PALO ALTO — Something was unusual about the 1663 map of the Western Hemisphere.

Yes, much of the North and South American coasts followed contours geographers would recognize today. And in California, Santa Catalina, Santa Barbara and Point Reyes were clearly marked. But wait! What was that body of water marked Mare Vermiglio, or Red Sea, separating California from the mainland? And why was California a big carrot-shaped island?


That geographic oddity caught the attention of Glen McLaughlin, an American businessman who was browsing through antique maps at a shop in London in 1971. He bought it — and began pursuing a quirky and expensive passion that would lead him to devote an entire room in his San Jose-area home to what is believed to be the largest private collection of such maps.

“It was not a very pretty map, but it had the concept that California was a very different place, a special place,” McLaughlin recalled about that first purchase.


Four decades later, his collection of 800 maps, all showing California as an island, is making a splash in academia. And to both California lovers and haters, it promotes the sentiment that the state, even if not a physical island, remains a cultural and political one.

McLaughlin recently turned his collection over to Stanford University’s Branner earth sciences library in an arrangement that was part sale, part donation. It is thought to be worth $2.1 million.


An Oklahoman who found a new home and success as a Silicon Valley venture capitalist, McLaughlin became intrigued with 17th and 18th century depictions of California as a mysterious island of riches and, he said, “hope for the future.”

From early exploration to Gold Rush days to the current high-tech era, California has been a kind of island of freedom and innovation, he said. “There is enormous tolerance for different points of view. So inventors, who might be called kooks or nuts someplace else were embraced here and encouraged,” said McLaughlin, a hearty 77. It is, he added, “the grandest place on Earth.”


The maps and an online repository are expected to enrich scholars’ knowledge of the first California experiences by European explorers. Spurred in part by imaginary descriptions in an early 16th century novel, Spanish travelers originally searched for an island supposedly populated by cannibalistic Amazons with plentiful jewels and gold. It took two more centuries to refute that and other island theories.

The collection shows “layer upon layer of history,” said Julie Sweetkind-Singer, a Stanford map librarian. “It shows the perceptions of the times and the idea of exploration and finding new worlds.” In their day, the maps excited people the way images from the Hubble Space Telescope do today, she added.


Among the first to study the maps intensively will be author and geography expert Rebecca Solnit, whose 2010 book, “Infinite City: A San Francisco Atlas,” mapped that city for such things as Native American place names, contemporary murders and coffeehouses. She soon will start a six-month fellowship at Stanford with the goal of writing a book based on the McLaughlin collection.

Although the maps are technically wrong, their symbolism remains powerful, she said.


“California is not an island and doesn’t have an east coast and no Vermilion Sea. But it is so separate from other parts of the United States, economically, culturally and even spatially,” Solnit said. With mountains and deserts isolating California, and its agriculture, high-tech and entertainment industries so well developed, “who’s to say we are not this magical, amazing place?”

The maps, she added, “show this weird kind of dance between imagination and desire on the one hand and exploration and fact on the other.”


McLaughlin said he has cartography in his DNA. His great-grandfather was a surveyor, his father once won a school contest in drawing maps, and McLaughlin himself was an Air Force pilot trained in navigation. He fell in love with Northern California when stationed there in the late 1950s and returned as a civilian to its high-tech and finance industries. Among other positions, he was a co-founder of Greater Bay Bancorp, a large bank that was acquired by Wells Fargo.

Not a golfer or one for the party circuit, he fell into his map habit as quiet relief from the financial minutiae of his work and the stress of dealing with the computer world’s “bits and bytes.”


It also gave him entree to the rarefied world of scholars and collectors, where the mistaken island images, like misprinted postage stamps, “always draw more attention than the run of the mill,” said McLaughlin, an unexcitable man who recounts his map acquisitions like a retired professor recalling good students of the past.

The growing size of his collection sometimes exasperated his wife, Ellen. At first he stored them under a bed, but that made them difficult to protect from the family cat. He then acquired architects’ cases and eventually moved them to a dedicated study in a 10-room house in Saratoga. With part-time helpers, he produced well-regarded essays and catalogs on his collection and UC Berkeley’s.


Recently, he and his wife moved to a smaller home nearby, pared their possessions and arranged the transfer to Stanford. The collection is expected to move across campus in 2014 to a center that will be created at the university’s main Green Library; the space will be named after David Rumsey, a real estate developer who is donating his immense collection of 18th and 19th century Western Hemisphere maps and atlases.

McLaughlin’s maps, carefully stored in Mylar sleeves or framed behind glass, display beautiful curiosities. His first, in English and Latin, shows sea monsters and galleons in the oceans. A 1656 French one gives “Californie Isle” a foot-like northern coast with five peninsula toes. A 1670 Dutch version shows angels on top and below a bare-chested Native American chief with snakes and bars of gold.


Whatever the geographic facts or discredited myths, McLaughlin said people remain fascinated by the maps because in their hearts they still perceive California “as a big island floating in the Pacific off the West Coast of North America.”

Jon Christensen, a UCLA history professor and environmental specialist, said McLaughlin has “that kind of obsession and vision and persistence to put together such a great collection. He was very disciplined and dedicated.”


Christensen said such incorrect maps “often turn out to be some of the most interesting windows into history. They really show us that the past is a foreign country and people did things differently then and thought differently.”

The concept of California as an island persisted because of romantic illusion, wrong suppositions and difficult navigation.


Spanish novelist Garci Rodriguez de Montalvo, in a 1510 fantasy book, described a wealthy California island east of the Indies populated by powerful and licentious women and ruled by a Queen Calafia. In the early 1600s, Friar Antonio de la Ascension accompanied explorers and wrote an influential and incorrect account saying California lacked big rivers — they never saw the Sacramento or San Joaquin — and so is not connected to a continental watershed. Later efforts to better explore the coast and the Gulf of California were hindered by Pacific winds that pushed sailors from Mexico westward, experts say.

Although some early maps showed California on the mainland, a powerful refutation of the island theory came in 1701 when Jesuit explorer Eusebio Kino crossed the Baja peninsula and, with a telescope, saw that it was part of the continent.


But the myth “had been too deeply entrenched for too long for it to be easily shaken loose,” Dora Beale Polk wrote in her 1991 book, “The Island of California: A History of the Myth.”

Other voyages showed the Gulf of California dead-ending at the Colorado River and proved it was not a waterway that extended up to Oregon.


Finally, in 1747, Spain’s King Ferdinand VI made it official, proclaiming to friends and foes: “California is not an island.”

larry.gordon@latimes.com