News in Science

Tags on fish may act as a 'dinner bell' for predators

Conservation science Sound-emitting tags fitted to fish to track their survival may be alerting predator seals to their location, report scientists who warn of a 'dinner bell' effect.

Tests with captive grey seals showed that they learned quickly to associate the tag's sound with the presence of an easy meal, British researchers report in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B.

Ten juvenile seals, who had not been exposed to acoustic tags before, were put to the test in a concrete pool with twenty boxes into which fish, tagged and untagged, were randomly placed for them to eat in 20 trials.

"The seals found the tagged fish in fewer box visits than the untagged fish in later trials, demonstrating the learned use of the acoustic tag to locate food," found researchers from the University of St Andrews.

With each consecutive test, seals needed about five percent less time to find the box with the tag inside. And they visited the boxes with tagged fish much more frequently than empty boxes or those with non-tagged fish.

Acoustic tags are widely used in mark-and-recapture studies to assess fish survival and stock health. They produce ultrasonic frequencies thought to be imperceptible to the fish that carry them

Previous studies had suggested the signal was audible to some predators, like seals, but this was the first research to find a "learned association between a signal and food leading to a 'dinner bell' effect," the authors say.

"Our results... illustrate the importance of considering the auditory sensitivities of all animals in the environment when designing an acoustic tagging study," they say.

"We showed that acoustic tags... aid prey detection, potentially increasing predation of tagged animals and potentially skewing study findings".

The team say similar results are likely for other animal species and for other anthropogenic sounds like boat engines, turbines and sonar -- causing behaviour changes that could have profound effects on an ecosystem.

This may include tagged predators, like sharks, having less and less hunting success as seals and other prey scatter in front of the acoustic signal.

"When introducing artificial sound sources into an environment, it is important to take into consideration all potential effects on local species, both detrimental and beneficial," the scientists say.