Mandy: We accidentally told her we loved her after sleeping together twice, which was weird. She assured us it wasn’t a big deal though after explaining she didn’t feel comfortable saying that yet. Still, things were awkward after that. We could feel her pulling away, and every time we tried to get closer to her, the more put-off she became. She broke things off about a month later. We still think of her from time to time. Photo : The Onion