Colton Underwood gave Cassie Randolph a Neil Lane engagement ring. She thought it was so ugly, she returned it.

The former Bachelor said it's not quite that simple, though.

Sadly, Colton Underwood's days of jumping fences are behind us because the Bachelor decided to pick Cassie Randolph at the end of his season. Since their relationship was hardly solid at the end of everything, Colton and Cassie decided to skip getting engaged like every other Bachelor Nation couple has.

Since they didn't get engaged, ABC was like, "Hard pass" to giving them a free engagement ring, so Jimmy Kimmel had to call in a favor to Neil Lane to get it back to Colton in case he ever proposes to Cassie. However, when Cassie saw the ring, she thought it was so ugly, she just had to return it. Please, hold your laughter for just a second so you can read all the cringey details.

In a teaser for the LadyGang show on E!, Colton said the ring was a double halo square cut ring. If that sounds like a foreign language to you, host Becca Tobin's "Super Bowl ring" description fits it perfectly. Colton, however, got pretty defensive about the ring and insisted he didn't order it, but agreed with another host who said it looked amazing.

This content is imported from YouTube. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.

Then, Colton called Cassie while he was on the show, and Becca asked her about switching it. Cassie laughed and diplomatically responded, "I just have a particular idea in my mind." So, yeah, she's returning that massive design.

Even though Cassie has a ring, that doesn't mean she's engaged just yet. While on Jimmy's show a couple weeks ago, she and Colton said they were in the stage between dating and getting engaged. Riiiiight. Let's just pray they get past their awkward body language soon.

Shannon Barbour News Writer Shannon is a news writer at Cosmopolitan.com, and when she's not obsessing about Cardi B, she's thinking about Justin Bieber and still trying to memorize Beyoncé's Beychella choreography.

This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io