I received a box that had inside a four-pack of Pepperidge Farms Mint Millano cookies! I've never tried this type of cookie before, but I absolutely love them!! They're just so good :) There was also a note inside that said the other part of my gift was on its way also. I can't wait! This was my first exchange, and I want to thank /u/SterlingArcherr for the great cookies! Can't wait to see what the other thing he sent me is!

UPDATE: So, about two weeks ago I received a package with an odd-looking utensil in it, without any other note or explanation. I had no clue whatsoever what it was, and it puzzled me. My dad and I have the same name and sometimes I receive his mail, so I thought it may have been some sort of tool he had ordered that the post office redirected to me. So the next day I went to his house and gave it to him, saying "I received this in the mail but I didn't order this; I don't know what it is but it must be yours". He took a look at it and likewise was puzzled as to what it was. "I don't know what it is either," he replied, "but thanks".

A few days ago, I was browsing the front page of Reddit when I saw that someone had posted a video called "baby vs. scalp massager". In the video, the father uses a utensil that looks identical to the one I received in the mail on the head of his child. It was in that moment that I realized it must have been the other part of the gift that I was expecting, and I didn't even realize it until I had given it away. Then I was disappointed in myself, because a scalp massager sounds completely awesome! I'm going to go ask my dad if he still has it, and if so I will show him what it does. Unfortunately, I didn't take a picture of it, but I should have. Thank you so much for that awesome gift! And if my dad still has it I will be sure to enjoy it too!