Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford is rated 4.4 out of 5 by 1214 .

Rated 1 out of 5 by Trey from Defective return replaced with exact same shoe Long time AE customer but no more. I received my original pairof Park Ave's in Dark Chili and returned due to poor quality. Poor quality was noted on the RMA. Today, two months later I receive my replacement and it's the exact same pair that I returned. Literally, not figuratively! I am positive because the original pair had unique stains on them as well as a rough patch of leather in the exact same spot. Unacceptable. I will return these and switch to another brand. I've noticed a downward trend in quality over my last few pairs. My last pair of black Park Ave's had similar quality issues but I sucked it up. No more!

Rated 5 out of 5 by WINOLOGY from Good Purchase I purchased two pairs of Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford in black and coffee. After lacing up the shoes and wearing them around the house I knew I made a good purchase. I wear an 8.5 D. The length of both pairs is spot on. The width is slightly narrow. I wore the same thin socks during my check-out that I wear to work. Not sure the shoes will fit well if I wear thicker socks. Craftsmanship was what I expected - very good. Shoes were well packaged and the shipping box arrived in good condition. Delivery was prompt and communication from Allen Edmond was good. Time will tell if I should have ordered an 8.5 E. I think the leather will stretch a bit over time. I hope Allen Edmonds will also offer this shoe in dark brown and mahogany. If it did I would have bought four pairs. I will recommend this shoe and brand to friends.

Rated 1 out of 5 by Jpizzle from Causes extreme pain in heel After being fitted at two stores to confirm the sizing result, I took the plunge on these a little over 2 years ago. I returned to the store saying they felt tight but they assured me this was the right size and I needed to wear them in a bit. Unfortunately, this never happened. I've tried over and over to wear these, but I'm always in extreme pain by the end of the day, which is so severe it lasts through the next day (wearing other shoes.) They look nice but are ultimately a complete waste.