Sheriff Jody Mills is returning to SUPERNATURAL, but this time she’s got a little entourage of teenage girls with her.

Claire Novak (Jimmy’s daughter) gives the Winchesters a panicked call and tells them that she believes the recent murders in town are due to supernatural beings. Dean and Sam pay a little visit to Jody, Claire and Alex (the other girl Jody had taken in), but Jody doesn’t believe there’s a case here for the boys. She tells them that Claire has been getting into trouble because she’s been attacking normal people and accusing them of being monsters. Is Claire on to something here or has she gone overboard?

Browse through photos below for an all new episode of SUPERNATURAL on February 1 at 9:00 p.m. ET/PT on The CW.