Years: 2004-Present

Team(s): Dallas Cowboys

Career stats: 32,084 passing yards, 230 TDs, 107 INTs

His critics say: "He's a mistake waiting to happen."

One day, Tony Romo—a.k.a. "Tony Oh-No"—might win a Super Bowl. And if he does, all of his critics will be forced to leave him alone. Much like LeBron James did when he finally won an NBA title, Romo will be able to shake the reputation that he has of being a guy who can't come up big in the clutch. But until that day, NFL fans and analysts are going to continue to expect Romo to make mistakes at the worst possible times. And they're going to call him out for making them, poke fun at them, create memes about them, and make Romo out to be the worst quarterback in NFL history.

The funny thing is that, based on his stats alone, Romo deserves the "elite" title more than a lot of other QBs in the league. But his inability to win when it counts, coupled with the fact that he plays for the Cowboys, has been his undoing. And until he's able to win a Super Bowl, he's going to continue to be the NFL's version of the 2010 LeBron James.