While in the midst of my 15th boss fight in Sword Art Online: Lost Song

see deal Sword Art Online: Lost Song - PlayStation 4 $19.99 on Gamestop

Loading

Watch 7 minutes of Sword Art Online gameplay above.

Like the entertaining Sword Art Online anime, Lost Song takes place in a fictional fantasy MMO called Alfheim Online, where you can take to the skies and battle monster hordes or duel with non-playable characters. In other words, the core mechanics are all about fight and flight, both of which are done well thanks to easy and intuitive controls. It takes just a couple of quick taps on the d-pad’s up arrow to elevate into the sky (tap down twice to land), and the flight camera is dependable, though I sometimes got disorientated from having to quickly spin the camera around while fighting more agile winged enemies. Combat moves are as simple as holding down the R1 button and tapping on the face buttons or d-pad to quickly switch between sword skills and magic attacks. Combined with a block and dodge action, I quickly fell into an overly comfortable rhythm of slash, dash, blast, block, and dodge over the course of the 20-hour single-player adventure.

“ At first it was all brainless fun.

For The Birds

At first it was all brainless fun: I gleefully wrecked skeletons and griffons on the battlefield and in the air. I loved owning hostile NPCs in one-on-one duels. I enjoyed gliding through the clouds and smashing strange, batlike creatures. Sometimes I was just happy to take in the view from atop a floating island. The graphics aren’t exactly cutting edge, but looking down on monsters and NPCs from above was a refreshing perspective. 28 IMAGES

“ There’s no real sport in standing in a corner and sniping a dragon with fireballs and ice arrows.

Even flying got to be a snooze, due to an annoying “altitude limit” placed on my heroes for the first half of the story. It was only when I completed a later quest and the ban was finally lifted that I felt a real sense of joy gliding over sunny meadows and frozen tundras, but that wasn’t enough to make the campaign worth sticking around for.

A Tedious Tale

Lost Song presents Sword Art Online fans with an original story not found in the series, but it’s not that great. It retcons the awful second story arc in the Sword Art Online anime, but instead of replacing it with something exciting and meaningful it presents us with….well, nothing really. There’s a mystery involving a group known as Shamrock and their adorable leader Seven, but since there’s no real reason for Kirito and his group to get involved in their affairs, unravelling the mystery is pretty dull. On top of that, the story makes no effort to properly introduce any of the characters, so if I hadn’t already been familiar with Sword Art Online, I might have been massively confused about who these people were were and how they were all connected.

[poilib element="quoteBox"parameters="excerpt=The%20story%20makes%20no%20effort%20to%20properly%20introduce%20any%20of%20the%20characters."]

It’s pretty clear that Lost Song is aimed at hardcore SAO fans, which is why I was disappointed with the lack of fun fan-pleasing moments. Interactions between Kirito and his friends are limited to short cutscenes consisting of little more than awkward flirting. These moments might be amusing if the dialogue was cute or witty, but the humor is so flat and the dialogue so forgettable that towards the end I started jamming on the fastforward button so I could move on to something else.

Loading

Watch the Story Trailer above.

“ I found it easier to just stick with a small handful of team members.

Lost Song’s saving grace is its well executed multiplayer. It allows you to team up with up to three other people in co-op or versus mode and is easily accessible via the town inn. I had no trouble connecting online and syncing up with other Sword Art Online fans, and I enjoyed coordinating attacks against rock monsters and harpies in co-op mode. Plus, I got a real kick out of testing my skills against other players in one-on-one duels – it puts the combat system to much better use, since humans aren’t nearly as predictable as Lost Song’s repetitive enemies.