Just one day after Phish opened their Wednesday night show at Madison Square Garden with a debut of Fleet Foxes’ “White Winter Hymnal,” Robin Pecknold returned the favor with an intro of the band’s “Bouncing Around the Room” before playing the very same song Phish covered the previous night.

Pecknold was alerted to the cover through a commenter on his Instagram, with the Fleet Foxes frontman commenting its “so wild” that Phish would cover one of his songs. And last night at Thompson’s Point in Portland, ME, Pecknold did the same with one of Phish’s better known tunes.

Watch below.