A lot of horrible things have happened to Sansa Stark on Game of Thrones. Too many to name in full. Her father was killed (then she was made to look at his head on a pike), she got betrothed to Joffrey, she ended up marrying Tyrion against her will, she was nearly pushed out the Moon Door, and Ramsay raped her on their wedding night. That last moment of misery is one of the show’s most controversial scenes, and in this past Sunday’s episode, the tragic “The Door,” Sansa confronted the man who sent her to the Boltons.

“What do you think he did to me?” Sansa asked a dumbfounded Littlefinger. He beat her, he cut her, he never hurt her face (“he needed my face”) he did things “ladies aren’t supposed to talk about.” Sansa continued, “I can still feel it. I don’t mean ‘in my tender heart, it still pains me so.’ I can still feel what he did, in my body, standing here, right now.” It’s Sansa’s last comment that has many viewers believing the unimaginable has happened.

I’ve been think a lot about Sansa this week. -New dress

-Appetite problems with the Watch’s food.

-She tells Littlefinger that she can “still feel right now” what Ramsay did to her. Sansa is pregnant! (Via)

I think Sansa is pregnant — Nicolas (@NickDassonval) May 25, 2016

I bet that Sansa is pregnant #GameofThrones — مريم (@UKBeliebs_In1D) May 24, 2016

What if Sansa is pregnant?!?!?!?!? What if the evil spawn of Ramsey grows within her?!?!?!?!? #gamesofthrones #demthrones #sansa nooooo — Tia (@TiaNicole88) May 24, 2016

Btw, by that convo with Little Finger, I'm betting that Sansa is pregnant. #GameofThrones — Crissy Campise (@CrissyCampise) May 24, 2016

@GameOfThrones Am I ready too far into it or did Sansa basically tell Baelish she's pregnant? — Bob Longo (@RoadWarrior8831) May 25, 2016

If Sansa IS pregnant, I could totally see her aborting, OR giving birth and immediately dropping it over a cliff without thinking twice. — Kashipan (@YukataSugata) May 24, 2016

What if Sansa is pregnant?! #gotconspiracytheory — BabethLafont (@BabethLafont) May 24, 2016

There are holes to pick apart in this theory — for instance, even people who aren’t pregnant would have “problems” with Castle Black’s food — and considering all the criticism they received last season, I can’t imagine David Benioff and D.B. Weiss would make the newly empowered Sansa suffer even more. Then again, this is Game of Thrones we’re talking about. Suffering is the status quo. Especially if you’re Sansa Stark.

(Via Reddit)