Let’s start with the The Lady In Black AKA The Black Widow.

Marlene has said multiple times, “The Lady in Black is End Game”, “Black Widow is PLL’s EndGame” Etc.



However, so many people have this hatred for Sara Harvey, that they forget her story isn’t over.

Think about it for a second, we don’t know anything related to Sara’s motives. We don’t know –why Sara helped torture the girls, why she was helping CeCe, if she was or wasn’t kidnapped, why she was willing to blow herself up in the dollhouse. etc.”

Sara is one of the biggest mysteries on this show right now and people are blinded by her acting that they aren’t paying attention to the character itself. A girl from another town that parallels Rosewood has had her hands directly in the torturing of the Liars and no one knows why.



Now let’s get to Avenger A. It’s been pretty clear to me since the beginning that Sara Harvey is Charlotte’s avenger. It’s almost too easy. But don’t forget they revealed Charlotte three times as A and people were still lost. They revealed CeCe as red coat after Aria kicked her mask off, she was wearing the hoodie outside of Ezra’s door, and she unveiled herself at the christmas ball in the white cloak. (Now the last one can be argued, but the previews kept acting as if A was in the white cloak and wouldn’t show her face). Take a look at this promo picture below hyping the reveal of red coat (the same red coat who stole the game from Mona) (A) in season 4:

Yet no one connected the dots then that CeCe was said Red Coat.

Now to the clues as to why I think Sara Harvey is Avenger A.

Let’s start with the graveyard. We are led to believe, Avenger A was placing the flowers on Charlotte’s plot.

Which we can determine based on the flowers next to Jessica’s headstone (the purple ones) that Sara was also there visiting Charlotte’s plot.

Next clue, which is my favorite–The Gloves! We see Avenger A leaving the hotel to get into the town car and get a really good close up of her gloves.



Now an episode later, the liars break into Sara’s room to investigate her as the crazy stalker and what does Spencer find under the bed? The same white gloves, Avenger A is wearing in the episode before!

Now for some dialogue clues. When Ali and Sara had their conversation in the school, a few things stuck out to me:

“We both knew what it mean to be close with Charlotte, I felt like we were sisters. When no one else was there for her, I was… We never really knew all of her, but I was hoping, maybe you and I could put our pieces together and understand her a little better….we’re all she had.“

Another thing I noticed from the dialogue was when Sara said,

“I guess I just wanted to say, I’m sorry Alison..Sorry for your loss”

Avenger’s A driver just said that to them a few episodes ago.

Sara was a lot closer to Charlotte than we thought and she is staying in Rosewood to learn more about Charlotte, as well as AVENGE her death.

Obviously, whoever is avenging Charlotte was close to her. Right now there are only TWO characters that we know of, that was close to Charlotte - Alison and Sara. Sara clearly has plans for Alison as well. You can tell by her little sinister smirk at the end.

Now what was also interesting in the scene with Alison and Sara was that Sara flat out lied to Alison and then questioned why she did it.

“I didn’t realize you worked here? I’m looking for room 19…. I knew you worked here, I don’t know why I lied..”

Clearly, Sara is a manipulator and has no problem lying to fix her situation. She even did it to the judge to get out of going to jail. Who else did we used to see lie flat out? Charlotte. One particular scene I remember, where they showed CeCe lying and the viewers knew she was–was the time she told Aria that her car was towed WHILE she was sitting in it.



Let’s go backwards a bit and talk about Aria and the drive. A is notorious for having dirt on the girls. However, you can usually go back and figure out which characters had prior knowledge of the girl’s secrets and help you narrow down who A is. You can do it with Mona and with CeCe.

The tape with Aria sneaking out was only revealed to the Liars in the beginning. However, over time other characters were starting to get looped in. So before Avenger A sent them a message about the drive, the only characters that we know that had knowledge of it were 1. The liars 2. The Cops 3. Hanna’s mom and last but not least 4. Sara Harvey.

How did Sara know? The Liars being as naive as they are, discussed the murder and the tape with Aria and Ezra during their little Spa trip. And who was there the whole time listening?

Yes Ms Harvey. She has learned a thing or two being with Charlotte for so long.

Next up is the golf club picture, Avenger A sent to the girls.

We find out from Hanna later that the carpet is from the rooms at The Radley hotel.

Then later on, we find out from the cops–that the Golf Club is not actually the weapon. Oh and anyone notice that Sara’s gloves were so bulky in 6x15? That’s because she was wearing GOLF GLOVES.

Similar golf gloves above.

Fast forwarding… Marlene has been known for being extremely blunt in revealing A. So blunt that us viewers think it’s a red herring. Not only did she reveal CeCe as A so many times visually, but she has done it in countless dialogues. For example, she revealed that CeCe Drake booked the flight that A used at the lodge. Marlene even mentioned in an article that she was being really daring when she revealed that piece of the puzzle to the audience, but not many people picked up on it. They swept it under the rug as a lie and a red herring.

Now the reason I bring this up is because they show Sara in the hospital doing something to Emily. We are led to believe Emily was seeing things, because of the drugs she was under. HOWEVER, we see Avenger A at the end wearing the EXACT same gloves, Sara had on in the hospital scene.

This is so blunt and obvious, I almost couldn’t believe it. Marlene is counting on everyone to explain it away. Let’s not forget, the liars were hell bent on calling CeCe A. They even used CeCe’s name as a substitute for A during season 4. Who else are they doing that too? Yup Sara Harvey.

Another interesting thing I noticed was the files on A’s laptop that was shown when Caleb hacked it. One of the files was Art Archive.

I instantly started thinking about the people on the show that has artistic abilities. Then it clicked to me. The painting that Charlotte received in 6A on her birthday was from Sara! Her one and only Ally.

It’s clear that Sara has some artistic abilities and knows her way around a paint brush. It also means CeCe trusted Sara enough to let her know that she was once a boy named Charles–as well as show her tapes of her past! Additionally, CeCe must have really adored the painting because she places it in her room, in Radley, alongside her other special mementos.

Last, but not least! Let’s jump into the rabbit hole they found in Sara’s room at Radley. Sara is clearly obsessed with Charlotte, that she would break a hole into a closet that was Charlotte’s old room. I mean, who has the balls to open up a hole in a hotel room? We understand now, why she doesn’t want the maids cleaning her room and how she has been able to sneak in and out of Radley without being seen.

Does no one see this parallel? CeCe also used to sneak in and out of Radley to do her dirty work. Marlene is slapping us in the face with clues right now. I mean she has to right? We only have 1 ½ seasons left to tell Avenger A’s story and Charlotte’s killer. We don’t have time for a whole lot of red herrings. Sara already has 2 episode titles directly related to her, “The Gloves are On” and “Do Not Disturb”. She’s a really important character and her story is not over.

Later, they even show us, that avenger A was in the hole messing with these torture switches at the end. We only know of 6 characters, that know about the Radley hole so far. The 4 liars, Alison, and Sara.



There is one more parallel, I want to briefly discuss. So we know Charlotte revealed to the liars that she used Sara as a decoy red coat when she needed her to be. Which means that Sara was the red coat in 6B who joined her in the surveillance room. The most interesting thing though, is that Sara was seen looking into the Marin’s house which directly parallels Charles looking into the Dilaurentis house.

Which leads me to question– why did Ashley Marin purchase the Radley? That is so odd to me! Out all the people and parents to become the owner of that place, it would be Ashley Marin. This sort of reminds me of how Alison’s mom placed herself on the board at Radley to keep close to her child.

Now I am starting to think the twin ghost children may not have been such a random incident. Think about it, the twin ghosts are only shown to the Marins. Now we see Sara looking outside their home as if she should be apart of their family.

Could the notorious ghost twin represent Sara after all? What does this all mean? I have yet to figure this part of the story out, but I won’t be shocked if Sara ends up having the twin. Maybe, Sara and CeCe weren’t so different after all. Long lost siblings?

Either way, I hope everyone is ready, because Sara Harvey isn’t done…not yet. When you lose someone you love, most of us tend to mourn their loss. Not Sara, she plans to get even and she has her eyes set on the Liars. But is Sara working alone or does she have a partner? If she does, my guess would be either Alison or Rollins.



In my next post, I’ll discuss who killed Charlotte and why.