Rated 4 out of 5 by Tiki Girl from ONE OF MY MAKEUP STAPLES!! I have been using "Whipped Cream" single since probably around...2014 when I was first introduced to NYX at Ulta. It is one of, if not, my absolute go-to single most essential product in my makeup routine. I stock up when it is actually available on the shelf. Couple CONS from the last year or so. Like others have mentioned, and I don't know if this is an issue across the board for all their singles as if they tweaked their formula, this white used to be very intensely pigmented and smooth and a little bit went a LONG way! I find that at some point in the last year or so, the eyeshadow has become rather dry and weak. That is not to say it is a wet shadow, it's not, but it had a very dense velvety texture and now it's just meh. I have to use a lot and go over and again across my lid to build up to the strong white I love which stinks for 1: getting the job done well, quickly and 2. not going through it too quickly (see what they did there?). I have deep-set eyes and my "awakening" and finally finding an eye makeup routine/technique that really works for me, was applying white to the brow and inner corners and sweeping outwards across my lid. This is the only white I use. I have tried to substitute with others when this is not available, and it just isn't the same. This usually is very pigmented and blendable so I am annoyed that it is now so chalky. i will still keep using it, though. The lid on these singles almost always eventually breaks off which makes it hard to travel with these, or not even, because sooner or later the lid will come off when it should not and the rest of the shadow will get broken apart into a million pieces and get all over. I find the same t be true of the HD finishing powder, which is another go-to product for me. Both crumble and break apart far too easily in my opinion but when they do I grind them into a fine powder and re-set in the containers with rubbing alcohol. Once it dries you have a nice, smooth hunk of make up again and actually works even better than before. I really wish companies would stop messing with the formulas for their products or altogether discontinuing stuff they've been making for a long time. I guess they just don't market like they used to.

Rated 4 out of 5 by Negra from Not enough you have to apply a lot for it to show not enough pigmentation

Rated 3 out of 5 by Anonymous from more pigment, please! I ordered the yellow color of the product and it was quite sheer, I was expecting more pigment.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Peales from Shimmer and soft without too much glitz! Great versatile eyeshadow. Slightly shimmer. Color very soft and beautiful.

Rated 5 out of 5 by soelkec from great eyeshadow I love this eyeshadow. It goes on smooth and stays on all day!

Rated 3 out of 5 by IN2RNR from COLORS ARE NOT AS PICTURED I have ordered multiple colors, several times from this site. I do like the shadows, although they are quite powdery. However, NONE of the colors are as shown on this site. The Haywire is more of a slight purple, the Chandelier more of a gold beige, and there are just NO blue-grey options available. If purchasing to get a specific color, I would recommend you go into a store first. The prices are very reasonable so no reason to give a 1-star.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Rackleysrose from Eyeshadow Marvel Finally! Eyeshadows that are fully pigmented, not too powdery and last a long time. Very, very happy.