Warning: spoilers ahead! In exclusive interviews, Bachelor in Paradise cast members tell Life & Style that there may be a proposal in store for this season’s strongest couple, Derek Peth and Taylor Nolan, on the live finale.

Host Chris Harrison recently said no one got engaged during filming, but the finale will be live for the first time ever. “I definitely see Derek and Taylor getting engaged,” Christen Whitney, 25, predicts.

MORE: ‘Bachelor in Paradise’ Spoilers — Everything You Need to Know About Season 4’s Steamy Romances!

Adam Gottschalk agrees, telling us that the pair had the hottest hookup on the show. Ben Zorn, 28, adds, “From early on, you could tell there was something between the two of them.

“They seem to be going pretty strong,” he says. We’ll be keeping our fingers crossed.

For exclusive details on all the drama from this season of Bachelor in Paradise, pick up the new issue of Life & Style, on stands now!