Imagine that you are just walking down the street in Hollywood, out for a casual Friday night stroll. Suddenly you hear this low, sort-of-raspy laugh. You’ve heard it before—possibly in many Oscar-nominated movies? You look up, and you see none other than Jack Nicholson, laughing at something Paul McCartney, across the table from him, just said. Ringo Starr, next to McCartney, chuckles, too. You survey the table. Is that Eagles musician Joe Walsh? And country crooner Vince Gill? By now, you’re probably thinking, “O.K., either this is a scene out of a 1980s issue of Rolling Stone, or it’s something that actually happened.” Per Page Six, it’s, miraculously, the latter.

Last Friday, this very diverse group of legends was seen sitting outside L.A. Italian spot The Ponte on West Beverly Boulevard. Though this would be a surprising scene to witness in real life, it’s not entirely shocking. Earlier this year, Starr and McCartney reportedly joined forces to record a new single, with the help of Walsh. Starr and McCartney last collaborated on Starr’s 2010 L.P., Y Not.

And Starr and McCartney seem to be pretty fond of sharing meals. Per TMZ, they were seen with Walsh, Tom Hanks, and Dave Grohl at dinner in Santa Monica in February. McCartney seems to be the connection to Nicholson; the two have palled around before, at a New York Yankees game in 2009, where Nicholson appeared to give the Beatle a big smooch.

But this particular get-together might have been a celebration of sorts; in just two days, the Beatles will celebrate the 50th anniversary of their album Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band. Maybe they were secretly recording a new version after the meal?