Whoops, sorry!

I don’t think there’s much to be said here: most of those arguments stem from purely subjective reasons, and something subjective can hardly be wrong or right, everyone is entitled to like what they want. In canon, on a more objective level, we know three things for sure:

That Star and Marco work amazingly together and have a great chemistry and like eachother (that has been shown plenty of times throughout all the series, and most recently Booth Buddies confirmed with no room left for doubts that they like eachother romantically, and that the strain their relationship suffered during this season hurt both of them, and they’d like for things to be back to normal). This doesn’t mean that they can’t like other people as well, but it has been made plenty of clear that they are the best option for eachother. And this doesn’t mean that they can never make mistakes or hurt the other or can’t have good moments with other characters. “Jackie was an angel of a person and it was only Marco’s incapability to settle for something that killed their relationship!” that’s true, and? It just means that Marco deep down liked Star more, even if she’s not as perfect as Jackie is. If people can have subjective tastes regarding ships, so the characters in the show can have non objective reasons to like one person more than the other! “Tom helped Star too! And Star helped grow in Demoncism!” absolutely true, it’s not like they can only help their soulmates and not other people. But if the show wants us not to think that, at the end of the day, Star and Marco are the most important person to eachother, then it’s failing big time. THIS DOESN’T MEAN THAT THEY HAVE TO THINK ONLY ABOUT THE OTHER ALL DAY LONG, they are not attached at the hip, but this is a work of fiction for goodness sake, Star forgetting about Meteora destroying her kingdom to help Marco has to mean more than, I don’t know, Star wanting to rush to St. Olga, despite the terror the place instilled in her, to save Pony Head! This- this is not a contest, it’s not like the two things can’t coexist, but the hierarchy of events can’t be ignored either, especially when it’s this painfully clear!



That the other people they dated don’t hold a grudge on them, and they were as inexperienced and confused as they were (Jackie definitely liked Marco, so she wasn’t as ‘confused’, but she understood why their relationship had to end and, while it certainly hurt, she absolutely didn’t seem to hold it against Marco; Tom was probably as ‘confused’ as Star was when they began their new relationship, misguided in what he think he wanted, and the recent season finale put a strong argument for FRIEND vs BOYFRIEND and showed what makes Tom happier, and what helps him being the best person, and despite knowing about the kiss, despite his personality, he didn’t react with anger at all, and if this doesn’t tell us that the break up is going to be more than amicable I don’t know what could);





And that the Blood Moon is absolutely not a “love potion” or something that forces feelings. Maybe it’s a curse, maybe it’s a prophecy, maybe it’s a huge sphere of evil, but it definitely didn’t force Marco and Star to like eachother, nor it influenced their feelings.