The Mother of All Theories Part 2

Here we are again, another theory, another finale, and another lightbulb going off in every direction. I thought I had some parts of the story correct before, and I did- but now everything falls into place so perfectly, there’s no other way the story can go.

Jessica is the one with the twin, definitively. For theory purposes I’m going to name the twin Jennifer, just so you know exactly who I’m talking about throughout the theory.

Something that always bewildered me was the twin story, there are multiple things throughout the twin story that I didn’t understand… For example, the fact that the setting of the twin story looked like it took place in the 60’s, if the twins were in fact one of the liars- or even one of the older siblings, there’s no way any of them would be born even CLOSE to the 60’s. Another thing that didn’t make sense to me was the fact that absolutely no one matched the story, if it had been Charlotte who was supposed to be represented in the twin story- Charlotte would have deliberately hurt Alison in a malicious way, which she didn’t. From the twin story we know that the twins were playing with the dolls when all of a sudden they both began to fight over the same doll, one of the twins then got up and stabbed the other- one twin was sent away and the other twin was never said to be dead or alive.

Both twins survived, Jessica was the twin that got stabbed. Why do I think this? Jessica has a very specific sense of style, one that is very conservative… She is always wearing a button up blouse, a sweater, a jacket, and/or a suit. A wardrobe that could very easily hide, I don’t know… A stab wound on her chest? Another reason I think Jessica was the twin that was stabbed is all of the medications she was on, we know for a fact that she had a prescription for a very heavy sleep aid, one that Alison used to drug the girls the night of Labor Day. We also know she had blood pressure medication, with the sleeping pills and high blood pressure medication we can assume something very traumatic happened to her to cause sleepless nights and high stress levels.

Another thing that had never been brought up again was the haunted house in the first secret, I believe it was Emily who said she felt like something bad had happened there… From the look of the house, it had been abandoned for a very long time, and the only bad thing we known to have happened a long time ago WAS the twin story.

Now, to get to the BIG secrets… Jennifer is the mother of Bethany Young, AND Peter Hastings is the father. We know from the twin story that whatever one twin had, the other wanted, I think it’s safe to assume that since Jessica was dating Peter, Jennifer wanted him too- and most likely pretended to be Jessica to sleep with him and therefore got pregnant with Bethany. THAT is one of the huge reasons there is so much tension between the Hastings and DiLaurentis families, whether Peter knows about Bethany being his child I think is pretty likely, this could be the reason Jennifer is going after Melissa- because she knows she killed Bethany.

This is how everything started. Bethany was most likely thrown in Radley because of either one of the Hastings or DiLaurentis family members, probably Jessica or Peter, this is how the hatred for her sister grew into rage.

It is quite possible that Jennifer was the one who was taking Bethany out to the horse stables- since she looked like Jessica (who was on the board of Radley) she could see her daughter and take her out whenever she wanted… This could ALSO be why Bethany threw a fit when Jennifer asked her to call her “Aunt Jess” instead of calling her “mom”, if anyone asked about seeing a patient out of Radley, they would say that it was Jessica. It would also explain the sudden hatred towards Jessica, Jennifer could’ve told Bethany that Jessica was dating Peter and taking her away from them, hence the drawings of Jessica as a devil taking Peter away from them.

Bethany had always been Uber A’s motivation, everyone involved with her death is now either dead or being tortured or blackmailed for it, but another motivation is her pure hatred and envy of her twin. If she couldn’t have them, no one could.Melissa buried Bethany alive, Mona hit her, Charlotte defaced Bethany’s grave, Jessica and Wilden covered the murder up, she hates Alison because Bethany was taken away from her- she hates all of the DiLaurentis children because Bethany was taken away from her.

Jennifer has Melissa’s taped confession admitting to burying Bethany alive and unless Melissa finds Charlotte’s “killer” by election day, she’s going to release the confession everywhere and destroy the entire Hasting’s family. Melissa is trying desperately to find out who the killer is, when she doesn’t realize the killer is the one blackmailing her in the first place- she’s torturing the liars to the point of having one of them admit to it. That will take care of Charlotte’s murder, Jennifer will get away with it once Melissa finds someone to take the fall.

Now, getting to poor Alison- Jennifer is dressing up as Jessica to drive Alison insane, only the person who knew what Jessica was wearing when she died (or in this case who buried her in the first place) could dress up like her. Also, in the scene where “Jessica” comes in to see Alison- “Jessica” is wearing the same outfit as in episode 4x14:

Jennifer is trying to make Alison go insane and to end up in a mental institution like Bethany was. This also brings up the fact that Jennifer and Rollins are working together, why of all things would “Jessica” come to visit Alison just to tell her that Rollins is a nice guy? It’s to give Alison piece of mind to trust Rollins, and it’s most likely to set up for Rollins admitting Alison into a mental institution. It’s also quite possible he’s drugging her at the same time. No one but Rollins, Alison, and the girls knew Alison was there.

It could be quite possible that Rollins and Jennifer are… Involved *cough* or he could possibly be an older son, I wouldn’t cross either of those possibilities off.

So, there we go. Another mystery solved. Happy PLL Day, Everyone!!