Honesty is the best policy in any relationship, but telling the truth has always been complicated for the Pretty Little Liars.

When the Freeform drama returned for the second half of Season 6, the show jumped five years into the future. The little Liars are all grown up, with new lives, new careers, and new men. Hanna (Ashley Benson) is engaged to businessman Jordan (David Coussins) — we feel you, Haleb fans! — and she explains why he’s so good for her in this exclusive sneak peek of Tuesday’s new episode.

“Ever since I’ve been back here, all I’ve done is spin and twirl,” Hanna tells Emily (Shay Mitchell). But Jordan “keeps me grounded.”

Unfortunately, she’s already keeping things from her fiancé — like erasing that security tape. Can Hanna really go forward with the wedding with a big, fat lie between them?

Pretty Little Liars airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. on Freeform.