President Donald Trump, who did not give his wife a gift for her birthday back in April spent his 72nd birthday alone in D.C. after First Lady Melania Trump fled to New York, leaving her husband behind.

The First Lady was photographed in New York on Trump’s special day with a caravan of black S.U.V.s, Vanity Fair reports.

According to her spokesperson, Melania arrived in New York on Wednesday and toured the city on Thursday. The spokesperson clarified statements made by the president, who told reporters last week that Melania was unable to fly after undergoing surgery for her kidney. She is still able to fly domestically.

In an interview with Fox News, Trump told host Steve Doocy that he “got a lot of kisses” from his “beautiful wife” for his birthday, even though she was miles away in “a series of meetings.”