Bill was going to kill Dipper

I believe that in the scene in the finale when Bill was going kill one of the twins “just for the heck of it” he was going to choose Dipper.

He flips between Dipper and Mabel’s symbols while counting down “eenie meenie miney…”

We know he was about to say “you” before Stan interrupted him. Now, who else did he say “eenie meenie miney…” to?

That’s right, Dipper. And who else has said the exact same phrase to choose Dipper?



Plus, the last symbol Bill flashed in his eye was Mabel’s.You get the feeling that he was just about to flash the pine tree symbol right before snapping his fingers and saying