The argument of the right is wrong because a cheap, disposable and compliant labour force only brings insecurity, resentment and a breadline existence. It’s the opposite of the confident, proud and secure communities we should be building. While the argument of the left allows a bizarre 'diversity dogma’ to trump all other reasoning. There’s no reason why we shouldn’t be training up more doctors and nurses here for starters. And why are we constantly recruiting nurses from developing countries where they are struggling to provide basic care? What’s progressive about that? The next time you’re sat before a Malawian doctor in Manchester remember that there is just one doctor for every 40,000 people in Malawi and that 110 children in every 1,000 born there will die before the age of five.