Countries Ranked by Their Economic Complexity

In the past, the trade between nations was a much simpler matter to grasp. Commodities and a few finished goods moved between a handful of countries in a straightforward way.

Today, around 6,000 officially classified products pass through the world’s ports, and digital products and services zip across country lines creating an extra layer of difficulty in measuring economic activity.

To try to understand this enormous level of economic complexity, the team at Harvard’s Growth Lab have created the Country Complexity Ranking. Here’s a look at the top 50 countries in the ranking:

Rank Country Score Top Export(s) 1 Japan 2.28 Cars, ICT (tech) 2 Switzerland 2.14 ICT, gold, packaged medicaments 3 South Korea 2.05 ICT, cars 4 Germany 2.02 Integrated circuits, ICT, cars 5 Singapore 1.81 ICT, cars 6 Czech Rep. 1.79 Cars, vehicle parts 7 Austria 1.71 ICT, tourism 8 Finland 1.69 ICT 9 Sweden 1.67 ICT 10 Hungary 1.64 ICT, cars 11 Slovenia 1.57 Cars, ICT 12 United States 1.47 ICT, tourism 13 Italy 1.42 ICT, tourism 14 United Kingdom 1.42 ICT, finance 15 Slovakia 1.41 Cars 16 France 1.40 ICT, tourism 17 Ireland 1.39 ICT 18 Israel 1.37 ICT, diamonds 19 China 1.30 Electronic equipment 20 Mexico 1.27 Cars 21 Poland 1.19 ICT 22 Denmark 1.18 Transport, ICT 23 Belgium 1.16 ICT 24 Romania 1.16 ICT, vehicle parts 25 Thailand 1.15 Tourism 26 Netherlands 1.04 ICT 27 Estonia 1.03 ICT, transport 28 Malaysia 0.95 Integrated circuits 29 Belarus 0.93 Refined oils, ICT 30 Croatia 0.92 Tourism, ICT 31 Lithuania 0.85 Transport, refined oils 32 Spain 0.85 Tourism, ICT 33 Philippines 0.75 Integrated circuits, ICT 34 Portugal 0.72 Tourism, ICT 35 Canada 0.69 Crude oil, cars, ICT 36 Bosnia and Herz. 0.65 Tourism, ICT 37 Serbia 0.65 ICT 38 Turkey 0.65 Tourism, transport 39 Latvia 0.64 Transport, ICT 40 Bulgaria 0.62 Tourism, ICT 41 Norway 0.56 Crude oil, petrol. gases 42 Ukraine 0.42 ICT, transport 43 Cyprus 0.38 Tourism, transport 44 Tunisia 0.34 Electrical wire, tourism 45 India 0.32 ICT 46 Costa Rica 0.30 ICT, tourism 47 Uruguay 0.29 Tourism, wood pulp 48 Brazil 0.24 Soya beans, iron ore 49 Russia 0.24 Crude oil, refined oils 50 Lebanon 0.24 Tourism, ICT

Source

Japan, Switzerland, and South Korea sit at the top of the ranking.

Czech Republic – which was recently ranked as the most attractive manufacturing destination in Europe – has a strong showing, ranking 6th in the world. The United States slipped out of the top 10 into 12th position.

The Power of Productive Knowledge

Highly ranked countries tend to have the following attributes:

• A high diversity of exported products

• Sophisticated and unique exported products (i.e. few other countries produce similar products)

In short, the ranking hinges on the concept of “productive knowledge” – or the tacit ability to produce a product.

Muhammed Yildirim, of Harvard University, has thought up a useful analogy for thinking about the role of productive knowledge in the complexity of an economy:

“Suppose that each type of productive knowledge is a letter and each product is a word composed of these letters. Like the game of Scrabble, each country holds a set of letters with plenty of copies of each letter and tries to make words out of these letters. For instance, with letters like A, C and T, one can construct words like CAT or ACT. Then our problem of measuring economic complexity resembles interpreting how many different letters there are in each country’s portfolio. Some letters, like A and E, go in many words, whereas other letters, like X and Q, are used in very few. Extending this analogy to the countries and products, only those with a larger diversity of letters will be able to make more and more unique products. On the other hand, words that require more letters will be made only in the countries that have all the requisite pieces.”

Not All Exports are Created Equal

Much like the rack of letters in a Scrabble game, the elements of every export-driven economy can be broken down and quantified. The resulting categories encompass everything from rendered pig fat to integrated circuits, each contributing to the country’s overall score.

Agricultural and extractive industries tend to score lower on the complexity scale. Machinery can be highly complex to produce and is connected to many facets of the global economy.

Visualizing this overall mix of categories can provide a unique perspective beyond big picture numbers like GDP. Below are a few real world examples of export markets on both ends of the complexity spectrum.

Japan

Since this ranking began in the mid-1990s, Japan has never been bumped from the top spot.

Due to a restricted land mass and some ingenuity, Japan has become the prototypical example of a low-ubiquity, high-sophistication export economy.

Interactive breakdown

⁨Cars and electronics are obvious standouts, but there numerous other high-value product categories in the mix as well. The country also has a wide variety of high value exports and trading partners, lowering the risk of a trade war or industry downturn crippling the country’s economy.

Australia

Many will be surprised to learn that Australia sits in the lower third of this complexity ranking.

Although Australia’s global ranking is high in a myriad of categories – household wealth per person, for example – its economic complexity score is -0.60, much lower than expected for its income level. Looking at the breakdown below, there are clues as to why this might be the case.

Interactive breakdown

Australia’s⁩ largest exports are in ⁨low⁩ complexity categories, such as minerals and agriculture. To compound matters, the country’s economy is heavily linked to China’s. To underscore this point, a recent study found that a 5% drop in China’s GDP would result in a 2.5% dip in Australia’s.

Venezuela

It’s no secret that Venezuela has seen some tough times in recent years. The chart below shows just how reliant Venezuela was on oil exports to sustain its economy.

Interactive breakdown

An over-reliance on a single export can leave a country extremely vulnerable in the event of price volatility or geopolitical events. In the case of Venezuela, three quarters of their export economy was comprised of crude oil – one of the lowest scoring product categories in the ranking.

The Rush to Diversify

A low level of economic complexity isn’t necessarily a problem. Many countries with middle-to-low scores in the ranking have great standards of living and a high level of wealth. Countries like Canada, Norway, and Australia were all well down the list.

On the other hand, some countries have made diversification a priority. SoftBank’s $100 billion Vision Fund is partially the result of Saudi Arabia’s push to develop a diversified, knowledge-based economy. Other oil-rich nations, such as Kazakhstan, are also pushing to diversify in the face of the world’s evolving energy mix.

As world economies evolve and the shift from fossil fuels continues, we will likely see economic complexity increase across the board.