The plan was for Happy Death Day to be a trilogy, with the sequel’s end-credits scene setting the stage for part 3, but the surprising box office under-performance of Happy Death Day 2U has called that into question. Mind you, any film making over $50 million worldwide on a $9 million production budget isn’t at all a fail, but when compared to the $125 million worldwide total for the first film, well, let’s just say it wasn’t quite what Blumhouse was hoping for.

In a Q&A session over on Twitter last night, the always open and honest Jason Blum was asked about the likelihood of Happy Death Day 3 happening, and he had this to say:

“Not very [likely], but not impossible.”

Director Christopher Landon recently explained to EW, “I have more than an idea. I always imagined this as a trilogy, so I have the third movie, but it’s just a question of whether this one does well. I would love to make the third one. I think it’s a really bonkers, fun idea.”