On June 15, 2015, nearly a year to the date of their first date, with Ms. Wolfe soon on her way to spending months in La Jolla, Calif., to appear in “Up Here,” Mr. Krauthamer proposed marriage. “We were deeply in love and I knew I wanted to spend the rest of my life with her,” he said.

Carving out time for a wedding between show schedules was nearly impossible: a 2015 plan to marry in a Manhattan townhouse once owned by Liz Taylor was thwarted after discovering the elevator to the only bathroom was not functioning and couldn’t be fixed on their timeline.

But on Dec. 17 just over 100 guests gathered in an outside courtyard at the Rancho Valencia Resort in Rancho Santa Fe, Calif., for a ceremony combining aspects of both families’ faiths.

Led by the groom’s brother-in-law Matt Gewolb, who was deputized by the County of San Diego for the occasion, the couple exchanged personal vows against a cascade of autumnal-colored roses and eucalyptus leaves.

Mr. Krauthamer promised to support Ms. Wolfe’s “wildest dreams and relentless work ethic” and to shop with her even “during the brief between-show break on a two-show day.”