"I look at Ryan and I really do see the potential that I can really be crazy about him," Methuen says in an exclusive clip

Are Married at First Sight's Ryan Ranellone and Jaclyn Methuen Ready to Consummate Their Marriage?

They say first impressions are everything, but that luckily wasn’t the case for Married at First Sight‘s Ryan Ranellone and Jaclyn Methuen.

The two currently star on the second season of the social experiment show, in which a couple is paired together by a group of experts and meet for the first time as they walk down the aisle to say “I do.”

Get push notifications with news, features and more.

“We’re not essentially a couple. Legally we are, but emotionally we’re still strangers,” Ranellone’s new wife Methuen said after tying the knot. “I was expecting to be a little bit more attracted. I don’t look into his eyes and see my husband right now. This feels like a huge mistake.”

RELATED: Meet the Six Singles Who Got Married at First Sight!

While she seemed determined to keep her new husband in the friend zone, in a clip shared exclusively with PEOPLE, Methuen appears to have had a change of heart after a few weeks of marriage.

In fact, Ranellone brings up the idea of possibly consummating their union to his giggling wife, who now admits she has the potential “to really be crazy about him.”