Last season, How I Met Your Mother planted yet another whacky story seed when Ted walked into McLaren’s wearing a green dress and exclaimed, “Now we’re even!” Well, the mystery surrounding his unusual attire will be revisited in the April 16 episode, aptly titled “Now We’re Even,” which also finds Barney trying to entice Ted into going out every single night.

Meanwhile, Lily has a naughty dream, and it’s not about — gasp! — Marshall.

Check out the first look gallery below and then hit the comments with your thoughts.