deputy editor Mara Reinstein went on-location to San Juan del Sur, Nicaragua, to recap the biggest, baddest and most shocking moments in series history. Joining Reinstein for the recap is Parvati Shallow, who won Survivor: Micronesia, and competed on Survivor: Cook Islands and Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains.

Watch the video above as Reinstein and Shallow look back on memorable blindsides, tribal councils and immunity challenges to determine the No. 1 moment in Survivor series history.

Did they forget your favorite? Sound off with your pick in the comments!

Survivor: Blood vs. Water premieres Wednesday, Sept. 24 at 8 p.m. (EST) on CBS.