Social media erupted last night when several viewers, including conservative radio host Glenn Beck, noticed the actor playing the devil bared a striking resemblance to the current president:

Anyone else think the Devil in #TheBible Sunday on HIstory Channel looks exactly like That Guy? twitter.com/glennbeck/stat… — Glenn Beck (@glennbeck) March 17, 2013

Okay y'all. Satan on #thebible looks just like Obama. Me and Riley realized it at the same time. #weird — Chase Richburg (@Chase_richburg4) March 18, 2013

Is anybody noticing that satan kinda looks a bit like Barack Obama right now??? #TheBible — e.m. ricchini (@owlrika) March 18, 2013

While some viewers merely noticed the likeness, others questioned whether something fishy was at play:

Wow… seriously… doesn't the Satan character look alot like Obama? Did he agree to play the part… or maybe he's not playing. #TheBible — ElishaNEWS™ (@ElishaNEWS) March 18, 2013

A few conservative Tweeters, including former presidential candidate and pizza magnate Herman Cain, predicted an oncoming progressive conspiracy theory:

If liberal progressives believed in the Bible they'd probably be upset by this: bit.ly/Z9bOvN They're upset anyway? Go figure — Herman Cain (@THEHermanCain) March 18, 2013

So some believe the devil in The Bible looks like Obama.I guess his followers see him in everything. — CavGuynCO (@CavGuynCO) March 18, 2013

Show producer Mark Burnett, who donated $2,700 dollars to the Obama campaign in 2008, has yet to comment. Entertainment Weekly notes, the show’s devil actor, Mohamen Mehdi Ouazanni, has made several other biblically themed television appearances.