Higgins Mill Boot with Dainite Sole is rated 4.4 out of 5 by 262 .

Rated 2 out of 5 by uglystik from Poor Manufacturing/QC It took two returns and a fresh pair being shipped from the factory to get a pair that didn't have obvious defects. After wearing this new pair three times, I've noticed several issues that you wouldn't expect from a company of this reputation or from a boot that costs $400+ after tax. There is stitching coming out. The sole on the left toe is separating. And when I walk down stairs and step on the right foot, it sounds like there is air swooshing out from a void somewhere in the sole. Will most likely be my last pair of AE.

Rated 2 out of 5 by Alexander from Loved at first, Stretched out so wide. Bummed they're useless now Hope you find this helpful. I was told to purchase the Natural model true to size (10.5 D) and at first they fit great and I really loved them! Very versatile and cool. Though after wearing them for a few months, they've stretched out so much, especially in the width. Now my foot is just swimming in them. Even trying to fix the problem with heavy wool socks on the other day I managed to sprain my ankle because they've stretched out so much. I now have useless wide boots, they do look nice though.... it's a shame

Rated 3 out of 5 by Dennis14 from Heel started to separate Purchased the first purple back in September because I’ve been wanting a solid pair of boots. Went with AE because of their reputation for quality. I noticed after about 2 months the heels started to separate from the sole. I went to my local AE shop and they said they’ve never seen anything like it and offered to send me a new pair. Waited a week before they came in. When I got the replacement pair, first thing I noticed was that they didn’t come with the shoe sleeve like the firstborn pair I had. Not too big of a deal so I didnt bother. After not even a handful of wears, the heels started to separate again! Brought them back to the store and again they said what are you doing with the shoes because we’ve never heard of this happening. They were willing to replace them but said they’re out of stock until after the holidays. So now I’m stuck with a $400 (original price that I paid) boot that’s falling apart with each wear. Pretty disappointed considering the cost.