Is Tesla Search Trend vs Audi, VW, GM, BMW, & Porsche Search Trend An Early Disruption Indicator?

April 20th, 2016 by Zachary Shahan

Tesla is set to disrupt the heck out of the auto market, according to many of us who watch the industry closely, and search trends on Google may be one of the earliest indicators.

I have tried hard to remember who passed this insight on to me, but have been unable to do so, so if it was you, please drop a note in the comments! It was either during or right before our Cleantech Revolution Tour event in Berlin, which just followed my trip to Los Angeles to cover the Tesla Model 3 unveiling, so I will claim innocence via lack of sleep and too much cleantech craziness on my plate. (Update: thanks to Alharbi for the tip!)

Back to the story — as you can see in the graph below from Google Trends (USA), searches for “Tesla” climbed considerably from 2013 to 2016, but then jumped through the freakin’ roof sometime in the past month or so … hmm, wonder why. It climbed up to a point not far below Audi, GM, and VW up until that big rise, but then it shot up to quickly and dramatically surpass them and also BMW (which sits a bit higher than the larger but less desired Audi, GM, and VW brands).

Wowza. Does this article/video come to mind for you?

It does for me.

Here’s another graph but changing BMW to Porsche (you can only put 5 in at a time):

The bottom line is manifold:

Tesla has created an insanely popular brand. The Tesla Model 3 has made much of the world stop and say, “wow!” Even more than many of us expected it would at this stage. The Tesla Model 3 — much better than any car in its price range, arguably goes down to $25,000 … or even lower (story coming soon on this) — is primed to become one of the highest-selling cars in the United States, perhaps surpassing any model that BMW, Audi, GM, and VW have to offer. The Chevy Bolt is not in the same league as the Tesla Model 3 … as much as GM would like you to believe that it is. Here’s a comparison of “tesla model 3” searches vs “chevy bolt” searches (USA):

There are a handful of what I think are obvious reasons for the discrepancy in this last graph and the broader trend noted above regarding the brands. I’ll again resort to a list, since I like those:

Yes, the large, established, “too big to fail” automakers of the US, Germany, and Japan need to wake up and come up with a real plan for the electric vehicle future. (I’ll spill the beans on an idea I supported during that Cleantech Revolution Tour event in Berlin: spin off sub-brands that can wholeheartedly and with common sense pursue electric vehicle competitiveness, insulated from the demise of the internal combustion engine — in lay speak, gasmobiles.)

We’ve been having some fun discussions lately on CleanTechnica about the future of these large automakers. There’s plenty of healthy and interesting debate whether they will pull themselves through the transition (and what they need in order to do so) or be eaten alive by their own size and institutional weight. (Again, we have a fun deep dive on this topic that should be published in the coming weeks.)

But let’s be absolutely clear, Tesla isn’t just getting press because Elon Musk is a lovable character who has hypnotized the masses. Tesla doesn’t just have fans because Elon jokes with the common folk on Twitter. Tesla has demonstrated the following competitive advantages with its cars (which grow the size of this list):

insane — nay, ludicrous — acceleration

world-leading autonomous driving options

continued improvement (via deep learning) of its autonomous driving options

over-the-air software updates

a giant iPad (well, tablet) for controlling your new toy

Supercharging (this is basically a requirement for EVs akin to oxygen for humans, btw*)

no-pressure direct sales experience, with no haggling

lowest-cost batteries

offers battery upgrades (for a price) for existing cars, and will continuously do so

instance after instance of doing things for the benefit of the consumer even if not financially beneficial (in the short or medium term) for Tesla

If you aren’t drinking the Kool Aid yet, maybe it’s time to go to the store.

If you aren’t producing/selling the Kool Aid yet, maybe it’s time to move beyond Death In A Bottle and get into the game.

*slight overstatement possible

By the way, here are interactive versions of the three charts above:











Appreciate CleanTechnica’s originality? Consider becoming a CleanTechnica member, supporter, or ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.

Sign up for our free daily newsletter or weekly newsletter to never miss a story.

Have a tip for CleanTechnica, want to advertise, or want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.

Latest Cleantech Talk Episode