So, a couple of things happened late last week worth mentioning:

First, the Newfoundland Budget was released and as predicted it was a slash-and-burn exercise. The province, facing a deficit of something like 8% of GDP, had to make major changes. Unbelievably, the tuition freeze stayed, sort of (more on this tomorrow), but student aid took a hit. Remember in 2014 when Newfoundland eliminated grants? That’s over, the first $40 week in provincial aid is now a loan again. But more importantly, the government has completely eliminated grants for students studying outside the province if their program of study is offered inside the province. So, a law student going to Dal gets the grant, but if God forbid you want to study Science or Engineering somewhere other than MUN – it’s loans only on the provincial side (said students would still receive federal grants).

Second, the premier of New Brunswick announced pretty much out of nowhere that low-income students in his province would be free and that details would be available from the Ministry of Advanced Education “in a few days” (at time of writing we’re still waiting). Not many details yet – from the few nuggets available it sounds a lot like the Ontario program (provincial tax credits are being axed) – which is of course a Good Thing. But one key point did come out, namely that the grant would not be portable. If you chose to leave New Brunswick, it would be loans only on the provincial side.

I. Am. Furious.

The extent to which young people in Atlantic Canada are treated as “resources” to be hoarded is just appalling. It’s almost never “how can we attract young people”, it’s “how can we keep the ones we’ve got from leaving”. From a very young age, bright young people are essentially sold a bill of goods by guidance councilors and community leaders – “don’t leave the province, it’s a betrayal to leave the province, you are our future”. The guilt-trips are outrageous. And now along comes provincial policies in Newfoundland and New Brunswick to use financial means to punish students who have the temerity to want to study outside the province.

At least you can sort of excuse the Newfoundland one on grounds of austerity because financially that government really is in trouble. But New Brunswick? They canned a huge graduate tax rebate last year and promised to re-invest the money. There is no way that amount of money wouldn’t cover an extension of the program to out-of-province students. Hell, Ontario actually cut total grant + tax-credit dollars in its announcement and still managed to extend the coverage of its new grants (currently, the Ontario Assistance Grant is portable but the Ontario Tuition Grant is not – the new grant is fully portable). Instead, New Brunswick is doing this specifically to try to divert New Brunswick students away from out-of-province schools in order to give its own universities more tuition revenue and hence obviate the need for the province itself to actually pony up some money. Brian Gallant calls that a win; we’ll see if he thinks the same when New Brunswick lose students after Nova Scotia and PEI retaliate in kind.

Now look, I get it. People want what’s good for their communities, and the economics of Atlantic Canada have been scary for decades. It’s easy to retreat into a defensive shell. But holding your own youth hostage is not cool. Those kids aren’t resources to be hoarded; politicians need to let them go and succeed wherever they want to succeed. Student aid should be about expanding opportunity, not limiting it.

These changes need to be reversed. And if the provinces won’t do it on their own, the federal government should change the legislation underlying the Canada Student Loans Program to penalize partner provinces whose loan programs don’t provide mobility across Canada. More than ever before, their programs are built around federal largesse – Ottawa should extract something in return. And freedom to study without penalty anywhere in the country is a right worth fighting for.