So Marlene tweeted that the actor who plays A finally knew he/she was A on June 4, roughly 7 weeks ago…

Yesterday stills from 6x09 got released and there’s photos of Ali talking to a masked person, who at first glance looks so much like Jason that everyone assumed it was Jason. But it’s not Jason/Drew in that photo. In the caption it shows the name Justin Fix.

Justin is not listed on IMDB or anywhere with the show as ever appearing on PLL before, but his website and all his online acting resumes show him in a “guest star” role for PLL, so that is for sure him in the picture. So why introduce a new actor in 6x09 if it isn’t Charles? Why put him in a mask? Why make him look EXACTLY like Jason (that hair is sooooo Jason)?

I think Justin is no other than Charles. Justin even looks like what I would think is a good sibling for Ali and Jason.

I think ABC Family released Justin’s name by accident. I think we were supposed to just assume it is Jason in the photo, but I think Justin’s name slipped through the cracks. I also think that maybe Ali even thinks it’s Jason in the photo. Her facial expression tells me she’s confused or concerned. I think she thinks it’s Jason but something isn’t adding up right… meaning that it’s actually Charles, not Jason she’s talking to.

Ok so why mention that tweet by Marlene? Well Justin posted this photo of his script roughly 7 weeks ago right when he found out he got a part on PLL and then he posted a set photo 6 weeks ago. The script photo was almost immediately deleted after his name got “leaked” on the photo and someone commented on it asking if he was Charles.

Ok so I know what people will say, “but Marlene said we’ve seen the actor before. She’s said it wasn’t some new person.” My response to this is why would she tell us it would be a new person playing Charles/A? If she said it wasn’t an actor we’ve seen before, then we wouldn’t be theorizing about who on the current cast it could be. If we knew that we’ve never seen the actor before, then we wouldn’t be having tumblr/reddit/twitter fights about if it’s Wren or CeCe or someone else. She had to LIE to us about who Charles would be so we would remain involved in creating theories.

Now I don’t think Justin as Charles will be a bad guy. I think Wren and/or CeCe is still A. I think Charles will be just another puppet in their game, but I truly believe that Justin will be playing Charles.

