Astronomers just found 12 more moons around Jupiter. One, though, is really weird. Eleven of the newly discovered moons orbit in the same direction as their nearest neighbors. But one doesn’t. And that may put it on a fatal collision course.

“It’s driving down the highway on the wrong side of the road,” says Scott Sheppard. He’s a planetary scientist at the Carnegie Institution for Science in Washington, D.C.

Sheppard and colleagues found the moons while looking for something else entirely. They were searching for a putative planet that could exist beyond the orbit of Neptune. It’s known colloquially as Planet Nine. The researchers were conducting a survey in 2017 of the most distant objects in the solar system using the Victor Blanco 4-meter telescope in Chile. Jupiter happened to be visible in the same area of sky that the team was searching during one of its observing runs. “Might as well kill two birds with one stone,” Sheppard thought.

Educators and Parents, Sign Up for The Cheat Sheet Weekly updates to help you use Science News for Students in the learning environment Client key* E-mail* Go

The researchers found a dozen objects moving around the sun at the same rate as Jupiter. Follow-up observations confirmed the moons’ existence and orbits. Two inner moons orbit in the same direction that Jupiter spins. Nine outer moons orbit the planet in the opposite direction. And then there’s that oddball traveler.

For all but the last one, these motions are normal for Jovian moons, which now number a whopping 79. Scientists think the inner moons formed from a disk of gas and dust that orbited the giant planet in the solar system’s early days. That’s similar to how the planets formed around the sun. The outer moons were probably free-floating space rocks captured when they came too close. Their opposite orbit was set by the direction from which they approached Jupiter.

But one moon broke the mold. The team calls this rock Valetudo after the Roman goddess of health and hygiene. It’s tiny, only about a kilometer (0.6 mile) across. It orbits in the same direction as Jupiter’s spin, but alongside the farther-out moons. As a result, Valetudo is probably doomed to collide with one or more of the other moons someday. The researchers are still calculating when this might happen. But they expect it to occur sometime between 100 million and a billion years from now.

Valetudo may be the last remnant of a bigger object that has already withstood several collisions. Or it could be from a family of moons that has since been smashed to smithereens. “It’s probably the largest surviving member, if not the only one,” Sheppard says.

Such nonconformist satellites are not rare, notes David Jewitt. He’s a planetary scientist at the University of California, Los Angeles, who was not involved in the new work. “But they are very interesting, because we know that they have been captured by their host planets, but we don’t know how, or from where,” he says. Figuring out what oddballs like Valetudo are made of could help nail those details down.