Claudia Tenney's red-meat rhetoric may play well with a national GOP base that's loyal to President Donald Trump. But some Republicans are nervous that she's boxing herself into a posture that won't play well in her center-right district. | Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call Tenney’s red-meat rhetoric alarms House Republicans The congresswoman suggested most mass shooters are Democrats and called for a special prosecutor to investigate Hillary Clinton.

Rep. Claudia Tenney learned last week that she’d been outraised by her Democratic opponent for the third quarter in a row, a sign that her hold on a moderate upstate New York district is in peril.

But if GOP leaders thought that would be a five-alarm reminder for the vulnerable freshman to pursue a moderate path to reelection, they were mistaken. Days later, Tenney called for the jailing of Hillary Clinton and James Comey — embracing a hard-line stance championed by President Donald Trump but shunned by most GOP leaders and virtually all moderates.


“Lock them up!” a Tenney campaign email blared on Tuesday, touting her call for a special counsel to investigate the Democrat presidential nominee and former FBI director.

Tenney's red-meat rhetoric may play well with a national GOP base that's loyal to Trump. But some Republicans are nervous that she's boxing herself into a posture that won't play well in her center-right district.

Tenney is one of the most vulnerable Republicans in the House. Her once reliable GOP district is now considered a toss-up by political handicappers. But unlike other colleagues in swing districts who have distanced themselves from President Donald Trump and shunned partisan rhetoric, Tenney is leaning into both.

POLITICO Playbook newsletter Sign up today to receive the #1-rated newsletter in politics Email Sign Up By signing up you agree to receive email newsletters or alerts from POLITICO. You can unsubscribe at any time. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

In an interview, Tenney shrugged off the complaints from jittery Republicans, saying she has a better feel for the district than anyone and that she's simply calling issues like she sees them — not concertedly embracing Trump.

“I praise him when I think he’s got the right thing and I don’t support him when he’s done the wrong thing,” she said, later adding: “I think if anyone can figure out a way to win. … I’m very competitive. I have a good feel. I’m in my district.”

But behind the scenes, GOP operatives think Tenney is damaging her reelection chances.

"If she would stop talking, she’d probably win,” one senior Republican operative said. “But every week she says something controversial or stupid. These are self-inflected wounds.”

Tenney has developed a bombastic reputation on Capitol Hill, adopting Trump-like rhetoric to defend scandal-plagued administration officials or blast the media for “fake news.” She accused the “deep state,” for example, of setting up Housing and Urban Development Secretary Ben Carson with his now infamous $31,000 furniture purchase, though Carson himself said his wife made the order. Jimmy Kimmel poked fun at her for those remarks.

After the school shooting spree in Parkland, Florida, Tenney was widely criticized when she said that “it’s interesting that so many of these people that commit the mass murders end up being Democrats, but the media doesn't talk about that either.” And this week, Tenney joined some of the most conservative members of the House to accuse top Justice Department and FBI officials of malfeasance.

“These elitists all held positions of higher authority when they appear to have broken the law … Why are these Obama administration cronies getting away with it?” her campaign email read.

That rhetoric is unusual for a swing-district Republican; typically they prefer to talk about tax cuts and other pocketbook issues. Among those alarmed that Tenney is about to hand the district to Democrats is her GOP predecessor, former Rep. Richard Hanna.

“Her unmitigated support of all things Trump is more a function of her own personal ambition and general extremism on all subjects,” said Hanna, a staunch Trump critic who is backing Tenney’s Democratic opponent, Anthony Brindisi. “Claudia is a wasted seat.”

Tenney waived off criticism of her campaign strategy. Establishment Republicans, she said, backed her primary opponents in a three-way race in 2016 when “I had $200,000 and my opponents had $3 million.”

“I still won by 10 points,” she said, arguing that she runs a “hard campaign at the grass roots… and that’s how I’ve been able to win.”

Tenney also dismissed the notion that her race in a rural central New York district is a “toss-up,” or that her messages are out of sync with her constituents. She noted that her district voted for Trump by 15 points in 2016. Since then, the president has become even more popular with her constituents, she contended.

“He polls 20 points higher now than he polled when he was elected,” Tenney said, adding: “My district may not like his personality but they like getting a tax cut. … They like some of the things that are happening. … They like a little bit of a rollback in regulations.”

In a statement for this story, Tenney's campaign said, “What the media and the D.C. elite see as vulnerabilities the people of upstate New York see as Claudia being a real person willing to speak her mind and fight for them."

And Tenney has her defenders, including fellow GOP Rep. Chris Collins.

“Upstate New York likes Trump, so for a member to support Trump and be from upstate is probably good politics,” he said. "[A]ll politics is local and we all make our own decisions.”

One senior Republican also suggested perhaps Tenney knew something her critics don't. While party leaders would prefer she talk about policy and avoid controversial remarks, the lawmaker said perhaps she was right that embracing Trump is the best way to win.

While Tenney’s central New York district has moved right in recent years, constituents have a history of voting across party lines. In 2012, for example, the district went for Mitt Romey by less than 1 percentage point but also embraced Democratic Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand.

Democrats think they can benefit from what they see as her blunders.

“Congresswoman Tenney has spent her short time in Congress demonstrating just how unfit she is to hold elected office,” said Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee spokesman Evan Lukaske. “In addition to her divisive and extreme rhetoric, Tenney has blindly supported an agenda that has increased healthcare premiums and hiked taxes for many of her constituents.”

Enter Brindisi, a Democratic state assemblyman who is running as a moderate. According to a DCCC commissioned poll in early March, he leads Tenney by 6 points even though the district prefers a Republican.

Brindisi has also outraised Tenney for the past two quarters, and his war chest is bigger.

Tenney's embrace of the polarizing battle by Trump allies against top Justice Department officials might be an attempt to tap more deeply into a broader, pro-Trump donor network, one GOP operative suggested.

But Tenney swatted that idea down, saying her stances have nothing to do with Trump or campaign strategy.

"I’m not running ‘a strategy,’" she said. "I won because I’m who I am."



CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story misstated Ben Carson’s position.