Liverpool Chelsea Dress Boot is rated 4.2 out of 5 by 140 .

Rated 2 out of 5 by Zach from Poor Quality Control? I recently purchased this boot in tan, 10.5” in 3E width. It’s a handsome, slender design, with a more pointed, European toe than many other American Chelsea boots. The leather feels supple and smooth. After a few wears, I began to notice significant defects in quality. Both heel blocks are wearing harshly, and even becoming cracked and separated from the sole. The rubber sole protectors have shifted. Most disappointingly, the stitching on the uppers became heavily frayed on one boot inside, below the elastic. These are issues that didn’t occur until a few—but only a few—wears outside in fair weather, not out of the box. AE is my go to for high quality leather shoes, but I fear in 2020 and beyond, with all other concerns in decreased quality, I may have to find future alternatives.

Rated 4 out of 5 by Pilgrim from I like them and recommend them. I wear these in both black and walnut. I have a very narrow heel, wide toe, and a very low, close to the ankle instep. These boots fit me better than anything I have worn in a very long time. I WOULD LOVE TO HAVE A PAIR IN SHELL CORDOVAN....can you help me Allen Edmonds?

Rated 4 out of 5 by Drew from 2F Walnuts Well Worth It I got a $500 retail boot for a steep discount and there were only slight blemishes in the leather and not the burnishing on the toe could have been slightly better, but I will not complain on 2F's discounted. Best value for money shoe I've ever bought.