It depends on who really has the best attack or denense. Though Nicks blade is build for attack and power, Judy's is rebuilt after Nick destroys the first one with a far stronger defence and endurance capability.In a drawn out battle, Judy has the upper hand, so long as she steers clear of him for a long period of time. Nicks' only hope is to catch her and finish her off quickly, as his endurance is rather poor and his attack is really only effective from the get-go