After one of the worst years of hedge fund performance on record, investors are shifting to fee structures where they pay only if they see returns on their money.



Hedge funds have been dropping the once typical 2-and-20 model, in which funds charge investors 2% of assets under management fees and 20% of profits.

Investors paid hedge fund managers millions of dollars in 2018 — even though most funds posted dismal returns.

For years, most hedge funds charged investors a flat rate of 2%, known as a management fee, as well as a 20% performance fee — known as the 2-and-20 model. Hedge fund fees are typically higher than those at other types of investment funds based on the promise they'll make money even if the market is down.

But the emergence of public pressure from big investors like pension plans to lower costs — as well as several years of mediocre performance from hedge funds — has led to a rethinking of what investors should be paying for.

Sign up here for our weekly newsletter Wall Street Insider, a behind-the-scenes look at the stories dominating banking, business, and big deals.

Commonfund, a Connecticut-based manager that oversees $24.1 billion for foundations and endowments, is OK with writing big checks to hedge funds, as long as they're making money.

The investor has pushed for managers to accept a fee structure of 0-and-30 — as in no management fees whatsoever but a performance charge of 30%.

"We are trading on some of the hubris of the hedge fund managers themselves," Commonfund's CEO, Mark Anson, said at the firm's 2019 outlook breakfast in New York last week. Anson believes that confident hedge fund managers will take on this structure and view it as an opportunity to make even more money based on their investment acumen, despite a lack of reliable management fees.

"We would prefer to pay no management fee, but give them a higher incentive fee," he said.

The truth is that investors do not mind paying high fees if hedge funds are performing, Antonio DeRosa, the head of advisory at Jefferies, told attendees at Context Summits conference in Miami this past week.

Context Capital Partners, which invests in funds on behalf of family offices, has for years invested with a hedge fund manager that keeps half of the returns it generates, and investors are OK with it because the strategy has been successful, according to CIO John Culbertson.

Investors looking to trim their hedge fund fees are facing off with an industry that is coming off a tough year. Last year, performance was in the red for nearly every strategy type and launches were nearly cut in half as several industry titans closed shop or nixed strategies as they struggled to scratch out returns.

More funds were liquidated in 2018 than were launched. Shayanne Gal/Business Insider

Read more: A storm is brewing in the hedge fund industry. Here are 5 major changes coming to the industry in 2019.

According to Hedge Fund Research, only 30% of managers still use the 2-and-20 structure. The Teacher Retirement System of Texas — the biggest US pension fund in terms of hedge-fund assets — has since 2016 pushed hedge funds to accept a structure of 1% management fees and 30% performance fees, according to Brad Gilbert, the pension's senior director of hedge funds.

With a more mature industry, "now is the time to be creative" with fees, says Jon Hansen, the managing director of Cambridge Associates, who invests in hedge funds on behalf of pensions, endowments, and family offices.

On a panel at Context Summits conference, Hansen said there was "an anchor effect" early on in the hedge fund space that made new entrants to the industry feel as if they were required to charge 2-and-20 — a sentiment he has seen slip away.

Brian Goldman, who focuses on emerging managers in his role at the allocator Lanx Management, said it's "mind-boggling" when a new fund pitches a 2-and-20 structure to his team.

"That ship sailed years ago," Goldman said on the panel in Miami.

Read more: It's not enough to be 2 guys from Goldman in a room with $5 million — the bar for launching a hedge fund is rising in 2019

But emerging and smaller managers say they are stuck between two demands from investors, who want both lower fees and a strong business model.

"When you're a smaller manager, if you have a zero management fee, it's considered a business risk, it's a red flag," said Gary DiCenzo, the CEO of Cognios Capital, which runs a $60 million hedge fund and a $160 million mutual fund.

The Oaktree Capital founder Howard Marks said recently that it was harder than ever for new funds to get off the ground.

Increased costs for technology, data, and compliance staff, along with tougher regulatory standards, have made the environment more challenging. These pressures are coupled with continued demand from investors to lower fees.

That environment made 2018 the fifth year in a row when total fund launches declined, plummeting nearly in half to 609 from 1,169 the year before, according to the hedge fund tracker Preqin.

Cognios charges a 1% management fee and a 15% performance fee — both below industry average — and its cofounder and chief investment officer, Jonathan Angrist, has no problem switching to a model that puts more pressure on the manager to generate returns.

"I personally would do it, but it's viewed as an operational risk," he said.