This email has also been verified by Google DKIM 2048-bit RSA key

Re: Rubio and Missed Votes

From:tcarrk@hillaryclinton.com To: oshur@hillaryclinton.com CC: john.podesta@gmail.com Date: 2015-10-07 23:00 Subject: Re: Rubio and Missed Votes

We missed a lot of votes in 2008. We did go after Obama on attendance though in 2008, but that was more on his chairing committee hearings. If we do this it should be through the dnc or without our fingerprints. I like where bush is going: docking pay. There should be a movement to get him to resign Sent from my iPhone On Oct 7, 2015, at 8:28 PM, Oren Shur <oshur@hillaryclinton.com> wrote: Yeah, the other R’s are hitting this pretty hard. Tony, do we have vulnerabilities here from Senate days or is this an open go-zone for us? * Interesting. ---------- Forwarded message ---------- John, We met briefly at the Clean Energy Summit in Las Vegas. I am a Marine Corps veteran and former California legislator who narrowly lost a campaign for San Diego Mayor. I am also a long time Clinton fan and supporter. I wanted to send you an email to share an experience from my Mayoral campaign that could prove useful. Many people smarter than me disagree but I would not want to run against Marco Rubio in a general election. The issue of his missing votes has been raised. I had a similar problem when I was a legislator running for Mayor. Prior to the campaign, we actually assessed the potential damage from missing votes and were assured by others that it never resonated, they had tested, not to worry, etc. However, my opponents used a slightly different approach. They claimed I didn’t show up to work. They outlined the government salary I received for not showing up to work. They very creatively (although not honestly) counted the days I missed in Sacramento even when there were no votes taking place to say I wasn’t there XX% of the days. We initially ignored the hits because I had always been rated the “hardest working” and “most effective” legislator, etc. By the time we realized the damage done it was too late to respond. The other challenge is there isn’t a good response when you are an elected official. You are paid to do your job—not run for another office. People do resent that someone is getting a government paycheck (from them) and not showing up to do their job. Just a suggestion based on my very painful experience. Hope your well. Nathan