Allison and Tom are kinda suspicious, aren’t they?

We are introduced to them via a Good Cop - Bad Cop scenario

Tom is mean to us, causing us to bond with Allison, who is always nice and sweet. This is an often-used psychological trick, that could very easily have been just an act on their part.



Allison knows that the secret messages are leading in circles, yet she encourages us to follow them

She even gives us her precious seeing tool, despite the fact that she claims not to trust us. How often do you hand over your most precious valuables to a person you distrust?

They act like they don’t know what’s inside their own hideout.

How come they didn’t know that there was a secret toilet there? How come they never thought of looking around with the seeing tool? The ‘Never!’ On the table by the animatronic Tom got his hand from proves that they can see the same messages we can see. Could it be that they are simply pretending not to know?

There’s a gent pipe inside the toilet - we see Tom holding the same one at the end of Chapter 4. Have you seen another gent pipe anywhere inside the hideout?



There are only 2 spoons inside the hideout - one reveals the secret door. If they were unaware of that, it means they’ve both been eating with only one spoon, and ignoring the other one for who knows how long!

Allison doesn’t give us a spoon when she gives us the soup. If we’d tried to eat it using the spoon in our cell, the secret would’ve been revealed. What a lucky coincidence that Tom prevented us from eating, and Allison never attempted to feed us again! Almost like the whole scene was planned in advance…

Allison pretends to help us out of our cell, yet she doesn’t tell Tom to use the axe in his hand



Or use any of the weapons and objects she has with her, such as the machete, which she later uses to break open the door leading to the administration.



We fall a moment after Allison told us to lead the way.

And if that’s not suspicious enough by itself - there’s a picture of the seeing tool down in that hole. The seeing tool was created by them, and as far as we know, there’s only one copy of it. Isn’t that strange?

“Not Monsters” attack us when we’re with with Allison and Tom

Why would people, who make it a point that they aren’t monsters, attack us on sight? Unless they believe that we are the true monsters? Yet they didn’t attack us when we were alone back in Chapter 4. What’s more, the message in that room was 'No Angels!’ - they hate all angels, not just Susie. What must have happened between them and Allison to cause such a radical dislike?

Allison tells us she can’t walk through ink or she will die. How did she survive coming out of the ink machine in the first place?



It’s flooded by design. If she came out of another ink machine, how could destroying this one set her free?



Susie said that a 'she’ forced her to kill all those Borises.

There’s only one other 'she’ in the studio, who could have done this, and the first time we meet her, she strikes Susie down. We never get an explanation as to how she and Tom got there, and why did they kill Susie.



And if you think they did it out of the goodness of their hearts…



They were in the R&D room, yet they didn’t free this woman. Why would they help us?

They were searching for something. We never found out what that thing is.

The only places left were Level 4 and Level P. There’s only one thing on level P that might interest them…

Where they hoping to build their own ink machine?

They framed Bendy with Sammy’s death



We can see Boris’ feet in the image that used to show at the end of Chapter 2, and one of the sketches on Joey’s desk shows a Boris inside the Bendy costume - the same costume that’s missing a left hand, same as Tom.



While escaping the ritual room, we hear sounds coming from the shaft above, moving in the direction of the door to the ink machine control room. Someone is whistling inside that room - presumably Allison. Allison controls the ink machine?



They might not be who they claim to be

There are letters from real Allison and Thomas on Joey’s corkboard. They seem to be alive and well out in the real world. The number of coffins in the game doesn’t add up. Their names aren’t on the coffins, nor among the unused names in the datamined files. There are numerous hints on level K that Allison and Tom have been wandering around. Which means they had probably heard the tapes - hell, Allison even tells us that Tom reacts to his name, implying he’s heard it before.



What guarantee do we have that they didn’t decide to adopt personas based on people mentioned in those tapes?

