Darren Criss surprised fans recently with an impromptu performance at the NYC gay piano bar Marie’s Crisis. The Glee star played the piano while singing “A Whole New World” from Aladdin with Tony-winner Lea Salonga, who provided the singing voice of Jasmine in the original 1992 Disney film.

Criss made his Broadway debut last year in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying. With the end of Glee near, may we suggest another musical he could step into? He already knows the words to at least one song!