Disney’s Dumbo remake may have opened in first, but the numbers it pulled in were far from acceptable considering its massive production budget. Meanwhile, Universal’s Us fared well in its second weekend, while Unplanned opened well above expectations.

Dumbo took first with an estimated $45 million this weekend – exactly on par with my prediction, but well below the $50-70 million it had been tracking for. For such an old IP that doesn’t exactly have a massive built in audience, this would have been a fine start if it didn’t cost so much to make. Whether it was because Tim Burton was at the helm or because of the star power in its cast, Disney decided that a $170 million budget for the film was a good call, but considering the competition it faces in the next month, it’s hard to imagine it gets anywhere close to $400 million worldwide. Ultimately, there’s a very good chance this becomes a write-off.

Us may not have had the same stellar hold as Get Out – not that it was ever expected to – but its 53% drop is still fairly impressive in its own right. Considering the responses were somewhat polarizing from general audiences last weekend, many thought that it may have burned out quickly, but that doesn’t seem to be the case; while it does face strong competition from Pet Sematary next weekend, it still seems like there’s a good chance for Us to top $200 million domestically.

Three films entered wide release in around 1,000 locations each, to decidedly mixed results; of the three, Unplanned fared the best with an excellent $6.1 million from 1,059 locations, for an impressive average of $5,770. The only downside is that it wound up being massively front loaded, down a whopping 42% on Saturday. This implies that it may have burned through all of its controversy-fueled ticket sales on opening day, leaving little interest in the rest of the weekend. Still, this is a big win for distributor Pure Flix, who reportedly produced the title for just $6 million – especially since its R rating will likely mean much of its audience comes from the ancillary market.

The two other wide releases were The Beach Bum and Hotel Mumbai, in 1,100 and 924 locations respectively. Mumbai fared better than expected, with a solid $3.1 million, while The Beach Bum was a beach bomb, taking in just $1.8 million for an awful per theater average of $1,636.

Among other holdovers, Captain Marvel pulled in another $20 million as it now sits just $10 million away from the billion dollar mark, while Five Feet Apart continued its impressively leggy run, down another 27% for a solid $35 million in 17 days.