Edit, 7:58 AM PST: Not only did it actually happen, but there’s video as well! Check it out below:

First Blur, now Mutemath. Are Reddit AMAs becoming the place where fans make their musical dreams come true?

Last week, Blur played a song during a show in Mexico City that the band hadn’t performed live in 15 years after a fan made a request during an Ask Me Anything with guitarist Graham Coxon. On Monday, lightning struck again, this time with another musical act and another fan.

RELATED: Blur Plays Song Live for 1st Time in 15 Years After It’s Requested in an AMA

During Mutemath’s three-hour AMA, Reddit user PointlessGIF asked to sit in and play the trumpet with the band during its Monday night show in Los Angeles:

PointlessGIF also strengthened his case to make an appearance by linking to a video showing him sitting in with the Preservation Hall Band.

So how did Mutemath respond? Well, like rockstars.

Did PointlessGIF make it to soundcheck? Did Mutemath follow through and let him jam with them on “Armistice” or another song? No confirmation yet, but we’ll update the story when we find out.

Check out the full AMA with Mutemath.