I genuinely wanted to be surprised so I left my likes intentionally vague (Something like "Surprise me, I'm 36 and am feeling nostalgic for things from my youth - video games, music, etc.)...

I got a laugh out of it anyway. I thought I was getting shafted so I was happy to get anything. Package was marked shipped on the deadline day, 11 days after my information was last retrieved, the cheeky monkey.