Marco Rubio is a very talented politician. He walked into an arena full of 7,000 Floridians who were determined to heckle him for siding with the National Rifle Association (NRA) for his entire career.

But within minutes of talking, he earned some respect. He didn’t stop the heckling, but he did his very best impression of a sincere man who honestly wanted to keep children safe, if only there weren’t so many complications to this whole lawmaking thing.

There are apparently lots of guns, and lots of loopholes. How on earth can a little law tackle such a big problem?

Marco Rubio on gun control: where does he stand on the issues? Read more

He offered up some token concessions that would do not very much at all to stop the massacres: raising the age you could buy an assault weapon, but not banning them. Better background checks, but not universal ones. Stopping the sale of bump stocks, which played no part in the bloodshed at the Marjory Stoneman Douglas high school.

With ample charm and empathy, he almost got away with it. Until he met a 17-year-old student who was just as talented as him: Cameron Kasky, who survived the shooting by huddling with his brother in a classroom.

Kasky walked up to Rubio and shook his hand, along with the hands of the other politicians on stage: Florida senator Bill Nelson and his local congressman, Ted Deutch, both Democrats. He asked his friend to stand up and be acknowledged for signing up to serve in the military. And he asked the crowd not to boo Republicans and cheer Democrats. Like Rubio, he believed the nation needed to come together. “Anyone who is willing to change is someone we need on our side,” he declared.

Play Video 2:02 Florida shooting: students walk out of schools to call for gun control – video

Then the student closed in. “So, Senator Rubio,” he said casually, “can you tell me you won’t be accepting a single penny from the NRA?”

The crowd cheered like it was a slam dunkfest.

“People buy into my agenda,” insisted Rubio, ignoring the public disgust with buying and selling politics.

“So you won’t take more NRA money?” Kasky pressed on.

“That’s the wrong way to look at it,” Rubio said. “People buy into my agenda.”

“In the name of the 17 people who died, you can’t ask the NRA to keep their money?” Kasky asked in disbelief. “I bet we can get people to give you exactly as much money.”

Rubio told Kasky he was right: there was money on both sides of politics. But that wasn’t the question, and his answer was as irrelevant as his favorite playlist.

You know the ground is shifting when the NRA and its A-plus-rated politicians need to show up to a CNN town hall

It was a day for excessive sympathy and inadequate concessions. There were so many fine words of encouragement for all those feisty teenagers, and so many regrets for the grieving families. It was a long-winded way of sending thoughts and prayers; the modern-day version of paying for tears at a Victorian funeral.

You know the ground is shifting when the NRA and its A-plus-rated politicians feel the need to show up to a CNN town hall where they know they will be the targets of abuse for a grieving community.

But they also think they can ride this thing out with lots of talk about stopping insane people, rather than stopping the semi-automatics.

It’s just so darn hard to do what every other country has done to stop these mass shootings.

It took a sheriff in uniform to call out the NRA’s charade. When Dana Loesch, the NRA’s media-hating spokesperson had empathized her heart out, Broward County sheriff Scott Israel set her straight.

“You just told this group of people you’re standing up for them,” he said. “You are not standing up for them until you say you want less weapons.”

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Dana Loesch and Sheriff Scott Israel during the CNN town hall meeting. Photograph: Michael Laughlin/Sun-Sentinel via Zuma Wire/Rex/Shutterstock

Unlike the NRA, Rubio could at least consider an alternative, as he adopted his familiar posture of Solomon-sized thoughtfulness. He said he would “reconsider” his position on high-capacity magazines that carry enough bullets to kill a whole classroom in seconds.

If only it were easier to take his seriousness seriously.

He was serious about immigration reform, before he completely caved. He wrestled day and night with how to reconcile his nativist party with the civil rights of the undocumented. Naturally, he sided with the xenophobes.

He was serious about warning the country about the obvious dangers of electing Donald Trump. He told us Trump was “a first-rate con artist” and “clown act” who would bankrupt the nation.

But then he decided Trump was a true leader on Cuba, and all was forgiven.

At least the senator and the sheriff agreed that Trump’s latest idea for school safety – arming the teachers – was as dumb as it sounded.

Who is Dana Loesch? The NRA's chosen defender after the Florida shooting Read more

They both slapped down the latest fantasy of gun-makers and gun-dealers, just a few hours after Trump spun a story about Aaron Feis, the heroic high school coach who was killed last week.

“If the coach had a firearm in his locker when he ran at this guy – that coach was very brave, saved a lot of lives, I suspect,” Trump rambled. “But if he had a firearm, he wouldn’t have had to run, he would have shot him, and that would have been the end of it.”

Play Video 1:15 Trump says arming teachers with concealed weapons could prevent school massacres – video

As one of the high school teachers told Rubio, no one wants to be holding a gun when the Swat teams enter a school.

This has been a tough week for the American people, and most of all for one of them who happens to be president.

It’s bad enough that Donald Trump has to look serious around the victims of a school massacre, which he finds impossible, for some incomprehensible reason. Nothing says you’re serious about saving the lives of children like grinning with a big thumbs up.

Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) Our entire Nation, w/one heavy heart, continues to pray for the victims & their families in Parkland, FL. To teachers, law enforcement, first responders & medical professionals who responded so bravely in the face of danger: We THANK YOU for your courage! https://t.co/3yJsrebZMG pic.twitter.com/ti791dENTy

It’s doubly bad that Trump has to pretend that he’s going to do something to stop school shootings, when he is in fact super-duper proud of serving as the NRA’s stooge. “You came through for me, and I am going to come through for you,” he promised the NRA convention last year. At least we’re clear whose side he’s on.

But, then to cap it all, some bright young staffer thought it was a great idea to stage a listening session with the victims of several shootings. You’d think, after a year of working together in what you might call a hostile workplace, those brilliant staffers would know the boss by now.



Trump would perform far better if these were presidential exercises in speaking, rather than listening. Perhaps that explains the grotesque need to write on Trump’s crib sheet: “I hear you.”

It might have been more meaningful if they had scripted the line: “I’m listening.” But that was Frasier Crane’s catchphrase, so it’s not that much better.

Sadly even a sitcom psychiatrist would do a better job at grieving for America’s lost children.

Sign up for the Guardian US opinion newsletter