Sometime around the first of the year, as I sat down to take inventory of my tobacco cellar, I was struck by how many of my favorite blends come from a single blender: G.L. Pease. I'm not sure any line of tobaccos has achieved a more elevated status among American pipe smokers. Each new release is an event here at Smokingpipes.com as customers clamor to get their hands on the new blend.

As often as I have reached for Greg's tobaccos over the years, at the time there were still more than half of them that I had not smoked. Sitting in the floor of my home office that day, I resolved to work my way through the entire collection. I set some simple rules to help focus my sampling and rein in my omnivorous tobacco tendencies:

I would smoke a full tin of each blend, even if I initially disliked it. I would only sample fresh tins. While Pease's blends are designed to improve over time, I wanted to sample them fresh from our amply stocked warehouse. I would only keep two tins open at any given time. Finally, I decided that I would share my experience here at the SPC blog by offering some thoughts about the tobaccos that comprise each series.

The release of Greg's new blend, Sixpence, was the perfect opportunity to reflect on the blends that started the Pease phenomenon, the Original Mixtures. What follows is not an in-depth review of each tobacco, but rather one pipe guy's field notes from an intriguing and rewarding journey.

Greg is justly celebrated as a master when it comes to producing Latakia blends. Indeed, it was his English and Balkan blends that piqued my interest three or four years ago when I purchased my first tin of Maltese Falcon (Okay, I'll admit it: the fact that I'm a sucker for the film probably played a role in making this my first Pease blend too). It's easy to see how Pease solidified his reputation as Lord Latakia with the Original Mixtures.

Caravan, Odyssey, Samarra, and Robusto are remarkable blends and demonstrate the versatility of the smoky leaf, as well as the blender's ability to use it in a variety of ways. Caravan is probably the Latakia blend in the series that I find myself reaching for most often. It epitomizes so many of the things that I find appealing in a Balkan-style blend: the leathery notes of the Latakia, the spice of the Oriental tobaccos, and the sweetness of quality red Virginia, all of which come together to form one harmonious bouquet. At the same time, there's an aspect of Caravan that strikes me as distinctive. While most Latakia blends have a woodsy aroma and flavor, they almost always call to mind cedar or a similar conifer. As others have noted, however, Caravan has a hickory note that we seldom find in a Latakia blend. No matter how many bowls I smoke, that element always surprises and delights my palate. Over the course of this experiment, Caravan has actually displaced Odyssey as my favorite Latakia blend in the series.

Odyssey and Samarra

There was a time when I smoked at least one bowl of Odyssey almost every day, but I just don't favor the big Latakia blends in the way that I used to. Don't get me wrong, Odyssey is still a go-to choice on certain occasions — a dreary winter afternoon or a cold night by the fire, but living here in coastal South Carolina, there really aren't too many of those occasions. Still, smoking the tin of Odyssey was a bit like a chance meeting with an old flame. We got comfortable with each other again, and on a few occasions I wondered why our romance didn't last. As big as Odyssey is —and as Greg himself notes, it is huge — I was again surprised by just how graceful and elegant a smoke it is. I think what makes Odyssey so much better than other blends in this genre is just how tightly knit the various constituent tobaccos are. It's like hearing Rachmaninov's Vespers. Taken separately, the voices all sing in strikingly different registers, but sung right it sounds like one big voice. That's what smoking Odyssey is like for me. As such, I think Odyssey and Samarra make for an interesting juxtaposition. Where Odyssey is rich and full, Samarra is more delicate and more complex. Samarra is like Mozart, and its appeal is probably more universal.

In some ways, it's a little misleading to group Robusto with the other Latakia blends in this series, as cigar leaf is the most distinctive condimental tobacco used in the blend. I smoked this blend in early fall and found it perfectly suited to an afternoon smoke. It's earthy and musty, but sweet and spicy at the same time. Just as Greg recommends, it pairs perfectly with a strong cup of coffee, which seems to accentuate the blend's sweetness. Like its sister blend — Key Largo — it's one of the few pipe tobaccos with cigar leaf that I enjoy.

While the Latakia blends in the Original Mixtures have been among Greg's most successful, I think anyone who works his way through the series is sure to be equally impressed by the quality of the blends that I'll broadly group into a Virginia or Virginia-Burley family here. My favorite of these blends are Cumberland and Haddo's Delight. In bolder moods, perhaps fortified with a glass or two of wine, I've argued that Cumberland is Pease's best blend. There is something about the tin note that I find indescribably delicious. It's sweet and earthy — really earthy. Virginia and Kentucky take the lead in the first half of the bowl, but they are quickly joined by a rich bass note of Perique. The character of the smoke continues to darken as the bowl progresses. The most remarkable aspect of this blend is its complexity. In some sense, it's a fairly simple blend of Burley, Virginia, and Perique. Yet Pease manages to use those three notes to produce an absolute symphony of flavor. This one is a masterpiece.

Some people may sneak into the kitchen at midnight for cookies and milk. I snuck into the den to light up a bowl of Haddo's