ANOTHER UPDATE!: Today I received yet another box from my super-rematch. Not from Amazon this time...it was a box with three candy corn candles!! They are in a place of honor in my entryway, I shall not sully the candles by doing something so pedestrian as LIGHTING them. It will be nice to have a reminder each year of the fun that I've had with this exchange. Thanks again, no-longer-anonymous redditor - you've made it great!

UPDATE: Today I received ANOTHER shipment of awesome. I was thrilled when the candy corn fell out (mmmm....candy corn), but then The Nightmare Before Christmas tumbled onto the table! I do not own this, I can't wait to watch it. I also received a comically honest gift note, which I appreciated.

Thanks again no-longer-anonymous redditor! You are aces in my book, and I still have one more box coming! Squee!

After my original match totally welched I was lucky enough to be rematched with a semi-anonymous redditor now known as Derek. I received an email that day letting me know he was reviewing my comment history and that fun would commence in the form of multiple shipments.

Today I received my first box (from AMAZON, my favorite place ever) and it held Candy Corn M&Ms. Beautifully selected, as I love all things candy corn and had been having trouble finding them in stores. Excellent comment history perusal.

Thanks semi-anonymous Derek, you made my whole week! I will update as the other shipments arrive, I am tracking them closely.