President Donald Trump’s selections of Stephen Moore and Herman Cain were a departure from his past picks for the central bank. | Evan Vucci/AP Photo white house Trump Fed pick Stephen Moore withdraws amid GOP opposition

President Donald Trump announced Thursday that conservative commentator Stephen Moore has withdrawn as a candidate for the Federal Reserve, a stinging blow to the president’s efforts to install political loyalists at the central bank.

“Steve Moore, a great pro-growth economist and a truly fine person, has decided to withdraw from the Fed process,” Trump tweeted. "Steve won the battle of ideas including Tax Cuts...and deregulation which have produced non-inflationary prosperity for all Americans. I’ve asked Steve to work with me toward future economic growth in our Country."


Moore's move comes a little more than a week after another embattled Fed pick, Herman Cain, also took his name out of consideration. The president had declared both men to be his preferred choices for the central bank even before the White House and the FBI had completed vetting them, but both faced stiff opposition from Republicans in the Senate, largely over concern about their past conduct with women.

Moore, who like Cain was never formally nominated, is withdrawing after a chorus of GOP senators expressed doubt that he would be able to secure enough votes to be confirmed, given his history of comments that demeaned women.

Sen. Joni Ernst (R-Iowa), a member of the GOP leadership who had raised the most emphatic criticism, said today it was “the right call for him to move on.” She added, “hopefully now we can see another nomination that’s been thoroughly vetted and someone that’s more appropriate for that position.”



POLITICO Playbook newsletter Sign up today to receive the #1-rated newsletter in politics Email Sign Up By signing up you agree to receive email newsletters or alerts from POLITICO. You can unsubscribe at any time. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Senate Republicans were told that Moore would be pulled on Thursday morning, one senator said.

Moore -- who earlier today had declared in an interview with Bloomberg News that Trump was moving "full speed ahead" with his nomination -- said in a statement to the president: "I am respectfully asking that you withdraw my name from consideration. The unrelenting attacks on my character have become untenable for me and my family and 3 more months of this would be too hard on us."

Moore called Trump's economic policies a "spectacular success" and said he was "proud to have played a small role in helping make that happen. I will continue to be a loud economic voice advocating for your policies."

Trump’s selection of two overt political allies had set off alarms among lawmakers that they would erode the Fed’s political independence by focusing on the president’s reelection prospects rather than on what’s best for the long-term health of the economy. Moore has consistently defended the president on TV and in his writings, and Cain formed a super PAC last year to promote Trump's agenda.

That concern was stoked, in part, by Trump's relentless attacks on Fed Chairman Jerome Powell and the central bank since last July for pursuing a campaign of interest rate hikes, a policy that the president said was hurting the economy but has been all but abandoned.

Sen. Richard Shelby (R-Ala.), a senior member of the Banking Committee, said it was good that Moore withdrew because his potential nomination had “obviously been in trouble.”

“Everybody ought to be vetted as much as they could before they are seriously nominated because they will be vetted later,” Shelby said.

But Moore and Cain stepped down mainly because of issues with women; Cain has been accused of sexual harassment in the past, and Moore has written disparagingly of women.

In a March 2002 column, Moore criticized the NCAA for allowing a woman to referee a college men’s basketball game. “How outrageous is this?” he wrote. “Is there no area in life where men can take vacation from women?”

In 2014, he wrote that women earning more than men could be “disruptive to family stability,” and in 1994, he blasted the Violence Against Women Act, a tool aimed at combating and prosecuting sexual assault and other violent crimes, as “the most objectionable pork” in a crime prevention bill.

“First, Cain. Now, Moore," Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said in a statement. "Thank goodness neither were actually nominated. The only thing less funny than some of Mr. Moore’s tasteless, offensive, sexist ‘jokes’ was the idea that President Trump would even consider him for a seat on the Federal Reserve.

“Now President Trump must nominate two serious candidates who will strengthen our economy.”

Moore said on Sunday that he was “apologetic” and “embarrassed” by some of his past writings, some of which he says were intended as jokes, but did not elaborate.

Republican senators had initially spoken warmly about Moore, who has long been a presence in the GOP, particularly as a fierce advocate for lower taxes. A founder of the conservative Club for Growth, he is also a prominent proponent of supply-side, or “trickle-down economics,” which suggests lowering taxes and deregulation are the best way to spur economic growth.

Moore has been defiant, decrying the attacks on his possible nomination as a smear campaign. “I think I’m going to be on the Fed. By the way, the president and the White House economics team’s totally behind me,” Moore said on April 30 on CNBC.

National Economic Council Director Larry Kudlow, a close friend of Moore’s, also repeatedly affirmed the White House’s support for the Heritage Foundation fellow.

Trump’s selections of Moore and Cain were a departure from his past picks for the central bank. Four of the five Fed board members were appointed by the president, including Powell as chairman, and all of them cleared the Senate easily on bipartisan votes.

But Trump soured on Powell last year over the Fed's interest rate moves. The president has also railed against the central bank for removing the extraordinary economic support put in place during the last recession and repeatedly called on the Fed to slash rates despite strong economic growth – an opinion shared by Moore. Moore had also called for Powell to resign.

In addition to his past comments, Moore faced blowback over a $75,000 tax dispute with the Internal Revenue Service and for his previous failure to pay more than $300,000 in child support and alimony payments. He was also criticized for 2014 remarks in which he referred to Cleveland and Cincinnati as “armpits of America.” “If you live in the Midwest, where else do you want to live besides Chicago, right?” Moore said during a forum at the Heartland Institute.

Economists across the political spectrum also questioned his economic credentials, with Moore himself having admitted that he is not an expert on monetary policy or bank regulation – the Fed’s two main areas of purview.

As the controversy over his past writings intensified, Moore called for a focus on his economic ideas, but even some of those -- such as his belief that interest rate moves should be tied to commodity prices -- generated opposition and some derision.

He has also maintained that the U.S. economy is experiencing deflation, though the Consumer Price Index indicates the opposite, putting the inflation rate at just under 2 percent.

“Sometimes the Senate advises and sometimes the Senate consents,” said Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), a Senate Banking Committee member. “In this case I think the senate was offering advice.”

Burgess Everett and Zachary Warmbrodt contributed to this report.