How much do you really hate the notch?

Companies like Oppo and Vivo, which are devoting serious engineering resources to find creative solutions to avoid 2018’s most conspicuous design trend, are hoping that the answer is “a lot.” The Oppo Find X and Vivo Nex both use complex moving parts to hide and reveal components like selfie cameras and face scanners that would otherwise have to be housed in a notch in an “all-screen” phone.

I was in Shanghai and Shenzhen a few weeks ago, and one thing that struck me was the huge, ubiquitous marketing for these two phones. They may not be expected to sell the most units, but they’re also far from wild experiments. They need to execute on their futuristic promise in order to establish each brand as an innovator.

And, based on my time with the flagship Vivo Nex S at least, I can say that it’s a seriously impressive device that essentially delivers on the full-screen phone dream.

The headline feature of the Nex S — its elevating selfie camera — first appeared on Vivo’s Apex concept phone that I saw at Mobile World Congress in February, so that aspect of the hardware wasn’t too novel for me. The biggest change is how the blocky Apex has morphed into an attractive and surprisingly slim premium phone with curved glass and a holographic back panel. The phone does pick up a lot of fingerprints, but the way it shimmers and diffracts in different lighting conditions is just really cool and feels appropriate for a phone positioning itself on the cutting edge.

Importing the Nex I wouldn’t recommend the Chinese Nex S model I’ve been using to anyone in a Western country. It doesn’t come with Google services or the Play Store, so you have to install them through alternate means, which is never going to be as stable as a phone sold through official Android channels. There are also problems with English text rendering throughout the OS, causing odd problems with spacing and punctuation. The Nex S has been confirmed for release in India and elsewhere, however, simply dubbed the Vivo Nex. That model will be a lot more attractive to importers.

So, too, does its spec sheet. Inside there’s a Snapdragon 845 processor, 8GB of RAM, 256GB of storage, a 4,000mAh battery, a dual-camera setup with a 12-megapixel f/1.8 primary module, a headphone jack, a USB-C port, and a huge 6.6-inch 2316 x 1080p OLED screen.

Along with the mediocre haptics and lack of wireless charging, that screen is actually the only part of the phone that doesn’t feel as high-end as it could. Its color reproduction, contrast, and viewing angles are all fine — great, even — and the bezels are almost nonexistent all around (except for the bottom edge, which is roughly twice as thick as the rest). But the resolution is slightly insufficient to be stretched over such an expansive canvas; it’s a PenTile screen, and you can see jagged edges on text if you look closely. This isn’t a huge deal, and I tend to think 1080p is the right choice for most phones, but I feel like Vivo could have sprung for a 1440p panel like Samsung and LG if it really wanted to push the Nex S as the most advanced phone on the market.

The screen does hold one key feature over virtually every other competitor, however: a fingerprint sensor integrated right in the display. This is Vivo’s thing more than anyone else. The company has been showing off prototypes for over a year, and finally it’s shipping the recent flagship X21 phone with the feature. Vivo says the Nex S scanner is “third-generation” with 50 percent higher recognition accuracy and 10 percent higher unlock speed, though, unfortunately, it doesn’t have the Apex’s much bigger sensor area. You still have to place your thumb on a thumbprint-sized icon.

I haven’t noticed any improvement over the second-gen sensor in the X21, to be honest; it works almost exactly the same way, only with an area of the screen that lights up neon green instead of teal. As with the X21, I continue to think this is a preferable option to putting a slightly faster traditional fingerprint sensor on the back of the phone or on a chunky bottom bezel, though reasonable people may disagree.

Nex and security Some reports suggested that the camera could pop up unexpectedly when triggered by API requests from third-party apps such as Telegram. I haven’t been able to replicate this, and, if anything, I’d think users concerned about privacy would appreciate a camera that’s incapable of capturing images unless it’s physically exposed.

I also think the pop-up selfie camera is an acceptable compromise. Unlike the Oppo Find X’s 3D face-scanning array, it’s only called into service when you want to use the camera to take pictures or videos, meaning people who don’t take selfies or video calls regularly won’t see it very often. The mechanism is sturdy and fast enough not to be a practical problem; the camera will be in position by the time you’ve framed your shot. At only five megapixels, though, this probably isn’t the phone for you if selfies are a priority, even with Vivo’s assortment of “Face Beauty” and AI-powered features. It’s fine for my needs, but Vivo is a company that markets many of its phones specifically on their selfie capabilities — some with dual front-facing cameras and 25-megapixel sensors, for example — and this is not one of those phones.

Overall, the Nex S deals with the question of where to put a front-facing camera on a bezel-less device far better than any laptop I’ve seen. Dell’s XPS line continues to place webcams below the screen, resulting in unflattering up-the-nose camera angles, while Huawei’s MateBook X Pro cleverly integrates a camera into the keyboard but with a similar resulting image. Vivo’s camera mechanism isn’t going to be practical in the ultra-thin top halves of most laptops, of course, but that doesn’t make its solution any less ingenious.

The question, however, is whether there’s really much of a problem to solve. Virtually every major Android OEM, from OnePlus to LG to Huawei, has released a phone with a notch already this year, and of course Apple’s instantly recognizable iPhone X design has rendered the idea extremely mainstream. There’s little evidence yet that consumers consider it a dealbreaker.

A problem doesn’t have to be a deal-breaker to have an extremely cool solution, though, and that’s exactly what it feels like to use the Vivo Nex S. I can’t deny that it’s more natural and cohesive to use a near-bezel-less screen with two-way symmetry, with the extra landscape usability and notification visibility that notches trade away. The in-display fingerprint scanner and pop-up selfie camera are serviceable in regular use, and the moving parts aren’t called into action nearly as often as on the Oppo Find X, which has to raise its face scanner every time you unlock the phone.

Is the notch a matter so pressing that it should guide your buying decisions? Probably not. But that doesn’t stop the Nex S from being a good product, arguably the most technically advanced Android phone on the market right now, and one that should make the whole world take a long look at Vivo as a serious company.

Photography by Sam Byford / The Verge