Pro Tour Update

Grand Prix Nashville

Over 450 teams, a total of just under 1,400 players, showed up in Music City to compete in Khans of Tarkir limited. Team formats are always exciting and the best and brightest came out to rub elbows in Nashville. Among the top teams at the end of day one were a slew of top pro players including the team of Tom Martell, PVDDR, and Shahar Shenhar in 3rd place and teams including Sam Black, Josh Utter-Leyton, Jon Finkel, Jamie Parke, and Huey Jensen scattered in the top 16. At the end of day two it was Martell, Rosa, and Shenhar sitting at the top of the standings.

They faced off against Sam Black, Gaudenis Vidugiris, and Matthew Severa. Black was able to defeat Martell, but PVDDR and Shahar Shenhar came out on top to send the all-star team to the finals. Once there they met a young gun team consisting of Matt Nass, Jesse Hampton, and Jacob Wilson. Martell and de Rosa each won their first game giving their team the early lead in the match. Jesse Hampton, however, was able to defeat Shahar Shenhar 2-0, meaning that only one of Matt Nass and Jacob Wilson needed to win their match to claim the trophy.

Matt Nass managed to tie up his match with Tom Martell giving him an opportunity to win the match in the pivotal third game. Meanwhile, de Rosa and Wilson played a very close second game featuring a very crowded board which only grew more crowded as the game went on. Ultimately Wilson was able to win the match, leading to not one but two pivotal game threes. A win by either Nass or Wilson would secure victory. Martell and de Rosa would both need wins to turn the tide. Both matches battled on but it was Matt Nass winning first and securing the trophy for himself, Jacob Wilson, and Jesse Hampton.

Grand Prix Santiago

A total of 660 players traveled to the Chilean capital city to battle the latest Standard decks against each other. When the dust settled on the first day of competition a few notable Latin American players were competing for a shot at the top 8 including Willy Edel. By the end of swiss competition on Sunday, Edel, the four-time Pro Tour top 8 competitor, was sitting in first place going into the final tables of the Grand Prix. This was Edel’s seventh trip to the top 8 of a GP but his day came to an end in the quarterfinals at the hands of Daniel Gaete Quezada.

The metagame for this event included two Abzan Midrange decks, one Red Deck Wins deck, three RG Monsters decks, and two [casthaven]Whip of Erebos[/casthaven] decks. It appears that these are the four decks to beat over the coming months before the release of Fate Reforged. Eduardo Vieira brought a Whip deck without Sidisi and piloted it all the way to a Grand Prix championship. Along the way he defeated both Abzan decks and one of the RG Monster decks. The Whip is shaping up to be a very powerful tool indeed.

Top 25 Rankings

With very little representation from the Top 25 players in the world at GP Stockholm, the rankings remained stagnant this week. Nashville will likely have some impact, but if not then things will remain silent for quite some time.

The Quick Hits

Several of the senior columnists at Gathering Magic shared their thoughts on the recent cheating issues. Editor Alex Ullman wants to see more transparency in the investigation process. Community manager Heather Lafferty argues that the best way to combat cheating is by educating players to recognize cheating. Content manager Adam Styborski just wants us to all be nicer to each other about the whole thing. All in all this is a great microcosm of the wider discussions taking place [Gathering Magic]

Meanwhile, Jordan Kennedy lays down the rationale for why cheating is bad. One would think that this sort of explanation is self-evident but the fact that Kennedy feels the need to present this means that as a community we really don’t understand the issues [LegitMTG]

After countless outages and uproars from the community, Wizards has changed the MTGO reimbursement policy to no longer take into consideration prizes already won in the event. This is a small change but will be a big boon to folks who play many hours of an event only to have it crash in the late rounds and leave virtually empty-handed [Daily MTG]

Zac Hill shares an in-depth insider look at his experience covering Pro Tour Khans of Tarkir for the official Wizards coverage crew. KTK was Hill’s last Pro Tour as a member of the coverage team and his enthusiasm and passion was one of the highlights of tournament coverage [Star City Games]

James Arnold looks at the evolution of Magic art through five supposedly iconic cards from the game’s history. I have to question his inclusion of Dark Ritual, Healing Salve, and Counterspell as iconic spells as they haven’t been reprinted in a standard-legal set since 1999, 2001, and 2001 respectively. Arnold also used Lightning Bolt, a card that didn’t have it’s art changed for 16 years, as an example. I’m not sure what’s going on here [Gathering Magic]

Natasha Lewis Harrington continues her in-depth psychological look at how we can invoke change in the way we approach Magic. If you are trying to improve your habits such as getting on tilt after losses or making common mistakes, you really need to give this a look [Gathering Magic]

Danny Brown presents the incredibly strong argument for banning Treasure Cruise in Modern and Legacy and restricting it in Vintage. I can’t say he’s wrong and I agree completely that if you’re holding onto foil copies I would get rid of them now [Quiet Speculation]

Following up on last week’s post, it turns out that Jared Boettcher is a cheater and has been stripped of his title as Rookie of the Year. As such, the title has been passed on to Ray Perez Jr. who will also be going to the World Championship in Nice next month [Daily MTG]

If you enjoyed my Modern Hero series over the summer, you should give this new Legacy Hero series a try [MTG Price]

Last but not least, Paul Rietzl has compiled a comprehensive guide to avoiding being the victim of cheating at your next Magic tournament. A lot of guides like this have come out over the past week but this is really the only one you’ll need [Channel Fireball]

Sometimes the artwork for a dragon will include what are known as “scale birds” which are meant to show just how big the dragon is, because otherwise we may not know. I don’t think the art for [casthaven]Polluted Delta[/casthaven] does a good enough job of conveying just how large this dead dragon is. I think there are some “scale skeletons” but it would have been helpful to have some “scale birds” hanging around.

Grade: B-



The Week Ahead

It’s time to enjoy a week off from the rigors of the Grand Prix circuit. Instead, get down to your LGS for some Commander 2014 action! The latest multiplayer set features five new mono-colored Commander decks chock full of nostalgia. If that’s not your thing, then I recommend getting outdoors and enjoying the waning weekends of fall. I’ll be doing just that at the New York Botanical Garden. Grand Prix events return in two weeks with GP New Jersey and GP Madrid!

What We Learned is a weekly feature here at Hipsters of the Coast written by former amateur Magic Player Rich Stein, who came really close to making day two of a Grand Prix on several occasions. Each week we will take a look at the past seven days of major events, big news items, and community happenings so that you can keep up-to-date on all the latest and greatest Magic: the Gathering community news.