ASIO cover-up: Previously suppressed information reveals South Korean spies sought "to obtain sensitive information" on trade deals between Seoul and Canberra. The revelation of economic espionage is embarrassing to Seoul and Canberra as Australia has strongly backed South Korea in its stand-off with North Korea. Last month Australian troops took part in joint military exercises with South Korea and the United States for the first time. Although engaged in what ASIO described as "inappropriate activities" harmful to Australia's interests, no South Korean spies have been expelled from Australia. Instead, in an effort to maintain good relations with the NIS, ASIO took legal action to prevent disclosure of the incident and protect the identities of the South Korean agents so they might continue their clandestine careers. In mid-2010 ASIO learnt Dr Kim had been meeting a South Korean diplomat declared to the Australian government as an NIS liaison officer. Dr Kim, the principal author of an ABARES study of the Korean beef market, had taken part in free trade agreement negotiations between Australia and South Korea in December 2009. ASIO officers interviewed Dr Kim in October 2010. On September 15, 2011, ASIO director-general David Irvine issued an adverse security assessment of Dr Kim "after finding that he had had contact with successive NIS officers who he had not reported as required by Australian government policy".

ASIO alleged Dr Kim had been involved in clandestine contact with and provided sensitive information to an NIS officer, South Korean embassy minister-counsellor Hoo-Young Park. ASIO determined that Dr Kim had been "successfully cultivated" by the NIS; that he had been "deceptive" in his responses to questioning; and there was a "specific threat" to Australian government information. ASIO recommended his secret-level security clearance be revoked, effectively ending his career as a public servant. Dr Kim has said his contact with South Korean diplomats was purely social and any discussion of trade issues was confined to publicly available information. However the Administrative Appeals Tribunal upheld ASIO's adverse security assessment last August. Dr Kim appealed against the decision to the Federal Court. The court proceedings revealed that ASIO had raised its security concerns with the NIS and believed the South Korean agency's ''inappropriate'' activities in Australia had ceased. The South Koreans requested ASIO "do all in its power" to prevent public disclosure of the NIS activities and the identities of officers.

In an affidavit submitted to the court, Mr Irvine warned that any disclosure of the NIS activities would have a "detrimental impact" on relations between Australia and South Korea, including with regard to security co-operation. Dr Kim's lawyers argued ASIO was seeking to avoid embarrassment for the NIS and it was not clear why that was necessary for national security. Justice Lindsay Foster agreed and ruled that keeping the information secret could not be justified. The court has now released information about the case, including the identities of four NIS officers who have served under diplomatic cover in Canberra. Aside from Mr Park, they are minister-counsellors Bum-Yeon Lee and Sa-Yong Hong and a diplomat also named Kim, who was in Australia for a short time. Dr Kim, through his lawyers, declined to speak about his circumstances. The South Korean embassy declined to comment. Loading

A spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade affirmed "the long-standing practice of Australian governments not to comment on intelligence matters." Follow the National Times on Twitter