We’ve made a lot of euphoric flavors over the years, but, for better or worse, some of them have moved on to the great waffle cone in the sky. Tears of sadness are shed for our dearly de-pinted flavors, and we receive several thousand requests each year from our fans begging us to rein-cone-ate their favorite fallen flavor. Here are the most mourned of the bunch…and who knows? One of them may rise from the graveyard once again!

1. Oatmeal Cookie Chunk Sweet Cream Cinnamon Ice Cream with Chunks of Oatmeal Cookies & Fudge Limited Batch 2003

Full-Time Flavor 2004-2012 From the moment that this oatmeal went

There’s been no end to fans’ lament.

If you’d “sowed more oats” before the reap

We wouldn’t have buried it quite so deep.

2. Dublin Mudslide™ Irish Cream Liqueur Ice Cream with Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies & a Coffee Fudge Swirl Limited Batch 2004

Full-Time Flavor 2005-2012 How’d you get so stuck on this flavor?

Oh, wait – you realized it just now:

Mudsliding’s no fun

When there’s no erin go wow.

3. Crème Brûlée Sweet Custard Ice Cream with a Caramelized Sugar Swirl 2007-2012 Pardon our French, but we still swear

Our Crème Brûlée was beyond compare.

We also swear we don’t know when

The Crème de la Crème will rise again.

4. Brownie Batter Brownie Batter Ice Cream with a Rich Brownie Batter Swirl 2003-2011 Batter fans are all boo-hooing:

What were we thinking? What’re we’re doing?

Whatever Batter’s fate may be

We’re gonna need a referee.

5. Festivus Brown Sugar Cinnamon Ice Cream with Gingerbread Cookies & a Ginger-Caramel Swirl

(the Flavor for the Rest of Us) Limited Batch, Holiday Seasons 2000 & 2001 Fans of TV comedy Seinfeld found this sassy batch as fun to eat as Seinfeld's classic Festivus episode is to watch. In fact, they loved it so much we did it again the following year, just in time to coincide with the seasonal re-run of the Seinfeld episode that started the whole “Festivus, the Holiday for the Rest of Us” frenzy. After we put Festivus’ name to rest, we brought the flavor back twice

(as “Gingerbread Cookie” in 2004 and as “Gingersnap” in 2009).

6. Dave Matthews Band One Sweet Whirled™ Caramel and Coffee Ice Creams with Marshmallow & Caramel Swirls

& Coffee Flavored Fudge Chips 2002-2004 Working hand in hand with the band

Creating global warming awareness

We kinda forgot about the flavor, in all fairness.

7. Vermonty Python™ Coffee Liqueur Ice Cream with a Chocolate Cookie Crumb Swirl & Fudge Cows 2006-2008 When they’re not pining for the fjords

or playing “wink wink, nudge nudge,”

Vermonty Python fans most love to “fetchez la vache”

– especially vaches made of fudge.

8. Wavy Gravy™ Caramel cashew Brazil nut ice cream with a chocolate hazelnut fudge swirl & roasted almonds Caramel cashew Brazil nut ice cream with a chocolate hazelnut fudge swirl & roasted almonds 1993-2001

Thanks to fans who voted to “Raise a Flavor from the Graveyard,” the flavor re-appeared in scoop shops for a limited time in 2005. Just so there’s no confusion, we thought we oughtta warn ya:

Wavy Gravy isn’t dead - he lives in California.

No such luck for Wavy’s flavor, but we’ve been wrong before,

We won’t give up the ghost if you won’t, so what’re you waiting for?

9. Dave Matthews Band® Magic Brownies™ - Encore Edition Black Raspberry Ice Cream Swirled with Sweet Cream Ice Cream & Fudgy Brownies 2007-2011 Some thought the original “too vanilla”,

so in 2006 we deep-sixed it

Fans then declared it raspberrily better

after we re-mixed it.

10. Coconut Almond Fudge Chip Coconut Ice Cream with Fudge Chips & Roasted Almonds 1993-1996

Revived in special “Flavor Flashback” pints 1998-2000

Survived as a scoop shop-only flavor 2001-2009 This coconutty contender

Was just too good to surrender.

Of the Graveyard’s legendariest,

It’s among the temporariest.