The Patriots have appeared in eight Super Bowls, with a ninth on deck against the L.A. Rams. There have been plenty of memorable plays in those games. The most shocking? Which plays had fans jumping out of their seats when they happened. Here’s the Top Six from our view.

1. Malcolm Butler interception, Super Bowl XLIX — This was literally a jump-out-of-your-seat moment. The Seahawks were poised to win. All they had to do was get the ball over from the one yard line. Instead of handing the ball off to Marshawn Lynch, Pete Carroll & Co. opted for a pass play. Russell Wilson dropped back, and delivered the football and Butler jumped the route, cutting in front of Ricardo Lockette at the goal line. Said Butler: “From preparation, I remembered the formation they were in … I just beat him to the route and made the play.”

2. David Tyree catch, Super Bowl XLII — This was a jaw-dropping stunner. This was the catch that killed the perfect season. Tyree had velcro on his helmet. First Eli Manning made the great escape to avoid the Patriots pass rush, then Tyree made an improbable catch, leaping up and securing the ball against his helmet with one hand, with safety Rodney Harrison desperately trying to yank it away. The “Helmet Catch” continued the drive that resulted in the Giants game-winning touchdown in a 17–14 victory over the previously undefeated Patriots.

3. Julian Edelman catch, Super Bowl LI — It’s been called many things. Gravity-defying. Ridiculous. Obscene. The Pats were down by 8 with 2:28 to play. It was 1st-and-10 from New England’s 36, and the Patriots wide receiver, fighting off three Atlanta Falcons defenders – sliding through the legs of one of them – somehow scooped up the ball before it hit the ground. “It was one of the greatest catches I’ve ever seen,” Tom Brady said. “I don’t know how the hell he caught it.”

4. Ty Law pick-six, Super Bowl XXXVI — The cornerback had a 47-yard interception return of a Kurt Warner pass in the second quarter. With his right arm waving in the air as he arrived in the end zone, the Patriots were up 7-3 on the heavily favored Rams in the second quarter. Suddenly, Rams fans began to get nervous. Law’s pick is the only touchdown a Patriots defensive player has scored in the Super Bowl.

5. Adam Vinatieri game-winning kick, Super Bowl XXXVI — With the score tied, TV analyst John Madden suggested Tom Brady take a knee with 1:21 remaining. Only Bill Belichick trusted the then 24-year-old Brady to move the ball and get in field goal range. And that he did, quickly advancing the ball ahead and getting in range as Vinatieri drilled a 48-yarder through the uprights and shocked the world. No one expected the underdog Patriots to win this game.

6. Nick Foles touchdown catch Super Bowl LII — This is now famously known as the “Philly Special.” When it happened, everyone was caught off guard, including the Patriots. No one was expecting the quarterback to go out for a pass in the red zone, especially on fourth and goal at the end of the second quarter. But Eagles coach Doug Pederson called the play, instead of going for a field goal. Corey Clement took the direct snap behind center, flipped the ball to tight end Trey Burton. He rolled right, and lofted a short pass to the right corner of the end zone to a wide open Foles. A shocker to say the least and a huge play in the 41-33 Eagles victory.