1 of 315

Rating: 5 stars I bought a pumpin at the farmer's market for making pie & seeds, but found this recipe on a "quick meal" search & thought, "What the hey? Sounds healthy & the ratings are great." SO>>> I followed other reviewers & added about 1/4 Cup of food processed onions to the bubbling butter, then did the recipe as followed. Added about 1 cup of shredded chicken to it & used Coconut milk instead of the 1/2 & 1/2, AND I used Indian Curry which made it near impossible for my children to feed their bodies so wonderfully as my hubby & me! Made wheat rolls & topped the soup with the seeds & we were so satisfied, in & out! This is a great, warm up your insides & get your nose running soup! So good for you too! Thank you for this addition to my fave site! Now this recipe card sits in front row in my soup slot in the recipe box!!! Thumb Up Helpful (145)

Rating: 5 stars really good and creamy. Sauted minced onions with the butter used coconut milk instead of half-n-half and added cumin. will make this again. Thumb Up Helpful (101)

Rating: 5 stars This soup is ridiculously good. I made this to use up some unused Christmas dinner ingredients and I think it's going to be replacing my current pumpkin soup recipe! I made a few changes: I added one chopped yellow onion and about 2 tablespoons of minced garlic to the curry saute and I replaced the vegetable stock with chicken stock and the cream with evaporated milk because I had it on hand and wanted to use it up. I'm sure this soup is great without any changes though! I also added a pinch of ginger. Served it with some warm crusty popovers. Delicious! Thanks so much for the recipe! Thumb Up Helpful (92)

Rating: 5 stars I have done this recipe with the onion and half-and-half a couple of different ways. I have chopped the onion to add texture and I have also thrown it into the blender so it was creamy. I like it creamy and my husband prefers the onions chopped. Either way you go this recipe is a winner and so easy you will not believe it. I am so glad I tried this in October. I will be making this a lot and we will be able to eat this warming dish all winter long! I think it is substantial enough for a main dish. Wonderful as is! Thumb Up Helpful (73)

Rating: 3 stars I'm rating medium because I know this can be so much better. my fiancee makes a soup similar to this but it definitely uses coconut milk instead of cream which is so much better for you and fish sauce instead of soy sauce. both substitutes are actually oriental ingredients instead of americanized versions. also if you use a butternut squash you don't need to add the sugar as it's naturally sweeter than pumpkin. Thumb Up Helpful (70)

Rating: 5 stars FABULOUS.. I can't believe I made something so great tasting and easy to prepare. I used chicken broth instead of vegetable and I used heavy whipping cream instead of half and half. The way to give it a kick in flavor is either to add more curry or just more salt. I also put in a little more sugar and it really tasted fantastic and I will definitely make this again....it's an awesome "comfort" food on a cold fall afternoon. Thumb Up Helpful (41)

Rating: 5 stars THE ORIGINAL RECIPE is great. It didn't need changes. It's obnoxious when people rate recipes based on their substitutions. Thumb Up Helpful (32)

Rating: 4 stars I love this soup or anything with pumpkin! I have made this with coconut milk instead of half and half with yummy results. Thumb Up Helpful (31)