11% weight

This is a 2nd **Dual-Review** [PART-A by Brunhild and PART-B by myself].



[PART A] Brunhild's review:



1. The team is composed by ceo and his wife



2. The partnership are most of all with other companies the ceo runs (celerswap tesla duo and others)



3. The token metric is not clear (the sum is 102%) and also in the advisor agreement there is no mention to vesting period



4.The light paper is confused and not clear, with a bunch of things not linked (AI, charity, IoT, exchange). It had also a lot of corrupted links to another ico (probably a scam itself)



Since i think it is a total scam i would give them a 1 1 1

T= the team is non existent as it is composed by the ceo and his wife. There is also the bounty manager listed but he has no power

V= the vision is totally confused, the project is a bunch of stuff not clearly linked between them

P= it is not existent and there are no devs in charge to deliver it.

For these reasons I think they have no intention to develop anything



[PART B] My review & list of questions:



C1. The official Telegram chat group created on 7 July 2018 has 970 members (as at 3 Aug 2018): https://t.me/TradePharmaNetwork

This is a selected extracts of postings:

.....07.07.2018 03:09:52, Tyler ?????? [@Ty_Sainkoudje]: >>upgraded the group to a supergroup<<

07.07.2018 07:50:54, Marie [@Marie_Mendez]: [[Webpage]]https://www.nasdaq.com/article/tatatu-hosts-the-worlds-third-largest-ico-earns-over-500-million-cm984527

07.07.2018 07:55:41, Tyler ?????? [@Ty_Sainkoudje]: [[Webpage]]https://bitcoinist.com/malta-blockchain-bill-law-legal/

.....07.07.2018 17:09:47, Debabrata Samal [@devsamal84]: >>unsupported service message type: messageActionChatJoinedByLink<<

.....07.07.2018 17:09:49, Yaroslav Yaroslav [@LectorProctor]: >>unsupported service message type: messageActionChatJoinedByLink<<

.....07.07.2018 17:10:25, nostradamus [@nostradamus16]: >>unsupported service message type: messageActionChatJoinedByLink<<

.....07.07.2018 17:16:36, @pranimbo [@Pranimbo]: >>unsupported service message type: messageActionChatJoinedByLink<<

.....07.07.2018 17:23:43, bilbilon| https://wppenergy.io [@bilbilon]: >>unsupported service message type: messageActionChatJoinedByLink<<

.....07.07.2018 17:26:55, Shi Bob [@Shibob89]: >>unsupported service message type: messageActionChatJoinedByLink<<

:

:

07.07.2018 19:07:22, Marie [@Marie_Mendez]: [[Webpage]]?? PLEASE HAVE A LOOK AT THIS FIRST! ??

Welcome, all new members! ???????? and BIG THANKS to EACH & ALL of you for joining us! ????????

????? Trade Pharma Network Bounty Campaign is LIVE:

?? https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4616376.0

?????? Our LIGHTPAPER is out and is out. Here is the link to it:

https://www.tradepharma.network/lightpaper

??Please check it out! The WHITEPAPER will follow soon.??????

???? Our private sale has not started yet. We don’t have any Private Sale accurate details available for you now. Our team is mainly focusing on building our technology as well as the launch of this superbe ICO.

???? The best way to get the most up-to-date information is to join our ANNOUNCEMENT CHANNEL and subscribe to our website. So stay tuned!

?Official Website ??https://www.tradepharma.network

?Announcement Channel ??https://t.me/TradePharmaNetwork

????Want more info about Trade Pharma Network? Please check our Marketing Website (ICO Website under construction):

?? https://www.tradepharma.network/

:

:

:"



C2: What is your smart contact address?



C3: Trade Pharma Network (TPN) is operating under which company - would appreciate if you could share with us (a) name of the company, (b) company website, (c) company registration number, (d) office address so that I can visit you, (e) date of registration, and (f) country of incorporation.



C4. Who are the company directors of TPN?



C5: What is the token lockup/vesting period for the team members?



C6: What is the token lockup/vesting period for the advisors?



C7. What are the roles of each of your advisors and who among them is in your Telegram community?



C8: What's your github address?



C9. Any MVP to show?



C10. When will the full whitepaper be ready?



C11. What is the difference between this ICO and the other one at: https://icobench.com/ico/pharmaparalleltrade



C12. I will revise my ratings after receiving further responses to above comments & questions from Brunhild as well as mine.



For your reply, pls use this notation, R1 for C1, R2 for C2, ..., R11 for C11.



My rating is T=1 V=1 P=1.



*****



For the Dual-Review: The average rating is therefore T=1, V=1, P=1.

+7 Agree +7

+2