Author Message

Blurf

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 2 Sep 06

Posts: 8940

Credit: 12,678,685

RAC: 0

Message 1698251 - Posted: 3 Jul 2015, 19:53:01 UTC



BOINC's funding from the U.S. National Science Foundation has ended,

at least for the time being.

This funding supported me, Rom Walton, and Charlie Fenton.

We're now working on other things,

although we'll stay involved in BOINC at some level.



The BOINC project will continue, and will be run according to

a community-based model rather than centrally.

In essence, the people who contribute to BOINC now make the decisions about it.

This model is summarized here:

http://boinc.berkeley.edu/trac/wiki/ProjectGovernance

and described in detail here:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1C6pU5RqidYBxk9oyAevm1yH1tn4Hw27oM8YpvsnR-gg



There will probably be little visible change.

The BOINC software will continue to work.

The translation system, Alpha testing project, BOINC web site,

message boards, and email lists will continue to operate.

However, any new development and major bug fixes to BOINC

will need to be done by volunteer programmers.

I'm confident that the BOINC community will meet the challenge.



I welcome your feedback.

Please post it to boinc_admin@googlegroups.com,

a new email list for discussions about the BOINC project as a whole.



-- David



Was posted on Bitcoin Utopia: ID: 1698251 ·

Jord

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 9 Jun 99

Posts: 15176

Credit: 4,362,181

RAC: 3

Message 1698259 - Posted: 3 Jul 2015, 20:27:05 UTC Hallelujah, the cat is finally out of the bag. I've known about this since April and it has been very difficult for me to answer some posts on the various forums in which people asked for bug fixes or enhancements/additional add-ons. Most of the time I went and ignored them, because I wasn't allowed to breathe anything about this pending doom. :-/ ID: 1698259 ·

HAL9000

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 11 Sep 99

Posts: 6533

Credit: 196,805,888

RAC: 57

Message 1698294 - Posted: 3 Jul 2015, 22:02:22 UTC



Having community driven development structure has been shown to work pretty well in several software development projects. I imagine it may time some time for others to become failure with the server side of BOINC. Given that, other than the BOINC devs, only project admins & the curious would have bothered to look under the hood. SETI@home classic workunits: 93,865 CPU time: 863,447 hours

Join the While the news on funding isn't good. This isn't on the whole bad news.Having community driven development structure has been shown to work pretty well in several software development projects. I imagine it may time some time for others to become failure with the server side of BOINC. Given that, other than the BOINC devs, only project admins & the curious would have bothered to look under the hood.Join the BP6/VP6 User Group today! ID: 1698294 ·

kittyman

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 9 Jul 00

Posts: 50516

Credit: 1,018,363,574

RAC: 1,004

Message 1698332 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 1:31:03 UTC

i PUT MY MONEY WHERE MY MOUTH IS, KIDS.

i HAVE DONE SO MANY TIMES OVER THE YEARS.



mEOW. "Learn from yesterday. Live for today. Hope for tomorrow." Albert Einstein

"With cats." kittyman



SO THERE...THE KITTIES JUST TOSSED A C NOTE INTO THE POT.i PUT MY MONEY WHERE MY MOUTH IS, KIDS.i HAVE DONE SO MANY TIMES OVER THE YEARS.mEOW."Learn from yesterday. Live for today. Hope for tomorrow." Albert Einstein"With cats." kittyman ID: 1698332 ·

Blurf

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 2 Sep 06

Posts: 8940

Credit: 12,678,685

RAC: 0

Message 1698369 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 4:48:24 UTC - in response to Message 1698259. Hallelujah, the cat is finally out of the bag. I've known about this since April and it has been very difficult for me to answer some posts on the various forums in which people asked for bug fixes or enhancements/additional add-ons. Most of the time I went and ignored them, because I wasn't allowed to breathe anything about this pending doom. :-/



Jord-I feel you should've been allowed to tell people sooner or someone should have. However it is what it is.



Thank you for the information



Jord-I feel you should've been allowed to tell people sooner or someone should have. However it is what it is.Thank you for the information ID: 1698369 ·

jason_gee

Volunteer developer

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 24 Nov 06

Posts: 7489

Credit: 91,093,184

RAC: 0

Message 1698371 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 4:56:58 UTC - in response to Message 1698369. Well there are some of us that saw things not going right without being told.



I've recommended a few of the top Boinc experts to start looking at the Boinc's recommendations toward community development, and provided them somewhere to keep track of any dialog they have.



I'm hopeful if they can get past the doomsday prophecies and panic, they'll find a way to embrace the change, and take things in new directions. Could be a good thing. "Living by the wisdom of computer science doesn't sound so bad after all. And unlike most advice, it's backed up by proofs." -- Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions. ID: 1698371 ·

Admiral Gloval



Send message

Joined: 31 Mar 13

Posts: 14915

Credit: 5,308,449

RAC: 0

Joined: 31 Mar 13Posts: 14915Credit: 5,308,449RAC: 0 Message 1698391 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 5:57:39 UTC

How big of a hole does this "temporary" I hope lack of funding cause to any remaining budget?

I gues I will ask a big question.How big of a hole does this "temporary" I hope lack of funding cause to any remaining budget? ID: 1698391 ·

FeK9

Send message

Joined: 20 May 99

Posts: 40

Credit: 61,229,677

RAC: 26

Joined: 20 May 99Posts: 40Credit: 61,229,677RAC: 26 Message 1698401 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 7:20:18 UTC Seti@Home started the ball rolling, we can always go back to 'Classic'... :) Noli tangere circulos meos... ID: 1698401 ·

Gone with the wind

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 19 Nov 00

Posts: 41738

Credit: 42,645,437

RAC: 42

Message 1698406 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 8:10:19 UTC



Or am I wrong? "none so blind as those who will not see" (John Heywood 1546)



Don't drink water, that stuff rusts pipes!





You are making Proof out of Logic, by just being dubious! {Bluestar to me) Hold on here. Isn't it the case that it is funding for Boinc development that is ceasing. Seti@home which is a project running under the Boinc umbrella, is still being funded and is a separate issue.Or am I wrong?"none so blind as those who will not see" (John Heywood 1546)Don't drink water, that stuff rusts pipes!You are making Proof out of Logic, by just being dubious! {Bluestar to me) ID: 1698406 ·

BaldBear

Send message

Joined: 21 May 99

Posts: 4

Credit: 5,336,655

RAC: 0

Joined: 21 May 99Posts: 4Credit: 5,336,655RAC: 0 Message 1698407 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 8:14:16 UTC - in response to Message 1698251. That is disappointing news. Was the funding cut or just expired? After running Seti@Home for around 15 years, I had hoped something would have been discovered by now. Well, I hope it can continue for a few more years. ID: 1698407 ·

Claggy

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 5 Jul 99

Posts: 4654

Credit: 47,537,079

RAC: 4

Message 1698411 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 8:41:09 UTC - in response to Message 1698406. Hold on here. Isn't it the case that it is funding for Boinc development that is ceasing. Seti@home which is a project running under the Boinc umbrella, is still being funded and is a separate issue.



Or am I wrong?

Agreed, there is no point doing a funding drive to Seti in the hope of them doing Boinc development, they already don't have the spare time, Support the volunteer programmers that will be submitting patches and doing Boinc development instead:



There will probably be little visible change.

The BOINC software will continue to work.

The translation system, Alpha testing project, BOINC web site,message boards, and email lists will continue to operate.

However, any new development and major bug fixes to BOINC will need to be done by volunteer programmers.

I'm confident that the BOINC community will meet the challenge.



Claggy Agreed, there is no point doing a funding drive to Seti in the hope of them doing Boinc development, they already don't have the spare time, Support the volunteer programmers that will be submitting patches and doing Boinc development instead:Claggy ID: 1698411 ·

jason_gee

Volunteer developer

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 24 Nov 06

Posts: 7489

Credit: 91,093,184

RAC: 0

Message 1698417 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 9:07:47 UTC

Last modified: 4 Jul 2015, 9:22:32 UTC Interesting set of emotions reading the [BOINC development] governance document myself.



I'm particularly curious about why, given the basically clean slate opportunity, a multilevel committee based structure has been chosen, when the bulk of the software development industry has been working for more than 15 years toward leaner Agile development practices. go figure. "Living by the wisdom of computer science doesn't sound so bad after all. And unlike most advice, it's backed up by proofs." -- Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions. ID: 1698417 ·

Richard Haselgrove

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 4 Jul 99

Posts: 14185

Credit: 200,643,578

RAC: 874

Message 1698420 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 10:10:56 UTC - in response to Message 1698407.

Last modified: 4 Jul 2015, 10:44:14 UTC That is disappointing news. Was the funding cut or just expired? After running Seti@Home for around 15 years, I had hoped something would have been discovered by now. Well, I hope it can continue for a few more years.

Please be careful, folks. This thread is about funding for * BOINC *, and only BOINC: SETI is just one of probably over 100 scientific projects around the world which use the BOINC-developed infrastructure for their own purposes. The software exists, it works (I know, I know, we would all like it to work better), it'll go on working, and we can go on using it.



With regard to the BOINC funding: it expired. Actually, according to the record, it expired some time ago: they must have been running on fumes.



Until yesterday, the BOINC home page said "BOINC is supported by the National Science Foundation through awards ..."



I've dug through the NSF archives and pulled out



Start Date End Date Awarded Amount to Date SCI-0221529 October 1, 2002 September 30, 2005 $911,264.00 SCI-0438443 January 1, 2005 December 31, 2006 $711,538.00 SCI-0506411 September 1, 2005 August 31, 2009 $198,720.00 PHY/0555655 August 15, 2006 July 31, 2011 $998,862.00 * OCI-0721124 September 15, 2007 August 31, 2012 $1,320,000.00 ------------- Total NSF funding to date $4,140,384.00

* Sponsored by Einstein@Home (Principal Investigator Bruce Allen)



Edit - maybe I should have listed these two as well, although BOINC itself didn't claim them.



http://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1105572

http://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/showAward?AWD_ID=1148523



That would add another $1,648,546 to the pot. Please be careful, folks. This thread is about funding for, and only BOINC: SETI is just one of probably over 100 scientific projects around the world which use the BOINC-developed infrastructure for their own purposes. The software exists, it works (I know, I know, we would all like it to work better), it'll go on working, and we can go on using it.With regard to the BOINC funding: it expired. Actually, according to the record, it expired some time ago: they must have been running on fumes.Until yesterday, the BOINC home page said "BOINC is supported by the National Science Foundation through awards ..."I've dug through the NSF archives and pulled out* Sponsored by Einstein@Home (Principal Investigator Bruce Allen)Edit - maybe I should have listed these two as well, although BOINC itself didn't claim them.That would add another $1,648,546 to the pot. ID: 1698420 ·

Gone with the wind

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 19 Nov 00

Posts: 41738

Credit: 42,645,437

RAC: 42

Message 1698422 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 10:37:24 UTC Thank you very much for setting the record straight Richard. I think that many people get confused and think that seti=Boinc and vice versa. Seti@home will continue on under the Boinc umbrella, as it currently is, there is no need whatsoever for people to leave seti@home thinking erroneously that the project has died. It hasn't!! ID: 1698422 ·

jason_gee

Volunteer developer

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 24 Nov 06

Posts: 7489

Credit: 91,093,184

RAC: 0

Message 1698424 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 11:13:19 UTC - in response to Message 1698420. That would add another $1,648,546 to the pot.



Look I'm really sorry if it bursts anyone's bubble, but in the engineering scheme of things that's nothing more than a token gesture. Busy work. "Living by the wisdom of computer science doesn't sound so bad after all. And unlike most advice, it's backed up by proofs." -- Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions. Look I'm really sorry if it bursts anyone's bubble, but in the engineering scheme of things that's nothing more than a token gesture. Busy work."Living by the wisdom of computer science doesn't sound so bad after all. And unlike most advice, it's backed up by proofs." -- Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions. ID: 1698424 ·

Richard Haselgrove

Volunteer tester

Send message

Joined: 4 Jul 99

Posts: 14185

Credit: 200,643,578

RAC: 874

Message 1698426 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 11:16:36 UTC - in response to Message 1698424. That would add another $1,648,546 to the pot.

Look I'm really sorry if it bursts anyone's bubble, but in the engineering scheme of things that's nothing more than a token gesture. Busy work.

I just like my analyses to be complete, don't want to be accused of selling either BOINC or the NSF short. Even though BOINC sold itself short. I just like my analyses to be complete, don't want to be accused of selling either BOINC or the NSF short. Even though BOINC sold itself short. ID: 1698426 ·

Jord

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 9 Jun 99

Posts: 15176

Credit: 4,362,181

RAC: 3

Message 1698427 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 11:16:53 UTC



Rom's latest plans I heard of was that he was going to work for World Community Grid/IBM.

Charlie is still available for bug-fixes and specific Mac questions, but otherwise no longer attached to BOINC.

David still works at SSL and will continue to be the director of Seti.



As far as I understand, BOINC 7.6 will still be released to the public within a couple of days or weeks. After that the development of both the client and the back-end will fall to anyone who wants to contribute:



The only thing is, before any changes can be made, Let me also add: it's just the BOINC developers whose monthly income has dried up. Which means that Rom (Walton) and Charlie (Fenton) had to go look for new work.Rom's latest plans I heard of was that he was going to work for World Community Grid/IBM.Charlie is still available for bug-fixes and specific Mac questions, but otherwise no longer attached to BOINC.David still works at SSL and will continue to be the director of Seti.As far as I understand, BOINC 7.6 will still be released to the public within a couple of days or weeks. After that the development of both the client and the back-end will fall to anyone who wants to contribute: https://boinc.berkeley.edu/trac/wiki/ContributePage The only thing is, before any changes can be made, the PMC must converse about that and decide if they want BOINC to go in that direction. The PMC decides this about everything, from how the documentation looks like, to what the GUI should look like, to what can be done in the forums, to the inner workings of the client. Aside from the frustration that adds --I've run into one or two of them already-- best take my advice and shrug at it. It's like the past where David said he would or wouldn't add it, but this time times eight. Good luck in your fights. ID: 1698427 ·

jason_gee

Volunteer developer

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 24 Nov 06

Posts: 7489

Credit: 91,093,184

RAC: 0

Message 1698429 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 11:21:00 UTC - in response to Message 1698426. That would add another $1,648,546 to the pot.

Look I'm really sorry if it bursts anyone's bubble, but in the engineering scheme of things that's nothing more than a token gesture. Busy work.

I just like my analyses to be complete, don't want to be accused of selling either BOINC or the NSF short. Even though BOINC sold itself short.



Well no-one without funding is going to accuse you of jack :) The point is more that now the management laundry is aired, perhaps there's a chance of something more inclusive being developed. "Living by the wisdom of computer science doesn't sound so bad after all. And unlike most advice, it's backed up by proofs." -- Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions. Well no-one without funding is going to accuse you of jack :) The point is more that now the management laundry is aired, perhaps there's a chance of something more inclusive being developed."Living by the wisdom of computer science doesn't sound so bad after all. And unlike most advice, it's backed up by proofs." -- Algorithms to live by: The computer science of human decisions. ID: 1698429 ·

Jord

Volunteer tester



Send message

Joined: 9 Jun 99

Posts: 15176

Credit: 4,362,181

RAC: 3

Message 1698430 - Posted: 4 Jul 2015, 11:24:29 UTC what about crowd-funding", it was one of the first things I asked David when I got the news. He answered me:



That would be a last resort.

The main beneficiary of volunteer computing is government-funded science research.

We save these funding agencies (like NSF) many millions of dollars, so logically they should fund us.



Also, Rom and I are expensive, and it's not likely that crowd-funding would

produce enough to support us. Before you ask "", it was one of the first things I asked David when I got the news. He answered me: ID: 1698430 ·