There are bad Tinder dates, and then there are Tinder dates in actual hell—like when you get stuck on a boat cruising around Lake Michigan for five hours with a gaggle of other girls from the dating app.

Kayla Hutch has lived this Tinder nightmare.

The Chicago resident originally matched with a guy named Emad six months ago, in March. He’d been flirting with her and asking her on dates for a while, but she always turned him down because she wasn’t quite into the guy. But when Emad invited her onto a boat over Labor Day weekend, Kayla simply couldn’t refuse.

Sounds like a perfect way to celebrate the end of the summer, right? But there was trouble on the horizon.

“When I got there I could tell something was up because he was kind of standoffish, which seemed weird considering he’d been trying to get a date with me for six months and had sent five texts that morning confirming I was going to be there,” Hutch told the Daily Dot. “However, I thought he was just shy so I went on the boat. There were about 20 women and 5 men on the boat, so I ended up talking to some 21-year-olds. I asked how they knew the guys and they said they’d met Emad on Tinder and this was the first time they’d gotten together.”

On the left are their original conversations on Tinder, the right their texts leading up to the boat setting sail on Lake Michigan. Screengrabs via Kayla Hutch

Realizing that Emad had bamboozled her with a surprise group date like something out of ABC’s The Bachelor, Kayla went over to a corner to sulk. She said she would’ve tried to swim the 300 feet back to land—but she never learned how. So instead she started posting to Facebook, broadcasting the whole scenario live.