FX

American Horror Story and SpongeBob SquarePants are on opposite ends of the TV spectrum, audience-wise, yet Tumblr has proven that they perfectly mash up — and it's a little unnerving. Fans have been memeing AHS using SpongeBob pics since Day 1, but a new trend developed on Reddit recently with the unveiling of Season 6's Roanoke.

Fans take an actor who's been on the show for several seasons — sorry, Lady Gaga — and choose a SpongeBob pic to illustrate each character on the anthology series, joking how their secret identity has been "confirmed." It's unclear exactly who started this trend, but we thank the internet (especially Reddit users theahsfan, funky-al, Jesus_Christa, and fistyday) for always keeping us laughing.

[Note: Several images have been converted from their original horizontal layout to a vertical one for easier viewing.]