Amazon and Google discounted their smart speakers so deeply in the holiday sales that they likely lost money on each unit, say analysts. Amazon discounted its Echo Dot to $29.99 in the run-up to the holidays, with the Google Home Mini also seen for the same price in various sales.

The two companies’ willingness to lose money on the hardware reveals their very different strategy to Apple with its upcoming HomePod speaker …

Reuters reports that while Apple wants to make money from both the hardware and additional Apple Music subscriptions, Google and Amazon are willing to pay for the data gathered from their speakers.

Both companies took small losses or broke even on sales of the hockey puck-shaped devices, analysts estimated. The Echo Dot has about $31 worth of parts, according to analysis by ABI Research. Components in the Google Home Mini cost about $26. The figures do not include overhead, shipping and other expenses, meaning discounted versions likely sold at a loss […] Apple aims to make a profit on the device itself and bolster sales of its $9.99 per month Apple Music subscription, analysts said. Apple’s voice assistant Siri likely will focus on recommending new songs. Amazon and Google, meanwhile, are eager to give consumers a taste of their respective digital assistants, Alexa and Google Assistant, at impulse-buy prices, hoping to lock in customers and profit from later sales of goods and data about buying habits.

Views are split on the likely impact of the discounted speakers when the HomePod goes on sale. My colleague Zac wrote yesterday about the possible impact of the increased competition in the market, especially when you can combine an Amazon Dot with a Sonos Play:3 to get something which would match both the smarts and the audio quality of the HomePod.

Analysts cited by Reuters agree.

“That kind of pricing is great for consumers and bad for Apple,” said Paul Erickson, a senior analyst with IHS Markit […] “Apple is in a bit of trouble,” said Adam Wright, senior research analyst at IDC, who estimated that about 35 million smart speakers had been installed worldwide as of a couple of weeks ago – not including U.S. Christmas sales. “We’ve witnessed an explosion in the last six months.”

An alternative view put forward in the piece is that anyone who has only bought one of the discounted Amazon or Google devices isn’t that invested in it.

Some consumers might consider a $30 speaker to be cheap enough to throw away and not a barrier to buying the Apple device when it arrives.

Personally, I’m sufficiently deeply embedded into the Apple ecosystem that I haven’t bought any competing IAs. I’m also currently satisfied with my Apple Watch as a means of controlling things around the home, and see no great benefit in sticking Siri inside a speaker – but know enough to acknowledge that my view may change once I’ve experienced the HomePod. What are your views?

Image: Time

Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news:

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news: