A couple days ago Peyton Manning and Magic Johnson played an epic game of Egg Russian Roulette on The Tonight Show. The two sports legends were so into the game. They were smashing the eggs with tons of gusto — raw egg flew everywhere and Magic couldn’t stop laughing.

NBA on TNT tried to replicate that game with Shaquille O’Neal and Kenny Smith on Friday night after the Rising Stars Game. It didn’t go as planned.

Shaq and Kenny don’t smash the eggs on their heads. They lightly tap them. It’s not as fun as Peyton vs. Magic, but it’s still funny because Shaq and Kenny are absolutely terrified of the eggs. And the orange poncho on Shaq is amazing because it barely fits him.

When Shaq finally gets a raw egg, it oozes all over him (though nowhere near as badly as when Peyton played) and he gets annoyed and flings it everywhere — onto Kenny, onto Ernie Johnson’s suit … AND INTO THE CROWD. Shaq really tossed potentially raw eggs into the crowd watching them.

It was such a nice thing of Shaq to do — share those eggs with the fans — that I don’t think that NBA on TNT will play this game ever again. But I am definitely going to bring this game out at a party.