I've been using a Startech PEXHDCAP for a long time. An internal card, that is, it's a rebranded Micomsoft that I absolutely adore. I use it to capture HDMI 360 footage, component PS3, and SCART>component Saturn footage. The thing is an amazing beast for retro footage, which is why I got it - it's one of the few current market capcards that can handle a Genesis signal properly. The fact that it can handle a 360 HDMI signal fine too is a bonus...I just find it odd that it won't show the PS4 signal even after I turned off HDCP and restarted the system a few times. I also tried setting it to 720p, and messing with the other settings. Still audio only.