Throw out the current tax code

By James R. Donnell

April 04, 2013

Thursday PM



Time magazine reported this week that the estimated tax gap - the amount of money the IRS fails to collect due to misfiling or tax cheaters - is an estimated $600 billion dollars. The fact that this money goes uncollected ultimately increases the tax rates and the amount of money that you and I pay.

An article from the 2002 study by the Government Accountability Office showed that "fifty-six percent of [tax] returns prepared by a paid preparer had errors in comparison to only forty-seven percent prepared by the taxpayer." In short, over 50% of tax returns being filed in the 2002 study were wrong and we "only" had 53,280 pages of tax code back then. Fast forward to 2012 and the code has grown to over 73,000 pages. That's taxation without comprehension and it is only expanding the tax gap.

Studies show that simplifying the code leads to better compliance. That makes sense, but what makes a lot more sense is to throw out the entire income tax code and switch to a national retail sales tax like that proposed by the FairTax Bill - HR25 / S122.

The FairTax is simply a different way to collect taxes - by taxing consumption rather than income. Under the FairTax plan the government would collect the same amount of money without the complexities of the income tax. In fact, the FairTax bill is only 133 pages double spaced. The number of "filers" would be reduced from 150 million individual returns to simple sales reports from approximately 20 million businesses.

Yes, it's possible to cheat a sales tax but, unlike income tax where it takes only one person to cheat by not reporting or under-reporting their income, a sales tax take two people to cheat - the person selling and the person buying. In addition, the bill specifically includes provisions to reward whistle-blowers which makes it a little less likely people will cheat. Not to mention that well over 80% retail sales are through big chain stores like Wal-mart or Target and they are not going to risk their business by cheating the system. Used items are not taxed under the FairTax so there's no compliance issue there.

After 100 years of income tax, and the code growing from 400 pages in 1913 to over 73,000 pages last year, it's time we do something that makes sense. Tweaking the code hasn't worked. Let's throw it out and switch to the FairTax.

Sincerely,

James R. Donnell

Cameron Park, CA