We knew it would come to this eventually: A full on fangs out, hair coiffed vampire throw down. And right here in our E! Celeb of the Year tournament, no less.

We started with 16 actors from a wide range of roles—strippers, superheroes and sitcom stars—and had them square off, eliminating 8 after the first round and 4 more after Round 2. Now, two undead hunks make up half of the Final Four.