Skip to comments.

Adie's Syndrome: A Possible Explanation for Hillary Clinton's Cough

J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry ^ | March, 1998 | J Kimber

Posted on by nikos1121

I'm not trying to construct a crazy hypothetical, but I can't examine Hillary Clinton, so here's one possible explanation for her cough. Holmes-Adie Syndrome. It also falls in line with the neurologist who apparently shines a flash light for her, when she's walking. I contend that the problems Hillary is having might be from her inability to see when she is in bright light, in addition to a neurological problem affecting her physical mobility--two of the features seen in Adie's Syndrome.

SIGNS AND SYMPTOMS OF ADIE SYNDROME

Adie syndrome is a rare neurological disorder that usually affects the pupil of one eye or occasionally both eyes. Usually, the pupil constricts in the presence of bright light, or when focusing on nearby objects. The pupil usually dilates in light that is dim or in darkness, when focusing on far away objects, or when a person becomes excited. In Adie syndrome, these usual reactions to darkness and light do not happen.

In the majority of people with Adie syndrome, the affected pupil is larger than usual all the time and does not constrict very much or at all in response to light stimulation. The person's pupil constricts slowly when focusing on objects close to view. In some people with the syndrome; however, the opposite is true - the pupil stays smaller than usual all the time. Most people with Adie syndrome have poor or absent reflexes as well.

I've looked at several photos of Hillary's Eyes, and the pupils are equal, but you would have to shine a light on each and then look for the response to rule out an Adi pupil.

Pupils appear equal in this photo. Don't know when it was taken.

Here's one of several scientific articles on a condition, commonly called Adie's Syndrome. (See:https://www.google.com/#q=Cough+and+Adie%27s+syndrome for additional). The article presents five cases, that involve a chronic dry cough that is unaffected by treatment. The cough is worsened by public speaking and associated with photophobia. Read the article and the cases presented and judge for yourself.

The Holmes-Adie syndrome consists of unilateral or bilateral tonic pupils with near light dissociation and tendon areflexia. It is associated with autonomic disturbances affecting sudomotor and vasomotor function. Five such patients are reported on who also had a troublesome chronic dry cough, which was of unknown aetiology and was resistant to a range of treatments. The cough may be related to involvement of afferent or efferent pathways in the vagus. Chronic cough may be an accompaniment in the Holmes-Adie syndrome, like other forms of autonomic dysfunction.

The Holmes-Adie syndrome1 2 (tonic pupil, near-light dissociation, and tendon areflexia) has been associated with a range of autonomic disturbance that includes orthostatic hypotension,3 impairment of cardiovascular reflexes,4 5 segmental6 and generalised hypohydrosis (Rosss syndrome),7 carotid gustatory syndrome,8 and chronic diarrhoea.9 Limited histological studies in this condition indicate loss of ganglion cells in the parasympathetic ciliary ganglia10 which correlates with the pupillary abnormalities. Degeneration of the dorsal root ganglia or the fasciculus gracilis and cuneatus may explain the absent tendon reflexes.11 Autonomic dysfunction has been variously ascribed to lesions of both afferent and efferent sympathetic and parasympathetic neurones.

Although Holmes-Adie syndrome is considered to be benign and of unknown aetiology, troublesome symptoms may result from autonomic dysfunction; these include hyperhydrosis, heat intolerance, and syncope. We report a further feature in five patients with Holmes-Adie syndrome in whom there was a persistent dry cough, of unknown aetiology.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The patients are described individually. None had a history of exposure to irritant chemicals or impairment of exercise tolerance. All had bouts of paroxysmal dry coughing during the day, with lesser frequency at night. Cough was not provoked by lying flat. None was taking angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors, and all underwent detailed cardiovascular autonomic function tests with thermoregulatory sweat testing12 (table 1). Pulmonary function testing and other investigations to determine possible causes for their cough are shown in table 2. In all the chest radiograph was normal. Thorax CT was questionably abnormal in patient 4, with peribronchial shadowing in the right upper zone that may have represented localised bronchiectasis, but bronchoscopy was normal. There were no features of gastro-oesophageal reflux and all were treated with H2antagonists with no benefit. In the three who underwent cine-video fluoroscopy, there was no evidence of laryngeal aspiration. In three, capsaicin challenge indicated increased cough sensitivity. Laboratory testing to exclude secondary causes of autonomic dysfunction included glucose, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, serum electrophoresis, autoantibody screen, treponemal serology, and brain MRI, and the results were normal in each case. Where Holmes-Adie syndrome was not previously documented, patients also underwent pupillography and EMG (to show absent or reduced H waves) to confirm further the diagnosis.

CASE REPORTS

Patient 1 was a 39 year old white man, a non-smoker, who had been investigated when aged 21 for anisocoria and a tonic right pupil that was unresponsive to light. When aged 35 he developed hyperhydrosis affecting the right arm and trunk; a right cervical sympathectomy was performed with only minimal improvement. He then developed symptoms of postural hypotension and was bothered by frequent paroxysms of coughing that resulted in syncope on several occasions. There was no history of lung disease.

Examination indicated a dilated right pupil with near-light dissociation. Other cranial nerves were normal. Tendon reflexes were absent bilaterally. Sweating was marked in the right axilla. There were no respiratory system abnormalities. Cardiovascular autonomic testing suggested an afferent baroreceptor lesion. Paroxysmal coughing during head up tilt resulted in a fall in blood pressure from 151/99 to 98/70 mm Hg, inducing presyncope. He was treated with a high salt intake and fludrocortisone to improve orthostatic tolerance. Probanthine (15 mg thrice daily) and clonidine (25 mg thrice daily) were used to reduce hyperhydrosis but were stopped due to a dry mouth. Investigation of cough (table 1) indicated no identifiable aetiology. The cough was refractory to therapeutic trials of inhaled, nasal, and oral steroids, lignocaine spray and nebuliser, local anaesthetic lozenges, and oral H2 antagonists. The patient is currently on proprietary antitussive agents (containing morphine, capsiacin, and ipecachuana).

Patient 2 was a 58 year old white woman, who had stopped smoking 15 years previously. When 51, she noticed inequality of pupils. Two years later she developed asymmetric facial sweating and paroxysmal coughing attacks, particularly while eating and during prolonged talking. She had occasional dyspnoea but no wheezing and on investigation was diagnosed as having late onset asthma. Although bronchodilator treatment improved the dyspnoea it did not prevent coughing. She had been hypertensive and noted that treatment with an angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor exacerbated her cough and the drug was withdrawn. Examination confirmed a left tonic pupil with near light dissociation, hemifacial anhydrosis, and tendon areflexia. Cardiovascular and respiratory examination was unremarkable. Cardiovascular autonomic testing showed minor abnormalities. Investigations for cough indicated mild reversible airway obstruction. Treatment with inhaled bronchodilators and steroids (salbutamol, salmeterol, beclomethasone) produced a partial reduction in coughing. Oral H1 (loratadine) and H2 antagonists (ranitidine) and nasal steroids (fluticasone and beclomethasone drops) produced no further benefit. The patient noted that coughing, especially during public speaking, was markedly reduced after taking lomotil (diphenoxylate hydrochloride and atropine sulphate); inhaled ipratropium bromide (40 μg four times a day) has been initiated with moderate benefit.

Patient 3 was a 59 year old white woman, a non-smoker with a 20 year history of postural dizziness. Previous investigation at the age of 40 had documented bilateral tonic pupils in association with tendon areflexia. Subsequently she developed facial anhydrosis and a chronic dry cough. Examination confirmed small irregular pupils with near light dissociation and tendon areflexia with no other CNS abnormality. Cardiovascular and respiratory systems were unremarkable. Cardiovascular autonomic testing indicated baroreceptor dysfunction (orthostatic hypotension, blocked blood pressure response to Valsalvas manoeuvre, and exaggerated pressor responses). Investigations for cough identified no obvious aetiology. Treatment with proprietary antitussive drugs resulted in some improvement of symptoms.

Patient 4 was a 31 year old woman, a non-smoker of mixed (white-AfroCaribbean) origin. On presentation at the age of 26 she had a 2 year history of posture induced syncope together with paroxysmal throbbing headaches and epistaxis provoked by prolonged recumbency. She had had mild asthma since childhood and used a salbutamol inhaler intermittently. Examination indicated a right tonic pupil with near light dissociation. Tendon reflexes in the lower limbs were reduced. There were no other neurological abnormalities. Cardiovascular and respiratory examination was normal. Cardiovascular autonomic testing confirmed orthostatic hypotension and pressor stimuli raised blood pressure at times to 250/120 mm Hg suggesting impaired baroreceptor afferent activity. Methyldopa (250 mg twice daily) reduced the paroxysmal hypertensive episodes. A prominent symptom was persistent dry coughing that was refractory to increasing bronchodilator treatment and this was investigated further (table 2). Treatment with inhaled and nasal steroids (fluticasone inhaler (200 μg twice daily); fluticasone nasal spray (50 μg/nostril daily)) partially improved her cough. Oral H1 (chlorpheniramine) and H2 antagonists (ranitidine) were of no further benefit. She continued to have an unremitting dry cough.

Patient 5 was a 66 year white woman who was a non-smoker. She had presented 12 years previously with a troublesome dry cough. She had also noticed a unilateral dilated pupil and began having episodic diarrhoea up to 12 times daily. Panendoscopy plus large bowel biopsies failed to identify a cause. She then also noted truncal hyperhydrosis and postural dizziness. She had dry eyes and hypostomia with no history of joint or skin inflammation and no reduction in exercise tolerance. Further serological investigation indicated positive anti-Ro antibodies, suggesting primary Sjögrens syndrome. Examination showed near light dissociation of the right pupil and tendon areflexia. Truncal sweating was prominent bilaterally. There were no other abnormalities. Cardiovascular autonomic function tests indicated no abnormalities and investigation of her cough identified no obvious cause. She had been treated with numerous courses of antibiotics for presumed upper respiratory tract infections and with antirhinitis treatment and cough suppressants containing opiates without effect. Proprietary antitussive agents containing capsaicin are currently being assessed.

DISCUSSION

Chronic cough is a common symptom and may be caused by various stimuli which range from neoplasms, inflammatory lung disease, and postnasal drip to increased cough sensitivity resulting from respiratory tract infections, asthma, gastro-oesophageal reflux, and drugs such as angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors.13Despite extensive investigation, a proportion of patients have no diagnostic reason to explain their cough. Our findings suggest that the Holmes-Adie syndrome may be a disorder associated with a chronic dry cough.

All our patients had typical ocular findings and tendon areflexia indicative of Holmes-Adie syndrome. They also had associated autonomic impairment, either cardiovascular or sudomotor, and this combination presumably reflects the interests of the referral units. All were investigated in detail for autonomic dysfunction and also for a cause for their coughing. Coughing was provoked in each patient by deep breathing or hyperventilation during autonomic testing, suggestive of increased cough reflex sensitivity. This was formally tested in three. All were investigated for asthma. One patient had had mild asthma as a child and another was a probable late onset asthmatic; asthma may cause chronic cough and increased cough sensitivity, but there was no relation between coughing and indices of airflow limitation and furthermore the cough did not respond to effective asthma treatment. Treatment with H2 antagonists for occult gastro-oesophageal reflux, and H1 antagonists and topical steroids for rhinitis, were of no benefit.

Consideration of the cough reflex pathways enables speculation on the mechanism of cough in these patients. Afferent pathways carry stimuli from receptors in the trachea, larynx, and larger bronchi to the dorsal medulla via the vagus nerve. The motor (efferent) reflex arc innervates the muscles of the larynx, diaphragm, and chest wall. Efferent pathways for bronchiolar smooth muscle and mucosal glands are also vagal in origin. In Holmes-Adie syndrome, cardiovascular4 5 14and tendon reflex abnormalities suggest an impairment of the afferent reflex arc. This alone is an unlikely explanation as in animals with neuropathy induced by acrylamide(affecting vagal myelinated afferent fibres), and in diabetic patients with peripheral autonomic neuropathy, the cough response to mechanical stimulation15 and citric acid is diminished.16 Whether impaired afferent activity resulted in a relative increase in vagal efferent traffic cannot be discounted.

An increased sensitivity of airway cough receptors is a possible explanation as cough reflex sensitivity using capsaicin challenge was increased in each of the three patients tested. This may have been due to changes in the local environment of sensory nerves in the airway, particularly bradykinin and prostaglandin production17 as has been noted in cough induced by angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor .13 In the three patients who underwent cine-video fluoroscopic examination of swallowing, there were minor abnormalities of coordination that may have provided an abnormal stimulus for coughing; there was, however, no clear association with swallowing or eating except in patient 2, and in none was there evidence of laryngeal aspiration.

One patient responded to an oral and later an inhaled anticholinergic agent and the mechanism may have been through reduced vagally stimulated (muscarinic) effects on bronchial secretions. In patients with refractory epilepsy fitted with vagal nerve stimulators, a proportion experienced coughing corresponding to the stimulator on period.18 A therapeutic trial of anticholinergic agents, as in patient 2, may help to determine the vagal efferent component to the cough.

There is uncertainty about the CNS component of the cough reflex. In Holmes-Adie syndrome there is no known evidence of a clear central abnormality, and although it cannot be discounted or tested this seems less likely.

Although chronic cough is a common symptom, detailed investigation in each of our patients with Holmes-Adie syndrome showed no obvious aetiology for their cough; in four out of five patients the coughing seemed temporally related to the onset of other autonomic features. In Holmes-Adie syndrome the autonomic features affecting cardiovascular and sudomotor function favour a patchy involvement, with resultant exaggerated activity, such as increased pressor responses in some and compensatory hyperhidrosis in others. Whether a similar process affects the autonomic control of the respiratory tract and involves the pathways involved in the cough reflex in such patients can only be speculated on at this stage. However, in all five patients, chronic cough produced appreciable morbidity. We conclude that these findings indicate yet another troublesome symptom, the mechanism of which needs to be further elucidated, to add to abnormalities of the somatic and autonomic nervous system previously described in the Holmes-Adie syndrome.

References 1.↵ Adie W J (1932) Tonic pupils and absent tendon reflexes. A benign disorder sui generis: its complete and incomplete forms. Brain 55:98113. [FREE Full text] 2.↵ Holmes G (1931) Partial iridoplegia associated with symptoms of other diseases of the nervous system. Trans Opthal Soc UK 51:209. Google Scholar 3.↵ Croll W, Duthie R, MacWilliam J (1935) Postural hypotension: a report of a case. Lancet i:194198. Google Scholar 4.↵ Bacon P, Smith S (1993) Cardiovascular and sweating function in patients with Holmes-Adie syndrome. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 56:10961102. [Abstract/FREE Full text] 5.↵ Johnston R, McLellan D, Love D (1971) Orthostatic hypotension and the Holmes-Adie syndrome: a study of two patients with afferent baroreceptor block. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 34:562570. [Abstract/FREE Full text] 6.↵ Lucy D, Allen M, Van Thompson H (1967) Holmes-Adie syndrome with segmental hypohydrosis. Neurology 17:763769. Google Scholar 7.↵ Ross A (1958) Progressive selective sudomotor degeneration. A case with coexisting Adies syndrome. Neurology 8:809817. Google Scholar 8.↵ Shibaski H, Tomi H (1990) Carotid gustatory syndrome in a patient with Holmes-Adie syndrome. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 53:359. Google Scholar 9.↵ Burns R, Wing L (1980) Adies syndrome (tonic pupil and areflexia). Sweating disturbances and diarrhoeaa new syndrome? Clin Exp Neurol 17:243. Google Scholar 10.↵ Harriman D, Garland H (1968) The pathology of Adies syndrome. Brain 91:401418. [FREE Full text] 11.↵

Smith S (1992) Pupil function tests and disorders. in Autonomic failure, a textbook of clinical disorders of the autonomic system. eds Bannister R, Mathias CJ (Oxford University Press, Oxford), 3rd ed. pp 421441. Google Scholar 12.↵

Mathias CJ, Bannister R (1992) Investigation of autonomic disorders. in Autonomic failure. A textbook of clinical disorders of the autonomic system. eds Bannister R, Mathias CJ (Oxford University Press, Oxford), 3rd ed. pp 255290. Google Scholar 13.↵ Fuller R, Choudry N (1987) Increased cough reflex associated with angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitor cough. BMJ 295:10251026. Google Scholar 14.↵ Hope-Ross M, Buchanan T, Archer D, et al. (1990) Autonomic function in Holmes-Adie syndrome. Eye 4:607612. Google Scholar 15.↵ Hersch M, McCleod J, Sullivan C (1989) Abnormal cough reflex in canine acrylamide neuropathy. Ann Neurol 26:738745. [CrossRef][Medline]Google Scholar 16.↵ Vianna L, Gilbey S, Barnes N, et al. (1988) Cough threshold to citric acid in diabetic patients with and without autonomic neuropathy. Thorax 43:569571. [Abstract/FREE Full text] 17.↵

Fuller R (1995) Cough. in Respiratory medicine. eds Brewis R, Corrin B, Geddes D, et al. (Saunders, London), 2nd ed. pp 238242. Google Scholar 18.↵ Ramsey E, Uthman B, Augustinsson L, et al. (1994) Vagus nerve stimulation for treatment of partial seizures: 2. Safety, side effects and tolerability. Epilepsia 35:627626.



TOPICS:

Culture/Society

Editorial

News/Current Events

Politics/Elections

KEYWORDS:

cough

elections

hillary

hillaryshealth

unfittoserve





To: 3D-JOY; 1217Chic; Abbeville Conservative; Abby4116; acoulterfan; Airwinger; Albion Wilde; ...

The photos I’ve seen of Hillary Clinton’s eyes where you can see the pupils, finds that they are equal, but what happens to them when you shine light on them is a different story. The examiner would need to do this. As I said above, I’m not trying to concoct a crazy theory about her cough. I thought it might be from her medication for hypertension, but the cough now seems to occur when she’s speaking in public. The cases presented above describe patients with similar coughing.



by 2 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: nikos1121

by 3 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: nikos1121

Or it could just be that she is crazy as a loon.



by 4 posted onby llevrok (Lies are born the moment someone thinks the truth is dangerous.)

To: nikos1121

http://media.gettyimages.com/photos/democratic-presidential-nominee-hillary-clinton-speaks-to-reporters-picture-id599532514 http://binaryapi.ap.org/5284d4c81bc54921b279b40059c5d6d8/preview/AP16249788698093.jpg?wm=api&ver=0 Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton holds up a book entitled Stronger Together as she speaks to members of the media on her campaign plane while traveling to Quad Cities International Airport in Moline, Ill., Monday, Sept. 5, 2016.



To: nikos1121

Please; never shine a light into the eye of a money sucking vampire!



To: nikos1121

I had a cough that we discovered was from my BP meds but it was nothing like hers. I doubt we will ever be told/find out what her issues are. Regardless, she is unfit in numerous ways to be POTUS.



by 7 posted onby ozaukeemom (If we continue to divide, they will conquer!)

To: nikos1121

I don’t care what syndrome she has. She has an advanced case of Liberal/Socialist/Megalomaniac/Murderous/Monster-itis. That’s bad enough.



by 8 posted onby shibumi (Dancin in the Dark with Tramps in the Park, I'm the Fleetfoot VooDoo Man)

To: Noob1999



Here's the examination for Adie's pupil. The pair of eyes in the lower photo are equally round, however when light is shined into the left eye as seen in the above photo, instead of constricting, it dilates, which is abnormal.

by 9 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: nikos1121

I’m more likely to believe this scenario than anything else shown. It would be curious what she’s using for cough suppression....has to be the heavy-duty prescription stuff.



To: ozaukeemom

Yes, Lisinopril will cause that, but the cough is episodic, sometimes a few hours after you take your meds. Her cough seems to occur when shes speaking in public. This is not the kind of cough you see from Lisinopril.



by 11 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: pepsionice

In Adie’s nothing will suppress the cough.



by 12 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: nikos1121

She will not die. If elected, she will be managed by her Saudi handler, Huma, throughout her term.



To: pepsionice

We would need a photo of her eyes in very bright light.



by 14 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: nikos1121

In Adies nothing will suppress the cough. A necklace of garlic cloves or a wooden stake through her heart (if she has one)



by 15 posted onby llevrok (Lies are born the moment someone thinks the truth is dangerous.)

To: nikos1121

Having been given some blood pressure medication years ago....after about six weeks...I started to develop a dry mouth cough. And at least once a day...it was an absolutely four-star coughing attack...driving my blood pressure even higher from the cough itself. I’m guessing from her episode....she has to have elevated blood pressure episodes when these coughing attacks occur.



To: pepsionice

The cough from your medication is episodic, and not influenced by anything. You could just sitting there reading, and you start the cough. Her cough occurs when she’s talking.



by 17 posted onby nikos1121 (Here's how I'm going to beat you. I'm going to out work you. That's all there is to it. -Pat Summitt)

To: nikos1121

I am not a medical expert, but I did respond to many thousands of medical calls during my 25 years working as a firefighter. a fairly high percentage of these calls were to people suffering from congestive heart failure. Much of the time the symptoms we observed included swollen feet, ankles and legs along with a cough and horse voice and also having difficulty from any form of physical exertion. Many also had other medical issues related to falls they had taken. I think that the examples of Adie’s Syndrome are very interesting and definitely could fit Hilary’s symptoms. But this condition is less common than CHF whose symptoms and side effects from the medications commonly used in treatment also seem consistent with what we have observed. Of course most people in later stages of CHF use inhalers and oxygen which we have not seen with Hillary... but these may be intentionally not used because of the speculation they would cause.



by 18 posted onby fireman15 (The USA will be toast if the Democrats are able to take the Presidency in 2016)

To: nikos1121





by 19 posted onby Bobalu (The moment Hillary was born, the doctor slapped her with a subpoena)

To: nikos1121

Interesting theory!!!



by 20 posted onby Freedom56v2 (This election is about Nataional Sovereignty, Liberty, and Freedom for future generations)

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

FreeRepublic , LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794

FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson