Smith is entering his fourth year in the league -- his third without a broken jaw -- but has yet to silence his many detractors. The former West Virginia quarterback is turnover-prone, has accuracy and leadership issues and makes questionable decisions that make MetLife maniacs cringe. Still, Smith has "had the tools" since he was drafted in 2012 and always gets talked up prior to training camp; before he got popped in the face by IK Enemkpali last season, Smith was the favorite to win the starting role over Fitzpatrick.