We already showed you the contestants of Survivor: Cambodia—Second Chance talking about the players they were surprised to see not voted in by fans . But now it’s time for the flipside: Who were they shocked to find did make the cut?

We talked with the cast on location in Cambodia the day before the game began (which premieres Sept. 23 on CBS) and got them to spill the proverbial beans as to who they thought would not make it but did. Which name comes up the most as the biggest surprise? Who counts himself as the biggest shocker among the final 20? And which two players did some think would split the vote and cancel each other out? Watch the video above to see for yourself.