This week administrative committee member Greg Mirabella, husband of former Federal Liberal MP Sophie Mirabella, emailed his colleagues saying the party needed to decide whether the current team at the top should be the one to fight the federal election. Mr Mirabella listed the loss of votes in blue-ribbon Liberal seats among his main concerns. “This means that not only does our product stink, it stinks to our own people,” he wrote. “We can understand why the hip-pocket voters in the eastern suburbs might have turned against us, but in Hawthorn and Brighton? Our own people don’t like us enough to vote for us.” Our own people don’t like us enough to vote for us Guy Mirabella

In a subsequent email Mr Mirabella said the party urgently needed rebranding. “You should appreciate better than most the maxim that in politics, perception is reality and the perception is that Michael [Kroger] is the public face of the party and our party is almost terminally on the nose.” In response to Mr Mirabella’s email party treasurer David Mond suggested moving a motion of no confidence in the party’s president and in his capacity as chair of the administrative committee, and asked those included on the email to second him. Liberal Party president Michael Kroger on election night Credit:AAP “Whatever personal differences there may be around the table, we must be of one voice on this issue,” Mr Mond said. “I will say that for each one of you, this is a moment of truth.”

However, it is understood the motion was not put to the committee. One Liberal source said it was "a bit rich" that the Mirabellas were "talking about brand damage". Last night the Coalition was on track to win just 26 of 88 seats in the lower house of the Victorian Parliament. The distinct possibility that Hawthorn MP John Pesutto could lose his seat has devastated the party considering he was touted as a possible leadership candidate. Senior Liberal sources confirmed former opposition leader Matthew Guy urged the administrative committee to avoid "lynching" Mr Kroger and state director Nick Demiris, telling Wednesday’s meeting the party needed to stick together. Mr Guy is also understood to have praised the team for the campaign effort, including what he described as an impressive advertising campaign as well as one of the most successful volunteer turn outs and “ground game” the party had run in recent years.

Illustration: Matt Golding Credit: But he was frank in describing what he saw as problems with the “Liberal brand” and the electorate’s overall perception of the party, which he said had suffered from the leadership instability of August and the dumping of Malcolm Turnbull. He told members at the table the party would soon be “defunct” if it didn’t address problems within the Liberal brand. But Mr Guy was "unelectable", according to an angry email fired off on Thursday by failed Liberal candidate for Albert Park Andrew Bond. In his review of the campaign, Mr Bond said it became “worryingly obvious that Matthew Guy was unelectable” from phone calls with voters in the electorate.

“After a few weeks of making calls, I estimate approximately one in 10 people would respond unprompted that they could never vote for the Liberal Party whilst Matthew Guy was leader,” he said. Mr Bond said “numerous scandals” and Mr Guy’s record as planning minister were regularly mentioned by voters. Loading The federal leadership crisis was merely "the final nail in the coffin", Mr Bond said, after a poorly run campaign with badly thought-out policies and messaging. "Would we have won if the federal leadership challenge didn't occur? Probably not, as much else went wrong post the leadership spill."

Mr Bond said the opposition lost because it had lost its appeal to a “core group of our supporters”. “This group are comfortable, asset rich, employed professionals or retirees, and small business owners. “However they are also non-religious but not anti-religion, somewhat concerned about the environment but not Greens, and compassionate about their fellow humans, but not Social Justice Warriors.” However, the bitterness in Federal Parliament since "ensured that right up to election day the idea that the Liberal Party is out of touch and dysfunctional was continually top of mind for many." He warned that some of the constituents who told him they would vote Liberal at state level made clear they would not vote Liberal at the federal election.