So I came across a post with the puzzle painting a couple of minutes ago and i noticed something weird:

Who on earth is the guy next to the sheriff?? All of the non-characters in the painting have painted faces, where all the characters have photo-realistic faces, like someone photoshopped them in. Now, this person doesn’t look familiar to me, but maybe one of you recognize him??

Now before you tell me i’m reading too much into it, maybe this is just another painted face, yeah, i had that thought too. but here’s the thing–this face was added AFTER the pieces were all put together (with some terrible photoshopping, i might add). i screenshot this directly from the teen wolf tumblr. here’s the google docs version of this same piece from the puzzle:

WHO IS THIS??