Send this page to someone via email

A Calgary man who was issued a fine for following his friend through a SkyTrain fare gate in Vancouver has lost his bid to have the ticket thrown out.

Karl Lusawovana Nunu drove 10 hours from Alberta to fight the fine in court, after failing to have the ticket cancelled.

For Lusawovana Nunu, the incident was particularly frustrating because he had a valid fare, but followed his friend through the gate after his own ticket failed to activate its tap-to-open function.

READ MORE: ‘This is not right’: Former B.C. man facing costly fight over SkyTrain ticket

On Tuesday, a judge ruled that despite having a valid fare, Lusawovana Nunu had still broken the law as written by following someone through the gate, and that his “hands were tied.”

Story continues below advertisement

“He bought himself a ticket, I believe that, but this is not about whether he had a valid ticket,” said Justice Zahid Makhdoom.

“When you ride the coattails of a friend to exit, you are breaking the law.”

The judge added that the Calgary resident had not done his due diligence by trying to tap on another gate or using the service phone for help.

WATCH: Calgary man ticketed on SkyTrain despite paying fare

1:55 Calgary man ticketed on SkyTrain despite paying fare Calgary man ticketed on SkyTrain despite paying fare

However, the judge did lower the fine from $173 to $70.

“I am a little bit disappointed with the judge’s decision,” said Lusawovana Nunu.

“The judge mentioned that I should be aware of the procedure when the ticket doesn’t open [the gate]. As someone like me who doesn’t usually use TransLink I’m not even aware of it.”

Story continues below advertisement

Despite the failure to have his fine overturned, Lusawovana Nunu said it was worth it to fight the ticket until the end, because it could help raise awareness for other people who aren’t regular users of the system.

WATCH: (June, 2017) One year in, how are TransLink’s fare gates working out?

1:39 One year in, how are TransLink’s fare gates working out? One year in, how are TransLink’s fare gates working out?

“They don’t bring the awareness for their clients, being aware about the actions they should take if something like this happens,” he said.

“Like me, someone who didn’t know, they just put me in the same bucket like people who are pretty much trying to get free rides.”

Lusawovana Nunu’s fight started back on Sept. 14, 2018 when he was out celebrating a job transfer with a friend.

READ MORE: Transit police dishing out more tickets for fare gate funny business, fewer for fare evasion

He bought a fare at Columbia Station, but was unable to tap out properly at Stadium Station. After two failed attempts to tap the gate open, his friend opened it with his own Compass card.

Story continues below advertisement

A Metro Vancouver Transit Police (MVTP) officer immediately intervened, and ticketed Lusawovana Nunu, despite his attempts to explain he had a valid fare.

Lusawovana Nunu made a complaint to MVTP, who investigated, but determined he had, in fact, committed an offence.

— With files from Kristen Robinson