A growing body of evidence indicates that local police departments are being used to provide revenue for municipalities by imposing and collecting fees, fines, and asset forfeitures. We examine whether revenue collection activities compromise the criminal investigation functions of local police departments. We find that police departments in cities that collect a greater share of their revenue from fees solve violent and property crimes at significantly lower rates. The effect on violent crime clearance is more salient in smaller cities where police officers’ assignments tend not to be highly specialized. We find that this relationship is robust to a variety of empirical strategies, including instrumenting for fines revenue using commuting time. Our results suggest that institutional changes—such as decreasing municipal government reliance on fines and fees for revenue—are important for changing police behavior and improving the provision of public safety.

References

Alm, James, Buschman, Robert, Sjoquist, David. 2011 . “ Rethinking Local Government Reliance on the Property Tax .” Regional Science and Urban Economics 41 (4): 320–31.

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials . 2013 . “ Commuting in America 2013: The National Report on Commuting Patterns and Trends .” http://traveltrends.transportation.org/Pages/default.aspx.

Google Scholar

Angrist, Joshua, Pischke, Jörn-Steffen. 2009 . Mostly Harmless Econometrics. Princeton : Princeton Univ. Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Baicker, Katherine, Jacobson, Mireille. 2007 . “ Finders Keepers: Forfeiture Laws, Policing Incentives, and Local Budget .” Journal of Public Economics 91:2113–36.

Google Scholar Crossref

Bawn, Kathleen . 1995 . “ Political Control Versus Expertise: Congressional Choices About Administrative Procedures .” American Political Science Review 89 (1): 62 – 73 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Benson, Bruce, Rasmussen, David, Sollars, David. 1995 . “ Police Bureaucracies, Their Incentives, and the War on Drugs .” Public Choice 83 (1): 21 – 45 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Brooks, Laure Weber . 2015 . “ Police Discretionary Behavior .” In Critical Issues in Policing: Contemporary Reading, Seventh Edition, edited by Dunham, Roger, Alpert, Geoffrey. Long Grove, IL : Waveland Press . pp. 122 - 142 .

Google Scholar

Brown, Michael . 1981 . Working the Street: Police Discretion and the Dilemmas of Reform. New York : Russell Sage Foundation .

Google Scholar

Carey, Benedict, Goode, Erica. 2016 . “ Police Try to Lower Racial Bias, but Under Pressure, It Isn’t So Easy .” The New York Times, July 11 . https://nyti.ms/29JNznU

Google Scholar

Chalfin, Aaron, McCrary, Justin. n.d. “ The Effect of Police on Crime: New Evidence from US Cities, 1960-2010 .” NBER Working Paper18815. http://www.nber.org/papers/w18815.pdf.

Google Scholar

Chaney, Carole Kennedy, Saltzstein, Grace Hall. 1998 . “ Democratic Control and Bureaucratic Responsiveness: The Police and Domestic Violence .” American Journal of Political Science 42 (3): 745–68.

Google Scholar Crossref

Desmond, Matthew, Papachristos, Andrew, Kirk, David. 2016 . “ Police Violence and Citizen Crime Reporting in the Black Community .” American Sociological Review 81 (5): 857–76.

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Diller, Rebekah, Bannon, Alicia, Nagrecha, Mitali. 2010 . “ Criminal Justice Debt: A Barrier to Reentry .” New York Univ. School of Law . https://www.brennancenter.org/publication/criminal-justice-debt-barrier-reentry.

Google Scholar

Epp, Charles R., Maynard-Moody, Steven, Haider-Markel, Donald P. 2014 . Pulled Over: How Police Stops Define Race and Citizenship. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Falcone, David N., Wells, L. Edward, Weisheit, Ralph A. 2002 . “ The Small-Town Police Department .” Policing: An International Journal of Police Strategies & Management 25 (2): 371–84.

Google Scholar Crossref

Ferreira, Fernando, Gyourko, Joseph. 2009 . “ Do Political Parties Matter? Evidence from U.S. Cities .” Quarterly Journal of Economics 124 (1): 399 – 422 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Frug, Gerald E., Barron, David J. 2008 . City Bound: How States Stifle Urban Innovation. Ithaca, NY : Cornell Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Fung, Archon . 2003 . “ Survey Article: Recipes for Public Spheres: Eight Institutional Design Choices and Their Consequences .” Journal of Political Philosophy 11 (3): 338–67.

Google Scholar Crossref

Gammon, Robert . 2015 . “ Why Oakland Police Can’t Solve Crime .” East Bay Express, May 20 . http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/why-oakland-police-cantsolve-crime/Content?oid=4288948.

Google Scholar

Garrett, Thomas, Wagner, Gary. 2009 . “ Red Ink in the Rearview Mirror: Local Fiscal Conditions and the Issuance of Traffic Tickets .” Journal of Law and Economics 52 (1): 71 – 90 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Gerber, Elizabeth, Hopkins, Daniel. 2011 . “ When Mayors Matter: Estimating the Impact of Mayoral Partisanship on City Policy .” American Journal of Political Science 55 (2): 326–39.

Google Scholar Crossref

Gibson, Chris L., Fagan, Abigail A., Antle, Kelsey. 2014 . “ Avoiding Violent Victimization among Youths in Urban Neighborhoods: The Importance of Street Efficacy .” American Journal of Public Health 104 (2): e154–61.

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Goffman, Alice . 2009 . “ On the Run: Wanted Men in a Philadelphia Ghetto .” American Sociological Review 74 (3): 339–57.

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Gottschalk, Marie . 2008 . “ Hiding in Plain Sight: American Politics and the Carceral State .” Annual Review of Political Science 11 (2): 235–60.

Google Scholar

Hackworth, Jason . 2007 . The Neoliberal City: Governance, Ideology and Development in American Urbanism. Ithaca, NY : Cornell Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Harris, Alexes . 2016 . A Pound of Flesh: Monetary Sanctions as Punishment for the Poor. New York : Russell Sage Foundation .

Google Scholar

Harris, Alexes, Evans, Heather, Beckett, Katherine. 2010 . “ Drawing Blood from Stones: Legal Debt and Social Inequality in the Contemporary United States .” American Journal of Sociology 115 (6): 1753–99.

Google Scholar Crossref

Holcomb, Jefferson, Kovandzic, Tomislav, Williams, Marian. 2011 . “ Civil Asset Forfeiture, Equitable Sharing, and Policing for Profit in the United States .” Journal of Criminal Justice 39:273–85.

Google Scholar Crossref

Huggins, Martin Knisely . 1998 . Political Policing: The United States and Latin America. Durham : Duke Univ. Press .

Google Scholar

Hunter, George . 2009 . “ More Tickets in Hard Times .” caranddriver.com. http://www.caranddriver.com/features/more-tickets-in-hard-times.

Google Scholar

Kane, Robert . 2005 . “ Compromised Police Legitimacy as a Predictor of Violent Crime in Structurally Disadvantaged Communities .” Criminology 43 (2): 469–98.

Google Scholar Crossref

Kantor, Shawn, Kitchens, Carl, Pawlowski, Steven. 2017 . “ Civil Asset Forfeiture, Crime, and Police Incentives: Evidence from the Comprehensive Crime Control Act of 1984 .” NBER Working Paper 23873. http://www.nber.org/papers/w23873.

Google Scholar

Katzenstein, Mary Fainsod, Waller, Maureen R. 2015 . “ Taxing the Poor: Incarceration, Poverty Governance, and the Seizure of Family Resources .” Perspectives on Politics 13 (3): 638–56.

Google Scholar Crossref

Kirk, David, Papachristos, Andrew, Fagan, Jeffrey, Tyler, Tom. 2012 . “ The Paradox of Law Enforcement in Immigrant Communities: Does Tough Immigration Enforcement Undermine Public Safety?” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences 641 (1): 79 – 98 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Kohler-Hausmann, Issa . 2014 . “ Managing Justice and Mass Misdemeanors .” Stanford Law Review 66 (2): 611–93.

Google Scholar

Langton, Lynn, Durose, Matthew. 2016 . “ Police Behavior during Traffic and Street Stops, 2011 .” Bureau of Justice Statistics . Washington D.C . https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/pbtss11.pdf

Google Scholar

Lemos, Margaret, Minzner, Max. 2014 . “ For-Profit Public Enforcement .” Harvard Law Review 127 (3): 853 – 913 .

Google Scholar

Leovy, Jill . 2015 . Ghettoside: A True Story of Murder in America. New York : Penguin Random House .

Google Scholar

Lerman, Amy E., Weaver, Vesla M. 2014 . Arresting Citizenship: The Democratic Consequences of American Crime Control. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Lipsky, Michael . 1980 . “ Street-Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services .” New York : Russel Sage Foundation .

Google Scholar

Luna, Erik . 2003 . “ Race, Crime, and Institutional Design .” Law and Contemporary Problems 66 (3): 183 – 220 .

Google Scholar

Maguire, Edward R., Uchida, Craig D. 2000 . “ Measurement and Explanation in the Comparative Study of American Police Organizations .” Criminal Justice 4: 491 – 557 .

Google Scholar

Makowsky, Michael, Stratmann, Thomas. 2009 . “ Political Economy at Any Speed: What Determines Traffic Citations? .” American Economic Review 99 (1): 509–27.

Google Scholar Crossref

McCubbins, Mathew . 1985 . “ The Legislative Design of Regulatory Procedure .” American Journal of Political Science 29 (4): 721–48.

Google Scholar Crossref

McKenzie, Brian, Rapino, Melanie. 2011 . “ Commuting in the United States: 2009 .” United States Census Bureau Report: ACS-15. https://www.census.gov/prod/2011pubs/acs-15.pdf

Google Scholar

Moe, Terry . 1990 . “ Political Institutions: The Neglected Side of the Story .” Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization 6 (2): 213–53.

Google Scholar

Mummolo, Jonathan . 2018 . “ Modern Police Tactics, Police-Citizen Interactions and the Prospects for Reform .” Journal of Politics 80 (1): 1 – 15 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Natapoff, Alexandra . 2015 . “ Misdemeanor Decriminalization .” Vanderbilt Law Review 68 (4): 1055 – 1116 .

Google Scholar

Niskanen, William A. 1971 . Bureaucracy & Representative Government. New York : Routledge .

Google Scholar

Ostrom, Elinor, Whitaker, Gordon. 1973 . “ Does Local Community Control of Police Make a Difference? Some Preliminary Findings .” American Journal of Political Science 17 (1): 48 – 76 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Peterson, Paul . 1981 . City Limits. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Roberts, Aki, Roberts, John. 2015 . “ Crime Clearance and Temporal Variation in Police Investigative Workload: Evidence from National Incidence-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) Data .” Journal of Quantitative Criminology 31: 1 – 24 .

Google Scholar

Sances, Michael W., You, Hye Young. 2017 . “ Who Pays for Government? Descriptive Representation and Exploitative Revenue Sources .” Journal of Politics 79 (3): 1090–94.

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Sharkey, Patrick . 2018 . “ The Long Reach of Violence: A Broader Perspective on Data, Theory, and Evidence on the Prevalence and Consequences of Exposure to Violence .” Annual Review of Criminology 1: 85 – 102 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Sharkey, Patrick, Torrats-Espinosa, Gerald. 2017 . “ The Effect of Violent Crime on Economic Mobility .” Journal of Urban Economics 102 (1): 22 – 33 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Skogan, Wesley G. 2006 . “ Asymmetry in the Impact of Encounters with Police .” Policing & Society 16 (2): 99 – 126 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Soss, Joe, Fording, Richard, Schram, Sanford. 2011 . Disciplining the Poor: Neoliberal Paternalism and the Persistent Power of Race. Chicago : Univ. of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Stock, James, Wright, Jonathan, Yogo, Motohiro. 2002 . “ Survey of Weak Instruments and Weak Identification in Generalized Method of Moments .” Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 20 (4): 518–29.

Google Scholar Crossref

Tiebout, Charles . 1956 . “ A Pure Theory of Local Public Expenditures .” Journal of Political Economy 64 (5): 416–24.

Google Scholar Crossref

U.S. Department of Justice—Federal Bureau of Investigation . 2015 . “ Effects of NIBRS on Crime Statistics ” https://ucr.fbi.gov/nibrs/2014/resource-pages/effects_of_nibrs_on_crime_statistics_final.pdf.

Google Scholar

United States Department of Justice Civil Rights Division . 2015 . “ Investigation of the Ferguson Police Department .” United States Department of Justice Civil Rights Division, March 4 . Washington, D.C . https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/opa/press-releases/attachments/2015/03/04/ferguson_police_department_report.pdf

Google Scholar

Warren, Patricia Y. 2011 . “ Perceptions of Police Disrespect during Vehicle Stops: A Race-Based Analysis .” Crime & Delinquency 57 (3): 356–76.

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Weaver, Vesla M., Lerman, Amy E. 2010 . “ Political Consequences of the Carceral State .” American Political Science Review 104 (4): 817–33.

Google Scholar Crossref

Western, Bruce, Kling, Jeffrey R., Weiman, David F. 2001 . “ The Labor Market Consequences of Incarceration .” Crime & Delinquency 47 (3): 410–27.

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Williams, Gregory . 1984 . The Law and Politics of Police Discretion. Westport, CT : Greenwood Publishing Group .

Google Scholar

Willis, James J., Mastrofski, Stephen D., Weisburd, David. 2007 . “ Making Sense of COMPSTAT: A Theory-Based Analysis of Organizational Change in Three Police Departments .” Law & Society Review 41 (1): 147–88.

Google Scholar Crossref

Wilson, James Q. 1968 . Varieties of Police Behavior. Cambridge : Harvard Univ. Press .

Google Scholar