Colton Haynes, the handsome star of MTV’s Teen Wolf and CW’s Arrow, has cooked up a lot of speculation after posting an ambiguous post to Tumbler.

Tumbler user “pornandmariah” submitted a comment to Hanyes’s official account, telling him: “when i found out colton haynes had a secret gay past i got so excited even though it makes absolutely no difference in my life. ”

Haynes reblogged the comment to his own account, adding: “was it a secret? Let’s all just enjoy life & have no regrets :)”