

Absintheuse

Posts: 348



11/8/2016 You may have seen recently that Apple has allowed rolling subscriptions within their App Store. We had originally designed the mobile version of Fallen London to have one-month rolling subscriptions, to match the browser. However, when the iOS app first released in April 2016 this wasn’t an option and so we created 1, 3, 6 and 12 month subscriptions instead. Now that rolling subscriptions are allowed, we’re going to bring the iOS subscription functionality back in line with browser and Android.



We’re currently working on making these adjustments, and they should be up sometime next week. We’ll be sure to make a fuller, and more official announcement once everything is live!





Absintheuse

Posts: 348



11/8/2016 Skinnyman wrote:

So buying bigger and cheaper packages won't be possible with iOS either or I understood the other way around?

Correct, the larger packages will no longer be available. Instead, a 1 month, auto-renewing subscription purchase option will be available across all of our platforms.



Estelle Knoht

Posts: 1751



11/8/2016 Considering the occasional complaints from people about credit card and subscription trouble, perhaps it wouldn't hurt to leave people the option to buy a month of EF?



--

Estelle Knoht, a juvenile, unreliable and respectable lady.

I currently do not accept any catbox, cider, suppers, calling cards or proteges.



lady ciel

Posts: 2566



11/8/2016 A way to change card details without having to wait for our current subscription to end would be good, if it is possible.



--

https://www.fallenlondon.com/Profile/lady%20ciel



Sorry RL means I am not a very active player at the moment. No social actions unless you are prepared to wait and definitely no sparring or other mult-action things.



No Calling Cards or boxed cats please. Will take dupes on the affluent photographers. Other social invitations welcome. Parabolan Kittens usually available, send me an in-game social action saying you want one and I will get one to you as soon as possible.



storynexus name - reveurciel



Skinnyman

Posts: 2149



11/8/2016 What?

So from this:

Alexis Kennedy wrote:

Hi all!



The 3/6/12 month subscription options were a last-minute surprise we had to implement because of some of the circumstances of working with Apple.



We will be offering them through the website as well, as soon as we've tidied up everything post mobile launch. Last year we were very wary of offering multi-month subscriptions, because Exceptional Friendship was still experimental and we worried we might need to change price or benefits. But we know what we're doing, now.



we ended up having this:

Absintheuse wrote:

Skinnyman wrote:

So buying bigger and cheaper packages won't be possible with iOS either or I understood the other way around?

Correct, the larger packages will no longer be available. Instead, a 1 month, auto-renewing subscription purchase option will be available across all of our platforms.



Really...? Bit odd, but from the last two weeks I'm starting to get the feeling FBG is trying to leech more money. Hope an explanation will prove me (and probably other) wrong!



--

ESs items and quality requirements sheet. Please check if there are errors or if something is missing

Achievement list if you're feeling bored!

I am accepting Plant battles, Neath's Mysteries card, Starveling Cats and boxed cats.

No suppers, no second chances gain and no need to cure my menaces!



Skinnyman

Posts: 2149



11/8/2016 I am quite aware of the work required to implement to other platforms, but did you really have to remove it from iOS? I wasn't able to pay my EF subscription via iOS app, but I was patiently waiting for it to arrive on mobile/Android.



Why implement a 12 month payment of 55$ for web and Android when you can just remove it from iOS and leave the "cheaper" 12 x 7$ option?



--

ESs items and quality requirements sheet. Please check if there are errors or if something is missing

Achievement list if you're feeling bored!

I am accepting Plant battles, Neath's Mysteries card, Starveling Cats and boxed cats.

No suppers, no second chances gain and no need to cure my menaces!



genesis

Posts: 929



11/8/2016 Guys, come on. It's a commercial company. "Leeching"?!?



Things being left unfinished is a valid complaint. Poor communication (inlcuding changing the expected pricing model without explanation) is a valid complaint. But criticising a business for prioritising paying customers?!



--

http://fallenlondon.com/Profile/mikey_thinkin



Keeping track of incomplete content and loose ends in Fallen London



Skinnyman

Posts: 2149



11/8/2016 genesis wrote:

Guys, come on. It's a commercial company. "Leeching"?!?



Things being left unfinished is a valid complaint. Poor communication (inlcuding changing the expected pricing model without explanation) is a valid complaint. But criticising a business for prioritising paying customers?!

Probably, but let's put it this way:

The option for bigger EF packages was promised and, let's face it, only the hard-core player would have bought bigger packages. I doubt many people would had rushed to 3+ EF with out being certain they'll enjoy the game. This means that FBG's profit would have been lower from the player base which always renew their EF.



Another fact was this festival which non-PoSI probably weren't able to view it as a festival; more like a freebie possibility. As I'm a hoarder I would have enjoyed to get all companions, but I wasn't able to get two more confessions! Solution for both cases: pay Fate.

The Zee festival was harsh, but only due to RNG factor. Even so, I'm guessing that most people were able to get everything from it. I managed to get everything from it in about 10-12 days and I even returned to the island to increase Stormy-Eyed only for RP! The number of AP invested in the Zee festival was way smaller than this and after every failure the solution was to pile up a few more AP and try again!



--

ESs items and quality requirements sheet. Please check if there are errors or if something is missing

Achievement list if you're feeling bored!

I am accepting Plant battles, Neath's Mysteries card, Starveling Cats and boxed cats.

No suppers, no second chances gain and no need to cure my menaces!



John Moose

Posts: 276



11/8/2016 I'd like to point out that by NOT having the option to pay for a long membership in advance, FL might be throwing money away - if the way people purchase and use gym memberships, for example, can be used as an analogue. I don't know FBG's reasons for this decision, but they generally haven't been "this way we'll pump more money out of our players." "Leeching" isn't a word I'd use for a company no longer giving a discount.



I don't think the restaurant comparison is very fair either, unless I misunderstood something and people who bought a longer subscription are now not getting the months they already paid for, or somesuch.



Catherine Raymond

Posts: 2608



11/8/2016 Personally, I like being able to start a subscription for $7 and then cancel it if my personal economics change abruptly. Of course, everyone's mileage varies.



--

Cathy Raymond

http://fallenlondon.com/Profile/cathyr19355



Catherine Raymond aka Mrs. Rykar Malkus http://fallenlondon.com/Profile/Catherine%20Raymond (Gone NORTH)



Skinnyman

Posts: 2149



11/8/2016 Catherine Raymond wrote:

Personally, I like being able to start a subscription for $7 and then cancel it if my personal economics change abruptly. Of course, everyone's mileage varies.

I couldn't say it better, Cath!

I intend to stay here a lot, enjoy every bit of content and this festival's possibility to grab 3 ES at a discount was great! Maxed out my budget with them, but, in the long run, I'll be able to get another ES from it.

But why promise something in a certain context and, after a few months, announce you'll implement the opposite in less than a week? At least wrap things in a lovely package.



--

ESs items and quality requirements sheet. Please check if there are errors or if something is missing

Achievement list if you're feeling bored!

I am accepting Plant battles, Neath's Mysteries card, Starveling Cats and boxed cats.

No suppers, no second chances gain and no need to cure my menaces!



genesis

Posts: 929



11/8/2016 Skinnyman wrote:



But why promise something in a certain context and, after a few months, announce you'll implement the opposite in less than a week? At least wrap things in a lovely package.



For better or for worse, FBG have made a number of statements in the past in the spirit of casual communication with their players on the boards. Some of these have not panned out. From memory, there was much talk several years ago about FBG having more public consultations on proposed features. I think they did one (on Journals) and maybe one other but then that initiative stopped. There was also some secret feature mentioned by Hannah last summer in the (then) Parabola forum which, to my knowledged, never materialised. Et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. When this happens forum-goers have cry foul.



Do we have reason to be upset/frustrated? Sure. Could FBG have handled it better? Probably. Are there factors we are not privy to? Almost certainly.



The end result, though, is that FBG have curtailed their communication even more. This is my speculation and I might be completely off-base. But I think all the complaining has made FBG less communicative because they can no longer afford being open and casual with their player base. Any announcement is now just that now - any official announcement, that goes through company pipelines, approvals, QA etc.



So to answer your question, the "promise" (such as it was) was a forum communication by a member of the company who has now left, who probably did not "log" the "promise" in some sort of binding database of promises, over half a year ago.



--

http://fallenlondon.com/Profile/mikey_thinkin



Keeping track of incomplete content and loose ends in Fallen London



Flyte

Administrator

Posts: 672



11/8/2016 I'm happy to say a bit about our thinking, here.



First of all, the main benefit of renewing subscriptions to us is that they make our revenue more predictable. The games industry is quite a volatile environment, because by and large you work on a game for two years without having any real idea how much money it's going to make, or whether it will cover the cost of creating it. Even long established and prudently managed companies can run into serious difficulties if two of their games do less well than expected in a row.



Renewing subscriptions really help with this – we can estimate how much we're going to earn from them six months from now, and be in the right ballpark. That makes it much easier for us to plan responsibly, and make sure we're still able to make games five years from now (and, with luck, don't have to lay anyone off to make that happen). This predictability is also the reason we've been able to justify monthly EF stories, which can be logistically tricky at times.



Supporting two different models also imposes significant maintenance costs on us, and the iOS model has been less popular than we expected – it currently accounts for less than 10% of subscriptions. I don't think this is the right thread to talk about content plans, but I can say that establishing closer parity between the app and web version will increase the pace at which we can do technical work in future.



Flyte

Administrator

Posts: 672



11/8/2016 lady ciel wrote:

A way to change card details without having to wait for our current subscription to end would be good, if it is possible. I agree – I'd like to make it a bit easier and more intuitive to manage web subscriptions than it currently is, although I can't say when exactly to expect that at present.



Robin Alexander wrote:

If you go into a restaurant and are promised steak from the chef at £10, then the waiter comes out and tells you that you're now getting lamb at £20, you'd be pretty miffed, right? You just had your order changed and were charged extra for the trouble. Wouldn't a more accurate analogy would be this? You go into a restaurant and get the steak you ordered at the price advertised; the waiter then mentions that they're changing the menu, and you won't be able to get the same dish at the same price the next day.



If you're still not enthusiastic about these changes you can, by the way, purchase a 12-month subscription on iOS right now – naturally, we'll honour it in full. The equivalent of buying a lot of steaks and freezing them, I guess? Although I think it will be more appetising with Exceptional Friendship than restaurant food. (Delicious friends.)



Estelle Knoht

Posts: 1751



11/8/2016 When it comes to money matters, perhaps it'd be best to put this heads up on all of your social channel? Or, more importantly, an announcement on the App itself. (I just scampered off to the App to check.)

edited by Estelle Knoht on 11/8/2016



--

Estelle Knoht, a juvenile, unreliable and respectable lady.

I currently do not accept any catbox, cider, suppers, calling cards or proteges.

0 link



Optimatum

Posts: 3739



11/9/2016 Flyte wrote:

If you're still not enthusiastic about these changes you can, by the way, purchase a 12-month subscription on iOS right now – naturally, we'll honour it in full. The equivalent of buying a lot of steaks and freezing them, I guess? Although I think it will be more appetising with Exceptional Friendship than restaurant food. (Delicious friends.)



I currently have one of the longer subscriptions which is due to expire shortly. Is there any way for me to purchase another long-term subscription anyways? As far as I can tell, I can't purchase another through the app until the current one runs out, and it won't expire until after the changes.



--

Optimatum, a ruthless and merciful gentleman. No plant battles, Affluent Photographer requests, or healing offers; all other social actions welcome.



Want a sip of Cider? Just say hi!



PM me for information enigmatic or Fated. Though the forum please, not FL itself.

0 link



Absintheuse

Posts: 348



11/9/2016 Optimatum wrote:

I currently have one of the longer subscriptions which is due to expire shortly. Is there any way for me to purchase another long-term subscription anyways? As far as I can tell, I can't purchase another through the app until the current one runs out, and it won't expire until after the changes.

It is possible to have an active subscription and buy any other subscription you'd like on top of that. You can do this from within the app.