So my first Trick or Treat Santa never sent me anything. It was my first exchange, and I was so bummed - between a no-show gifter and a giftee who never even thanked me, I felt like the exchange was a huge mistake. Then my unknown rematch benefactor stepped in to show me how exciting exchanges can be! After they confirmed the gift shipped, I was thrilled, and eagerly awaited my package ... and I finally got it yesterday! Even more, my wonderful rematch hinted that there might be another gift coming! Thank you, rematch Santa; you really made my whole week.

UPDATE: I did indeed get another gift, but it took it a little while to cross the ocean! It was an amazing and very Halloween-y nail polish! My rematch Santa is the best. It is known.