Odell Beckham Jr. was recently ranked as the No. 10 player in the league courtesy of his peers, Victor Cruz appears to be healthy after nearly two years away from football, Dwayne Harris proved his worth in his inaugural season with the team and Sterling Shepard was added via the NFL Draft. By all accounts, the New York Giants’ wide receivers should be cast among the very best in the NFL.

Pro Football Focus (PFF) disagrees. And as part of their ongoing series grading various positional units across the NFL, they’ve ranked the Giants near the bottom half of the league at No. 16 overall.

16. New York Giants Projected starters: WR Odell Beckham Jr., WR Sterling Shepard, WR Victor Cruz, TE Larry Donnell Key depth: WR Geremy Davis, WR Dwayne Harris, TE Matt LaCosse, TE Jerell Adams Key stat: In terms of yards per route run, Odell Beckham Jr. has ranked third among WRs in both of his first two pro seasons. The debacle against Josh Norman and the Carolina Panthers aside, Odell Beckham Jr. was even more impressive in his second season in the league than he was as a rookie, with 13 touchdowns, 13 missed tackles forced, and just four dropped passes. In fact, he has now dropped just six of the 193 catchable passes thrown his way since entering the league. The addition of Sterling Shepard (Oklahoma)—PFF’s highest-graded overall receiver in college a year ago—is a big help, and he can make an impact from the slot immediately in the NFL. Shepard’s 3.19 yards per route run from the slot were the third-most in the FBS a year ago, something that will help the Giants right away.

One glaring absence out of the gate is that of tight end Will Tye. Initially the team’s back-up, Tye took over for an injured Larry Donnell (neck) and eventually finished the season having hauled in 42 receptions for 464 yards and three touchdowns. All three of those touchdowns came over the final four weeks of the season.

Even with Donnell returning and both Matt LaCosse and Jerell Adams in the mix, Tye seems to have the inside track on the starting job heading into training camp.

Meanwhile, with high grades on both Beckham Jr. and Shepard, plus the return of Cruz, you’d think the Giants would be able to crack the Top 15 at the very least. In this instance, that’s not the case.

What do you say, Giants fans? Do you agree or disagree with PFF’s assessment?