The triumphant, chart-topping return of Brand New in August has led to all sorts of renewed recognition of the Long Island rock group and Los Angeles singer-songwriter Luna Shadows is adding her tribute with a cover of “Jesus Christ” from their 2006 album The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me.

Upon the release of their long-awaited fifth studio album Science Fiction, Shadows and co-producer Thomas Powers (The Naked and Famous) got together and recorded the cover in two days at Shadows’ home studio. The song was the last single to chart before the band’s eight-year hiatus, at No. 30 on the Alternative Songs chart, and its importance to the Brand New catalogue was not lost on Shadows.

“‘Jesus Christ’ by Brand New has haunted me since I first heard it over a decade ago,” Shadows tells Billboard. “I did not take covering this song lightly, as I know how much it means to my generation.”

Among the notable distinctions of the cover is Shadows’ use of piano for the base melody, which adds a melancholic accompaniment to Jesse Lacey’s original lyrics. Shadows does seem challenged by such evocative source material, and her vocals are more raw than overwrought as the track reaches its climax.

As with this labor of love from Luna Shadows, the return of Brand New is a comeback that keeps on giving. Check out the track exclusively on Billboard below.