1985: Emilio Estevez and Judd Nelson

We have a tie, because it's necessary. On the one hand, The Breakfast Club delivered the young Estevez, who epitomized the prep factor of the mid-'80s. On the other, there was Judd Nelson, who rebelled his way into our hearts. So: you decide. Are you Nelson or Estevez? Keeping in mind everything about you will be decided by your choice.