So everyone knows that in the Pretty Little Liars books Alison has an evil twin but that the show is not going that route. Its confirmed now that someone will have a twin sister but it won’t be Ali. Now if someone in that town had a twin that no one knew about I would assume that she was locked up in Radley at a young age. Don’t forget in an episode the writers made a point to show us the childrens ward in Radley, With the story of the twin stabbing the other twin it makes since that if that happened the parents would send her to a mental intuition, right? Right ;) Going with the twin in Radley theory I would assume that the “fragile patient” who saw Tobys mom die would be this twin. It never made sense to me that the evil twin who stabbed her sister and got sent to Radley would be described as fragile. I’m not certain that the person who has the twin is necessarily A either. If you look at the twin girls in the Halloween episodes you notice they both have different beauty marks on there face. One has 2 beauty marks on her cheek most similar with the Pretty Little Liar Spencer. No one I’ve noticed has the mole like the other twin so that would make me believe that she is the twin that hasn’t been revealed yet. She would be the one in Radley that we didn’t know and Spencer would be the one that got stabbed. Now whats confusing is that in the next Halloween episode the twin that did the stabbing is the one showing up as a ghost to Hannas mom all timid stating that her “sister” is always telling lies about her and she is worried she told there mom something bad about her. People have made the assumption that the story was told wrong and that the other twin, resembling Spencer, was the evil one and killed the other twin. The only way to make the twin reveal surprising and good is to make it the twin of a character we know so the twin shouldn’t be dead. I think Hannas mom remembers/knew the twin girls before the stabbing incident and assumed the one that got sent to Radley died. She recalls a time when the twin who supposedly did the stabbing came to her house and mentioned how she is worried her sister told her mother something bad about her and that she is always telling lies about her and getting her in trouble. So are we to believe that Spencer is the bad sister telling lies about her then? I can see Spencer having a twin but I can’t see her being this ultimate evil crazy person. Confusing right? So to understand my theory fully you should read my reblog of another persons findings of the movie Alice Sweet Alice and its amazing similarities to Pretty Little Liars. There are 2 sisters in the film an older sister named Alice and a younger sister named Karen. Alice is the crazy one and is jealous of Karen. Alice uses Karens porcelain doll to torment her by luring her into a room with it and locking her in it. She threatens her not to tell her parents or she will never see the doll again. Alice eventually kills Karen. She then goes around wearing a plastic mask of her similar to the ones throughout Pretty little Liars of Alison and a yellow hooded jacket killing other people. Now here’s another connection for you. The twins name that visits Hannas mom in Pretty Little Liars is Alice. Coincidence? I think not. Alice sweet Alice film reference. Then you have them acting out the play The Bad Seed which is basically about a extremely jealous little girl who wants what everyone else has and kills people for petty things like a medal that was won from a classmate that she wanted to win. With these two film references in mind my theory is that Spencer has a twin and she was stabbed by her sister, but not her twin sister, her older sister Melissa. Melissa, much like Alice, was jealous of her little sisters, or at least Spencers twin sister. Melissa is the sister that the other twin who Hannas mom remembers spoke about always telling lies about her. We all assume when she says sister that she means the twin but if she is a Hasting then she has more then one sister. I think Melissa wanting to get rid of her younger sisters decides to stab Spencer and blame it on the one who talked with Hannas mom. The twin goes home thinking that Melissa just told there parents that she ran away and really she has stabbed her sister and blamed it on her and gets sent to Radley. Spencer doesn’t die like intended by Melissa but the other is locked up in Radley. With the way Spencers parents talk about not handling imperfections in there family well it wouldn’t be wrong to assume that if they thought they had a crazy daughter they would turn there back on her and try to cover up the unflattering truth. Alisons mom would know of the twin because she is on the board at Radley. This could be what she means when she tells Ali that you never turn your back on a Hastings and she knows what there family is capable of. Spencer having a near death experience and being so young may not remember having a twin sister. There have been times when Spencer talks about remembering something Melissa and her did as children that Melissa doesn’t remember doing. It could be because Spencer is remembering something her and her twin did. If my Melissa is Uber A and Spencer is the one who has a fragile twin locked up in Radley theory is correct, then I can explain everything else that we have learned what happened that night. All the inconsistencies suddenly make sense when you are looking at 3 sisters, maybe even 4 if you count that Ali is there half sister, with the older sister being extremely jealous of everything they have. My next blog will explain the rest of the show and how it all connects to these sisters. Its going to be good.