Overall

Vision Vision

Originality Originality

Technique Technique

Impact Impact

My first thought upon seeing the thumbnail of this in the contest entries was, "Is that... a?" In a sea of entries having to do with red, blue, black, white, fire, light, angels, devils, and other typical Good vs. Evil symbols, yours stood out. Plainly. I couldn't help but click. Not to knock the other entries -- they're technically stunning, and very well-done -- but the concepts and subject matter among many of them weren't exactly new or unique. I really enjoyed reading about the inspiration for this piece, and I really think you've achieved what you were going for: a humorous interpretation of the theme.I do have a little bit of a problem with the evil roll of toilet paper. It didn't quite strike me as being a roll of toilet paper in thumbnail view, and it still didn't when I took a closer look at it. It actually looks a little more like a cylinder of wood. I think this is because unlike the good roll of toilet paper it doesn't have the distinctive imprint toilet paper often has, or even the little cut lines that toilet paper has. And while I must agree that toilet paper without the cut line is the most evil toilet paper of all (not only is this type of toilet paper relatively uncomfortable to wipe with, but it never EVER cuts, even if you yank it against the dispenser) it's kind of hard to recognize as toilet paper -- especially since it's really not the right size of roll for that kind of toilet paper.I agree with the other critic's advice on lighting. I'd say look at the edge around the good toilet paper's wings especially -- it feels a little harsh to me.I love how the evil tp's wings seem to be burning slowly with tiny embers on the edges. It's a very nice, subtle detail to see. I also really enjoy the way the good toilet paper shoots out of heaven. The infinite stretch of the holder and the way it seems to move at a quick pace really boosts the comedic factor of the work. I mean, a roll of tp with wings is ridiculous enough, but having it fly out of the sky so quickly like that just makes it hilarious.This is truly awesome, and again, I can't emphasize enough how happy I am to see this original, very funny interpretation of the theme. Good luck!