13 Reasons Why seems to have forgotten all about Hannah Baker in Season 3. While the Netflix teen melodrama’s second season felt bogged down by constant appearances from Hannah’s ghost, everyone seems to have a more pressing matter to deal with now: figuring out who killed Bryce Walker.

The season’s first teaser-trailer posed that very question, as a disembodied voice narrated: “Here’s the thing about the kids at Liberty High. They’re connected by their secrets. Connected and forever changed. The truth is, given the right circumstances, the right motivation, anyone could have done this.” The list of possible killers is, indeed, long; Bryce was a bully and a rapist, and therefore not the most well-liked guy in school.

Still, our old pal Clay appears to be in the most trouble here. The trailer cuts to his nervous-looking face when everyone learns that Bryce has been found dead, and he’s seen getting perp-walked out of the school before the trailer ends. He insists to his mother that he didn’t do anything, but she shoots back, “But the police think that you did.” Given Clay’s obsession over the past two seasons with finding justice for Hannah, whose suicide occurred soon after Bryce raped her, it’s not hard to imagine him doing this.

That said, there are plenty of other suspects as well. There’s “the person Bryce Walker hurt the most,” Jessica Davis—whom he raped at a party while she was passed out. There’s bullied Tyler, who has a gun. There’s Monty, who pins Tyler against a wall, asking, “What’d you tell em, man?” There’s Justin, who was dating Jessica when Bryce raped her, and who now is also seen holding a gun. And then there’s Tony, whom we see walked into a police interrogation room in handcuffs. Whoever did this, it appears the truth is about to come out—but not before a lot of twist and turns. The next season of 13 Reasons Why premieres August 23.

More Great Stories from Vanity Fair

— Our September cover story: how Kristen Stewart keeps cool

— The lowdown on Lion King’s billion-dollar haul

— Why is Quentin Tarantino (supposedly) retiring from filmmaking?

— What the surfer-mom influencers of Byron Bay reveal about our world

— The horrors of Jeffrey Epstein’s private island

Looking for more? Sign up for our daily Hollywood newsletter and never miss a story.