God may finally be answering Supernatural‘s prayers.

Rob Benedict will reprise his role as Chuck — Dean and Sam’s possibly-All Powerful prophet pal — in Episode 20 of Season 11, TVLine has learned exclusively.

Details about Chuck’s reappearance are being kept under wraps, but the current season’s heavy focus on God’s sister, The Darkness, suggests that the man believed to be The Creator may at last be showing up for a confrontation. Or perhaps he will respond to one of the Winchesters’ pleas for help?

Benedict — who made a surprise cameo at the end of last season’s 200th installment — isn’t the only fan favorite on tap to return to the CW series. As TVLine exclusively reported, Jim Beaver and Steven Williams will be back as hunters Bobby and Rufus, respectively, in an upcoming episode that flashes back to a Season 5 case.

Supernatural fans, what are theories about Chuck’s comeback? Hit the comments to share!