Evan Peters has been playing creepy characters on American Horror Story for six seasons now (and is confirmed for a seventh!), and we're not ashamed to say that we've come to really love his dark and twisted nature. The 33-year-old actor has graced our TV screens as murderous teenager Tate Langdon, wrongfully convicted killer Kit Walker, frat boy Kyle Spencer, deformed circus performer Jimmy Darling, psycho hotel owner James March, and harsh aristocratic Edward Philippe Mott / lovable actor Rory Monahan (season six was confusing, we know).

While all of his characters are either slightly mysterious or extremely dangerous, you probably can't get him out of your head after watching an episode . . . and you're not alone. Not only is Peters an insanely good actor, completely encompassing every new character he takes on in AHS, but he also humanizes them in a way where you root for him, hope he makes it out on the other side, and ends up with, well, you. To satisfy your Evan craving while waiting for more season seven details, keep reading to see all the times you crushed hard on him, then check out seven theories about season seven.