Are they breaking up or aren't they? It seems to be the eternal question with Long Island emo favorites Brand New , who are keeping things just mysterious enough to confuse the crap out of everyone.

Last night at Saltair in Magna, Utah, at the kickoff show of their tour with Modest Mouse, Lacey told the crowd, "Oh, we're done. Oh yeah, we're done, and it makes nights like this all the more special so thanks for being here." He then launched into the intimate "Sowing Season" from 2006's The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me.

Watch the moment above (courtesy Adam Derfler, thank you). Then click through this list of 21 emo and pop-punk reunions we'd like to see.