Poverty is not a choice, nor is it a moral failing. I’ve long known this, growing up working class in the shadow of shuttered factories in Dayton, Ohio and coming of age in the coalfields of Eastern Kentucky. The people around me struggled – many on benefits, some without a car, at least one high school classmate without heat in her home – but still managed to pull together as a community, taking care of one another through families, churches, and civic groups. Poverty wasn’t something abstract or Dickensian. It was a fact of life.

This is a lesson Republican Congressman Jason Chaffetz appears not to have learned. Tuesday morning he appeared on CNN’s New Day to defend the Republicans’ replacement for the Affordable Care Act, popularly dubbed Trumpcare. “You know what, Americans have choices. And they’ve got to make a choice,” he said. “So maybe rather than getting that new iPhone that they just love and they want to go spend hundreds of dollars on that, maybe they should invest in their own health care.” Chaffetz later attempted to walk back his comments by saying he believes in “self-reliance”, but this conservative trope is a myth that enables poverty to continue.

Health Secretary points to smaller stack of paper to prove new healthcare bill is better than Obamacare

It is impossible to pull yourself up by your bootstraps if you have no boots on your feet. I likely wouldn’t be writing this if it wasn’t for government benefits like Pell Grants putting me through university – making me the first person in my family to transition from the underserving poor to the metropolitan elite. Yet framing poverty as an active decision is fairly typical of the right on both sides of the Atlantic, as is pointing to the luxury goods those on benefits have. This is, of course, exactly what Chaffetz aimed to do, because it diminishes the need for us to actively look at ways of helping to end the cyclical poverty that exists in places like Glasgow (both the city in Scotland and the town in Kentucky).

In the UK, Channel 5 has weaponised this myth to build a cottage industry out of “poverty porn” that shows just how “good” those on benefits supposedly have it. Shows like On Benefits and Proud and Channel 4’s controversial 2014 series Benefits Street, both about people living on the dole who happen to smoke, drink, and not be completely despondent or dejected, have been cited as evidence that it pays to be poor. Though these shows are British, these same attitudes exist in America, where the myth of the “welfare queen” – a usually Black inner-city woman who lives lavishly off benefits – was developed by Ronald Reagan in the 1980s, and that racialised picture of the undeserving poor still exists in the minds of many Americans.

This is all, to use a five dollar word, bullshit. Most Americans in poverty are rural white people, the same folks who are credited with putting Donald Trump in the White House. I doubt Chaffetz or anyone else in the GOP would call them scroungers. I wouldn’t. I call them my family.

The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Show all 9 1 /9 The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and the media White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer takes questions during the daily press briefing Getty Images The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and the Trans-Pacific Partnership Union leaders applaud US President Donald Trump for signing an executive order withdrawing the US from the Trans-Pacific Partnership negotiations during a meeting in the Roosevelt Room of the White House in Washington DC. Mr Trump issued a presidential memorandum in January announcing that the US would withdraw from the trade deal Getty The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and the Mexico wall A US Border Patrol vehicle sits waiting for illegal immigrants at a fence opening near the US-Mexico border near McAllen, Texas. The number of incoming immigrants has surged ahead of the upcoming Presidential inauguration of Donald Trump, who has pledged to build a wall along the US-Mexico border. A signature campaign promise, Mr Trump outlined his intention to build a border wall on the US-Mexico border days after taking office Getty Images The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and abortion US President Donald Trump signs an executive order as Chief of Staff Reince Priebus looks on in the Oval Office of the White House. Mr Trump reinstated a ban on American financial aide being granted to non-governmental organizations that provide abortion counseling, provide abortion referrals, or advocate for abortion access outside of the United States Getty Images The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and the Dakota Access pipeline Opponents of the Keystone XL and Dakota Access pipelines hold a rally as they protest US President Donald Trump's executive orders advancing their construction, at Columbus Circle in New York. US President Donald Trump signed executive orders reviving the construction of two controversial oil pipelines, but said the projects would be subject to renegotiation Getty Images The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and 'Obamacare' Nancy Pelosi who is the minority leader of the House of Representatives speaks beside House Democrats at an event to protect the Affordable Care Act in Los Angeles, California. US President Donald Trump's effort to make good on his campaign promise to repeal and replace the healthcare law failed when Republicans failed to get enough votes. Mr Trump has promised to revisit the matter Getty Images The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Donald Trump and 'sanctuary cities' US President Donald Trump signed an executive order in January threatening to pull funding for so-called "sanctuary cities" if they do not comply with federal immigration law AP The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and the travel ban US President Donald Trump has attempted twice to restrict travel into the United States from several predominantly Muslim countries. The first attempt, in February, was met with swift opposition from protesters who flocked to airports around the country. That travel ban was later blocked by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The second ban was blocked by a federal judge a day before it was scheduled to be implemented in mid-March SANDY HUFFAKER/AFP/Getty Images The controversial orders Donald Trump has already issued Trump and climate change US President Donald Trump sought to dismantle several of his predecessor's actions on climate change in March. His order instructed the Environmental Protection Agency to reevaluate the Clean Power Plan, which would cap power plant emissions Shannon Stapleton/Reuters

For people like Chaffetz, this is proof that the poor aren’t spending their money properly. Leaving aside that policing how people spend their money (and it is their money, not “mine as a taxpayer”) is the antithesis of small government philosophy, it’s simply not true. A US Bureau of Labor Statistics study found that there is negligible difference (within less than two percentage points) between the spending habits of those on benefits and those not for entertainment and apparel and services. However, Americans on benefits are spending 6.8 per cent and 4.4 per cent more of their annual budget on food and housing, respectively, than those who are not. These expenses account for more precisely because the poor have less.

Life in poverty is bleak enough without us judging the poor for having a luxury item like a smart phone (which, as Philip Bump points out in the Washington Post, is becoming less of a luxury and more of a necessity – especially if you don’t have internet). And it certainly shouldn’t be an impediment to get healthcare. After all, as Bump again points out, an iPhone might cost around $700, but health insurance costs hundreds a month totaling thousands a year – and that’s not counting out-of-pocket deductibles and copays.

The Republican plan Chaffetz is defending could lead six to ten million people losing healthcare. This is a national disgrace. Unlike in Britain where the National Health Service is still free at the point of access no matter how much you earn, in America being poor won’t only mean you’re supposed to have a wretched life devoid of even the smallest joys, but that your poverty should kill you, too.