Yesterday, we brought you the heartwarming story of an old woman’s appearance on the Antiques Roadshow with her baseball cards from 1871. The woman learned on the show that her collection, handed down from her great grandfather, was valued at $1 million.

This is her reaction.

It was magical television and according to Keith Olbermann, it was all a lie.

“Those cards we’ve never seen before?” Olbermann began, readying to crush this woman’s dreams of becoming a millionaire. “Theyre actually scorecards from the Boston games of 1871. The photos were a novelty to sell more scorecards and they are beautiful and rare because they didn’t sell well. But there are at least two dozen different ones known and at least 100 of them total – even I have a bunch. And they’re in all the catalogs and they have a name. They’re called Mort Rogers 1871 Boston scorecards and the 10 of them there are NOT worth a million dollars.”

He then made this face.

It’s true that there are other cards like this, however, don’t let Olbermann’s surliness lead you to believe this woman’s collection is worthless. Looking at auctions of individual Mort Rogers scorecards from 1871 and 1872, these cards have been sold for anywhere between $7,000 – $12,000 individually. That doesn’t take into account the handwritten note or the fact that these cards are a set. The last time the woman took the cards to be appraised, she was told their worth was $5,000. At worst, she just learned that her cards are worth 20 times more.

This also isn’t the first time Olbermann has yelled at people for spending a lot of money on 19th century baseball cards or for calling them baseball cards.

In 2013, he wrote a very, very long piece about a 1865 photograph of the Brooklyn Atlantics selling for $92,000 in Maine. Olbermann’s issue with the item? It wasn’t actually a baseball card.

Olbermann writes: “I mean, it’s a picture of what was then a major league baseball team, it’s on cardboard, and the French term for what it is includes that country’s word for ‘card’ – let me mention that I don’t disrespect anybody who disagrees with my conclusion, and that the idea of which items from the pre-1886 era are cards and which aren’t is very fluid and very open to interpretation.”

The lesson? Antiques Roadshow still succeeded in making a woman’s day by notifying her that she owns a very expensive set of baseball CARDS that probably aren’t worth a million dollars but are worth well over $100,000, which is still a ridiculous sum and Keith Olbermann is such a grump.