In August 2012, the Pemberton Township man ordered a water, a beer, and a soda, plus his meal at the Toms River restaurant, according to a lawsuit he filed against the eatery. He believed that all of this, plus tip, would cost about $20. But he said he was “shocked” when he got the bill that charged him more than $5 for a “mass-produced beer” and almost $3 for the soda.