For the character design phase, animator Hisashi Ezura spent lots of time adjusting the thickness of the line because of the wider dynamic range. Having an outline on characters is unique in anime, but using the typical line thickness for SDR became too sharp and looked fake in HDR. He adjusted the pen pressure to have a bit softer touch than usual.

A test image to check line thickness

In the color design phase, the team initially thought 300 nits would be good enough for pre-production. However, once they saw the impact of 1000 nits on an Eizo CG3145 monitor, they felt the gap between the two was huge and 300 nits didn’t provide the color designer a full palette. Since color decisions are made in pre-production for anime, it was very important for Production I.G. color designer Miho Tanaka to look at an actual mastering monitor at 1000 nits at this point.

Establishing the skin tone was also a challenge. Shadow color in particular needed careful adjustment as it could easily make the overall appearance of the face very different, and impact the character design. Miho spent lots of her time making the character look pretty at all times of the day. For dark scenes, HDR made it easier to create colors because it didn’t get “muddy”, and the line kept its sharpness. Without enough dynamic range, it’s hard to retain thin lines like eyelashes. HDR allows for distinct color separations instead of ones that blur in a way that is undesirable.

During the look development, other challenges and opportunities emerged. Thanks to HDR, the typical VFX effect to make eyes appear to sparkle could be replaced by simply using colors differently. By adding simple bright lines on the lips, they become glossy. The director received all this feedback and adjusted her designs and colors.

(L) Test Image (R) Final Image

One of the biggest challenges during pre-production were the limitations in design and drawing tools in HDR. The user interface of graphics software was far too bright to view consistently at 1000 nits, and the background needed to be changed to grey (180) instead of white (255) during preview on an HDR monitor. Inside many graphics tools, 16 bit output is still not fully supported — a critical requirement for HDR. And when selecting color swatches, the color picker in design software would look different on SDR and HDR monitors, leading to difficulty in accurately selecting colors.

Challenges with 4K also emerged at this stage. When artists drew lines, limitations on resolution for their screen or tablet required them to scale up and check their work repeatedly. When fully zoomed out, the lines were too thin to recognize minute details.

Sol Levante: Production Findings

Pre-production went smoothly in our collaboration with Production IG. The real challenges began to emerge in the production phase.

To start, the team had to go through a lot of experimentation to establish the right signal flow and set-up the proper color profiles and view color correctly on each display depending on the software. The team needed to have multiple monitors for each artist to show SDR and HDR, and to continue to support the SDR projects they continued to work on in the studio. Management of color in animation is a challenge across many productions globally. This was a particularly complex project, but Junichiro Aki and Katsushi Eda and color management specialist Masakazu Morinaka created a system that worked.

For Sol Levante, everything was created digitally. Aside from using Procreate on the iPad for the pre-production drawing and ideation phases, Production I.G. used ClipStudio for in-betweening, Vue for background and a few select elements, Retas Stylus for color, Photoshop, and After Effects. Animators experimented with Toon Boom Harmony, which is well-known for “cut out” animation, a technique widely used outside Japan.

Sol Levante’s workflow diagram: click to expand

Right away, the team realized some anime techniques they had relied upon for years wouldn’t work with the additional brightness and color gamut. For example, “white out” is a common effect in anime: a fade to 100% white as a storytelling technique. The white was far too overpowering in HDR, so they chose to add a white layer on top of the existing color instead. Every time they found something that couldn’t work as expected, they found another way to accomplish the same feeling.

The biggest impact 4K had on the workflow was when rendering final shots with compositions that contained images much bigger than 4K to allow for panning. In fact, the rendering problems at this resolution caused such an issue that the entire project was delayed for months. Some of these issues were caused by hardware configurations that needed to be adjusted for the 4K pipeline, while others were rooted in the design of software and how it utilized system resources. Redesigning software to better handle system resources continues to be a major problem for software manufacturers to solve.

Digital drawings also retain delicate lines because there’s no need to scan paper for digitization. Compared to paper, the animator wasn’t as conscious about the canvas size. He also made a “settings sheet” to limit the level of detail for characters and accessories under certain conditions. The amount of detail is related to the size of the character on the screen. This needs to be refined to decide to add additional detail in 4K resolution, or to not spend time on detail that won’t be seen.

Production I.G.’s settings sheet

As Production I.G. continued to work on Sol Levante, the team decided to outsource some of the “in-between” animation work — generating the intermediate frames between two images — to other companies (a common practice in anime production). It was difficult to accomplish this since a typical response from these subcontractors was to refuse new ideas like a digital workflow, which would require investment in equipment and retraining staff to adopt these new tools. Additionally, since Production I.G. found that working on an HDR monitor at 1000 nits was absolutely necessary for color decisions, line work, or compositing, the persistent shortage of HDR monitors — particularly affordable monitors — in the post production market has a major impact on the ability to decide to work in HDR from the beginning.

Ultimately, Production I.G. was able to get enough subcontractors on board with a fully digital workflow with one exception: timesheets used for timing out the drawings and making indications for in-betweens, camera movements, and other technical information. This became the only paper in Sol Levante’s entire pipeline.

Final color grading is not usually part of the finishing process for anime, but for Sol Levante the animators worked with a 10,000 nit image container (PQ) yet displayed it on a 1000 nit monitor, so a “trim” pass was necessary to finalize the visible range and look. During the grading session, the colorist and director discovered opportunities to enhance the final anime by changing some initial color choices and allowing elements to stand out from the background. For example, the colorist adjusted the color of the lightning on one frame to make it stand out more, and added film grain on the volcano eruption to give it more texture.

Since the full range of PQ was utilized in production, the colorist had more freedom and “headroom” to adjust during grading, and the archived project has greater flexibility for remastering in the future. While relying on original color is traditional, this showed Production I.G. that there are more creative decisions that can be made throughout the pipeline.

One of the director’s greatest learnings throughout the entire production was that the studio in charge really needs to take the lead and provide a fixed workflow and tools to the subcontractors instead of endless options. Things can’t change unless big studios team up with manufacturers to push the transition to digital.

The Sound of Anime: Immersive Audio

Unique to the world of anime is a soundscape unlike any other content type. Music and sound are critical to a storytelling experience, and Sol Levante was the perfect opportunity to showcase this in an experience that blended immersive audio with the experiment of 4K and HDR in anime. Our team believes immersive sound mixing is the natural next step in the evolution of audio because of what it brings to the quality and creative opportunity of a story. Blending 4K, HDR, and immersive audio would make Akira’s world truly alive. And it could be done while using all the same tools mixers are already used to using.

Mixing in Dolby Atmos, sound mixer Will Files and sound designer Matt Yocum collaborated with director Akira to create the sound of her world. Getting involved early in the process while animations were still being completed, Haruka helped to translate Akira’s ideas from Japanese to English while maintaining the creative nuance and meaning.

In one instance, Matt added a raven sound behind the shot of hundreds of birds flying upward, and received feedback from Akira to try a sound from a bird native to Japan instead. Matt created something brand new from the native bird, developing an effect that wouldn’t have existed without this global collaboration.

Using Dolby Atmos inside Pro Tools, Will brought contrast to the sound mix and wove in composer Emily Rice’s original orchestral score which had been recorded on a Schoeps ORTF 3D microphone during the scoring session. By moving sounds around the room, to the ceiling and the floor and back again, the sound and music tell the drama of Sol Levante without dialog.

Immersive audio mixing is still a new concept for many mixers, including those in Japan where there aren’t yet enough updated rooms to support playback across many shows. However, mixing in Dolby Atmos allows the creative team to create one single mix that can be used to derive all others, from 7.1,5.1 to Stereo, which makes it an ideal archival format, and a great way to bring a new dimension to anime.

Sound Supervisor and Re-recording Mixer Will Files working with Dolby Atmos

The Future of Anime Production: What’s Next?

The gorgeous world of Sol Levante was a culmination of art, technology, and curiosity. Given all that we’ve learned in this two year collaboration with Production I.G., we want to start a conversation with animators and creatives about evolving technologies, partner with manufacturers to better support the anime industry, and work with anime studios to apply our findings to their productions. In order to help the industry better understand 4K HDR and immersive audio in anime, we’ve released raw materials used in Sol Levante for download and experimentation. Subscribers can watch Sol Levante on Netflix today. It’s best enjoyed on an HDR configured device with a premium subscription.

(From Left) Production I.G.’s Katsushi Eda, Miho Tanaka, Akira Saitoh, Hisashi Ezura, Masakazu Morinaka

Director Akira Saitoh told us that “4K HDR is like getting wings and an engine to see a new horizon where a new era is rising. We keep challenging ourselves and being innovative for the future.” There have been many challenges for this project, but Akira believes 4K HDR is the only way for them to continue being a top runner of content creation.

However, the current reality is that these technical challenges do persist, especially for moving from HD to 4K. We encourage creatives to push the boundaries of resolution to serve their story. We want to create content in the format that viewers will be consuming it, and we want that content to look great for as long as possible. But we can’t ignore the fact that for anime, the tools and equipment are still not prepared for a 4K workflow without a major overhaul. There is more to do and learn, and the Creative Technologies team is engaging with software and hardware manufacturers to share these learnings and try to accelerate improvement in the industry.

For HDR, the adjustment is much easier because the challenges are simpler to solve. There are already software manufacturers making changes to account for the issues faced on Sol Levante, like the color picker’s different visual representation across monitors and a searingly bright UI. The biggest hurdle that remains across the industry is the lack of affordable HDR monitors. After all, even with an HDR color picker, you need the monitor to see what color you are picking. Once they become more plentiful, it’s only a matter of time before HDR is common in anime.

“At the end, who doesn’t want a bigger house?”

This is what animator Hisashi Ezura told us about working in HDR, and the analogy made Haruka laugh because the Japanese are well known for living in small apartments and always wanting to have a big house — but it’s a dream. For him, this dream came true for his work. And now that he can achieve things he never thought possible by using HDR, he’ll never go back.

In Italian, Sol Levante means “sun rising from east”, a metaphor for Japan. Akira chose this title because to her, the theme of the project was the beginning — the beginning of something new for Japan’s animators. As the last shot in the film is the dawn, so too is this the dawn of new creative technology for anime!

[Download the image and sound assets for Sol Levante including TIFF sequence and IMF, selected After Effects projects, ProTools sessions, animatic and storyboard, and more.]