We asked you to pick your favorite fall show, and you voted — again, and again, and again. And the winner is…

Supernatural!

In their 12th season, the Winchester brothers (Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles) have added yet another victory to their list of achievements. (And this one comes right after stopping the apocalypse!) After 2.6 million votes were tallied, Supernatural came out on top, beating 63 other new and returning fall shows in our bracket competition.

This week, subscribers will receive the Supernatural edition of the Fall TV Preview cover — jam-packed with scoop from the set of The CW’s longest-running series, as well as info on 136 other shows — and the special collectors’ edition will be sold exclusively at Barnes and Nobles nationwide, beginning Sept. 9. Buy it here, and for more exclusive interviews and photos only in EW, subscribe here.

Image zoom MATTHIAS CLAMER for EW