Tickets for Bruce Springsteen’s one-man Broadway show are going for as much as $12,500 on the resale market, putting the musician into “Hamilton” territory.

The New Jersey-born rocker’s “Springsteen on Broadway” show, which opened Thursday to mostly positive reviews after a brief preview period, is sold-out for its entire run through Feb. 3. Seats on StubHub, the resale site, start around $1,500 for most performances, with select tickets costing five figures in a few instances.

The original prices ranged from $213.50 to $875, not including 26 tickets made available for every performance through a lottery for $75.

Last week, the show took in $1.9 million at the box office, according to figures released Monday by the Broadway League, a trade group. That puts “Springsteen on Broadway” almost in the same league as such sales juggernauts as “Hamilton,” “The Lion King” and “Hello, Dolly!”

That is despite the fact Mr. Springsteen’s show, which consists of an extended monologue with musical interludes, is being staged in one of Broadway’s relatively smaller venues—the Walter Kerr Theatre, which has slightly under 1,000 seats.