Fifth Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford is rated 4.4 out of 5 by 932 .

Rated 5 out of 5 by DL Richardson from Would by again So, this is my first pair of Allen Edmonds, to be truthful I was hesitant to buy after reading online reviews about how the quality of A & E has fallen. After quite a bit of debate I finally ordered the Black Fifth-Avenue Cap Toe Oxford. I got them on sell at a great price. The shoes arrived very quickly, and the packaging was perfect. A shoe bag that I had not ordered was also enclosed. Quality Control for the product looked very good. The quality of the leather looked good, the coloring looked even with no variances. The only problem at all was minor, there were several loose threads. The insole is smooth with no defects. The size was spot on the 9.5 E fit me perfectly. I did use leather conditioner and polished the shoes prior to wearing them. I also changed out the laces only because I wanted colored laces in the shoes. They were comfortable from day one. So, will check back in when I have had the shoes for a few months and comment on how well they are lasting, but for the moment I am very happy with them and plan on additional purchases later this year and into next year.

Rated 1 out of 5 by shc from Right shoe sole caused terrible toe pain. The shoes look great, however the right shoe has a differently formed sole. I thought I could wear through it and break them in, but the difference has not changed. Would love to wear them if I could comfortably. Sadly that is not the case.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Justin from Heel fell off after 10 months. Title says it all. I’ve never had a pair of shoes literally fall apart in such a short period of time. Absolute garbage quality control.