A Vanderbilt University brain-mapping study has found that people’s ability to make decisions in novel situations decreases with age and is associated with a reduction in the integrity of two specific white-matter pathways.

The pathways connect an area in the cerebral cortex called the medial prefrontal cortex (involved with decision making) with two other areas deeper in the brain: the thalamus (a highly connected relay center in the brain) and ventral striatum (associated with the emotional and motivational aspects of behavior).

Gray vs. white matter

Gray matter is the part of the brain that contains neurons while white matter contains the cable-like axons that carry signals from one part of the brain to another. Most brain-imaging research has concentrated on the gray matter.

Recently, however, neuroscientists have begun looking more closely at white matter. It has been linked to the brain’s processing speed and attention span, among other things, but this is the first study to link white matter to learning and decision making.

“The evidence that this decline in decision-making is associated with white-matter integrity suggests that there may be effective ways to intervene,” said Gregory R. Samanez-Larkin, post-doctoral fellow in Vanderbilt’s psychology department and Institute of Imaging Science, who is the study’s first author. “Several studies have shown that white-matter connections can be strengthened by specific forms of cognitive training.”

Study details

The study involved 25 adults ranging from 21 to 85 years of age. They were asked to perform a monetary learning task. The task was designed to elicit what psychologists call probabilistic reward learning. “This is a common type of decision making that we use every day,” said Samanez-Larkin. “Whenever we try to choose the best alternative based on previous experience and are uncertain of the outcome, we are relying on probabilistic reward learning.”

On the same day, the participant’s brains were scanned using a relatively new MRI technique called diffusion tensor imaging (DTI). In the last 20 years, most brain imaging research has been done with fMRI, an imaging method that measures variations in the oxygen consumption in different areas of the grey matter, which correspond to variations in neuron activity levels. By contrast, DTI detects the water trapped by the myelin sheaths that surround the axons in white-matter regions and produces a signal related to the density, diameter and amount of myelination of the axons (a combination the researchers call ‘integrity’).

“The protocols for DTI have improved substantially,” said Samanez-Larkin, “In future studies we’d really like to combine fMRI and DTI to better characterize age differences in these neural circuits and examine how training might improve both structure and function.”

Samanez-Larkin performed this research while he was a graduate student at Stanford University. His co-authors are Brian Knutson, Robert Dougherty and Michael Perry from Stanford and Sara Levens from Carnegie Mellon University.

Ref.: Gregory R. Samanez-Larkin, Frontostriatal White Matter Integrity Mediates Adult Age Differences in Probabilistic Reward Learning, The Journal of Neuroscience, 2012; [DOI:10.1523/​JNEUROSCI.5756-11.2012]