Twice: 49,904 (2015) -> 67,149

Lovelyz: 8,299 (2014) -> 10,483

Girlfriend: 6,486 (2015) -> 9,508

Singer - debut album, sales of debut year - current total sales (since 2012)145,925 (2012) -> 295,68087,553 (2012) -> 188,62480,262 (2012) -> 87,035: 52,312 (2015) -> 83,61424,441 (2013) -> 62,31752,783 (2015) -> 59,420: 34,882 (2012) -> 39,53531,085 (2015) -> 31,0852,462 (2012) -> 13,0341. [+86, -0] EXO's a wall2. [+81, -5] VIP here but I remember Winner being amazing with 'Empty'... They were so different from the styles YG usually came out with. For a YG artist, they also sold a lot of albums and had huge voting power. I should be careful saying this but their fandom seems more like a fit for SM than YG...3. [+69, -3] Hul, Winner's in third...!!4. [+42, -1] And after their debut, freaking YG put Winner on hiatus5. [+40, -1] Hul, had no idea Winner sold that many6. [+34, -1] I remember EXO lacked public recognition but they had a really strong fandom for a rookie group7. [+27, -2] I'm a late iKON fan so I only bought their album recently but I guess sales have been consistent for them... and EXO's been amazing since debut, huh?8. [+27, -0] EXO sold a lot even as a rookie...9. [+20, -0] I was really pissed YG made fan signing entries for Winner on DVDs.. ㅎㅎ and one of their album versions cost $40 so it's amazing that they sold as many as they did ㅠㅠㅠ they'd be doing so much better now if not for their hiatus ㅠㅠ YG are you reading this?10. [+19, -0] There'd be so many more Winner fans now if YG didn't put them on such a long hiatus. The fandom's still growing but it's not at the speed it used to be so it always makes me upset.