"He still gives you a pretty good at-bat most of the time, and I don't want to jump on Chooch's bandwagon right now and say he'll provide more offense because if you catch him three or four days in a row, it wears and tears on your body," Mackanin said. "At some point I'll probably have to make that decision if Rupp isn't hitting and Chooch is, I'll lean that way. But I'm not a fortune teller."