Homemade Tagliatelle with a Fresh Tomato Olive Sauce

May 19, 2020 · Last Updated on July 25, 2020 By Anjali Shah on· Last Updated on

Share This:

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure

There’s nothing quite like fresh pasta, and this homemade tagliatelle recipe walks you through step by step on how to make pasta at home without a machine. Finished with a fresh tomato olive sauce, its an authentic Italian dish!

Before my daughter was born, my husband and I had an amazing babymoon in Italy. One of the highlights of our trip was a day-long cooking class we took through Convivio Rome – run by a husband and wife team, Sally and Guido, in a tiny medieval town named Toffia.

We literally spent the entire day with them – from 10am-5:30pm and enjoyed every minute of it! And as a result, I came away with three delicious, authentic, healthy Italian recipes to share with all of you 🙂

Before I start with the recipe, I have to tell you a little bit about our cooking class experience. We took about a 45 minute train ride from Rome to a small town near Toffia, where Sally was there to greet us with a warm smile and enthusiastic welcome. On the drive to her and Guido’s house, we learned a bit about the history of these medieval towns and what our day would be like. Toffia is a quaint, rustic, cozy little town that makes you feel like you are far away from the bustling city of Rome. It has gorgeous views with groves of fresh olive trees everywhere – and we couldn’t resist taking a few pictures.

We arrived in Toffia and took a little walking tour through the town, picked fresh herbs from a nearby garden to use in our cooking (I nearly died when I smelled the fresh lemon verbena), and headed to meet Guido – our chef instructor for the day.

Tools and Equipment You’ll Need

Our class started with making the homemade tagliatelle from scratch – using nothing but our hands and an enormous wooden cutting board.

How to make Homemade Tagliatelle – Step by Step

Step 1: On a clean, wooden cutting board, create a well in the middle of the flour and break the eggs into the center. Carefully mix the eggs with a fork as if you were making an omelette, bringing a little bit of flour each time you mix into the eggs. The key here is not to break the outside of the “well” before the eggs are completely mixed into the flour, otherwise you’ll have eggs running all over your cutting board (not fun!).

Step 2: Once the eggs and flour begin to mix (so there are no runny eggs left), start working the dough with your hands until the mixture is smooth but firm. Kneading the dough takes a bit of time! At first the dough isn’t completely mixed together and is a bit rougher to the touch.

We all took turns kneading the dough because it was tiring 🙂 My turn next!

Finally when the dough is ready, it becomes super soft and a little shiny too.

Step 3: Let dough rest for 20-30 minutes. After 30 minutes, roll out the dough with a rolling pin until extremely thin (you should be able to see the dark part of the cutting board faintly through the dough) and as circular as possible. Keep dusting with flour as you roll it out. This rolling out process also takes quite a bit of time. First, we rolled out the edges of the ball of dough – making it look a little like a flying saucer (see the first picture in the sequence below). . Guido taught us a trick of rolling the dough around the rolling pin and spreading it out with our hands — helped to make the dough stay rolled out instead of springing back.

The dough kept growing and growing in size, getting thinner and thinner, as we rolled it out. Eventually it was almost paper thin! We really could see the cutting board through the dough.

Step 4: When it’s thin enough, sprinkle cornmeal on the cutting board and the dough (to help prevent it from sticking). Fold up the dough into a flat “burrito” before you begin slicing it with a sharp knife.

Step 5: Now the dough is ready to cut! Slice the dough with a sharp knife into 1/4 inch thick (or slightly less thick) slices.

Step 6: As you cut the fettuccine, be sure to ruffle it up with your hands a bit and add cornmeal as needed to keep it light and to prevent sticking (as it sits).

Step 7: Cook in salty, boiling water for just 3-4 minutes until al dente.

Before we actually cooked the pasta, we started on the sauce.

How to make Fresh Tomato Olive Sauce – Step by Step

Step 1: Finely mince all the vegetables and the garlic. This is called “sofrito” in Italy.

Step 2: Fry the veggies in 1 Tbsp olive oil over medium heat. Add a little white wine to reduce, then add the tomato sauce (passata), whole olives, marjoram/oregano and salt.

Step 3: Simmer the sauce for 40 minutes. When the sauce is about 5 minutes from being done, cook your pasta. Drain your pasta (don’t rinse it!) and mix the sauce with the pasta.

Step 4: Top with freshly grated parmesan cheese.

Needless to say, we had worked up quite an appetite when we got around to eating!

What makes Homemade tagliatelle healthy?

Natural and Fresh Ingredients : When food is cooked from scratch using natural and fresh ingredients that are unprocessed, your end result is a healthier option than a store or restaurant bought meal.

: When food is cooked from scratch using natural and fresh ingredients that are unprocessed, your end result is a healthier option than a store or restaurant bought meal. Low in Calorie : Using fresh unprocessed ingredients equates to lower calories that restaurant style pasta dishes. This homemade tagliatelle dish comes in at around 200 calories a serving.

: Using fresh unprocessed ingredients equates to lower calories that restaurant style pasta dishes. This homemade tagliatelle dish comes in at around 200 calories a serving. No Sugar Added : Many store bought pastas and sauces have added sugar, but this dish uses just a pinch of salt and Italian spices.

: Many store bought pastas and sauces have added sugar, but this dish uses just a pinch of salt and Italian spices. Prepared “al dente”: Al dente pasta is lower glycemic – which means that it doesn’t give you that blood sugar spike and crash that typical carbs do.

Will kids enjoy Homemade Tagliatelle?

My kids love pasta, and I’m sure yours do too! They will be blown away by the freshness and flavor of this homemade pasta. If your kids aren’t big fans of olives, you can simply leave them out of their serving. Extra olives for you!

What is tagliatelle pasta?

Tagliatelle is from the Emilia Romagna region of Italy. It is long and flat in shape and looks similar to fettuccine. It’s made by mixing flour with egg to create a dough. It’s often stored in little mounds or nests. You can serve it with a variety of sauces from rich and creamy, to a bolognese, or this fresh tomato and olive sauce!

How thick should tagliatelle be?

Tagliatelle should be rolled out to a thickness of about 1/8 of an inch or 3mm. See pictures above. It should be rather thin and you should be able to see through it.

What do you serve with homemade tagliatelle?

When we took our cooking class we prepared a few other authentic Italian dishes that we enjoyed with this pasta.

Top Tips for Making Homemade Tagliatelle

You can use this pasta recipe as a base for just about any additional ingredients – veggies, cheeses, etc. But sometimes it’s just fun to eat the simple original version.

Cook the pasta al dente – it’s better for you and no one likes mushy pasta!

Be sure to let the dough rest before rolling it out.

If you have kids, get them involved in making the pasta! It can be a really fun activity for the whole family to do together!

Check out these other delicious pasta recipes!

If you have tried this Homemade Tagliatelle with a Fresh Tomato Olive Sauce, or any other recipe on my blog, then please rate it and let me know how it turned out in the comments below! You can also FOLLOW ME on FACEBOOK, TWITTER, INSTAGRAM and PINTEREST to see more delicious, healthy, family friendly food!