Lea Michele, star of Glee and Scream Queens, was on Ellen yesterday to promote her new show. During her time with the beloved host, she talked about Scream Queens and her Women’s Health magazine feature and cover.

Ellen, then, took notice that Lea has been single for a while, saying that she was “single and alone, and lonely, and desperate.” Lea Michele responded, laughing, “Hey, hey, I’m doing good.” Still, apparently Ellen didn’t buy it and decided to play matchmaker by setting up a hilarious game of ‘Who’d You Rather?’

To kick things off, Lea had to choose between new Scream Queens regulars, John Stamos and Taylor Lautner — a tough decision, indeed. She noted that both are “so handsome,” but ultimately chose the Twilight star, saying, “Stamos is probably a little on the older side for me, but I love you, John. So I’m gonna go with Taylor.”

She still had some super hard choices to make, having to decide between the likes of Nick Jonas, Prince Harry, Tom Hiddleston (Lea said he has too much going on between Taylor Swift and Priyanka Chopra) and Michael B. Jordan, among others. Jordan seemed like a surefire winner until Calvin Harris came along and surprisingly — to Ellen, at least — took over the game. At the end, the man of everyone’s dreams came up on the screen, Zac Efron. As soon as Lea took a look at his picture she made it pretty clear he was the winner, stating, “Give me Zac Efron any day. Any day.”

Watch the video below:

So Efron won the game, and, if Ellen has her way, he will be Lea Michele’s new boyfriend. The actress did say, however, “if Michael B. Jordan wants to call me, he totally can.” Ellen jokingly said she would text Jordan and, a few hours later, tweeted she already had. So we’ll have to wait and see if something comes from all of this, either with Jordan or Efron. Probably not, but wouldn’t it be a great story to tell their grandchildren?