There is only one explanation for David Bowie: He was actually a wizard who attended Hogwarts.

Observe:

David Bowie was born in 1947 in Brixton, South London. According to your average (muggle) history books, he attended Stockwell Infants School, then Burnt Ash Junior School, and then ended up at Bromley Technical High School following his eleven-plus exams in 1958. While Bowie was reportedly in a band as early as the age of fifteen, his career as a musician didn’t truly begin until 1967, when he began releasing singles with a slew of different bands that he joined and then departed. He then proceeded to become one of the most widely acclaimed rock stars of the 20th century, whose penchant for reinventing himself was nothing short of magical.

I have a theory. Hogwarts is real. David Bowie attended it. And he’s one of the few graduates to achieve such marvelous success outside of the wizarding world.

Okay it’s more of a joke than a theory, but then you start thinking about it…

Being born in London, England means that he certainly would have been eligible for a Hogwarts education. He also would have been born after all the mess with Grindelwald and Dumbledore fighting while World War II was ablaze. This means that he would have potentially attended Hogwarts from 1958-1965, roughly two school generations removed from Harry’s parents. Interestingly enough, here is a description of Bromley Technical from Bowie’s biographer Christopher Stanford:

Despite its status it was, by the time David arrived in 1958, as rich in arcane ritual as any [English] public school. There were houses, named after eighteenth-century statesmen like Pitt and Wilberforce. There was a uniform, and an elaborate system of rewards and punishments.

That… sounds like Hogwarts. Of course, that in and of itself is not remarkable—Hogwarts was based on the structure of boarding schools in England. But it was apparently a strange thing for a technical high school (being state-funded rather than privately owned) to carry these traits. So perhaps that whole thing was just a quick cover for the sake of a biography, and David Bowie was not going to Bromley Technical at all. Instead, he got his Hogwarts letter, and headed off to Scotland with all the other magic kids.

You should also know that Peter Frampton went to Bromley a few years behind Bowie, and his dad was an art teacher there. (If you think I am suggesting that this school was an elaborate front, and that Peter Frampton was also a wizard and that his dad taught magic choir at Hogwarts, you are correct, I am saying that exact thing.)

Emily, you reply, voice full of patience. This is not anywhere near enough evidence to suggest that David Bowie was a wizard. We’re pretty sure we would have heard something to that effect if he were doing concerts for muggle and magic folk alike. Plus, his name is pretty distinctive.

Ah, but what if it wasn’t always?

Because Bowie wasn’t the man’s original name. In fact, his given name was David Jones, a name he decided to change when it kept getting confused with Davy Jones of The Monkees (apparently, no one thought to confuse him with Davy Jones of sea legend, which seems remiss). And Jones is a name that wizards know quite well:

Hestia Jones: A bonafide member of the Order of the Phoenix.

Gwenog Jones: Captain of the Holyhead Harpies

Megan Jones: A half-blood Hufflepuff in Harry’s year at Hogwarts.

Jones is a very common British surname, and so it would seem to be a fairly common wizarding surname at well. Even with longstanding wizarding lineage, Bowie could have easily been a half-blood with plenty of muggle family members, making sense of why he might have continued to straddle the line between both worlds professionally.

If he’s a member of the same family that little Megan is (maybe a cousin’s kid?), then there’s a good chance that he was also a Hufflepuff. Although, frankly, he was probably an epic hat-stall during the Sorting: the tenacity of Gryffindor, the curiosity of Ravenclaw, the ambition of Slytherin, the ability to work with many different types of people like a Hufflepuff.

Either way, this wizarding education might help to explain a few of Bowie’s early career decisions—the muggles thought it was all about messing with gender norms when the cover of The Man Who Sold the World featured Bowie with long hair wearing a frock, but some of the more isolated wizards clearly only wear robes (sans trousers) in their day-to-day activities.

So for Bowie it was probably just normal, and the reactions he got among non-magic folk were baffling, to say the least. From there, he moved on to space-age wear, seeing as it went with the concept of his concept album. It’s a safe bet that the magic community was baffled by those first few records… with references to things like space and Khalil Gibran (wait no, he was probably a wizard too) and drive-ins and cigarettes. His band was called Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars (Wait, but what if Aragog’s species did originate on Mars? What if all spiders come from Mars and wizards are the only ones who know it?) and even for a world full of whomping willows and paintings that talk, Bowie’s music must have seemed like something truly unique, truly mind-blowing.

Of course, you all know what this means: Sirius Black was a huge fan.

Think: The Marauders were at Hogwarts from 1971 to 1978, the perfect Bowie-window for impressionable young minds. Ziggy Stardust and Aladdin Sane, Station to Station, the Berlin trilogy were all happening in that period. A rock star from their alma matar who was doing brand new things by both wizarding and muggle standards would appeal to them, and Sirius would be the most likely to glom onto him as yet another way of upsetting his pureblood family. This means that Sirius Black wore glitter and jumpsuits on Halloween and was probably the worst Bowie karaoke singer at your local bar. (The Hog’s Head Inn?) James Potter probably loved this.

David Bowie’s “chameleon” capabilities could also point to metamorphmagus talents! As a performer, he seemed to have no difficulty becoming someone else entirely, and if you can already do that on a magical level, doing it on a more mundane one probably isn’t such a big deal. Oh, and then he married Iman! Who is definitely a wizard. (Did she go to Uagadou? Was she an exchange student at Beauxbaton? Is she part-veela, like Fleur Delacour? Probably all of the above and more?)

During the second war against Voldemort, Bowie was in an industrial rock phase that makes even more sense if you account for the turmoil going on in the wizarding world. His albums 1. Outside and Earthling could have served as veiled commentaries on what was going on at the time. The title track of Earthling contains words about fear and “Earthlings on fire.” The song “Battle for Britain” (telling enough title as it is) contains the lyrics:

Don’t be so forlorn,

it’s just the payoff

It’s the rain before the storm

Don’t you let my letter get you down

Don’t you

When asked what the song was actually in reference to, Bowie reportedly said that he had no intention of explaining what event inspired the lyrics. So the whole thing could be read as a shoutout to bolster magic folk while the war raged on. It seems like the sort of song that Lee Jordan would blast on their resistance radio station, for sure. Hell, there’s a song called “Dead Man Walking,” which reads like an autobiographical account… but what if it was meant to be a song about Albus Dumbledore’s final months? He was a effectively a dead man walking for Harry’s entire sixth year.

Look, I am just saying there are a lot of metaphors available here and none of them are telling me that David Bowie is not a wizard, so that probably means that he is one.

Duncan Jones, his son, is a film director with a couple of interesting movies under his belt, including Moon and Warcraft. So the real question is… did he also inherit magic genes? Or is he a squib who channeled his talents elsewhere? (The latter is a nice thought, since all squibs can’t be as bitter and disturbing as Argus Filch.) Alexandria, his daughter with Iman, is probably in her last year at Hogwarts right now, though—so look out, world.

The point is that I am very certain that David Bowie went to Hogwarts because it is too much fun to think about and we should all agree that this is our reality from now on. For the good of magic and music… which are essentially the same thing anyhow.

Emmet Asher-Perrin does not spend her afternoons thinking of all the ways to place David Bowie into every story she’s ever read, so stop saying she does that. You can bug her on Twitter and Tumblr, and read more of her work here and elsewhere.