Fifth Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford is rated 4.4 out of 5 by 931 .

Rated 1 out of 5 by shc from Right shoe sole caused terrible toe pain. The shoes look great, however the right shoe has a differently formed sole. I thought I could wear through it and break them in, but the difference has not changed. Would love to wear them if I could comfortably. Sadly that is not the case.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Justin from Heel fell off after 10 months. Title says it all. I’ve never had a pair of shoes literally fall apart in such a short period of time. Absolute garbage quality control.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Steve H. from Online sale is great These are the second pair of Allen Edmonds I have purchased online. The first were a disaster, not because of quality but getting the right fit. I finally resolved the issue by visiting the nearest AE store. This pair of Fifth Avenue fits perfectly, I am a size 10 E, and find it hard to get a proper fit in a quality shoe elsewere. AE has become my go to shoe store with the right styles, the right color selections, the right fit, and the high quality I want. If you will keep up the quality, I will keep purchasing.