That path is blocked by a gate and a sign that warns against future access after October 1, 2016. The neighborhood HOA owns the path, according to a presentation by town staff at Wednesday's meeting. Without any ownership, the town has no jurisdiction over decisions affecting the path, according to a letter from Oro Valley's former town attorney.



Michael Douglass, board president of the HOA, said Wednesday night that there wouldn't be an issue with access to the trail if there wasn't a small percentage of bike riders who refuse to follow the rules posted at the start of the trail.



The rules prohibit motorized vehicles and nighttime use.



In a town hall full of crowds lining the walls, several people spoke either in support or opposition to the closing of the trail access.



Those in support of the closure cited concerns over dust, possible Valley Fever, noise and a potential lawsuit from anyone who is hurt while using the unkempt access trail.



Those in favor of keeping the access open to the public claim it's a benefit to the community's health and economy through tourism and property values.