CLEVELAND, Ohio — A Cleveland woman who coaches youth baseball was accused this week of killing the father of their two children six years ago by poisoning his tea with antifreeze.

Holly McFeeture, 34, was indicted Tuesday, charged with the 2006 murder of Matthew Podolak. They were engaged at the time and lived on Archmere Avenue in the Old Brooklyn neighborhood of Cleveland.

McFeeture, who is single, still lives on Archmere with the two children, but in another house. She was arrested Wednesday morning by U.S. marshals and taken to the Cuyahoga County Jail. She is to be arraigned Friday morning on one count of aggravated murder and one count of contaminating substance for human consumption.

Matthew Podolak's older brother, Mark Podolak, said his family long suspected McFeeture had something to do with Matthew's death.

"She just wasn't acting like somebody who was losing or about to lose a loved one," he said.

Matthew Podolak, 31, died July 31, 2006, after becoming seriously ill and being admitted to Parma General Hospital. Elizabeth Balraj, the county coroner at the time, ruled the cause of death to be chronic intoxication by ethylene glycol, which is the active ingredient in antifreeze. She left the manner of death undetermined.

That changed in March of 2010 when then-Coroner Frank Miller ruled the death a homicide based on information Cleveland police had received in the form of a tip, Assistant County Prosecutor Brian McDonough said. The information ruled out suicide or accidental death, leaving only homicide as a possibility, he said.

McDonough said police believe McFeeture began poisoning Podolak days, if not weeks, before he died.

"We believe the anti-freeze was administered in sweet raspberry ice tea that he would drink daily," McDonough said.

Ehthylene glycol is sweet and odorless when consumed, McDonough said. When it metabolized in Podolak's body, the byproducts formed small crystals in his kidneys.

Five days before his death, Podolak went to the doctor's office complaining of pain, McDonough said, and was given medication for kidney stones. The prosecutor said Podolak later consumed enough anti-freeze to cause organ failure and death.

When asked why he believed McFeeture wanted to kill Podolak, McDonough said, "We believe that she wanted to end the relationship."

Podolak said his brother and McFeeture had an "up-and-down" relationship.

"He was the nicest dude and he cared so much for his kids," Mark Podolak said.

Matthew Podolak loved to hunt and fish and played varsity hockey at Brooklyn High School, his brother said. He spent time in the U.S. Navy, for a while serving on a ship in the Persian Gulf, and later worked at Phoenix Industrial Finishing as a manager.

McDonough said police do not suspect anybody else was involved in Podolak's death, but they believe there are people who have yet to come forward that have information that could be helpful to the case.

McFeeture coaches baseball in the Old Brooklyn Youth League. Her 2012 team was in the coach-pitch league. The president of the league, Angelo Gaudino did not return a call seeking comment.

McFeeture's facebook page lists her most recent job as a butcher at Dionne's Meats, which is in West Side Market.