melbournestokie21

Youth Player







Posts: 404

Youth Player

Player Ratings / Analysis via mobile Quote Select Post

Select Post Deselect Post

Deselect Post Link to Post

Link to Post Member Give Gift

Member Back to Top Post by melbournestokie21 on Start with the worst first.



Cousins- 3, absolutely terrible. Whether it was first match nerves or what not. How on earth weve pretty much traded cameron for him is unbelievable.



Afobe- 4,again cant see how hes any better than campbell. Campbell strikes me as faster and youd hope could control a ball.



Vokes- 4, Offered absolutely nothing, for a target man how can anyone actually make a case for him over Crouch for instance. Let alone an additional 9 mil we paid for him.



Powell- 5, Im prepared to give him time but was more or less anonymous

---------



Best for me were..



Ince- 9, im not his biggest fan but at least he looked a genuine threat. Has to start next week



Gregory- 8, Very intelligent flicks and play, think we will be very very happy with him



Campbell- 8, didnt have a chance to do much but the effort was there big time, winning that corner.



----------



The average,



Allen- 7, didnt think he played poorly but didnt do anything remarkable either



Clucas- 6, even with the goal was invisible for the most part



Smith- 6, neither here nor there, did his part



Baath- 6, same as above showed grit when needed



Collins- 5, didnt play that bad but was caught out big time for 2nd goal



Mclean- 5 thought he offered a threat second half but dear god defending is gonna be a worry with him, you can see what he offers in the wing back role though so will have to see how this plays out.



Butland- 5, didnt have a lot to do other than the stuff up for the first goal.



----------------







The match overall had the ability to turn really really toxic quickly, luckily we showed some fight and snagged a goal back but very worrying signs again...



Cousins looks incredibly average in every sense and cant see him starting next week