Ali: I don’t like that she is saying that. That they stayed as Garnet, because Rose told them to. Sure Rose told them to never question it and all that stuff, but it’s not like she was controlling them or forcing them to do it. If they would ever decide that they don’t want to be Garnet anymore, or just that they don’t want to be her all the time, they were free to do that.

And beside that, they already formed Garnet in that forest before meeting Rose, because they wanted to. Hell, they probably already fallen in love at that point. And even after Rose died, they kept being Garnet. They separated on few occasions, but they always genuiely wanted to be back together. They were eager to do it. Maybe even if the didn’t meet Rose, they would still want to be Garnet all the time.

My point is, I don’t like how she seems to be concinved that it was all Rose doing and it had nothing to do with what they had on their own.

Like… I don’t know, imagine you meet a boy or a girl and you fall in love with them. You love them really a lot, you get married, you have kids. You all did that together, without anybody pushing you to do it. But then you find out that your parents and that person parents staged your first meeting and if not because of them, you would never meet. Does that in any way nullifies your real feelings for that person and all the shared experiences?