The Taxi and Limousine Commission of NYC has filed a proposal that would require car-service apps that only accept credit-card payment, such as Uber, to give users the choice to tip on their card.

Currently, passengers are automatically charged for an agreed-upon fare with the card they have on file.

But the Independent Drivers Guild, which represents Uber drivers in New York, claims drivers aren’t getting their due when passengers don’t have an easy tipping option.

Uber’s policy on tipping has been unclear, and many passengers have had the impression that a tip was already included in the price.

We asked New Yorkers how they feel about tipping their drivers, and whether they’d continue to ride with Uber. Hear their thoughts in the video above.