Overall

Vision Vision

Originality Originality

Technique Technique

Impact Impact

They share a similar base idea, but are vastly different pictures both in terms of message and visual impact.One could make an argument that this image is probably the technically superior one. Use of color, lighting, perspective, it's all really good. My one quibble is the pony anatomy; Celestia's rear left hip and leg draws too much attention.I love the stars and circles in Luna's mane, though it looks like maybe she used a little too much conditioner and it distracts from her face. I like that you put some regular mane in there for her too, and the fluffy ears work for me as well.Other than the style, it's Luna's face that's the big difference between the previous pic and this one. I'm not quite sure what you're going for, whether Luna's a little annoyed at her sister for something, or if this is the beginnings of jealousy, or something like that. I've always liked that aspect of their relationship, but it feels out of place when you set this image next to the first.It's a great pic, there's no doubt of that, but I think on the whole I prefer the first, mainly because it was a departure from typical styles and was very well executed.Thank you as always for sharing your work with all of us!