(WARNING: SPOILERS)

Why would you put a baby in a tiny boat? Isn’t that unsafe? Wouldn’t he be more likely to survive if you brought him back to Poland or wherever?

The baby’s mother says “You don’t understand, we can’t bring him back.” What don’t we understand? Why can’t they bring him back?

bring him back.” What don’t we understand? Why can’t they bring him back? How did that baby survive?

Why was there a tiny boat in the Ellis Island office?

Why did the flying horse ghost its way through an iron gate when it can fly?

Why does Pearly have to stop Peter from using his miracle? What happens if he does?

Why did Peter’s friend recognize the horse? Is he an angel? Or a demon?

Why did Pearly kill the waiter? For fun?

What caused the fugue state that led Pearly to draw the back of the girl’s head? Why could he not have drawn her face?

Why is the horse repeatedly referred to as a dog in disguise, and yet we never see the dog?

Why does Beverly tell the doctor she’s not contagious? Isn’t consumption contagious?

Why does consumption cause Beverly to melt ice? Is that scientifically accurate?

Why does Beverly believe she can see greater truths because she has an illness? Is this an alternate universe where the illness does something else?

Why would the father decide to go “down with the ship” when the house explodes, when he can easily get out in time, and has two daughters to raise?

Does Christmas not exist in this world?

Why does Pearly insist that they ensure Peter Lake is “actually” dead, then he throws him off a bridge into the river without checking to make sure he’s dead?

Why does amnesic Peter know to write “Peter Lake?” on the mirror? Why would he write that on the mirror?

How does amnesic Peter have an apartment? How does he have only two sets of clothes, one of which is from 1914 and looks the same? Why is the other outfit a hipster outfit? Why does he have a hipster haircut? Why doesn’t he have a full beard and back length hair, if he hasn’t shaved or had a haircut since 1914?

Why is Willa 107 years old and still running a newspaper?

Why do Willa and Peter look out the window when Willa is talking about Beverly becoming a star in the night sky, when it is around 2:30 in the afternoon?

Why does Willa tell Virginia knowingly that she likes pecans?

When Pearly tells his men to “get off the ice,” why do they run back ONTO the ice?

What is the miniature boat placard made of that it can slice Pearly’s neck multiple times without bending or breaking?

What are the points of miracles if no one’s life matters more than any other person’s?

What is the point of saving this child from cancer when many more will die of cancer?

Please add your own in the comments.