An investment banker deep-sea fishing in the Bahamas two weeks ago hooked a 12-foot-long tiger shark. As he pulled the beast onto his boat, a human leg popped out of its mouth.

Using DNA tests, Bahamian officials have determined that the leg – and other body parts still inside the shark – belonged to a missing sailor.

Judson Newton, 43, went missing on August 29. He and some friends were fishing off Jaws Beach, so-called because one of the movie’s sequels was filmed there.

The engine of the boat failed. Three of the people on board decided to wait for help, but Newton and another man tried to swim to shore. Neither man was seen again. Authorities surmised they had both drowned.

One of Newton’s friends, Samuel Woodside, told AP that he doubted that outcome.

“To me, he was always a strong swimmer. I don’t know what happened,” Woodside said.

It’s not clear if Newton was already dead when the shark consumed him. But much of his body was found inside the animal - including his other leg, both arms and his torso.

With files from The Associated Press