From putative racial profiling to copying artist designs, Zara is no stranger to controversy. The Spanish retail giant seemingly has a knack for cause célèbre and this time it got smacked with a massive $5 million USD lawsuit for its alleged “deceptive pricing practices.” This past May, a man by the name of Devin Rose bought three shirts from a Zara store in Los Angeles, California. According to Us Weekly the lawsuit stated that “the actual euro-dollar exchange rate would have resulted in his €9.95 shirts costing approximately $11.26 each. Instead, however, Zara charged Mr. Rose $17.90 per garment, a markup of nearly 60%.”

Zara habitually prints euro prices rather than dollar amounts on its clothing tags and from Rose’s assertion, apparently the brand isn’t keeping tabs on the shifting exchange rates—causing confusion amongst customers who are presumably getting swindled due to the aforesaid statement. By the same token, Rose suspects that “behind its façade of attainable elegance, Zara is engaged in a widespread practice of deceiving American consumers through a classic bait and switch.”

Now, this is where the suit gets interesting: if approved, folks who ever bought falsely-priced garments from Zara can enter the case and split the settlement amount. According to The Fashion Law, Zara USA released a statement saying that it “denies any allegations that the company engages in deceptive pricing practices in the United States.” Having added:

While we have not yet been served the complaint containing these baseless claims, we pride ourselves in our fundamental commitment to transparency and honest, ethical conduct with our valued customers. We remain focused on providing excellent customer service and high-quality fashion products at great value for our customers. We look forward to presenting our full defense in due course through the legal process.

In response, Rose and his legal team said: