Wayne Rooney officially drew level with Sir Bobby Charlton to become Manchester United’s joint all-time record goalscorer in the FA Cup against Reading on Saturday.

His goal saw him equal Charlton’s record of 249 goals for the Red Devils, over a year after breaking his record at international level with England.

However, there is an argument that Rooney did not in fact level Charlton’s record with the history books revealing the 79-year-old actually managed 251 goals for the club.

In the last of his 758 recognised appearances for United in April 1973, Charlton had 249 goals, although he went on to play in the Anglo-Italian Cup a week later against Verona, scoring two goals.

The game was an official game organised between the Football Association, the Italian FA and Uefa, but the goals, and the appearance, is not recognised by United as it was not considered a ‘first-class game competition’.

Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Show all 22 1 /22 Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Sergio Romero – 5 out of 10 It was an incredibly easy day at the office for Romero, who remained untested throughout. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Ashley Young – 6 out of 10 It was a disciplined display, with his attacking nature causing problems for the Reading defence down the right. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Chris Smalling – 7 out of 10 Battled relentlessly and created a number of chances from his clearances at the back. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Marcos Rojo – 5 out of 10 Was subbed in the early stages of the game due to an injury. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Daley Blind – 5 out of 10 Was beat by McCleary on occasions, but aside from that he did make a number of crucial interceptions and challenges Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Marouane Fellani – 6 out of 10 He battled persistently in the middle of the park which broke down Reading’s moves at times. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Michael Carrick – 6 out of 10 Provided service up to the United forwards throughout and his experience was visible out there. He led by example. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Juan Mata – 7 out of 10 He was a key element to almost every United attack, but his shooting needs improve significantly. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Wayne Rooney – 9 out of 10 His early goal made club history and his performance today reflected this. He was energetic, determined and created numerous chances. He was a joy to watch. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Anthony Martial – 8 out of 10 His fine run of form continued today, with his pace proving unbearable for the Reading defence. He deserved his goal and created a number of United moves. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Marcus Rashford – 9 out of 10 The young prospect again proved his worth in the starting 11 today, with his unforgiving pace, clever runs and tantalising touches when in possession. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Ali Al-Habsi – 5 out of 10 It was a tough day for the 35-year-old who was under constant pressure from the off, but there is no excuse for his mistake that gave them their fourth goal. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Chris Gunter - 5 out of 10 Made a number of crucial tackles, but as the skipper, he should have done more to raise the tempo and determination of his side. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Liam Moore – 5 out of 10 For a man of such ability, it was a tiresome performance today. He created very few chances and made a habit of losing possession. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Joey Van Den Berg – 6 out of 10 It was a disciplined display from the 35-year-old, but he was outplayed in the middle of the field at times. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Tyler Blackett – 5 out of 10 Failed to make any real impact on the game against his former club, despite confident talk prior to the game. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Danny Williams – 6 out of 10 He battled relentlessly, sparking a particular feud with Fellaini. The 27-year-old appeared to be a well-needed influence in the Reading side. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings George Evans – 7 out of 10 The youngster showed glimpses of brilliance today, with clever through balls and a number of impressive touches. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Garath McCleary – 7 out of 10 Even when his side was battling a four-goal deficit, he continued to charge forward and attempt his skilful runs. He caused United problems at times. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Liam Kelly – 6 out of 10 He looked comfortable and composed in possession. He created chances for the visitors and proved himself to be a promising prospect. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Roy Beerens – 5 out of 10 It was a somewhat mediocre display from the winger, who failed to make an impact or find space throughout. Manchester United vs Reading player ratings Yann Kermorgant – 5 out of 10 He lacked any kind of service, so was unable to show his ability. The United defence simply played him out of the game.

United insist Charlton’s last-ever game was the 1-0 defeat to Chelsea, and not the game against Verona.

Despite this, the yellow cards picked up in the fixture contributed towards suspensions for players, leading many to claim the goals should also stand.

Therefore Charlton actually scored 251 goals for United, and not the 249 officially recognised, leaving it up for debate whether Rooney is actually the club’s joint all-time record goalscorer.