So, the replay we wanted to do was past it's download date. Very embarrassing, we're noobs, GG. So, we just found a random captain's mode replay and casted it! We had a fun time. The draft is as follows:

Radiant: Enigma / Ogre Magi / Gyrocopter / Templar Assassin / Timbersaw

Dire: Clinkz / Mirana / Clockwerk / Bane / Dazzle

http://dotabuff.com/matches/554083158

As always, check out our sub-reddit at reddit.com/r/welikedota, and our Youtube channel. An, upvote on reddit.com/r/dota2 and reddit.com/r/learndota2 in addition to telling others about the show are huge helps to us. Thanks for listening!