Pulling Whiskey Cavalier from the field after its freshman run was both “a very tough decision” as well as the final decision that ABC entertainment chief Karey Burke made ahead of announcing the schedule for the 2019-20 TV season.

The Whiskey premiere was given a cushy sneak-preview following the Academy Awards in February. But the show’s numbers had eroded ever since, and as of May 9 — when it hit season lows — its 0.57 demo average made it ABC’s third-lowest-rated drama (besting only fellow midseason entries The Fix and For the People, both of which have also been cancelled).

Related stories

Fresh Off the Boat Controversy: ABC Boss Weighs In on Recast Option in Wake of Constance Wu's Job Conflict

ABC Fall Schedule: Million Little Things Stays With #TGIT, Rookie on the Move

With DVR playback, though, it enjoyed the third-largest boost of any ABC series, rising 117 percent in the demo.

“We felt like we gave it a very strong launch this spring and it had its chance to do what it could do,” Burke told reporters on Tuesday morning. But at the end of the day, “we lost audience” and opted to instead “try something new” — the Cobie Smulders-led Stumptown — in that Wednesday time slot.

Series co-lead Scott Foley addressed the cancellation (alongside tearful wife/guest star wife Marika Dominczyk) in a May 12 Instagram video, calling the decision a “tough call” for ABC.

Sign up for TVLine's Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.