The remarkable journey of Orthodox Jewish woman cast out into a life of poverty by her family after buying a tight sweater at 17... who then went on to graduate Harvard

At the age of 17, Leah Vincent was sent to live in New York, alone. It was there she learned about life in the real world but not before making a number of mistakes

Leah was unprepared to navigate the freedoms of secular life. She worked as a prostitute, cut herself, and had an affair with a married professor

Leah eventually found true love, graduated from Harvard after winning a scholarship there and is now married with a daughter



Leah Vincent was born into the Yeshivish community, a fundamentalist sect of ultra-Orthodox Judaism.

The fifth of 11 children born to a prominent Orthodox rabbi in Pittsburgh. Leah and her ten siblings were raised to worship two things: God and the men who ruled their world.

At the age of 15, Leah was preparing for marriage. But the tradition-bound future Leah envisioned for herself was cut short when, at 16, she was caught exchanging letters with a male friend questioning her ultraorthodox Jewish faith.

Scroll down for video



Estranged: Leah Vincent was born into the Yeshivish community, a fundamentalist sect of ultra-Orthodox Judaism but she was shunned by her parents at the age of 17

She had violated the religious law that forbids contact between members of the opposite sex.

‘I was now marked as a girl who had spoken with boys. I was no longer a good girl,’ she says. ‘I wanted to be good. I was just too curious. My evil desires had momentarily led me astray,' she told the New York Post.



‘Your behavior has become unacceptable,’ said her mother. ‘We give you chance after chance, and you keep on messing up and hurting people. Disappointing people.'

‘You are not getting any more allowance. You’ll have to figure out how to get by on your own,’ she continued. ‘You think you’re so grown-up? Let’s see how grown-up you are.’

The final straw was when she purchased a sweater that her parents deemed immodest; she expressed an ambition to one day attend college and doubted the strict codes of conduct prescribed by her religion.

Leah’s parents were unforgiving. Afraid, in part, that her behavior would affect the marriage prospects of their other children, they put her on a plane to New York City before her 18th birthday and cut off ties.

Video filmed by Haimy Assefa for Footsteps.org



Shunned: At the age of 17, Leah Vincent was sent to live in New York, alone. It was there she learned about life in the real world but not before making a number of mistakes

After the sweater incident, Vincent’s parents found her a studio apartment in Kensington, Brooklyn for $450 a month and job as a secretary that paid minimum wage. They paid the first month’s rent — but after that she was completely on her own in every sense of the word.

In her Yeshivish community, there was a strict segregation of the sexes.

‘Women in my family were not allowed to attend college or become Jewish scholars. Men had the ultimate authority in the home and in the community,’ Vincent writes in her memoir, Cut Me Loose.

A girl’s two most important goals, she says, are to be modest and obedient. In order to reach these goals, according to Vincent, a girl must:

Wear shirts buttoned to her neck with sleeves covering her elbows and with skirts that fall below the knee. Even wearing patterned tights or wide belts are banned as too provocative.

Abstain from talking to unmarried men. Be seen and not heard. The community frowned on women singing or talking too loudly.

Orthodox Judaism: Women must abstain from talking to unmarried men.¿Essentially, be seen and not heard. The community would frown on women singing or talking too loudly. Leah's parents believed that anything to the contrary would jeopardize her chances of finding a husband

These rules (and many more) were vital to maintaining a good reputation, an absolute necessity for landing a suitable husband.

‘A girl’s sexuality was so powerful,’ says Vincent, ‘any hint of it had to always be completely hidden.’

At 17, she was banished by her parents and left to fend for herself in New York City. It was then her heartbreaking and terrifying experience began.

For several years she lived alone in a shabby studio apartment in the Kensington neighborhood of Brooklyn. She was lonely. Her mother rarely phoned. Her father had severed communication entirely.

Accustomed to seeking male approval, she now attracted plenty of the wrong kind.

She approached men hung out on the local basketball court and began a series of grim and risky relationships, culminating in her rape age 17 by a boyfriend.

‘I soon began to stop and watch the games,’ she says. ‘I longed for my stares to beckon one of those people to the bench where I sat, to talk to me.’

Several of the men began to flirt with her and one, called Nicholas, took a special interest in her.

When Nicholas asked her to accompany him back to his apartment, she said yes, knowing that as a good Orthodox girl, she could not date or marry him.

Awakening: Leah was unprepared to navigate the freedoms of secular life. She worked as a prostitute, cut herself, and had an affair with a married professor

Ultimately in the basement at a Manhattan club, Nicholas raped her.

Not even knowing what intercourse entailed, and asked herself, ‘Was that sex?’ She lacked the basic understanding of the body and the tools to deal with men to whom she had spent a childhood learning to yield and please.

By 19, Ms. Vincent had overdosed, swallowing a half-bottle of aspirin after mutilating herself with a rusty razor and ended up spending 10 days in a psychiatric hospital..

And by 21 she had tried to establish herself as a Craigslist prostitute.

The responses flooded in. She picked one, a lawyer from the Upper East Side. And even though she had been in the city now for several years, even after living a very ‘modern’ life, she still was clueless. She never quoted a fee and

agreed to meet him at his place. He paid her after their second go-round — and only $60. Shamed, she vowed not to prostitute herself again.

Cast out in New York City, without a father or husband tethering her to the Orthodox community, Leah was unprepared to navigate the freedoms of secular life.

Cut Me Loose: Sin and Salvation After My Ultra-Orthodox Girlhood. The book details Leah Vincents life as she left her Orthodox sect and ventured out into a brave new world

'There is little room for a single girl in Yeshivish life,' she explains, referring to the many daily restrictions imposed by ultraorthodox practice. 'For a woman, the rhythm of observance is tied to family. One is either a daughter or a wife.'

At one point she returned back to the family home for a family dinner. Her parents made her eat off paper plates—not to meet the requirements of Jewish law, her sister explained, but to prevent her from 'contaminating' the family.

After Ms. Vincent attempted suicide, she writes, her parents told her other siblings that she just wanted attention and that they should ignore her.

She spent the next few years using her sexuality as a way of attracting the male approval she had been conditioned to seek out as a child, while becoming increasingly unfaithful to the religious dogma of her past.

It took Ms. Vincent a long time, years even, to shake the feeling that she was corrupted and didn’t deserve happiness.

Long after she had dropped the external markers of religiosity—her modest clothes and dietary restrictions—she still judged her actions based off of the standards with which she was raised.

'Even though I put on pants and was having sex with people, it doesn’t meant that my brain bounced back into normal, un-fundamentalist religion shape,' she said.

She succeeded however, when it came to education. She had been accepted to Brooklyn College on a scholarship and achieved straight-A’s.

She became involved with a married professor, 42 years her senior who encouraged her to speak up when it came to her opinions on politics, culture and the world.

Leah has tried to confront the oppressive world of religious fundamentalism and the broader issues that face even the most secular young women as they grapple with sexuality and identity.

Ms. Vincent also used her freedom to attend college, and with the encouragement of the prof, was awarded a scholarship at Harvard earning a master's degree at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government.

Happy endings: Leah eventually found true love, graduated from Harvard after winning a scholarship there and is now married with a daughter

Ms. Vincent never fully explains her parents' vicious behavior. 'I felt like I was caught in a garish nightmare,' she says, recalling the period that led to her estrangement.

Now at the age of 31, Leah is married to Zeke, who also left a Hasidic upbringing in Borough Park, Queens. The two have since married and have a daughter.

‘I fiercely believe that all people should have a right to a self-determined life,’ she says.

'My parents getting stricter and stricter, my petty transgressions ballooning into terrifying sins.'