Text Size:

ANOTHER Epic Fail for Influenza Vaccine



by Barbara Loe Fisher

To activate and view hyperlinked references, please click here once and then click any superscripted number below to access a hyperlinked reference, or scroll down to the bottom of the article to view all hyperlinked references.



Here we are in the winter of 2015 and U.S. public health officials admit that the historically ineffective influenza vaccine is once again an epic fail. 1 2 Here we are in the winter of 2015 and U.S. public health officials admit that the historically ineffective influenza vaccine is once again an epic fail.

Flu Vaccine Effectiveness Measured from 0 to 62 Percent

In the past three flu seasons, the CDC has claimed the flu vaccine’s overall effectiveness clocked in at between 47 and 62 percent 3 while some experts have measured it at 0 to 7 percent. 4 Other studies suggest that when children get a flu shot every year it can interfere with healthy immune responses and make them more likely to get influenza in certain flu seasons. 5 6 Independent medical literature reviews document that flu shots don’t really prevent influenza or complications of influenza 7 8 or influenza-like-illness (ILI) associated with other types of viruses that cause about 80% of all respiratory or gastrointestinal infections during any given flu season. 9 10 11 12 In the past three flu seasons, the CDC has claimed the flu vaccine’s overall effectiveness clocked in at between 47 and 62 percentwhile some experts have measured it at 0 to 7 percent.Other studies suggest that when children get a flu shot every year it can interfere with healthy immune responses and make them more likely to get influenza in certain flu seasons.Independent medical literature reviews document that flu shots don’t really prevent influenza or complications of influenzaor influenza-like-illness (ILI) associated with other types of viruses that cause about 80% of all respiratory or gastrointestinal infections during any given flu season.

A car in which seatbelts and brakes only worked at best half the time is not a car Americans would choose to buy or drive. Car manufacturers profiting from selling that kind of defective product would be sued in civil court and rightly so.

Americans Forced to Get Flu Shots or Suffer Sanctions

Yet, U.S. public health officials are making flu vaccine policy that gets turned into law. 13 14 They are forcing Americans to buy and use a pharmaceutical product that fails to work as advertised time and again and can brain injure people, too. 15 16 17 But we can’t sue drug companies for vaccine failures, brain injuries and deaths in civil court. 18 Many of us are being fired from our jobs or denied an education, childcare and medical care if we refuse to salute smartly and get a flu shot every year or give it to our children. 19 20 21 22 Yet, U.S. public health officials are making flu vaccine policy that gets turned into law.They are forcing Americans to buy and use a pharmaceutical product that fails to work as advertised time and again and can brain injure people, too.But we can’t sue drug companies for vaccine failures, brain injuries and deaths in civil court.Many of us are being fired from our jobs or denied an education, childcare and medical care if we refuse to salute smartly and get a flu shot every year or give it to our children.

Dominant Influenza A Strain NOT In Current Flu Shot

23 and one or two influenza B virus strains 24 to include in flu vaccines released in the fall. This past December, CDC officials held a press conference and informed Americans that they were unaware last spring that one of the influenza A strains selected for the 2014/2015 flu vaccine – the H3N2 subtype – was starting to “drift.” It turns out that the genetically mutated subtype is the dominant influenza A strain causing sickness this year but it is not in the flu vaccine. 25 26 27 28 Every spring, federal health officials select two influenza A virus strains (usually H1N1 and H3N2 subtypes)and one or two influenza B virus strainsto include in flu vaccines released in the fall. This past December, CDC officials held a press conference and informed Americans that they were unaware last spring that one of the influenza A strains selected for the 2014/2015 flu vaccine – the H3N2 subtype – was starting to “drift.” It turns out that the genetically mutated subtype is the dominant influenza A strain causing sickness this year but it is not in the flu vaccine.

Some Experts Warn Flu Shot Does NOT Make Symptoms Less Severe

29 Bottom line: If you or your child got a flu shot this year, it does not protect you from the most common influenza A subtype making people sick. And now, some influenza experts are warning that flu shots do not make symptoms less severe if the vaccine fails to prevent influenza infection.

2003/2004 Flu Shot Failure: Same Story

Is this the first time that federal health officials have been aware that the influenza A H3N2 subtype constantly mutates and is often the dominant strain of flu that circulates in the U.S.? No, it’s not.

Let’s go back and take a look at the 2003/2004 flu season’s epic influenza vaccine fail. In the spring of 2003, federal health officials did know ahead of time that the influenza A Panama strain they chose for the seasonal flu vaccine was not a match for the emerging mutated H3N2 Fujian strain making people very sick. Influenza experts told the FDA vaccine advisory committee (VRBPAC) that two genetic mutations in the H3N2 strain would likely cause the flu shot to fail if it was not included in the vaccine. Let’s go back and take a look at the 2003/2004 flu season’s epic influenza vaccine fail. In the spring of 2003, federal health officials did know ahead of time that the influenza A Panama strain they chose for the seasonal flu vaccine was not a match for the emerging mutated H3N2 Fujian strain making people very sick. Influenza experts told the FDA vaccine advisory committee (VRBPAC) that two genetic mutations in the H3N2 strain would likely cause the flu shot to fail if it was not included in the vaccine. [30]

31 So what was the government’s rationale for allowing drug companies to produce a flu vaccine they knew was likely a non-starter from the very beginning? As the consumer voting member at that March 2003 FDA committee meeting, I abstained from the influenza vaccine strain selection vote because the influenza A strain being recommended was not a match for the emerging mutated H3N2 strain and said I thought the public should be told.So what was the government’s rationale for allowing drug companies to produce a flu vaccine they knew was likely a non-starter from the very beginning?

Well, the vaccine manufacturers said they couldn’t include the mutated H3N2 subtype in the vaccine because they would miss the fall 2003 delivery and marketing deadline! In other words, it was all about protecting a multi-billion dollar flu vaccine market and not about truth in advertising.

32 Flu vaccine effectiveness for the 2003/2004 season was described by health officials as 3% to 14%, which does qualify as an epic fail.

2012/2013 Flu Shot Failure: Vaccine Manufacturing Problem

33 Now let’s look at the 2012/2013 flu season, when flu vaccine effectiveness was 50% and only 41% in preventing the H3N2 subtype that caused most of the disease that season. A little digging into the medical literature reveals that the H3N2 subtype problem was not due to a natural antigenic drift like CDC officials are claiming it is this season. No, flu vaccine failure two years ago was about mutations in the egg adapted H3N2 vaccine strain used by drug companies to produce the vaccine.

In other words, it was a vaccine manufacturing problem. Drug companies introduced H3N2 mutations through the vaccine manufacturing process, creating a mismatch between the circulating H3N2 strain and the vaccine strain.

Congress Funds Aggressive Influenza Vaccine Push on Americans

How honest is the CDC being with legislators voting to give federal health agencies and drug companies billions of dollars to produce influenza vaccines 34 35 36 37 38 39 that are being aggressively pushed on all Americans, including infants, children, pregnant women and health care workers 40 41 42 43 using a pathetically poor evidence base? 44 45 46 How honest is the CDC being with legislators voting to give federal health agencies and drug companies billions of dollars to produce influenza vaccinesthat are being aggressively pushed on all Americans, including infants, children, pregnant women and health care workersusing a pathetically poor evidence base?

Influenza Viruses Always Mutating, Vaccine Strain Virus Shedding

47 48 49 50 51 Vaccine strain influenza viruses can recombine with other viruses as well, 52 particularly those shed and transmitted by children and adults given live influenza virus vaccines 53 54 55 56 and by experimental live virus vectored vaccines being created in labs, with unknown effects on humans, animals and the environment. 57 58 59 60 Influenza viruses that infect humans and animals are always mutating and evolving, recombining with each other and creating new influenza strains being shed and transmitted in body fluids and waste products of animals and humans.Vaccine strain influenza viruses can recombine with other viruses as well,particularly those shed and transmitted by children and adults given live influenza virus vaccinesand by experimental live virus vectored vaccines being created in labs, with unknown effects on humans, animals and the environment.

GMO Flu Vaccines, Risky Adjuvants: Follow the Money

And yet, billions of dollars are being spent by government and industry to build more flu vaccine plants to create genetically engineered flu vaccines that contain insect and animal DNA, foreign proteins 61 62 63 64 65 and novel adjuvants designed to hyper-stimulate human immune responses. 66 67 68 69 70 In an irrational crusade to outsmart influenza viruses, vaccine risks are increasing 71 while vaccine failures continue to haunt the entire money-driven enterprise. 72 73 74 And yet, billions of dollars are being spent by government and industry to build more flu vaccine plants to create genetically engineered flu vaccines that contain insect and animal DNA, foreign proteinsand novel adjuvants designed to hyper-stimulate human immune responses.In an irrational crusade to outsmart influenza viruses, vaccine risks are increasingwhile vaccine failures continue to haunt the entire money-driven enterprise.

Repeal Flu Shot Mandates, Hold Companies Accountable

After decades of government propaganda trumpeting the benefits and minimizing the risks of annual flu shots, one-size-fits-all, cradle to the grave influenza vaccine recommendations should be revised. Flu shot mandates should be repealed and vaccine manufacturers held accountable for vaccine risks and failures in civil court.