When she arrived at Janklow's house, the teacher said, she brought the food into his bedroom, where he was lying in bed under the covers, the reports say. He then pulled out a handgun and pointed it at her, saying she caused him to lose his job (Urban said Janklow has not been fired) due to a November 2018 incident. The woman told police that she and Janklow went out with other people and she and other friends ended up calling a limo to take Janklow home since he was being drunk and aggressive. She said Janklow later received a call from a school administrator about the evening.

The woman said she tried to calm Janklow down but he pulled out a shotgun from underneath the covers and pointed both weapons at her, according to police reports. She said Janklow threatened to kill her and himself, and then made her write a letter saying that what happened in November wasn't true. She later emailed that letter to police.

After writing the letter and leaving the home, the woman said, she immediately called a defense lawyer but couldn't reach her until Feb. 18., the reports say. The lawyer told the woman to call police, which she did. When asked why she didn't immediately call 911, the woman said she had "some distrust with people and the police."