When New Girl returns on April 30, they're bringing a real treat with 'em: a flashback episode focusing on how each of the gang lost their virginity. And knowing these guys, none of the stories will involve a smoothly planned, ultra-romantic, happily memorable first time. Well, maybe Cece's. But definitely not anybody else. Nick, in particular, is at a serious disadvantage, due to his hair. Just check out how they looked then:

Aw, look at these two innocent doves and with their sweet high ponies and deep feathered side parts.

Yep. These look like virgins to me.

Cece ready for a night on the town is my absolute favorite. She couldn't look bad if she tried, but I love this overdone vibe since we're always seeing her in maddeningly natural-gorgeous mode:

Since I've been pining for more college Nick since the whole Big Guy foot-rub scene, I'm extremely happy to see him and his ill-advised long locks. What's actually happening in this dorm room, though—that I'm a little scared to find out.

Whose throwback look do you love the most?

Photo: FOX