A liquid liner pen may be your usual go-to for a cat-eye, but try a brush this time, so you can really get as close and into your lash line as possible. Yumi opted for a gel liner with a thin firm angled liner brush for more control over the line contour. Paint your liner all over the lid, hugging your lash line with the brush. This way, your liner is visible on open and closed lids. Extend that line beyond the outer corner into a point, as well as the inner corner, forming a pointed tip to visually elongate a smaller eye shape.

Try Bobbi Brown's Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner in Cobalt Ink ($27) because its formula can withstand the oiliest eyelids and it's got one of the smoothest strokes in the game.