Robb Topolski, the man who helped unearth Comcast's P2P interference, wants Comcast customers to opt out of the $16 they have coming to them from a class action lawsuit. But Eric Somers, the lawyer leading the class-action case, just can't understand the sentiment.

"This is a good settlement," he told Ars. "If you opt out, you're basically giving that money to Comcast."

At issue is the settlement of the Hart v. Comcast class action, a resolution three years in the making. When John Hart noticed that his BitTorrent connections would "hang"—sometimes for an entire night—he called up Somers and asked if he knew anything about it. Comcast was still denying that P2P upload blocks were in place on its network, and it took the legal team time to figure out what was happening.

Hart's case was the first one filed, and his lawyers were eventually certified as counsel for the entire class of affected Comcast users. Since 2008, Somers and his team have argued that Comcast violated the FCC's Internet Policy Statement (PDF); the FCC famously agreed. Comcast agreed to settle the class action suit rather than proceed to trial.

The deal puts Comcast on the hook for $16 million, plus up to $3 million extra for the lawyers. That $16 million will be split up between every Comcast subscriber who was affected, with a cap of $16 per person—but no one gets any money unless they sign onto the class at the official settlement website. Any unclaimed money goes right back into Comcast's coffers.

Best possible result?



Somers believes this is the best deal he could get—and better than anyone is going to get in the future. As the judge noted, the damages here aren't easily quantifiable, and Comcast argued that people were barely affected; they could still do e-mail, browse the Web, even download on BitTorrent. Where was the real harm?

As for putting that $16 million pot to better use, say by funding some bigger public project, Somers said he'd love to do that—but courts frown on class-action awards going anywhere but to those actually harmed.

Sixteen dollars isn't enough to do much more than buy a bottle of decent wine, but Somers says that those who want the small individual payouts to do more common good should donate them somewhere like the Electronic Frontier Foundation. "That would be fantastic," he said.

Besides, he argues, if you're concerned about the settlement, look at what just happened in DC. There, the Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit recently tossed out the FCC's entire authority over "network management" and invalidated the agency's Comcast order. If the case went to trial, the ruling "makes it more difficult to win the case, absolutely."

What about the common complaint about class actions, that they disburse tiny amounts of money to victims but concentrate large sums on a single law firm? "There was an enormous amount of work" on this case, Somers said, pointing out that his firm has fronted the money on this case since the beginning and that it fought to keep its own award from coming out of the general class settlement fund.

After creating the $16 million pot of cash, Somers now wants to see people claim it: "I don't think anyone's going to do any better than that."