The witcher 3 by far. Skyrim was my first open world rpg. The genre had never really interested me before. The closest game would have been GTA but thats not really an rpg. I loved skyrim and was hooked. It took me 80 hours to do all quests which is a lot of time for me to stick with one game.



Witcher 3 took me 110 hours and i wanted to start over again as soon as i finished. To this day i still have never played skyrim a second time. Maybe when the remaster releases. My second playthrough of witcher 3 took 160 hours with both expansions. I'll definitely be going through it again at some point and much slower to make sure i do stuff i missed!



Everything in witcher 3 is just done way better. Quests, characters, story, gameplay, combat, map size/detail.