Sanford Cap-Toe Derby Dress Shoe is rated 4.1 out of 5 by 207 .

Rated 4 out of 5 by Sac Edgar from My introduction to AE These were the first pair of AE's I purchased. These are beautiful, casual shoes. The leather is nice and should age nicely. They are a little narrow in my opinion.

Rated 3 out of 5 by Chris S. from My First Pair of Allen Edmonds Shoes Ordered the Sanfords, in black, 9D, on clearance, so for an AE shoe, the price is good. My only complaint is that when looking down at the toes, the toe shapes are different from one another. The left is more triangular while the right is more rounded. The distance from the tip of the shoe to the first perforated hole on the toe is different on each shoe. Without a picture it can be difficult to explain. Had I paid full price, I would return them. I'm on the fence as to whether I'll try another pair, but it wouldn't be at full price for sure.

Rated 1 out of 5 by TexasDad from Sole broke and has a hole! After wearing around 30-40 times in 2 years, the sole broke and has a hole. When I reached customer service, they told it might be due to weather or hard surface(?!?). They told I need to pay around 100+ dollars for repair. Thanks. But No,Thanks. My other shoes last longer and doesn't cost me even the repair price.