Mythology aside, the truth is the Civil War was a hell of a lot less popular in the North than it was in the South, especially among recently-arrived white immigrants. Whites in both the North and South were often resentful about being drafted to fight in "Mr. Lincoln's War"... remember the New York City Riots? White hooligans rampaged through the city for days. It required the imposition of martial law and public executions of rioters to quell that mess. Black people, on the other hand, were eager to enlist. Frederick Douglass, a US MARSHAL HIMSELF, was a strong advocate for allowing black men to fight. He made the explicit argument that this would be how black men could show they were worthy of the right to vote.

"Once let the black man get upon his person the brass letter, U.S., let him get an eagle on his button, and a musket on his shoulder and bullets in his pocket, there is no power on earth that can deny that he has earned the right to citizenship." Frederick Douglass

In fact, that was one of the reasons opponents of black service used to make their case. "If you let them fight, next thing you know they'll want to vote." You have to admit, it's hard to argue with that. Anyone who lived through the 60s remembers the argument for dropping the voting age to 18 -- "If we're old enough to die, we should be old enough to vote."

Let's return to Gettysburg for a moment. Lee's incursion into Pennsylvania did a wonderful job of overcoming that state's resistance to raising black troops. Plenty of them fought and died at Gettysburg. Hell, they died in droves in battlefields across the nation. One example that recently got a lot of renewed attention due to the movie "Glory" was the story of the Massachussetts 54th Regiment.

The Massachusetts 54th regiment consisted of freed blacks recruited in the North; they were led by Colonel Robert Gould Shaw, the son of ardent Boston abolitionists. Shaw had to argue with his commander in order for his men to have a chance to fight. On July 18, 1863, Shaw led the 54th in an assault against Fort Wagner, which guarded Charleston, South Carolina. Under heavy fire, a small group of these troops broke through the Fort’s earthworks and for an hour held the parapet, until Confederates drove them back. Shaw and almost half of his troops were killed in the assault, but the tragic incident showed that black troops would fight well and bravely if given a chance.

And they weren't the only ones. By the time Lee reached Gettysburg, 10% of the Union Army was black. A lot of them were used in support roles, but many of them did fight. They were often the most highly motivated, for good reason:

When they did fight they faced not only the prospect of being killed or maimed in battle, but also the prospect of being executed if they were captured by Confederate forces. The Confederates declared that all black men fighting for the Union were rebel slaves, regardless of whether they were actually former slaves or had been born free, and frequently executed them. With sorrow, Lincoln responded that he would have to execute southern prisoners of war, if the south executed any Union prisoners. For the most part Lincoln’s threat paid off, but captured black soldiers were treated more harshly by the Confederates than were white Union soldiers.

By the war’s end 30,000 to 40,000 black soldiers had died, like many deaths in the days before antibiotics, the majority of these men died from disease. Twenty three black soldiers were given the Medal of Honor for their heroic service in the Civil War.

They may not have been any black Union soldiers at the start of the Civil War, but they were there at the end, at Appomattox.

There were seven Black units (approximately 2,000 men, or 3% of the Federal force) which made the journey all the way to Appomattox Court House with Major General Edward Ord's Union Army of the James and arrived in time to be involved in the final fighting. On their way they passed through the settlements of Blacks & Whites, Nottoway Court House, Burkeville Junction, Rice's Station, and Farmville. From the latter point they stayed south of the Appomattox River and traveled via Walker's Church (present day Hixburg) to Appomattox. These regiments were of Colonel William W. Woodward's brigade, the 29th and 31st U.S.C.T., along with the 116th U.S.C.T., assigned to them from another brigade. Colonel Ulysses Doubleday's brigade, 8th, 41st, 45th, and 127th U.S.C.T., were also present. On the morning of the 9th at Appomattox Court House, the Black units were sent forward to support other Federal units in the closing phase of the battle. Consequently, only Woodward's brigade participated in the final advance on the Confederate line. Some of Doubleday's skirmishers did proceed forward, and the only casualty for the U.S.C.T. brigades was Captain John W. Falconer of Company A, 41st U.S.C.T., a white officer. He was mortally wounded and died on April 23rd. According to Surgeon-in-Chief Charles P. Heinchhold, during the entire campaign, the U.S.C.T.'s lost 4 men killed, 1 officer (mortally) and 30 men wounded, a total of 35 casualties.

Let's return to Gettysburg on last time. I know this is going to upset Uncle Pat and his apologists, but I can't resist throwing in this contemporary quote from the New York Herald.

"...And after the battle of Gettysburg in July 1863, ...reported among the rebel prisoners were seven blacks in Confederate uniforms fully armed as soldiers..." - New York Herald, July 11, 1863

That's right, kids. All those good ole boys who fly the stars and bars as a Rebel Yell and hate how the colored done drag down this great nation need to doff their caps in respect for the fact that none other than Saint Robert E. Lee his own self proclaimed the Confederacy needed black soldiers. That's right, Uncle Pat, it wasn't just the North that had black soldiers, tens of thousands of black soldiers fought for the Confederacy.

So, in conclusion, let me say this:

I don't care if Pat Buchanan is a racist, a hypocrite, a Republican, or all of the above. I do care that he is a fool who perverts history in a vain effort to score political talking points and thereby misleads his audience. If MSNBC wants to have racists or hypocrites or Republicans on their shows, fine. But don't insult our intelligence by putting on morons.

=============

"He who controls the past, controls the future." --- George Orwell