Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost have a strong bond — but it's being tested by New York baseball

Scarlett Johansson Says Her Love for New York Yankees Is a 'Sore Subject' with Fiancé Colin Jost

Scarlett Johansson and Colin Jost's romance has one clear obstacle: New York baseball.

The New York natives, who confirmed their engagement in May 2019, strongly disagree when it comes to their favorite baseball team in the state. While Johansson is an ardent Yankees fan, Jost goes for the Mets — just like her entire family.

Get push notifications with news, features and more.

Her obsession with the Yankees started when she was in high school and they were "killing it," fostering a love so strong for shortstop Derek Jeter that she even "used to keep his rookie card in my wallet!” she told Parade in a recent interview.

But while Johansson is used to going up against her Mets-obsessed family, it's a little trickier when it comes to her fiancé.

“It’s a sore subject,” she said of her baseball rivalry with Jost. “He just told me that he’d rather see the [Boston] Red Sox win than the Yankees win. Like, what?! I said I was just going to ignore that.”

WATCH: Scarlett Johansson and SNL's Colin Jost Are Engaged After Two Years of Dating

Johansson, 35, and Jost, 37, confirmed their engagement in May 2019 after making their public debut as a couple in November 2017.

Since then, Jost and Johansson have often been seen out and about together with Johansson’s daughter, whom she shares with ex-husband Romain Dauriac. The two were married from 2014 to 2017; Johansson was previously married to Ryan Reynolds from 2008 to 2011.