The media is never slow to point out a weak Oscar year, leading us to think that perhaps handing out awards once a year is too often? What would the Academy Awards look like if the competition was stacked and awards were given out once every 4 years — like the Olympics?

To get a clue, we gathered all 34 Best Picture nominees from 2013 to 2016 and normalized the ratings from IMDB, Taste, Rotten Tomatoes, and Metacritic into one single ranking.

Of course, that’s only what the stats say. Whether you agree or not, be sure to cast your own vote here.