When police questioned McGarty at his residence, he stated he and the victim spoke briefly and confirmed giving her $20 “because she was in need of money, as she is homeless.” He denied making physical contact, despite being told of the video evidence, or asking for a kiss.

Attorney Cheryl Gill entered a not guilty plea on McGarty’s behalf Monday. Judge Todd Bjerke set a $500 signature bond and asked Gill to bring McGarty in for booking by the end of the week.

“I will try, your honor, but as you may know Msgr. McGarty is 94 and he has some difficulty getting out and about, notwithstanding this particular charge, so I’ll try to get him in here,” Gill said.

“I know he’s been out and about,” Bjerke replied, instructing that McGarty needs to be booked by Friday. A pre-trial is scheduled for Aug. 8.

Jack Felsheim, director of communications and public relations from the diocese, previously issued a statement regarding the case: