1 of 155

Rating: 4 stars Yum! My boyfriend couldn't keep his hands off of these! I took advice from some of the other reviews and made a few changes. I cut the spices down by half and upped it to 3/4 c of eggnog. I also made eggnog frosting using powdered sugar eggnog and a pinch of nutmeg and cinnamon. I dyed the frosting bright yellow to make them a bit more cute. Thumb Up Helpful (189)

Rating: 5 stars Yes the nutmeg flavour is strong they are great warm but also great when they harden. No they are not a fancy cut out or decorated cookie but they are so easy to make! I have given them to many people and used them for a cookie exchange and they were a big hit with everyone. My oldest son loves them my youngest doesn't like them at all. If you like nutmeg cinnamon and eggnog you'll love them. PS. If you don't like them crunchy substitute brown sugar for all or half of the white sugar; they'll stay soft. Thumb Up Helpful (151)

Rating: 5 stars My family loved these. I did make a few changes more eggnog in the cookie dough. Baked for only 15-17 minutes. Made frosting with eggnog powdered sugar and nutmeg. Garnished with sliced almonds. Thumb Up Helpful (112)

Rating: 4 stars THESE COOKIES WITH A FEW CHANGES TURNED OUT GREAT LIKE ANOTHER REVIEWER WE USED 1/2 WHITE AND 1/2 BROWN SUGAR ALSO MADE A SECOND BATCH WITH JUST WHITE SUGAR THE ONES WITH THE BROWN SUGAR WERE BETTER BY FAR ALSO ADDED EXTRA EGGNOG. FOR THE FROSTING I USED CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED RUM. THESE WILL BE USED FOR A COOKIE EXCHANGE THIS WEEKEND. THANKS! Thumb Up Helpful (53)

Rating: 5 stars Made these yesterday and can tell I will need to make again this week. For those who don't think they look pretty; roll dough into 1" balls and bake. When cool sift with combined powdered sugar and nutmeg. Beautiful! Thumb Up Helpful (49)

Rating: 5 stars This is the BEST eggnog cookie I have EVER had!! The only thing I changed was I put about 1/2 cup of eggnog as opposed to the 1/4 cup of eggnog it called for. I think if I had put the requested 1/4 cup in it would not have been enough to give it that distinctive eggnog flavor. It was just right not too strong but not bland either. Yummy!! I HIGHLY recommend this recipe! Thumb Up Helpful (43)

Rating: 5 stars Very yummy!! As others have suggested I used half the nutmeg (ie. 1/2 tsp) and they were perfect... I did not find them "ugly" like some other reviewers said. Not exactly an elegant cookie but not ugly - just make your teaspoons of dough a little bit "rounded" and they should be ok. However I only cooked them for 8-10 minutes -- not the 20-23 minutes called for. Whoa! I would've been calling the fire dept. by then!! DO watch for brown edges on the cookies and then take them out right away - they will remain nice and soft even after cooling. I also made sure to use butter as I had some fairly disappointing results with another cookie recipe recently when I substituted margarine for butter. These are wonderful cookies to share!! Thumb Up Helpful (32)

Rating: 5 stars I tried this recipe last year at Christmas. It was requested again this year. It is now a holiday tradition! I used a cookie press this year which makes more attractive cookies. They are the best! Thumb Up Helpful (24)

Rating: 4 stars This recipe is nice and easy to make. I tried one of the other eggnog cookie recipes and my 4 year old took one bite and gave it back. I tried this one second and everyone loved it. My husband who's a picky eater kept coming back for me. Also definitely cut the nutmeg portion in half. Otherwise it will overpower the cookie. Thumb Up Helpful (23)