Harley-Davidson workers say plant closure after tax cut is like a bad dream

Candy Woodall | York (Pa.) Daily Record

Show Caption Hide Caption Video: America First tax cuts didn't save Harley's Kansas City plant America First tax cuts didn't save Harley-Davidson's Kansas City plant

YORK, Pa. — Harley-Davidson workers across the USA are reeling from the planned closure of the motorcycle maker's Kansas City plant, even as the firm is expected to reap huge financial benefits from the federal corporate tax cut.

The Milwaukee-based motorcycle manufacturer benefited from the tax cuts enacted Jan. 1, then announced cuts of 350 jobs across the company in late January. On Feb. 5 , it approved a half-cent dividend increase and buyback of up to 15 million shares.

Harley’s U.S. sales have been sinking in recent years as Boomers decide they are becoming too old to continue riding and fewer younger people step up to take their place. As a result, Harley said it was forced to cut excess factory capacity.

“Unfortunately there is nothing that could have been done to address the pressure of excess capacity we have in the U.S. market,” Harley said in a statement.

The company maintains that the dividend increase and stock buyback are unrelated to the tax savings.

► May 21: Loud Harleys: Is motorcycle noise sweet harmony or out-of-control din?

► May 11: Harley-Davidson to ship work to Thailand from U.S. plant, union says

► May 10: Shareholders ask questions, but media kept out of annual meeting

Workers say they are dismayed.

“We did everything Harley-Davidson asked us to do,” welder Tim Primeaux said in an NBC News interview that aired last week. "To have it all blow up in your face is kind of disappointing.”

When Harley-Davidson announced in January that it would slash 800 jobs upon closing the Kansas City plant by fall 2019, Primeaux said he and other workers were in a state of "shock and awe."

“It was like I was in a bad dream, just stuck in it," Primeaux told the network.

In May 2017, Harley-Davidson had announced it was adding 118 workers at its Kansas City plant to consolidate Softail cruiser motorcycles and laying off the same number of workers at its Springettsbury Township facility near York, Pa.

Now with the Kansas City closure, 450 full-time, casual and contractor positions will be added in Pennsylvania, yielding a loss of 350 jobs overall.

Days after it announced the plant closure, the company announced the dividend increase that would reward shareholders and cost the company about $846,000.

The stock buyback plan, which has the effect of boosting share prices, was another expense of $696 million at the time, both to benefit shareholders. That came on the heels of the company's corporate tax cut from 35% to 21% percent and its previous announcement last year that a new motorcycle assembly plant in Thailand would open later this year.

Harley has said the opening of the Bangkok plant is unrelated to the Kansas City closure

► April 24: Harley-Davidson profit falls as U.S. motorcycle sales remain weak

► April 20: Harley-Davidson seeks 8 interns to ride motorcycles for the summer

Rick Pence, who has worked at the Kansas City plant for 21 years, isn't buying that.

"They are sending our jobs overseas. Absolutely," said Pence, a machine repairman.

Milwaukee-based Harley has similar operations in India and Brazil, where complete motorcycles are assembled from kits. The Thai tariff on motorcycles assembled in the United States is about 60%, according to Harley.

“By opening this plant, we expect our regional (Asian) operations to help reduce those costs,” Harley spokeswoman Katie Whitmore said last year.

Company executives were asked multiple times what it would take to keep the plant in Kansas City, according to Kevin Amos, president Local Lodge 176 of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers whose members work at Harley-Davidson's Kansas City plant. He also has worked 17 years for the bike maker.



He said he was under the impression workers were doing everything to keep the company in Missouri.



“We thought we had met the mark. Clearly we didn’t,” Amos said.

The workers agreed they have loved working for Harley-Davidson, and Pence said he felt like he had won the lottery when he got hired.

Primeaux still is holding hope company leaders will change their minds and keep the plant open in Kansas City — not just for himself, but for his three daughters.

► March 14: Harley-Davidson going all-in on electric motorcycles

► March 6: Harley-Davidson responds to threat of EU tariffs on its bikes

“If my girls want to work there, it’s a good place to work,” he said to NBC News.

When Harley-Davidson received news of the tax cut in September, House Speaker Paul Ryan said reform meant companies like Harley would be able to keep jobs in America.

In January, a CNBC survey of the 100 largest companies by market capitalization determined that's not happening, and only 10 of those companies said they planned to use the tax savings to boost worker pay. Harley, part of the S&P 500, is not in the S&P 100.

► March 1: Harley-Davidson invests in Alta Motors electric bike company

► Feb. 18: Harley still to close Kansas City plant despite Missouri delegation plea

But Primeaux isn't holding the survey results against Congress or President Trump.

“I blame the company more than I blame the president," he said.

Contributing: Rick Barrett, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Follow Candy Woodall on Twitter: @candynotcandace

Related

► Feb. 9: Harley-Davidson tries to regain its coolness factor

► Feb. 7: Harley recalls nearly 175K bikes in U.S. because brakes can fail

► Jan. 30: Harley-Davidson closing Kansas City plant as motorcycle sales fall

► Jan. 17: Harley-Davidson needs to rev up Millennials about motorcycles

► Dec. 26: Amid sales drop, Harley-Davidson wants to teach more to ride