From the W 4 St-Wash Sq station, it’s about a 40-minute train ride to 25 Av and then a less than 10-minute walk on 86th Street to get there. They get busy around noon and even busier in the evenings, so I always try to be out of there by 5:00. They are famous for their Sicilian Pie, which comes in 12 (thick) slices (half) or 24 (full). I’ve never seen anyone eat more than six slices. Most eat three or less. Although they have a full menu, you are likely to see their Sicilian pie on at least half of the tables if you look around. I recommend the seafood salad for an appetizer, but there are plenty of others. However, if you are looking for something less heavy, the seafood salad is the way to go. There were four people at our table and we barely finished the half pie. I recommend finishing it there since it’s not nearly as good reheated. Eat it while it’s hot. In fact, if you order other things, eat the pizza first before it starts getting cold! When you are done, try their Italian Ice. Lemon and cherry are my personal favorites, but if they have watermelon, that’s excellent too!