Paper Reviewed

Truchelut, R.E. and Staehling, E.M. 2017. An energetic perspective on United States tropical cyclone landfall droughts. Geophysical Research Letters 44: 12,013-12,019.

One of the more often cited claims of climate alarmists is that CO 2 -induced global warming is increasing both the frequency and magnitude of hurricane events. Rarely does a hurricane event occur these days without the media quoting someone who places blame for its existence on CO 2 emissions.

Fortunately, such assertions are false and easily refuted upon close examination of observational data, exposing the ignorance (or perhaps blatant disregard for the truth!) of the media and those they prop up to peddle such deception. We have posted numerous reviews of scientific papers on this topic over the past two decades proving this point which can be accessed by clicking on the many links accessible after clicking on the many sub headings under Hurricanes on this page. Our most recent addition to this archive covers the work of Truchelut and Staehling (2017).

As their contribution, the two researchers introduced and examined an extended record of U.S. tropical cyclone activity based on accumulated cyclone energy (ACE, which accounts for hurricane intensity) over the period 1900 to 2017. Key findings of their study are presented in the three-panel graphic of Figure 1.

Perhaps the most significant observation noted in their ACE times series of Figure 1b is the lack of any statistically significant trend across the 118 year record, albeit there are fluctuations on various time scales. Such absence of a long-term upward trend in the data is contrary to claims that rising levels of atmospheric carbon dioxide are causing more frequent or more severe storms. This point is further supported by the data presented in Figure 1a, which depicts the number of days between U.S. hurricane landfalls since 1900. As seen there, the average return period of major hurricanes with wind speeds of 100 kt or greater (i.e, Category 3) is approximately 700 days. Interestingly, prior to the passing of Hurricane Harvey in 2017, there was a record 4,324 days where no Category 3 or higher hurricane made landfall in the U.S., which time period the authors say "is almost double the length of the next-longest gap in major hurricane landfalls." Thus, if anything, these data suggest that CO 2 -induced global warming is reducing the number and strength of landfalling U.S. hurricanes.

In one final data demonstration to show that the climate alarmists have got it wrong (and possibly backwards), Truchelut and Staehling prepared a plot of the percent of each Atlantic hurricane season's observed basin-wide ACE that occurred over or within a 0.5° buffer of the continental U.S. over the period 1950-2017. Analysis of these data revealed that "the 2006-2015 average is the lowest on record, with just under 3% of the total ACE in the period occurring over the continental U.S." Such drought of hurricane activity in later years contributed to an overall downward trend in the record that the authors report was statistically significant at the 99% confidence level.

Clearly, based on the data presented in this paper, there is no evidence to support the contention that rising levels of atmospheric CO 2 are increasing the frequency or magnitude of hurricanes hitting the U.S. If anything, the data suggest rising CO 2 is reducing them. So, the next time you hear someone claim a U.S. hurricane is caused by CO 2 -induced global warming, be sure to show them the data and teach them that is incorrect.



Figure 1. Panel (a): Record of calendar days between continental U.S. hurricane landfall events of 100 kt or greater between 1 January 1900 and 15 November 2017. The horizontal red line designates the mean return period and the vertical blue line represents the most recent period of hurricane inactivity. Spaces with no visible bar represent short within-season lengths of time between U.S. hurricane landfalls. Panel (b): Time series of Integrated Storm Activity Annually over the Continental U.S. (ISAAC) from 1900 through 2017, with a 10 year centered average value shown in red. Panel (c): Time series of proportional ISAAC expressed as a percentage of the annual cumulative ACE occurring in the Atlantic Basin over the period 1950-2017, with a 10 year centered average value shown in red.