plus-circle Add Review

comment Reviews

Reviewer: OTRRArchive - - January 7, 2020

Subject: Files Updated!

FYI:



Replaced files on this page from the Version 3 Release (07-Jan-2020).



For the full OTRR Release, see the OTRR Certified page:



OTRR Dark Fantasy



- Old Time Radio Researchers Group FYI:Replaced files on this page from the Version 3 Release (07-Jan-2020).For the full OTRR Release, see the OTRR Certified page:- Old Time Radio Researchers Group - January 7, 2020Files Updated!

Reviewer: Leviathis_Krade - favorite favorite favorite favorite - January 23, 2019

Subject: Great Stories I found all of these to be very insightful into the world of days past and what they found as suspense and it still has that alluring power, though some stories are weaker than others; all around though I would recommend giving these a listen. - January 23, 2019Great Stories

Reviewer: MPDMedia - favorite favorite - November 1, 2018

Subject: Rest of Sleeping Death Series doesn't hold a candle to Suspense, Mysterious Traveler, et al, but does anyone have the final half of the hokey last episode, Sleeping Death? Set in a sanitarium on an island, a mad doctor holds several people hostage for witnessing his past crimes in a court case. The implication is (Spoiler) that he's still in jail and creeping into the witnesses dreams via telepathy. - November 1, 2018Rest of Sleeping Death

Reviewer: Uncle Flaco - favorite favorite favorite favorite - February 2, 2018

Subject: 1st Impression I love the story "It thing from the darkness" as my first story to Dark Fantasy. I was intrigued with the mystery of the main character as the outsider to a group of traditional people who they believed he offended their god, as well as having a little drama with the chief's daughter who opposed his choice of marriage. But I was more interested in the Leopard/Panther men (sort of got confused which one they said), that were said to be aggressive under the moon and were to be given a sacrifice to calm them down. The noise that was produced as their roar/calling convinced me that they sounded more spiritual/phenomenon than just large animals. Another thing I liked from this story was the mystery around the chief and their belief. They made it sound like old customs, but to hear that the main female character (who was white) was taken as an infant by the chief (who claims to hate white) just to have a daughter. Leaves a good mystery to his character and his motifs. To say the least, I was happy to give this a listen. - February 2, 20181st Impression

Reviewer: Laikadog - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - January 29, 2018

Subject: Men call me mad too Dark fantasy. Well what can you say? Genius or utter trash? Some of the stories are laughable ... and yet ... there is something that transcends criticism. There are moments in some episodes when you are utterly fascinated by the originality of the ideas. In the thing from the sea - the creature is at the wheel and singing some weird sea shanty. Genius. Or in men call me mad we are told that rivers are bright red and a strange being is riding an unidentified animal. Genius. I love this series. So different. Quirky and a little left-field. Well worth a listen. - January 29, 2018Men call me mad too

Reviewer: furryscurry - favorite favorite favorite favorite - June 14, 2016

Subject: Good Horror show Some of the plots are pretty thin and I imagine that the production values were pretty low, but all things considered, Dark Fantasy is consistently creepy and unsettling. Generally the actors are pretty good and there are some truly great plots. A little sad that there aren't more episodes. - June 14, 2016Good Horror show

Reviewer: Mr. Lo - - June 8, 2016

Subject: Recording quality @Out Of Stone, considering the age of these programs I think the people who transfer them are doing a job commensurate with the data they have to work with and therefor it may not be the fault of the person doing the work. You are welcome to try to present a more acceptable recording transfer of the broadcasts in question, as I am sure you can do better. Good luck, we look forward to your uploading of your transfer, one that will meet your expectations. - June 8, 2016Recording quality

Reviewer: Out of Stone - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - April 30, 2013

Subject: Good Stuff Transfers of some of the episodes are atrocious - Debt from the Past and The Headless Dead, for instance, are of such inferior quality with their low bit-rates resulting in mangled audio that it makes for rubbish. Amateurs who make shoddy transfers ought to be shot.



Anyway, Dark Fantasy can be very affecting. The audio-play is so artificial and stilted that it becomes almost a work of art... a minimalist dreamscape. - April 30, 2013Good Stuff

Reviewer: rlemmon - favorite favorite favorite favorite - October 12, 2011

Subject: Dark Fantasy Well said "Shadows Girl" I agree completely! - October 12, 2011Dark Fantasy

Reviewer: Shadows_Girl - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - October 11, 2011

Subject: "Wooden cast? Bad Writing?" No..Just stupid reviewers. Scott Bishop, who was a well-known and wildly popular mystery writer back in the day (Hell, you could hardly pick up a copy of BLACK MASK, MICHAEL SHAYNE, ALFRED HITCHCOCK, or ELLERY QUEEN'S MYSTERY MAGAZINE without running across a story by him.



The cast includes Ben Morris(who also took over the role of "Pat Novak" in PAT NOVAK FOR HIRE from Jack Webb) was in THOUSANDS of old time radio programs "BROADWAY IS MY BEAT also comes to mind.

The rest of the in-house cast, including the lovely and talented Eleanor Naylor Caughron (whose last name has been mis-spelled in just about EVERY possible way) Fred Wayne, Tom Paxton, Garland Moss, and Murillo Scofield are usually pretty damn good.



The cry of "Cliche" is ridiculous when aimed at any of these old shows.

IF YOU WERE WRITING A STORY TODAY AND USED THESE THE CRITICISM MIGHT BE VALID

But cliches only BECOME cliches because they work so well and a lot of them originated with THIS show.

To be a fan of OTR (like being a fan of old horror films) the FIRST TRICK is to try to put yourself in the place of a listener or viewer BACK THEN.



You haven't encountered these plot devices before so they aren't CLICHES to YOU.



They scare the HELL out of you.



Especially when you listen to them late at night (well, after 10 PM) like the audiences were back then...with the lights out and your eyes shut to help you VISUALIZE what's happening.



If you can't contribute YOUR part to this "Theater of the Imagination"---if, in other words, you have no imagination...then go watch some piece of crap CGI movie down at the local theater.



And, right at the end, when the Monster you thought was dead, suddenly does a "Carrie" on you and leaps up again...remember where you met that cliche first.



And it wasn't in CARRIE...it was in those old movies and old time radio...and, most especially, it was in the Realm that is



DARK FANTASY - October 11, 2011"Wooden cast? Bad Writing?" No..Just stupid reviewers.

Reviewer: emahrwriter - favorite favorite favorite favorite - November 29, 2010

Subject: A Toast To The Radio Auteurs I write here as a professional author who works mainly in the field of audio drama (yes, it's still an ongoing popular, LIVING medium, here in the UK certainly), for the likes of BBC radio, Big Finish (their new Lovecraftian Doctor Who, Lurkers At Sunlight's Edge) and most recently "Blood & Stone" for 3Dhorrorfi. And I just want to put on record how much these great auteurs of 40s horror drama such as Scott Bishop and Arch Oboler mean to me, how much they continue to inspire me: other horror writers can have Stephen King et al for their role models; these guys are mine and I'm so grateful to the Archive for making their work available (I only recently became a member, but I've been listening for over a year now). The important thing is that they and their work aren't just relics of a bygone age, of only nostalgia value in the modern world, but the instigators of an ONGOING tradition. As one small contributor to that tradition's continuing, I salute these guys, wherever they may be. - November 29, 2010A Toast To The Radio Auteurs

Reviewer: gl1200phil - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - November 25, 2010

Subject: At the Top... Dark Fantasy! Top honors must be given to Scott Bishop's fine series, Dark Fantasy. This is one of the finest series ever aired in the horror genre. As is the case WITH ALL RADIO SERIES, some shows are better than others... Mr Bishop had the ability to craft shows week after week, of the highest caliber... Few if any, could be labeled mediocre. Unless someone has been in a situation, where they have had to come up with new material EVERY WEEK, it is difficult to appreciate the genius of Mr Bishop's solo work.

Mr Bishop's series demonstrates his inclusion into an elite class of writers and producers that would have to include such notables as Arch Oboler and Orson Welles. Many of Mr Bishop's plays could air in 2010, and there wouldn't be a clue that it wasn't contemporary, let alone give hints to the fact that this body of work is nearly SEVENTY YEARS OF AGE! The writing and production of Dark Fantasy has few equals.



Many thanks to Mr Prelinger and the Old Time Radio Researchers' Group for making so many fine programs available! - November 25, 2010At the Top... Dark Fantasy!

Reviewer: dreibel50 - favorite - October 11, 2010

Subject: Turkey Sandwich with Extra Cheese while Scott Bishop may have been a part of the classic Mysterious Traveler and The Sealed Book, he unfortunately didn't have his bosses at those series, writers Robert Arthur and David Kogan writing these episodes. These stories, for the most part, have hopeless plotting, wooden performances, and very sloppy scriptwriting - plot holes and contradictions abound in these stories as if they were written 20 minutes before airtime. (The planet Venuto? Give me a break!) In one story a character even changes her entire personality for no good reason! There are some exceptions ("Demon Tree" and "Pennsylvania Turnpike" are nice little chillers), and a few actually had some ideas which could've been improved with tighter writing ("Man With The Scarlet Satchel"), but for the most part these episodes sound like they were made by Dr. Uwe Boll. Those looking for excellent examples of radio horror and thrillers should check out shows like Mysterious Traveler, Suspense, Murder At Midnight and The Clock - this show is merely a curio and a DON'T example of how to write a horror script. - October 11, 2010Turkey Sandwich with Extra Cheese

Reviewer: Jake429 - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - January 3, 2010

Subject: A fantastic show! I love these fantasy/horror shows. Kudos to the great folks at the Old Time Researchers Group! - January 3, 2010A fantastic show!

Reviewer: DaNess - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - June 14, 2009

Subject: Greatness One of the best OTR Horror shows right there with Lights Out and Quiet, Please... Thanks for the Upload! - June 14, 2009Greatness

Reviewer: yotam der keine heilige - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - July 23, 2008

Subject: I love it! while today the radio story-telling can be found only in some radio station which are highly naive or highly experimental, the OTR project is a living proof to the its' golden age.

oh, of course that a lot of these episodes have a not-so-subliminal moral, but here the fact that once radio was considered widely as a mind provoking thing and done in exellent quality is what's important.

dark fantasy is a great example for what non-muxical radio programs should be like. thank you for it. yotam der keine heilige -- July 23, 2008I love it!