Charlotte’s Killer, The Big Bad, and the Twin

So, long time no talk my theory buddies! I know it has been a while since my last theory, but that’s mostly due to the fact there hasn’t exactly been a large amount of clues as of yet. Well, I think I’ve got enough down to have figured out who exactly killed Charlotte (and Jessica for that matter) and who the Big Bad is, as well as who the twin could possibly be.

Now, lets start off with who killed Charlotte and Jessica… It was Dr. Rollins, yes- Alison’s soon to be hubby Dr. Rollins. I’ve talked it over with my theory buddy Nick and we both came to the conclusion that this persons motive could possibly be Bethany (which I will get to later, don’t worry!). Didn’t it seem a little odd to anyone that Dr. Rollins happened to have brought Charlotte home the exact day she was going to be killed? And didn’t it also seem odd that he was not only Charlotte’s psychiatrist but ALSO Mona’s? And why in the world does he want to get married to Alison so quickly? And, if Dr. Rollins WAS in fact Mona’s doctor in Radley, that would also mean he had to have known Charlotte as well, everyone thought Wren was the one who was screwing with the visitors passes… And he admitted to getting “Cece” in to see Mona, but who got Mona the passes? Who gave her the nurses outfit?

Now, as for who I think the Big Bad is… After all this time (and a LONG time coming for me to write this sentence) Melissa Hastings. This Big Bad’s motive isn’t anything like Charlotte’s or Mona’s, this Big Bad wants revenge on whomever killed Charlotte and is trying to desperately figure it out. Now, lets look at Charlotte and Melissa’s history now, shall we? Knew each other in high school, went to UPenn together, vacationed together, and the ENTIRE TIME Charlotte was playing the game- Melissa was helping her. She was the Queen of Hearts. She buried Bethany alive (Which is ANOTHER huge point I have to explain), whenever Charlotte was mentioned, Melissa’s name was never too far behind. They had one of the biggest off-screen relationships of the show, and probably the most important one as well, because it was never explained exactly what their connections were, the caressing of the monitor with Charlotte on it? Melissa Everyone knows Melissa is shady, she was at the Lodge Fire, she was in contact with Charlotte the entire A-Game, she was on the Halloween Train, hell- she helped Mona build her ARMY FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!

Here’s the kicker, so you remember last episode ended with finding out the murder weapon was Melissa’s suitcase? Rollins is framing her in revenge for killing Bethany. Every single person involved in Bethany’s death is being checked off one by one. Jessica handled the cover up, Melissa buried her, and Charlotte- Charlotte was the reason she got hit in the first place. And I can guarantee you that Mona will be the next on the chopping block. Even further, he’s using Alison as an alibi- Alison saw Rollins take Charlotte home, his alibi is safe and sound.

As for the twin? There’s a high probability that Bethany is the one with the twin, it can’t be someone on the main cast, i.e. the girls, and here’s why… So, remember a long time ago when Alison told that story to the little boy that Hanna was babysitting? Initially we thought the twins were supposed to represent Charlotte and Alison but here’s the thing… The story is made for one of the twins to be absolutely batshit violent and crazy, Charlotte was neither violent nor a crazy killer, but who was? Bethany Young. We often wondered who exactly belonged in that haunted house, who the twin was, and how exactly it tied into the grand scheme of things… The answer leads back to how this all started, with Bethany Young. Now, there’s another reason I bring the twins up, so as we know the night Bethany escaped she was accidentally murdered by Melissa and Mona, but what IF the other twin was still alive? Because I can guarantee you, this chick going into the church the night Charlotte was murdered is NOT Charlotte, Charlotte died with no red sweater and it looks too small for Charlotte or Alison.

I’m wondering if the twin has a personal connection to Dr. Rollins, whether or not this will turn out to be true… We have yet to see. But I think it’s worth mentioning this little connection… Alison puts these flowers out and then hears Charlotte get out of the car with Dr. Rollins, Charlotte is then found dead with those same flowers in hand, and THEN we see Dr. Rollins with a purple shirt to the funeral… Of all the colors you could choose, a purple shirt and tie?

The next thing is, Melissa’s timing… Sure, Charlotte was murdered in 6x11, BUT the Big Bad doesn’t show up until the DAY MELISSA SHOWS UP IN 6x13! It’s also noted that Melissa is freaking the f*** out over not having any clothes, which means her luggage was MISSING ALONG WITH THE HANDLE THAT KILLED CHARLOTTE.

So, Melissa thinks the liars know who killed Charlotte, Dr. Rollins and Bethany’s twin is framing Melissa for the murder of Charlotte, oh and… That tunnel in Radley from Charlotte’s bedroom? It’s the entrance to the Dollhouse. The dollhouse was bricked up.

Glad to be back, guys. Glad to be back.