It’s officially the age of the reboot. But, what happens when the casts of the shows everyone most desperately wants to see reunited refuse?

Well, we keep begging. Which is exactly what we did when we had the chance to sit down with Mad About You’s Paul Reiser just a few days after the 25th anniversary of its debut.

And, to our sweet surprise, he wasn’t as against it as he has been in the past!

While Paul and Jamie aren’t exactly returning to the small screen just yet, you can enjoy Reiser’s quick wit whenever you want. Just tune into Season Two of Stranger Things (Netflix, Oct. 27), the final season of Red Oaks (Amazon, Oct. 20), or enjoy his writing in the forthcoming There’s… Johnny!.

And if that isn’t quite filling the Paul/Jamie void, our interview with the actor, writer and comedian might help. Plus, he fills us in on his Stranger Things role, the Red Oaks finale and working with Matthew Weiner.