Why It’s Hard Being a Black Companion Animalby Marla Rose

Back when I worked at a large animal shelter in Chicago, there were certain dogs and cats who were practically guaranteed a quick adoption: the puppies and kittens, the purebreds, and the outgoing and physically distinctive ones.

For many others, the likelihood of a rapid adoption was less certain. The older animals, adult dogs and cats who were not housebroken, and the ones who were scared or less social often languished for weeks or even months without anyone considering them for adoption. Staying too long at a shelter that euthanizes is in itself an increased risk of being killed. For one thing, the animals are more likely to be exposed to upper-respiratory infections; these are not usually a serious health concern, but at a crowded shelter in need of available cages, such infections are grounds for euthanasia. For another, animals who are shy can become even more socially withdrawn, and less desirable habits like barking can worsen. No-kill shelters are not necessarily a solution: they have to be very selective about the animals they take in, often considering only the most highly adoptable ones.

At the shelter I worked at for five years, I would see cage after cage with large black mixed-breed dogs and black cats. Many of them were relatively young, outgoing, and charming—and in perfect health. Yet these animals often lingered at the shelter, day after day, without having anyone look into adopting them. What I didn’t know then was that these lovely and friendly animals had a decreased likelihood of being quickly adopted simply because of the color of their fur and thus, these potential perfect companions were at increased risk of euthanasia.

Since my days back in the shelter, a new awareness has emerged about the unique challenge that homeless black dogs (especially large ones) and cats face in their journey toward being adopted due to the cultural bias against their fur color. It is such a pronounced liability that an actual phenomenon has been identified: Black Dog (sometimes Big Black Dog) and Black Cat Syndrome.

Statistics on the phenomenon are rare, but shelters and rescue workers have known about it for years. There is speculation but no conclusive answer as to why homeless black companion animals face such a challenge getting adopted. Some have guessed that it is because of negative cultural associations: of course, the superstition of a black cat bringing bad luck is a deeply entrenched, common one. Black dogs, especially large ones, are also depicted as harbingers of doom in folklore and literature, such as the demonic death hound in Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s The Hound of the Baskervilles and, more recently Grim, the big black dog who stalks Harry in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. If that weren’t gloomy enough, Winston Churchill referred to the depression that plagued him as his “black dog.” (I wish that Sir Winston had been to meet Murph, the black Labrador who lived once next door to us. He was filled with youthful exuberance long after his muzzle had gone grey and was an anti-depressant in canine form.)

Others have conjectured that black-coated animals are not as visible at poorly lit shelters and do not photograph as well for potential adopters browsing websites. Their features and expressions do not pop out as much as those on lighter-coated animals and, frankly, they are often seen as less physically distinctive than those with markings. Due to some white facial hair, even young ones may appear to be older than they are, which is another large hurdle for any homeless animal to overcome. The black-coated large dogs can also be perceived as menacing with expressions that are less easy to interpret. To level the playing field, many shelters and rescues have taken to taking photos of their black animals with colorful ribbons and bow ties to help make them more noticeable.

Regardless of why, the unique difficulties that face otherwise very adoptable black companion animals has made them more at risk at shelters. Many no-kill shelters and rescues are reluctant to accept even a perfectly healthy black-coated dog or cat with a good temperament when they know that the animal may take months and months to place in a home, and these animals are at an elevated risk at shelters that do euthanize. Thankfully, now that the phenomenon has been identified, animal advocates are figuring out how to best offset the bias against black dogs and cats. One way is for rescue organizations to raise public awareness about the real repercussions of unexamined bigotry against companion animals born with black coats.

Erin Lamparter, vice president and co-founder of Lulu’s Locker Rescue, a Chicago-area rescue that focuses on placing black dogs and cats (as well as FIV-positive cats), spoke to me about the pervasive superstitions that black domestic housecats must overcome in order to be adopted.

“People we speak with nod in agreement when we mention that black cats are the least adopted animals. They immediately refer to the idea that black cats are bad luck for many reasons. Though, it’s interesting that when we dig deeper and ask why they believe black cats actually bring bad luck, not one person we’ve spoken to can give an example of a direct, personal experience,” she said. “More than anything, these misconceptions arose from having read or learned about such silly stereotypes as a child. We’ve found that people haven’t had a direct, negative experience surrounding black cats. Each person walks away surprised and educated, wanting to help black cats (and dogs) even more, and educate others about their new-found information.”

Another organization, Black Pearl Dogs, operates on a national scale and has been educating the public about the unfair bias against big black dogs and helping them find homes since 2004. Black Pearl Dogs was founded when Tamara Delaney offered to find a suitable home for a black Labrador retriever named Jake who had been waiting without adoption for three years. She looked for a home for Jake for eight months before adopting the sweet-natured dog herself. Today with Black Pearl Dogs, Tamara is a liaison between shelters and the public, raising the visibility of their high-risk black dogs and the challenges they face.

What can the rest of us do? Consider adopting a black-coated dog or cat the next time you are looking for a companion. If you are not able to adopt, foster homes are vitally important to rescue groups like Lulu’s Locker. If you cannot foster, consider sponsoring an animal, donating or helping to put together a fundraiser. If you are a skilled photographer, consider donating your time and talents to a shelter, capturing the animals in the best way so potential adopters will not overlook them so easily. Last, those helping to forge new associations with black dogs and cats will make it easier for the animals in need of a permanent home to find one.

“Through no fault of their own, blacks cats and dogs have historically been the most overlooked and highly euthanized animals. They wait much longer to be adopted than animals of other colors or markings, and a disproportionate number of them end up being euthanized because they are consistently overlooked and discriminated against in fables as well as everyday life,” said Erin of Lulu’s Locker. “Creating a shift in thinking is key and parents, teachers, friends and family can play the biggest part.”

Most importantly, we need to educate the public about companion animal overpopulation. If shelters weren’t already overflowing with dogs and cats, black-coated animals wouldn’t face such a struggle to find a home in the first place. Spaying and neutering has to be our top priority when it comes to improving the lives of all companion animals and their chances of finding a home. In the meantime, maybe you have room for a black-coated beauty in your life?

To Learn More

How Can I Help?