For years, Germany's foreign intelligence agency (BND) has invited a select number of journalists for background briefing sessions — but those previously exclusive meetings are now set to change.

Germany's Federal Administrative Court ruled on Wednesday that journalists are allowed to ask the BND about the off-the-record talks and that the agency must disclose the dates of the discussions, the reporters who were invited and the topics that were discussed.

The intelligence agency does not, however, have to delve into the specifics of the content discussed, but can rather name "general topics" that were raised.

The court ruled that the BND "did not sufficiently explain" what public interests would be violated by disclosing the information.

"Providing this information does not create or significantly increase the risk of drawing conclusions about the work and the methods of the BND," the court said in its decision.

The case was brought by Jost Müller-Neuhof, a legal policy correspondent with the Berlin-based Der Tagesspiegel, after the BND denied his request for the information in the spring of 2017.

Müller-Neuhof, who was not part of the BND's selected circle of journalists, said he had a right to the information under press law and criticized the BND's "selective distribution of information."

Read more: Germany's BND spy agency employed Heinrich Himmler's daughter

Inside Germany's new spy HQ In the heart of Berlin Decorated with steel palm trees, the new BND headquarters sits right where the Berlin Wall used to bisect the city. The move signals a major symbolic change for Germany, no longer shying away from taking a prominent role on the global stage.

Inside Germany's new spy HQ Palatial grounds The limestone and aluminum-fronted complex covers 10 hectares (25 acres) and cost €1.1 billion ($1.25 billion). It is one of the world's largest secret service bases.

Inside Germany's new spy HQ The thing A huge monolith called "The Thing" (Das Ding) adorns the central courtyard of the new headquarters. The work was created by the Düsseldorf-based artist Stefan Sous, whose massive sculptures can be found in public squares thoughout Germany.

Inside Germany's new spy HQ A glimpse inside There are plans to open a visitors center at the new BND headquarters. This marks a massive shift for a populace that has long been suspicious of intelligence agencies, with memories of the Gestapo and the Stasi still alive. "A healthy distrust is helpful, but being overly suspicious is a hindrance," Chancellor Angela Merkel said at the opening.

Inside Germany's new spy HQ Keeping tabs on time The clock in the situation room shows the time in New York, London, Berlin, Moscow and Beijing. The building itself, however, did not open on time. A series of delays, mishaps and cost overruns. The inauguration in February 2019 came more than 12 years after construction began.

Inside Germany's new spy HQ The situation room Around 4,000 of the BND's 6,500 secret service agents work in the huge new building. Merkel stressed that Germany "needs a strong and efficient foreign intelligence service more than ever." International terrorism, global organized crime structures, as well as cybersecurity and nuclear proliferation are among the challenges the BND is looking to target. Author: Elizabeth Schumacher, Rob Turner



Consequences for government agencies

The legal team representing the intelligence agency defended the meetings, saying that the BND wasn't revealing any secrets during the off-the-record talks, the taz newspaper reported.

The background meetings typically involved some 30 personally invited journalists who were not allowed to quote the agency afterward.

Diplomatic problems could arise, however, if a journalist were to list the BND as the source behind an assessment of certain developments abroad.

Müller-Neuhof argued that since the BND rarely holds public press conferences, the contents of its exclusive background discussions needed to be made more transparent.

"If the content isn't confidential, why should the circumstances of the meeting remain secret?" Remo Klinger, the lawyer representing the journalist, told the court last week.

Read more: Austria angry at Germany over 'enormous' spy effort

Watch video 04:26 Share Hacking for Germany Send Facebook google+ Whatsapp Tumblr linkedin stumble Digg reddit Newsvine Permalink https://p.dw.com/p/3GUrr Hacking for Germany

Journalists affected?

Wednesday's ruling had been watched closely by both journalists and government agencies, as it could have a massive effect on the way public agencies carry out their work with the press.

If the intelligence agency and other public bodies are required to give out information from their background talks with journalists, it could lead to briefings being stopped altogether, the BND's legal team argued.

That would effectively cut off a source of information for journalists looking for important analysis or information for them to further research.

Hendrik Zörner, the press spokesperson with the German Federation of Journalists (DJV), hailed Wednesday's decision as an "important step" for journalists, adding that ending the practice of off-the-record briefings is not necessarily a bad thing.

"The BND and other public agencies must take a more head-on and more transparent approach when it comes to providing information," he told DW.

Despite concerns about how public agencies will proceed, Müller-Neuhof told Die Zeit that he thinks it is unlikely they will do away with background briefings.

"The state will always have an interest in making its topics public," he told the paper.

Each evening at 1830 UTC, DW's editors send out a selection of the day's hard news and quality feature journalism. You can sign up to receive it directly here.