Music, Spies And Exact Change: The Strange History Of Electronic Tolls

Enlarge this image toggle caption Stephen Nessen/WNYC Stephen Nessen/WNYC

There was a time when the most frustrating thing about summer road trips were the lines at the tollbooth.

Remember digging through the seats for exact change or scrambling to find the shortest line? Toll collection has come a long way, from handing money to cashiers to simply driving through the booth with an E-ZPass.

But the technology passed through many, often surprising, hands — musicians and spies and NASA scientists — to become the electronic tollbooths many highways enjoy today.

"Music out of thin air"

The story of the electronic tollbooth begins at the turn of the century, in St. Petersburg, Russia. That's where Leon Theremin was born.

Yes, that Theremin — the creator of the musical instrument you play without even touching.

U.S. Analyzing the Hidden Costs of E-ZPass Tolls Analyzing the Hidden Costs of EZ Pass Tolls Listen

"Just as World War I was starting, and then the Russian Revolution, he found himself in the middle of that and was pulled into the new Soviet inner circle and told he was now a Soviet scientist," says Albert Glinksy, who wrote the biography Theremin: Ether Music and Espionage.

Playing with electromagnetic fields while working on a gas detection meter, Theremin discovered a trick: Using the radio frequency between two antennas, he'd wave one hand for volume and the other for pitch.

"The headlines were just over the top," Glinsky says. " 'Magician of music creates music out of thin air; how is this possible?' Even scientists, until they really understood the principle, were kind of baffled by what he was doing."

Theremin was sent to New York City, where he performed and continued to invent. But he also had another mission.

YouTube

"He was carrying out espionage, so he had this sort of double life in New York," Glinsky says.

Back in the USSR

In 1938 — after 11 years in the U.S. — Theremin hitched a ride on a freighter back to Russia.

But the political winds had changed, and he was sent to a Siberian labor camp, then transferred to a prison for scientists.

It was there that Theremin took spying to a new level when he was ordered to build a bugging device to spy on the U.S. ambassador in Moscow.

"The brilliance of this device was it had no batteries, it needed no electrical external source," Glinsky says. "And it was perfectly inert until it was activated, when they wanted to externally, by microwave beams from a companion device that was a few buildings down."

YouTube

The bug was the size of a quarter and placed in the office of the U.S. ambassador in Moscow. It was hidden in a seal of the United States, where it stayed for seven years before being accidentally discovered.

Phantom tollbooth?

Theremin may have created the first RFID-like device. But it took a Brooklyn inventor to connect another technology — friend or foe radar — with modern computing that gets us to electronic toll collection.



Mario Cardullo began his career working on jet propulsion on Apollo 11.

"I was responsible for all the engines," says Cardullo, who now lives and works in Alexandria, Va.



In the 1960s radio identification, or RFID, tags were used on anti-theft devices in stores and for keeping track of cattle.



Cardullo took that technology and the work Theremin had done 30 years before — using microwaves to activate a device — and added a modern twist: a memory chip. In 1970 he filed the first patent on a battery-free transponder that could transmit and receive information.

He imagined what the RFID device would revolutionize: "Toll systems, doorways, medical records."

A year later, Cardullo landed a meeting with the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.

Enlarge this image toggle caption Courtesy of Mario Cardullo Courtesy of Mario Cardullo

He wanted to demonstrate an electronic toll collection device on the George Washington Bridge. The prototype was the size of two packs of cigarettes.

"The first thing they [said] to me was, 'Well, nobody will ever put that on the window of their car, it's too big,' " Cardullo remembers.

He reassured them he could make it smaller. But the Port Authority passed.

Road ready

Cardullo's patent expired in 1990 — and that's when electronic toll collecting exploded.

The first electronic tollbooth in the world had been installed in Norway in 1987; Dallas quickly followed in 1989.

Not until 1994, however, did multiple states — New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania — agree to use the same device for their toll systems. That device, the E-ZPass, was quietly unveiled the next year in New York City, with its very own lane and purple sign.

Politics Proposal To Allow State Tolls On Interstates Hits Roadblocks Proposal To Allow State Tolls On Interstates Hits Roadblocks Listen · 3:50 3:50

Now the E-ZPass is accepted in 16 states, with a handful of similar systems used all across the country. And all of them use the same technology Leon Theremin created nearly a century ago.