A plan to build an underground suburban rail loop linking every major line in Melbourne has inspired the city’s cartographers to try to map the proposed network.

On Tuesday, we showed you three maps and asked you to vote on your favourite.

It was a close race, but spatial analyst and self-confessed “map geek” Adam Mattinson came in first with 3050 votes for his circular geographic map, inspired by the Moscow Metro Map.

Coming in second was Age designer Jamie Brown with 2751 votes for his map based on the current Metro one, but adding in the proposed new loop.