The category was “Jacket Required” and when a picture of Jim James popped up as the $1000 question on Jeopardy, many of us would’ve been in the money on this one.

Thankfully, Emlen was able to buzz in and wow Trebek with his My Morning Jacket knowledge. Unfortunately the extra grand in his pocket didn’t put him in the lead, as he chased Kevin for the title.

The band was alerted of their appearance on the show and tweeted out the below video.