This was our first trip to Key West, and authentic conch fritters were at the top of my list. Let me start this out by saying that I am not a seafood lover. I’ve never liked the taste, but I wanted to step out of...my comfort zone and try new things local to the area. The research I had done on conch fritters stated that you should seek out the establishments that make their own sauce. ✔️- they had it! You could see directly inside the kitchen where they were preparing the food. It was very clean and well kept. The two gentlemen inside were very personable and friendly. I ordered the conch fritters and the WarDog. My husband and SIL got a seafood basket. I explained to the gentleman taking my order that this was my first time eating these and he immediately started giving great recommendations! He gave me the spicy fritters and explained about the dipping sauce and the lime. They have a seating area in the back that seats about 5 people in a bar like setting. We were able to people watch as we waited for our food. It was nice to be able to step out of the hustle and bustle that is Duval St. and have a really good meal. Now for the best part… the food was ready… I hit the warm fritters with a splash of lime juice , then dipped them in the special sauce and… holy moly!!! The heavens parted… I’m pretty sure at one point angels were singing… I got the order of 6 or 8 so that we could all share and try them. I aborted mission. They were gonna have to get their own dang conch fritters. It was like biting into a fluffy hush puppy. And get this: I loved the conch!! It was great!! The fishy taste I was afraid of didn’t exist! I also ate some of the WarDog which is a bacon wrapped hot dog, deep fried with the works piled on there and it was amazing!! But I kept going back to the fritters!! My husband and SIL really enjoyed their seafood baskets as well. I’m sorry that I can not be of more help as to what all care in their baskets, but I was too busy in my own utopia establishing a perimeter that they couldn’t breach to even think about taking one of my fritters. It’s one of those times I wish I had a taser. I’m just kidding!(no I’m not 😉) Anyway, if you want to try really good, handmade , authentic conch fritters, this is definitely the place. This is the meal that all other meals from here on out will always be compared to. I seriously wish I had some right now!! I don’t know what was in that batter or secret sauce, but it’s the stuff dreams are made of.