Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers continued last night and saw the elimination of NFL player Alan. After the tribes were swapped into three new tribes of five, Alan found himself with his former enemy Ashley, up against the Healers pair of Desi and Joe, with lone Hustler Devon in the middle. Alan was able to put aside his differences with Ashley, and the two seemed to have Devon on their side after he was put off by Joe’s used car salesman like patter. But when Joe decided to cause chaos at camp in hopes of drawing a target towards himself, it had the former Heroes worrying about a potential idol play. With Devon’s vote blocked by Jessica’s secret advantage, it looked like we were heading for a two-two tie, but Joe correctly played his idol for himself, sending Alan out of the game with two votes.

The fifth episode, “The Past Will Eat You Alive” airs Wednesday, October 25 at 8:00 pm (ET) on CBS.

View the gallery of Episode 5 press photos below:

Written by