Migrations by Mastigias

If you were to snorkel in "Jellyfish Lake" (Ongeim'l Tketau, OTM), Palau, just before dawn, you would find millions of Mastigias medusae milling around the western half of the lake. The gentle, rhythmic, pulsing of their bells would be more likely send you back to sleep than to remind you of jet propulsion, which is the mechanism by which they move. They swim in all directions, change their heading often, and have no particular destination. All this changes at dawn (6 am, never much less and never much more) when, with the sky brightening in the east, the jellyfish turn and swim diligently toward the rising sun. For an hour or more they swim, never faltering, rarely turning, with incessant contractions of their bell, until they approach the eastern end of the lake. Here, although still stimulated to swim eastward by the rising sun, they are stopped, not by the edge of the lake, but by the shadows cast by overhanging trees which they meticulously avoid. The medusae become trapped between swimming east toward the sun and swimming west away from the shade. The millions of jellyfish that were once in the west are now packed densely around the illuminated eastern rim of the lake, with nowhere else to go.



Mastigias medusae avoid shaded water medusae avoid shaded water

Nowhere else to go, that is, until the afternoon. As the day progresses, the sun passes directly overhead and then gradually begins to descend in the west, releasing the medusae from their quandary. As the sun begins to track westward, all the jellyfish accumulated in the east begin to follow the sun back across the lake, returning to where they originated in the morning. The jellyfish swim west until they encounter the shadow lines cast along the western edge of the lake as the sun descends in the west. They accumulate in the west, as they did in the east, swimming around, continually avoiding the shadows, staying in the sunlight and avoiding the shore. By 3 or 4 p.m., the eastern basin which became densely packed with jellyfish between 9 a.m. and 12 is again almost devoid of jellyfish as they have all returned to the western end of the lake. As the sun sets (very rapidly in the tropics), the shadows quickly move across the lake and the jellyfish can no longer remain in the sunlight. Now in the shadows, and lacking any directional light by which to orient their swimming in a horizontal direction, the animals begin to swim vertically, up and down in the water column, remaining more or less in the same position with respect to the shore (thus, this behavior keeps them away from the shore during the night). At this time, they may swim downward and encounter the nutrient rich boundary between the anoxic depths and the oxic upper layers where their algal symbionts absorb lots of nutrients. However, they are always moving - swimming up and down. When the sun rises the next day (but before it actually illuminates the lake's surface), the jellyfish accumulate at the surface in response to the increasing light. Here, once again, they mill around until the first rays of sun entice them to the east.



Mastigias medusae aggregate against the shadow-line

cast by overhanging trees

In summary, the jellyfish complete one round-trip migration from west to east and then back to the west every day between sunrise and sunset. At no point do they ever stop swimming - during the day or night. During the day, their swimming is either strongly directional as they migrateeastward (in the morning) or westward (in the afternoon)or haphazard as they mill about waiting for the sun or avoiding shadows. At night, they also swim continually, but vertically rather than horizontally as during the day. The migration is the summed result of each individual animal responding to the light cues in the same way.

Left: Bubble plot showing changes in the density of Mastigias across the lake as each day progresses. Early in the morning (0700 hrs) Mastigias are found mostly in the western half of the lake, but they rapidly move to the east. During the afternoon, they return to the west, where they remain overnight. The rose diagrams down the side show the directions in which the jellyfish are swimming at those times. Below: Bar graph showing the vertical distribution of Mastigias. The medusae are shallower during the day (light bars) and deeper during night (dark bars).

Why do the jellyfish migrate? Mastigias medusae get much of their energy from photosynthetic organisms - zooxanthellae - that live inside their cells. Consequently, it would make sense for the jellyfish to migrate so that they maximise the time they spend in the sun and, therefore, the energy they get from the zooxanthellae. However, the direction the Mastigias migrate in OTM does not maximize the time they spend in the sun. To achieve this, they should migrate from west to east, rather than from west to east and back to west. Mastigias in some other lakes do migrate from west to east and maximize their illumination. In these lakes, the migratory pattern is also much more diffuse, suggesting that the jellyfish don't respond as consistently to cues (light or shade) as they do in OTM. So, why do the jellyfish in OTM migrate the way they do? Probably it is because OTM, unlike the other lakes, is inhabited by a large population of an important predator of the jellyfish - the anemone Entacmaea medusivora. In OTM, the direction in which the jellyfish migrate ensures that the edge of the lake, where the anemones lie in wait, will always be in shadow when the jellyfish arrive. The presence of this false edge, and the jellyfishes' response to it, minimizes their contact with the real edge inhabited by their predators. Those who don't respond, get eaten and don't reproduce. Thus, in this lake conflicting selection pressures have shaped their behavior - the need to sun their algae versus the need to avoid predators. In the end, it turns out that the medusae can miss a bit of dinner, but not be dinner, and survive.





The End