Description

This article is from the Puzzles FAQ, by Chris Cole chris@questrel.questrel.com and Matthew Daly mwdaly@pobox.com with numerous contributions by others.

51 arithmetic/clock/thirds.p



Do the 3 hands on a clock ever divide the face of the clock into 3

equal segments, i.e. 120 degrees between each hand?



arithmetic/clock/thirds.s



First let us assume that our clock has 60 divisions. We will show that

any time the hour hand and the minute hand are 20 divisions (120 degrees)

apart, the second hand cannot be an integral number of divisions from the

other hands, unless it is straight up (on the minute).



Let us use h for hours, m for minutes, and s for seconds.

We will use =n to mean congruent mod n, thus 12 =5 7.



We know that m =60 12h, that is, the minute hand moves 12 times as fast

as the hour hand, and wraps around at 60.

We also have s =60 60m. This simplifies to s/60 =1 m, which goes to

s/60 = frac(m) (assuming s is in the range 0 <= s < 60), which goes to

s = 60 frac(m). Thus, if m is 5.5, s is 30.



Now let us assume the minute hand is 20 divisions ahead of the hour hand.

So m =60 h + 20, thus 12h =60 h + 20, 11h =60 20, and, finally,

h =60/11 20/11 (read 'h is congruent mod 60/11 to 20/11').

So all values of m are k + n/11 for some integral k and integral n,

0 <= n < 11. s is therefore 60n/11. If s is to be an integral number of

units from m and h, we must have 60n =11 n. But 60 and 11 are relatively

prime, so this holds only for n = 0. But if n = 0, m is integral, so

s is 0.



Now assume, instead, that the minute hand is 20 divisions behind the hour hand.

So m =60 h - 20, 12h =60 h - 20, 11h =60 -20, h =60/11 -20/11.

So m is still k + n/11. Thus s must be 0.



But if s is 0, h must be 20 or 40. But this translates to 4 o'clock or

8 o'clock, at both of which the minute hand is at 0, along with the second

hand.



Thus the 3 hands can never be 120 degrees apart, Q.E.D.



This assumes, of course, that the second hand is synchronized with the

minute hand. This is not true on some inexpensive analog watches. This

also assumes that the watch is not broken (:^)).







Continue to:







