I'm doing an epic thread on the FACTS on the #MedeVacBill to bust all the myths being spread by the #Morrison Government. RT's are so appreciated. Here we go. #auspol #manus #nauru #morrison #dutton

MYTH 1: Two doctors will decide if someone is transferred



FACT 1: Actually 11 doctors decide this incl. an Independent Medical Panel that makes final medical recommendation made up of 9 doctors that incl. Surgeon General of Border Force, Home Affairs & C/w Chief Medical Officer

MYTH 2: The #MedeVacBill will encourage people to seeking #asylum by boat



FACT 2: The bill only applies to people seeking asylum on Manus & Nauru as of 13th Feb 2019 (& children born to them), anyone who arrives thereafter is not eligible for medical evacuation under this bill.

MYTH 3: #MedeVacBill is not needed because there are 60 doctors already on Nauru



FACT 3: Yes 60 health professionals, but they're fly in-fly out. Therefore there’s only about 1/2 @ any one time. Also rostered on in 3 shifts a day, so only a maximum of 8-10 doctors per shift.

MYTH 4: #MedeVacBill allows convicted sex offenders into Australia



FACT 4: Firstly, we know of none on #Manus and #Nauru. Secondly, bill has a Character Test taken from S.501(7) of Migration Act that bans anyone convicted of criminal offences totallying 12 months imprisonment.

MYTH 5: The #MedeVacBill wasn't needed because adequate care exists



FACT 5: 12 people have died.

No mental health services on Manus

Our data shows 100s without medical care

Our data shows people waiting up to 5 years for medical transfer

MYTH 6: The #MedeVacBill allows people charged with serious criminal offences to be in Australian community



FACT 6: If someone brought to Oz had been charged with serious crime would be held in detention while being treated under sole discretion & control of Minister. No risk.

MYTH 7: The #MedeVacBill will result in more people being placed in detention.



FACT 7: It is a standing 5 year practice of Abbott/Turnbull/Morrison Gov that all people medically transferred here (almost 900 so far) are all placed into detention, so this is just the status quo.

MYTH 8: Control of our borders has been lost by the Minister & given to doctors



FACT 8: Minister still in control. Can refuse transfer if



- suspects would be prejudicial to security (ASIO Act) or

- knows has substantial criminal record and

- can indefinitely detain while in Oz

MYTH 9: The #MedeVacBill has destroyed border protection regime



FACT 9: The bill does just one thing, make clinicians more central to decisions about duty of care than currently are and provide a pathway in law for sick people to be evacuated for medical care, that is it.

MYTH 10: Medically transferring sick people to Australia will encourage people to seek asylum by sea



FACT 10: LNP Gov has already transferred nearly 900 sick people from Manus & Nauru to Australia for medical care and this has had no material impact on sea arrivals. #MedeVacBill

MYTH 11: Xmas Island had to be re - opened because of #MedeVacBill



FACT 11: Gov doesn't need to, people can be held in community detention (residential) as they have done with 900 people they have transferred & keep in detention just anyone with pending charges, if there are any

MYTH 12: Doctors will sign off on medical transfer of people even if not sick.



FACT 12: Doctors act ethically, have a code of conduct they are bound to follow. Also worth noting every medical transfer that has gone to court, the courts have sided with the doctors every time.

MYTH 13: #MedeVacBill unnecessarily allows medical transfer just on basis of need for “medical assessment.”



FACT 13: “assessment” a ground because the medical facilities are so poor offshore that vital tests for health issues like risk of blindness & heart problems not possible.

MYTH 14: Medical transfers were already happening when needed by Gov so #MedeVacBill not needed.



FACT: Last year approx 80% of sick kids that were evacuated were only after legal action was taken or court ordered it. Gov consistently ignored recommendations of contracted IHMS.

The following newspapers have done excellent pieces busting the myths too on #MedeVacBill



@GuardianAus



https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/feb/13/nine-facts-about-the-medical-evacuation-bill?CMP=share_btn_tw …



https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/audio/2019/feb/14/nauru-manus-and-why-we-need-the-medevac-bill-australian-politics-live-podcast …



and



@smh



https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/cutting-through-the-claims-the-refugee-medical-debate-explained-20190214-p50xpd.html …



and



@SBSNews



https://www.sbs.com.au/news/how-will-the-medevac-bill-actually-affect-ill-asylum-seekers …

You can follow @Kon__K.

Share this thread

Bookmark

____

Tip: mention @threader_app on a Twitter thread with the keyword “compile” to get a link to it.



Enjoy Threader? Sign up.



Since you’re here...



... we’re asking visitors like you to make a contribution to support this independent project. In these uncertain times, access to information is vital. Threader gets 1,000,000+ visits a month and our iOS Twitter client was featured as an App of the Day by Apple. Your financial support will help two developers to keep working on this app. Everyone’s contribution, big or small, is so valuable. Support Threader by becoming premium or by donating on PayPal. Thank you.



Download Threader on iOS.