Freed French hostages return amid ransom speculation Published duration 30 October 2013

media caption The hostages were greeted by their families and French President Francois Hollande

Four Frenchmen kidnapped in Niger three years ago have arrived back in Paris after being released.

President Francois Hollande welcomed them home at a military airfield.

The four were seized by al-Qaeda-linked gunmen in raids targeting French firms operating a uranium mine in September 2010. They were held in the northern desert of neighbouring Mali.

Their return comes amid reports that a ransom of 20m euros (£17m; $26m) was paid to ensure their release.

The French defence minister has said the four were freed without a military assault or a ransom being paid.

French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius flew back with the hostages and told AFP news agency before take-off that the men were in "very good shape".

'Embarrassing questions'

The BBC's Christian Fraser in Paris says that while the country celebrates the return of the four hostages, embarrassing questions are being asked of the French government over whether a ransom was paid for their release.

image copyright Reuters image caption The freed hostages were working in northern Niger when they were seized by gunmen linked to al-Qaeda

image copyright AFP image caption They arrived in Paris to be greeted by President Francois Hollande, who reminded onlookers that there were still three hostages being held in Africa and four in Syria

image copyright AP image caption Correspondents say that amid the joy over the releases, questions remain over the details of the deal that saw them freed

image copyright AFP image caption None of the released hostages wanted to speak after the president, and some appeared visibly uncomfortable at being in the media glare

An unnamed source, quoted by Le Monde, said 20m euros was paid, from a secret fund operated by the intelligence services.

This echoes earlier comments from a member of the men's families that a ransom had been paid.

The government denies the claims.

Earlier this month, senior figures from French nuclear company Areva were in the Niger capital Niamey for a meeting with President Mahamadou Issoufou at which it is said certain guarantees were made.

Our correspondent says it seems unlikely that the French government would make a payment directly and that the focus is turning to what assurances or payments were made indirectly.

The group of four arrived back at Villacoublay military airfield, to the west of Paris, on Wednesday morning after a flight from Niamey.

The men - identified as Thierry Dol, Daniel Larribe, Pierre Legrand and Marc Feret - were seized on 16 September 2010 near Arlit. They were all employees at a uranium mine run by the French nuclear company Areva.

The al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM) group said it was responsible.

No further details of the men's release were given, but it is believed that Niger's top negotiator Mohamed Akotey, a former Tuareg rebel, secured the release over the last few days.