Though plastic was invented in the 1800s, it was really only around 1950 that the human-plastic love affair took off. And boy did it—the nearly 2 million tonnes (2.2 million tons) of plastic produced in 1950 had surged twentyfold in just two decades (by around the time a young Dustin Hoffman was advised to consider a future in plastics in The Graduate) (video).

Since the 1970s, at least 0.1% of this plastic has ended up in the ocean. Conservative estimates put the amount of plastic bobbing around the ocean at 1 million tons (though it’s probably a lot more).

​

Here’s the weird thing: It’s not there. Or at least, most of it isn’t. Scientists have found between 7,000 and 35,000 tons of plastic floating around the surface of the open ocean, according to a just-published study. In other words, 97-99% of that plastic trash has gone missing.

So where’d it go? Though it’s possible that sunlight is eroding it into nothingness, or that tiny pieces are washing back ashore, researchers are skeptical.

What’s probably happening, scientists theorize, is that tiny fish are eating it. The most likely plastic-snackers are lanternfish and other small “mesopelagic” species, meaning those that live in the middle swath of the ocean, swimming to the surface at night to feed. These are far and away the most populous fishes in the sea.

NOAA Photo Library via Flickr ​

One clue that these little fish are scarfing down tons of plastic comes from the fact that the size of the plastic pellets that have gone missing are mostly those ranging from 0.5 to 5 millimeters in size—about the same dimensions of the creatures that mesopelagic fishes like to eat.

Sure enough, studies of their stomach contents have found not only that around a third had swallowed plastic chunks, but that the size of the trash they’d chowed down on was that exact size.

This also makes sense because of where the plastic is ending up. Here’s a map:

"Plastic debris in the open ocean," Cózar et al. 2014 ​

As you can see, the highest concentrations are in the five gyres (giant rotating oceanic currents).

The University of Waikato ​

When cold currents come in contact with warm ones, they whip up an enormous vortex of stagnant water and debris. These currents are thought to act as conveyor belts, moving plastic pumped into the sea by storm runoff into one of these gyres, sometimes hundreds of thousands of miles away. The only one of the five that has been well studied—the North Pacific Ocean Subtropical Gyre—is thought to be twice the size of Texas. And as it happens, these tiny mesopelagic fish abound around ocean gyres, with a density in the open ocean of about one fish per square meter.

We don’t have a good sense of what swallowing plastic does to these fishes, or even whether they’re able to excrete or throw up their plastic meals. That’s worrisome, since the toxic chemicals in plastic might permeate their tissue—bad for mesopelagic fishes, but also potentially bad for humans. Pellets in the 0.5-5-millimeter range are also commonly found in the bellies of the predators who eat these smaller fishes, according to the study. Those include tuna, mackerel and other sushi-menu faves.

Read This Next: Why not even exercise will undo the harm of sitting all day—and what you can do about it