Bachelor star Madison Prewett got the first one-on-one date of Peter Weber’s season, and honestly their vibes were very cute. But, um, in a somewhat uncomfortable turn of events, fans think Madi’s created a fan account, specifically to write positive comments on her own Instagram photos. Yikes!

Apparently Madison Prewett “accidentally” commented this on her own Instagram pic: “Beautiful date Madi. You are so genuine and real.”And per Entertainment Tonight, aptly named Bachelor fan account @BachSleuthers managed to catch the comment before it was deleted, writing on Instagram Stories, “We, too, believe that we are real and real. Glad to give tutorials on switching between your personal and fan accounts”.

The plot then thickened when a friend of Madison’s chimed in and took responsibility for the comment, writing “Oops. I thought I wrote that comment about my account being real, but was logged into Madi’s from when she came back from filming. Don’t hate me @madiprew.”

Madison wrote back “hahahaha you’re good. It happens love youuuu.” But, like, obviously there are a lot of unanswered questions here. Questions like, who TF gives someone their Instagram password? Anyway, fans have doubts, with comments like “it’s happening?!?????? That literally never happens.🤣” and “definitely Jan 😂.