Jacoby Jones -- WR, 2008-11

Were it not for his epic postseason run and deep run on the latest season of Dancing with the Stars, it's likely Jacoby Jones would hardly be known by the common football fan. Unless of course, that football fan was a Houton Texans fan. Then, they might remember Jones for never developing into the No. 2 receiver they wanted him to be. Jones, a third-round pick for the Texans in 2007, had flashes of potential, like when he caught six touchdowns in 2009 on only 27 receptions. Yet, the next year, he saw his yards-per-catch average drop by five, and his touchdown total was cut in half -- on 24 more receptions. It's not as if the expectations for Jones were ever sky-high, but Jones' flashes of potential outweighed his actual performance, and as such he's an unfortunate victim on the overrated list.