Earlier this week, we celebrated Howard Cosell’s 100th birthday by looking back at his patented Monday Night Football Halftime Highlights. While that was definitely one of Cosell’s career successes, let’s take a look at one of his career’s unmitigated disasters. Back in 1975, ABC greenlit a live variety show called Saturday Night Live With Howard Cosell.

Now you’re probably thinking, “Wait…Saturday Night Live?” That’s right, ABC got the title first, while NBC’s late night show called NBC’s Saturday Night premiered the same year.

ABC was thinking that due to Monday Night Football’s popularity and Cosell’s crossover appeal (he had made guest appearances on various shows like The Odd Couple), it would bring strong ratings to the network. In addition, ABC was hoping to revive the variety show which had died in the early 1970s. To top it off, ABC used the Ed Sullivan Theater in New York, the same place now used by CBS for its Late Show franchise, first with David Letterman and now with Stephen Colbert.

The network did a lot of promotion for the show, using its sports shows like Wide World of Sports and its primetime lineup in hopes of bringing viewers over. There was an article in People previewing the show and also questioning whether it could be successful.

“… the host of Saturday Night Live with Howard Cosell might say: this could be, ladies and gentlemen, and I mean this sincerely, the most extraordinary phantasmagoria in the recent chronicle of entertainment; or—and I say this because it must be said—it could very well prove to be an insult to the American intelligence and an abomination to the American eye.”

However, the show would go up against CBS’s powerhouse Saturday night lineup, led by The Jeffersons.

The problem was that Saturday Night Live With Howard Cosell tried to be a combination of things, and ended up as a variety show featuring interviews and a few sports crossovers. In addition, ABC Sports Executive Producer Roone Arledge made a major miscalculation thinking that Cosell would make a good variety show host. As Classic TV Sports noted back in 2013, Cosell’s strengths in ad-libbing and interviewing never showed during Saturday Night Live:

“Cosell was so nervous before the opening show that he wanted cue cards for backup despite the fact that he was legendary for doing his daily radio commentaries without notes or a script. That initial episode included Frank Sinatra, John Denver, Paul Anka, Shirley Bassey, Jimmy Connors, and the cast of The Wiz.”

Ratings never materialized for the show. The live aspect of the program led to problems, as some segments ran over. Arledge, who was successful in programming ABC Sports, had never produced a variety show. Director Don Mischer, who later became known for producing the 1996 Atlanta Olympics Opening Ceremony, The Oscars, and the Prince Super Bowl halftime show, said he regretted working on the Cosell show:

“(Arledge) said, ‘I’ve got a new show coming up with Howard Cosell. I’m hearing good things about you, can you come in and have a meeting with me about directing this?’ Then I ended up getting an offer to do Saturday Night Live with Howard Cosell, which was 8:00 to 9:00 p.m. on Saturday night, live from New York. Really high profile. They guaranteed me 18 shows, at $3,000 a show, which was big money. Then I got a call from a guy named Lorne Michaels who said, I’m starting a show called Saturday Night, its late-night, I’ll guarantee you eight shows. And I think it paid, like, $1,100 per show. So I chose Saturday Night Live with Howard Cosell, and I regretted that decision for a long, long time. Lorne never ceases to remind me of that when I speak with him.“

By October, one columnist wrote that the cancellation of Saturday Night Live With Howard Cosell was a “foregone conclusion.” The series’ last show was on January 17, 1976.

However, Saturday Night Live With Howard Cosell did break a few stars like Billy Crystal, Bill Murray, Brian Doyle-Murray, and Christopher Guest, as well as musical group The Bay City Rollers.

Thanks to Classic TV Sports, here are the show’s guest lists:

9/20/1975 — Frank Sinatra, John Denver, Paul Anka, Shirley Bassey, Jimmy Connors, The Cast of The Wiz

9/27 — John Wayne, Redd Foxx, Barbara Walters, Linda Ronstadt, Harry Blacksone Jr., The Eagles

10/4 — Alan King, Charo, Yogi Berra, Billy Martin, The Bay City Rollers

10/11 — Bill Cosby, Barry Manilow, Andy Griffith, Joe Frazier, Roberta Flack, The Rockettes

10/18 — Johnny Cash, Gabe Kaplan, Muhammad Ali, Evel Knievel, Ronee Blakley

10/25 — Soupy Sales (in Sea World), Evel Knievel, Kate Smith, Steve Landesberg, Chinese Acrobats of Taiwan

11/1 — Lee Majors, O.J. Simpson, George Burns, Walter Matthau, Joan Sutherland, Steve Landesberg, Rene Simard, The Rockettes

11/8 — Billy Crystal, Roy Clark, Ted Kennedy, Gwen Verdon, Chita Rivera, Esther Satterfield

11/15 — Andy Williams, Norm Crosby, Marilyn Michaels, Mark Wilson, Linda Hopkins

11/22 — Lionel Hampton, Tony Bennett, Lynn Anderson, John Byner, Ed Bluestone, Eunice Kennedy Shriver, Argentinian Gauchos

11/29 — Bob Hope, Rita Moreno, Doug Kershaw, Billy Eckstine

12/6 — Ben Vereen, Rodney Dangerfield, Olga Korbut, Billy Crystal, Roberta Peters

12/13 — Steve Allen, Robert Merrill, Esther Satterfield, Fred Travalena, Paul Anka, Chuck Mangione

12/20 — rerun

12/27 — rerun

1/3/1976 — rerun

1/10 — Milton Berle, Martin Mull, Charley Pride, Melissa Manchester, The Lockers

1/17 — Billy Crystal, Elayne Boozler, Ed Bluestone, The Bay City Rollers, The Movies

Because of the show’s short run, there aren’t any videos of any of the programs, but we do have a promo for the November 1, 1975 show:

NBC would start using the Saturday Night Live title in 1977 and never relinquish it, while Saturday Night Live With Howard Cosell would become just a blip in television history.