Ichabod Crane (Tom Mison) and Abbie Mills (Nicole Beharie) get some more familiar company in Season 2 of Fox’s breakout hit “Sleepy Hollow.” In addition to Mison, Beharie, Orlando Jones and Katia Winter, the new season will see Season 1’s recurring guest stars John Noble and Lyndie Greenwood upped to series regulars.

TheWrap has the exclusive first photo of the newly expanded cast gathered together. The group of humans, supernatural beings and time-traveling classic literary characters stand around brooding in some moonlit woods in a clear nod to the first season’s iconography, though the stakes are sure to be even higher this time around.

See video: John Noble Brings War to ‘Sleepy Hollow’ in Season 2 Teaser

Noble’s character Jeremy is set to have a major role in Season 2, since it was revealed in the season finale that he was not only the long-lost son of Ichabod and Katrina (Winter), he was also one of the Four Horsemen prophesied to bring about the apocalypse. “War has been here all along,” he says in the first promo for the new season.

“Sleepy Hollow” returns for its second season on Monday, Sept. 22 at 9/8c on Fox.