Oysterhead, the supergroup power trio featuring Trey Anastasio of Phish, Les Claypool of Primus and Claypool Lennon Delirium, and Stewart Copeland of The Police, has booked a healthy set of dates during 2020 as an official reunion following their brief stints together as a band in the previous 20 years.

The band originally linked up for a Jazz Fest after-show in New Orleans in 2000 (!), brought to you by the same team that started the Bonnaroo music festival, and they recorded one LP (The Grand Pecking Order), toured for a small window, came back for a Bonnaroo set in 2006, and then everything paused as Trey’s life got back on track following an arrest.

Now that we know they’re back and busy in 2020 and recently met to kick off the discussions of what to play this tour, we thought we’d round up the 10 songs from their back catalogs that we’d want to see performed as the power trio. Stew DID ask us, so we delivered.

❓🎼QUESTION TIME❓🎼 So…d'ya think we should play some Police/Primus/Phish stuff too? Or stick to Hendrix/Cream/Doors? Or maybe just make it up on the night.#thepolice #oysterhead pic.twitter.com/3vLtDXBR3E — Stewart Copeland (@copelandmusic) October 22, 2019

The trio pretty much fully avoided back catalog covers on their initial tour and subsequent Bonnaroo performance, although The Police classic “Walking on the Moon” did make a brief appearance over a sprawling jam that emerged out of “Army’s on Ecstasy” during their Denver show in 2001. We’d consider that jam a bit of a failure to deliver on what’s promised in that gorgeous song, so hopefully the list below will serve as a set of songs the band should rehearse, deliver well, and wow the fans in the process. Here’s to hoping Trey can hit some of those Sting high notes from the list below!