We have it all wrong.. Toffee isn't evil he is taking back his world from Alien Invaders!



Evidence..



1. The Monsters have all been lobotomized.. Toffee the first time he appears tells the Boss Monster that he isn't the only monster to have fallen to the Mewniuns Magic. So the Mewniuns have made all the monsters stupid except Toffee...



2. In the episode about the origins of Star's people it is implied that Stars family are not native to the dimension and genocidal-ly murdered the native monsters in mass.



3. Toffee doesn't want power he wants to destroy the source of the Alien Mewniuns Power in the final we see!



Toffee is the survivor of Alien Invasion who is trying to take back his world... He is fighting Magical Space Nazis who have enslaved his people!