Adam McCann, Financial Writer

Oct 23, 2019

What does it take to be a true baseball fan? Mostly a lot of patience and sometimes a lot of money, depending on how closely you want to follow the sport. In this slow-paced ballgame, hits and home runs are less frequent than strikes and misses. Yet baseball claims the title of Americans’ third most popular sport, after football and basketball.

Fans are willing to pay top dollar to see a game, too, especially during the highly anticipated World Series that kicks off every October. Of course, tickets are kinder to the wallet during the regular season. But to see Game 1 of the 115th World Series on Oct. 22, for instance, the cheapest seat at Minute Maid Park in Houston would cost $471, according to TicketIQ. For Game 7 on Oct. 30 at the same stadium, the damage would range from a starting price of $559 all the way to a whopping $16,450, as of Oct. 23. That doesn’t leave much room for peanuts and cracker jacks. And that’s not mentioning the hundreds of millions of dollars wagered by the betting market every year.

But it’s more fun, not to mention cheaper, to love on baseball in certain parts of America, so which cities would fans consider a home run? WalletHub crunched the numbers to find out, comparing 361 of the largest U.S. cities with at least one professional or college baseball team, grouped by division. In each city, we looked at 31 key indicators of baseball fan-friendliness. They range from performance level of team(s) to average ticket price per game to stadium accessibility. Read on for the winners, a ranking by city size and a full description of our methodology.

Below the rankings, you’ll find commentary from baseball experts about the challenges facing the sport, advice on enjoying the ballgame on a budget and more. Make sure to also check out WalletHub's 2019 World Series Facts – Astros vs Nationals infographic for fun and interesting stats about the matchup.

Main Findings

Best Baseball Cities





Ranking by City Size

Rank

(1 = Best) Large City

(Score) Rank

(1 = Best) Midsize City

(Score) Rank

(1 = Best) Small City

(Score) 1 New York, NY

(57.93) 1 Cincinnati, OH

(41.54) 1 Annapolis, MD

(20.68) 2 Los Angeles, CA

(53.16) 2 St. Petersburg, FL

(36.31) 2 Clemson, SC

(19.22) 3 St. Louis, MO

(49.16) 3 Spokane, WA

(20.81) 3 Oxford, MS

(18.83) 4 Boston, MA

(47.63) 4 Durham, NC

(20.16) 4 Johnson City, TN

(18.71) 5 Chicago, IL

(46.07) 5 Birmingham, AL

(19.57) 5 Starkville, MS

(18.37) 6 Atlanta, GA

(44.97) 6 Richmond, VA

(19.36) 6 State College, PA

(18.36) 7 San Francisco, CA

(43.59) 7 Greensboro, NC

(19.30) 7 Binghamton, NY

(18.16) 8 Arlington, TX

(42.14) 8 Eugene, OR

(18.98) 8 Lynchburg, VA

(18.11) 9 Oakland, CA

(41.62) 9 South Bend, IN

(18.37) 9 Orem, UT

(17.21) 10 Pittsburgh, PA

(41.18) 10 Springfield, MO

(18.25) 10 Buies Creek, NC

(16.95) 11 Minneapolis, MN

(38.98) 11 Lowell, MA

(18.19) 11 Fort Myers, FL

(16.80) 12 Cleveland, OH

(38.80) 12 Charleston, SC

(18.08) 12 Greenville, SC

(16.74) 13 Detroit, MI

(36.88) 13 Peoria, IL

(17.89) 13 Hanover, NH

(16.71) 14 Baltimore, MD

(36.77) 14 Winston-Salem, NC

(17.80) 14 Asheville, NC

(16.63) 15 Houston, TX

(36.71) 15 Norfolk, VA

(17.54) 15 Chapel Hill, NC

(15.67) 16 Milwaukee, WI

(36.36) 16 Dayton, OH

(17.49) 16 Spartanburg, SC

(15.65) 17 Philadelphia, PA

(36.09) 17 Baton Rouge, LA

(17.49) 17 Charlottesville, VA

(15.54) 18 Washington, DC

(35.94) 18 Salt Lake City, UT

(17.39) 18 Champaign, IL

(15.49) 19 San Diego, CA

(34.21) 19 Fort Wayne, IN

(16.85) 19 Kingston, RI

(15.23) 20 Phoenix, AZ

(34.15) 20 Ann Arbor, MI

(16.66) 20 Jacksonville, AL

(15.20) 21 Seattle, WA

(34.15) 21 Mobile, AL

(16.51) 21 Fairfield, CT

(15.07) 22 Kansas City, MO

(33.96) 22 Montgomery, AL

(16.11) 22 West Point, NY

(15.06) 23 Denver, CO

(33.43) 23 Gainesville, FL

(15.75) 23 Elon, NC

(14.93) 24 Miami, FL

(29.37) 24 New Haven, CT

(15.65) 24 Athens, OH

(14.61) 25 Indianapolis, IN

(20.69) 25 Knoxville, TN

(15.41) 25 Cullowhee, NC

(14.59) 26 Nashville, TN

(19.80) 26 Tempe, AZ

(15.20) 26 Mount Pleasant, MI

(14.56) 27 San Antonio, TX

(19.16) 27 Columbia, SC

(15.04) 27 Cookeville, TN

(14.55) 28 Tulsa, OK

(18.62) 28 Cambridge, MA

(14.77) 28 Fishkill, NY

(14.55) 29 Louisville, KY

(18.20) 29 Providence, RI

(14.50) 29 Princeton, NJ

(14.42) 30 Fresno, CA

(17.77) 30 Jackson, MS

(14.24) 30 Morgantown, WV

(14.40) 31 Austin, TX

(17.57) 31 Tallahassee, FL

(14.07) 31 New Britain, CT

(14.39) 32 Jacksonville, FL

(16.70) 32 Columbia, MO

(13.91) 32 Kent, OH

(14.35) 33 Lexington, KY

(16.66) 33 Newark, NJ

(13.82) 33 Stanford, CA

(14.34) 34 Charlotte, NC

(16.60) 34 High Point, NC

(13.62) 34 Radford, VA

(14.26) 35 Albuquerque, NM

(16.41) 35 Buffalo, NY

(13.38) 35 Stillwater, OK

(14.24) 36 Corpus Christi, TX

(16.25) 36 Rochester, NY

(13.35) 36 Pullman, WA

(14.10) 37 Columbus, OH

(16.14) 37 Berkeley, CA

(13.17) 37 Grambling, LA

(13.95) 38 Tampa, FL

(15.88) 38 Provo, UT

(12.71) 38 Corvallis, OR

(13.89) 39 New Orleans, LA

(15.66) 39 Wilmington, NC

(12.68) 39 Morehead, KY

(13.88) 40 Memphis, TN

(15.57) 40 Greeley, CO

(12.62) 40 Boca Raton, FL

(13.85) 41 Stockton, CA

(14.90) 41 Toledo, OH

(12.54) 41 Statesboro, GA

(13.82) 42 Las Vegas, NV

(14.88) 42 Reno, NV

(12.51) 42 Coral Gables, FL

(13.80) 43 Tucson, AZ

(13.57) 43 Clarksville, TN

(12.28) 43 Trenton, NJ

(13.78) 44 Fort Worth, TX

(12.09) 44 Hartford, CT

(12.26) 44 Bowling Green, OH

(13.71) 45 Raleigh, NC

(11.66) 45 Lubbock, TX

(12.20) 45 Kalamazoo, MI

(13.68) 46 Colorado Springs, CO

(11.38) 46 Athens, GA

(12.19) 46 Lewisburg, PA

(13.66) 47 Omaha, NE

(11.06) 47 Fullerton, CA

(12.19) 47 Kennesaw, GA

(13.64) 48 San Jose, CA

(11.05) 48 Beaumont, TX

(11.28) 48 Bethlehem, PA

(13.53) 49 Honolulu, HI

(10.98) 49 Abilene, TX

(11.28) 49 Harrisonburg, VA

(13.52) 50 Wichita, KS

(10.78) 50 Billings, MT

(11.26) 50 Muncie, IN

(13.50) 51 Dallas, TX

(10.64) 51 Little Rock, AR

(11.19) 51 Highland Heights, KY

(13.40) 52 Portland, OR

(10.50) 52 Murfreesboro, TN

(10.88) 52 Fayetteville, AR

(13.30) 53 Long Beach, CA

(10.45) 53 Waco, TX

(10.79) 53 Conway, SC

(13.28) 54 El Paso, TX

(8.56) 54 Lincoln, NE

(10.70) 54 New Brunswick, NJ

(13.25) 55 Bakersfield, CA

(8.11) 55 Norman, OK

(10.68) 55 Daytona Beach, FL

(13.21) 56 Sacramento, CA

(7.66) 56 Lafayette, LA

(10.56) 56 Huntington, WV

(13.19) 57 Oklahoma City, OK

(7.32) 57 College Station, TX

(10.35) 57 Charleston, IL

(13.12) 58 Riverside, CA

(6.39) 58 Evansville, IN

(9.96) 58 West Lafayette, IN

(13.06) 59 Irvine, CA

(9.82) 59 Troy, AL

(13.04) 60 Macon, GA

(9.33) 60 Hattiesburg, MS

(13.00) 61 Cedar Rapids, IA

(9.09) 61 Iowa City, IA

(12.99) 62 Huntsville, AL

(9.07) 62 New Rochelle, NY

(12.87) 63 Davenport, IA

(9.00) 63 Emmitsburg, MD

(12.86) 64 Fargo, ND

(8.99) 64 Richmond, KY

(12.78) 65 Modesto, CA

(8.78) 65 Cape Girardeau, MO

(12.73) 66 Akron, OH

(8.72) 66 Hammond, LA

(12.66) 67 Boise, ID

(8.66) 67 Terre Haute, IN

(12.60) 68 Everett, WA

(8.62) 68 Tuscaloosa, AL

(12.58) 69 Syracuse, NY

(8.61) 69 San Luis Obispo, CA

(12.53) 70 Orlando, FL

(8.48) 70 Valparaiso, IN

(12.49) 71 Hillsboro, OR

(8.46) 71 Lawrence, KS

(12.47) 72 Chattanooga, TN

(8.30) 72 Ruston, LA

(12.46) 73 Las Cruces, NM

(8.28) 73 San Marcos, TX

(12.45) 74 Clearwater, FL

(8.26) 74 Brookings, SD

(12.43) 75 Midland, TX

(8.17) 75 Greenville, NC

(12.42) 76 Port St. Lucie, FL

(8.09) 76 Amherst, MA

(12.40) 76 Worcester, MA

(8.09) 77 DeKalb, IL

(12.36) 78 Augusta, GA

(7.96) 78 Bluefield, WV

(12.34) 79 Des Moines, IA

(7.95) 79 Hempstead, NY

(12.30) 80 Tacoma, WA

(7.92) 80 Jonesboro, AR

(12.25) 81 Lakeland, FL

(7.91) 81 Davis, CA

(12.22) 82 Grand Rapids, MI

(7.87) 82 College Park, MD

(12.21) 83 Rancho Cucamonga, CA

(7.57) 83 Bloomington, IN

(12.17) 84 Lancaster, CA

(7.53) 84 Rock Hill, SC

(12.10) 85 Allentown, PA

(7.51) 85 Normal, IL

(12.08) 86 San Bernardino, CA

(7.48) 86 Elizabethton, TN

(12.05) 87 Lansing, MI

(7.45) 87 Moraga, CA

(11.96) 88 Round Rock, TX

(7.42) 88 Evanston, IL

(11.92) 89 Manchester, NH

(7.37) 89 Prairie View, TX

(11.90) 90 Visalia, CA

(7.11) 90 Malibu, CA

(11.67) 91 Fayetteville, NC

(7.02) 91 Bowling Green, KY

(11.64) 92 Amarillo, TX

(6.49) 92 Thibodaux, LA

(11.63) 93 Savannah, GA

(6.43) 93 Williamsburg, VA

(11.62) 94 Frisco, TX

(5.99) 94 Nacogdoches, TX

(11.29) 95 Santa Clara, CA

(5.83) 95 Lake Charles, LA

(11.28) 96 Jersey City, NJ

(2.32) 96 Great Falls, MT

(11.12) 97 Martin, TN

(11.09) 98 Hackensack, NJ

(10.99) 99 Huntsville, TX

(10.98) 100 Rochester Hills, MI

(10.95) 101 Manhattan, KS

(10.93) 102 Granville, WV

(10.88) 103 Storrs, CT

(10.75) 104 Idaho Falls, ID

(10.73) 105 Zebulon, NC

(10.72) 106 Edinburg, TX

(10.62) 107 Boone, NC

(10.59) 108 Auburn, NY

(10.41) 109 Natchitoches, LA

(10.37) 110 Princess Anne, MD

(10.25) 111 Blacksburg, VA

(10.24) 112 Auburn, AL

(10.20) 113 Papillion, NE

(10.17) 114 Conway, AR

(10.16) 115 Orono, ME

(10.08) 116 Ogden, UT

(10.02) 117 Pulaski, VA

(9.97) 118 Monroe, LA

(9.90) 119 Princeton, WV

(9.77) 120 Woodbridge, VA

(9.76) 121 Itta Bena, MS

(9.67) 122 Salem, VA

(9.55) 123 Boiling Springs, NC

(9.53) 124 Appleton, WI

(9.47) 125 Stony Brook, NY

(9.46) 126 Troy, NY

(9.42) 127 Kingsport, TN

(9.41) 128 Norwich, CT

(9.36) 129 Davidson, NC

(9.26) 130 Burlington, VT

(9.22) 131 Lexington, VA

(9.15) 132 Oxford, OH

(9.14) 133 DeLand, FL

(9.05) 134 Fayette, MS

(9.00) 135 Albany, NY

(8.96) 136 Lewiston, NY

(8.94) 137 Palm Beach, FL

(8.91) 138 Newark, DE

(8.90) 139 Long Branch, NJ

(8.84) 140 Danville, VA

(8.82) 141 Batavia, NY

(8.81) 142 Harrisburg, PA

(8.80) 143 East Lansing, MI

(8.78) 144 Altoona, PA

(8.75) 145 Frederick, MD

(8.72) 146 Poughkeepsie, NY

(8.67) 147 Bristol, VA

(8.65) 148 Pensacola, FL

(8.53) 149 Williamsport, PA

(8.53) 150 Scranton, PA

(8.51) 151 Clinton, SC

(8.44) 152 Pasco, WA

(8.36) 153 Keizer, OR

(8.35) 154 Wilmington, DE

(8.34) 155 Reading, PA

(8.28) 156 Hickory, NC

(8.24) 157 Portland, ME

(8.24) 158 Fairfax, VA

(8.21) 159 Niles, OH

(8.21) 160 Carbondale, IL

(8.19) 161 Burlington, NC

(8.15) 162 Grand Junction, CO

(8.11) 163 Myrtle Beach, SC

(8.08) 164 Jackson, TN

(8.08) 165 Allegany, NY

(7.96) 166 Salisbury, MD

(7.95) 167 Santa Barbara, CA

(7.95) 168 Port Charlotte, FL

(7.94) 169 Greeneville, TN

(7.94) 170 Pawtucket, RI

(7.93) 171 Rome, GA

(7.93) 172 Kinston, NC

(7.88) 173 Clinton, IA

(7.85) 174 Aberdeen, MD

(7.84) 175 Burlington, IA

(7.84) 176 Dunedin, FL

(7.83) 177 Springdale, AR

(7.80) 178 Missoula, MT

(7.76) 179 North Little Rock, AR

(7.72) 180 Hagerstown, MD

(7.70) 181 Lakewood, NJ

(7.62) 182 Biloxi, MS

(7.59) 183 Dover, DE

(7.52) 184 Eastlake, OH

(7.41) 185 Beloit, WI

(7.37) 186 Erie, PA

(7.31) 187 Pearl, MS

(7.21) 188 Ithaca, NY

(7.20) 189 Lake Elsinore, CA

(7.17) 190 Ypsilanti, MI

(7.13) 191 Charleston, WV

(7.10) 192 West Sacramento, CA

(7.04) 193 Kannapolis, NC

(7.02) 194 Jupiter, FL

(6.96) 195 Bowie, MD

(6.89) 196 Bradenton, FL

(6.79) 197 Kissimmee, FL

(6.77) 198 Easton, PA

(6.70) 199 Macomb, IL

(6.59) 200 Murray, KY

(6.53) 201 Midland, MI

(6.31) 202 Pine Bluff, AR

(6.24) 203 Edwardsville, IL

(5.99) 204 Geneva, IL

(5.84) 205 Towson, MD

(5.82) 206 Farmville, VA

(5.51) 207 Youngstown, OH

(5.47)

Ask the Experts

As baseball grows in popularity in the U.S. and abroad, so will the challenges for those in the industry. For insight into those issues, advice on enjoying the ballgame and more, we asked a panel of experts to weigh in with their thoughts on the following key questions:

What are the biggest issues facing MLB today? How has fantasy sports affected fans’ enjoyment of MLB? What is your take on the time-based contract structure used by MLB, as well as the various other spending constraints imposed by the league? Who are your picks to win the World Series, MVP and Cy Young Awards? What is the best way to enjoy a baseball game on a budget?

Methodology

In order to determine the best cities for baseball fans, WalletHub compared 361 of the most populated U.S. cities based on 31 key metrics, which are listed below with their corresponding weights. Each metric was graded on a 100-point scale, with a score of 100 representing the most favorable conditions for baseball fans. For our sample, we chose cities with at least one Major League Baseball (MLB), Minor League Baseball (MiLB) or college baseball (NCAA) team.

We then grouped the cities by division and assigned weights to each divisional category according to its popularity among fans. Finally, we determined each city’s weighted average across all metrics to calculate its overall score and used the resulting scores to rank-order our sample.

For the ranking by city size, we grouped and ranked the cities based on the following population-size guidelines:

Large cities: More than 300,000 people

Midsize cities: 100,000 to 300,000 people

Small cities: Fewer than 100,000 people

MLB – Total Points = 70

Number of Teams: Full Weight (~7.00 Points)

Performance Level of Team(s): Triple Weight (~21.00 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing the number of wins by the total number of games played. The past three seasons’ average was used for this calculation.

Number of Championship Wins: Half Weight (~7.00 Points)

Number of Regular Season Division Titles: Full Weight (~3.50 Points)

Number of Hall of Fame Head Coaches: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

Franchise Value: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

Note: This metric measures the team(s) estimated value in dollars.

Average Ticket Price per Game: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

Fan Engagement: Full Weight (~7.00 Points)

Note: This metric measures the number of Twitter followers and Facebook “Likes” per capita.

Number of Coaches in Past 10 Seasons: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

Note: “Past 10 Seasons” include seasons 2009–2010 to 2018–2019.

Stadium Capacity: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing stadium capacity by city population.

Attendance: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing average home-fan attendance by stadium capacity.

Popularity Index: Half Weight (~3.50 Points)

MiLB – Total Points = 10

Number of Teams: Full Weight (~1.33 Points)

Performance Level of Team(s): Full Weight (~1.33 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing the number of wins by the total number of games played. The past three seasons’ average was used for this calculation.

Number of Championship Wins: Full Weight (~1.33 Points)

Number of Division Titles: Half Weight (~0.67 Points)

Number of Hall of Fame Head Coaches: Half Weight (~0.67 Points)

Minimum Season Ticket Price: Full Weight (~1.33 Points)

Fan Engagement: Full Weight (~1.33 Points)

Note: This metric measures the number of Twitter followers and Facebook “Likes” per capita.

Number of Coaches in Past 10 Seasons: Half Weight (~0.67 Points)

Note: “Past 10 Seasons” include seasons 2009–2010 to 2018–2019.

Attendance: Half Weight (~0.67 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing stadium capacity by city population.

Stadium Capacity: Half Weight (~0.67 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing average home-fan attendance by stadium capacity.

NCAA Baseball – Total Points = 20

Number of Teams: Full Weight (~2.86 Points)

Performance Level of Team(s): Full Weight (~2.86 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing the number of wins by the total number of games played. The past three seasons’ average was used for this calculation.

Number of Championship Wins: Full Weight (~2.86 Points)

Number of Regular Season Division Titles: Half Weight (~1.43 Points)

Number of Hall of Fame Head Coaches: Half Weight (~1.43 Points)

Minimum Season Ticket Price for a Game: Full Weight (~2.86 Points)

Fan Engagement: Full Weight (~2.86 Points)

Note: This metric measures the number of Twitter followers and Facebook “Likes” per capita.

Number of Coaches in Past 10 Seasons: Half Weight (~1.43 Points)

Note: “Past 10 Seasons” include seasons 2009–2010 to 2018–2019.

Stadium Capacity: Half Weight (~1.43 Points)

Note: This metric was calculated by dividing stadium capacity by city population.





Videos for News Use:



Sources: Data used to create this ranking were collected from the U.S. Census Bureau, Team Marketing Report, ESPN, MLB Advanced Media, Minor League Baseball, Nielsen, Sports Reference, National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, The National Collegiate Athletic Association, Forbes, Wikipedia, Facebook, Twitter and each team’s website.

Was this article helpful? Yes No Awesome! Thanks for your feedback. Thank you for your feedback. Sorry! Failed to send the feedback. Please try again later. Submit