This article offers a new account of the development of China’s territorial claims in the South China Sea. It argues that a collective Chinese belief in a “historic claim” to the reefs and rocks therein emerged in distinct episodes during the first half of the twentieth century, partly in response to perceived threats to the country’s sovereignty but mainly as attempts to shore up declining nationalist legitimacy. It situates the claim within efforts by Chinese intellectual and state elites to construct a national “geobody” in the first decades of the twentieth century. It argues that this was not a process of documenting a preexisting claim but of imagining and asserting one through the mobilization of both emotion and archival documents. Moreover, this account emphasizes the importance of the acquisition of knowledge from foreign sources and the confusion that entailed. The legacy of this confused claim-making shapes South China Sea geopolitics today.

References

Anderson, Benedict ( 1991 ) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism . London : Verso .

Google Scholar

Bonnet, François-Xavier ( 2004 ) “ The Spratlys: a past revisited .” World Bulletin, Manila : Univ. of the Philippines Institute of International Legal Studies 23 ( July–Dec. ): 13 – 27 .

Google Scholar

Bonnet, François-Xavier ( 2012 ) “ Geopolitics of Scarborough Shoal .” Discussion paper 14. Bangkok : Institut de recherche sur l’Asie du Sud-Est contemporaine (IRASEC) .

Google Scholar

Boyle, John Hunter ( 1972 ) China and Japan at War, 1937–1945: The Politics of Collaboration . Stanford, CA : Stanford Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Callahan, William A . ( 2009 ) “ The cartography of national humiliation and the emergence of China’s geobody .” Public Culture 21, 1: 141–73.

Google Scholar

Callahan, William A . ( 2012 ) China: The Pessoptimist Nation . Oxford : Oxford Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Chemillier-Gendreau, Monique ( 2000 ) Sovereignty over the Paracel and Spratly Islands . The Hague : Kluwer Law International .

Google Scholar

Chen Hsin-Chih ( 2001 ) “ La Réponse chinoise à l’occupation française des Îles Spratly en 1933 .” Guerres mondiales et conflits contemporains 199 ( July ): 5–24 .

Google Scholar

Chen Hurng-Yu ( 2016 ) “ Republic of China’s decision-making process in regards to drawing a U-shaped line on the map of the South China Sea and its implications .” Pacific Focus 31, 2 ( Aug. ): 283 – 306 .

Google Scholar

Chen, Leslie H. Dingyan ( 1999 ) Chen Jiongming and the Federalist Movement: Regional Leadership and Nation Building in Early Republican China . Ann Arbor : Center for Chinese Studies, Univ. of Michigan .

Google Scholar

Chen, Qianping ( 2017 ) “ The Nationalist government’s efforts to recover Chinese sovereignty over the islands in the South China Sea after the end of World War Two .” J. of Modern Chinese History. doi:10.1080/17535654.2017.1313527.

Google Scholar

Chen Tianxi 陳天錫 ( 1928 ) 西沙島東沙島成案彙編 ( A compilation of materials concerning the Xisha and Dongsha Islands case ). Guangzhou : Guangdong shiyeting .

Google Scholar

Cheng, Tao ( 1975 ) “ Dispute over the South China Sea islands .” Texas Int. Law J. 10, 2: 265–77.

Google Scholar

Chinese Biographical Database ( 2010 ) “Chen Tianxi .” http://www.berkshirepublishing.com/chinesebiodb/BioView.aspx?id=2204 (accessed Aug. 14, 2017).

Google Scholar

Chiu, Hungdah, Park, Choon-Ho ( 1975 ) “ Legal status of the Paracel and Spratly Islands .” Ocean Development & Int. Law 3, 1: 1 – 28 .

Google Scholar

Chung, Chris P. C. ( 2016 ) “Drawing the U-shaped line: China’s claim in the South China Sea, 1946–1974 .” Modern China 42, 1 ( Jan. ): 38 – 72

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Collingwood, Cuthbert ( 1867 ) “ The natural history of Pratas Island .” Pp. 145–52 in Samuelson, James, Crookes, William (eds.), Q. J. of Science 4, 13. London : John Churchill and Sons .

Google Scholar

Culp, Robert ( 2007 ) Articulating Citizenship: Civic Education and Student Politics in Southeastern China, 1912–1940 . Cambridge, MA : Harvard Univ. Asia Center .

Google Scholar

Davies, Stephen , withWong, Kenneth Kwan-Kin ( 2006 ) “ Swords become station-pointers: the charting of the China coast 1841–1930 .” Pp. 79 – 613 in Proceedings of the International Conference on the History and Culture of the British Concessions in China during the Late Qing Dynasty , held in Weihai , , Organizing Committee of ICHCBC .

Google Scholar

Dirlik, Arif ( 1997 ) “ Narrativizing revolution: the Guangzhou Uprising (11–13 December 1927) in workers’ perspective .” Modern China 23, 4 ( Oct. ): 363–97.

Google Scholar

Edward Stanford Ltd . ( 1918 ) Asiatic Archipelago. Map. British Library shelfmark Maps 88715.(13) .

Google Scholar

Fu, Jiaojin 傅角今, Zheng, Ziyue 鄭資約 [eds.] ( 1947 ) 南海諸島地理誌略 ( Geographical recording of the islands in the South China Sea ). Shanghai : Commercial Press .

Google Scholar

Granados, Ulises ( 2005 ) “ As China meets the Southern Sea frontier: ocean identity in the making, 1902–1937 .” Pacific Affairs 78, 3: 443–61.

Google Scholar

Granados, Ulises ( 2006 ) “ Chinese ocean policies towards the South China Sea in a transitional period, 1946–1952 .” China Rev. 6, 1 (Spring): 153–81.

Google Scholar

Granados, Ulises ( 2008 ) “ Japanese expansion into the South China Sea: colonization and conflict, 1902–1939 .” J. of Asian History 42, 2: 117–42

Google Scholar

Gunn, Geoffrey ( 1991 ) “ Anglo-French rivalry over the Spratlys (1930–1937): an aspect of world historical incorporation .” Pp. 262–82 in Hill, R. D., Owen, Norman G., Roberts, E. V. (eds.), Fishing in Troubled Waters. Hong Kong : Centre of Asian Studies, Univ. of Hong Kong .

Google Scholar

Han, Zhenhua 韓振華 [ed.] ( 1988 ) 我國南海諸島史料彙編 ( A compilation of historical sources on our country’s Southern Sea islands ). Beijing : Dongfang chubanshe .

Google Scholar

Hancox, D. J., Prescott, John ( 1995 ) “ A geographical description of the Spratly Islands and an account of hydrographic surveys amongst those islands .” Maritime Briefing 1, 6. Durham, UK : International Boundaries Research Unit, Univ. of Durham .

Google Scholar

Hayton, Bill ( 2017 ) “When good lawyers write bad history.” Ocean Development & Int . Law 48, 1: 1 – 18 .

Google Scholar

Heinzig, Dieter ( 1976 ) Disputed islands in the South China Sea: Paracels, Spratlys, Pratas, Macclesfield Bank . Hamburg : Institut für Asienkunde .

Google Scholar

Hongkong General Chamber of Commerce ( 1923 ) Report of the General Committee of the Hongkong General Chamber of Commerce .

Google Scholar

Hu, Huanyong 胡焕庸 ( 1934 ) “法日凱覦之南海諸島” ( The Southern Sea islands coveted by France and Japan ). 外交評論 3, 5: 65 – 72 .

Google Scholar

Lary, Diana ( 1974 ) Region and Nation: The Kwangsi Clique in Chinese Politics 1925–1937 . Cambridge : Cambridge Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Li, Jinming, Dexia, Li ( 2003 ) “ The dotted line on the Chinese map of the South China Sea: a note.” Ocean Development & Int . Law 34, 3– 4: 287–95.

Google Scholar

Li, Zhun李準 ( 1933 ) “ 李準巡海記 ” ( On Li Zhun’s patrol of the sea ).” 國聞周報 10, 33 ( Aug. ): 1 – 8 .

Google Scholar

Maher, Captain Thomas ( 1937 ) USC&GS Manila, Memorandum to Mr. Wayne Coy, Office of the U.S. High Commissioner, Dec. 10, 1937 . Bureau of Insular Affairs (BIA) 907.127 NARA. Quoted in Bonnet, 2012: 16 .

Google Scholar

Ministry of Foreign Affairs ( 1933 ) 外交部公報 ( Gazette of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs ) 6, 3 ( July–Sept. ): 206–23.

Google Scholar

Ministry of Foreign Affairs ( 1995 ) 外交部南海諸島檔案彙編 ( Compilation of archives of the South China Sea islands of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs ). Taipei .

Google Scholar

Ministry of Information ( 1943 ) China Handbook 1937–43. Calcutta: July 1943 (British Library shelfmark BLL01000687158) , and New York : Macmillan, Nov . 1943 (British Library shelfmark BLL01000687157)

Google Scholar

Ministry of Information ( 1947 ) China Handbook 1937–1945. Revised and Enlarged with 1946 Supplement. A Comprehensive Survey of Major Developments in China in Eight Years of War . New York : Macmillan .

Google Scholar

Ministry of the Interior ( 1947 ) 內政部公布: 南海諸島新舊名稱對照表 ( Ministry of Interior announcement: table comparing the new and old names of the islands of the South China Sea ),Oct. N.p.: 內政部方域司印.

Google Scholar

Murray, Dian ( 2004 ) “ Piracy and China’s maritime transition, 1750–1850 .” Pp. 43 – 60 in Gungwu, Wang, Chin-Keong, Ng (eds.), Maritime China in Transition, 1750 – 1850 . Wiesbaden : Harrassowitz Verlag .

Google Scholar

Po, Ronald C . ( 2016 ) “ Mapping maritime power and control: a study of the late eighteenth century ‘Qisheng yanhai tu’ (A coastal map of the seven provinces) .” Late Imperial China 37, 2 ( Dec. ): 93 – 136 .

Google Scholar

Rhoads, Edward J. M. ( 1975 ) China’s Republican Revolution: The Case of Kwangtung, 1895–1913 . Cambridge, MA : Harvard Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Roberts, Quincy F . ( 1933 ) American consul, Saigon. “French annexation of certain isolated islands near the Philippine Islands .” U.S. Department of State archives GRC 851.014/65, Sept. 20 .

Google Scholar

Salmon, Claudine ( 2006 ) “ Coastal maps from the beginning of the Qing dynasty, with special reference to the Qingchu haijiang tushuo .” Pp. 177–90 in Schottenhammer, Angela, Ptak, Roderich (eds.), The Perception of Maritime Space in Traditional Chinese Sources. Wiesbaden : Otto Harrassowitz Verlag .

Google Scholar

Samuels, Marwyn S . ( 1982 ) Contest for the South China Sea . New York : Methuen .

Google Scholar

Sasges, Gerard ( 2016 ) “ Absent maps, marine science, and the re-imagination of the South China Sea, 1922–1939 .” J. of Asian Studies 75, 1 ( Feb. ): 157–80.

Google Scholar

Stuart-Fox, Martin ( 2003 ) A Short History of China and Southeast Asia: Tribute, Trade and Influence . London : Allen & Unwin .

Google Scholar

Svarverud, Rune ( 2007 ) International Law as World Order in Late Imperial China: Translation, Reception and Discourse, 1847–1911 . Leiden : Brill .

Google Scholar

Times ( 1907 ) “ The Japanese & Pratas Island .” Sept. 9, p. 7 .

Google Scholar

TØnnesson, Stein ( 2006 ) “ The South China Sea in the age of European decline .” Modern Asian Studies 40, 1: 1 – 57 .

Google Scholar

Tai, Tsung-Han, Tsai, Chi-Ting( 2014 ) “ The legal status of the U-shaped line revisited from the perspective of inter-temporal law .” Pp. 177 – 208 in Ho, Szu-Shen, Wang, Kuan-Hsiung (eds.), A Bridge over Troubled Waters: Prospects for Peace in the South and East China Seas. Taipei : Prospect Foundation .

Google Scholar

United Kingdom Hydrographic Office ( 1906 ) The China Sea Directory , 5th ed. London : Printed for the Hydrographic Office, Admiralty, by Eyre and Spottiswoode, printers to the King’s Most Excellent Majesty .

Google Scholar

U.S. Dept. of State, Division of Far Eastern Affairs ( 1933 ) Memorandum to the American minister at Peiping . Aug. 18 .

Google Scholar

U.S. Navy ( 1968 ) Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships, Volume 2 . Washington DC, 1963 reprint with corrections.

Google Scholar

Van De Ven, Hans ( 2014 ) Breaking with the Past: The Maritime Customs Service and the Global Origins of Modernity in China . New York : Columbia Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Winichakul, Thongchai ( 1994 ) Siam Mapped: A History of the Geo-body of a Nation . Honolulu : Univ. of Hawaii Press .

Google Scholar

Wong, Sin-Kiong ( 1993 ) “ The Tatsu Maru incident and the anti-Japanese boycott of 1908: a study of conflicting interpretations .” Chinese Culture 34, 3 ( Sept. ): 77 – 92 .

Google Scholar

Wu, Feng-Ming ( 2011 ) “ On the new geographic perspectives and sentiment of high moral character of geographer Bai Meichu in modern China .” Geographical Research 30, 11: 2109–14. http://www.dlyj.ac.cn/EN/10.11821/yj2011110018.

Google Scholar

Xin, Yejiang 辛業江 [gen. ed.] ( 1996 ) 中國南海諸島 ( China’s southern sea islands ). Haikou : Hainan guoji xinwen chuban zhongxin .

Google Scholar

Zheng, Fangjian 鄭仿健 ( 2011 ) “ 永遠的南中國海——懷念父親鄭資約教授 ” ( Forever South China Sea: remembering my father, Professor Zheng Ziyue ). Chinese Univ. of Hong Kong, China Research Centre. http://mjlsh.usc.cuhk.edu.hk/book.aspx?cid=6&tid=536&pid=3453 (accessed Aug. 14, 2017).

Google Scholar

Zou, Keyuan ( 1999 ) “ The Chinese traditional maritime boundary line in the South China Sea and its legal consequences for the resolution of the dispute over the Spratly Islands .” Int. J. of Marine and Coastal Law 14, 1 ( Mar. ): 27 – 55 .

Google Scholar