The adventures of a modern-day sleuth cracking mysteries are the same as a dread pirate avenging his childhood sweetheart? Inconceivable! you might cry. But Tumblr user Jadzia says, Elementary, my dear fan. And she’s got the GIFs to prove it.

No surprise, a lot of the comparisons that Jadzia makes cast Sherlock/John as Westley/Buttercup—faking your death, approaching your beloved under a false identity, outwitting villains to save the one you love. And even saving your sweetheart from a fiery death:

But it’s not just Sherlock and Westley who are kindred spirits. Jadzia also pointed out how Buttercup and John grieve fiercely and similarly:

The parallels extend to battles of wits revolving around the highest of high stakes—which one is the poison?

And while pirates play a more significant role in one property than the other, this comparison couldn’t be ignored:

Back to the feels: Once Westley and Sherlock both come back from the dead, they’re staying put. They promise.

Check out Jadzia’s full list of parallels (part 1; part 2) for the full GIF effect.

[via The Daily Dot]