The 19-year-old midfielder went toe-to-toe with Pogba in Genoa’s defeat to Juventus and has enjoyed an impressive start to his first season on loan in Italy

After only four games of a two-year loan at Genoa, Manchester City’s Olivier Ntcham is already beginning to sparkle. The 19-year-old has swapped performing before the modest crowds watching Patrick Vieira’s elite development squad last season for the 36,000-capacity Stadio Luigi Ferraris and a starting place in Gian Piero Gasperini’s side.

Despite having never made a first-team appearance in City colours, Ntcham is mixing it with the aristocrats of Serie A, as he did in Sunday’s 2-0 defeat to a Juventus led by Paul Pogba, the high-class midfielder Ntcham is drawing comparisons with in Italy.

Ntcham, who like Pogba is French, arrived at the Etihad Stadium from Le Havre in 2012. Ntcham was a vital part of Vieira’s under-21 side who won last season’s inaugural Premier League International Cup. He played every minute en route to the 1-0 defeat of Porto in May’s final, which was staged at the City Football Academy and settled by Kelechi Iheanacho’s fifth-minute finish.

Manchester City sink Sunderland by half-time to reach fourth round Read more

Ntcham, who wore the No8 shirt for City, is a natural in Steven Gerrard’s position at Liverpool. Despite still being a teenager he already appears a powerhouse, a quality that is balanced by mobility, the ability to play the simple or clever ball, and a natural instinct to ghost into the penalty area at the right time to score.

He is also a flexible footballer, and is proving so for Genoa. In the defeat to Juve at the Stadio Luigi, Ntcham again showed how his talent is being honed by competing in Serie A. Genoa, who finished sixth last season, went down to 10 men when the defender Armando Izzo was sent off before the break. At this stage a Juve side who featured Pogba, Mario Mandzukic, Álvaro Morata, Gianluigi Buffon and Giorgio Chiellini were winning 1-0. A second-half Pogba penalty confirmed victory for the visitors yet Ntcham was Genoa’s finest performer, operating in the No10 role.

This has been his position for three of the club’s four matches this campaign. In the opening game Ntcham played wide right when Genoa lost 1-0 at Palermo, and that display also drew plaudits. He was similarly impressive in the 2-0 win over Verona and the 1-0 defeat at Fiorentina, when the former France Under-16 captain was stationed in the hole behind the strikers, Goran Pandev and Diego Capel.

Following the victory over Verona, Ntcham tweeted: “Merci a tous pour votre soutien et vos messages. Thanks all for your support. Work hard play hard.”

This message was to fans and the wider calcio cognoscenti, who believe a genuine talent has landed in their game. Gasperini, who has a penchant for harnessing promising young footballers, is a keen admirer. He says: “Ntcham is an unbelievable player. He’s a surprise for me – Olivier is only 19, but plays like a leader. He will become a top player.”

Genoa’s president, Enrico Preziosi, adds: “I’ve been in the world of football 26 years and I’ve never seen a similar player at his age. He has an unlimited potential, and is really a fantastic talent.”

The view at Genoa is Ntcham could fly as high as Pogba, who was also at Le Havre before he arrived at Juventus via Manchester United. Pogba’s club are now keeping tabs on Ntcham, as are Internazionale, whom he came close to joining before City.

Ntcham chose Manchester ahead of Milan after City persuaded his family of the attractions of the club, paying Le Havre just over €1m (£730,000). Genoa have an option to buy Ntcham, who signed a fresh five-year contract in the summer and whose loan expires in June 2017, though City have safeguarded their investment by inserting a clause which effectively allows veto over any prospective permanent deal.

Following the loss to Juve, on Tuesday Ntcham tweeted: “Every game is a fight... Forza @GenoaCFC.”

It sums up his attitude well and it sums up why he has been able to move effortlessly from under-21 football to the big time. And, it points to why City are observing him closely at his new home.

During the last transfer window they had been intent on signing Pogba before dropping their interest. City could yet revive this. Yet as they continue to watch Ntcham’s rise they may not need to. The French schemer would cost City nothing more and save them spending around €100m for Pogba.