On May 8, Radiohead unveiled A Moon Shaped Pool—its first studio album in five years, and the latest in a decades-long career that’s seen the band grow from a scrappy, slightly sour-pussed guitar-rock outfit to a sprawling, slightly sour-pussed experimental combo. The group’s reshaped and re-purposed its sound on each record, and every Radiohead fan has his or her favorite phase, whether it’s the crunching, stadium-ready sounds of the Bends era, or the astral bombast of the OK Computer years, or the blissed-out mysteries of In Rainbows period. Here’s our ranking of the group’s studio efforts; we understand if, after reading, you want to come at us with knives out.