Alright, I didn’t actually win the internet. Several people told me I did, so I looked into it, and there’s no such contest. No prize to claim, no oversized check, not even a Starbucks gift card. But I did manage to strike a chord with a certain corner of the internet, at least, even if I still have to buy my own coffee.

We’ve Always Been at War With Eastasia

If you’re not Mormon, you might have noticed a news story last week explaining why the LDS Church released pictures of an egg-shaped rock. If you did notice, you probably shrugged.

If you are Mormon, you noticed. And your Facebook feed blew up. And you either freaked out or you didn’t. But you probably didn’t.

Joseph Smith’s relationship with folk magic isn’t exactly new information, but now that the Church has made it Facebook official, a lot of Mormons are having to deal with it for the first time. The fallout has sparked an Orwellian struggle between Mormons who didn’t know about the seer stone and Mormons who did. Collectively, we’re trying to exchange one set of facts we always knew for a new set, which, of course, we always knew.

Some Mormons assumed the new photographs were anti-Mormon lies, as this response to BuzzFeed’s coverage shows. (This exchange is not fake, unlike the one I made. But it is abridged, because some people are really mean and their comments were in the way.)

I’m not sure what other powers the seer stone has, but so far it seems to have neutralized our ability to show compassion. In discussions across the internet, those who were surprised by the disclosure find themselves being blamed, rather than supported: If you didn’t know Joseph Smith dictated the Book of Mormon with a stone (and his face) in a hat, you’ve only got yourself to blame. The information was out there — it isn’t the Church’s fault you got the wrong idea.

Malarkey!

Yes, some Mormons curse like 90-year-old Brits, and I call malarkey on anyone who wants to blame faithful Mormons for not knowing the way the Book of Mormon was actually written.

At the 18:44 mark of this official Church video, we see the translation method we’ve been taught — one completely unsupported by the historical record.

Sure, there are a handful of official documents that mentioned the face-in-the-hat technique, but these are isolated needles buried within haystacks that have been carefully arranged by Church gatekeepers.

Needle: 150 words from a 38-year-old article in an official Church magazine.

Haystack: 150 years of sermons, art, film production, and culture that celebrate a striking, blue-eyed demigod reading from gold plates the way a third-grader reads Harry Potter. (Which is to say, not with a rock in a hat.)

Plot twist: You don’t even know there is a needle to look for until someone blames you for not finding it.

The Way the Internet Was Won

Of course, most Mormons, whether they knew about the seer stone or not, didn’t freak out last week. As ever, all is well in Zion, and we’re on board with whatever the Church is saying. What is there to talk about?

The catalyst.

Those of us who think there is something to talk about have seen a lot of confusion, betrayal, and, sometimes, humor. When a Facebook friend posted a “play in one act” in which key Mormon characters realize their efforts to deliver the golden plates were trumped by a stone, it made me wonder: What if key personalities were on Facebook, reacting to the seer stone announcement along with the rest of us? A few minutes later, I uploaded an imagined conversation that would make a lot of people laugh and win me my very first internet.