hump was lower and broader, and started centuries earlier, and was already

surpassed by Modern Warming by 2000 or possibly as early as 1950.

32B) The solar-output graph is remarkably similar to Earth's surface-temperature

graph, matching it as far back as 10,000 years in: (A) overall hockey-stick shape

(Usoskin et al. 2005); (B) existence of superimposed short-term (decades-centuries)

up-down 'sawteeth'; (C) proportionality (i.e. relative height of 'shaft' versus 'blade');

(D) pre-eminence of the impressive post-1700 rise in both graphs; and (E) similar

ratio between average sawtooth amplitude and final-spike height. There is also a

graph- to -graph cross-match of numerous peaks and troughs (with a ~60-100-year

lag-time; Bullet 21). Thus, dominant solar control of Earth's temperature is beyond

doubt. In stark contrast, the only match between CO2 and temperature in the last

10,000 years is the apparent correlation after 1850, with both CO2 and temperature

rising impressively (Bullets 8, 11). Further proving the accidental nature of this

coincidence, CO2 sawteeth for the entire 10,000 years to 1850 are tiny in comparison

to the post-1850 spike, and they do not correlate with the temperature sawteeth.

33) The IPCC assures us that Earth's temperature is controlled by CO2 and that the

Sun has minuscule or zero effect. This is precisely backwards. In truth, solar-

magnetic output controls our climate (Svensmark effect, Bullet 14) and CO2 has little

or no influence (Bullets 1, 10, 11, 19, 32). Varying solar output even controls the

timing of large earthquakes, making it even harder to believe the IPCC's claim that

the Sun might not affect climate.

CONCLUSION

'Man-made global warming' is readily demolished in just 500 words ...

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/341622566_IPCC_three_pillars_of_man-

made_global_warming_collapsed

These 33 bullets collectively prove that any CO2 effect on global temperatures of the

Holocene period (i.e. the last 11,650 years), including the 'Modern Warming' period,

was too small to detect. Instead temperature changes were driven almost entirely by

solar changes (superimposed on a long-term decline due to Earth's declining axial

obliquity). Evidently CO2's greenhouse effect was already essentially exhausted at

the lower CO2 concentrations of pre-Holocene time, due to the 'saturation effect'

and, presumably, an already insignificant 'climate sensitivity' (Bullet 5B), explaining

‘The Holocene Temperature Conundrum’ (Bullet 19). Ongoing Modern Warming,

which I predict will last until ~2050 (Bullet 21), will be >99% due to the Sun. Any

future CO2 effect will be minuscule, swamped by Sun-driven warming and, after

~2050, cooling.

___________________________________________________________________________

GERMAN TRANSLATION of the first 25 of these 32 bullet points ...

https://www.eike-klima-energie.eu/2019/06/18/25-punkte-die-beweisen-dass- co2 -

keine-globale-erwaermung-verursacht-diesmal- von -einem-geologen/

CHINESE TRANSLATION ...

https://principia-scientific.org/ 全球 变 暖的元凶是太阳而不是二氧化碳 - 换 个角度看 /