The man's wife took the case to the Brisbane Supreme Court to manage her deceased husband's estate. Her argument suggested the text was not valid because it was never sent. But, judge Susan Brown said the phrasing of the message (which included the words "my will") indicated the man was of sound mind. In the text, he'd also directed for his ashes to be put "in the back garden," and wrote that he had a "bit of cash behind TV and bit in the bank." The decision also took into account evidence of the man's fraught relationship with his wife.

The Queensland government advises that a valid will must typically be in writing and signed in front of two witnesses. But, a change in the law in 2006 allowed for less formal types of documents to be considered as well. A holographic will, without witnesses, being deemed acceptable isn't a new phenomenon. For instance, the shortest will to historically be recorded was of a Czech man who scribbled "everything to wife" on his bedroom wall in anticipation of his death. A dying Canadian farmer's will, etched onto the fender of a tractor he was trapped beneath, was also determined by the courts to be valid almost 70 years ago.