Fire at Cosmo Bella Pizza in Pequannock displaces family, destroys community fixture

Show Caption Hide Caption Scene of Pequannock pizzeria fire at Cosmo Bella Cosmo Bella Pizza, established in 1970 in Pequannock, was destroyed in a fire Dec. 27, 2019.

PEQUANNOCK — An overnight fire Friday displaced a family of five and left only charred remains of Cosmo Bella Pizza — a fixture in town for nearly 50 years.

The fire, which prompted the evacuation in the apartments above the restaurant, occurred about 1:10 a.m., Police Capt. Daniel Comune said. There were no injuries.

The scene was cleared just after 7 a.m. as the building was taped off, with holes through its roof and walls. The sign that used to hang over the entrance, evocative of the Italian flag with its green, white and red color scheme, sat wedged in the ruins of the roof.

Story continues below gallery

The fire does not appear suspicious, Comune said.

The pizzeria was founded in 1970 by Cosmo and Antoinette Boniello, , who lived in the apartment attached to the restaurant space with their children. The couple operated the pizzeria until 1984, but still own the building and frequently visit the area.

"It was like your memories were burning up in flames," Donna Laterzo, daughter of Cosmo and Antoinette said.

A fundraiser was started on Facebook by Karli Anne Boniello, Antoinette's granddaughter, and has collected over $5,000 since the fire for the family and current pizzeria owners. There are also clothing donations being taken at family-owned Boniello's restaurant in Riverdale.

People mourning the restaurant on a Pequannock Facebook page called it a landmark of the town with great food.

"I grew up on their pizza," one person wrote.

"So sorry for this devastating loss," said another. "Pequannock would not be the same without Cosmo Bella."

Anthony Zurita is a breaking news reporter for NorthJersey.com. For unlimited access to all the major news happening in North Jersey, subscribe here. To get breaking news directly to your inbox, sign up for our newsletter.

Email: zuritaa@northjersey.com Twitter: @AnthonyRZurita

More North Jersey news

Fire: Mahwah restaurant opens on Christmas, brings fresh pizzas to firefighters battling blaze

Environment: Recycling can help your county get money. Here's which NJ counties recycle the most

NJ pizza: All the best pizza and where to get it