The second trooper to file a federal lawsuit against the Massachusetts State Police, Col. Richard McKeon and other troopers over the redaction of a police report involving the arrest of a judge's daughter said she refused to shred her report despite direct orders to do so.

Trooper Ali Rei filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court Friday, just days after Trooper Ryan Sceviour filed a federal lawsuit in connection with the redaction of an arrest report involving Alli Bibaud, the daughter of a Worcester County judge.

Rei claims she was told to shred and redact reports containing embarrassing statements made by Bibaud, but that she ultimately did not redact or shred reports. Rei feared she would lose her job or be disciplined for disobeying an order, the lawsuit says.

Both troopers claim orders to redact the arrest report, which contained alleged statements made by Bibaud about performing sex acts for drugs, came from McKeon. A 35-year veteran of the State Police and Worcester native, McKeon announced his retirement Friday as the allegations he ordered the removal of embarrassing details from Bibaud's arrest report appeared in the federal lawsuits.

Bibaud, who is the daughter of Judge Timothy Bibaud and once worked as a victim/witness advocate for the Worcester County District Attorney's Office, was involved in a crash on Oct. 16 on Interstate 190 in Worcester.

Sceviour and Rei both responded to the crash. Troopers said they discovered a yellow handbag containing syringes, a metal spoon and plastic baggies - all signs of possible heroin use. Bibaud was arrested on charges she was driving under the influence of drugs and alcohol.

Rei is a trained drug recognition expert with the State Police. She was called to the crash scene and evaluated Bibaud only to find the judge's daughter had signs of drug use, Rei wrote in her lawsuit.

"The suspect stated that she had used heroin 'this morning' and drank two nips of alcohol," Rei claims in her lawsuit. Bibaud failed field sobriety tests as well, both troopers wrote in their lawsuits.

At the Holden barracks, Bibaud allegedly told Rei she "regularly used two grams of heroin" daily. Bibaud claimed she crashed the car on I-190 on purpose because she was upset with her boyfriend, the passenger in the vehicle, Rei said in her lawsuit.

"Ms. Bibaud stated that she was 'sick of living like this. Trooper Rei asked what she meant by that statement and Ms. Bibaud responded by stating that she had to perform multiple sexual acts in order to obtain the drugs for 'us' (presumably, her and her boyfriend)," the lawsuit said.

As Bibaud was booked, Rei heard Bibaud offer Sceviour sexual favors for leniency. The allegation was made in lawsuits filed by both troopers.

Rei said she made detailed notations in the electronic Administrative Journal about the evaluation of Bibaud. She also completed her report on Oct. 17.

Both Rei and Sceviour say they were told to redact Bibaud's arrest report to remove comments about the sexual favors and also a comment where Bibaud said her father is a judge.

Sceviour made redactions to his report, but according to Rei's lawsuit, she did not shred copies of her journal extract and did not alter her report. The troopers both say they were given the orders during meetings or phone calls on Oct. 19 with Major Susan Anderson.

Anderson, the troopers say, told them both the orders to change or shred reports in Bibaud's arrest came from McKeon. The troopers claim Gov. Charlie Baker's public safety chief, Daniel Bennett, also made the order, but Bennett's office said he never asked for anything to be done to the report.

Rei claims Anderson told her she deleted Rei's log notes from the computer, removed the journal pages and shredded them. Anderson allegedly to Rei to create new journal entries to replace the deleted ones and shred the original journal entry copies. Anderson told Rei to alter her original report as well, the trooper claims in the lawsuit.

"Despite Major Anderson's direct order, Trooper Rei did not shred the copies of the Administrative Journal extract and did not alter her DRE report to remove the incriminating statements made by Ms. Bibaud," the lawsuit said. "Trooper Rei is in fear of being disciplined and terminated from her employment because she did not obey Anderson's illegal orders. As a result, Trooper Rei suffered and continues to suffer from severe emotional distress as a result of the orders that were given to her by Major Anderson to commit illegal acts."

Bibaud's case was transferred to Middlesex County and out of Worcester County as it continues in court. According to Rei's lawsuit, she sent her original, unaltered report to prosecutors on Nov. 9.

Rei is claiming her state and federal rights were violated and the situation caused emotional distress. Sceviour filed similar claims.

The state's attorney general is investigating the altered arrest report. Sceviour and Sgt. Jason Conant, the trooper's supervisor at the Holden barracks, were both given reprimands in the Bibaud case. State officials said the reprimands will be invalidated. McKeon's retirement is effective Nov. 17.

Trooper Ali Rei lawsuit against Massachusetts State Police by Scott Croteau on Scribd