American Christianity is now being drawn into yet another conflict, this one between religious rights and gay rights. Having lost the battle over same-sex marriage to the sexual revolutionaries, American Christianity, once again panicked, is overplaying its hand trying to legislate its rights and protections absent any consideration of civic rights for the LGBT community. Protecting religious rights is foundational to the well-being of a pluralistic society and all forms of faith. But it is neither American nor Christian to deny civic rights to others. To do so is unacceptable and unsustainable, particularly for those among the younger generations that place a greater priority on fairness for all.