So we came up with 3 solutions on how this could be done.

Draft 1

We removed the ‘favorite’ icon and instead added a ‘transfer’ icon. First we thought it was a great and easy fix, but thinking about replacing a action with another one in the same spot, this could create a lot problems with users already using this button to favorite. So this is a no-go.

Draft 2

The Floating Action Button before just opened a money that showed the ‘favorite’ and ‘transfer’ action. Why have two ‘favorite’ actions on the same view? Well, so we removed the opening of a menu, and made this button to just do the transfer. The problem though with using a FAB to do the transfer action only, is that transferring a Pokémon isn’t the primary action, or an action that is should be promoted per se. So this draft is a no-go too.

Draft 3

Boom! We like this solution. The ‘transfer’ button is grouped in with the other buttons and we colored it red, to show it’s a danger action — since it’s doing something presumably dangerous to make your cute Pokémon into candy.

This looks a lot like Pokémon Go v 1. but we moved the button higher up and colored it red. So now you don’t have to scroll down and can spot it.

All of the screens use the confirmation-dialog to make sure the users really want to do that to their cute Pokémon.