“Pastry Stouts have been big for a while, and we wanted to do something in that category,” said Old Bakery’s James Rogalsky. “We’ve always stayed away from pumpkin beers, but get a lot of requests for them. So, this is our foray into that. Carrot Cake is a personal favorite, so we tried it out.”

Carrot Cake Brown Ale is very different from most of Old Bakery’s other beers. Brewed with carrots and a blend of spices, it also contains lactose. Lactose is not fermentable by brewers yeast, so it leaves a sweetness behind in the beer after the yeast is done. It also adds some body and a creamy sweet character.

As described above, many of the pastry inspired brews we have seen are stouts, but Rogalsky decided to go another way. “I thought that a stout would be a bit heavy for the flavor profile we wanted, so a brown ale seemed more appropriate. We hand-picked 150 lbs of carrots from Earthdance Farm School in Ferguson, MO. Each batch got 50 lbs of carrots. We boiled, pureed them, and added them to the mash.”

Tasting Notes

The result is pure pastry heaven.

On the pour: Dark brown, should be fairly clear. Off-white head.

On the nose: Mostly spices including cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, vanilla. Not much from the carrots.

On the tongue: Similar to the nose. Spicy, but with a mellow, vanilla finish. Sweet.

Label Art