Roy Sorensen & Michael Weisberg

Roy Sorensen (left) and Michael Weisberg (right) on idealization and scientific realism.

Idealization is the intentional introduction of distortion into scientific theories. If science aims at the truth, as scientific realists believe, then why are scientific theories routinely idealized? To answer that question, Weisberg take a pluralistic approach. He distinguishes three kinds of idealization (Galilean, minimalist, and multiple-models), and recommends that realists pursue different accounts of each kind. In contrast, Sorensen proposes that realists can develop a unified account of idealization if they can show that idealized scientific theories are merely supposed rather than asserted.

Related works

by Sorensen:

“Bald-faced Lies! Lying without the Intent to Deceive” (2007)

“Logically equivalent—but closer to the truth” (2007)

Thought Experiments (1992)

by Weisberg:

“Who Is a Modeler?” (2007)

“Three Kinds of Idealization” (2007)

[display_podcast]