When Aaron Rodgers throws an interception, it’s a surprise. His precision and accuracy throwing the ball alongside his consistency makes you think, just for a split second, that maybe the interception was a planned strategic move.

Rodgers is the most precise quarterback in NFL history. He has thrown an interception on just 1.5% of his passes, a league record. He’s thrown fewer career interceptions than the careers of Cam Newton, Andy Dalton, Mark Sanchez, Joey Harrington, Matt Cassel, Tony Banks, Marc Bulger and Mike Vick.

But what might be most impressive about Aaron Rodgers is this: he has thrown one career interception that’s been returned by the defense for a touchdown. This is commonly called a “pick six.”

Rodgers’ lone pick six somehow becomes more impressive when you compare him against some of the NFL’s greats throughout history:

Brett Favre: 35 (4 were in the playoffs)

Peyton Manning: 31 (4 were in the playoffs)

Dan Marino: 29 (1 was in the playoffs)

John Elway: 19 (1 was in the playoffs)

Tom Brady: 13 (1 was in the playoffs)

Joe Montana: 9 (3 were in the playoffs)

Bart Starr: 6

Aaron Rodgers: 1

How Aaron Rodgers threw a pick six in 2009