Cards Against Humanity—the game that features incredibly ridiculous answers being paired up with various questions—has now raised a lot of questions about its own recent PR stunt.

The Kickstarter-funded brand purchased an island in Maine last fall for $190,000 and then split the six-acre spot into 250,000 separate one-foot-square plots. Each was licensed to the people who bought the company’s $15 holiday mystery pack that gave them 10 different gifts, including the plot of land. Plenty of happiness erupted from those who bought up the little squares of land on the island that had been renamed Hawaii 2.

“We wanted to do something big,” Max Temkin, a co-creator of the game, told the Chicago Tribune. “We thought about trying to launch something into space, or doing something visible from space. Eventually that led us down the path of buying a private island, which is something we’ve joked about in the past.”

According to the Portland Press Herald, the license read, in part, “You may name your square foot of land. You may use the entire private island for passive, non-commercial, non-motorized recreational activities. You may tell people at parties that you own part of a private island.”

Folks in the surrounding community, though, don’t love the idea of so many people owning a bit of their landscape. Cards Against Humanity has been told it wasn’t allowed to hand out those 250,000 licenses, according to the Bangor Daily News. In addition, the platform, shed and safe that the company placed on the island “within 22 feet of the lake’s normal high-water line are in violation of Liberty (Maine)’s subdivision and shoreland zoning ordinances.”

According to CNET, the safe contained “a bottle of scotch and 250,000 special cards with a close-up of a sloth on each one.” That’s worth traversing through other people’s property, right?

If it doesn’t do anything before April 15, Cards Against Humanity could see fines of as low as $100 per day for each violation and as high as $2,500 daily per day.

“While it is unlikely that the court would order penalties of $625,000,000 per day (250,000 multiplied by $2,500), the town will seek the maximum fines, penalties and legal fees as may be awarded by the court,” Liberty Code Enforcement Officer Donald Harriman wrote to the company, the Daily News notes. “A remedial plan acceptable to the town must be in place on or before April 15, 2015, to avoid the filing of a land use enforcement action in court.”

Area residents are concerned that many of those new folks with license to the land are going to show up at once, something that would be quite a jolt to the region. The safe on the island is part of the reason for concern. It contains prizes, and Cards Against Humanity held a race for consumers to try and get to the safe and open it. This resulted in some of those who had purchased the foot-square plots gaining “access to the island by crossing private property without permission of landowners,” the Daily News wrote. That led to complaints being filed with the sheriff’s department—never a good thing in a small town.

Harriman is also concerned about a geocoding game that Cards Against Humanity is working on that involves placing 100 thumb drives in a tree on Hawaii 2. “I find that an unpermitted commercial use has begun on Birch Island, in violation of the Liberty Shoreland Ordinance,” he wrote, the Daily News reports. “The entire scheme appears to be a development and/or divisions of land for profit with the possibility of intense use at various times.”