My rematch paid attention to the keywords Fairy and Things that Smell good.

Amy Brown Necklace, Figurine, and Coffee Cup. And a Gold Canyon Scent Pod Warmer with three Scent Pods: Coconut Mango Breeze, Pineapple Coast, and Apple Spice.

Thank you SO much!! I couldn't expect more from a re-match who was also not gifted the first time around.