After Rialmo stepped into the front door of the building, LeGrier came "barging" out the front door of the second-floor apartment, holding a baseball bat in his right hand, according to the lawsuit. Rialmo had been standing in the front doorway, and when LeGrier got downstairs, he "took a full swing" at the officer, "missing (his head) by inches, but getting close enough for Officer Rialmo to feel the movement of air as the bat passed in front of his face."