This coupe managed to sneak on to our list because somehow Audi decided that an all-wheel-drive system was something people wanted on a coupe, and somehow we decided to filter out those "impractical" sports cars by eliminating anything with a rear-wheel-drive. Oops. In any case, here the RS5 is, and here it's going to stay. What do we like about it? A combined mpg of 21 is not bad (we suspect it would even be a notch or two better if it were rear-wheel-drive, but then again in that case it wouldn't make our list). What else makes this car Wyse? At about $70k, it's not the sticker price. Don't worry, Audi's depreciate notoriously quick, and we don't typically recommend buying new anyways. What we like about the RS5 is you get to take advantage of Audi's renown reliability ratings. 0-60 in 3.9 seconds, 21 mpg, AND low maintenance costs? We'll take it.

Horsepower: 450

Combined FE: 21

MSRP: $69,900