SnK S3E14 Poll Results (Manga Reader Version)

The poll closed with 355 responses. Thank you to everyone who participated!

Please note that these are the results of the manga reader poll. Anime only watchers are suggested not to read if you do not wish to be spoiled about certain events! Anime only viewers, click here to view your poll results!

RATE THE EPISODE

346 Responses

Despite some negatives about the animation of this episode, 87% of the fandom enjoyed it overall, giving it positive votes!

Animation’s not movie quality, but damn it was a good episode

I think it lacks some kind of tempo: some moments are stretched out, others are too short.

Could’ve been paced better, better music choices, less cgi roof shingle focus and could have cut the thunder spear flashback or at least have shortened it… but it didn’t look terrible. Although, I wish the fight had a bit more “weight” to it, with moments such as eren punching reiner ( “This is the place where I once called home!” )

Loved it!

Reiner Vs Eren looked a bit stiff, but overall it was a great episode.

The mUSIC WAS SO BOMB

IT WAS SO GOOD I CANT WAIT FOR THE NEXT ONE WIT NEVER CEASES TO IMPRESS



WHICH OF THE FOLLOWING WAS YOUR FAVORITE MOMENT?

346 Responses

Levi agreeing to fight the Beast Titan was the winner in this category with 31.5% of the vote. The Thunder Spears in action come in second place and Levi sassing Erwin in third.

Levi the madman not losing any of his sass

Liked Erwin’s monologue

Reiner and Erwin’s inner monologue was pretty nice in this episode imo. I like the manga just as much as the anime but hearing their voices in the anime, especially Erwin’s, made those scenes heavier and much more real to me.

Hange looked amazing!

WEAPONRY! It’s the way to get it done! WEAPONRY! It’s effective and it’s fun!





WHO DID YOU FIND YOURSELF ROOTING FOR MORE?

346 Responses

With the 81.8% of the votes, Eren was getting the majority of cheers from the fandom, while only the 18.2% were rooting for Reiner.

Seeing Anime people hating Reiner hurts my feelings. Specially because it will take a lot of time until we see the Marley arc





WHICH SIDE OF THE WALL WOULD YOU RATHER BE ON?

345 Responses

89.3% of respondents agree that they’d much rather be inside of Shiganshina facing off with Reiner than dealing with the threat of the Beast Titan.





STRATEGY MAPS: WHO DID IT BETTER?

345 Responses

This question has a more equal response, with 54.2% of the fandom believing that Isayama did it better with the Strategy Maps while the 45.8% preferred WIT’s animation of it.





HOW MUCH DID YOU SYMPATHIZE WITH ERWIN AS HE REFLECTED ON HIMSELF?

348 Responses

33.3% of the fandom sit directly in the middle between sympathizing with Erwin and feeling that he needs to shoulder the responsibility of his decisions, while 28.2% of respondents truly sympathize with him.



Erwin’s speech was the moment I was holding my breath for in this episode, and it was done justice. Not as impactful to me personally as the manga version, but justice done. And that’s all I’m asking for.

That look on dead!Mike’s face… It was revolting, because real, alive Mike would never have looked at his best friend like that. And that just tells us how terrible Erwin’s own perception of himself is… God, he deserves a hug. :’(





HOW MUCH DOES IT HURT TO SEE THE 104TH ATTACKING REINER?

347 Responses

This answer had a lot of relatively equal votes! About 40% of respondents overall didn’t feel too badly about the 104th attacking Reiner, while 23.3% of the fandom felt neither sad nor happy about seeing the 104th attacking Reiner.



104 kickin ass?!?! bless the lord?!?!

If I was anime only I would be happy seeing Reiner’s suffering. But as a manga reader I felt a bit of sadness when I saw him being attacked by the SC.





RATE HOW WELL THE ANIME ADAPTED THE CHAPTERS OVERALL:

347 Responses

The fandom seems very pleased with the adaptation of chapters 75-76, with 49.3% ranking it at a 4, while 36% of respondents gave it a 5.



I was so looking forward to Erwin’s reflection moment, especially the scene in which he stood on top of all of the corpses. Really well adaptated, just as I expected it to be (even though it was better in the manga, maybe because it was my first contact with it)

Great, faithfully adapting some aspects from the manga, but still the quality should’ve been a lot better. I hope WIT would rise the standard bar in the future episodes. Overall, it was satisfying to watch.





WERE YOU SATISFIED WITH THE ADAPTATION OF EREN VS. REINER?

347 Responses





Overall the fandom gives the adaptation a pass, with 64.6% of respondents feeling it went about as expected, while 21.3% believe that it was worse than their expectations. The remaining 14.1% felt it exceeded their expectations.



IMO they really could’ve done better with the OST in Eren vs Reiner fight.

Eren vs Reiner could’ve had better music to fit the scene. It was a little generic?

Although the adaptation of the Eren vs Reiner fight wasn’t as good as I was expecting, I still enjoyed the fight. Definitely wasn’t as disappointed as a lot of other people are. I just hope they do my Boi Bert justice next episode.





HOW PUMPED WERE YOU TO SEE PIECK’S TITAN UP CLOSE?

348 Responses

As expected of Pieck! With a slight winning edge, 36.8% are hyped for best girl, while 36.5% feel that WIT captured the eeriness of her titan perfectly! 10.6% felt she looked very cool.

I RABU MY CUTE WIFE PIKU

This design fits her more than the initial one Isayama did back when he wanted to have a middle aged man instead of Pieck. So yeah, I like this one more.

I feel like the Cart Titan looks more feminine than it does in the manga.

It’ll be very surprising if she suddenly talks or makes a short noise in the anime version lol

Cart Titan might be my favorite character design of any anime, cartoon, or show. She’s just as beautiful here as in the manga.

They made the eyes more feminine. But it clearly resembles Pieck

I’ve been waiting so long for this I’m satisfied and excited af :’)!!!





GIVEN WHAT HAPPENS LATER, DO YOU THINK ERWIN’S PLAN WAS A GOOD ONE?

347 Responses

64.6% of the fandom feel that Erwin’s plan is the best decision they could have made, while 16.7% feel that while the plan was good, there may have been better options.15.9% are still not sure of the answer.



I don’t even know my own name anymore

This episode really cemented the fact that Erwin never stopped caring about his dream to find out the truth of the world and that Levi made the wrong choice.

Erwin no





DO YOU FEEL THAT ERWIN’S REFLECTIVE MONOLOGUE HAD THE SAME WEIGHT AS IT DID IN THE MANGA?

344 Responses

Erwin’s self-reflection is an emotional part and adds important weight to Erwin’s character! 56.1% of the fandom thinks that the scene was as good as they remember it in the manga, while 25.3% were more deeply impacted by WIT’s rendition of the scene. 18% felt that it could have been done better.



I WAS NOT READY FOR ERWIN’S MOUNTAIN OF CORPSES I DID NOT KNOW IT WOULD HAPPEN SO SOON AND IT CRUSHED ME

WIT does action well, but character moments not so much. The mountain of corpses was almost too big imo. Somehow it had more impact in the manga. Making things bigger and more extreme doesn’t necessarily make them more intense in terms of emotional impact.





WHAT DID YOU THINK ABOUT THE ANIMATION AND SOUND EFFECTS OF THE THUNDER SPEARS?

345 Responses

Well over half of the fandom were pleased with the animation and effects of the Thunder Spears. We’ve been waiting a long time and it seems the vast majority of us were not disappointed! :’)



seeing some of the thunder spears in action made their function and operation easier to understand.

YAASSSSSSSSSSS!!! THUNDER SPEARS MAH BOISSS!!

Oh man I did not expect the thunder spears to make those high-pitched squeals but it was actually amazing

Thunder spearsssss





WHICH SCENE FROM THE PREVIEW ARE YOU MOST LOOKING FORWARD TO?

347 Responses

With 44% of the vote, manga readers are most looking forward to seeing the Bertl Bomb™! Following behind that at 23% is seeing Marco get eaten by Araki Titan, and 17% of respondents are looking forward to Armin and Bertolt’s confrontation.

I’m REALLY looking forward to watch Marco’s death (even though they already showed it in the Lost Girls OVA) and the flipping Serumbowl, which will be epic “

really good cliffhanger, left me uhhhh,,, hung

BERTPISODE WHEN

The ending scene really hyped me up for what’s coming

Can’t wait to see the corps get obliterated by rocks

GIVE ME THE BIG SWEATY……… LET ME ENJOY HIS LAST ANIMATED MOMENTS :(

These week long waits keep getting worse





ADDITIONAL THOUGHTS ON THE EPISODE?

WHERE’S MY MOBLIT? THEY CAN’T JUST KILL HIM OFFSCREEN WITHOUT EVER SHOWING HIM! :(

Seeing Anime people hating Reiner hurts my feelings. Specially because it will take a lot of time until we see the Marley arc

It was so so slow. I mean I loved every second of it but it was painfully slow, they showed every characters thoughts. Not a bad thing, but not good either idk. I guess it has to build up the tension before the battle.

Does Hanji get prettier with each passing episode?

Needs more Sawano

Aside from the slow/awkward reiner vs eren fight, the animations were honestly sO amazing! the smooth ODMG animations and the Thunder Spears—even down to Reiner sliding back down the wall; it was verryy impressive! In addition, the pacing is honestly perfect and it draws out quite the tension and emotion! Loved it!

I remember reading Eren saying "This is where I…where we..once called home! I’m taking it back!” in the manga and I was like “YES! DO IT!!” but in the anime it didn’t have that feeling. Not to mention that the OP had a better punch animation than the actual episode? The second half of the brawl felt more in tune (probably helped by the music that carried from Erwin’s part of the episode).

I hope there are gonna be as little changes as possible. WIT butchered one arc already, let’s hope they won’t repeat those mistakes.





WHERE DO YOU PRIMARILY DISCUSS THE SERIES?

331 Responses



Thank you to everyone who participated! We’ll see you again in a few days!