According to 2x13 “The First Secret”, which was set in 2008, Toby’s mom died almost exactly a year ago (making the scene in the finale take place in 2007). Charles looked about elementary school age. Then, the summer that the family goes to Cape May, Alison is 15 years old. If Ali was 15, Charlotte would’ve been about 19/20 years old. How did she age nearly a decade over the course of 2 years? Such a strange time jump.

