Adam McCann, Financial Writer

Feb 24, 2020

Many Americans view hard work as the path to achieving the American Dream. We work so hard, in fact, that we put in more hours at our jobs than several other industrialized countries. The average U.S. worker puts in 1,786 hours per year – 106 hours more than the average in Japan, 248 more than the U.K. and 403 more than Germany.

But some U.S. cities represent the strong work ethic that helped to build the world’s biggest economy better than others. In order to determine which cities outwork the rest of America, WalletHub compared the 116 largest cities across 11 key metrics. Our data set ranges from employment rate to average weekly work hours to share of workers with multiple jobs. Read on for our findings, expert insight from a panel of researchers and a full description of our methodology.

Main Findings





Hardest-Working Cities in the U.S.

Overall Rank* City Total Score ‘Direct Work Factors’

Rank ‘Indirect Work Factors’

Rank 1 Anchorage, AK 80.07 4 8 2 San Francisco, CA 76.87 3 43 3 Virginia Beach, VA 76.61 6 13 4 Cheyenne, WY 76.11 8 30 5 Irving, TX 75.65 2 74 6 Norfolk, VA 74.79 9 17 7 Corpus Christi, TX 74.65 5 107 8 Washington, DC 74.46 12 10 9 Austin, TX 73.94 1 93 10 Plano, TX 73.28 7 64 11 Denver, CO 73.00 11 39 12 Aurora, CO 72.34 15 27 13 Dallas, TX 71.89 10 63 14 Chesapeake, VA 71.35 20 11 15 Portland, ME 71.22 21 22 16 Nashville, TN 70.39 13 51 17 Fort Worth, TX 70.30 14 60 18 Honolulu, HI 70.30 27 24 19 Billings, MT 69.74 40 5 20 Sioux Falls, SD 69.51 19 69 21 Arlington, TX 69.38 18 60 22 Oklahoma City, OK 69.08 16 67 23 Salt Lake City, UT 68.58 54 1 24 Houston, TX 68.52 17 80 25 Durham, NC 68.20 25 90 26 Garland, TX 67.89 22 52 27 Chandler, AZ 67.85 23 49 28 Seattle, WA 67.65 43 9 29 Raleigh, NC 67.60 28 37 30 Charlotte, NC 67.58 29 33 31 Gilbert, AZ 66.91 31 36 32 Omaha, NE 66.75 45 21 33 Fargo, ND 66.37 36 55 34 Fremont, CA 66.12 35 35 35 Tampa, FL 65.85 24 86 36 Scottsdale, AZ 65.72 32 53 37 Laredo, TX 65.59 30 103 38 Manchester, NH 65.57 39 65 39 Tulsa, OK 65.34 41 75 40 San Jose, CA 64.81 34 59 41 Colorado Springs, CO 64.44 55 42 42 Boston, MA 64.19 57 16 43 Minneapolis, MN 64.09 66 7 44 Irvine, CA 63.95 33 85 45 Jacksonville, FL 63.94 26 102 46 Kansas City, MO 63.67 56 26 47 Indianapolis, IN 63.50 58 14 48 Jersey City, NJ 63.37 53 40 49 Oakland, CA 63.24 51 45 50 El Paso, TX 63.18 48 95 51 St. Petersburg, FL 62.95 38 91 52 Little Rock, AR 62.91 44 110 53 San Antonio, TX 62.41 37 101 54 Des Moines, IA 62.35 62 46 55 San Diego, CA 62.19 46 81 56 Boise, ID 62.15 67 20 57 Anaheim, CA 61.89 49 77 58 Louisville, KY 61.87 61 28 59 Atlanta, GA 61.87 47 79 60 Portland, OR 61.79 80 3 61 Phoenix, AZ 61.70 59 44 62 Lincoln, NE 61.47 70 25 63 Orlando, FL 61.28 42 104 64 Lexington-Fayette, KY 61.27 60 71 65 Santa Ana, CA 60.98 50 87 66 Baltimore, MD 60.91 88 4 67 Lubbock, TX 60.78 52 112 68 Wichita, KS 59.97 65 94 69 Long Beach, CA 59.30 64 68 70 St. Paul, MN 59.21 91 6 71 Chula Vista, CA 58.82 69 58 72 Fort Wayne, IN 58.64 74 72 73 Glendale, AZ 58.49 76 34 74 New York, NY 58.26 72 57 75 Los Angeles, CA 57.91 73 66 76 St. Louis, MO 57.83 86 19 77 Chicago, IL 57.42 87 23 78 Miami, FL 57.06 63 108 79 Henderson, NV 56.88 68 96 80 Columbus, OH 56.84 75 62 81 Reno, NV 56.83 71 111 82 Wilmington, DE 56.79 78 50 83 Winston-Salem, NC 56.74 77 99 84 Bakersfield, CA 56.50 82 84 85 Mesa, AZ 55.37 90 47 86 North Las Vegas, NV 54.97 81 82 87 Madison, WI 54.92 97 15 88 Greensboro, NC 53.87 92 98 89 New Orleans, LA 53.85 79 97 90 Las Vegas, NV 53.69 89 88 91 Milwaukee, WI 53.53 103 2 92 Jackson, MS 53.10 84 114 93 Charleston, WV 52.97 83 115 94 Memphis, TN 52.93 94 56 95 Philadelphia, PA 52.41 101 12 96 Sacramento, CA 52.38 93 92 97 Birmingham, AL 52.33 85 105 98 Riverside, CA 51.15 98 76 99 Cincinnati, OH 50.58 102 29 100 Baton Rouge, LA 50.31 99 100 101 Albuquerque, NM 49.71 96 113 102 Hialeah, FL 49.39 95 109 103 Pittsburgh, PA 48.99 104 18 104 Stockton, CA 47.12 107 38 105 Tucson, AZ 46.60 105 70 106 Toledo, OH 46.33 108 53 107 Columbia, SC 46.30 100 116 108 San Bernardino, CA 45.17 106 83 109 Fresno, CA 42.74 109 89 110 Newark, NJ 41.84 111 40 111 Providence, RI 41.35 110 73 112 Bridgeport, CT 40.42 112 32 113 Cleveland, OH 40.10 114 31 114 Buffalo, NY 36.21 113 106 115 Burlington, VT 33.15 115 78 116 Detroit, MI 32.96 116 48

*1=Hardest Working

Employment Rate Over Time









Ask the Experts

The American work structure contrasts with that of other countries. For additional insight, we asked a panel of experts to weigh in with their thoughts on the following key questions:

Research shows that Americans work 25% more hours than their counterparts in Europe. Why do Americans work so much more, and is it worth it? Does working more hours always translate into higher productivity? Does this vary by industry or job type? What is the ideal number of hours to work per week? What policies should governments and firms adopt to improve the quality of life of American workers?

Methodology

In order to determine where the hardest-working Americans live, WalletHub compared 116 of the most populated cities across two key dimensions, “Direct Work Factors” and “Indirect Work Factors.”

We evaluated those dimensions using 11 key metrics, which are listed below with their corresponding weights. Each metric was graded on a 100-point scale, with a score of 100 representing the “hardest-working.” Data for metrics marked with an asterisk (*) were available only at the state level.

We then determined each city’s weighted average across all metrics to calculate its overall score and used the resulting scores to rank-order our sample.

For our sample, we ensured that at least one city from each of the 50 states was represented. Each city refers to city proper and excludes the surrounding metro area.

Direct Work Factors – Total Points: 80

Average Workweek Hours: Triple Weight (~36.92 Points)

Employment Rate: Full Weight (~12.31 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated as follows: Civilian Population Aged 16 Years and Over Employed / Total Civilian Population Aged 16 Years and Over in Labor Force.

Share of Households where No Adults Work: Full Weight (~12.31 Points)

Share of Workers Leaving Vacation Time Unused: Half Weight (~6.15 Points)

Share of Engaged Workers*: Half Weight (~6.15 Points)

Note: This metric measures the share of employees who are “involved in, enthusiastic about and committed to their work and workplace,” as defined by Gallup.

Idle Youth (16-24) Rate: Half Weight (~6.15 Points)

Note: This metric measures the rate of residents ages 16-24 who are neither in school nor working.

Indirect Work Factors – Total Points: 20

Average Commute Time: Full Weight (~4.00 Points)

Share of Workers with Multiple Jobs*: Full Weight (~4.00 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated as a percentage of total employment.

Annual Volunteer Hours per Resident: Full Weight (~4.00 Points)

Share of Residents Who Participate in Local Groups or Organizations: Full Weight (~4.00 Points)

Average Leisure Time Spent per Day*: Full Weight (~4.00 Points)



Videos for News Use:



Sources: Data used to create this ranking were collected from the U.S. Census Bureau, Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Travel Association, Gallup, Social Science Research Council and Corporation for National & Community Service.

Was this article helpful? Yes No Awesome! Thanks for your feedback. Thank you for your feedback. Sorry! Failed to send the feedback. Please try again later. Submit