Modigliani Wingtip Oxford is rated 2.7 out of 5 by 6 .

Rated 5 out of 5 by World Traveller from First Perfect True to Size 9EEE Fits true to size in 9EEE classic fit. When people mention the finish coming off, I wonder if they know the difference between Vegetable Tan vs Chrome Tan. Natural tanning creates a leather that is not as durable. It's more "premium", artisan and hand made, it requires more maintenance. The durability of the finish appears on par with other Veggie Tan products I own (admittedly this is the first Veggie Tan pair of shoes I own).

Rated 1 out of 5 by Caseyjonesbklyn from Finish comes off These are fairly new. Polished only a couple of times. Finish is completely falling off the crease areas on the vamp. Very poorly made shoe.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Jared A. from Exceptional IF on Sale and You Love Patina TLDR: You'll probably love these if you buy them, ON SALE, wanting a shoe that quickly looks weathered/patina-ed/kinda' beat up. THE BAD: These are NOT typical $495 Allen Edmond's shoes and do not live up to the company's history or expected quality. You'll be disappointed if you buy them as such. The leather practically bleeds its polish if the room is humid. They were a great dark brown out of the box. I moisturized them when brand new and my hands got stained brown. The leather is a light tan, almost white color, underneath and I expect they'll get scratched up very easily. I live in the San Francisco Bay Area where hoodies and flip flops are a mark of success. If you're not in real estate or finance, nice shoes stand out against the sea of running shoes and sandals. So, these will be awesome to wear with a worn-in/beat up/patina. They're perfect for a "nice shoes" worn casually look. THE GOOD: If you can get them on sale, they're an AWESOME $125 dollar alternate to wearing sneakers or department store disposables. The style and sole seem up to Allen Edmond's standard so that's good. They're breaking in well so I expect them to be comfortable too. True to size and width. BIG thanks to previous reviewers! Your advice helped me buy these with the right expectations for what they are.