Now that the nationwide talent search is over for Season 13 of America’s Got Talent, the first round of eliminations has begun filming and the judges — Simon Cowell, Heidi Klum, Mel B and Howie Mandel — and host Tyra Banks walked the red carpet at the Pasadena Civic Auditorium on Monday afternoon to talk about what fans can expect.

What was surprising is that the majority of the judges have already found their Golden Buzzer contestant.

“I did mine Day 1,” Cowell says. “He is an extraordinary guy. You’ll see the story. Great talent. Great story. Fantastic. That is why I like doing the Golden Buzzers. I think the best one though is Tyra’s. I won’t tell you much about it, but they flew in 6,000 miles. It is one of the most extraordinary things I have ever seen. Extraordinary. I mean amazing.”

But when Banks was asked to spill the beans a little more on her choice, she kept mum, simply saying, “They are not a singer.”

Banks, of course, also didn’t pick a singer for her Golden Buzzer last season, which was her first season as host of the show. Her act of choice was dance troupe Light Balance, which went on to place third behind winner Darci Lynne and second place Angelica Hale.

Klum was a little more forthcoming, saying she found the most amazing, talented superstar.

“Either she’s going to win this show, and if she doesn’t, I think she’s definitely going to go places,” the Project Runway producer and host says. “She’s 15 years old and she’s a singer. She has the total package. She projects to the people in a way as if she’s done it ten years already. A lot of younger people, they’re still very introverted when they’re on the stage. They kind of sing more to themselves, and they don’t really project to the audience and play with them. It’s part of entertaining when you’re a singer. Most singers have to do that. They strut down and play with the audience, play with the cameras. At 15 years old, she did all of that already. I was pretty impressed, and her voice was incredible. So the looks, the way she moves, the voice, everything was there. So boom, my hand went straight for that Golden Buzzer before anyone else did.”

As the judging panel’s reigning comic, one would think that Mandel would make sure to hit his buzzer for a comedian. And even though he says that several of his top acts this season are comedic acts, he has yet to hit his buzzer.

“I think I am being more discerning than I have ever been,” Mandel tells Parade.com. “Because I don’t know what it is that I’m looking for. For me, it has to fire on so many different levels, so many different boxes. You can’t just sound good. You can’t just look good. You can’t just do it good. Who are you also? All these things have to come together. It’s like love. You say, what are you looking for? That’s why people have such a hard time on Tinder. I’m on Talent Tinder.”

America’s Got Talent returns for its 13th season on May 29 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on NBC.