Kaohsiung has Chinese cameras: NPP

NO KNOWLEDGE? A city official said that it had bought the cameras before the Executive Yuan issued a ban on Hikvision and it would remove them if so directed

By Ke Yu-hao, Chang Chin-ya and Jonathan Chin / Staff reporters, with staff writer





Kaohsiung City Government-issued security cameras for city councilors were made by a Chinese company banned by the Executive Yuan as a cybersecurity risk, New Power Party (NPP) Kaohsiung City Councilor Huang Jie (黃捷) said yesterday.

Hangzhou Hikvision Digital Technology Co is one of the Chinese technology companies whose products the Executive Yuan blacklisted last year, but the Beijing-backed company has supplied cameras to the council as part of a municipal contract, Huang said.

Huang’s remarks came a day after Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Taichung city councilors Chiang Chao-kuo (江肇國) and Huang Shou-ta (黃守達) said that Hikvision also made many of the security cameras installed in underpasses in Taichung.

A surveillance camera is pictured outside Kaohsiung City Councilor Chen Chih-chung’s office in the city’s Cianjhen District yesterday. Photo copied by Ko Yu-hao, Taipei Times

Huang Jie said she raised the issue with DPP Councilor Lin Yu-kai (林于凱) at a council session this year, but to no avail.

Hikvision cameras were awarded numerous contracts prior to the ban due to their low cost, she said.

However, Washington has moved to ban the company’s products from next month, with the US National Defense Authorization Act citing security reasons, she said.

DPP Kaohsiung City Councilor Chen Chih-chung (陳致中) said that four security cameras issued by the city and installed at his district office are Hikvision products.

The firm’s products are reportedly used by Beijing to monitor Muslim minorities at camps in China’s Xinjiang region.

The cameras in the district office could have given Chinese officials complete access to his activities, Chen said, adding: “The spread of ‘red’ surveillance is a danger to the right to privacy of Taiwanese and national security at every level.”

Kaohsiung Mayor Han Kuo-yu (韓國瑜) said that the city has no knowledge of owning Hikvision surveillance devices.

However, a Kaohsiung City Council official said that it had bought Chinese cameras before the Executive Yuan issued the ban, adding that the council would comply if the central government orders their removal.

The Taichung Construction Bureau said that Chinese-made security cameras would be removed from city underpasses.

The Taichung City Government is in the process of verifying the maker of its security cameras and 136 Hikvision units have been found so far, the bureau said, adding that one vehicle and nine pedestrian underpasses have been inspected, with 10 remaining.

Contractors that sold Hikvision cameras to Taichung are expected to supply replacements to the city free of charge, the bureau said, adding that it aims to phase out the blacklisted devices within a week.

The city did not realize banned cameras were used, because the contract delivery assessment process only checked the cameras for function, not place of manufacture, the bureau said.

Orders for Taiwan-made security cameras have soared after reports about Hikvision emerged, an industry insider said on condition of anonymity.

Requests to replace security cameras came mostly from high-income households, the source said, adding that one client placed an order for 30 cameras.

Requests to replace security cameras came mostly from people who live in mansions, but also some who use Hikvision cameras at their factories, the source said.

“The client is in the manufacturing sector and owns factories in Taiwan and China, so they are worried about personal privacy and the proprietary technologies of their business,” they said.

Using Chinese security cameras or surveillance systems has inherent risks, as Chinese companies are known to install backdoors in firmware, allowing third-party access to information on connected devices, the source said.

The Taiwanese security technology sector needs to develop facial recognition and biometric algorithms to remain competitive with China, they said.

Additional reporting by Huang Chung-shan and Hsu Kuo-chen