There are a number of choices for the title of most memorable goal in U.S. Soccer history. The list starts with Landon Donovan’s shot off a rebound to beat Algeria in 2010, Eric Wynalda’s free kick against Switzerland in 1994 that gave the U.S. its first World Cup point in 44 years, and Paul Caligiuri’s left-footed rainbow that beat Trinidad and Tobago and qualified the Americans for the 1990 World Cup.

But the list of most memorable miss begins and ends with one shot: Chris Wondolowski’s stoppage-time shank on what would have been a game-winning score against Belgium in the 2014 World Cup.