The curious nature of DC’s Legends of Tomorrow spinoff had many wondering if a potential Season 2 might change up the cast with new DC favorites for a different story. Now that Season 2 is confirmed, the CW drama confirms its intent to keep the core team, even as its Season 1 finale adds a major DC superhero to take us into Season 2.

Where previously producers had stoked the possibility of a rotating roster for Legends of Tomorrow Season 2, the official renewal helped lock down the current iteration, as TVLine confirms producers have no intent to shake up the core cast of Brandon Routh, Caity Lotz, Arthur Darvill, Victor Garber, Wentworth Miller, Franz Drameh, Ciara Renee, and - hopefully - Dominic Purcell.

That said, should Season 1 end in Vandal Savage’s defeat, a major DC hero might make an appearance in the finale to boost us into Season 2:

Rumor has it the final scene of Legends of Tomorrow‘s May 19 season finale will introduce a “beloved superhero from the DC canon” whose mysterious agenda serves as “a launching off point for Season 2.”

That … could really mean anything, but don’t let those “men of steel” and “dark knights” references get your hopes up yet. Might we finally get the Booster Gold fans have been clamoring for? Is Vixen joining full time? What other beloved DC heroes might make for a Legend-ary Season 2 fit?