This product has been great. My only complaint is that 1/4 of the time when I plug in my controller, the status light immediately turns green. If I take if off the base and plug it back it, it will then be red as expected to indicate it is charging. This is a very strange glitch. It is certainly not fully charged when it shows green like that. In fact, once or twice, I've taken the controller off the charger only to find that I got a low battery warning shortly thereafter. After that, I've been careful to make sure I see a red light after plugging it in before walking away.