Baseball can be a very complicated game with its abundance of rules, but a baseball player is expected to, at minimum, be able to count to three and keep track of the number of outs.

Phillies outfielder Odubel Herrera had trouble with that on Thursday. During the eighth inning of a 10-1 game against Toronto, Herrera caught a Michael Saunders fly ball. He then proceeded to jog and toss the ball into the stands unaware that his catch was just the second out.

[mlbvideo id=”822645383″ width=”600″ height=”324″ /]

Now, if there was nobody on base, that wouldn’t be a problem for Herrera. But Edwin Encarnacion was on first, and by rule, he was given two bases.

The Phillies also didn’t escape Herrera’s mental error unscathed. The Blue Jays scored three more runs in the eighth.