The hot new feature on the Apple Watch Series 5 is one that you’re going to use the most: the always on display. With every other generation of Apple Watch, the display turned black after you were done using it, but the Series 5 stays lit so you can quickly see the time without waiting a second for the display to light up.

But more important than the convenience it brings, the Always On feature fundamentally changes how your Apple Watch looks. Since the always-on display will be visible some 90 percent of the time, it’s more like a regular watch than ever before, so you’ll want to choose a face that looks good.

Apple Watch Series 5 Always On: Turn it on

The Always On display will be on by default when you pair your Apple Watch Series 5 for the first time, but if it’s not working on your watch, here’s how to activate it. Head over to the Settings app, then Display & Brightness, and Always On. On the next screen, tap the toggle to turn it green and you’re good to go.

Apple Watch Series 5 Always On: Hide Sensitive data

Once you turn on the always-on display, you’ll see a toggle below labeled Hide Sensitive Complications. Turn that green and your watch won’t show mail messages, calendar appointments, or anything else that might be for your eyes only once the always-on display is active.

Apple Watch Series 5 Always On: Pick a face

Choosing a watch face on your Apple Watch Series 5 is the same as it was on Series 4. Tap and hold on the watch face until it gets smaller and a Customize button appears. You can swipe through your available faces to pick one or you can swipe all the way left until you see a plus sign with New above it. Tap it and you’ll get a list of every available watch face. Select the one you want and it will appear in your main list. You won't be able to see what the always-on version looks like, however.

Apple Watch Series 5 Always On: Customize your watch face

When you’re on the watch face selection screen, you can tap on the Customize button below each screen to change the color, look, and complications. Each one is different, but you’ll swipe to change what your customizing and spin the crown to cycle through the options. Most faces have numerous colors and complications to choose from, so take time to discover each one.

Apple Watch Series 5 Always On: From worst to best

Now for the moment you’ve been waiting for. We tested every always-on face so you don’t have to.

33. Toy Story

Michael SImon/IDG

The Toy Story Always-On face is a real missed opportunity. As it stands, the picture goes away and all that remains is a white digital clock and up to two complications. But Apple could have had some fun with the colors and the background or played with the characters. Instead, we get nothing.

32. Kaleidoscope

Michael SImon/IDG

Apple’s Kaleidoscope face is one of the coolest, but the always-on version leaves much to be desired. Like the main face, it randomly changes, but since it’s only updated once a minute, the kaleidoscope effect is lost. And it’s too dim to see from a distance

31. Timelapse

30. Motion

29. Fire and water

28. Liquid metal

27. Vapor

Michael SImon/IDG

Apple’s full-screen animated faces might look cool when they’re filling up with fire and steam, but the always-on counterpart isn’t nearly as creative. The animation goes away, as does the second hand, leaving a white hour and minute hand along with many complications you may have. Any complications you've added stick around, which is nice, but ultimately they're quite boring

26. Breathe

Michael Simon

Like the other animated faces, the always-on Breathe face only has a set of hands and up to three complications. However, the hands keep their light blue hue, which is a nice touch.

25. Siri

24. Photos

23. Modular

22. Numerals

21. Activity Digital

20. Solar Graph

19. Infograph Modular

18. Astronomy

Michael SImon/IDG

Faces 18 to 25 on this list merely dim (and lose their second hand, if applicable) when in always-on mode, which isn’t a bad thing. Your chosen color stays, as do any complications you’ve chose. Also, since none of them are traditional-style faces, they’re definitely unique. For the most part, if you like them as a face, you’ll like their always-on option, too, though the Siri face isn’t nearly as useful in a semi-static state.

17. Modular compact

Michael SImon/IDG Apple Watch Series 5 always on modular

Just a tick above the last group is the Modular Compact face. Like the ones above, it dims and loses the second counter, but there’s something about the clock turning from white to black that we particularly like.

16. Simple

15. Chronograph

14. Solar Dial

13. Utility

12. Activity analog

11. Infograph

10. Meridian

Michael SImon/IDG

Like the previous group, all of these watch faces simply dim when they enter always-on mode. The Chronograph also loses its inside dials as well as its stopwatch arm, which takes away some of its character. But since they’re all styled after classic watch-based faces, they will all look sharp on your wrist.

9. Pride Digital

8. Pride Analog

Michael SImon/IDG

At first glance, Apple’s Pride Digital and Pride Analog look like standard dimmable faces, but there’s a subtle difference that makes them stand out: they change color as they dim. So the next time the screen lights up, it will have a different color pattern than the last.

7. Color

Michael SImon/IDG

Apple’s Color face is simple, but there’s just something about it that we love. With the always-on display activated, the color disappears from the screen, but you’ll see a thin colored outline around the clock (in circular mode) and the display (in full-screen mode) along with the white hands.

6. Mickey Mouse

Michael SImon/IDG

The always-on Mickey Mouse face makes the Toy Story face look even lamer. As expected, the always-on face dims and Mickey stops dancing, but there’s a neat touch: The gloves on his hands stay brighter than the rest of the face, so you can see them at a distance.

5. Numerals Duo

4. Numerals Mono

Michael SImon/IDG

This was a surprise. When they were introduced as part of watchOS 6, we didn’t pay much mind to the new Numerals faces, but we kinda dig them on the Apple Watch Series 5. The number are bold and colorful, and the always-on version features outlined numbers, even if you opt for the solid ones.

3. X-Large

Michael SImon/IDG

We’ll admit that we never used the X-Large face before testing it for this article, so call this a pleasant surprise. While the face itself is very plain, it works very well as an always-on option. The giant numbers dim but keep your chosen color, and a thin outline makes them easy to read at a glance. And if you choose the giant complication with a smaller time, the always-on display will show that instead.

2. California

Michael SImon/IDG

Apple’s new California face is a winner both when it’s on and always-on. There’s nothing special about it—depending on your color combinations, the display dims or turns to black—but the California dial’s half Roman-half Arabic numerals and inverted triangle look straight-up classy.

1. Gradient

Michael SImon/IDG

We might not have considered the Gradient face at all if not for the Series 5’s always-on feature—but it’s our favorite of the crop. But you need to pick the right style to take advantage of it. If you stick with the default option, which changes the shade as the hour, minute, and seconds hands rotate, the always-on version will be just as colorful. As with the other faces, the second hand goes away, but the hour and minute hands stick around (and keep their color) but the gradient they create gets darker and way cooler.