Abstract Adult female mosquitoes need blood to develop their eggs and both sexes use nectar and honeydew as carbohydrate resources for flight, survival and to enhance reproduction. However, there are also a few reports in the literature of mosquitoes feeding on haemolymph of soft-bodied insects such as caterpillars. The frequency and significance of this entomophagous behavior is not well understood, but is thought to be a vestige of ancestral feeding behavior or an opportunistic behavior that has evolved over time. In our current paper we investigated the extent to which the malaria mosquito, Anopheles stephensi, is attracted to, and can successfully feed on, larvae of two common moth species, Manduca sexta and Heliothis subflexa. Using y-tube olfactometer assays we found that female An. stephensi readily flew upwind to and landed on the caterpillars of both moth species. The nature of the volatile cues used in host location remains unclear but respirometer studies suggest a possible role of CO 2 . Laboratory cage assays further showed that the female mosquitoes were able to actively feed on moth larvae and gain sufficient nutritional benefit to influence survival. The extent to which such an opportunistic behavior occurs in the field has yet to be explored but our results suggest that this haemolymph feeding behavior could play a role in malaria mosquito life history and could provide a novel mechanism for horizontal transmission of pathogens and other micro-organisms between hosts.

Citation: George J, Blanford S, Thomas MB, Baker TC (2014) Malaria Mosquitoes Host-Locate and Feed upon Caterpillars. PLoS ONE 9(11): e108894. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0108894 Editor: Luciano A. Moreira, Centro de Pesquisas René Rachou, Brazil Received: March 20, 2014; Accepted: August 11, 2014; Published: November 5, 2014 Copyright: © 2014 George et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Data Availability: The authors confirm that all data underlying the findings are fully available without restriction. All relevant data are within the paper and its supporting information files. Funding: The authors received no specific funding for this work Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Introduction Speciation in mosquitoes began to accelerate during the Mesozoic era (65 million years ago), corresponding to the establishment of terrestrial dwellings and nests by birds, mammals and reptiles [1]. Feeding on carbohydrates from flower nectar or honeydew is known to give mosquitoes enough energy for flight, but in order to reproduce they need a blood meal. Adult female mosquitoes are primarily blood-feeders that require blood proteins for developing their eggs [2]. They feed on a wide range of hosts including a variety of vertebrates. Haematophagy in lower dipteran flies is thought to have evolved through a switch in adult feeding behavior from a predatory habit to a bloodsucking one [1], [3], [4]. Mattingly [5] suggested that the ancestors of Culicidae (mosquitoes), which possessed a soft, flexible proboscis not typical of predatory flies, may have originally pierced the skins of soft fruits for nourishment and evolved a blood-feeding habit later. Also, adult males of Calyptra thalictri (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), in a genus that otherwise consists only of adult fruit feeders, exhibit facultative blood feeding behavior that might have evolved from its normal fruit feeding behavior [6]. There is intriguing evidence that haematophagous insects can, and still do, feed on larval stages of other insects, which may have been a part of the evolution toward vertebrate blood-feeding. Triatomine bugs (Hemiptera: Reduviidae) can also feed opportunistically on haemolymph of cockroaches (Blattodea) [7], [8], [9]. The proboscis extension and feeding behavior of triatomine on cockroaches suggests that arthropod haemolymph represents an alternative source of food for triatomines, and they have partially conserved their entomophagous behavior during their evolution to haematophagy [9]. Historic studies report black flies feeding on butterfly pupae [10] and mosquitoes attacking small dipterans and cicadas [11] and caterpillars [12], [13]. This potential for mosquito entomophagy has been generally ignored until recently [14]. The caterpillar feeding behavior of mosquitos' suggest that they have not completely abandoned the entomophagous behavior during evolution and it is still conserved as an opportunistic behavior among dipteran blood feeding insects such as mosquitoes. In this paper, we investigated whether females of the malaria mosquito Anopheles stephensi, were attracted to caterpillars, whether they would feed on them and if so, whether this affected mosquito longevity. We used a Y-tube olfactometer [15], [16] to compare the degree to which An. stephensi females were attracted to living vs. dead fourth instar larvae of Manduca sexta and Heliothis subflexa by landing on or near the caterpillars and feed on them. We then measured the amount of carbon dioxide produced by individual living versus dead caterpillars in order to determine whether there was a significant correlation between caterpillars' CO 2 output and the amount of upwind flight behavior we had observed in the Y-tube assays. Finally, we placed An. stephensi females in cages either containing or lacking live fourth instar caterpillars of Heliothis subflexa to measure the degree to which feeding upon caterpillar haemolymph affected mosquito survival. Here we report this opportunistic behavior of Anopheles stephensi mosquitoes to fly upwind and land on caterpillars, and the possible visual and olfactory cues they might be using to hostfind and feed on the caterpillars.

Discussion Our study shows that females of the malaria mosquito An. stephensi are attracted to, and opportunistically feed upon, two different species of caterpillars, and survive better when they have access to caterpillars as possible food sources than when they are deprived of food completely. Two prior studies have shown that females of two other mosquito species will readily feed upon soft-bodied insects including caterpillars [12]–[13] and gain enough nutrition to lay viable eggs [13]. A third study recently showed that mosquito-feeding on caterpillars is sufficiently detrimental to the caterpillars that it reduces their fitness [14]. A recent study by our group has also shown that An. stephensi females were attracted to caterpillars infected by fungal pathogens [16] but did not directly examine the extent of feeding. This study showed that mosquitoes can fly upwind to the olfactory cues emanating from fungal spores and they pick up spores and get infected with the Beauveria bassiana fungus. The infected mosquitoes died in 4–6 days and sporulated and these sporulating cadavers elicited upwind flight behavior from other mosquitoes in Y-tube olfactometer choice assays [16]. Very few studies [12], [13], [14] have looked at this unusual behavior of mosquitoes which might have been partially conserved as an opportunistic behavior during the evolution from entomophagy to haematophagy. None of these previous studies have conducted choice discriminating assays such as olfactometer choice assays to study their upwind flight behavior or have not looked at the specific cues mosquitoes' use for finding the caterpillar host. In this study we show that mosquitoes can detect the CO 2 and other heat cues emanating from live caterpillars compared to dead caterpillars and can use them along with visual cues to land on them and feed on them. Our results show that significantly higher numbers of mosquitoes were alive on days 3 to 6 and the following days compared to no sugar water/starved condition. Cage assays shows that mosquitoes are able to survive longer by feeding on caterpillars under no food or nectar conditions and this opportunistic feeding behavior of mosquitoes can provide them some nutrition when nectar feeding resources are not readily available. However, observations from the relevant cages revealed that many mosquitoes were actually being killed by the caterpillars. Thus, it is difficult to determine whether the sugar-fed mosquitoes survived better because of nutritional factors alone, or whether reduced risk of mortality due to caterpillar defensive behaviors (and even predation), also played a role. Healthy caterpillars evoked substantial levels of upwind flight attraction of An. stephensi mosquitoes that was correlated with the higher CO 2 emission rates from living compared to dead caterpillars. In nature, female mosquitoes face the obligatory task of finding suitable protein resources for egg production, and they use their olfactory system to respond to different vertebrate host-odor cues. CO 2 plays a significant role in activating and orienting the females of most species to fly upwind over long distances to locate their hosts [17], [18], using volatile co-attractant factors as well, such as lactic acid [19] and 1-octen-3-ol [20], [21]. Our analysis of dead vs. live caterpillar CO 2 emission indicated that the greater amount of attraction to the living caterpillars was correlated with a 10-fold higher emission of CO 2 . The amount of CO 2 produced by caterpillars in nature could very well be at behaviorally detectable levels for mosquitoes, and could act as a significant volatile co-factor involved in the location of caterpillars, just as it is in the orientation of mosquitoes toward vertebrate hosts. The degree of caterpillar feeding by mosquitoes in nature has not yet been established, but it is an important opportunistic behavior by female mosquitoes that warrants further research considering their ability to vector pathogens of human diseases. Mosquitoes derive sugar from diverse plant sources [22], [23] and many species spend time resting outdoors [24] so it is possible that they are in close proximity to plant-feeding caterpillars. Thus, the potential for opportunistic feeding on caterpillars might be high. Such behavior could provide alternative food resources that might be especially important when availability of nectar or fruit sugars is limited. Additionally, by feeding on insect larvae, mosquitoes might act as vectors of insect diseases and perhaps transfer viruses and other microorganisms (such as Wolbachia) from insect to insect, or even from insect to vertebrate hosts. These events could be ecologically and evolutionary important, even if rare. More research needs to be done using natural populations to examine how much, if any, feeding is performed upon soft-bodied insect larvae by mosquitoes in the field. If such feeding was indeed a basal trait before the shift to blood-feeding on vertebrates occurred, it would be important to know whether or not it has been entirely abandoned by present-day mosquitoes.

Materials and Methods Mosquito Rearing An. stephensi Liston were reared under standard insectary conditions of 27°C, 80% humidity and 12:12 light: dark photo-period. Eggs were placed in plastic trays (25 cm×25 cm×7 cm) filled with 1.5 l of distilled water. To reduce variation in adult size at emergence, larvae were reared at a fixed density of 400 per tray. Larvae were fed Liquifry for five days and then on Tetrafin fish flakes (Tetra, Virginia, USA). From approximately two weeks after egg hatch, pupae were collected daily and placed in emergence cages. The adults that emerged were fed ad libitum on a 10% glucose solution. All experiments used four to six day old adult female mosquitoes. The sugar solution was removed four hours before the mosquitoes were used in the experiments. Caterpillar Rearing Fourth instar larvae of H. subflexa or M. sexta were used in the experiments, because they are representative of the cosmopolitan moth families Noctuidae and Sphingidae whose caterpillars An. stephensi females might easily encounter in their natural habitats in Asia. Laboratory colonies of these species were maintained on artificial diet under controlled conditions (14:10 h L: D, 23°C, 60% relative humidity) in a rearing room. The eggs of tobacco hornworm (M. sexta L.), were obtained from Carolina Biological Supply (Burlington, NC, USA) and allowed to hatch in Petri dishes (90 mm×15 mm) on moist filter paper (Whatman 1; 90 mm) in a growth chamber (16 : 8 L : D; 25°C: 22°C Day: Night; 65% RH). Larvae were then moved to plastic containers (35 cm long×10 cm high×15 cm wide) in the same growth chamber for mass rearing on artificial casein diet. Late third instars of M. sexta were used in the Y-tube olfactometer assays and for CO 2 measurements. Late third instars of H. subflexa were used in olfactometer assays, CO 2 measurements and in the cage assays to assess the survivability of An. stephensi by feeding on caterpillars. Caterpillars were removed from the diet cups one hour before using in the experiments and all the surface excrements were removed before using them in the experiments. Olfactometer Choice Assays A Y-tube olfactometer (70×35×6 cm) was used for the behavioral assays (Fig. 1). Only female mosquitoes were used in the olfactometer assays as male mosquitoes showed poor upwind flight behavior to caterpillars or to other chemical odorants. Female An. stephensi were released at the main, downwind end of the Y-tube with charcoal-purified air pushed through both arms of the Y-tube at the rate of 0.75 litre/sec. One 4th-instar laboratory-reared larva of either H. subflexa or M. sexta was placed on a cardboard disc and retained inside the arms of the Y-tube at the extreme upwind end. Mosquitoes were assayed individually and those that flew upwind the length of the tube and landed on or near the caterpillars or in the control arm (cotton dental wick of the same dimension caterpillar) were removed using an aspirator and never used again. The orientation of the arms of the Y-tube were flipped 180° after 15 individual flights to avoid lighting-related bias, and tube's interior walls were rinsed with hexane at that time. Four-to-six day old lab-reared female An. stephensi were used in the study. Females that did not initiate an upwind flight after two minutes were discarded. Choice assays were performed using live caterpillars vs. a blank (dental wick) control, and in addition, live caterpillars were compared against dead caterpillars that had been frozen for 12 hours at −20°C, and then thawed back to room temperature. Carbon dioxide Measurement using Respirometer Assays Metabolic rates were measured by placing each live or dead caterpillar into its individual flow-through respirometry chamber as explained in Blanford et al. [25]. Dry CO 2 -free air was passed through the 20 ml chambers at 0.25 litres/min and then dried and passed through a Li-Cor 6252 CO 2 analyzer. Within each run, seven experimental chambers containing an individual caterpillar were sampled in sequential fashion by using a computer-controlled valve system. Three chambers each contained a live caterpillar and four contained a dead caterpillar; these were used in the first run and the order was reversed for the second run giving 7 replicates. An eighth chamber was left empty and sampled between each of the occupied chambers to establish a baseline. All chambers were housed in a reach-in incubator set to 25 (±0.2)°C. Analog signals from the flow meter and carbon dioxide analyzer were converted to digital and recorded on a computer (Sable systems, Salt Lake City). The amount of CO 2 produced by live and dead caterpillars were measured. The caterpillars were used only once in the experiments. Cage Assay to Study the Mosquito Survivability by Feeding on Caterpillars Female An. stephensi that were four to six days old were used for the study. The mosquitoes were never blood-fed, and were given access to 10% sugar solution until the start of the experiment. Forty mosquitoes were introduced into a rectangular plastic cage (30 cm×15 cm×15 cm) that had a removable top covered with a mesh that allowed free passage of air. The experiment consisted of three treatments and four replicates for each treatment (N = 160). In the first treatment, mosquitoes were provided with 10% glucose solution in a 40 ml glass bottle with filter paper wicking the sugar solution for mosquitoes to access to the wick. In the second treatment, three 4th -instar H. subflexa larvae were placed inside a second cage and allowed to roam around the cage. A previous study of mosquito feeding on caterpillars [10] had used caterpillars that had been either coddled or else had been tied to the sides of the cages, which prevented the free movement of caterpillars in the cage. No food or water was provided to the caterpillars as this could have provided nutrition for the mosquitoes as well. H. subflexa caterpillars were changed every 24 hours with new freshly fed caterpillars. In the third treatment group mosquitoes received no glucose or any other form of nutrition for the duration of the experiment. All cages were kept under 14: 10 light-dark cycle and their positions were randomly rotated each day. The experiments were run until all the mosquitoes in the caterpillar cage were dead, or else until 10 days had elapsed and mosquito mortality was monitored daily. Data were analyzed using SAS and Chi-square 2×2 tests of independence. The cage assays for mosquito survival were analyzed using Wald Chi Square statistics. Pairwise comparisons were conservatively adjusted using a Bonferoni correction.

Supporting Information Movie S1. Video showing the upwind flight behavior of female An. stephensi mosquito towards a fourth instar larvae of Manduca sexta Mosquito took only 6 seconds to enter the y-tube arm containing the caterpillar and only 20 seconds to land on the caterpillar. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0108894.s001 (MPG)

Acknowledgments We thank Dannielle Krocyznski for assistance in the lab, Rupesh Kariyat for supplying the Manduca sexta caterpillars and Michael Domingue for help with statistical analysis.

Author Contributions Conceived and designed the experiments: JG TCB. Performed the experiments: JG SB. Analyzed the data: JG TCB MBT. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MBT SB. Wrote the paper: JG TCB MBT.