shacklesburst answered:

5. Kyouko sees no reason to hold out against anything. She jumps somebody, then gets bored, then jumps the next person coming up. Her sessions with Sayaka get markedly more heated than most other people, but other than that, Kyouko does not discriminate in her affections.

4. Madoka makes a token effort for like four seconds, then starts making out with everybody, but like, in a friendship sort of way.

3. Mami manages a few minutes before giving in, but at least she feels conflicted the whole time!

2. Sayaka. It goes against her very being to just do stuff like this, so she’s holding back as much as possible, but eventually even she succumbs, especially after being grabbed in one of her hot Kyouko sessions.

1. Homura only ever has Madoka in sight and she’s managed to withhold her horny for several lifetimes already. Fanfic pollen doesn’t even register.