Twilight perhaps would...

Well... actually we can't be sure if ponies eat meat or not.

True, we didn't actually see pony eating meal, but there are some hints that perhaps they are.

I mean firstly in one scene among food we could seen something what look like ham.

Secondly what for are pigs on Applejack's farm? Cows are there for milk, chicken for eggs, but pigs? The only logical reasons seem to be "for meat". What more even if cows seemed to be sentient we can't say the same about pigs in MLP.

So perhaps no one would be surprised in her taste of food.



...and I think that if ponies are vegetarian then its just because of one reason: they can't devour meat. So Sunset couldn't eat meat as a pony.

...but perhaps she would miss it. And actually... i think in human world she could also missed some more pony food...