JSR #375

Java TM EE Security API

Public Review Ballot

Ballot duration: 2017-06-27 to: 2017-07-10

These are the final results of the Public Review Ballot for JSR #375. The EC has approved this ballot. Votes

EC Arm Limited Azul Systems, Inc. Credit Suisse Eclipse Foundation, Inc Fujitsu Limited Gemalto M2M GmbH Goldman Sachs & Co. Grimstad, Ivar Hazelcast Hewlett Packard Enterprise IBM Intel Corp. JetBrains s.r.o. Keil, Werner London Java Community MicroDoc NXP Semiconductors Oracle Red Hat SAP SE Software AG SouJava Tomitribe Twitter, Inc. V2COM

Icon Legend Yes No Abstain Not voted

View Vote Log

EC

On 2017-06-30 Azul Systems, Inc. voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-06-30 SAP SE voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-06-30 Software AG voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-09 Fujitsu Limited voted Yes with the following comment: Fujitsu's vote is based on the technical merits of this JSR and is not a vote on the licensing terms. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-03 MicroDoc voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-09 Credit Suisse voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 Keil, Werner voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-07 Goldman Sachs & Co. voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-06-29 Oracle voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-05 NXP Semiconductors voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-06 Gemalto M2M GmbH voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-07 Grimstad, Ivar voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 IBM voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-07 V2COM voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 Arm Limited voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-03 SouJava voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 London Java Community voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 Hewlett Packard Enterprise voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 Twitter, Inc. voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 JetBrains s.r.o. voted No with the following comment: We do not feel comfortable voting "yes" on the public review ballot for JSR, 375, given the lack of clarity in the documentation, missing support for other valuable technologies like OpenID, and outstanding issues such as issue #76 on hardcoded values in the code. While we know it's not possible to get everything perfect in one step, security is an enormously important topic (one that has frequently given Java a bad name) and we would like to see a specification which reflects this. We appreciate it is very late in the process to give such feedback, and also understand that much more specific feedback and suggested actions will be required by the Expert Group in order to address our concerns. We are working on a more detailed response and will be reaching out to the EG directly shortly. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 Eclipse Foundation, Inc voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ On 2017-07-10 Tomitribe voted Yes with no comment. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------



