Rusty Nail Menus

Eggs All come with our best home fries and your choice of toast - rye, wheat or white EGGS ANY STYLE (one/two) 3.50/4.75 add applewood bacon or sausage 1.50 EGGS "THE NAIL" 16 poached on top of a crab cake on an English muffin, with Old Bay hollandaise sauce OMELETS all come with our best home fries and your choice of toast - rye, wheat, white

add choice of cheese (American, Swiss, provolone, pepper jack, Cooper sharp, cheddar, feta) $1 each

substitute egg whites $2

substitute fruit for home fries $2 BEACH PLUM FARM OMELET 8 onion, tomatoes, spinach, mushroom EGG WHITE OMELET 7 WHOLE EGG OMELET 6 WESTERN OMELET 7.50 peppers, onions, ham HAM OMELET, BACON OMELET, SAUSAGE OMELET 7 RUSTY NAIL MEAT LOVER’S OMELET 10 ham, bacon and sausage PANCAKES & FRENCH TOAST Comes with maple syrup and butter MACADAMIA NUT PANCAKES 10 Each bite of these fluffy macadamia nut pancakes is a taste of the Islands. Finish it off with a cool whip butterscotch topping and your choice of coconut or classic maple syrup. SHORT STACK (2) 5 PLAIN PANCAKES (3) 6.50 SHORT STACK FRENCH TOAST (2) 5 PLAIN FRENCH TOAST (3) 6.50 add blueberries, chocolate chips, or banana / $1

add Beach Plum Farm berries & whipped cream / $2 PLATES BREAKFAST BURRITO 8 scrambled egg, ham, cheese and black beans, pico de gallo, with home fries HAM, BACON, OR SAUSAGE, EGG & CHEESE 6.50 on your choice of bagel, biscuit or English Muffin CHEF JIMMY’S OWN CREAMED CHIPPED BEEF 8.50 on toast, with home fries JUST FOR KIDS 5 cereal & milk, eggs any style, home fries & toast, mini pancakes or french toast, served on our Beach Shack frisbee with a Rusty Nail cup SIDES TOAST 2 ENGLISH MUFFIN 2.50 BAGEL 2.50 with cream cheese / 3.75 BISCUIT 2.50 CORNBREAD 4 with honey PANCAKE (1) 2.50 BREAKFAST MEATS 3 applewood bacon or sausage EGG any style (1) 3.50 HOME FRIES 2 CEREAL OR GRANOLA & MILK 3.50 FRESH FRUIT (cup/bowl) 3/5 PARFAIT 6.50 yogurt, granola, fresh fruit

SOUPS & SALADS add to any salad: grilled chicken, salmon, shrimp, crabcake (broiled or fried) $6/$8/$11/$12 NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER (cup/bowl) 6/8 light and creamy, clams, bacon, oyster crackers, celery and potato CHILI (bowl) 8 house made, beans, ground beef, spicy tomato base, pico de gallo, sour cream and cheddar CORN CHOWDER (cup/bowl) 5/7 CAESAR SALAD 8 romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese, creamy Caesar dressing SPINACH SALAD 8 radishes, egg, bacon dressing STUFFED PORTOBELLO SALAD 19 crab imperial stuffing, Cooper sharp cheese, seasonal leafy greens and vegetables from our farm, strawberry vinaigrette FARM HOUSE SALAD 7 seasonal leafy greens and vegetables from our farm in a very simple dressing APPS NAIL NACHOS 9 crispy corn tortillas, topped with cheddar cheese sauce, served with a side of pico de gallo & sour cream

add guacamole 2 / chili 3 / grilled chicken 6 / crab meat 12 LOADED FRIES 13 topped with cheddar, crumbled bacon and scallions, served with a side of sour cream 14 STEAMED CLAMS 16 served in an garlic herb white wine clam sauce 6 CLAMS CASINO 12 traditional recipe with bacon, onions, peppers and topped with melted Cooper cheese 6 BBQ CLAMS 13 Jimmy’s famous recipe topped with melted Cooper cheese 10 STRAWBERRY HOT WINGS 12 served with BPF fresh strawberry dipping sauce 10 CHICKEN WINGS 11 hot or bbq sauce, with blue cheese or ranch dressing BOARDWALK STYLE CONES FRIED CLAM STRIPS 12 tartar sauce FRIED SHRIMP 16 cocktail sauce FRIED MOZZARELLA 9 marinara sauce FRENCH FRIES 7 RUSTY NAIL FRIES 8 Old Bay seasoning BOARDWALK FRIES 8 drizzled with malt vinegar JIMMY’S HOMEMADE FRESH TEMPURA STYLE ZUCCHINI STICKS 9 with marinara or chipotle mayo DEEP FRIED MAC-N-CHEESE BALLS 10 horseradish dipping sauce SPECIALTIES MAC ATTACK baked mac-n-cheese 10

baked mac-n-cheese, buffalo chicken 13

baked mac-n-chees, bbq pork 14 QUESADILLAS served with a side of sour cream and pico de gallo cheddar cheese 8 cheese only garden 9 cheddar cheese, onion, red and green peppers grilled chicken 13 cheddar cheese, onion, red and green peppers grilled shrimp & crab 16 cheddar cheese, onion, red and green peppers Beach Plum Farm smoked pork 15 cheddar cheese, onion, red and green peppers BBQ RIBS (half/full rack) 18/26 served with cornbread and choice of one side

add bbq shrimp 11 2 BAJA GRILLED FISH TACOS 19 grilled mahi, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole 2 GRILLED CHICKEN TACOS 14 grilled chicken, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole, with cole slaw SANDWICHES All sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, onion, chips and a pickle or a side salad. THE NAIL BURGER 15 with fries or a side salad

choice of cheese (cheddar, American, provolone, Cooper sharp, blue cheese or spicy pepper jack) 1 each

choice of bacon, mushrooms or fried onions 1 each FRIED LOCAL FLOUNDER SANDWICH 16 cole slaw and tartar sauce CRAB CAKE SANDWICH 19 broiled or fried, with tartar sauce and cole slaw CRAB MELT 19 served open face on an English muffin, sliced tomato, melted cooper cheese SHRIMP PO BOY 14 fried shrimp, tossed in house made slaw BEACH PLUM FARM PULLED PORK SANDWICH 14 fresh-smoked roast pork, house made bbq sauce and a side of cole slaw BEACH SHACK CLUB 12 all natural apple wood smoked turkey and bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato & mayo, served with a pickle and chips BLT 11 served with mayo, your choice of toast GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH 13 tomato and lettuce, brioche roll

choice of cheese (cheddar, American,provolone, Cooper sharp, blue cheese or spicy pepper jack) 1 each. BEACH PLUM FARM REUBEN 15 smoked roast pork from Beach Plum Farm, open-faced on rye, chipotle mayo, cole slaw, Cooper sharp cheese WRAPS THE NAIL WRAP 18 fried local flounder, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, lettuce, chipotle mayo, served with a side of guacamole and sour cream GRILLED VEGETABLE WRAP 11 grilled seasonal vegetables from our farm, provolone cheese CHICKEN SALAD WRAP 11 cranberries, lettuce, tomato THE NAIL STEAK WRAP 12 steak, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, lettuce, chipotle mayo, served with a side of guacamole and sour cream SIDES MAC & CHEESE 5

HOUSE MADE COLE SLAW 4

1/2 FARM HOUSE SALAD 5

FRENCH FRIES 5

RUSTY NAIL FRIES 6

BOARDWALK FRIES 6

VEGETABLE OF THE DAY 4

CORNBREAD 4

SOUPS & SALADS add to any salad: grilled chicken, salmon, shrimp, crabcake (broiled or fried) $6/$8/$11/$12 NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER (cup/bowl) 6/8 light and creamy, clams, bacon, oyster crackers, celery and potato CHILI (bowl) 8 house made, beans, ground beef, spicy tomato base, pico de gallo, sour cream and cheddar CORN CHOWDER (cup/bowl) 5/7 CAESAR SALAD 8 romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese, creamy Caesar dressing SPINACH SALAD 8 crumbled bacon, radishes, egg, bacon dressing STUFFED PORTOBELLO SALAD 19 crab imperial stuffing, Cooper sharp cheese, seasonal leafy greens and vegetables from our farm, strawberry vinaigrette FARM HOUSE SALAD 7 seasonal leafy greens and vegetables from our farm in a very simple dressing APPS MAC ATTACK baked mac-n-cheese 10

baked mac-n-cheese, buffalo chicken 13

baked mac-n-cheese, bbq pork 14 NAIL NACHOS 9 crispy corn tortillas, topped with cheddar cheese sauce, served with a side of pico de gallo & sour cream

add guacamole 2 / chili 3 / grilled chicken 6 / crab meat 12 LOADED FRIES 13 topped with cheddar, crumbled bacon and scallions, served with a side of sour cream 14 STEAMED CLAMS 16 served in an garlic herb white wine clam sauce 6 CLAMS CASINO 12 traditional recipe with bacon, onions, peppers and topped with melted Cooper cheese 6 BBQ CLAMS 13 Jimmy’s famous recipe topped with melted Cooper cheese 10 STRAWBERRY HOT WINGS 12 served with BPF fresh strawberry dipping sauce 10 CHICKEN WINGS 11 hot or bbq sauce, with blue cheese or ranch dressing BOARDWALK STYLE CONES FRIED CLAM STRIPS 12 tartar sauce FRIED SHRIMP 16 cocktail sauce FRIED MOZZARELLA 9 marinara sauce FRENCH FRIES 7 RUSTY NAIL FRIES 8 Old Bay seasoning BOARDWALK FRIES 8 drizzled with malt vinegar JIMMY’S HOMEMADE FRESH TEMPURA STYLE ZUCCHINI STICKS 9 with marinara or chipotle mayo DEEP FRIED MAC-N-CHEESE BALLS 10 horseradish dipping sauce SANDWICHES All sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, onion, chips and a pickle or a side salad. THE NAIL BURGER 15 with fries or a side salad

choice of cheese (cheddar, American, provolone, Cooper sharp, blue cheese or spicy pepper jack) 1 each

choice of bacon, mushrooms or fried onions 1 each FRIED LOCAL FLOUNDER SANDWICH 16 cole slaw and tartar sauce CRAB CAKE SANDWICH 19 broiled or fried, with tartar sauce and cole slaw BEACH PLUM FARM PULLED PORK SANDWICH 14 fresh-smoked roast pork, house made bbq sauce and a side of cole slaw THE NAIL WRAP 18 fried local flounder, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, lettuce, chipotle mayo, guacamole, sour cream GRILLED VEGETABLE WRAP 11 grilled onion, red pepper, yellow squash, zucchini, portobello mushroom, eggplant, provolone cheese GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH 13 tomato and lettuce, brioche roll

choice of cheese (cheddar, American,provolone, Cooper sharp, blue cheese or spicy pepper jack) 1 each. 2 BAJA GRILLED FISH TACOS 19 grilled mahi, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole, cole slaw 2 GRILLED CHICKEN TACOS 15 grilled chicken, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole, cole slaw MAINS Select two: buttermilk mashed potatoes, baked potato, French fries, baked yam, side of pasta, seasonal vegetable selection, side salad FRIED OR BROILED FLOUNDER 28 GRILLED SALMON 25 CRAB STUFFED FLOUNDER 29 2 JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKES 34 broiled or fried CHICKEN PARMESAN 19 12 OZ. GRILLED NY STRIP STEAK 36 STEAK & CAKE 40 grilled NY strip, jumbo lump crab cake JERSEY CLAM BAKE* 34 16 clams, 8 shrimp, clam broth or white wine garlic sauce, corn on the cob, redskin potatoes BBQ RIBS (half/full rack) 18/26 served with cornbread and choice of one side

add bbq shrimp 10 --- * Jersey Clam Bake and Pasta entrées served complete PASTA SHRIMP SCAMPI 26 PASTA PRIMAVERA 16 bowtie pasta, fresh grilled vegetables, extra virgin olive oil, parmesan cheese

add grilled chicken 6, salmon 8 or shrimp 11 PASTA A LA VODKA 17 bowtie pasta, fresh grilled vegetables, vodka cream sauce

add grilled chicken 6, salmon 9 or shrimp 11 ANGEL HAIR PASTA A LA VONGOLE 22 fresh local clams in white garlic cream sauce SIDES BUTTERMILK MASHED POTATOES 4

MAC & CHEESE 5

HOUSE MADE COLE SLAW 4

1/2 FARM HOUSE SALAD 5

FRENCH FRIES 5

RUSTY NAIL FRIES 6

BAKED POTATO 5

BOARDWALK FRIES 6

VEGETABLE OF THE DAY 4

BAKED YAM 5

CORNBREAD 4

PASTA 4

Seasonal Sips THE NAIL ORANGE CRUSH 11 Stoli O, Fresh Orange, Triple Sec, Lemon-lime Soda THE NAIL GRAPEFRUIT CRUSH 11 Stoli, fresh grapefruit, Triple Sec, lemon-lime soda ELYX MULE 11 Absolut Elyx vodka, ginger beer, lime, served in a copper mug CRANBERRY OLD FASHIONED 13 Bulleit, aromatic bitters, fresh cranberry, orange, cherry, simple syrup SPICED HOT APPLE CIDER 11 Mount Gay, hot apple cider, cinnamon, cloves, orange THE NAIL WHISKEY PUNCH 11 Seagrams VO, fresh brewed iced tea, orange, lemon, cherry, simple syrup, ginger ale DARK AND STORMY 11 Gosling’s, ginger beer, lime THE ST. CANELA 11 Avion Repasado, orange, cherry, cinnamon, simple syrup APPLE HARVEST 11 Stoli, apple, lemon, cinnamon, simple syrup RUSTY NAIL MIMOSA 11 Louis Pommery sparkling wine, orange RUSTY NAIL MIMOSA 11 Louis Pommery sparkling wine, orange THE NAIL COMBO 10 Bud Light and Proper No. Twleve shot Mojitos ENDLESS SUMMER MOJITO 10 Bacardi Superior, lime, mint, simple syrup, soda

add strawberry, blueberry, passionfruit $1 WINTER SOLSTICE MOJITO 11 Gosling’s, blackberry, lime, mint, simple syrup, soda MARTINIS SPRING IS NEAR 12 Stoli, Lillet, St Germain, lemon, splash lemon-lime soda THE SHACK APPLE SIDECAR 12 Hennesy VS, Countreau, lemon, fresh apple GINGER LEMON DROP 12 Smirnoff Caramel, Malibu, lime, cream CARAMEL COCONUT KEY LIME PIE 12 Hennesy VS, Countreau, lemon, fresh apple MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP MARTINI 12 Absolute Vanilla, Crème de Menth, Crème de Cocoa, cream, chocolate drizzle CLASSIC CHOCOLATE MARTINI 12 Absolute Vanilla, Godiva Chocolate, Trader Vicks Chocolate liquor, cream, chocolate drizzle MARGARITAS SHACK MARGARITA 9 Cazadores Silver, Triple Sec, lime, simple sryup GOLDEN MARGARITA 11 Avión Reposado, Triple Sec, lime, simple syrup, Grand Marnier floater SMOKEHOUSE MARGARITA 11 Vicio Mezcal, Triple Sec, lime, simple sryup, Joel Gott pinot noir floater FESTIVE MARGARITA 12 Avión Repasado, Triple-Sec, cranberry, rosemary, lime, simple syrup TOP SHELF MARGARITA 14 Patron Silver, Cointreau, lime, simple syrup WINE White CAPOSALDO ITALY (G/B) 8/32 Pinot Grigio MONKEY BAY NEW ZEALAND (G/B) 8/30 Sauvignon Blanc THE SEEKER GERMANY (G/B) 9/34 Riesling RYDER ESTATE CALIFORNIA (G/B) 9/34 Chardonnay SURF SWIM CAN 8 Chardonnay Red JOEL GOTT CALIFORNIA (G/B) 9/34 Pinot Noir RAVENSWOOD CALIFORNIA (G/B) 9/34 Cabernet Sauvignon ALAMOS ARGENTINA (G/B) 9/34 Malbec QUERCIABLLA MAREMMA TUSCANA MONGRANA ITALY (G/B) 11/40 Red Blend Sparkling POMMERY POP FRANCE (G/B) 9 splits Champagne LOUIS POMMERY CALIFORNIA (G/B) 10/36 Sparkling Wine Rosé PINK FLAMINGO CÔTE DE PROVENCE (G/B) 8/30 Rosé LA CHAPELLE GORDONNE CÔTE DE PROVENCE (G/B) 10/38 Rosé CAN WINE BEACH JUICE CAN 10 Rosé BEER Coldest draft beer in Cape May as verified by Exit Zero magazine On Tap MILLER LITE 4 STELLA ARTOIS 6.25 ALLAGASH WHITE 6.50 BROOKLYN LAGER 6.50 CAPE MAY BREWERY IPA 6.50 FOUNDERS PORTER 6.50 YARDS BRAWLER 6.50 KANE HEAD HIGH IPA 7 LAST WAVE BREWING CO. COCONUT PORTER 7 ROTATING TAP (ASK YOUR SERVER) 6.50

Bottles & Cans FOUNDERS ALL DAY IPA 5 BALLAST POINT GRAPEFRUIT SCULPIN IPA 6 BUDWEISER 4.50 BUD LIGHT 4.50 MILLER LITE 4.50 COORS LIGHT 4.50 MICHELOB ULTRA 4.50 YUENGLING 4.50 CORONA LIGHT 5 HEINEKEN 5 RED STRIPE 5 GUINNESS DRAUGHT 6 KALIBER N/A 5 ANGRY ORCHARD 5 TWISTED TEA 5 CROOK & MARKER COCONUT PINEAPPLE 5 CROOK & MARKER MANGO 5 CROOK & MARKER BLACK CHERRY 5

All kids menu meals include a soft drink with a novelty cup and a cookie - served on our Beach Shack frisbee. Add 1 for milk, 1.50 for chocolate milk.

*children 12 and under HOT DOG & FRIES 11 MAC & CHEESE 11 SPAGHETTI POMODORO 11 BOWTIE PASTA & BUTTER 11 KIDS STEAK & FRIES 13 KIDS CHICKEN PARMESAN W/ PASTA 11 CRISPY CHICKEN FINGERS & FRIES 11 KIDS BURGER & FRIES 12 choice of cheese (cheddar, American, provolone, Cooper sharp, blue cheese or spicy pepper jack) / 1 each MINI PIZZA 11 FRIED FLOUNDER & FRIES 12 FRIED SHRIMP & FRIES 12

PEANUT BUTTER BOMB 6 a chocolate candy bar bottom, topped with a layer of peanut butter ganache and a mound of chocolate mousse surrounded with a dark chocolate and peanut butter candy shell

add a scoop of vanilla ice cream / 6.50 CLASSIC CHOCOLATE MOUSSE CAKE 6 a layer of chocolate cake topped with a dark chocolate mousse, finished in dark chocolate ganache, topped with whipped cream

add a scoop of vanilla ice cream / 6.50 KEY LIME CHEESECAKE 6 add a scoop of vanilla ice cream / 6.50 CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE ICE CREAM SANDWICH 6 BERRY COBBLER 6 granola brown sugar topping

add a scoop of vanilla ice cream / 6.50 HOMEMADE DOUBLE CHOCOLATE BROWNIE A LA MODE 6.50 double chocolate brownie served with vanilla ice cream and fresh berries