After a minor dust-up between the Chicago White Sox and Detroit Tigers on Thursday that started with Chris Sale plunking Prince Fielder and ended with Tigers manager Jim Leyland enjoying a lengthy post-ejection spat with the umpires, Tigers outfielder Torii Hunter gave an eyebrow-raising postgame interview. Literally.

Instead of answering questions about the showdown, Hunter opted for a series of curious noises and expressions, saying only, “the game polices itself.”

Your browser does not support iframes.

The first-place Tigers and last-place White Sox play each other 16 more times this season starting on July 22, so we almost certainly haven’t heard the last of this.

Tigers blog Bless You Boys has a full recap of the incident in GIFs, with evidence of Hunter’s similarly eyebrow-raising role in the fracas. He struggled to hold back veteran White Sox slugger Adam Dunn, who himself struggled to look like he cared that someone was holding him back: