Quick, I dare you to name me five other NFL punters besides the Indianapolis Colts’ Pat McAfee. If you can’t do it, don’t worry, because McAfee is the only strong-legged NFL player who most bros care about thanks to his wild antics on and off the field.

A total bro, McAfee decided to dabble in some stand-up this offseason—and, wouldn’t you know it, he’s pretty fucking hilarious, telling an unbelievable gambling story about former teammate Peyton Manning during a trip to Vegas together for a golf outing.

Uh, how did Peyton just do that? Turns out “The Sheriff” really is good at reading opposing players, because he just won some cash for McAfee and all the other players who took Manning’s gambling advice that night.

[H/T The Score]