From HaskellWiki

A (no longer theoretical) module which contains implementations/combinators for implementing every possible method of list-splitting known to man. This way no one has to argue about what the correct interface for split is, we can just have them all.

This has been brought up many times on the mailing lists, and there's a summary of the split proposals on List function suggestions. Just for reference:



Some possible ways to split a list, to get your creative juices flowing:

what to split on? single-element separator sublist separator use a list of possible separators instead of just one use a predicate on elements or sublists instead of giving explicit separators use approximate matching? chunks of fixed length

how to split? discard the separators keep the separators with the preceding or following splits keep the separators as their own separate pieces of the result list what to do with separators at the beginning/end? create a blank split before/after, or not? keep blank splits between consecutive delimiters, or merge multiple consecutive delimiters into one delimiter?



An important caveat: we should strive to keep things flexible yet SIMPLE. The more complicated things get, the closer this gets to just being a general parsing or regex library. So the right balance needs to be struck.

Add your implementations below! Once we converge on something good we can upload it to hackage.

{-# LANGUAGE ViewPatterns #-} import Data.List ( unfoldr ) -- intercalate :: [a] -> [[a]] -> [a] -- intercalate x [a,b,c,x,y,z] = [a,x,b,x,c,x,x,y,x,z,x] -- unintercalate :: [a] -> [a] -> [[a]] -- unintercalate x [a,x,b,x,c,x,x,y,x,z,x] = [a,b,c,[],y,z] -- unintercalate is the "inverse" of intercalate match [] string = Just string match ( _ : _ ) [] = Nothing match ( p : ps ) ( q : qs ) | p == q = match ps qs match ( _ : _ ) ( _ : _ ) | otherwise = Nothing chopWith delimiter ( match delimiter -> Just tail ) = return ( [] , tail ) chopWith delimiter ( c : cs ) = case chopWith delimiter cs of Just ( head , tail ) -> return ( c : head , tail ) Nothing -> return ( c : cs , [] ) chopWith delimiter [] = Nothing unintercalate delimiter = unfoldr ( chopWith delimiter ) -- NOTE: this unintercalate used to have bugs, don't trust it -- this one discards separators and combines multiple adjacent separators -- splitOn (==',') "foo,bar,,,baz" = ["foo", "bar", "baz"] -- this is the behavior you want for List.words -- splitOn :: ( a -> Bool ) -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] splitOn _ [] = [] splitOn f l @ ( x : xs ) | f x = splitOn f xs | otherwise = let ( h , t ) = break f l in h : ( splitOn f t ) -- this variant discards separators but does not combine adjacent separators -- splitOn' (==',') "foo,bar,,,baz" = ["foo", "bar", "", "", "baz"] -- this is the behavior you want for List.lines -- splitOn' :: ( a -> Bool ) -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] splitOn' f xs = split xs where split xs = case break f xs of ( chunk , [] ) -> chunk : [] ( chunk , _ : rest ) -> chunk : split rest -- this variant keeps the separators but combines them -- splitOn'' Char.isSpace "foo bar \t baz" = ["foo"," ","bar"," \t ","baz"] -- splitOn'' :: ( a -> Bool ) -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] splitOn'' sep xs = split xs where split [] = [] split xs = case break sep xs of ( chunk , [] ) -> chunk : [] ( chunk , rest ) -> case span sep rest of ( seps , rest ) | null chunk -> seps : split rest | otherwise -> chunk : seps : split rest -- take the element who make predict true as delimiter -- > splitOn even [1,3,5,6,7,3,3,2,1,1,1] -- [[1,3,5],[7,3,3],[1,1,1]] -- | like String split, except for any element that obeys Eq -- This trick works for all the 'splitOn' variants above. -- splitEq :: Eq a => a -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] splitEq e = splitOn ( == e ) -- | split at regular intervals chunk :: Int -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] chunk _ [] = [] chunk n xs = y1 : chunk n y2 where ( y1 , y2 ) = splitAt n xs -- another version (CPS) of chunk chunk n list = case list of { [] -> [] ; ( y : ys ) -> ch' ys ( n - 1 ) ( y : ) } where ch' [] _ k = k [] : [] ch' ( y : ys ) 0 k = k [] : ch' ys ( n - 1 ) ( y : ) ch' ( y : ys ) ( c + 1 ) k = ch' ys c ( k . ( y : ))

A combinator approach?

Here are some initial thoughts on a combinator approach. The trick is to find nice implementations of the declarations below. Please add your own thoughts, other combinators, etc.

data Splitter a split :: Splitter a -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] onElts :: [ a ] -> Splitter a -- split on any of these elements onSublist :: [ a ] -> Splitter a -- split on this exact subsequence whenElt :: ( a -> Bool ) -> Splitter a keepingDelims :: Splitter a -> Splitter a collapsingNulls :: Splitter a -> Splitter a -- other basic combinators? -- now you can write things like -- -- split (collapsingNulls $ onElts " ,") "abc,def , gh" -- -- which should evaluate to ["abc", "def", "gh"]. -- some convenience functions can be provided, such as... splitOn = split . onElts splitWhen = split . whenElt

Splits of known lengths

I frequently require two types of splits, splitting into blocks of fixed length and splitting into lists of sizes of increasing powers of 2. My implementation was designed to be fold/builded as much as possible, so here goes:

splitEvery :: Int -> [ e ] -> [[ e ]] splitEvery i l = map ( take i ) ( build ( splitter l )) where splitter [] _ n = n splitter l c n = l ` c ` splitter ( drop i l ) c n For more general splits with foreknown lengths , splitPlaces :: [ Int ] -> [ e ] -> [[ e ]] splitPlaces ls xs = build ( splitPlacer ls xs ) where splitPlacer [] _ _ n = n splitPlacer _ [] _ n = n splitPlacer ( l : ls ) xs c n = let ( x1 , x2 ) = splitAt l xs in x1 ` c ` splitPlacer ls x2 c n splitPowersOf2 :: [ e ] -> [[ e ]] splitPowersOf2 = splitPlaces ( iterate ( * 2 ) 1 )

To be sure, neither is a good consumer, but I don't think that's avoidable, given that drop isn't a good consumer either.

Here splitEvery is equivalent to "chunks" above, but it is a much better producer, I think. (It is also intended to be mapped on, given that the (map (take i)) makes every element of the list into a producer.

Break on Nothing

import Data.Maybe import Data.Either import Data.List ( find , isPrefixOf ) breaks :: [ Maybe a ] -> [[ a ]] breaks xs = ( if null cur then id else (( map fromJust cur ) : )) ( if null rem then [] else breaks ( tail rem )) where ( cur , rem ) = break isNothing xs replaces :: ( Eq a ) => [([ a ], [ b ])] -> ( a -> b ) -> [ a ] -> [ b ] replaces reps f = process where process [] = [] process l @ ( x : xs ) = case find ((` isPrefixOf ` xs ) . fst ) reps of Nothing -> f x : process xs Just ( pat , rep ) -> rep ++ ( process $ drop ( length pat ) l ) split :: ( Eq a ) => [([ a ], [ Maybe a ])] -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] split reps = breaks . replaces reps Just onSeq , onSeqKeep :: ( Eq a ) => [ a ] -> ([ a ], [ Maybe a ]) onSeq xs = ( xs , [ Nothing ]) onSeqKeep xs = ( xs , Nothing : ( map Just xs ++ [ Nothing ])) onElt , onEltKeep :: ( Eq a ) => a -> ([ a ], [ Maybe a ]) onElt x = onSeq [ x ] onEltKeep x = onSeqKeep [ x ] insertAfter :: [ Int ] -> a -> [ a ] -> [ a ] insertAfter [] _ xs = xs insertAfter ( i : _ ) _ [] | i > 0 = [] insertAfter ( i : is ) x xs = pre ++ [ x ] ++ insertAfter is x post where ( pre , post ) = splitAt i xs splitEvery :: Int -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] splitEvery i = splitPlaces ( repeat i ) splitPlaces :: [ Int ] -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] splitPlaces is xs = breaks $ insertAfter is Nothing $ map Just xs splitPowersOf2 = splitPlaces ( iterate ( * 2 ) 1 )

Implements all of the above ideas (except predicate matching). In order to split up an arithmetic expression, for example:

split ( onElt ' ' : map onEltKeep "+-/*^()" )

Split of known lengths again

I've written once something simply:

fixFields :: [ Int ] -> String -> [ String ] fixFields _ [] = [] fixFields ( n : ns ) ls = xs : fixFields ns ys where ( xs , ys ) = splitAt n ls fixFields _ ls = [ ls ]

Simple split at known length

Simple recursive definition:

chunk :: Int -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] chunk n [] = [] chunk n xs = ys : chunk n zs where ( ys , zs ) = splitAt n xs

Simple version using iterate:

-- Author: mm_freak irc.freenode.net #haskell chunk' :: Int -> [ a ] -> [[ a ]] chunk' n = takeWhile ( not . null ) . map ( take n ) . iterate ( drop n )

Simple version using unfoldr: