Come Halloween, everyone has a specific sweet treat they comb the Halloween candy aisles for. Caramel apple suckers, M&Ms, Tootsie Rolls, Hershey's, candy corn—the sugary list goes on and on. Influenster, a website covering products and reviews, may have found the Halloween treat that tops the list. While surveying 40,000 of their users for the best Halloween candies by state, they found that there was one chocolate snack that kept popping up: Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. The candy brought in the most votes and was one of three picks to show up in every single state—the other two being Kit Kat and Butterfinger.