Did you know This Is Us stars Milo Ventimiglia and Jon Huertas were both guest stars on Sabrina the Teenage Witch?

If there’s anything we love these days as consumers of pop culture, it’s nostalgia. We like it, we love it, we want some more of it! With reboots and revivals popping up left and rights, we seemingly can’t get enough of looking back into the past to inform the present — kind of like an episode of This Is Us. While the Sabrina the Teenage Witch reboot will soon hit Netflix, it’s time to look back at Milo Ventimiglia and Jon Huertas’ guest appearances on the original favorite.

Sabrina the Teenage Witch aired for seven magically hilarious seasons on ABC’s iconic TGIF lineup (and later The WB for three seasons of Sabrina’s college years) and helped to define a generation. Melissa Joan Hart starred as a teen witch trying to balance her secret supernatural life with her mortal existence. But did you know Milo Ventimiglia and Jon Huertas once encountered Sabrina Spellman’s magic touch?

You know Jon Huertas as Miguel on This Is Us, Jack Pearson’s best friend and Rebecca Pearson’s eventual second husband. But back in the ’90s, Huertas was still cutting his teeth in TV with guest roles on shows such as Beverly Hills, 90210; Moesha; Time of Your Life; Touched by an Angel and many others.

Before co-starring in ABC’s Castle and later NBC’s tearjerker phenomenon, Huertas dropped by Sabrina’s neck of the woods. That’s right, for 11 episodes in the fourth season, Huertas played Harvey’s friend Brad. You probably didn’t even know you crushed on Miguel in 1999!

via GIPHY

Likewise, before finding fame in The WB’s enduring classic Gilmore Girls, Milo Ventimiglia spent much of his early career jumping from one television series to the next in one-episode roles. It’s weird to think of a time when Ventimiglia wasn’t making as swoon as Jess Mariano or Jack Pearson, but here we are.

Interestingly enough, Milo Ventimiglia’s second credit ever as an actor comes from a tiny bit part in the fourth episode of Sabrina the Teenage Witch’s first season. His character doesn’t even have a name and he only says four words (“I’m voting for her”), but his quintessential ’90s heartthrob look definitely made an impression!

Check out Milo’s scene in the video below!

Clearly, we should be combing through more episodes of Sabrina the Teenage Witch in search of additional This Is Us stars hiding in the background. Justin Hartley, Mandy Moore, Sterling K. Brown… has Sabrina cast a spell on you? If anything, it’s a perfect game to play during an overdue binge-watch of one of television’s most spellbinding (and nostalgic!) sitcoms.

Were you aware of this connection between This Is Us and Sabrina the Teenage Witch? Can you believe both Milo Ventimiglia and Jon Huertas guest starred on the TGIF sitcom? Will you be tracking down their episodes? Let us know in the comments, and keep the nostalgic conversation going over on Twitter at @thisisuscrying!

This Is Us airs Tuesdays at 9/8c on NBC. All seven seasons of Sabrina the Teenage Witch is available to stream on Hulu.