Since reading many articles of late regarding the old North vs. South issue in rugby union, I felt the need to add my five cents. First, let’s have a look at all the stats from a North vs South perspective.

Between 20 June 2007 and 20 June 2010 (3 Years)

(Wins-Losses-Draws(if any)-Win%)

New Zealand vs.

Eng 4-0-100

Fra 2-2-50

Ire 3-0-100

Sco 2-0-100

Wal 3-0-100

A win ratio of 87% for NZ.

Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Reddit Email Share

South Africa vs.

Eng 3-0-100

Fra 1-1-50

Ire 0-1-0

Sco 2-0-100

Wal 5-0-100

A win ratio of 84% for South Africa.

Australia versus

Eng 3-2-60

Fra 4-0-100

Ire 1-0-1-50

Sco 0-1-0

Wal 2-1-66

A win ratio of 66% for Australia.

In the two years that followed, 20 June 2010 to 20 June 2012.

New Zealand vs.

Eng 1-0-100

Fra 2-0-100

Ire 3-0-100

Sco 1-0-100

Wal 2-0-100



A win ratio of 100% for New Zealand

South Africa vs.

Eng 3-0-100

Fra 0-0-0

Ire 1-0-100

Sco 0-1-0

Wal 2-0-100

A win ratio of 85% for South Africa

Australia vs.

Eng 0-1-0

Fra 1-0-100

Ire 1-1-50

Sco 0-1-0

Wal 5-0-100

A win ratio of 70% for Australia.

Over the last five years, dating from 20 June 2007 to 20 June 2012.

New Zealand vs.

Eng 5-0-100

Fra 4-2-66

Ire 6-0-100

Sco 3-0-100

Wal 5-0-100

A win ratio of 92% for New Zealand.



South Africa vs.

Eng 6-0-100

Fra 1-1-50

Ire 1-1-50

Sco 2-1-66

Wal 7-0-100

A win ratio of 85% for South Africa.

Australia vs.

Eng 3-3-50

Fra 5-0-100

Ire 2-1-1-50

Sco 0-2-0

Wal 7-1-87

A win ratio of 68% for Australia.

From this we can conclude the following; if we take the periods 2007-2010 and 2010 to present:

SANZAR vs. Five Nations

New Zealand’s win ratio went from 87% to 100% at an average of 92%

South Africa’s win ratio went from 84% to 85% at an average of 85%

Australia’s win ratio went from 66% to 70% at an average of 68%

Five Nations vs. SANZAR –

Englands win ratio went from 16% to 20%.

Frances win ratio went from 30% to 0%

Irelands win ratio went from 16% to 16%

Scotlands win ratio went from 20% to 66%

Wales win ratio went from 9% to 0%



Against Five Nations opposition, New Zealand are far superior, followed by South Africa, with Australia trailing behind.

Against SANZAR opposition between 2007 and 2010, France were the best followed by Scotland, then England, Ireland with Wales trailing behind.

The order has since changed and has Scotland leading by far, followed by England, then Ireland, with Wales and France trailing behind.

The statistics clearly put an end to the North versus South debate; one can conclude that the Southern Hemisphere has been and is still dominant over the Northern Hemisphere.

Between 2007-2010, the southern hemisphere had won 35 of 44 tests at an average of 79%,

2010 – 2012 the southern hemisphere had won 22 of 26 tests at an average of 84%

2007-2012 the southern hemisphere had won 59 of 72 tests at an average of 81%

Scotland seem to be the best performing northern hemisphere team, with Six Nations champions Wales the worst performer of both periods.

If anything, the only argument that the North can make is that the scorelines have become somewhat closer to the old wallops the northern hemisphere constantly received at the hands of the SANZAR nations. But results are what matter in world rankings, and there cannot be any doubt as to New Zealand’s spot at number one

Thereafter, there may be some debate as to which of South Africa or Australia should occupy second place.



With South Africa having a better record against both Five Nations, and New Zealand than Australia, the conclusion is that the only reason Australia are in second spot, is that they have had the better of South Africa in recent years.

That New Zealand, South Africa and Australia are the top three sides cannot be denied.

What happens therafter is rather interesting and one can only conclude that Wales success against their Northern hemisphere rivals may be the only reason they are ahead of Scotland and England. Based only on North versus South results it would be Scotland leading the way followed by England.

The stats would also suggest that in terms of bogey teams, England find it easiest against Australia, France have had their most success against New Zealand, Scotland have had the best of Australia, and Wales haven’t done anything other than win the Six Nations to suggest they are the fourth best team in the world.