Kids in U.S. worse off than in other rich nations, report says / UNICEF ranks 19 wealthy countries better for children

2007-02-15 04:00:00 PDT United Nations -- The United States and Britain ranked as the worst places to be a child among 21 wealthy nations, according to a report by UNICEF released Wednesday. The Netherlands was the best, it said, followed by Sweden and Denmark.

UNICEF's Innocenti Research Centre in Italy ranked the countries in material well-being, health, education, relationships, behaviors and risks, and young people's sense of happiness.

The finding that the children in the richest countries are not necessarily the best-off surprised many, said Marta Santos Pais, the study director. The Czech Republic, for example, ranked above countries with a higher per capita income, such as Austria, France, the United States and Britain, in part because of a more equal distribution of wealth and higher relative investment in education and public health.

Some of the wealthier countries' lower rankings were a result of less spending on social programs and "dog eat dog" competition in jobs that led to adults spending less time with their children and heightened alienation among peers, one of the report's authors, Jonathan Bradshaw, said at a televised news conference in London.

"The findings that we got today are a consequence of long-term underinvestment in children," said Bradshaw, a professor of social policy at York University in England.

The highest ranking for the United States was for education, where it placed 12th. But America and Britain landed in the lowest third for five of the six categories measured.

The United States was at the bottom in health and safety, mostly because of its high rates of child mortality and accidental deaths. It was next to last in family and peer relationships and risk-taking behavior. The U.S. has the highest proportion of children living in single-parent homes, which the study defined as an indicator for increased risk of poverty and poor health, though it "may seem unfair and insensitive," it said.

The United States also was close to the bottom of the scale for children who eat and talk frequently with their families.

Britain had the highest rate of children involved in activities that endangered their welfare: 31 percent of those studied said they had been drunk at least twice by the age of 15, and 38 percent had had sexual intercourse by that age.

Canada had the highest rate of children who had smoked marijuana by age 15 -- 40.4 percent. Japan ranked the worst on "subjective well-being," with 30 percent of children agreeing with the statement, "I am lonely."

Because of a lack of internationally comparable data, the study did not address children's exposure to domestic violence, both as victims and as witnesses, or children's mental and emotional health.

The report acknowledges that some assessment scales have "weak spots."

The study, for example, measured relative affluence by asking whether a family owned a vehicle and a computer, whether children had their own bedroom and how often the family traveled together on vacation. Some answers might depend on the quality of public transportation and real estate prices, making the average child in New York's affluent areas seem equal to one in a less developed country because of the constraints of city living.

The authors acknowledge the study is "a work in progress in need of improved definitions and better data." But they say it is a first step in providing benchmarks for comparing countries and highlighting poor performance in otherwise rich nations.

"All countries have weaknesses to be addressed," Santos Pais said.

Child well-being Economic inequality, poor levels of public support for families and high incidences of single-parent families are some factors that landed the U.S. and Britain at the bottom of a U.N. survey of child well-being. Average ranking position of child well-being in wealthy countries Netherlands 4.2 Sweden 5.0 Denmark 7.2 Finland 7.5 Spain 8.0 Switzerland 8.3 Norway 8.7 Italy 10.0 Ireland 10.2 Belgium 10.7 Germany 11.2 Canada 11.8 Greece 11.8 Poland 12.3 Czech Republic 12.5 France 13.0 Portugal 13.7 Austria 13.8 Hungary 14.5 United States 18.0 Britain 18.2 Note: Countries are listed by their average overall ranking, with the lowest figure indicating the best result. The countries are ranked on the following individual categories: material well-being, health and safety, education, peer and family relationships, behaviors and risks, and young peoples own subjective sense of well-being. Source: UNICEF Associated Press