Before you start to feel too bad for Jane the Virgin‘s baby daddy Rafael, just remember what he looks like.

In this exclusive video from the CW series’ Season 1 DVD release (on sale Sept. 29), the Jane cast reveal themselves to be near-unanimously Team Michael when it comes to who belongs with the titular heroine.

As for that one Team Rafael outlier, well, his answer might have been influenced by the lurking shadow of co-star Justin Baldoni, who plays the Marbella hotel owner.

Press PLAY above to watch the video, then hit the comments with your thoughts on the Team Michael vs. Team Rafael debate.