If horror movies have taught us anything, it’s that we should probably stay far, far away from creepy toys.

From Chucky, the possessed, knife-wielding “Good Guys” doll from the Child’s Play franchise, to the eerie and unholy night-terror that is Annabelle from The Conjuring films, warped playthings have long been used as a vehicle for scaring the shit out of people.

Perhaps the idea of something that’s supposed to comfort us, especially in our childhood years, turning out to be far more sinister than what we thought is the thing that excites — and scares — us most about the prospect of owning creepy toys.

Or perhaps it all comes down to morbid curiosity. After all, the most alarming thing about Chucky and Annabelle is that they were both inspired by true stories, making the likelihood of purchasing an evil gift for your kid seem even more real.

As toys age, they tend to look exponentially more “haunted,” especially if they’ve been well-used or mishandled. Facial cracks, dirt marks, or chipped off body parts can reinforce their paranormal patinas even more. Come across one, and the bulk of us are likely to chuck it, burn it, or take some other extraordinary measures to remove it from our lives.

But not everyone feels this way. Some people actually like being spooked by inanimate objects.

Unsettling Toys, a new business based out of Portland, Oregon, is well aware of this. One of the main reasons they exist is to make it easier for fright lovers to “adopt” nightmares of their own.