I had originally received a box of sandpaper from Amazon from my gifter. I thought maybe my gifter might be trolling me or may be sending me something that would require sanding. After some confusion and a post on /r/secretsanta, I contacted Amazon customer support. Turns out, I was sent the wrong package from the warehouse. My gifter also contacted Amazon and they sent me what he originally ordered. Lo and behold, I have a brand new boardgame to share with my girlfriend! Everything went better than expected!

Thanks super gifter!