Here’s a casting mystery: John Noble is set to reprise his Good Wife role as Alicia’s murdered client.

RELATED | Good Wife Season 5 Casts Talia Balsam as Political Reporter

As first reported by TVGuide.com, the Fringe vet will return for a Season 5 episode as Matthew Ashbaugh, who appeared in flashbacks last season.

Seeing as how Matthew is still very dead, might Alicia’s memories of her time with the eccentric, litigious man shed light on a new story?

The Good Wife premieres Sunday, Sept. 29 at 9/8c.

Good Wife fans, hit the comments with your theories on Noble’s reappearance!