Yesterday, actor Bill Murray stopped by Reddit HQ in San Francisco, Calif. for his second AMA, gearing up for his new film Rock the Kasbah. While he provided many hilarious answers to redditors’ questions, we decided to ask him a bonus one of our own:

“Would you rather fight 100 duck-sized horses or one horse-sized duck?”

We didn’t know how Murray would answer, but he took this question much, much more seriously than we expected.

Upvoted

Although Murray says, “I’m more of a lover than a fighter, especially when it comes to horse-sized ducks,” he doesn’t have any trouble getting into the specifics of how he’d step on a horse-sized duck’s webbed feet and even strangle it from behind. Watch above.

For more hilarious answers from Bill Murray’s AMA (including the greatest party he ever crashed and the best and worst things about being Bill Murray), check out the full discussion here.