Story highlights 12-year-old Autumn Pasquale went missing Saturday

Her body was found Monday in a recycling container

Brothers, 15 and 17, were charged with murder in her death

Two teenage brothers were arrested and charged with first-degree murder in the death of Autumn Pasquale, the 12-year-old-girl found dead Monday in Clayton, New Jersey, according to authorities.

"The brothers are ages 15 and 17 years old, and both are in police custody at the present time," Gloucester County Prosecutor Sean Dalton said Tuesday, adding that the younger brother had also been charged with one count of luring.

Prosecutors say Autumn was lured to the boys' home, where they murdered her -- possibly for her BMX bike, which police found among some of the girl's belongings when they searched the site early Tuesday.

Autumn's body was found in a recycling container. Dalton said she was strangled and died from blunt-force trauma, but based on preliminary findings, there were no signs of sexual assault.

Police were aided by the suspects' mother, who contacted police because of Facebook postings, according to Dalton.

The young suspects turned themselves in, accompanied by their attorneys, Tuesday.

"We're strongly considering waiving them to adult court. However, we want to let the process take its part," Dalton said.

In New Jersey, authorities are not permitted to release the names of juveniles charged with a crime.

A Facebook page was created after Autumn went missing Saturday, and many neighbors and friends donated their time to help 200 law enforcement members search for her.

She was last seen riding her bike from her home, according to the Gloucester County Prosecutor's Office.

Neighbor Joyce Fisher described to CNN affiliate News 12 New Jersey how she felt after volunteering and handing out fliers for the search effort, only to find out that those accused live just across the street.

"I'm exhausted," she said, and was especially unnerved when she saw investigators bring the girl's bike out of the suspects' house.

"Scared ... devastating ... unnerving. Nice quiet town. We know everybody's move around here. We never had any issues like this," she said. "Everything is shattered."

"At this point, we have to put our anger aside," Dalton said. "We have to let justice take its course and through the support of all the caring families in Clayton, with the support of the law enforcement community. ... We'll get past this, because we are strong."

Pasquale would have celebrated her 13th birthday next week.