“There’s an infinite number of realities, Morty, and in a few dozens of those I got lucky and turned everything back to normal.”

Thus spake Rick Sanchez in Adult Swim’s animated series Rick & Morty—but have the show’s avid fans considered the full implications of this bold infinitude?

On Thursday, Reddit user nijikai shared a video of one fan’s attempt to use this concept to predict what will happen in the show’s next season (after a long hiatus, of course, that fans are struggling to endure).

“This concept of an infinite multiverse is key to Rick and Morty‘s themes and plots,” redditor dillionmcrich explains in his video. “But it’s also the key to how the show’s creators, Roiland and Harmon, tricked their entire fanbase into thinking that everyone’s favorite Gromflomite was dead.”

Warning: The video below includes spoilers through the end of season 2, but as redditors noted in the comments on nijikai’s post, it might be entertaining even (or especially?) if you’ve never seen the show:

But what do the creators think of this elaborate theory?

So far, Harmon and Roiland haven’t weighed in on the discussion bubbling in Reddit’s Videos community—unless their most recent social media posts are in some kind of secret code:

I wanna beeee-eee a dolphin — Justin Roiland (@JustinRoiland) April 29, 2016

For now, dillionmcrich seems happy that his theory has struck a chord with Rick & Morty‘s fanbase:

And this fan theory may be just the first of many more videos that deconstruct the Harmon-Roiland multiverse: