Note: This ranking generated so much feedback, we did a poll asking you to vote for your faves. Here are the results: Your Top 5 meat jun.

Meat jun is a uniquely local dish found throughout Hawaii. It's Korean, but it doesn’t exist in Korea or anywhere else Korean immigrants have settled. It seems no one has a clear answer on how this dish came to be: thin, marinated slices of beef dipped in flour and egg batter and pan-fried. Usually served with a shoyu and vinegar-based sauce, meat jun is piled high on the plate lunch, a succulent, meaty-eggy.feast.

In our quest for the best meat jun in Hawaii, we discovered a few things. To be as objective as possible, we agreed on the following criteria:

The flavor of the meat is primary. About half of the places marinated their meat, some better than others. A few tasted like they weren’t marinated at all. We preferred the marinated ones, especially those that didn’t need a sauce to enhance the flavor.

Batter matters. The texture of the egg batter varied a lot. Some were light and crisp, others rigid and chewy, and some were almost like an omelet. At a few spots the batter didn’t stick to the meat, acting more as an envelope than a flavor partner.

We liked a 50-50 ratio of meat to batter. The ratios of the places we tried varied greatly from paper-thin all the way to chewy teri-beef like thickness.

Finally, while initially we cast a wide net and considered all types of Korean restaurants, in the end we refocused our search on places that do a large volume of takeout. Many of these spots built their businesses on the popularity of their meat jun. We didn’t hit up the sit-down restaurants much, especially those that pride themselves on more traditional dishes, because meat jun isn’t a traditional Korean dish. We love both types of restaurants equally, but agreed that the takeout joints are how we fell in love with meat jun, and it’s the reason we keep going back.

We didn’t take into consideration portion size, price, rice or sides, but focused solely on the quality of the meat jun itself. What we found to be our favorites might surprise you.

See all Our Top 5 rankings

No. 5: Kim Chee III

Regular meat jun plate from Kim Chee III, $13.90. - Photo credit Kelli Shiroma

An elder statesman in the pantheon of local Korean restaurants, Kim Chee III hasn’t skipped a beat in moving from Young Street near Thomas Square over to King Street by Stadium Park. Consistently thick and tender with a slight char on the batter, the meat jun is delicious and the plate a great value. Parking can be a little tough if you go on weekends.

Kim Chee III, 2239 S King St. • Moiliili • 944-3434

No. 4: Chodang

Chodang is known for its reasonable prices. This meat jun plate costs $8.90 and features a hefty portion. - Photo credit Kelli Shiroma

Old-time loyalists know Chodang as the restaurant with the $5 meat jun plate, which put them on the map years ago. Make that, quite a few years ago. Chodang's meat jun plate is now $8.90 but still cheaper than most. While the meat is tender and tasty, it's thinner than we like, and compared to other places the batter did come up a little short. Still, this meat jun plate hits the spot after a long day of shopping at Ala Moana.

451 Piikoi St, Ste 110 • Ala Moana • 591-0530

No. 3: Young’s Kalbee

Meat jun plate from Young's Kalbee, $15.90. - Photo credit Cavina Quach

While Honolulu seems to be the hub for great Korean food, the top of our list is dominated by places in the suburbs. Young’s, tucked away in Aiea Town Square, has a fierce and loyal following and was one of the places most mentioned when we were doing our research. Although much has been said about their wonderful kalbee, the meat jun lived up to the hype with juicy, thicker cuts and a flavorful egg coating to match.

99-084 Kauhale St, Ste A2 • Aiea • 488-0251

No. 2: Jin Joo

Jin Joo's $9.50 mini meat jun plate

One of Oahu's old-school Korean places, Jin Joo continues to deliver solid Korean fare, including their meat jun. It's tender and well-flavored, with a good balance between meat and batter. While not on most people’s radar (townies, we're talking to you), this one is worth a stop if you are close by.

98-020 Kamehameha Hwy. • Aiea • 488-3355 • jinjookorean.com

No. 1: Tasty Korean BBQ 3

Tasty regular meat jun plate, $10.95

Without question our top choice, Tasty Korean BBQ 3's meat jun delivers a crisp texture with the perfect ratio of batter to meat. It's extremely tender yet thick enough to feel substantial with each bite. The flavor is outstanding — one of the few meat juns that's so well marinated, it doesn’t need a sauce at all. We could go back again and again and never order anything else.

46-047 Kam. Hwy. • Kaneohe • 247-2388

For the record, here are the 18 places we tried:

Honolulu

Chodang Restaurant

Choi’s Garden

Gina’s Barbecue

HMart

Kim Chee Restaurant 2

Kim Chee III

Kyung’s Seafood

Mama Woo’s BBQ

Palama Supermarket (Kaheka)

Palama Supermarket (Palama)

Peppa’s Korean BBQ

Sam’s Delicatessen

Soon’s Kal-Bi Drive In

Yummy Korean Bar-B-Q

Leeward Oahu

Jin Joo

Young’s Kalbee

Windward Oahu

Tasty BBQ

Central Oahu

Dong Yang Inn