Good Morning guys!! Today I have a comparison for you! When I posted Captivated from Cult Nails the other day Mia commented that it looked similar to Icing Tigers Blood. I had Tiger’s Blood siting in my untrieds so I pulled it out and was stunned by how similar they looked!

Icing Tiger’s Blood is one of the 3 polishes Icing recently started carrying that have funny Charlie Sheen sayings as their names (the other 2 are Epic Winning and Rockstar from Mars). Once I got these 2 polishes on I couldn’t really tell a difference between them! The Cult Nails polish might have a bit of a redder base but in person it wasn’t a difference significant enough to see, my camera picked it up more than my eyes did! The formula was very much the same on both…thick but not terribly hard to work with. Both could benefit from thinner, I just haven’t gotten around to adding any yet!

The major differences between these two polishes are price and availability. Cult Nails retails for $10 a bottle and ships pretty much everywhere while Icing retails for $4.50 a bottle but is only available in Icing stores which I believe are in the US and Canada only. I’ve seen some people trying to find these Charlie Sheen polishes at Claire’s but they are Icing exclusives!

I used 3 coats of each polish for the photos below. The lighting is overcast sun, we’ve been having some major June gloom here lately 🙁

Big thank you to Mia for the suggestion of comparing these two!







https://web.archive.org/web/http://www.thepolishaholic.com:80/2011/06/cult-nails-captivated-vs-icing-tigers.html?showComment=1308081226135