Ok I can now only see this going one of 3 ways.

Theory One

A is a sibling/twin/relative of Ali or Jason hence the Charles thing. To support that we know A 1. Knew bed time stories Ali’s mom read to her as a child ( probably read the same ones to Jason) 2. We know there was a C with a cow jumping over the moon in the attic hinting at another child in the family. 3. A has similar hobbies as Ali such as they play piano and we see in next weeks preview they are also good at archery just like Ali ( remember her Archery award that Hanna found in the attic on Christmas?) 4. Then there’s the weird memory problems both Ali and Jason seem to have ( to be fair Jason’s are supposedly from drinking but that could just be a cover. ) and Ali couldn’t even remember where her guidance counselor office was located. 5. The baby books/picture albums. Ali has 3 and Jason has less than that is all we know but it could be that Ali has so many bc there of two people not just one or Jason could have so few because the family had to hide his if they include a twin or sibling they put away or adopted out. 6. The clues in Ali’s room with two of her and one of Jason and the little poem about twins in French. Not to mention the picture in their living room of Ali holding another child’s hand that is cut off with Mrs.D in the background. Anyway those are just a few hints that one of them could have a twin or that they have another sibling or even a cousin or another relative on the dad’s side. Suspects: If they have an identical twin then of course it’s gonna be the same actors just playing parts we didn’t know about. If it’s a fraternal twin or sibling then it could be a lot of people but I’ll narrow it down to who I think it could be … Wren ( I think the doctor or supposed doctor fits into this somehow and I listed some reasons on theory three of why I think he could be A, all this time I have thought he may of been the older guy Ali was seeing over the summer but it’s possible he’s in fact Jason’s fraternal twin or their sibling), Toby ( he has the whole blonde hair light eye thing going for him and Marion came in and interrupted before he and Ali could kiss. Maybe that was because they are blood related. All along I have thought that TOBY and Bethany might of been twins and it’s possible they were but they or he could still be Ali and Jason’s siblings or cousins. And if TOBY and Bethany were twins and Ali and the girls killed her by accident he may be getting revenge for that and because their parents gave them away. Plus TOBY has been acting super strange lately.) Next suspect Ezra (he would fit nicely with this because of the Holly Varjak:Paul Varjak thing except that I would think his connection with Ali and the hints/clues would be more of a romantic affiliation than a sibling one. Yet it’s still possible. Everyone knows all the clues for it being him so I’m not gonna rehash them but I’ll say what makes me doubt it. I sort of do not think its him because he threw himself in front of a bullet for the girls and Ali. Also if he had hired the lawyer wouldn’t the lawyer of known he was Varjak? I think he’s still involved with this, like maybe he’s still writing a book but I don’t really think he is A mainly because there’s so much that blatantly points to him) then there is Lucas ( ok if it’s Lucas and he’s Ali’s fraternal twin or their cousin then I could see him being obsessed with Ali and the girl and the SHIM clue that Marlene gave would fit well, it would explain why Mona felt betrayed, but why did the Dilaurentis family not want him? Maybe they thought he was weak or not beautiful enough to fit in, idk. Or maybe he was really born with both girl and boy parts at birth. Maybe the Dilaurentis family kept him for a while and did not know if he should be a boy or a girl. Maybe mr.D thought he should be a boy and Mrs.D wanted him to be a girl, maybe they chose for him to be a boy but then he started displaying signs that he had a girl personality like wanting to play with dolls and wear dresses. Then eventually they put him away or adopted him out. Maybe they put him away at institutions so young that Ali did not know about him. Although since A has a lot of the very same skills as Ali has and Jason may have ( it’s possible if Ali took piano and learned archery at summer camp then Jason did too) then I would think they were raised with them. Is it possible that Ali has just blocked it all out?)

Next we have Andrew ( I just want to start off saying they are throwing a lot of clues out like it’s him but if it is then I’ll be highly disappointed because he hasn’t been on the show that much. The clues are mounting up like crazy from the $20 bills with Andrew Jackson, to him throwing out creepy comments that sound like A to Aria, then him being there at Mona’s house in the bushes when the creepy French music had been playing. I can’t think of a reason he would hate the girls but maybe we don’t know yet.) Then there is Pastor Ted who could be a brother of Kenneth’s. He could be going by a different name for some reason or it’s possible the Dilaurentis’ changed their last name ( In the books the show is based off of their last name was originally Day Dilaurentis and they dropped the Day, so only a subtle change but on the show it may of been a bigger change). What would pastor Ted’s motive be? I think maybe either Sara or Bethany could of been his daughter and he may blame Ali and the girls for her disappearance or murder. There’s a lot pointing to him lately too. Someone made a thread about it and did a great job so I’m not gonna rehash the reasons). Then there is Mona ( although if she is A then idk if she could fit this theory but I suppose it’s possible that she’s the Dilaurentis’s daughter. She did have a weird relationship with Jason, but I think although it’s not going with my theory that if it’s her that she just wants to be a Dilaurentis so badly and has DID or multiple personality disorder and has an alter named Charles Dilaurentis. If that’s the case obviously something happened to her while she was young that caused her to split. We may not know the whole story yet but I do not think it was just bullying. I think if they go this direction that even though Mona was crazy all on her own that Charles did not manifest til the end of season 2 or beginning of season 3 or maybe I should say remanifest. Which means something must of happened in Radley to bring Charles out and it could just be that he came out to protect her while she was there. ) I also think it’s very likely Ali or Jason could have an identical twin and right now I’m leaning more toward it being Ali that has one, here’s what I think may be going on. Ali was born with a twin that has one of 3 things wrong with him/her either she was born a boy, but wanted to be a girl. She was born with both girl and boy parts, or she has DID ( multiple personalities) and Charles is an alter. If she was born a boy or with both parts I think her parents decided for her to be a boy. I think she hated that. I think Mrs.D may of indulged her with dresses like she wanted but her dad found out and said if you do it again I will leave you. That’s why she had Ali lie. Eventually they put the twin away somewhere and the twin grew up envious of her twin sister and wanted to be just like her. She had a sex change operation as soon as she turned 18 or had it done in another country when she was even younger than 18. Now, I think it could be her that came back as Alison, the one in jail. That is why she seems nicer etc. and somewhat remorseful of how her sister used to act. It also is why she can’t remember things. Or it could just really be Alison back and her twin is so envious of her and her friends and is taunting them. Either that or the real Alison is furious at her twin for taking her place and using the Charles D anagram to taunt her about her secret. Idk why she would be messing with the liars too if that’s the case, but who knows. Another theory is that Ali’s twin has an alter named Charles and that is who A is. I think it is one of those three if Ali has a twin and considering A has a lot of Ali’s same skills and knows stories her mom read to her I’m thinking her or Jason may very well have a twin.

Theory Two

Jason is Charles, either he has an alter named Charles or it’s his middle name. Clues to this are similar to the first theory. I’m not gonna relist them but I will add some to it. 1. In season one Jason (played by a different actor) was talking to Spencer and she said you are just like Ali and he said no I’m worse! 2. We know Jason dated Cece and in the webisodes we see him fighting with her in the Halloween store and he tells her that her and Alison belong together or deserve each other, something like that but he’s talking about Ali in the present tense and at this time they had already found Ali’s body (what we thought was her body). 3. In that same web series we see A go into the Halloween store to delete the video footage and they stroke/caress Cece’s image on the monitor which could easily point to Jason. 3. We know Jason had some kind of relationship with Mona because at one point she’s putting a bandage on him and to me it seemed kind of like he liked her and she liked him. Maybe if that is the case he got mad that she dated Mike and killed her. 4. We know that before Ali disappeared that she was possibly trying to get her grandmother to disinherit someone. Tippi was her grandmothers bird so if Ali was set to inherit it then Jason could of taken it as a way to say haha I got it anyway if he was the one she was trying to have disinherited. 5. Jason has been shady a lot and his mood swings are kinda crazy. One minute he will ignore or be rude to Spencer and the liars and the next he will act like nothing is wrong. On top of that he disappears a lot for no reason. He once said he was in rehab which was not true, in fact it was closed down. So where was he? 6. A lot of people have mentioned that Aria seems to get less of A’s wrath, that could be because Jason had a crush on Aria for awhile. 7. It’s also very convenient that as soon as he found out Wilden may of got his sister pregnant that Wilden ended up dead. 8. What could of messed Jason up to cause the alter or him to be crazy? Well we know that yellow dress was for someone maybe Mrs.D wanted him to be a girl and tried dressing him as a girl or maybe Jason liked to dress as a girl and play with dolls and his mother indulged him. Maybe his father found out and told her if she did it again he would leave her. Then obviously she was still doing it behind his back and that’s why she had to convince Ali not to tell about the dresses. Either way his father wasn’t his real father and seemed to resent him and his mother was a little loopy herself. Anyone remember her telling Ali to smoke Spencer out? Then she said you can’t trust a Hastings, but right there was her son who is biologically a Hastings. 9. If that wasn’t enough to mess up Jason maybe him kissing his half sister Melissa pushed him over the edge after he found out. 10. His breakup with Cece probably did not help either. Maybe he blamed Ali for befriending his girlfriend or maybe he blamed Ali for getting Cece kicked out of university ( we do not know if it’s true but cece’s college roommate told Aria that Cece hated Ali and the girls, that Ali had pushed that girl down the stairs at the frat party and got cece kicked out of college.) which if true was bound to put a kink in her relationship with Jason. 11. Recently he’s had a one night stand with Ashley Marin. Afterwards they met for coffee and she told him she was in a relationship that was serious. She said it’s been long distance for awhile, a lot of phone calls and emails and I was lonely and he said I know what that’s like. He could of just meant the lonely part, but to me it seemed like he also meant the long distance relationship part because later in the same episode he asks her if the one night stand happened so that she would have an excuse to say no to her engagement and he continues by saying that he had done stuff like that, screwed up a good thing because he was afraid his past was going to get in the way. Who was he talking about because as far as we know Jason has only had one girlfriend which was Cece. Was/is he still dating her or someone else? Could he of been using Ashley to make someone jealous? 12. When he testified it came out about his affair with Ashley. Ok, I know she didn’t want that out but maybe he did. After all he did kiss her after she said it couldn’t happen again. He may of thought if it came out that it would ruin her and Ted’s relationship. 13. Another thing I noticed was him contradicting himself. He told Spencer that he let Ali run because he knew she was innocent and he told Ali the same thing. Yet when Ali called his office from jail he told Ashley that he couldn’t even look at Ali without thinking she may of killed his mom. Then he told Aria that Ali was capable of all sorts of things. He also said she could do things right under your nose and Aria’s cell goes off with a text with an address. Ok, then we see a glimpse of Jason holding a white or silver phone and before they went in the coffee shop it showed him with a black phone. I think he may of messaged Aria. It’s possible he WANTED that fling with Ashley to come out and sent Aria texts and had her deliver the flowers to Hannah’s house to try to bring it out and when that did not work he had it brought out in Ali’s trial. That alone doesn’t make him A. However, bringing that out was pretty damaging for Ali’s defense, so would he sabotage his sister’s life just to let others know about him and Ashley? I think it’s too much of an A move that if he did it he is probably A or being blackmailed. 14. He told Aria that the police thought Ali had help. How did he know that? As far as I know no one knew that at the time he said it, not even Ali. Then when Ali was offered a plea he told Aria that Ali was thinking of taking the plea because her lawyer got her so rattled. Excuse me what? We, as viewers, saw that scene and she didn’t seem rattled, in fact she seemed pretty adamant she wasn’t going to take the plea. Later, some girls in the prison scared her and she called her lawyer and asked if she took the plea would she be moved to a safer place, but that was after Jason told Aria this. 15. I don’t know if people did not catch this, but I sure did. If people caught it they aren’t making a big deal of it and IMO it is a big clue. When Emily is at the listening table at The Brew she hears some secrets. The last one was the big clue I think. It was Jason saying the dog didn’t run away, I left the gate open on purpose. Then directly after the creepy French music that played when Varjak called Aria and at Mona’s house started playing. So, basically we knew Jason didn’t really like the dog Pepe that found his dead mother’s body, but now we know that he left the gate open for it to runaway. Remember back when they got the dog how he told the lady from the shelter that his mother did not order the dog and the lady said its a dog not a pizza. I think that pizza reference may of been a subtle clue that Jason is A. Then he tells the lady to put the dog back in the van, but Ali was having non of it. Anyway, how did he KNOW his mom did not request the dog? Could it be because she was already dead at the time the dog was requested? Maybe he knew because he killed his mother. There are other clues too but I don’t want to make this a book so on to scenario or theory 3.



Theory 3

Charles is Ali’s son and A is the father. We know that Cece said Ali thought she was pregnant by the older guy she was dating. She was scared the older guy would kill her so I think this could be why she ran away, to have the baby without anyone knowing. I think if this is true that a few people knew. I think Melissa and Ian both knew and Cece. I think the reason she went to CapeMay in the first place was to have an abortion, but couldn’t go through with it. I also think Ian and Melissa were helping her. I do not think Ian was the father. I don’t think he and Ali ever even slept together, but for some reason he let people think it was him she was seeing and so did Melissa. There were conflicting stories told about that trip. Melissa and Ian told that they went because Melissa was pregnant and she was going to have an abortion but lost the baby before it was time for the abortion. Yet, in a flashback Ali is seen with Ian in a motel room with a video camera. Let’s just say it doesn’t look good at all. Then Melissa comes knocking at the door upset saying I know she’s in there etc. but I think neither story is true. I think Ali was the one going for the abortion not Melissa and that Ian and Mel went to cover for her. Why would they do that? Idk, maybe they were being blackmailed or maybe there’s a reason we do not know yet. Things that validate that they were helping her and KNEW she was alive are first off Ali said ( though I question this) that she killed Ian to protect Spencer, but he looks at his killer and says what are you doing here. He doesn’t say omg, you are alive. If Ian was helping Ali idk why she would kill him, but I don’t think she killed him. If she did it’s possible he may of been about to tell the truth about Ali being alive or about her baby. But back to the theory itself. I think that Ali went away, maybe to France, to have the baby then she may of put it up for adoption or someone she knows could be there raising it. I think she did this because she was scared of the father of the baby. Maybe they seemed great and wonderful, she may of told them she was pregnant and they flipped out showing their crazy side or they may of pretended to be okay with it then tried to kill her and the baby. It’s possible that if this is the correct scenario that A thinks the girls were helping Ali or that A thinks the girls know where the baby is at. While it seems irrational to us, we aren’t crazy so it could seem perfectly rational to a crazy person. Clues to this theory 1. we know Ali was seeing an older guy the summer b4 she disappeared. We still don’t know who that guy is. 2. Cece said Ali thought she was pregnant. Plus Ali was away long enough to have the baby, lose the weight, and it not show. 3. The C with the cow jumping over the moon could be something she’s sending to her son. And A may know about the nursery rhymes because Ali may of sung them to the baby while she was pregnant. 4. In the episode 4x25 it starts out with a closeup of a painting of what appears to be a mother swaddling her baby while a scary figure lurks behind them. It was painted by A. I’m guessing Ali painted it or posed for it. 5. All the block letters, jack in the box, etc. are childish things making you think of a child. That’s all the clues I have for her having a child, but there could be some I am missing. As for who the father could be. It is more than likely someone older than her that was gonna get in trouble or had a lot to lose by getting a minor pregnant. At first We were led to believe she was seeing Ian ( he’s dead so he can’t be A), then Wilden ( again he is now deceased so I think it probably was not him), then Ezra ( it could be him but here is why I don’t think it is, Ali admitted in a flashback that they never slept together and also she doesn’t seem afraid of him. Also if they had some hot torrid affair you would think she would be upset Aria is/was dating him and if he was obsessed with her you would think as soon as she came back to town he would be kicking Aria to the curb to try to get back with Ali. Plus, he did take a bullet. We don’t know if the shooter was A, but if he were A I do not see him sacrificing himself to save the girls he is torturing. ). Now here are a list of other suspects.. Wren ( I’m not even going to list all the reasons Wren could be A because there are so many, but I will list a few such as he plays piano, he’s a doctor “plays with body parts”, there was a picture of a wren ( bird) in the A lair, he had a mannequin head that holds a wig in his apartment, being a doctor he has access to places like burn units, morgues, Radley, prison, jail, etc., when Spencer went to London he was not there, Shana was sending his things or mail to him in London then Shana turned out to be crazy and probably taking orders from A, he seemed to work at whatever place the girls were at whether it was Radley or the hospital until Ali came back. He clearly has a thing for younger girls, Charles was a Kings name in England where Wren is from, also his dad had a mental illness, he is OCD and A’s lair looked like it belonged to someone with OCD, there were suits in the lair that look like the ones Wren wears., and if you go back to the flashback to the night of the girl falling down the stairs at the frat party, Ali had been missing from the group of girls when the girl fell. Then she met back up with them and when they walk out to leave she runs over to ask a cop for a ride home and in the background there’s a guy that could be either Wren or Holbrook, Etc. etc. meaning there’s a lot more) next suspect is Holbrook (like I mentioned with Wren there was a fb of the frat party b4 Ali went missing and it looks like Ali had been off with a guy then returns and across the street we see a guy that looks like Wren or Holbrook, I can’t tell which one but it’s entirely possible he was the older guy Ali was seeing that summer, he’s a cop therefor he has a lot of police access to things, he and Ali hadn’t known each other that long, that we know of, yet they were kissing at the Christmas party, his father knew who she was but did mistake Hannah for her, the only reason I am not sure about it being him is because if she was afraid of him why would she start seeing him again unless she was scared not to. The last person is Toby ( Toby is a little bit older than the girls so yes it could be him and he has been acting strange lately, but I still don’t really think he would be the older guy that got her pregnant.)

You know I had been wondering if Jason is Varjak then why are there so many things that link Ezra and Aria. I think I may of found a solution to that. Okay, remember when Spencer and Hannah were talking and they were like why Varjak and one of them said Ali was obsessed with Breakfast at Tiffanys maybe Varjak is mocking her. That made me think, what if Jason is jealous of Ezria and is using the Paul Varjak alias not just to mock Ali but to mock Ezria. Especially considering when you called the number on the pizza receipt it said you have reached the Varjak’s residence. People thought that might be a clue to Ezria is in this as a couple, but it very well could be Jason. Also I thought of one more theory I will be adding in another post on here either later today or tomorrow.