Visit Stathead.com/football/ and sign up for a free trial for our new tools. The Play Index will be going away in a week or two. Please read our blog post: Play Index Tools Are Moving to Stathead.com

Peyton Manning vs. Eli Manning Player Comparison

Current search: Comparing Peyton Manning stats for 1998-2015 and Eli Manning stats for 2004-2018

Show/Hide Search Form __p("text that informs the user how to change the form", "Use the back button to change the form") Click for URL to Share With Others

Click on the red text to pre-fill the form with various values Cumulative Seasons (e.g., Compare(e.g., compare Peyton Manning through his 7th season to Tom Brady through his 7th season Single Seasons (e.g., Compare(e.g., compare Peyton Manning's 5th season with Tom Brady's 5th season Player 1 Javascript is required for the selection of a player. Type name to select an option Peyton Manning Season (of player's career) 1998 (age 22, 1st season) 1999 (age 23, 2nd season) 2000 (age 24, 3rd season) 2001 (age 25, 4th season) 2002 (age 26, 5th season) 2003 (age 27, 6th season) 2004 (age 28, 7th season) 2005 (age 29, 8th season) 2006 (age 30, 9th season) 2007 (age 31, 10th season) 2008 (age 32, 11th season) 2009 (age 33, 12th season) 2010 (age 34, 13th season) 2012 (age 36, 14th season) 2013 (age 37, 15th season) 2014 (age 38, 16th season) 2015 (age 39, 17th season) to 1998 (age 22, 1st season) 1999 (age 23, 2nd season) 2000 (age 24, 3rd season) 2001 (age 25, 4th season) 2002 (age 26, 5th season) 2003 (age 27, 6th season) 2004 (age 28, 7th season) 2005 (age 29, 8th season) 2006 (age 30, 9th season) 2007 (age 31, 10th season) 2008 (age 32, 11th season) 2009 (age 33, 12th season) 2010 (age 34, 13th season) 2012 (age 36, 14th season) 2013 (age 37, 15th season) 2014 (age 38, 16th season) 2015 (age 39, 17th season) Choice is: Player 2 Javascript is required for the selection of a player. Type name to select an option Eli Manning Season (of player's career) 2004 (age 23, 1st season) 2005 (age 24, 2nd season) 2006 (age 25, 3rd season) 2007 (age 26, 4th season) 2008 (age 27, 5th season) 2009 (age 28, 6th season) 2010 (age 29, 7th season) 2011 (age 30, 8th season) 2012 (age 31, 9th season) 2013 (age 32, 10th season) 2014 (age 33, 11th season) 2015 (age 34, 12th season) 2016 (age 35, 13th season) 2017 (age 36, 14th season) 2018 (age 37, 15th season) 2019 (age 38, 16th season) to 2004 (age 23, 1st season) 2005 (age 24, 2nd season) 2006 (age 25, 3rd season) 2007 (age 26, 4th season) 2008 (age 27, 5th season) 2009 (age 28, 6th season) 2010 (age 29, 7th season) 2011 (age 30, 8th season) 2012 (age 31, 9th season) 2013 (age 32, 10th season) 2014 (age 33, 11th season) 2015 (age 34, 12th season) 2016 (age 35, 13th season) 2017 (age 36, 14th season) 2018 (age 37, 15th season) 2019 (age 38, 16th season) Choice is: Player 3 Javascript is required for the selection of a player. Type name to select an option Choice is: Player 4 Javascript is required for the selection of a player. Type name to select an option Choice is: Player 5 Javascript is required for the selection of a player. Type name to select an option Choice is: Player 6 Javascript is required for the selection of a player. Type name to select an option Choice is:

If you utilize material unique to a Sports Reference site for a tweet, an article, or for research for a broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the source for the material. It would be greatly appreciated and would help us continue to produce this material.