Scott Morrison says government’s budget repair is ‘patient and measured’ but Labor accuses him of being a ‘one-trick pony’ targeting welfare fraud

This article is more than 4 years old

This article is more than 4 years old

Myefo: budget banks on 'unrealistic' $13.9bn savings blocked by Senate Read more

The Turnbull government has dismissed doubts about the budget savings it says will come from a plan to intensify existing programs to reduce welfare fraud.



The social services minister, Christian Porter, described the figures in Scott Morrison’s first budget update as “absolutely” achievable after Labor suggested the treasurer was a “one-trick pony” who kept announcing the same crackdown.

Morrison also defended the new 2020-21 target for returning to surplus, arguing deeper spending cuts or higher taxes could detract from economic growth. He said introducing them would be a case of “cutting off your nose to spite your face”, in a clear break from the Coalition’s previous rhetoric about “Labor’s debt and deficit disaster”.

Tuesday’s mid-year economic and fiscal outlook (Myefo) contained deficit forecasts for the next four years that were $26bn worse than expected when Joe Hockey handed down his final budget seven months ago. The deterioration has been largely blamed on revenue write-downs linked to falling commodity prices and downgrades in economic growth.



The Myefo included several measures described as “enhanced welfare payment integrity”. It estimated savings of $1.3bn from increasing the search for discrepancies between income declared to Centrelink and the Australian Tax Office (ATO) and $695m from additional matching of social security data with other sources.

A further $158m was expected to come from expanding the debt recovery activities of the Department of Human Services.

The new measures were announced seven months after the government earmarked savings of $1.7bn over five years from boosting the department’s fraud prevention and debt recovery capability, and improving assessment processes.

Malcolm Turnbull's stocks remain high, but his coffers are increasingly empty Read more

Labor’s treasury spokesman, Chris Bowen, said the government should justify the figures because Morrison “pulls this one out of the top drawer” whenever he needs to find a saving. “He’s a one-trick pony,” Bowen said.

Porter acknowledged the previously announced welfare crackdowns, but said ministers and departments had been “impressed with our enhanced ability to use new technology and data platforms to actually work out where the debt is and then recover the debt”.

“I guess the central question that you ask is, are those savings achievable? I absolutely consider that they are ... and more than that, it’s the right thing to [do],” Porter told ABC Radio National on Wednesday.

“Previous measures that we put in place are starting the bear the fruit ... it is not about trusting me as a minister. These figures are worked through, at arm’s length through Treasury, through the ATO, based on their recent experience and the application of new technology they’ve got.”

Morrison conducted a series of media interviews on Wednesday, a day after delivering the first budget update since Malcolm Turnbull ousted Tony Abbott as prime minister in September on the grounds that the country needed better economic leadership.

Myefo: Scott Morrison says budget will blow out by $26bn over four years Read more

He stood by cuts within the health portfolio, including $650m from bulk-billing incentives for pathology and diagnostic imaging services.

The changes prompted warnings from the Australian Medical Association that some people could be deterred from having necessary tests. The Royal College of Pathologists said it was “dumbfounded” by the decision, which could prompt people to present late with undiagnosed cancers.

The Labor leader, Bill Shorten, accused the government of being preoccupied with “attacking Medicare” rather than intensifying attempts to ensure multinational corporations paid their fair share of tax.



“An attack on Medicare is an attack on all Australians,” Shorten said.

It's the revenue, stupid (with no apologies to Scott Morrison) Read more

But Morrison said pathology was “a very big business” and the large amount of competition between providers should maintain downward pressure on prices. He argued that the government was making the changes because the bulk-billing incentives had been ineffective.

“Let’s remember that they are paid to the companies and these are pathology and diagnostic companies, some of which have turnovers of up to about $4bn a year,” he told Sky News.

“We were shelling out hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars every year in what were effectively corporate subsidies to support bulk-billing increases that weren’t being achieved by those subsidies ... so, why should the tax payer shell out more for those corporate subsidies?”

Morrison also defended the government’s slow-and-steady message on budget repair, which clashed with the messages on deficit reduction deployed by the Abbott-led Coalition before the 2013 election.

What a turn-up for the books: a big spending, big taxing Liberal party Read more

“We are on that path [to surplus] and each year [the deficit] is reducing by [an] average of 0.4% of GDP, so we make progress, but you make progress in the economic circumstances and you don’t cut off your nose to spite your face with higher taxes or even deeper spending measures,” the treasurer told the ABC’s AM program.

“You have to be patient and measured and that’s what the government’s doing to protect people’s jobs.”

Abbott declared “a budget emergency” in 2013 when the former Labor treasurer Wayne Swan’s final budget predicted deficits of $18bn in 2013-14 and $10.9bn in 2014-15, followed by narrow predicted surpluses of $800m in 2015-16 and $6.6bn in 2016-17.

The Myefo released by Morrison and the finance minister, Mathias Cormann, suggested the budget will remain in the red by $37.4bn in 2015-16, followed by deficits of $33.7bn in 2016-17, $23bn in 2017-18 and $14.2bn in 2018-19.