Looking for a movie to stream on Amazon Prime (for free, as long as you have a membership), but experiencing option paralysis over the thousands of titles available? Let us help. Here are some of the best picks from Prime’s most recent additions—including a rich Italian meal, a twisty con job, and a conundrum for the ages.

A game night for a group of very competitive friends gets a boost when the host’s one-upping brother (Kyle Chandler) plans a murder mystery in place of the usual parlor games…except that he’s actually involved in some shady dealings, and his “staged” kidnapping turns out to be the real thing. Jesse Plemons, as a neighbor desperate to be invited to game night, was robbed of an Oscar nomination (seriously!).

Watch it now on Amazon Prime with Cinemax add-on

Forrest Tucker (Robert Redford) has been a fugitive since escaping San Quentin Prison two years before, but hasn’t lost his talent for bank robbing. In fact, his advanced age makes him even more invisible—until he’s pulled off so many heists that the FBI gets involved in trying to track him down. At the same time, Forrest grows closer to a woman named Jewel (Sissy Spacek), trusting her with his secret as he tries to evade arrest.

Watch it now on Amazon Prime with HBONow add-on

When a mysterious aquatic life form is removed from the Amazon River and relocated to a shadowy government facility in Baltimore for inhumane tests, mute janitor Elisa (Sally Hawkins) forges a relationship with the creature and overcomes her fears to rescue it. The Shape of Water earned more nominations at the 90th Academy Awards than any other film, winning (among others) best picture.

Watch it now on Amazon Prime

If last year’s acclaimed If Beale Street Could Talk led you to learn more about James Baldwin, who wrote the novel from which the film was adapted, this documentary about the history of American racism is essential. Taking as its inspiration Baldwin’s unfinished memoir, Remember This House, I Am Not Your Negro was nominated for a best documentary feature Oscar at the 89th Academy Awards.

Watch it now on Amazon Prime

How does an American diocese of the Roman Catholic church conceal widespread sexual abuse by priests trusted to counsel and educate children? The Boston Globe’s “Spotlight” team of journalists investigated the corruption, won a Pulitzer Prize for Public Service in 2003, and became the subject of this docudrama, a best-picture Oscar winner.

Watch it now on Amazon Prime

The titular refugee camp—located near Johannesburg, South Africa, and inhabited by extraterrestrials whose spacecraft mysteriously appeared almost 30 years earlier—is about to be emptied by Multinational United, a private contractor. Wikus (Sharlto Copley), an MNU agent serving notice to camp residents, is injured in an accident, which gradually gives him a new perspective on the aliens’ situation.

Watch it now on Amazon Prime

In 1974, acrobat Philippe Petit challenged himself to run a tightrope between the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center—a feat in itself even before he went on to walk that tightrope, thousands of feet up; this documentary features footage shot during the planning phases as well as reenactments, and won the best documentary feature Oscar in 2009.