When Season 16 of Deadliest Catch premiered on April 14, fans were eager to see which cast members would return for another dangerous round of crab fishing.

Sure enough, the FV Wizard and its captains, Keith and Monte Colburn, are back in action, but did deckhand Freddy Maugatai — who previously worked on the Cornelia Marie and the Time Bandit — join the crew for a third straight year?