The pair dated for more than a year and pals reportedly say they could get back together

Is there a tear in her beer?

Nashville star Hayden Panettiere has broken up with her boyfriend of more than a year, New York Jets wide receiver Scotty McKnight, a source confirms to PEOPLE.

Get push notifications with news, features and more.

But the split doesn’t appear to be the stuff of a sad country song. The actress, 23, is still friends with McKnight, 24, and one source tells TMZ that their pals wouldn’t be surprised if they got back together.