"This looks like everything on my Pinterest board. When I saw this hanging there, I was like, that is totally the dress. It's the dress I've been dreaming about wearing—and it feels so good to finally put something on! It feels real now." —Katie

"It's exactly what I pictured when you were saying what you wanted." —Mom

"I love the buttons going down the back. That's one of my favorite things about wedding dresses." —Scheana

"It's perfect. It's like, boho chic-y couture-y." —Kristin

"I like how it has that little hug-the-butt situation happening. My butt is my best asset. Pun intended." —Katie

"Yeah, you gotta highlight that J.Lo bod." —Stassi

Dress 2: Pnina Tornai for Kleinfeld (style #4325), $8,900

"Oh my god, oh my god, you're The Princess Bride. You're The Princess Bride. She's The Princess Bride." —Kristin

"That is the prettiest thing I have ever. Seen." —Stassi

"I really like this neckline, and how the boning and structure sucks me in." —Katie

"You look amazing. And you ate pasta last night. How is this even happening?" —Scheana

"You have Mary Kate collarbone right now—what we strive for." —Kristin

"I love how deep the neckline is." —Stassi