With its stark, white walls and concrete floors, Rolling Orange, a new store in Cobble Hill, looks more like an art gallery than your typical New York bike shop. The lofty space houses just a few dozen retro-look bicycles, showcased like sculptures and priced to match. And the customers aren't your typical gear heads. When one stylish gent approaches shop manager Christine Brinkhorst with a burning question—"These are Dutch bicycles, right?"—he is delighted with the Amsterdam native's elegantly accented reply: "Oh yes, these are very Dutch."

Used...