Before rolling your eyes at the sight of Jones on this list, you might want to Google some of his highlights from his days as a Mountaineer. The oft-troubled defender was one of the most spectacular playmakers in the country as a cornerback/return specialist. Jones earned Big East Special Teams Player of the Year honors (2004) and dotted All-American lists as a two-position playmaker (cornerback and kick returner). Although Jones' diminutive dimensions made some skeptics question his ability to be a CB1, the big-play specialist flashed impressive skills as a young player until his off-field issues forced him off the field due to a league-imposed suspension. To his credit, he bounced back to eventually lead the league in kickoff return average (31.3 yards, 2014) and earn Pro Bowl recognition (2015) as a corner. But Jones' epic emotional meltdowns (see playoff games from the 2015 season) and questionable off-field behavior prevented the West Virginia standout from fully maximizing his potential as a two-phase contributor.