FLORHAM PARK, N.J. -- The New York Jets love drama. Now there's suspense, too.

After a night to contemplate the most important decision of his head-coaching career, Rex Ryan decided he needs more time before naming a starting quarterback.

Ryan declined to reveal his choice Monday, one day after he sparked a full-blown controversy by benching Mark Sanchez for the first time in his career.

The choice likely comes down between Sanchez and Greg McElroy, who rallied the team to a 7-6 win over the Arizona Cardinals.

Tim Tebow has been sidelined with a rib injury and thus is an unlikely option but his presence creates a three-ring quarterback circus for the Jets.

"I've got three quarterbacks I feel good about," Ryan said. "I think we're in a lot better situation than probably a lot of teams."

Cynics might snicker at that remark, but there's no doubt they have the most complicated quarterback situation.

Ryan refused to say if he's leaning in one direction, insisting he will have an "open discussion" with his staff. He likely will announce his choice Wednesday, admitting that he'd like to keep their next opponent, the Jacksonville Jaguars, in the dark as long as possible.