This article considers the significance of trolling for security processes through a contextual analysis of industrialized pro-Kremlin trolling in the Russian blogosphere. The publicity surrounding Russia’s hacking activities in international politics conceals the significance of the domestic trolling culture in Russia and its role in the ‘trolling turn’ in Russia’s foreign policy. We contextually identify the practice of ‘neutrollization’ – a type of localized desecuritization where the regime adopts trolling to prevent being cast as a societal security threat by civil society. Neutrollization relies on counterfeit internet activism, ostensibly originating from the citizenry, that produces political disengagement by breeding radical doubt in a manner that is non-securitizing. Rather than advocating a distinct political agenda, and in contrast to conventional understandings of the operations of propaganda, neutrollization precludes the very possibility of meaning, obviating the need to block the internet in an openly authoritarian manner. It operates by preventing perlocution – that is, the social consequences of the security speech act. This prevention is achieved through the breaking or disrupting of the context in which acts of securitization could possibly materialize, and is made possible by a condition of ‘politics without telos’ that is different from the varieties of depoliticization more familiar in Western societies.

References

Alexander, L ( 2015 a) Social network analysis reveals full scale of Kremlin’s Twitter bot campaign . Global Voices, 2 April . Available at: https://globalvoices.org/2015/04/02/analyzing-kremlin-twitter-bots/ (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Alexander, L ( 2015 b) Open-source information reveals pro-Kremlin web campaign . Global Voices, 13 July , Available at: https://globalvoices.org/2015/07/13/open-source-information-reveals-pro-kremlin-web-campaign/ (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Anon ( 2013 ) We are Anonymous. We do not forgive. We do not forget . Dazed, 14 June . Available at: http://www.dazeddigital.com/artsandculture/article/16308/1/we-are-anonymous-we-do-not-forgive-we-do-not-forget (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Aradau, C ( 2004 ) Security and the democratic scene: Desecuritization and emancipation . Journal of International Relations and Development 7(4): 388 – 413 .

Google Scholar

Austin, J ( 1962 ) How To Do Things with Words: The William James Lectures Delivered at Harvard University in 1955. Ed. Urmson, JO. Oxford & New York : Clarendon Press .

Google Scholar

Austin, J, Beaulieu-Brossard, P ( 2017 ) (De)securitisation dilemmas: Theorising the simultaneous enaction of securitisation and desecuritisation . Review of International Studies 44(2): 1 – 23 .

Google Scholar

Balzacq, T ( 2005 ) The three faces of securitization: Political agency, audience and context . European Journal of International Relations 11(2): 171 – 201 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Balzacq, T ( 2010 ) A theory of securitization: Origins, core assumptions, and variants . In: Balzacq, T (ed.) Securitization Theory: How Security Problems Emerge and Dissolve. London : Routledge , 1 – 30 .

Google Scholar

Balzacq, T (ed.) ( 2014 a) Contesting Security: Strategies and Logics. London : Routledge .

Google Scholar

Balzacq, T ( 2014 b) Legitimacy and the ‘logic’ of security . In: Balzacq, T (ed.) Contesting Security: Strategies and Logics. London : Routledge , 1 – 10 .

Google Scholar

Behnke, A ( 2006 ) No way out: Desecuritization, emancipation and the eternal return of the political – A reply to Aradau . Journal of International Relations and Development 9(1): 62 – 69 .

Google Scholar

Bilgin, P ( 2007 ) Making Turkey’s transformation possible: Claiming ‘securityspeak’ – not desecuritization! Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 7(4): 555 – 571 .

Google Scholar

Bourbeau, P, Vuori, J ( 2015 ) Security, resilience and desecuritization: Multidirectional moves and dynamics . Critical Studies on Security 3(3): 253 – 268 .

Google Scholar

Bubandt, N ( 2005 ) Vernacular security: The politics of feeling safe in global, national and local worlds . Security Dialogue 36(3): 275 – 296 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Burai, E ( 2016 ) Parody as norm contestation: Russian normative justifications in Georgia and Ukraine and their implications for global norms . Global Society 30(1): 67 – 77 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Buzan, B, Wæver, O, De Wilde, J ( 1998 ) Security: A New Framework for Analysis. Boulder, CO : Lynne Rienner .

Google Scholar

CaraDoxee5 ( 2015 ) Oppozitsiya vyekhala na ubiystve Nemtsova [ The opposition saved its face on Nemtsov’s assassination ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://caradoxee5.livejournal.com/399569.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

Ciutӑ, F ( 2009 ) Security and the problem of context: A hermeneutical critique of securitization theory . Review of International Studies 35(2): 301 – 326 .

Google Scholar

Coleman, G ( 2015 ) Hacker, Hoaxer, Whistleblower, Spy: The Many Faces of Anonymous. London & New York : Verso .

Google Scholar

Cush, A ( 2015 ) Emails link Kremlin troll farm to bizarre New York photography exhibit . Gawker, 20 August . Available at: http://gawker.com/emails-link-kremlin-troll-farm-to-bizarre-new-york-phot-1725347179 (accessed 25 April 2018).

Google Scholar

demouu1 ( 2015 ) Oppozitsiya prinesla v zhertvu cheloveka? [ The opposition made a human sacrifice? ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://demouu1.livejournal.com/330867.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

Floyd, R ( 2010 ) Security and the Environment: Securitisation Theory and US Environmental Security Policy. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .

Google Scholar

Gad, UO, Petersen, KL ( 2011 ) Concepts of politics in securitization studies . Security Dialogue 42(4–5): 315 – 328 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Guzzini, S ( 2011 ) Securitization as a causal mechanism . Security Dialogue 42(4–5): 329 – 341 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Hansen, L ( 2012 ) Reconstructing desecuritisation: The normative-political in the Copenhagen School and directions for how to apply it . Review of International Studies 38(3): 525 – 546 .

Google Scholar ISI

Herman, E, Chomsky, N ( 2002 ) Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. Updated edn. New York : Pantheon Books .

Google Scholar

Huysmans, J ( 1998 ) The question of the limit: Desecuritisation and the aesthetics of horror in political realism . Millennium: Journal of International Studies 27(3): 569 – 589 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

kater971 ( 2015 ) Odnogo iz svoikh poteryala oppozitsiya [ The opposition lost one of its own ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://kater971.livejournal.com/93877.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

Khachatryan, D ( 2015 ) Kak stat’ troll’hanterom [ How to become a troll-hunter ]. Novaya Gazeta, 10 March . Available at: https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2015/03/10/63342-kak-stat-trollhanterom (accessed 25 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Kurowska, X ( 2014 ) Multipolarity as resistance to liberal norms: Russia’s position on responsibility to protect . Conflict, Security & Development 14(4): 489 – 508 .

Google Scholar

MacKenzie, M ( 2009 ) Securitization and desecuritization: Female soldiers and the reconstruction of women in post-conflict Sierra Leone . Security Studies 18(2): 241 – 261 .

Google Scholar ISI

Merkacheva, E ( 2013 ) Tayny trollinga: kak nanimayut virtual’nykh killerov dlya politicheskikh ubiystv [ The mysteries of trolling: How they hire virtual killers for political assassinations ]. Moskovskiy Komsomolets, 17 November . Available at: http://www.mk.ru/social/article/2013/11/17/946434-taynyi-trollinga-kak-nanimayut-virtualnyih-killerov-dlya-politicheskih-ubiystv.html#loaded-37 (accessed 25 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Morozov, V ( 2004 ) Russia in the Baltic Sea region: Desecuritization or deregionalization? Cooperation and Conflict 39(3): 317 – 331 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Nemtsov, B ( 2012 ) Manifest svobodnoy Rossii [ Manifesto of Free Russia ]. Ekho Moskvy, 9 June . Available at: https://echo.msk.ru/blog/nemtsov_boris/897379-echo/ (accessed 31 March 2018).

Google Scholar

Pertierra, A C ( 2017 ) Media Anthropology for the Digital Age. London : Polity .

Google Scholar

Phillips, W ( 2015 ) This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things: Mapping the Relationship Between Online Trolling and Mainstream Culture. Cambridge, MA & London : MIT Press .

Google Scholar

Polyanskaya, A, Krivov, A, Lomko, I ( 2009 ) The Kremlin’s virtual squad . Open Democracy, 19 March . Available at: https://www.opendemocracy.net/article/russia-theme/the-kremlins-virtual-squad (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Pomerantsev, P ( 2015 ) Nothing Is True and Everything Is Possible: The Surreal Heart of the New Russia. London : Public Affairs .

Google Scholar

pqalongese ( 2015 a) Podstrekatel’stvo – glavnoe svoystvo SShA [ Instigation is the USA’s main feature ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://pqalongese.livejournal.com/200935.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

pqalongese ( 2015 b) Oppozitsiya: minus odin [ Opposition: Minus one ]. Web blog post , LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://pqalongese.livejournal.com/201033.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

pqalongese ( 2015 c) Ubiystvo Nemtsova: kto prav, a kto vinovat? [ Nemtsov’s assassination: Who’s right, and who should be blamed? ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://pqalongese.livejournal.com/202909.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

Prozorov, S ( 2008 ) Russian postcommunism and the end of history . Studies in East European Thought 60(3): 207 – 230 .

Google Scholar ISI

Reshetnikov, A ( 2017 ) Intervention as virtue, obligation and moral duty: The meaning of Russia’s rhetoric on responsibility during the Georgian and the Crimean crises . Russian Politics 2(2): 155 – 181 .

Google Scholar

Rezunkov, V ( 2016 ) Pobeg s ‘fabriki trolley’ [ Escape from ‘troll factory’ ]. Radio Svoboda, 6 September . Available at: http://www.svoboda.org/a/27970298.html (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Roe, P ( 2009 ) The ‘value’ of positive security . Review of International Studies 34(4): 777 – 794 .

Google Scholar

Rossiya 24 ( 2015 a) Vesti nedeli [ News of the Week ]. 1 March . Available at: http://vesti7.ru/video/1182768/episode/01-03-2015/ (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Rossiya 24 ( 2015 b) Vesti nedeli [ News of the Week ]. 8 March . Available at: http://vesti7.ru/video/1185751/episode/08-03-2015/ (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

ryypaulinm ( 2015 ) Komu vygodno ubiystvo Nemtsova [ Who benefits from Nemtsov’s assassination? ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://ryypaulinm.livejournal.com/358960.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

Snetkov, A ( 2015 ) Russia’s Security Policy Under Putin: A Critical Perspective. London : Routledge .

Google Scholar

Snetkov, A ( 2017 ) Theories, methods and practices: A longitudinal spatial analysis of the (de)securitization of the insurgency threat in Russia . Security Dialogue 48(3): 259 – 275 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

snowy_trail ( 2015 ) Ubiystvo Nemtsova na radost’ nekotorym. SShA i ES poshli v otryv [ Nemtsov’s assassination to someone’s benefit: The USA and the EU are running the show ]. Web blog post, LiveJournal, 28 February . Available at: http://snowy-trail.livejournal.com/64238.html (accessed 14 February 2017).

Google Scholar

Soshnikov, A ( 2015 ) Stolitsa politicheskogo trolling [ The capital of political trolling ]. Moy Rayon, 11 March . Available at: http://mr7.ru/articles/112478/ (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Stritzel, H ( 2007 ) Towards a theory of securitization: Copenhagen and beyond . European Journal of International Relations 13(3): 357 – 383 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Stritzel, H ( 2011 ) Security, the translation . Security Dialogue 42(4–5): 343 – 355 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Taureck, R ( 2006 ) Securitization theory and securitization studies . Journal of International Relations and Development 9(1): 53 – 61 .

Google Scholar

Toler, A ( 2017 ) The weird world of MH17 conspiracy theories: Part 1 . Bellingcat, 7 August . Available at: https://www.bellingcat.com/news/uk-and-europe/2015/08/07/mh17-conspiracies/ (accessed 25 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Volcheck, D, Sindelar, D ( 2015 ) One professional Russian troll tells all . Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 25 March . Available at: http://www.rferl.org/a/how-to-guide-russian-trolling-trolls/26919999.html (accessed 24 April 2018).

Google Scholar

Vuori, J ( 2008 ) Illocutionary logic and strands of securitization: Applying the theory of securitization to the study of non-democratic political orders . European Journal of International Relations 14(1): 65 – 99 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Vuori, J ( 2018 ) Let’s just say we’d like to avoid any great power entanglements: Desecuritization in post-Mao Chinese foreign policy towards major powers . Global Discourse 8(1): 118 – 136 .

Google Scholar

Wæver, O ( 1989 ) Security the speech act: Analysing the politics of a word . Working paper no. 1989/19. Copenhagen : Centre for Peace and Conflict Research .

Google Scholar

Wæver, O ( 1995 ) Securitisation and desecuritisation . In: Lipschutz, RD (ed.) On Security. New York : Columbia University Press , 46 – 86 .

Google Scholar

Wæver, O ( 1999 ) Securitizing sectors? Reply to Eriksson . Cooperation and Conflict 34(3): 334 – 340 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Wæver, O ( 2002 ) Security: A conceptual history for international relations . Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the British International Studies Association , London , .

Google Scholar

Wilson, A ( 2005 ) Virtual Politics: Faking Democracy in the Post-Soviet World. New Haven, CT & London : Yale University Press .

Google Scholar