2014 Shamus Beaglehole

2013 Leo Moses Spornstarr

2012 No vote held

2011 Taco B.M. Monster(NOTY High Committee and The People)

2010 Nohjay Nimpson (NOTY High Committee); Steele Sidebottom (The People)

2009 Juvyline Cubangbang (NOTY High Committee); Barkevious Mingo (The People)

2008 Destiny Frankenstein (NOTY High Committee); Spaceman Africa (The People)

2007 Vanilla Dong (NOTY High Committee and The People)

2006 Princess Nocandy

2005 Tanqueray Beavers

2004 Jerome Fruithandler

2003 Jew Don Boney Jr.

2002 Miracle Wanzo

2001 Tokyo Sexwale

2000 Nimrod Weiselfish

1999 Licentious Beastie (INVALIDATED 2006; Runner-up: Dick Surprise)

1998 L.A. St. Louis

1997 Courage Shabalala

1996 Honka Monka

1995 Ballots missing

1994 Mummenschontz Bitterbeetle (INVALIDATED 2006; Runner-up: Scientific Mapp)

1993 Crescent Dragonwagon

1992 Excellent Raymond

1992 Assumption Bulltron (Name of the Decade)

1991 Doby Chrotchtangle

1990 Otis Overcash

1989 Magnus Pelkowski

1988 No vote held

1987 No vote held

1986 No vote held

1985 Godfrey Sithole

1984 No vote held

1983 Hector Camacho