...RWBY's not written that well to begin with. if i can draw a conclusion from watching Dead fantasy. Monty had a specific way of telling stories which was action driven.

I read Shane's letter and i agree with everything he said; especially when he stated the first four trailers, vols 1-2 is Monty's Rwby. we don't know what Mony had plane for his show and since somewhere in the letter Shane said Monty wanted to leave Rooster Teeth. To find somewhere else and taking some animators with him to continuing making RWBY, we won't know what was really suppose to happen. Heck he even said that this Winter was not the Winter Monty had came up with.



As for making things up i think what drives most of the fans to do that is because they are becoming more aware that RWBY is missing a lot of detail. They are asking questions that shouldn't be asking, the show just conjures up more questions than answers for them( so i think that's just frustrates them.)

What i believe the problem is...that i don't think the writers understand the value basic human behavior, cause and effect and the like. i'm not saying the characters need to believe able, as far being normal .But i'm saying if their going to turn RWBY from this absurd show from hyper fighting to serious issues they have to face. make it look like it effects them in way that is understandable to us and give it some flavor. explain like how Naruto is(i know its along series and a lot of people grown out of it, but hear me out) in Naruto you can tell when something happens they act and respond in way that is believe able.

But in RWBY they only respond because PLOT and forget what that thing that happen and bring it up much later because of PLOT and don't allow themselves to just sit down think about it and heal from it.

however, you're an Emerald fan right so i'll give you these example.



in vol-2 Emerald tells Mercury to shut his stupid mouth and she would pay him to do so. the Fandoms reaction to that...

FANDOM: OMG, they'er so perfect let's ship em together.

Miles and Kerry reaction to what they did: Lets do nothing about these two who really aren't suppose to like each other to much much later. mm..maybe in RWBY Chibi we'll go in to it.

My reaction: one day i'm going to draw you to fighting like Cat's and Dog's and i'm going to make fun of the ship so hard.

Or how about that time when for some godawful reason Mercury open his mouth and said

Mercury: dahh, we'er the guys you'er suppose to be afraid of, herp derp.

for some reason they made Emerald smirk at that comment, no offence who think Emerald should be evil. I see her as neutral and she only there for Cinder, but really she should of just looked at Mercury and said.

Emerald:....why, do you even try Mercury?

Any poor Cinder, first she loses her good looks, then she gets no back story, then she is stuck at the bottom of vault somewhere.