A man bicycling around Columbus Circle stops his bike in the middle of traffic. "Is that a male romper? Are you fucking kidding me? You tell your fashion editors that male rompers are NOT FASHION," he shouts as we, and five men in rompers, make our way to Central Park for a photo shoot. Then he breaks into a chant: "No male rompers! No male rompers! No male rompers!"

After the Original RompHim launched on Kickstarter last week, the internet had been abuzz about the existence of a one piece aimed at bros. Was there really a place in mainstream menswear for such a novelty item? We even dug deeper to see what style experts thought about the concept of a romper for dudes (in short: a mixed reaction).

But talking about brompers wasn't enough to get a feel for the impact. We needed to find out what it felt like to wear a romper. So we recruited five real dudes to go where few men had gone before: for a walk around one of New York City's most densely populated areas. Wearing a romper.

Here's what they wore, how they felt, and what passersby screamed in their faces.

Exhibit No.1: Shom

Tyler Joe

Shom is Wearing: Onepiece Boombox Jumpsuit

Initial romper thoughts: "I don't find the idea of wearing a romper that weird. I grew up around motorcycles and cars, and we called what we wore overalls, but it's the same single piece idea as a romper. I also wear a one-piece when I do competitive road cycling."

Wearing a romper feels like: "Wearing a dress—not that I have that much experience in it. It feels easy, and you're not messing around with it every time you sit down. It lays how it lays, and that's it."

Would you recommend wearing one? "One hundred percent. Especially the one I'm wearing—I would seek this one out. Actually, where did you get it?"

Exhibit No. 2: KP

Tyler Joe

KP is wearing: Mr. Turk Keller 2 Jumpsuit

Initial romper thoughts: "Before I wore one: 'This is gonna be freaking ridiculous.' After I put it on: 'Damn! This isn't nearly as bad as I thought it would be. Actually... this is a solid look.'"

Wearing a romper feels like: "A classic mechanic's suit. I'm pretty sure mine is the most low-key, and feels the most me compared to the other ones. If I didn't feel like I'd get extra attention, I would definitely wear it."

Would you recommend wearing one? "Romper life is simple and easy and not about over-thinking things: yes/no, go/no-go. Don't overthink it."

Exhibit No. 3: Dave

Tyler Joe

Dave is wearing: Onepiece Lake Jumpsuit

Initial romper thoughts: "I feel like I lucked out in terms of the cut of this one. From the waist up, it's pretty nice—it looks like a mechanic's jumpsuit. But from the waist down, it's kind of a drop-crotch situation, so I think if it wasn't so drop-crotch-y it would be better. But for the most part, I feel ridiculous, yeah."

Wearing a romper feels like: "I mean, I've never worn a dress before so I'm used to having a belt or button supporting my waist, but the material of this one is super comfortable."

What should guys know about wearing a romper? "The first rule of romper club is don't join romper club. The second rule of romper club is if you're going to join romper club, make sure you get one that fits."

Would you recommend wearing one? "Absolutely not. Under no circumstance could I, in good conscience, recommend anybody wear a romper at any point. Unless you're chilling on Richard Branson's island and he gave you a romper and said you could only stay if you wore the romper. Maybe then, yeah."

Exhibit No. 4: Jake

Tyler Joe

Jake is wearing: The Original RompHim

Initial romper thoughts: "My style is normally pretty conservative—jeans and a T-shirt or business casual for work. I thought the romper was funny and novel, but maybe not something I'd wear for real."

Wearing a romper feels like: "It's an interesting feel because there's nothing on your waist. You feel a little naked, actually. I understand why women would enjoy it—it feels pretty good and breezy. Outside of the breeziness, the really low crotch is not great."

Would you recommend wearing one? "This could be a strength in numbers play. If you and your buddies want to wear it for a bachelor party, or you want to wear it in the park and you're going to be hammering rosé because it's summer? Then sure, yeah. But if you're going to buy one because you think you can wear this instead of shorts and button-down at a bar, then, no, this is not the play."

Exhibit No. 5: Joe

Tyler Joe

Joe is wearing: Chubbies Onesie (technically meant for indoor chilling)

Initial romper thoughts: "My normal style isn't too different, but I do normally wear two pieces of clothing. The color of mine was great—look at these pineapples!"

Wearing a romper feels like: "I felt like a little kid. It really brings out a lot of playful attitude. This one wasn't as mobility-restricting as the other ones might be. I don't know what this is made out of, but it is mighty fine. Chubbies!"

Would you recommend wearing one?: "Yeah, they're fun. I'd also recommend a regular onesie. I'd also recommend Crocs. Why not? And pinwheel hats. But that's just my style."

This content is imported from YouTube. You may be able to find the same content in another format, or you may be able to find more information, at their web site.

Commentary

"That is badass. You guys look hot."

Tyler Joe

"Wait, what is that? No, seriously where did you get it?"

Tyler Joe

"Dude, were you in Pike?"

Tyler Joe

(Into cellphone): "Oh my god. They're having a fucking photo shoot with guys in fucking rompers. I'm dead. I'm fucking dead."

Tyler Joe