Garrett Richards celebrated April Fools’ Day a little early this year, with an epic prank from his teammates (and Jesse and Jeana from Prank Academy on YouTube Red).

The Angels pitcher was part of a group of players approached by a fan while they were waiting for a table for dinner. After taking a selfie with them, the fan asked for ideas on how to break up with her boyfriend.

“Just give it to him straight,” Richards advised.

Later, when the players are seated for dinner, a man approached the group and told them that he’s planning on proposing to his girlfriend. She’s a huge Angels fan, he said, and asked Richards to carry the ring over to the table for the big moment. Because there’s really nothing that he can say but ‘sure’ even though honestly he’s just trying to eat dinner, he agreed.

But when the big moment came?

Spoiler alert! It’s the woman who wanted to break up with her boyfriend.

So awkward.

Finally, after Richards was pretty much frozen with no idea how to handle this very awkward situation, his teammates came over and told him it’s just a joke.