On August 26, 1995, Heather was sunbathing a Newburgh Beach in Henderson County, Kentucky. A witness observing the beach area through a telescope from across the Ohio River at approximately 12:45 p.m., told authorities their account.

According to this witness, he saw a Caucasian male approach Heather, allegedly grabbed her by her hair and dragged her into the woods off of Newburgh Beach at gunpoint. The witness described this man as approximately 6’0 tall, weighed between 2010 to 230 lbs, had brown hair and a bushy brown beard.

The witness also described the man as wearing jeans but no shirt, yet also oddly wearing a wig and a mosquito net as well.

Following her disappearance getting reported, authorities searched the beach area later in the day, discovering a part of Heather’s red, plaid bathing suit near the alleged site of her abduction. While investigators also found additional evidence, nothing pointed them to Heather’s whereabouts.

Heather has not been seen or heard from since.

A local farmer who was videotaping unrelated crop vandalism in the area that day caught Heather’s car, and a red Ford Bronco, which was just down the road, on camera. It is unclear, however, if the red Bronco was confirmed to be the same one related to Heather’s abduction.

A resident of Henderson County, Kentucky, a man named Marvin “Ray” Dill, was pulled over during a routine traffic stop following Heather’s disappearance. His vehicle was a red and white Ford Bronco, the same car that a witness reported as having parked beside Heather’s at the beach.

During the traffic stop, in his Ford Bronco, authorities discovered a pair of guns, a pair of knives, a roll of duct tape, rubber gloves, rope, and a hair resembling Heather’s.

Furthermore, the truck also had bloodstains on the inside tailgate. To make his possible involvement even more damning, the composite sketch made of Heather’s abductor strongly resembled Dill.

In August of 1995, investigators received multiple tips connecting Dill to Heather’s disappearance.

Following up on the tips, investigators arrived at his home for questioning. Upon arriving, Dill reportedly told his wife to vacate their residence once he learned of their presence on his property. Once she left, Dill promptly committed suicide by shooting himself in the head before authorities could enter his residence.

After his suicide, evidence was compiled by prosecutors against Dill, which before being brought before a grand jury. Dill’s wife, called as a witness during this phase, soon invoked her Fifth Amendment rights and refused to answer any questions regarding Heather’s disappearance.

Aside from Dill, another possible suspect in Heather’s case is Christopher J, Below, a native of Henderson, Kentucky who is pled guilty to attempted involuntary manslaughter in connection to the 1991 shooting death of Kathrn Fetzer, serving a prison sentence of 11 to 18 years.

Another possible suspect in Teague’s case is Christopher J. Below, a native of Henderson, Kentucky. He pled guilty to attempted involuntary manslaughter in connection with the 1991 death of Kathern Fetzer and is serving a prison sentence of 11 to 18 years for the crime. Though Fetzer’s body has yet to be found either, Below did confess and pled guilty.