#AEndingFridays Post 3 - Someone Call Security

In Season 4 episode 2, ‘A’ was seen feeding Tippi, a parrot that was stolen from Spencer’s room earlier in the episode. Reviewing the episode I picked up on a small clue that lead me to the Halloween web series, Pretty Dirty Secrets which showed us what was going in Rosewood leading up to the Halloween Special ‘This is a Dark Ride.”

In webisode 1x07 ‘Call Security,’ A was shown breaking into the Halloween costume shop where Shana worked. As he was hiding from the security officer, he pulled out a knife. This knife is the exact same knife we see later in 4.02. I believe this person is Noel Kahn, because of his recent involvement with Ali, which was brought to light in 4.24.

Noel Kahn has played both sides (Team Ali and Team Jenna). I believe he is the guy with the knife because he mentioned to Spencer in 5.09 “our friend likes to throw away people when she’s done with them and I need to be prepared.” Also, Alison told the girls in 4.24 finale that Noel Kahn has secrets as well, going off of this evidence I think that Ali blackmailed Noel to help her and what she has on him is that he is gay.

I know this is a major accusation and there’s no real evidence to back it up at this point but in the PLL books Noel Kahn’s father was a cross dresser and wouldn’t it be pretty sneaky if the writers incorporated this into the storyline but instead of the cross dresser being Noel’s father (whom we never met), it is Noel Kahn. He would fit the ‘A’ person in the webisode series perfectly due to him caressing the blonde wig, and his admiration for CeCe Drake. Noel is very familiar with her according to 5.01, when the trio were at the diner in Manhattan. Another thing, this could also be a major hint for the storyline in 5B which introduces a new gay male character which Spencer will come in contact with. I’m thinking that since the liars will be searching Alison’s house in the Christmas special they could find some piece of evidence that will lead them to a new character (just a guess). If this is the case then Noel’s secret won’t stay a secret for long.

Other things to take into consideration:

Noel broke into Jenna’s home to get look for something when the Cavanaugh home blew up. It is very possible he broke into Spencer’s home to retrieve Tippi. Him picking up the officer badge in the web series foreshadowed Officer Garrett’s death in 3.13. His secret could be he is gay. Caressing the wig would indicate an infatuation with womanly things and admiration for CeCe Drake. Also, possible link to the 5B storyline and introduction of new gay male character. I realize the new guy that Spencer will meet in 5B but I think his connection could link to Noel. I’m not saying Noel is the new gay guy, only that his character is undercover and that’s the secret that Ali have on him.

Basically, Ali has been blackmailing Noel into helping her due to his secret. Therefore, Noel has been putting in overtime covering tracks and gathering evidence of his own against Ali.