Judge Judy type TV Show genre Reality

Normally when viewers turn on Judge Judy, they can expect a defendant losing a case in less than a minute or the sitting-on-the-edge-of-your-seat drama of a dog choosing its rightful owner. Imagine their surprise when they flipped on CBS in the middle of the afternoon to find none other than comedian and Jennifer Lawrence BFF, Amy Schumer.

Naturally, people were shook and Twitter had a field day.

Turns out, Amy and her sister are huge Judge Judy fans, with Schumer taking to Instagram to comment on her surprise appearance. “Hell yeah! You know I was in the audience on #judgejudy,” she wrote. “My sister and I sat in on the cases for the day because we love her!!!!!”

We shouldn’t be too surprised though, because Schumer actually released a video on Instagram this past May of herself on the set of the courtroom reality show, where “Her Funnyness” goofed around with Petri Hawkins-Byrd, the bailiff on the show.