0614 PA8171 Victory Gardens

plus-circle Add Review

comment Reviews

Reviewer: Phil79 - favorite favorite favorite favorite - June 14, 2011

Subject: Sign of the Times This is an amazing video for the times. We planted front yards parking areas, and back yards. My Dad tells me that he got tired of eating tomato soup for every lunch. I think that we need to temper this need to grow and overuse of pesticides with todays want to grow organic movement...but it is hard work. - June 14, 2011Sign of the Times

Reviewer: ADCarter1 - favorite favorite favorite favorite - March 6, 2010

Subject: The 1940s Garden I happen to live in "Northern Maryland" and this property looks a lot like my neighborhood. I have never tried to plant an early crop and a late one, but I'm having a hard time believing in two potato crops in one season in Northern Maryland, not to mention the lettuce that never seems to bolt. And Good Lord! This family dealt with every type of disease and insect imaginable. I understand we talk a lot about organic gardening now (I myself am a practitioner) and organic/heirloom seed but I like my seed free of V,F wilts and other nasty diseases so I don't have to burn my entire garden when my tomatoes get fusarian wilt.



However, I did like the fact that the video showed all of the backbreaking labor that goes into producing a garden and gave a lot of good advice. I think a lot of people just think they can sprinkle some seed on the ground and viola! a garden will instantly appear. But the No Work, No Victory slogan was more frightening than encouraging. - March 6, 2010The 1940s Garden

Reviewer: JWilly48519 - favorite favorite favorite - April 25, 2009

Subject: Garden chemicals I'm not an anti-pesticide fanatic, but it's simply incorrect to suggest that '40s pesticides were less dangerous than modern stuff.



In the '40s, it was common to use phosphorus compounds, arsenic compounds, nicotine compounds, thallium bait, DDT and other complex organics that we now know are neurotoxins, carcinogens/mutagens, environmentally persistent/accumulative, etc. on food-bearing ground, directly on food crops and animals, or where they would be drained/washed/flushed into watercourses that later would be utilized as public water supplies, for irrigation of food-bearing ground, or for food fishing.



Modern rules and practices have made a difference, generally for the better. - April 25, 2009Garden chemicals

Reviewer: RHM94611 - favorite favorite favorite favorite favorite - April 22, 2008

Subject: Interesting Victory Garden Video So, I am 50 years old. Both of my parents lived to be in their 90's - we survived this kind of gardening just fine, chemicals and all. My father grew victory gardens during both wars, and we had a 2 acre garden year round when I was growing up. I would not be so quick to judge the chemicals used - most were far less dangerous than the "RoundUp" that homeowners use around their property for weed control today, not to mention the chemicals that commercial growers use. Organic is better, but it is FAR more labor intensive to always be vigilant over pest control - one day looking away can wipe out your whole garden. - April 22, 2008Interesting Victory Garden Video

Reviewer: Bill T. - favorite favorite favorite favorite - August 30, 2005

Subject: The Constant Gardener Well, at least this movie is more plausible then the the ridiculous 'Gardening' (also found on this site). A family decided to grow it's oen garden because of food rations, and just about grows everything under the sun (literally). Tomatoes! Watermelon! Corn! Collard Greens! Who on earth grows collard greens? Anyways, at least this is more indepth about how to plant these and the care it takes to cultivate these. It also shows us the many, many pests that can harm these and shows us how to deal with them (no bug stamping this time!) Very interesting. - August 30, 2005The Constant Gardener