New York Giants wide receiver Victor Cruz recently proposed to his longtime girlfriend Elaina Watley. Now, there’s video of Cruz’s proposal, which came in the middle of a prayer circle at a baby dedication ceremony for the couple’s young daughter. Cruz, showing nerves that are never present on the football field, is heartfelt and sweet with his proposal, which seemed to catch Watley off-guard. Disappointingly, the Giants’ showman doesn’t break into a celebratory salsa dance after she says “yes.”

Elaina showed off her new ring, as well as a funky bracelet, on Instagram.

http://instagram.com/p/qw2334JMUW

Cruz has known Watley since 2003, when he was still a New Jersey high-schooler.

http://instagram.com/p/qkB1tvpMRa/

Their daughter, Kennedy, was born weeks before the Giants were the surprise winners of the 2012 Super Bowl.

http://instagram.com/p/p3ZMvWpMWw