Gary Musgrave

On the November 2015 night that Jill says she was drugged, she was one of nearly 60 people packed into a makeshift living room theater for a night of open-mike comedy. The monthly event, All Effin' Night, was billed as "comics only"—a chance for stand-ups to try out new material on each other. As usual, the Roscoe Village apartment was lined with rows of couches, stools, and folding chairs. The fridge was full of beer for the taking. Open bottles of liquor circulated freely. The stage was hung with bedsheets, and the four hosts were dressed in pajamas; they were prepared for a long night. Jill, 26, was relatively new to Chicago's comedy scene, although it wasn't her first time at All Effin' Night. A petite sci-fi and video-game nerd with short-cropped brown hair, Jill (who asked to be identified by her middle name) had moved to Chicago from Indianapolis after graduating college in 2013. She started work at a local financial consulting firm, and in February 2015 became interested in comedy. She decided to try her hand at stand-up after realizing how few women there were—by her count only about one in five, "a terrible ratio," she says. By July of that year she was performing at open mikes three nights a week. As Jill scanned the room, she recognized several other comics she knew, including 26-year-old cohost Sam Gordon and 30-year-old Kahlil Wilson, a tall, brawny dude with a bushy mustache and big grin. But there were people there that night she didn't recognize—the scene is abundant with newcomers and drop-ins. Jill grabbed a cold PBR from a 30-rack and took a small sip. She'd already had one drink at another open mike earlier that evening, and she didn't want to get too drunk—she wanted to be relatively sober while trying out her new jokes. She nursed her beer for the next few hours, setting it down occasionally as she watched other people perform. Yet when Jill went up for her set around 1 AM, she stumbled over her jokes—and the stage itself—causing the hosts and partygoers to write her off as drunk. "I remember doing my set, and after that I can't remember anything," she says. "I remember my set was not great." When she was done she stumbled from the stage to a couch. A friend deemed her too drunk to stay at the party and put her in an Uber home to Logan Square. A tipsy comic at a casual open mike isn't unusual. But when Jill woke up the next morning she was practically paralyzed in her bed, unable to move and barely able to speak. Even rolling out of bed to go to the bathroom was too much for her body to handle. She soiled herself, and remained frozen in place for nearly 18 hours. Jill knew this wasn't a typical hangover—"I only had two beers, I don't understand why I woke up feeling like I was dead," she says. She came to the conclusion that she'd been drugged. She didn't appear to have been assaulted, however. Nor did she seem to be otherwise injured. So instead of going to the hospital or calling the police, she decided to sleep it off, hoping that would be her best option for a quick recovery. By Monday morning Jill was feeling back to normal. But the effects of that strange Saturday night would linger, sending shockwaves through the comedy scene she'd come to love. This incident—and others like it—would ultimately push local female comics together to confront the sexism, harassment, and assault they say has plagued their community for years. Their efforts are ongoing—even though the mystery of who might be drugging comics and why remains unsolved.

“We can’t blame some creep at the bar because the creep appears to be among our own community.” —Comic Sam Gordon in a December 2015 Facebook post­

A few days later, Jill told Wilson about what had happened at the open mike. Wilson, it turned out, had had a similar experience. He arrived at the house party around midnight, and grabbed a beer from the same case in the kitchen. He had drunk two beers at another open mike right before, and as the night went on he had two more. He also took sips here and there from other comics' drinks—including Jill's beer. And like Jill, Wilson went up on stage, did a less than stellar set, and blacked out. When Wilson came to he was still sitting in the audience. The show was winding down, and the party's hosts asked him to leave. But when he tried to stand up, he couldn't move. "It was really weird," he says. But he reacted to the suspicion that he'd been drugged differently than Jill had. "It was a little bit less scary for me. I'm a big dude. I wasn't scared—I almost thought it was funny." Eventually the hosts helped Wilson to the bathroom, where he made himself throw up. He instantly felt better—a sign to him that something bad had been in his system—and got a ride home to Pilsen from a fellow comic. The next morning he felt fine. He never considered reporting the incident to the police or getting checked out by a doctor. When Jill heard Wilson's story, she says she thought, "It's not a stranger in a bar following drunk comedians, it's someone in the scene." Jill also told Gordon, one of the show's cohosts, what had happened. Gordon, a veteran of the scene, agreed that something had likely happened to Jill. "I know what she's like when she's drunk, and she usually can handle herself, so this was very out of character," Gordon says. The possibility that Wilson had been drugged too "made us think that something was tainted in the common space." Gordon went to Facebook and wrote a post about what had happened to Wilson and Jill. "I sincerely hope that it was only these two people," she wrote, "but if you were there and think you may have also been drugged, please, please talk to one of us." She asked anyone who had noticed anything suspicious that night to reach out to her. And she issued a stern rebuke: "Having this at All Effin' Night is particularly disturbing since it is a house show that generally only has Chicago comedians and people we personally know there. We can't blame some creep at the bar because the creep appears to be among our own community."

Gary Musgrave

Other people chimed in: this wasn't the first time comics had suspected they'd been drugged. Two months earlier a female comic had allegedly been drugged at a stand-up night at Cole's Bar in Logan Square, wrote the event's organizer. The woman was a 24-year-old comic named Kendall—also a petite brunette, who asked to be identified by her first name. The bar was crowded that night, and she left her drink unattended when she went out for a smoke. She'd been drugged a year earlier, at a Fourth of July party, she told the Reader. So when she blacked out after two beers at Cole's, then woke up the next day with a raging hangover, she says she knew what had happened. "Honestly, when I woke up and put the pieces together, I was mostly just mad that I probably had a really bad set," she says. "I was just angry because people who didn't know me probably just thought I was just a drunk idiot, and that made me very sad. I was bothered that I seemed so unprofessional. "I'm lucky that that's what I get to be upset about, because the situation doesn't pan out like that for so many people," she adds. Like Jill, Kendall made it home to Logan Square safely and showed no signs of having been assaulted. Gordon and the other open-mike hosts began speculating about who might be responsible for these two incidents, cross-referencing their guest lists in an attempt to narrow down the suspects. The All Effin' Night show had been videotaped by a stationary camera set up at the back of the living room, so there was a record of every performance—and every guest who walked in that night. The hosts pored over the footage, digging into each attendee's whereabouts, even creating a time line of the night's events. The only person who stood out, according to Gordon, was a guy in a blue hoodie who sat in the kitchen and instructed partygoers on which beers to grab because "they were the coldest." ("That's not how a 30-rack of beer works," Gordon says.) The man in the hoodie was one of few people multiple partygoers couldn't identify, and according to those present, he never went up to perform a set. But because of the way the camera was positioned, the "party space"—the kitchen, porch, and back side of the living room—was off camera, and multiple viewings of the video revealed no such mysterious man, as far as Gordon could tell. Ultimately the hosts came up empty-handed. The only other constant between the two events was a large group of drunk comics. But a few weeks later, rumors of another incident began to circulate. A male comic had shown signs of being drugged at iO's annual holiday party in Lincoln Park, people said, after sharing drinks with a group of female improvisers. But attendees also say that everyone at the party was so intoxicated that it was unclear whether anyone had really been drugged or not. (And after months of searching, the Reader was unable to identify this man, or any of the women he was reportedly drinking with.) Still, rumors about the iO party, plus the conversation about what had happened to Kendall, Jill, and Wilson, began to crystallize into a shared sense of fear, anger, and frustration—especially among the scene's female comics.

Gary Musgrave