The stars of Pretty Little Liars all found out about who “Ultimate A” was in different ways.

Here’s how the girls found out, according to their new interview with Vulture:

Sasha Pieterse: “We all got little hints along the way. I think we all found out in our own ways. In the end, it was a huge shocker.”

Lucy Hale: “No one told me, and then I heard that an actor who never works on the show knew about it. Drew Van Acker knew about it! I’m like, ‘How did you know and I didn’t know?’”

Ashley Benson: “They were very tight-lipped about it, obviously, but I remember forcing it out of someone. We were on a late-night shoot and I was like, ‘Dude, you gotta f-cking tell me right now, because if you don’t tell me, I’m gonna go insane. Marlene [King]‘s not f-cking telling me, I wanna know.’ And then I got told and was like, ahhhhh! It was great…I was pissed that it wasn’t Hanna. [Winks.]

Troian Bellisario: “I was super nosy about it and I remember I cornered Marlene. I think Marlene might be slightly afraid of me. [Laughs.] Because it worked. I was like, ‘You’re gonna tell me, and you’re gonna tell me now.’ And it was a while ago. She was like, ‘Do you really wanna know?’ And I was like, ‘Yes, I really do.’”

Pictured below: Shay rocks a Black Sabbath t-shirt while leaving The Weeknd concert at The Forum on Sunday night (April 30) in Inglewood, Calif.