A recent survey counted just 30 resident bats on the Philippine resort island of Boracay, down from 15,000 in 1988.

Boracay has been subject to a massive rehabilitation effort after pollution and runaway development prompted President Rodrigo Duterte to close the island to tourism for six months in 2018.

The closure does not seem to have benefited the bats, including the endemic golden-crowned flying fox (Acerodon jubatus), one of the world’s largest fruit bat species, which is classified as critically endangered on the IUCN Red List.

Bat conservationists have persistently recommended declaring the island’s remaining forest cover as critical habitats for threatened bats, but formal recognition hangs in the balance as rehabilitation efforts end this May.

BORACAY ISLAND, Philippines — The bats that swarmed Boracay’s evening skies were once as iconic as the pristine white sand beaches that made this tiny island in the central Philippines one of the country’s hottest tourist destinations.

A survey in 1988 counted 15,000 resident bats. But as tourism exploded on the island, the bat population cratered. In 2017, at the peak of the tourism boom, conservationists conducting an exit survey counted only 2,425 bats flying off the island at sunset. By March 2020, a similar survey found numbers were down to a startling 30 bats.

The figure is extreme,” says Julia Lervik, president of Friends of the Flying Foxes (FFF), a group of conservationists and environmentalists that has been surveying Boracay’s bats since 2004. “We barely have any bats left on the island.”

The 2020 figure is doubly alarming because it comes after the island was temporarily closed to tourism and put under an environmental rehabilitation program.

Experts point to two key factors behind the decline of Boracay’s bats, both linked to the upswing in tourist numbers: locals catch bats and sell them to both foreign and local tourists as food, and bat habitat and roosting sites have been destroyed by the fast-paced development of resorts and tourist infrastructure.

This runaway development also fouled the island’s beaches and water. By 2018, the island was declared a “cesspool” by President Rodrigo Duterte, who ordered it closed to tourism from April to October that year. During the closure, Duterte ordered the creation of the Boracay Inter-Agency Task Force (BIATF), led by the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), to oversee the island’s rehabilitation. But almost two years into the process, the situation for Boracay’s resident bats appears to have only deteriorated.

Overtourism trade-offs

Famous for its 11 kilometers (7 miles) of white sand coastline, the island is a haven for fruit bats or flying foxes, including the endemic golden-crowned flying fox (Acerodon jubatus), classified as critically endangered on the IUCN Red List; and native species like the giant fruit bat (Pteropus vampyrus), the largest fruit bat species in the world, and the small flying fox (P. hypomelanus).

Bats around the world have recently gotten a bad reputation as potential carriers of disease following the COVID-19 outbreak. But in Boracay, cave-dwelling bats are known to help reduce outbreaks by feasting on the mosquitos that spread dengue to humans.

They also help disperse fruit seeds across Boracay and nearby islands, helping keep the ecology of the province in balance.

“[Bats are] considered an important part of the island’s booming tourism industry since bats regenerate the remaining green forest of Boracay,” Lervik says. “It enhances the beauty of Boracay especially when seen in the air as tourists planes pass by. Boracay’s potable water source also comes from the forest in the mainland, which the flying foxes reforest.”

As the bat population dwindled, the numbers of mosquitoes surged and dengue cases increased, echoing a trend seen across the province of Aklan, where Boracay is situated.

In 2019 alone, 4,680 dengue cases were recorded in Aklan, more than three times the number recorded in 2018. “Several of them have been recorded in Boracay, especially in Manoc-Manoc,” says Cornelio Cuachon Jr. of the Aklan provincial health office.

“We also found several breeding grounds of mosquitoes in Boracay,” Cuachon says. In 2019, the villages of Yapak, Balabag and Manoc-Manoc were considered high-risk areas for dengue.

Dying, disappearing bats

Yapak Beach was once an important roosting site for Boracay’s bats, says FFF’s Lervik, quoting from a significant series of studies that point to the northern portion of the island as a key site for the bats. But these same sites are the ones that have borne the brunt of the tourism bane.

Some of these roosting sites fall within a private property, where a 219-room upscale resort has been built. To regularly monitor the bats, the group has to get permission from the developers.

Other island businesses have also fallen short of implementing sustainable practices in dealing with the bats. Lervik cites instances of boatmen and tourist guides bringing visitors near the roosting sites as part of their tour packages. Some private companies even offer helicopter tour packages in bat areas. It’s also common to hear of guides catching bats and making them fly for the delight of their guests.

Daily direct flights have also stressed the bats, Lervik says. “The airlines in nearby Caticlan [airport] now have sunset and sunrise flight schedules, arriving in Caticlan at exactly the time the bats fly on their way to feed in the mainland [island of Panay] and it directly impacted the bats during the sunset and its return early in the morning,” Lervik says.

The forced closure of the island, however, yielded some concrete results. Levels of coliform, or bacteria from feces, on the main beach have dropped more than a hundred-fold since April 2018. At least a dozen of resorts and residential areas that violated environmental guidelines were demolished during the closure. Other establishments that violated guidelines were closed, though the DENR has yet to publicly release the list of non-compliant establishments.

But these measures still haven’t been enough to improve the flying foxes’ population. FFF sees a turning point in this: the destruction of the bats’ mother roosting site in 2017 by Mabuhay Maritime Express (MME), a subsidiary of the country’s flagship carrier, Philippine Airlines. MME bulldozed around 70 trees within a 500-meter (1,640-foot) stretch without a permit.