jojoandleo

Elder







Posts: 15,568

Likes: 20,691

Elder Adnan Syed was married?! Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by jojoandleo on Serial really wasn't that long, so I am not totally shocked this didn't come up. She talked so much about cell towers research because that WAS the state's case. Jay's story and cell phone towers. That's it. I am a little shocked that when she talked about people who knew Adnan this didn't come up, but she focused on people who knew him at the time of the murder. She probably just didn't think it was THAT relevant. Or maybe she didn't know. Who knows. It doesn't really change the narrative for me. I still have no idea if the dude did it. I do know there was not enough evidence to convict.

Faevantastic

Elder







Posts: 10,900

Likes: 11,969

Elder Adnan Syed was married?! Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by Faevantastic on wambam

PatBenatar



The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.



Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.



Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night. The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night.

wambam

Moderator







Making America Emo Again

Posts: 37,165

Likes: 56,613

Moderator Adnan Syed was married?! Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by wambam on Faevantastic said: wambam

PatBenatar



The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.



Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.



Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night. The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night.



2. But Nisha also said that they were calling from the video store, which Jay didn't start working at until much later.



3. I don't remember enough about this to comment.

1. With the lividity - I think that there are new color photographs based on Susan's latest blog post. I just listened to this episode and they said they had talked to multiple doctors who all said the same thing. I hope that they share those other interviews.2. But Nisha also said that they were calling from the video store, which Jay didn't start working at until much later.3. I don't remember enough about this to comment.

SKP82

Elder









Likes: 7,620 Posts: 10,913Likes: 7,620

Elder Adnan Syed was married?! via Tapatalk wambam likes this Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by SKP82 on

Faevantastic said: wambam

PatBenatar



The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.



Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.



Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night. The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night.



The guy in SD covers all of this. I don't think any of this discredits Undisclosed. The guy in SD covers all of this. I don't think any of this discredits Undisclosed.

Faevantastic

Elder







Posts: 10,900

Likes: 11,969

Elder Adnan Syed was married?! Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by Faevantastic on wambam said: Faevantastic said: wambam

PatBenatar



The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.



Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.



Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night. The lividity conclusion by the doctor is questionable based on the info and photographs Colin Miller provided to the dr.Then, in Nisha's original police interview notes - she specifically mentioned that the Nisha call happened a day or two after Adnan got his cell phone, which lines up with Jan 13. Nisha also mentioned that her school let out at 2;15 and she was home by 2:45pm. Yet, Unclisclosed fails to mention those things at all. In fact, Susan said the opposite. She said that Nisha couldnt have been home at that time.Also on not-her-real-name-Cathy interview notes, she mentioned that they talked about Stephanie's birthday. They didn't mention this either because it doesn't really support undisclosed's claim that the visit at cathy's apt happened on a diff night.



2. But Nisha also said that they were calling from the video store, which Jay didn't start working at until much later.



3. I don't remember enough about this to comment.

1. With the lividity - I think that there are new color photographs based on Susan's latest blog post. I just listened to this episode and they said they had talked to multiple doctors who all said the same thing. I hope that they share those other interviews.2. But Nisha also said that they were calling from the video store, which Jay didn't start working at until much later.3. I don't remember enough about this to comment.



Here's the reddit thread: #2 - the thory is maybe A & J were trying to create an alibi. Nisha mentions a store but doesn't specifically say "video" store until the trial. I just find it fishy that undisclosed didnt mention the day or two statement at all.Here's the reddit thread: www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/3m2z82/police_interview_with_nisha/?

wambam

Moderator







Making America Emo Again

Posts: 37,165

Likes: 56,613

Moderator Adnan Syed was married?! SKP82 likes this Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by wambam on Faevantastic said: wambam said:



2. But Nisha also said that they were calling from the video store, which Jay didn't start working at until much later.



3. I don't remember enough about this to comment.

1. With the lividity - I think that there are new color photographs based on Susan's latest blog post. I just listened to this episode and they said they had talked to multiple doctors who all said the same thing. I hope that they share those other interviews.2. But Nisha also said that they were calling from the video store, which Jay didn't start working at until much later.3. I don't remember enough about this to comment.



Here's the reddit thread: #2 - the thory is maybe A & J were trying to create an alibi. Nisha mentions a store but doesn't specifically say "video" store until the trial. I just find it fishy that undisclosed didnt mention the day or two statement at all.Here's the reddit thread: www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/3m2z82/police_interview_with_nisha/?



I still maintain the stance though that the state's theory of the case as presented at trial is absolutely, 100%, not possible. And Jay's story cannot be corroborated by the cell phone evidence because the cell phone evidence is completely bunk.

Thanks.I still maintain the stance though that the state's theory of the case as presented at trial is absolutely, 100%, not possible. And Jay's story cannot be corroborated by the cell phone evidence because the cell phone evidence is completely bunk.

SKP82

Elder









Likes: 7,620 Posts: 10,913Likes: 7,620

Elder Adnan Syed was married?! via Tapatalk Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by SKP82 on

wambam said: Faevantastic said:



Here's the reddit thread: #2 - the thory is maybe A & J were trying to create an alibi. Nisha mentions a store but doesn't specifically say "video" store until the trial. I just find it fishy that undisclosed didnt mention the day or two statement at all.Here's the reddit thread: www.reddit.com/r/serialpodcast/comments/3m2z82/police_interview_with_nisha/?



I still maintain the stance though that the state's theory of the case as presented at trial is absolutely, 100%, not possible. And Jay's story cannot be corroborated by the cell phone evidence because the cell phone evidence is completely bunk.

Thanks.I still maintain the stance though that the state's theory of the case as presented at trial is absolutely, 100%, not possible. And Jay's story cannot be corroborated by the cell phone evidence because the cell phone evidence is completely bunk.



SD has an episode where he walks though Jay's day and corroborates everything with the cell phone evidence. He creates a story where Jay could have done it on his own and then says based on this, Jay should be convicted. He then says he doesn't think that's what happened, but it is exactly the same thing the prosecution did to convict Adnan.



I knew the cell phone evidence was bunk, but when he put it into that perspective, it was even more eye opening. SD has an episode where he walks though Jay's day and corroborates everything with the cell phone evidence. He creates a story where Jay could have done it on his own and then says based on this, Jay should be convicted. He then says he doesn't think that's what happened, but it is exactly the same thing the prosecution did to convict Adnan.I knew the cell phone evidence was bunk, but when he put it into that perspective, it was even more eye opening.