I have read many of the comments, some positive, some negative. For some, we find it tough to wrap our heads around this rapid promotion, for some, there is no issue.

I personally, would only raise concern if there were a chance of coming out of the band, and into the traditional world, which I think there is little.

The band is designed to bring a small bit of joy to many who serve in very tough situations, and the only way to recruit people with that specific skill set is to hire at advance grade. Because that specific group is so small, further advancement is limited.

If there are any band members on RP, I would welcome input, but for me, I have no issue with it, as their rank structure impacts my unit, NOT AT ALL, and every time I have had the pleasure of enjoying their performances, I have taken great pleasure in their skills.