Quoted By:

No. First off, if they had just gone in, they would've at least taken goblins down with them. With her plan, they were left starving and freezing, which left them as very easy pickings for the goblins. The only thing her plan ended up accomplishing is giving GS's party more time to save her as the goblins waited until NF's party was weak.Second of all, her plan was to try and starve goblins with only a couple weeks of supplies on a freezing cold mountain? Not only that, but refuse to retreat when things start going awry because "mh honor". Yeah sure, she's not to blame here. Even if the end result was that the party was defeated either way, they didn't have to die starving in the cold while hardly able to defend themselves.