The Tally police department is convinced they have the evidence to arrest four people in a murder conspiracy. But prosecutors only charge three. Why?



Next episode will be a special bonus interview episode with host Matthew Shaer. Can't wait till next week? It’s available now exclusively to Wondery+ subscribers. Go to wondery.com/plus



“Where the Enemy Sleeps” is performed by Scott Mackay featuring Lucette.









Support us by supporting our sponsors!



Simplisafe - Protect your home and family today and get get shipping on your order at simplisafe.com/overmy



Boll & Branch - Get $50 off your first set of sheets at bollandbranch.com using promo code OVERMY



Robinhood - Get a free stock when you sign up today at overmy.robinhood.com



ShipStation - Get a 30-day free trial plus a free bonus month when you enter the code OVERMY at shipstation.com



Better Help - Get online affordable counseling and 10% off your first month at betterhelp.com/overmy



Zip Recruiter - Try Zip Recruiter for free and learn how to hire smarter at ziprecruiter.com/overmy