Another day, another sexy new suitor for Mindy Lahiri.

Justified fave Timothy Olyphant will grace The Mindy Project with his presence next Tuesday, Nov. 5 (Fox, 9:30/8:30c), and we have your exclusive first look at his meet-cute with Mindy Kaling‘s Big L Dr. L.

The bound-to-be memorable installment, titled “Sk8er Man,” finds Mindy trying to prove to Danny that she’s not too picky and judgmental by dating Olyphant’s skateboarder, Graham.

RELATED | 2014 Renewal Scorecard — What’s Returning, Cancelled?

Press PLAY below to watch Kaling and co-star Ike Barinholtz gush about Olyphant’s loosey-goosey alter ego, then hit the comments: How does Graham stand up to Mindy’s past loves?