Story highlights David Henneberry was obsessed with how his boat was stowed in the backyard

He noticed how protective pads fell to the ground

Contrary to police accounts, it wasn't blood that tipped him off to something amiss

When he re-inspected his boat, he eventually found the suspect and his trail of blood

It was a boat owner's obsession with perfection, making sure his "baby" was stowed just right in his backyard, that led him to discover the surviving suspect in the Boston Marathon bombings.

Contrary to police reports, David Henneberry said the discovery of blood had nothing to do with the inspection of his boat, the Slip Away II, he told CNN affiliate WCVB . During the inspection, he found a bloodied Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, 19, hiding in the boat, he said.

Henneberry said he had been obsessing over how two pads had fallen out of the shrink-wrap protecting his boat for the winter. He had put the pads under the shrink-wrap to prevent chafing, he told the station. It took two visits tending to the boat before he finally saw Tsarnaev and his trail of blood.

"It was really windy, so I didn't think twice about it," he said of the dislodged pads.

He couldn't address the problem until authorities lifted a "shelter-in-place" order for residents of Watertown, Massachusetts, about 6 p.m. Friday.

JUST WATCHED See the boat in which Boston suspect hid Replay More Videos ... MUST WATCH See the boat in which Boston suspect hid 02:01

JUST WATCHED Chief: Suspect did fire shots from boat Replay More Videos ... MUST WATCH Chief: Suspect did fire shots from boat 02:00

JUST WATCHED Neighbor photographs Boston shootout Replay More Videos ... MUST WATCH Neighbor photographs Boston shootout 04:32

JUST WATCHED Boston reclaims Boylston Street Replay More Videos ... MUST WATCH Boston reclaims Boylston Street 03:57

Then he went outside to get some air, he told the affiliate.

"I am just going to put the pads back. They were bugging me all day. So I went out in the yard and felt the freedom that everyone in Watertown was feeling. When I pulled the strap, it was a lot looser than it usually is. But again, the wind could have loosened things up," he said.

At this point, he didn't see blood on the exterior tarp, despite what police have said.

"No indication of anything. I know people say I saw blood on the boat, 'He saw blood on the boat.' Not true," he said.

"I said 'OK, everything is fine.' There are no visible signs of blood outside the boat. I went inside," he said.

But in a fit of obsession, he returned to the boat, climbed a ladder and inspected the Slip Away II again.

"I got three steps up the ladder and rolled the shrink-wrap. I didn't expect to see anything, but I saw blood on the floor of the boat. A good amount of blood," he told the affiliate.

"And I said 'Wow, did I cut myself last time?' I thought. I was in the boat a couple of weeks ago. Then I just look over there, and there is more blood," he continued.

The blood led to a revelation that would end a two-day manhunt for Tsarnaev.

"And I looked back and forth a couple of times and my eyes went to the engine block and there was a body," he told the station.

He didn't immediately connect the body to Tsarnaev.

"I think maybe (I knew), but I didn't want to think that. It's fast," he said.

He recounted how the person was hidden.

"I see him lying there just like you see on the film (from the State Police helicopter's infrared camera). He was just lying there by the engine block and the floor. I couldn't see his face. I'm glad I didn't see his face. I didn't see his face. He didn't move," he told WCVB.

Responding quickly, Henneberry didn't even remember climbing down the ladder and running to the phone to dial 911.

"I didn't waste any time. I didn't ask him if he wanted a cup of coffee. I was off that ladder. That is all I remember," he told the affiliate.

Police later escorted Henneberry and his wife to a neighbor's home. Police then surrounded the Henneberry's house. Tsarnaev eventually surrendered.

"I am lucky I am alive," Henneberry said. "These other people were killed. Sometimes, I just sit and say, 'Wow.'"

Many on social media want to buy him another boat.

But Henneberry wants nothing of it. He calls himself an "incidental hero."

"It makes me feel wonderful that people that are thinking like that, but it is my boat. People lost lives and lost limbs. I'd rather that (the money) go to the One Fund Boston. To buy me a new boat is a wonderful thing, I don't want that, really. I would wish that they donate it to the One Fund Boston. They lost limbs. I lost a boat," he told the affiliate.

"Slip Away is slipping away. But I say it did its job. It held a bad guy and is going away like a viking ship."