DiGregorio and Fera blended the old and the new for their serenade. Per tradition, DiGregorio's song choice, K.C. and Jojo's "All My Life," was a secret until Fera sat in a chair, surrounded by their guests for the big serenade. His encore, "No Higher Love" by Young Gunz, was a surprise detour from the conventional; guests posted live video of the performance and tagged the rapper on Instagram. But Fera switched up the traditional when she took the microphone after DiGregorio and sang "Respect" by Aretha Franklin, then "I Say a Little Prayer for You."