Having been a World of Warcraft player since the very beginning (and owning all Collecters Editions except the first one, stupid me) I can honestly say that this is THE best expansion for WoW Blizzard has ever released. I only reactivated my account because my kids wanted to try it and Im glad they made me change my mind. After the last 2 expansions I was skeptical there would be anything that would make me want to play in WoW any more. They have made changes to the play mechanics which take a little getting used to if you like the previous ones. However the changes are for the better once you experience them. There are a hugh number of intricate story lines that just keep going and going across multiple zones. Finally I have a desire to actually read the quests before accepting them. Unlike the previous expansions there seems to be a depth to the amount of content that makes me want to enjoy the trip rather than simply "get to the end" and be level capped. The ability to choose where I start in the new Broken Isles and how I progress is a refreshing change to the previous expansions that had a mostly fixed zone progression. Thats nice since I can take control and visit zones that suit my characters needs and my interests at the time. Plus Blizzard managed to put in an impressive feel to each of the zones that made me want to stop and look around. I can't say when the last time that happened in WoW but its been a VERY long time. The only down side to this one is that some quest chains require you to visit instances to complete. If you are a casual gamer (or are in a Guild that never does anything together) and hate waiting in the 30+ minute Looking For Group queues then you will not like that change. The wait times seem to be getting longer as fewer players are doing the regular instances and the players who want to level their professions have already done their forced runs. Still this is a relatively small ding against what is definitely a worthwhile expansion pack. I have yet to savor the extra Collectors Editions goodies much. They all are extremely well done and worth the extra cost over the regular version. The caliber of the material is on par with the previous CE versions of WoW Expansions. I VERY rarely score anything the maximum (or minimum) score simply because I rate on a bell curve. It takes real effort to score top or bottom marks in my book. In this case I think Blizzard has definitely gone above and beyond to make Legion a top notch expansion that all WoW players will enjoy.