Anonymous

I think pony head had something to do with Star and Tom break up, she did threaten marco and shoved him out to die ... What if she pushed Tom's buttons on purpose so they'd fight, Star would get mad at Tom and then ponyhead would have star's attention again, she is possessive and Star knows it, and since Star and Ponyhead were friends for a long time ...

You know, that’s a really good idea.

I’m not sure about if Star’s family/friends were entirely aware of their relationship yet (Because not a single one of them has mentioned it), but if they do…

Ponyhead could be considered a reason.

I’m not sure if she’d treat Star’s Boyfriend differently then she’d treat another best friend of hers (Because the huge stem for getting rid of Marco was she was kinda under the impression she was being replaced), but if Star and Tom were very close…

Ponyhead is far from the worst person in the show, but it would be in her character to lie and cause problems to Tom and Star’s relationship (She’s not exactly known for her honestly and clean record here).

IF she was under the impression Tom was bad news, or was upset over their closeness, i could buy that she might have pulled some strings to break them up.

However, if her, or anyone else was hugely responsible for their breakup, that makes Tom’s situation even sadder. Should he take care of his anger? Yes.

But all that self-loathing he has for his issues that broke him and star up, the issues that make HIM feel bad for losing his most valuable relationship….that would suck to know he felt bad over something that wasn’t his fault.

Tom clearly accepts that it’s all him, but if it’s not…then ponyhead, star, ect. All put him in a pit of self-loathing and that really sucks.

Who knows maybe ponyhead said something to tom that could’ve crossed the line for him? He got upset, and Star took PONYHEAD’s side and that’s why she left him?

It’s just a theory for now.

But considering how Ponyhead treated MARCO, another close relationship Star has to another guy…..yeah. If she knew about Tom it’s possible she could’ve had similar beef depending on how she felt about their relationship.

She was clearly rooting for her friend to ask out Oskar in the season finale, but i’m not sure how ponyhead would feel about Star having a relationship that might suppress her own. Especially since she gets jealous very easily.

Eh, if they ever get us our episode about Star and Tom’s past anytime soon, We might get our answers about what happened for sure.

Nothing is out of the realm of plausibility right now.