One of the most common criticisms of Teddy Bridgewater’s quarterbacking is his deep ball: talking heads frequently deride his deep passing, claiming that his arm strength and deep accuracy rank among the worst in the league. Analysts cite it as a driving factor as to why the Vikings might want to move on from Bridgewater. Fans perceive it as one of the key things holding Bridgewater back from being the quarterback of the future.

But is that true? Is Bridgewater a bad deep passer?

Pro Football Focus doesn’t seem to think so: they graded Bridgewater as above average in 2015 on passes more than 20 yards downfield. The Deep Ball Project, which reviews and grades every deep pass from every quarterback, doesn’t seem to think so either: they gave Bridgewater a “B” grade based on his 2015 deep ball tape and noted that his deep ball accuracy was 52.6% (ranking 12th of 33 overall).

So which is it?

I wanted to find out for myself, so I re-watched and charted all 87 deep passes Bridgewater attempted in 2015. In fact, I went ahead and compiled the All-22 of every single deep attempt from Bridgewater in 2015 in the video below. So while I have my own analysis about Bridgewater’s 2015 deep passing further below, as Reading Rainbow would say, you don’t have to take my word for it:

Statistics

Perhaps the main reason most folks think Bridgewater’s deep ball is lacking is his box score stats: of Bridgewater’s 87 deep passing attempts (defined by Game Pass as any pass that travels 15+ yards past the line of scrimmage) in 2015, only 34 passes were completed, for a 39% completion percentage, 831 yards, three touchdowns, and eight interceptions. That’s good for a passer rating of 47.6, which by any measure is awful production.

But how much of that awful production can really be attributed to Bridgewater? By my charting, Bridgewater was accurate on 52 out of 87 deep attempts – good for an accuracy percentage of 60% — almost double his completion percentage. By my count, 10 out of 87 incompletions were accurate, contested passes that you would reasonably expect the receiver to bring down. Another 5 incompletions were straight up dropped, going right through the receivers’ hands despite there being no defenders contesting the catch. That is 17% of Bridgewater’s passes that should have been caught, but that the receivers failed to bring in.

If you’re wondering how that is possible, consider that Mike Wallace was the Vikings’ No. 1 wide receiver, who led all position players in snap count in 2015.

He was PFF’s 101st ranked wide receiver that year. Take out all the deep targets to Mike Wallace, and Bridgewater’s deep completion percentage jumps to 41%, and his deep accuracy percentage jumps to 64% – approximately top five in the league. Once you account for all those drops and a few defensive pass interference penalties, Bridgewater’s deep passing stat line comes out to 52 of 87, for about 1340 yards, eight touchdowns and seven interceptions. A brief word on those interceptions: the average QB sees about half or more of their interceptable passes drop incomplete. By my charting, Bridgewater threw nine interceptable passes in 2015. He had eight interceptions. Against the Chiefs, Bridgewater wound up with more interceptions (2) than inaccurate passes (1). His interception luck was so awful that the cornerbacks he went up against had better hands than his own wide receivers. (You may think I am joking. I am not. Not a single one of Bridgewater’s interceptable throws were dropped. This interception by Ricardo Allen is a more impressive catch than any of the Vikings’ wide receivers’ catches for all of 2015.) An average deep passer is accurate on about 50% of deep attempts. A great deep passer is accurate on over 60% of deep attempts. Once you factor in drops and a few defensive penalties, Bridgewater’s deep accuracy comes out to 59.8% – solidly above average. That may be hard to believe, but it’s congruent with what Pro Football Focus and The Deep Ball Project have found as well. But again, you don’t need to take their word for it: every deep pass can be watched and re-watched here.

Breakdown by Route

Bridgewater’s strengths and limitations become even clearer once we break down his deep attempts by route:

Bridgewater is an outstanding anticipation passer to every level of the field, including on all his deep throws. He was exceptionally accurate on in and out-breaking routes as well as deep hitches, as he was accurate on 21 of 24 of those routes – an astoundingly high number. In fact, Pro Football Focus noted that he was the most accurate deep passer in the NFL on those kinds of routes. Bridgewater was similarly great throwing with anticipation on deep crossing routes, as he was accurate on 8 of 12 of those routes.

On the other hand, Bridgewater struggled a bit with vertical routes. He particularly struggled with fade routes, where the receiver (often Mike Wallace) sprints down the sideline to the end zone on the outside shade of the outermost corner. Wallace, despite his speed, often struggled to separate from cornerbacks, and moreover often got outboxed and pinned right next to the sideline, giving Bridgewater the tiniest of windows to hit.

However, even after accounting for his supporting cast, Bridgewater still underperformed on vertical routes, being accurate on 20/45 (44%) of all go routes, fades, seams, and deep wheel routes. 44% accuracy on vertical routes isn’t worst in the league, but it’s at least slightly below average.

Bridgewater’s vertical inaccuracies stem from his propensity to overshoot his targets: of his 87 deep attempts, 19 passes (22%) were overthrown.

Still, when you factor in all deep throws — power throws, anticipation throws, vertical routes, and everything else — Bridgewater was accurate on just under 60% of his deep throws. That’s not bad. It’s not even average. It’s solidly above average.

So to revisit our initial question: is Bridgewater a bad deep passer? He may struggle with vertical routes at times and he may not have the strongest arm in the league, but after accounting for receiver error, as The Deep Ball Project and Pro Football Focus both found, Teddy Bridgewater comes out as one of the better deep passers in the league.

Don’t believe me? Watch the tape and decide for yourself: