Azmin Ali Taken To Court Over Unpaid Sandakan Travel Bill - EXCLUSIVE

According to a writ lodged in the KL Sessions Court last week, Economics Minister Azmin Ali, who is also Deputy President of Malaysia’s biggest parliamentary party PKR, ran up a staggering travel bill of over RM300,000 ringgit, mainly for private family trips, in the course of just six months this year.

Also listed in the claim brought by his travel agency for alleged unpaid costs, is the bill for what has become a notorious visit to Sandakan in May (leaving KL on 10th and returning 11th) during which Santubong Youth PKR Chief, Haziq Abdullah Abdul Aziz has claimed he was filmed having a sex session with his senior party boss at the Four Points Hotel.

The material, which Azmin says is fake and a smear, has been widely distributed on WhatsApp. Police investigators say they have not proven its authenticity and are conducting a probe into who was guilty of circulating the intimate hour long video.

What is not in dispute is that Azmin Ali was campaigning in Sandakan at that time and the travel company, who say they arranged his flights, are now suing him for non-payment of this and an extensive list of other travel services, following what they say have been numerous requests for him to honour the bill.

Astonishing RM300,000 Travel Bill Run Up In Just Six Months

Perhaps more noteworthy than the apparent failure to pay for a return local flight, is the staggering size of the over-all bill of over RM300,000 that the company, YHA Travel & Tours, alleges Azmin ran up in the course of just six months for flights alone, which they claim he has never disputed.

They say he has merely refused on this occasion to pay it:

Despite repeated demand of payments by the Plaintiff and/or its representative from the Defendant and/or his representative, the Aggregate Amount has not been forthcoming even though the claimed sum was never disputed.

[Par 12 – writ WA-B52NCvC-505-11/2019 KL Sessions Court]

The writ continues by saying this has broken an established pattern by which Azmin (described as a frequent traveller) would arrange to pay or send a representative to pay bills much more promptly:

Due to the frequency of their travels, and by mutual understanding between the Plaintiff and the Defendant, payments have always been made and/or arranged by the Defendant and/or his representative every 1 to 6 months….

However, in this instance, the payments have been outstanding for far longer than the aforesaid time frame.” [Pars 9-10]

The Economics Minister, who is seen as a contender seeking to leapfrog his boss in the succession to the top job, has merely listed his ministerial salary (RM50,000 per month) and a house worth just over one million ringgit in the declaration of assets that all elected parliamentarians are now required to submit under new laws.

Under the circumstances it is therefore hard to understand how he ran up such enormous outstanding sums with a view to being able to meet the bill – many of the flights are for family members, who appear to have travelled business:

See the full list of travel laid out in court: Farah Shazliyana Mohamed Azmin – 3000/F0003 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) 1. Farah Shazliyana Mohamed Azmin2. Mohamad Syaqib Zainuddin3. Farah Inayah Rose 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 8,510.00 Total 8,510.00 Farah Afifah Mohamed Azmin – 3000/F0004 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) Farah Afifah Mohamed Azmin 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 3,880.00 Total 3,880.00 Farah Amira Mohamed Azmin – 3000/F0005 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) Farah Amira Mohamed Azmin 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 3,880.00 29.3.2019 Kuala LumpurtoJohor Bahru 370.00 31.3.2019 Johor BahrutoKuala Lumpur 430.00 17.5.2019 Kuala LumpurtoJakarta(Same-day return) 1720.00 Total 6,400.00 Mohamed Basheer Noor Alhaq Mohd Azmin – 3000/M0029 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) Mohamed Basheer Noor Alhaq Mohd Azmin 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 3,880.00 17.2.2019 – 29.3.2019 Kuala LumpurtoLondon Heathrow(Return) 28,260.00550.00(Change of date penalty) 5.5.2019 – 28.5.2019 Kuala LumpurtoLondon Heathrow(Return) 27,650.00 Total 60,340.00 Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin – 3000/M0030 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) 1. Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin2. Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 7,760.00 1. Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin2. Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 19.2.2019 – 20.2.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang (Return) 4,398.00 1. Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin2. Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 31.1.2019 – 6.2.2019 Kuala LumpurtoGold Coast, Australia (Return) 11,030.00 (flight)1,160.00 (lux airport transfer) Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin 11.3.2019 – 18.3.2019 Kuala LumpurtoGeneva (Return) 15,800.00600.00(Change of date penalty) Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 11.3.2019 – 16.3.2019 DubaitoGenevatoKuala Lumpur Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin 14.3.2019 – 18.3.2019 GenevatoLondon Heathrow(Return) 1,630.00 Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 14.3.2019 – 18.3.2019 GenevatoLondon Heathrow(Return) 62.00 Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin 18.3.2019 London HeathrowtoKuala Lumpur 5,010.00 1. Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin2. Mazreen Shanim Shaheen3. Mohammad Azlan Alias 25.3.2019 – 28.3.2019 Kuala LumpurtoLangkawi 2,300.00 Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin 12.4.2019 –14.4.2019 Kuala LumpurtoSingapore 2,400.00 Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 12.4.2019 –14.4.2019 Kuala LumpurtoSingapore 2,050.00 Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin 16.5.2019 Kuala LumpurtoSingapore(Same-day return) 2,400.00 Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin 6.6.2019 – 9.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoBangkok(Return) 1,380.00 1. Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin2. Mazreen Shanim Shaheen 22.7.2019 Kuala LumpurtoLondon Heathrow 34,300.00 26.7.2019 SantorinitoBarcelona 26.7.2019 BarcelonatoNice 30.7.2019 NicetoLondon Heathrow 5.8.2019 London HeathrowtoKuala Lumpur Total 92,280.00 Mohamed Yusuf Alsadiq Mohamed Azmin – 3000/M0042 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) Mohamed Yusuf Alsadiq Mohamed Azmin 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 3,880.00 Mohamed Yusuf Alsadiq Mohamed Azmin 12.4.2019 London HeathrowtoKuala Lumpur 800.00(Change of date penalty) Mohamed Yusuf Alsadiq Mohamed Azmin 5.5.2019 – 3.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoLondon Heathrow(Return) 27,650.00 Mohamed Yusuf Alsadiq Moha­med Azmin 9.6.2019 – 12.7.2019 Kuala LumpurtoLondon Heathrow(Return) 23,550.004,300.00(Change of date penalty) Total 60,180.00 Wan Putera Shahjuan Dato W Shalihudin – 3000/M0052 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) Wan Putera Shahjuan Dato W Shalihudin 11.3.2019 – 17.3.2019 Kuala LumpurtoGeneva (Return) 400.00 Wan Putera Shahjuan Dato W Shalihudin 18.3.2019 London HeathrowtoKuala Lumpur 2,170.00 Total 2,570.00 Pejabat Kementerian Hal Ehwal Ekonomi – 3000/P0016 Traveler Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 10.9.2018 Kuala LumpurtoHanoi 3,560.00 13.9.2018 HanoitoKuala Lumpur 13.9.2018 Kuala LumpurtoPenang 14.9.2018 PenangtoKuala Lumpur 14.9.2018 Kuala LumpurtoKota Kinabalu 16.9.2018 Kota KinabalutoSingapore 17.9.2018 SingaporetoKuala Lumpur Woon King Chai 10.9.2018 – 13.9.2018 Kuala LumpurtoHanoi (Return) 1,500.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 18.12.2018 – 22.12.2018 Kuala LumpurToJeddah (Return) 14,500.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 10.4.2019 – 11.4.2019 Kuala LumpurtoSingapore (Return) 3,538.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 28.4.2019 BeijingtoKuala Lumpur 10,079.00 Credit Note (976.00) Total 32,201.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali – 3000/Y0002 Traveller Date Origin – Destination Amount Due (RM) 1. YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali2. Shamshida Taharin 30.12.2018 MarrakechtoLondon Gatwick 13,760.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 11.1.2019 Century Pines Resort 1,650.00(1 night, 3 bedrooms) Suzumi Sudir 11.1.2019 Century Pines Resort 550.00 Muhammad Hilman Idham 11.1.2019 Century Pines Resort 550.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 14.1.2019 SingaporetoKuala Lumpur 282.00 (Change of date penalty) Suzumi Sudir 13.1.2019 JohortoKuala Lumpur 300.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 19.3.2019 SubangtoAlor Setar 50.00 (Fee for seat assignment) YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 10.5.2019 to 11.5.2019 Kuala LumpurtoSandakan (Return) 1,080.00 Suzumi Sudir 10.5.2019 to 11.5.2019 Kuala LumpurtoSandakan (Return) 1,080.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 16.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang(Same-day return) 3,650.00 Suzumi Sudir 16.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang(Same-day return) 3,650.00 Muhammad Hilman Idham 16.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang(Same-day return) 3,650.00 Saiful Asraf Idris 16.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang(Same-day return) 2,350.00 YB Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Bin Ali 29.6.2019 – 30.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang 3,050.00 Suzumi Sudir 29.6.2019 – 30.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang 3,050.00 Muhammad Hilman Idham 29.6.2019 – 30.6.2019 Kuala LumpurtoPenang 3,050.00 Total 41,752.00

According to the figures laid out in the claim Azmin ran up the RM300,000 between last September and June on what appear to have been a series of business/first class flights for various members of his family across the world.

They include a New Year’s break in Morocco that became widely reported after it emerged the Azmin family spent time at a luxury resort together with a senior political rival, ex-Defence Minister Hishamuddin Hussein, who is the cousin of disgraced ex-PM Najib Razak now facing multiple charges over 1MDB.

Athough all of Azmin’s six children are now adult the minister continues to pay for them and spouses to join him on holiday, according to the billing laid out in the statement of claim. Sarawak Report has enquired as to whether the Minister expects them to pay him back and if so how?

Including interest, the travel company says it is now owed RM328,901 plus damages and costs largely run up by the Azmin family’s leisure trips:

Nearly Rm100,000 (RM92,280.00) of the total bill appears to have been run up in flights enjoyed by the minister’s newly-wed son Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin and his spouse Mazreen Shanim Shaheen during their travel to Marrakech, London and Geneva. The lavish wedding ceremonies of the couple and that of another sibling were society high points in KL over recent months.

The bill does not include hotels and other expenses involved in the trips, which raise concerns about further potential costs. Azmin is known to favour London’s top hotel Claridge’s when he comes to the UK (where he has frequently come to visit his children), which costs around RM4,500 a night according to online booking sites:

Son Mohamed Ameer Shazrin Mohamed Azmin’s Facebook postings over the past couple of years have revealed he also has expensive tastes.

He in the past uploaded a plethora of pictures boasting himself in first/business class cabins, wearing large quantities of designer clothing, enjoying top global holiday destinations, five star restaurants and expensive tickets to international sports events. These have been removed in recent weeks according to followers. Whether the family funded the items or whether they were gifted (and if so by whom) was not detailed.

The pattern extends to other children in the family. According to reports, another daughter boasted on Facebook about her seat 1A (premier class) on a flight to London as recently as September before pulling down the posting. The designer outfits and accessories boasted by the family over the years has caused criticism on social media:

Sarawak Report has forwarded a request for comment on this matter to the Economic Minister’s office, asking if he confirms the travel bills cited in the writ are genuine and undisputed, as claimed, and if so how he had planned to pay the bill?

Customer for Two Decades

Whatever the reason for Azmin’s alleged failure to pay this latest bill, the writ makes clear the travel firm claims a long relationship with this client going back twenty years, which now appears to have broken down:

The Plaintiff and Defendant have had a long-standing history of business relationship which spans approximately 20 years. These separate account numbers with the Plaintiff are as per the Defendant’s instructions. (client to confirm)

During this period, the Plaintiff has been instructed by the Defendant (whether by himself or through his representative) to make travel arrangements for the Defendant’s colleagues and/or family members and/or business associates and/or friends [Pars 4-5]

In the past Azmin had paid up in reasonable time, the travel film claims. There is no indication as to whether the scandal that broke out over the Sandakan trip, one of the last items listed on the bill, is in any way linked to the sudden dispute with the agency.

However, in order to establish whether the RM300,000 bill was especially high or an abberation, Sarawak Report contacted YHA and has learnt there is believed to be nothing unusual in the scale of the sum spent on travel by this client compared to other bills in recent years.

Our informantion is that the minister’s travel bills have been in the region of one million ringgit annually and that these have been settled in the past by a regular third party envoy, who paid the KL office in cash.

Sarawak Report has requested confirmation from the minister about the role of the individual named as the intermediary for these cash settlements and for his own comments on the matter.