Studies in mice and humans have revealed intriguing associations between host genetics and the microbiome. Here we report a 16S rRNA-based analysis of the gut microbiome in 1,126 twin pairs, a subset of which was previously reported. Tripling the sample narrowed the confidence intervals around heritability estimates and uncovered additional heritable taxa, some of which are validated in other studies. Repeat sampling of subjects showed heritable taxa to be temporally stable. A candidate gene approach uncovered associations between heritable taxa and genes related to diet, metabolism, and olfaction. We replicate an association between Bifidobacterium and the lactase (LCT) gene locus and identify an association between the host gene ALDH1L1 and the bacteria SHA-98, suggesting a link between formate production and blood pressure. Additional genes detected are involved in barrier defense and self/non-self recognition. Our results indicate that diet-sensing, metabolism, and immune defense are important drivers of human-microbiome co-evolution.

Introduction

De Filippo et al., 2010 De Filippo C.

Cavalieri D.

Di Paola M.

Ramazzotti M.

Poullet J.B.

Massart S.

Collini S.

Pieraccini G.

Lionetti P. Impact of diet in shaping gut microbiota revealed by a comparative study in children from Europe and rural Africa. Martínez et al., 2015 Martínez I.

Stegen J.C.

Maldonado-Gómez M.X.

Eren A.M.

Siba P.M.

Greenhill A.R.

Walter J. The gut microbiota of rural papua new guineans: composition, diversity patterns, and ecological processes. Yatsunenko et al., 2012 Yatsunenko T.

Rey F.E.

Manary M.J.

Trehan I.

Dominguez-Bello M.G.

Contreras M.

Magris M.

Hidalgo G.

Baldassano R.N.

Anokhin A.P.

et al. Human gut microbiome viewed across age and geography. The gut microbiome is acquired from the environment starting at birth. Diversity builds up over the first few years of life and, thereafter, is largely shaped by environmental factors such as age, diet, lifestyle, hygiene, and disease state. Patterns of microbiome diversity across human populations can be pronounced, with stark contrasts in membership and structure observed in stool collected from people living on different continents (). Such population differences in microbiomes may be largely driven by diet and lifestyle, but genetic ancestry cannot at present be excluded as an important shaper of microbial diversity. Within a population, genetically encoded differences between hosts, such as those that dictate food preferences, aspects of immunity, or gut physiology, in principle could impact diversity and structure of the microbiome.

For several years, twin studies have provided the basis for asking whether genetic variation in the host associates with genetic variation in the microbiome. The basic premise is the following: if the genetics of the host influence a phenotype, measures of the phenotype will be more similar within monozygotic (MZ) twin pairs compared to within dizygotic (DZ) twin pairs, assuming that since they are reared together, twins within a pair experience similar environments. Given a large enough twin population, these differences can be modeled to yield estimates of heritability, which is the proportion of variance in the phenotype that can be attributed to genetic differences between hosts.

Van de Merwe et al., 1983 Van de Merwe J.P.

Stegeman J.H.

Hazenberg M.P. The resident faecal flora is determined by genetic characteristics of the host. Implications for Crohn’s disease?. Stewart et al., 2005 Stewart J.A.

Chadwick V.S.

Murray A. Investigations into the influence of host genetics on the predominant eubacteria in the faecal microflora of children. Zoetendal et al., 2001 Zoetendal E.G.

Akkermans A.D.L.

Akkermans-van Vliet W.M.

de Visser J.A.G.M.

de Vos W.M. The host genotype affects the bacterial community in the human gastrointestinal tract. Turnbaugh et al., 2009 Turnbaugh P.J.

Hamady M.

Yatsunenko T.

Cantarel B.L.

Duncan A.

Ley R.E.

Sogin M.L.

Jones W.J.

Roe B.A.

Affourtit J.P.

et al. A core gut microbiome in obese and lean twins. Yatsunenko et al., 2012 Yatsunenko T.

Rey F.E.

Manary M.J.

Trehan I.

Dominguez-Bello M.G.

Contreras M.

Magris M.

Hidalgo G.

Baldassano R.N.

Anokhin A.P.

et al. Human gut microbiome viewed across age and geography. Early twin studies that used culture-based methods () and fingerprinting of fecal 16S rRNA gene amplicons () lacked the sample sizes required to estimate heritabilities of specific gut microbiota, but their results did suggest that some part of the gut microbiome was heritable. Two subsequent larger twin studies cast some ambiguity on this conclusion, however (). Using a larger number of twins (∼50 pairs of the Missouri twin registry) and 16S rRNA gene sequencing, both studies reported that MZ twin pairs had slightly more similar microbiomes compared to DZ twin pairs, though the differences were not statistically significant. These studies underscored that environmental factors are paramount in shaping the microbiome, yet they also hinted at a small host genetic effect.

Goodrich et al. (2014) Goodrich J.K.

Waters J.L.

Poole A.C.

Sutter J.L.

Koren O.

Blekhman R.

Beaumont M.

Van Treuren W.

Knight R.

Bell J.T.

et al. Human genetics shape the gut microbiome. In, we increased the power to detect heritable microbiota with a 16S rRNA gene-based analysis of 416 twin pairs. As observed for the Missouri twin studies, the UniFrac distances for MZ twins were slightly less than for DZ twins, but due to the greater sample size, the difference reached statistical significance. Importantly, the greater number of subjects allowed us to identify taxa with significant heritabilities. Among common taxa (those found in at least 50% of samples), the most heritable was the family Christensenellaceae (phylum Firmicutes), which forms the hub of a co-occurrence network composed of other heritable taxa and is enriched in lean subjects. Experiments using fecal transplants from twin donors into germ-free mice demonstrated that Christensenella minuta addition to a microbiome deficient in Christensenellaceae limited adiposity gain in the recipient mice. Together, these observations supported the notion that heritable microbes could drive the human phenotypes with which they associate.

Blekhman et al. (2015) Blekhman R.

Goodrich J.K.

Huang K.

Sun Q.

Bukowski R.

Bell J.T.

Spector T.D.

Keinan A.

Ley R.E.

Gevers D.

Clark A.G. Host genetic variation impacts microbiome composition across human body sites. Consortium, 2012 Consortium H. Human Microbiome Project Consortium

Structure, function and diversity of the healthy human microbiome. Blekhman et al., 2015 Blekhman R.

Goodrich J.K.

Huang K.

Sun Q.

Bukowski R.

Bell J.T.

Spector T.D.

Keinan A.

Ley R.E.

Gevers D.

Clark A.G. Host genetic variation impacts microbiome composition across human body sites. Ma et al., 2014 Ma J.

Coarfa C.

Qin X.

Bonnen P.E.

Milosavljevic A.

Versalovic J.

Aagaard K. mtDNA haplogroup and single nucleotide polymorphisms structure human microbiome communities. A few studies have used quantitative measures derived from the gut microbiome as phenotypes in genetic association studies.performed an analysis of human genetic data generated as a byproduct of the Human Microbiome Project (HMP) for 93 subjects (). Without accounting for population structure, ethnicity, or geographic stratification, Blekhman reported correlations between the first principal component of the host genetic variation and the first principal coordinate of the stool UniFrac distances (). A second study using the HMP’s human DNA data showed that mitochondrial haplotypes correlated with abundances of specific microbiota in stool (). Both results reflect ancestry effects on the composition of the microbiome.

David et al., 2014 David L.A.

Maurice C.F.

Carmody R.N.

Gootenberg D.B.

Button J.E.

Wolfe B.E.

Ling A.V.

Devlin A.S.

Varma Y.

Fischbach M.A.

et al. Diet rapidly and reproducibly alters the human gut microbiome. Davenport et al. (2015) Davenport E.R.

Cusanovich D.A.

Michelini K.

Barreiro L.B.

Ober C.

Gilad Y. Genome-wide association studies of the human gut microbiota. Davenport et al., 2015 Davenport E.R.

Cusanovich D.A.

Michelini K.

Barreiro L.B.

Ober C.

Gilad Y. Genome-wide association studies of the human gut microbiota. Davenport et al., 2014 Davenport E.R.

Mizrahi-Man O.

Michelini K.

Barreiro L.B.

Ober C.

Gilad Y. Seasonal variation in human gut microbiome composition. Diet differs among subjects and can rapidly alter microbial community composition (), casting some doubt over the use of relative abundance data in genetic association studies.circumvented this issue with a genome-wide analysis of the fecal microbiome composition in the Hutterites, a founder population that lives and eats communally (). These analyses revealed a suite of heritable taxa and highlighted links between microbial taxa and genes involved in barrier defense and immunity.

Benson et al. (2010) Benson A.K.

Kelly S.A.

Legge R.

Ma F.

Low S.J.

Kim J.

Zhang M.

Oh P.L.

Nehrenberg D.

Hua K.

et al. Individuality in gut microbiota composition is a complex polygenic trait shaped by multiple environmental and host genetic factors. Benson et al., 2010 Benson A.K.

Kelly S.A.

Legge R.

Ma F.

Low S.J.

Kim J.

Zhang M.

Oh P.L.

Nehrenberg D.

Hua K.

et al. Individuality in gut microbiota composition is a complex polygenic trait shaped by multiple environmental and host genetic factors. Leamy et al., 2014 Leamy L.J.

Kelly S.A.

Nietfeldt J.

Legge R.M.

Ma F.

Hua K.

Sinha R.

Peterson D.A.

Walter J.

Benson A.K.

Pomp D. Host genetics and diet, but not immunoglobulin A expression, converge to shape compositional features of the gut microbiome in an advanced intercross population of mice. McKnite et al., 2012 McKnite A.M.

Perez-Munoz M.E.

Lu L.

Williams E.G.

Brewer S.

Andreux P.A.

Bastiaansen J.W.M.

Wang X.

Kachman S.D.

Auwerx J.

et al. Murine gut microbiota is defined by host genetics and modulates variation of metabolic traits. Studies in mice further reduce the environmental influences on the microbiome.performed the first quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping study, using 645 mice from an advanced intercross line (). QTL analysis detected 13 genetic loci that were significantly associated with microbial abundances and five additional suggestive loci. Many of the QTL were in regions with genes that play roles in the immune system. Subsequent studies in mice have confirmed some of these results (). Comparisons across mouse and human studies highlight some common themes: genetic control of certain bacterial taxa (e.g., Turicibacter) and associations with immune-related genes.