Oh I see. : ) Well, you two made an excellent list together that was surprisingly close to my own. Its nice to see there are other people who can analyize a class and aspect and match it with a characters personality.



I'm just not the sure on Pinkie with LIFE. Sure she'd make a GOOD hero of life, but its definitely not her defining attribute. The Heiress' were given the aspect of life because they had innate manipulation of it, both being immortal and extending life in others as adults. And we were shown VERY early on that Nanna 'Jane' Crocker was a life player, using her food powers to heal John in battle, constantly pestering people to eat and stay healthy. Pinkie Pie loves food, but she bakes for her job and most importantly to cheer people up. Applejack on the other hand takes pride on supporting Ponyville WITH her food. Pinkie's MAIN goal is to be a source of happiness and hope for Ponyville in its purest, most Caliborn can't tolerate it, form. Smile, smile, smile is a perfect example of performing her duties as the Bard of Hope...and considering how few success stories there are with Hope players, its a bit refreshing. Sure Feferi is bubbly and cheerful, but she wasn't exactly ACT as an inspiration to the group. She didn't have the will to keep everyone's courage up, while Pinkie does.



And above all else, the mark of a successful Hope player is a good sign for a group of heroes. Both troll universes were destroyed, while Jake is in a void universe that, once merged with the remains of the first universe, can be a successful session.



As for Spike...I just haven't figured him out yet. His class attribute is obvious, he is definitley a Page. He knows little of what he's capable of, has the idiot ball a lot when young, is used to getting ordered around, but has a lot of potential. Its the aspect I'm having trouble figuring out.



Life? No.



Space? No.



Hope? Not really.



Time? No connection there.



Rage? It exists within him but its more akin to wickedness and greed, a part that he rejects.



Doom? No



Light? Not really, luck and solutions aren't exactly his forte.



Heart? He's got a crush and thinks about romance, but there's more too him then that. He doesn't overvalue the development of others souls through romance or splintering



Blood? Blood is unity under equality. While I guess he's in the same boat as Karkat and Kankri, being a mutant among trolls and being a dragon among ponies, I'm not sure that's ever been a thing for him



Breath? Hmm...there is something there. We can't count out the idea that Spike is the potential success story of the Page of Breath while Tavros is the failure story. But I think deep down Spike is too much of a realist even at his age to be a natural adventurer.



Void? Hmmm....maybe. He has little knowledge about himself, there is a void in his life that he longs to fill (nurture: Rarity, Nature: Gold), has little talent at first but he is slowly building himself up from that, whether he wants to be a mean dragon or a honorable dragon.