Commentary from the peanut gallery with C J Dee , Rebecca Fleming and Nalini Haynes

It’s been a while since I posted a Peanut Gallery commentary. Bec, CJ and I are watching Supernatural together as part of Geek Girl Day, a supposedly fortnightly event where the 3 of us get together, we catch up, we eat, we celebrate all things geeky. CJ is a long-time fan of Supernatural so she’s proselytizing Bec and I. Bec and I had actually decided to watch Supernatural, we just hadn’t got there yet. We’re also living under the threat of watching Sharknado so 11 seasons of Supernatural can distract CJ from her mission in life: to convert us to love of really cheesy horror. Either that, or Supernatural will convert us.

I should add: we’re all Australians. Why does this matter, you ask. Because Australians tend to mock, take the piss and generally shit stir when we love something. If an Australian doesn’t say anything or react to something in any way, it’s a bad sign — because boredom or indifference is purgatory for TV shows. Supernatural has our love, which is growing. Especially during last Geek Girl Day because the one-liner jokes sparkle. We loves them!

Anyway, on with the show. Which begins with a man down a hole yelling “Help me, I’m trapped. I broke my ankle.”

CJ: Of course you did. Oh yeah, that’s broken.

R: Why doesn’t he get other people to help?

“Justin, I’m here!”

CJ: A bit bloody late.

Paper headlines read “Medical mystery”.

N: How about the mystery of the hole appearing?

Sam and Dean interrogate someone like police or journalists.

N: And he’s not tipped off that they’re not relatives? They sound more like reporters.

CJ: Or detectives or something.

Dean gets Sam to go down the hole.

CJ: Beta brother, so easily manipulated.

R: You’d think with all the shit in their car they’d have decent rope so they wouldn’t have to use the hose.

The Winchester brothers go to Larry Pike’s (the real estate agent’s) barbeque. The sales reps try to sell them a house. “…any race, religion or creed or…” says the real estate dude to Sam and Dean.

N: “I think you guys are gay.”

Yep, real estate dude thought the brothers were gay. And we learn that the housing estate is new, built on Native American sacred burial grounds.

N: This is poltergeist.

“I’m gonna go talk to Larry, ok honey?” says Dean to Sam.

[uproarious laughter from the peanut gallery]

Larry’s son Matt tries to scare Lynda Bloome, head of sales, with a tarantula. Matt clearly doesn’t like Lynda.

“Do you think he’s our Willie?”

N: What, two between the two of you isn’t enough willie?

N: They broke into a house to stay overnight but they’re parked outside although there’s a garage.

A spider appears in Lynda’s home. She continues showering.

N: eugh

CJ: Yeah, I’ll hunt the thing down.

R: As if you’d leave it. I couldn’t sleep in there until I’d hunted it down and killed it.

Lynda has a spider shower and dies. The next day the Winchester brothers drive three blocks. They don’t walk because they have to exercise their outer beast.

N: They drove THREE BLOCKS!!!

CJ: It is pouring down with rain. Look at the water in the gutters. They can’t have good drainage.

The brothers investigate Lynda’s home and find some spiders.

R: They look like rubber spiders.

N: That’s because THEY ARE. (Shortly after watching this episode of Supernatural I had a run in with a spider in my home that looked like a live version of one of these rubber spiders. Now I’m not so sure.)

The Winchester brothers meet up with Matt, whose tale of paternal conflict strikes a chord with Beta Brother. Having bonded with the kid, the brothers follow Matt into the woods where he shows them lots and lots of insects converging on a specific site.

CJ: Don’t pick it up!

R: It’s a stick insect.

CJ: SMUSH IT!

N: They don’t hurt anything.

CJ: SMUSH IT!

Dean puts his hand down a hole.

[unanimous UUUUUUUUUUgh]

CJ: Oh it just got a hell of a lot worse. That’s a weird shirt. In one shot it looks purple but from the front it looks paisley. And now it’s wet!

The housing estate was built on sacred Native American burial grounds.

N: I did mention Poltergeist really early on, didn’t I?

CJ: You did.

Matt reaches towards hole.

N: Oh come on.

CJ: You guys were ok when he picked up the stick insect.

“You need to leave.”

“What? Why?”

N: Because your backyard is full of cockroaches.

They don’t leave. Why? Because they’re stupid. And MONEY.

“You hear it?”

CJ: That’s the sound of BEING WRONG.

“Call 911. Joni!”

CJ: And tell them what? She doesn’t know anything.

“What do we do now?”

CJ: Spray Raid everywhere.

Dean picks up a can of Raid.

CJ: THANK YOU, DEAN WINCHESTER.

“What is that?”

N: They didn’t.

CJ: Spray the bug spray Dean.

“Oh god, what’s that?”

N: Dirt.

CJ: Spray the bug spray. Or don’t. Now he — yeah!

Bug spray. On ALL THE BUGS.

N: He’s got to be getting low on fuel.

R: Yep. Just ran out.

Dawn creeps over the horizon at the last minute. The sun’s first rays herald the end of the Seige of Insects.

R: There’s no way that was in 12 hours. It was like 12 minutes, if that.

Bzzz. An insect survives. Will there be a sequel?

CJ: Nice touch.

Rating: 3 out of 5 stars.

Enjoyment factor with friends: 5 stars.

Director: Kim Manners

Writers: Eric Kripke (created by), Rachel Nave, Bill Coakley

Stars: Jared Padalecki, Jensen Ackles, Andrew Airlie