Early the next morning, I got up quietly and let the girls sleep. It had been an eventful night to be sure. Downstairs, I brewed a pot of coffee and was busy making blueberry muffins when Jennifer appeared. I hoped she wasn’t sore about all that had happened this weekend. I hoped she wasn’t sore but, if she was, well I figured I could live with her moods in the long run. Or not.

Jennie fixed herself a cup of coffee and waited patiently for the stove timer to signal the muffins time to be devoured. I was attempting to be jovial about things but I could tell Jennie was still pissed. Finally, she spoke.

“So, my sister get spanked, I have to lick her asshole and you get off scot free. Is that how this works Jeff?” She said eyeing me warily.

“Oh, now Jen, we were just having some fun.” I attempted to pooh pooh the situation.

“Well, YOU were certainly having fun.” She shot back. I decided to just let it slide and try to ignore her annoyance. I remained quiet. I got the butter out of the fridge and put the plate of nice and warm muffins on the table in front of her. We both got coffee and started in on the muffins. Then, Jennie reached in to the pocket of her terrycloth robe. She produced a pair of white cotton panties, stained with sticky cum. Oh oh, I thought.

“Gee, I wonder what mom and dad will think when I show them Mary’s soiled panties?”

“Now, Jen, uh…you don’t really want to do that do you? I mean, all of us will be in hot water and…”

“No, YOU don’t want me to do this. Right Jeff? You had your fun with my little sister and me and now you think you’ll just walk away Mr. Innocent. Well, not so!” At that point, I understood what trouble I was in. My Mom and Dad thought of me as a perfect little clean cut “young man on the way up.” A steamy sex scandal didn’t fit in to their view of my world. I regularly used Mom’s car to do whatever I wanted including driving to the Rendezvous Ballroom way down in Balboa Island to see surf music. I could kiss that goodbye if this got out. Somehow, I had to wiggle out of this mess.

“Well, maybe we could work out some kind or a solution to this…uh…situation!” I offered.

“My sister and I have already worked out your solution Jeff, come up to our bedroom when you’re ready to accept your fate.”

At this point, I knew that the sisters had conspired against me. Mary had to have known where her cum splattered panties were and took them to her sister. I seemed to have no choice. With a sigh of resignation, I made my way up the Roberts sister’s room.

“You can just lose your pajamas now Jeff.” Jennie ordered me. I took off my pajamas and my briefs assuming I would have to be nude to accept my “punishment” whatever it might be. I must admit my cock was semi hard due to the proximity of both of the exciting Roberts sisters. Each in her own way, extremely sexy and desirable. Jennie, a hot lay and with the full blown teen age sexpot body. She knew how to do it dirty too. And her little sister, the sexually blossoming Mary, “Baby” to her family…and me, a young woman whose sexuality was exploding now. Still a virgin but eager to get past that hurdle.