I have had Xbox since my first console. I think I a lot of ways the Xbox one controller made some very good innovations from the Xbox 360 controller. The only problem I have with them is that if you use them heavily after a while the joy sticks start to drift. This means that after a while they will start to move on there own. I have also bought on of these controllers that out of the box one of the buttons didn't work. This was a one off thing so I don't think it's anything to be worried about, but I would recommend that anytime you buy a controller that you go into the Xbox one settings to accessories and test that all the buttons work and are registering on the Xbox.