Grade: B+

Tasting Notes: Halo Top’s seasonal flavor is exactly what you need to get into the fall spirit. It tastes like a pumpkin pie that’s been sitting in the refrigerator from the night before (leftover pie is the best kind of pie, in our opinions). But the texture is really what won our editors over—you can taste the crust in every bite.

Want to taste it for yourself? Buy it! icecreamsource.com