Court: No Warrant Needed For Police to Snag Cell Location Data

Article Comments 12

May 6, 2015, 8:01 AM by Eric M. Zeman @zeman_e

A federal court ruled police can obtain cell phone location records from carriers without first getting a warrant. A Florida man, Quartavious Davis, convicted of seven armed robberies in 2010 argued the cell phone records used to place him in the vicinity of the robberies were protected under the Fourth Amendment. A Florida court initially agreed with Davis' argument, but the Justice Department appealed that ruling and heard the case earlier this year. The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the Florida ruling and said Davis' rights against unreasonable search and seizure were not violated. "Davis has no subjective or objective reasonable expectation of privacy in MetroPCS's business records showing the cell tower locations that wirelessly connected his calls at or near the time of six of the seven robberies," said the federal judges. They maintain the records were created by MetroPCS and belong to that company rather than Davis. The ruling applies to law enforcement activity in Alabama, Georgia, and Florida, which fall under the purview of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court. "The reach of the majority opinion is breathtaking," said Davis' attorney. "It means that the government can get anything stored by a third party: your Facebook posts, your Amazon purchases, your internet search history, even the documents and pictures you store in the cloud, all without a warrant." Though law enforcement agencies in these three states can obtain cell records from carriers without a warrant, they cannot search individual cell phones without a warrant. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2013 that police must obtain a warrant before searching actual handsets.

NBC News »

AD

This forum is closed.

This forum is closed.

T Bone



The Solution to this Password protect your phone and tell the cops that they can have the password when they get a court order and a proper search warrant. Mark_S

Hopefully no excuse is found for them to slap on the cuffs at that point. 😲 arox413

That's only a solution if they get it off of your phone and not from the provider, which it sounds like that's where it came from in this case. ...

acdc1a



4th Amendment The 4th Amendment has been dead in this country for years. Unfortunately we keep electing fools who install fools into the court. Fortunately the 1st Amendment is OK for now. navydave

The message here should be simple. Don't text and rob. If you must break the law turn your cellphone off first. And in the effort to save the FBI tons of money and time. Yes!! I did buy a Firestick on AZ. ... Jon_Doh

Is alive and well. Orwell's prediction came true 30 years late.



If you think the 1st amendment is alive and well try saying certain things in a cell phone conversation and watch how fact men in black show up on your doorstep to cart you away to ...

(continues) ...