Our sources say Officer Williams came to the store to pick up the rings, filed a report, and then took them back to the police department where he vouchered them in the property room, WHICH IS normal procedure. Within a day or 2, sources say a young woman connected to Officer Williams (a connection unknown to police department personnel at the time) showed up at police headquarters claiming the rings (valued at almost $18,000) were hers, and she was able to provide a convincingly accurate description of the rings and the timing of their original disappearance.