Finding success as a new massively multiplayer online game in a crowded market is no small task. The genre has suffered from over-saturation for years and many companies have tried and failed to launch a new breakout success. Toppling World of Warcraft isn’t even the goal usually, it’s just about scratching out enough real estate to survive. Games like The Elder Scrolls Online and Final Fantasy XIV have done it, but not many others. Amazon Games hopes to add New World to the small list of truly successful big-budget MMO gambles.

Loading

New World Screens 15 IMAGES

“ Amazon Games Studio cited Dark Souls as heavy inspiration and it shows.

Loading

New World Concept Art Gallery 8 IMAGES

“ It was obvious to me that New World is built around PvP at its core.

Loading

“ Notably, the economy in New World will be entirely player-driven. There are zero merchants in the game.

IGN's Top 25 Modern PC Games 26 IMAGES

“ I truly loved the War battle I tried and it was by far the highlight of my preview.

Best Games of 2019 53 IMAGES

Unlike many of the popular shared-world shooters like Destiny and online action RPGs like Monster Hunter coming out lately, New World is a real, bonafide MMORPG . Servers are large holding over 1,000 players concurrently and it’s got a robust progression system, persistent world, and large-scale conflicts for territory and power. It’s much more than a match-based online game.In New World you take on the role of an intrepid adventurer that lands on the shores of a strange, foreign land known as Aeternum. This new continent is overflowing with a magical substance called Azoth, which has the potential of unleashing immense power in anything it contacts. Sometimes that manifests as good energy, other times evil. A twisted force known as The Corruption begins to take hold of the Azoth and starts to spread across Aeternum, thrusting you and every other player into the heart of the conflict.My preview session was held at Amazon Game Studios’ Irvine, CA office. I was joined by a handful of other journalists from around the world to try out the MMO ahead of its beta period and get a taste for both the new player experience and the end-game content.Predictably, my adventure in New World started at the character creator. Admittedly, it felt a bit barren. There weren’t a lot of hair options and most of the preset faces had a very “samey” vibe to them. Overall it felt lacking compared to its contemporaries and I was hoping to spend a little while tweaking things but ran out of stuff to alter very quickly. And since everyone plays as a human, it was extremely easy to get the various hunks of meat running around confused at first glance. Luckily the in-game text and proximity-based voice chat worked well to help tell people apart.The first several hours of New World were about as predictable and cookie-cutter as PvE content can get in an MMO. I’d talk to a quest giver with a flashing icon above their head, skim over quest text full of needless exposition and fluff, then run over to the quest location that was usually a solid few minutes away even when jogging at full speed. Every quest I did involved basic checklists like talk to this new person, kill these enemies, collect these thing-a-ma-bobs, and so on. Afterward, I had to run all the way back to turn in the quest, collect my reward, and grab the next quest which was often back at the previous spot or even further away -- without mounts. Rinse and repeat.As far as I could tell the main story exists entirely in optional lore pages scattered around the world, other than that it seemed to be a bunch of fetch quests to grind out levels. From what I was told it sounds like most PvE content is free-form open-world bosses and a few large “points of interest” scattered about, but there won’t be any actual dungeons or raids at launch at this time. Overall, I fear the result could be relentlessly tedious travel across a mostly empty world. PvE felt lifeless, uninspired, and unoriginal.Every weapon has actual weight and hit-detection based on its physical movement in space. So even if you walk up to an enemy and swing your sword it’s not going to do anything unless the swing actually hits the other character itself. This is a far cry from most any other major MMO on the market. Even action-heavy MMOs like TERA or Black Desert Online are still based on tab-targeting as the underlying foundation, but that’s not the case here. Even projectiles like arrows move through the world in real time meaning they can be dodged if you’re quick enough or behind cover.It’s a thrilling rendition of typical MMO combat. Rather than memorizing the correct ability rotation, I had to recognize enemy attack patterns. Some enemies would lunge for a heavy attack then follow-up with a quick swipe while others would try to block and counter attack. Wolves were ferocious and quick to lunge long distances while other infected enemies would spit globs of toxic goo at me from afar. Blocking, dodging, and understanding when to go for a heavy attack versus a light attack is all crucial.New World also does not have a class system at all. Instead, you level up your base attributes through amassing XP from completing quests and fighting enemies and then also level up each of your Weapon Mastery trees alongside your base level. Your combat style is determined by a combination of the two. The Weapons Mastery trees determine your powers and abilities, such as a sweeping sword strike or shield bash, whereas attributes determine your stats.Eventually you’ll have a total of three quick-swap weapon slots for a variety of situations. For example, if you plan on using a bow and arrow primarily, with a throwable hand-axe for your secondary slot and maybe a sword and shield as your third slot when things get dicey, you’ll probably focus a lot of your attribute points on Dexterity over Intelligence and Strength. It’s a good, flexible system that was fun to explore. Each weapon type is wildly different and being able to equip multiple weapon sets at once felt a bit like on-the-fly multiclassing. I didn’t get to see what it’s like over the course of an entire game though.All of Aeternum is split into territories, each of which can be owned and controlled by a Company, the New World equivalent of a guild. While controlling a territory, which is comprised of several settlements or villages, the head of that Company can delegate down leadership positions. The leader is appointed as the governor and gets to set things like the tax rate on players that own land and homes in that territory, as well as decide on community projects for upgrades such as new defenses or new shops.Notably, the entire economy in New World will be entirely player-driven. There are zero merchants in the game that sell or buy items from you. Instead, players will control all of the resource gathering, crafting, selling, buying, and so-forth. It’s a novel approach that should be interesting to observe over the long term.All of this builds up towards Company combat. Since power is derived from land ownership, territory struggles are the heart of New World’s end-game system. During a War the attacking and defending sides hit the battlefield to decide which Company will retain or gain control of the territory. The attackers must capture control points along the outside of the walls, then breach one of the gates, and finally take the central control point inside the keep. All the defenders must do is hold out until the time limit is reached. It’s a good, balanced format that rewards cooperation and tactical thinking. Rushing blindly will not succeed for the attacking team.During my preview event, I got to take part in a single War battle as a defender. Seeing dozens of enemies rushing towards our keep, lobbing arrows, bullets, fireballs, and more at us was both epic and intense. It really did make me feel like I was taking part in a climactic battle from a fantasy film such as The Lord of the Rings and I didn’t even have months of guild politics and baggage leading up to that moment. I can only imagine the tension players will feel when waging War against actual rival guilds.Apparently there is a PvE alternative to War referred to as Invasions that take place at keeps with a similar large-scale format against the Corrupted NPC enemies, but none of that was available for testing during my preview. It’s hard to say whether or not it will have the same end-game appeal as the addictive War skirmishes.In a lot of ways the game that I played a preview build of at the Amazon Game Studios offices recently is no longer the game Amazon originally set out to make. Now, you have to opt-in to PvP when you’re out and about in the main open-world map. War battles are capped at 50 vs. 50 and happen only at predetermined scheduled times. Every castle has the exact same layout, meaning territory leaders can only choose minor town projects to focus on, such as where to place the next trebuchet, but they don’t have actual control over how to build out the keep itself.Arguably these changes lead to a more streamlined, balanced, and accessible game, but it doesn’t really feel like the game as a whole was founded on these ideals originally.As it stands, New World feels like it’s struggling to find its identity. As a response to alpha concerns from fans, Amazon walked back many of its PvP-centric ideas to accommodate a wider range of players, but the end-game still seems to revolve around faction disputes and territory Wars which will inherently be driven by PvP conflict. But ultimately since the path to reach this PvP-focused end-game is a one-way road littered with monotonous PvE content, I’m not sure how many people will stick it out. Granted, I only got to try the game out in two relatively quick spurts equaling less than six hours total, but when you combine that with the interviews and presentations packed into that same day, I feel like I’ve got a well-rounded idea of what this game aims to be, and more importantly, what this game actually is.If the PvP side of things can live up to its promises it may convert me into a believer purely on the depth and intensity of its combat and inter-faction disputes alone. But until I see more creativity from the PvE side of things or a clearer picture of what the path to end-game actually looks like, I’m not sure it can hold my interest long enough to get there.

David Jagneaux is a freelance writer for IGN. Talk RPGs with him on Twitter at @David_Jagneaux.