CBS

Placement: 2nd (Australia), 12th (All-Stars), 5th (Heroes vs Villains)

Voted the Sexiest Male Player of All Time, Colby is more than just eye-candy. He is the series's first true "Hero", winning five immunity challenges. Colby may have chosen honour and taken the motherly Tina to the end instead of the unlikeable Keith, losing $1 million in the process, but he is still considered one of the most likeable people to have ever played.