When Zlatan Ibrahimovic was controversially red carded in the first half of Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea’s Champions League second leg game Wednesday, it seemed like the Swedish striker had doomed the French club. PSG was able to keep Chelsea from scoring for the majority of an ugly game that more closely resembled a wrestling match, but Gary Cahill gave Chelsea goal, and a 2-1 lead on aggregate, with just nine minutes to play.

PSG needed a miracle, and former Chelsea centerback David Luiz delivered. Luiz climbed above two defenders and hit a bullet header into the top corner at the near post. Chelsea goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois didn’t even have time to move his feet.

With the tie leveled 2-2 on aggregate, with each team having scored an away goal, the game went to extra time. PSG’s Thiago Silva conceded a penalty in the 96th minute after jumping to win a header in his own penalty area and touching the ball with an outstretched arm, but Eden Hazard’s ensuing goal from the penalty spot didn’t change PSG’s objective. With one more away goal, Chelsea would be out.

In the second period of extra time, Silva made up for his earlier error and stunned the crowd at Stamford Bridge. Chelsea allowed Silva a free header off a corner in the 114th minute, and Silva looped the ball over Courtois to tie the game at 2-2 (3-3 on aggregate).

The clock ran out on Chelsea, sending PSG through on away goals. Chelsea’s collapse means that unless Arsenal and Manchester City overcome first-leg deficits, there may be no English clubs in the quarterfinals of the Champions League.