“Eh…” [crunch, crunch] “What’s up, Doctor Watson?”

British smart-throb Benedict Cumberbatch is known for having strange fans, who express their love in unconventional ways—like obsessively comparing him to otters or desperately trying to get a whiff of his “Cumbermusk.”

Now, the actor can cross off yet another previously uncharted area of fan worship. Thanks to Reddit’s Photoshop Battles community, the seasonal chocolate Cumberbunny introduced by a British chocolatier last month just got much, much weirder.

It's leap day and they are leaping out the door!!! Come and get your Cumberbunny before its too late… pic.twitter.com/SSDZjUj74j — chocolatician (@UKChocolatician) February 29, 2016

If you’re not familiar with Photoshop Battles, here’s how they work: A random photo is presented. Anybody in the community can participate. All you need to do is edit the image as you please and submit your work in the comments section.

While Chocolatician offered the Cumberbunny with a limited range of standard options—white, milk, or dark chocolate base with a trademark gold tie—the edible creatures that redditors whipped up took the concept into more experimental territory. Soon after the battle began, everyone started hopping on the bandwagon.

Photoshop pro 2Thebreezes thought it was about time for the ill-fated Cumberbunny to meet his maker:

Redditor lechodu67 snagged the disembodied head from Wonka, and planted it on a new body that’s a little more… Jessica Rabbit:

User Lintuuli delved deep into the Cumberbunny’s backstory and, after returning from the library, shared the history behind the tall-eared mystery in the caption:

“Historians believe that this idol may have been venerated as a god or protector. Hieroglyphics often depict this deity as all knowing, able to decipher and solve any problem that is asked of it. Many came to the monument to seek closure and bear offerings in exchange for enlightenment.”

Artist and photo-editing master davepollotart chimed in to share the Cumberbunny’s more recent history, informing users that “[b]efore his acting career took off, Benedict spent time as a street performer to make ends meet”:

But as anyone peripherally aware of the Full House, Gilmore Girls, and countless other recent reboots knows, nostalgia reigns supreme these days, so it was only fitting that the Cumberbunny craze helped launch a revival of one of the most unforgettable book series of the ’90s: Animorphs.

As redditor SharkThug writes in the caption, “Bestselling Author K.A. Applegate returns for this exciting new entry in the classic series.”

Who wouldn’t read this?

To binge-click all of redditors’ funniest, tastiest, most creative, and/or most disturbing takes on the chocolate Cumberbunny, hop over to the original Photoshop Battles thread.