How can I give a C++ lambda expression more than one operator() ?

Raymond

November 7th, 2019

Suppose you have stored a C++ lambda expression into a variable, and you want to call it in different ways. This seems impossible, because when you define the lambda expression, you can provide only one operator() :

auto lambda = [captures](int v) { return v + 2; };

This lambda has only one way of calling it: You pass an integer and it returns an integer.

But it turns out that you can create a lambda that can be called in multiple ways: Use an auto parameter!

auto lambda = [](auto p) { if constexpr (std::is_same_v<decltype(p), int>) { return p + 1; } else { return "oops"; } }; auto result1 = lambda(123); // result1 is 124 auto result2 = lambda('x'); // result2 is "oops"

By declaring the parameter as auto , the lambda accepts any single parameter. We then use if constexpr and std::is_same_v to see what type was actually passed, and implement the desired function body for each type.

Notice that the different branches of the if don’t need to agree on the return type. In our example, passing an integer adds one and produces another integer. But passing anything else returns the string "oops" !

You can create a bunch of tag types to make it look almost as if your lambda had member functions.

struct add_tax_t {}; constexpr add_tax_t add_tax; struct apply_discount_t {}; constexpr apply_discount_t apply_discount; auto lambda = [total](auto op, auto value) mutable { using Op = decltype(op); if constexpr (std::is_same_v<Op, add_tax_t>) { total += total * value; // value is the tax rate return total; } else if constexpr (std::is_same_v<Op, apply_discount_t>) { total -= std::max(value, total); // value is the discount return total; } else { static_assert(!sizeof(Op*), "Don't know what you are asking me to do."); } }; lambda(apply_discount, 5.00); // apply $5 discount lambda(add_tax, 0.10); // add 10% tax

So far, all of our “methods” have the same number of parameters, but you can use a parameter pack to permit different numbers of parameters:

auto lambda = [total](auto op, auto... args) mutable { using Op = decltype(op); using ArgsT = std::tuple<decltype(args)...>; if constexpr (std::is_same_v<Op, add_tax_t>) { auto [tax_rate] = ArgsT(args...); total += total * tax_rate; return total; } else if constexpr (std::is_same_v<Op, apply_discount_t>) { auto [amount, expiration] = ArgsT(args...); if (expiration < now()) { total -= std::max(amount, total); } return total; } else { static_assert(!sizeof(Op*), "Don't know what you are asking me to do."); } };

In this case, the add_ tax “method” takes a single parameter, whereas the apply_ discount “method” takes two.

You could even dispatch based solely on the types and arity.

auto lambda = [total](auto... args) mutable { using ArgsT = std::tuple<decltype(args)...>; if constexpr (std::is_same_v<ArgsT, std::tuple<int, int>>) { // two integers = add to total auto [a, b] = ArgsT(args...); total += a + b; } else if constexpr (std::is_same_v<ArgsT, std::tuple<>>) { // no parameters = print print(total); } else { static_assert(!sizeof(Op*), "Don't know what you are asking me to do."); } };

This might come in handy if you have a lambda that is used to accumulate something: You can pass the lambda to the function that expects to do the accumulating, and then call the lambda using a secret knock to extract the answer.

auto lambda = [limit, total = 0](auto value) mutable { using T = decltype(value); if constexpr (std::is_same_v<T, const char*>) { // secret knock: Return total if invoked with const char* return total; } else { // Otherwise, just add them up until we hit the limit. total += value; return total <= limit; } }; auto unused = std::find_if_not(begin, end, std::ref(lambda)); if (unused != end) print("Limit exceeded."); auto total = lambda("total"); // extract the total

This is basically a complete and utter abuse of the language, and I hope you’re ashamed of yourself.

Bonus chatter: All of this is just a way of defining a struct without having to say the word struct .

struct { double limit; double total = 0.00; auto add_tax(auto tax_rate) { total += total * tax_rate; } auto apply_discount(auto amount) { total -= std::max(amount, total); } auto get_total() const { return total; } } lambda{1000.00 /* limit */};

Bonus bonus chatter: Java anonymous classes provide a more straightforward syntax:

var lambda = new Object() { int total = 0; public void add(int value) { total += value; } public int get_total() { return total; } }; lambda.add(2); lambda.add(3); var result = lambda.get_total();