Episode 1: Parvati returned to compete for a second time as part of the all-star Malakal tribe. Parvati stated that although she’s a flirt, she’s going to play smart this time. She flirted quite early with James. Eliza noticed the relationships between them and the relationship between Amanda and Ozzy, and started to worry. Parvati and Ozzy talked to Jonny Fairplay, trying to convice him voting with them against Eliza, saying that Amand and Ozzy would join them. After their conversation, Ami, Eliza and Jonathan tried to convice Jonny Fairplay to vote off Parvati. Malakal lost the first combined Reward and Immunity Challenge. After the challenge, Jonny Fairplay told the tribe that his mind was not really committed to the game because he missed his girlfriend and unborn daughter. Parvati had the idea to distract the alliance of Ami, Eliza, Jonathan and Yau-Man in the belief that they all voting out Jonny Fairplay, while Parvati’s alliance would vote out Eliza instead. However, at Tribal Council, the rest of the Malakal tribe granted Jonny Fairplay wishes, and he was unanimously voted out.

Episode 2: At Malakal, the couples of Amanda/Ozzy and Parvati/James grew closer, much to the concern of Jonathan and Cirie. Malakal won their first combined Reward and Immunity Challenge.

Episode 3: The alliance of Parvati tried to convice Eliza to vote off Yau-Man first, then Jonathan and Cirie, but Eliza didn’t trusted them. On day 7, Parvati, along with Amanda and Cirie were rowing in the ocean. Parvati assured Cirie that she hadn’t made any promises to James, and she don’t want to sit next to him at the final three, nor Ozzy. So, the three women made a final three deal. Malakal lost the Immunity Challenge. Parvati was targeted by the opposing alliance, but her alliance (now with Cirie) succeeded in voting off strategic threat Yau-Man.

Episode 4: Eliza tried to keep herself in the game by talking to Parvati about voting out Jonathan, but Jonathan overheard them. Parvati knew that Eliza do anything that she can to save herself, becuase if Malakal goes to the Tribal Council, Eliza would be voted out. Malakal won the Immunity Challenge.

Episode 5: At Malakal, Ozzy told Amanda, James, and Parvati that he found the Hidden Immunity Idol. Before the Reward Challenge began, Jeff announced a tribal switch. The tribes were divided by schoolyard pick. The new Airai tribe was composed of Alexis, Eliza, James, Jason, Jonathan, Kathy, Natalie, and Parvati; Amanda, Ami, Chet, Cirie, Erik, Joel, Ozzy, and Tracy made up the new Malakal tribe. the new Airai tribe won the Immunity Challenge.

Episode 6: At Airai, Eliza wanted to earn the trust of the fans along with Jonathan, in order to eliminate Parvati and James before the merge. However, after the Airai won the reward challenge, Jeff announced that the Survivor medical team wanted to look at Jonathan’s knee. The doctor recommended that he be evacuated and taken to the hospital for treatment as the knee had become seriously infected. Jonathan accepted the recommendation and left the game. Airai won the Immunity Challenge.

Episode 7: On day 18, the constant rain, poor camp conditions, and feeling of missing her family was too much for Kathy to bear and she decided to quit the next morning. Jeff arrived at the Airai beach and took Kathy away at her request. Airai won again the Immunity Challenge.

Episode 8: Parvati approached Natalie about forming an alliance with James and Alexis in order to get them to the tribal merge. Longer term, Parvati offered to Natalie the option of going to the final four with Alexis and Amanda, which Natalie agreed with. Airai won the combined reward and immunity challenge.

Episode 9: Parvati understood she’s in the middle. She had an alliance with Amanda, Cirie, James and Ozzy, and another alliance, with Alexis, Amanda and Natalie, and she knew that she had to make a decision in the future. On day 22, Airai and Malakal merged into one tribe and enjoyed the customary merger feast. The tribe decided to live at the Malakal campsite. Erik chose the name Dabu for the merged tribe, telling everyone that it meant “good” in Micronesian when in reality he had just made it up because he wanted to name the tribe something funny. Parvati told Amanda about the alliance she struck with Alexis and Natalie, but Amanda was angry about Parvati pledging Amanda’s allegiance without her consent. Parvati wanted to vote out Eliza, as she targeted her since the first day of the game. Patvati also converted her at Tribal Council for her trying to vote her out and than telling her she’s loyal to her. Parvati joined the majority to vote off Eliza.

Episode 10: Amanda and James were worried about Parvati, as she was close to Alexis and Natalie. Parvati won her first individual immunity challenge. When the castaways returned to camp, Amanda, James, and Ozzy immediately wanted to renege on their promise to Jason and vote for him. Cirie saw this as a good opportunity to blindside Ozzy, the biggest physical threat, and eliminate the danger of the Immunity Idol. She approached Alexis, Jason, Natalie, and Parvati about voting for Ozzy. The four agreed with her, but decided not to tell any of the others and hoped to throw them off by acting like Jason was going home. At Tribal Council, Ozzy stated that he might have had to play the Hidden Immunity Idol, but he did not bring it with him to Tribal Council. Following that, an angry Ozzy was voted out.

Episode 11: After Tribal Council, Amanda was angry that Parvati and Cirie did not tell her about their plot against Ozzy. Parvati tried to patch things up with James, but her efforts didn’t work and James no longer trusted Parvati. Her efforts also failed with Amanda, though she kept her distrust of Parvati and Cirie to herself. One of the items sold at the auction was a bottle containing a note that said that the winning bidder had to pick a castaway to immediately go to Exile Island. The item was won by Natalie and she chose Jason. Jeff announced that there was a new Hidden Immunity Idol on Exile Island, which was found by Jason. While Jason was on Exile Island, the girls planned to blindside him at the next Tribal Council. The plan was for Natalie to exploit Jason’s trust in her and tell him that he owed her for sending him to Exile Island so that he could find the Hidden Immunity Idol. Just before the start of the Immunity Challenge, Natalie put the girl’s plan into action by telling Jason that James was going to be voted out and Jason needed to make sure that James did not win Individual Immunity. On his 22nd birthday, Erik won Individual Immunity, unknowingly putting the second part of the girl’s plan into place. Back at camp, the girls searched Jason’s bag, much to the chagrin of James and Erik, and found the Hidden Immunity Idol wrapped in his belongings. Natalie convinced Jason that the girls would be voting for James. At Tribal Council, the girls’ plan finally succeeded when Jason did not play the Hidden Immunity Idol, and he was voted out.

Episode 12: After Tribal Council, the Survivor medical team took a look at James’ injured finger and told him that they would look at the finger again the next morning. James was told that if the infection spread to the joint, he would need surgery to prevent disablement of the joint. The Reward Challenge included the customary visit by the castaways’ loved ones. Jeff announced that Exile Island was back in play with another Hidden Immunity Idol. Alexis won the challenge to take a trip to Jellyfish Lake and opted to take along Cirie and her husband and Natalie and her mother. Amanda volunteered to go to Exile Island and Alexis granted her wish. After the challenge, the Survivor medical team looked at James again and made the call that the risk of the infection in his finger spreading to his joint was too great and that James be removed from the game for medication attention. On Exile Island, Amanda followed a new set of clues to learn that the Hidden Immunity Idol was buried under the tribe’s flag back at camp. Alexis, Natalie, and Parvati discussed what they should do if Erik succeeded in winning the next Individual Immunity. Natalie said that she would vote for Amanda since she thought Amanda had the best chance of winning over the jury while Parvati said that she could not vote for Amanda due to long term alliances. Erik’s sharpshooting enabled him to win the Immunity Challenge, foiling the all-girl alliance’s plan to vote him out at the next Tribal Council. Back at their campsite, Amanda truthfully told the tribe that she did not find the Hidden Immunity Idol. The idol clue stated that the idol was at camp, which she confided to Parvati. At that point, she recruited Parvati’s help in retrieving the Idol. The others were fooled by Amanda and wanted to vote her out, worried that she had a better chance to capture jury votes since she had not made any enemies. Amanda and Parvati thought they could convince Erik to join their voting block by asking him to return the favor of keeping him in the game over Ami, but he would not join them. At Tribal Council, James shocked everybody by appearing with an IV for his infection. Alexis, Cirie, Erik, and Natalie openly said they would be voting for Amanda, but the three fans received a second shock for the night when she produced the Hidden Immunity Idol. She said when she told the others she didn’t have it, she wasn’t lying because she didn’t have it at the time. This negated their votes against her, leaving only the votes cast for Alexis, who was voted out.

Episode 13: Amanda and Cirie reconfirmed their alliance with Parvati to go to the final three. They plotted to manipulate Erik into sending Parvati to Exile Island by having Amanda convince Erik that she forgave him for his switching loyalties and that they should team up since they were the two most physical players left. This would prevent Erik or Natalie from finding the Hidden Immunity Idol, making one of them vulnerable at the next Tribal Council. Erik won the Reward Challenge and selected Amanda to join him based on his agreement with her, while Parvati was sent to Exile. Back at the campsite, Natalie felt betrayed by Erik and vented her feelings to Cirie, who found pleasure in Natalie stressing over the betrayal. After returning from the reward, Erik talked to Cirie and attempted to make a final 3 alliance with her and Parvati. However, Natalie overheard their conversation and she, Amanda and Cirie all recounted what Erik said to them, stressing Erik. At the Immunity Challenge, Erik easily won, once again ruining the women’s hopes of getting rid of him. Erik later revealed his planned game play to Cirie involving his hopes of going to the final three with her and Parvati, unaware that Natalie was nearby and overheard it. Natalie explained this to the other three women, and Cirie suggested that Natalie attempt to try to convince Erik to hand the Individual Immunity over to Natalie using the argument that it would redeem himself in front of the jury and that Cirie and Natalie would agree to vote out Amanda only if Erik saved Natalie. At Tribal Council, Amanda lambasted Erik for his switching loyalties, and was soon joined by Natalie and Parvati. However when the time came, the plot worked, and Erik gave Natalie the immunity necklace, hoping that Cirie and Natalie would join him in voting for Parvati. However, the girls stuck to their plan, and Erik was voted out.

Episode 14: At the Immunity Challenge, Natalie quickly took an early lead, but Amanda came from behind during the ladder assembly stage to win Immunity. Natalie tried to break up the alliance of Amanda, Cirie, and Parvati. During Tribal Council, Jeff hinted that instead of a final three that there would be a final two, which caused Cirie to declare that she felt she was at the bottom of every alliance that she was in. This resulted in a short argument between Cirie and Amanda. Despite this, the Favorites alliance held and Natalie, the last Fan remaining, was voted out 3–1. After Tribal Council, Amanda and Cirie continued their argument over Cirie feeling that she was at the bottom of every alliance she was in, although they eventually made up and celebrated that they had all reached the final three like they had originally intended. Their happiness was cut short however, as the three found out on Day 38 that Jeff’s questions at Tribal Council about a final two were not hypothetical and they would have to go through one final Immunity Challenge after the customary honoring of past castaways who left the game. While Parvati didn’t really try, a distraught Amanda managed to regroup and win the final Immunity Challenge over Cirie. At camp, Cirie tried to convince Amanda why she should keep her, but at Tribal Council, Amanda kept her loyalty to Parvati and voted out Cirie.

Final Tribal Council

At the Final Tribal Council, Parvati tried to convince the jury to vote for her because of her aggressive game play compared to her previous season. Despite being accused of being a mean person (by Eliza) and a backstabber (by Ozzy), the jury decided to award Parvati the title of Sole Survivor with a vote of 5–3 against Amanda. Parvati received the votes from all the women on the jury and Jason.

Statistics

Tribes: Malakal, Airai and Dabu

Alliance: Malakal Couples Alliance and Black Widow Brigade

Challenge wins: 11

Votes against: 4

Votes from the jury: 5 out of 8