Abstract:

Selecting among alternative projects is a core management task in all innovating organizations. In this paper, we focus on the evaluation of frontier scientific research projects. We argue that the “intellectual distance” between the knowledge embodied in research proposals and an evaluator’s own expertise systematically relates to the evaluations given. To estimate relationships, we designed and executed a grant proposal process at a leading research university in which we randomized the assignment of evaluators and proposals to generate 2,130 evaluator–proposal pairs. We find that evaluators systematically give lower scores to research proposals that are closer to their own areas of expertise and to those that are highly novel. The patterns are consistent with biases associated with boundedly rational evaluation of new ideas. The patterns are inconsistent with intellectual distance simply contributing “noise” or being associated with private interests of evaluators. We discuss implications for policy, managerial intervention, and allocation of resources in the ongoing accumulation of scientific knowledge.

Read full text

Reference:

Looking Across and Looking Beyond the Knowledge Frontier: Intellectual Distance, Novelty, and Resource Allocation in Science. Kevin J. Boudreau, Eva C. Guinan, Karim R. Lakhani, and Christoph Riedl. Management Science, 2016 62:10, 2765-2783.

Looking Across and Looking Beyond the Knowledge Frontier: Intellectual Distance, Novelty, and Resource Allocation in Science

Tropical rainforest, Queensland, Australia. Photo by Dr. Rohan Davis.

Analytical equipment. Photo by Atanas G. Atanasov.

Hep-2 signal activated cells. Image by Dr. Vassilis Doucas.

Flower blossoms at gardens by the bay Singapore-photo by Dr. Hemanth Kumar Boyina.

Saffron plants, Zapponeta (Foggia), South of Italy. Photo by Dr. Grazia D'Onofrio.

Blood cells colored with fluorescence dye. Photo by Dr. Davide Barreca.

Substance library. Photo by Dr. Nikolay Tzvetkov.

Lichens of the Eastern Morocco, Oujda, Morocco. Photo by Dr. Khalid El Bairi ©.

The Botanical Garden of Department of Pharmacognosy, University of Vienna, Austria. Photo by Atanas G. Atanasov.

Lagoon of the seven cities, a twin lake in the crater of a dormant volcano in the western part of the São Miguel island (Azores, Portugal). Photo by Dr. Ana Sanches Silva.

Central Australian desert scene. Photo by Dr. Rohan Davis.

HEK293T cells. Photo by Atanas G. Atanasov.

Tropical rainforest, Queensland, Australia. Photo by Dr. Rohan Davis.

Australian ocean scene. Photo by Dr. Rohan Davis.

Laboratory equipment. Photo by Atanas G. Atanasov.

Rhododendron arboreum flower. Photo by Devesh Tewari.

The Valley of Flowers, Himalaya, India. Photo by Dr. Rajeshwari Singh.

Bryce Canyon, Utah, USA. Photo by Dr. Anupam Bishayee.

Euphorbia prolifera Buch. (Ham) Ex. Photo by Devesh Tewari.

Foothills of Himalaya, India. Photo by Devesh Tewari.

The Valley of Flowers, Himalaya, India. Photo by Dr. Rajeshwari Singh.

Eco-School Festival, Leiria-Portugal, Spring 2018

Polygonum maritimum (L.) (Polygonaceae)- Ourdania beach (Ain Temouchent- west Algeria)- taken by PhD. EL HACI Imad Abdelhamid

Flower blossoms at gardens by the bay Singapore-photo by Dr. Hemanth Kumar Boyina.

Keywords: scientific knowledge, grant proposals, intellectual distance, novelty, resource allocation in science, innovating organizations, evaluation of frontier scientific research projects.

Join for free INPST as a member

The International Natural Product Sciences Taskforce (INPST) maintains up-to-date lists with conferences, grants and funding opportunities, jobs and open positions, and journal special issues with relevance for the area of phytochemistry and food chemistry, pharmacology, pharmacognosy research, and natural product science.