shanimebib

Offline

Joined: Nov 2007

Posts: 9161 OfflineJoined: Nov 2007Posts: 9161

THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE.

----------------------------------------

OMG! Lots of lots of new scenes and I am loving it!







The story as expected, primarily focuses on Asuka. But overall it looks like worth watching as it touched more on Asuka's family situation and also Kumiko's situation with Mamiko. Unlike the first recap movie, it also has significant amount of Mamiko and Shuuichi contents (including some new scenes!) although the Mamiko and Kumiko final scene is replaced by Asuka and Kumiko. A bit sad though seeing Reina having so few content.



Edit: As promised, here are the reasons why you may want to consider watching the movie. To begin with there is approximately 20 minutes worth of new content or new cuts.



New Contents/Cuts:





+ Asuka as a kindergartner and receiving a Euphonium from her father.





+ Pre and post school festival Kitauji Brass band performance.





+ Asuka and her mom's segment at Asuka's home.





+ Kumiko's segment with her mom and dad at home.





+ An extension after Haruka's sax solo at the station performance (full performance).





+ Additional segments at Asuka's place (preparing for exams).



+ Small segment showing Asuka before the start of the final performance.

+ Final performance with a few new cuts and a different approach than the TV series at certain segments.





+ Kumiko is met by Asuka after she returns back chasing and meeting her sister.



+ There are a few more new cuts lasting few seconds each here and there. + Asuka as a kindergartner and receiving a Euphonium from her father.+ Pre and post school festival Kitauji Brass band performance.+ Asuka and her mom's segment at Asuka's home.+ Kumiko's segment with her mom and dad at home.+ An extension after Haruka's sax solo at the station performance (full performance).+ Additional segments at Asuka's place (preparing for exams).+ Small segment showing Asuka before the start of the final performance.+ Final performance with a few new cuts and a different approach than the TV series at certain segments.+ Kumiko is met by Asuka after she returns back chasing and meeting her sister.+ There are a few more new cuts lasting few seconds each here and there.



Exclusions:



- The celebration after winning in the Kyoto competition (photo session and all).

- The whole of Genji Matsuri.

- The swimming pool segment.

- Most of the training camp segment (only emphasis was given to Asuka's solo that she performs in the morning).

- The whole Mizore and Nozomi issue.

- Most of the post Kitauji brass band performance part during the school festival (maid cafe, fortune telling, haunted house etc.).

- The whole typhoon segment where Kumiko found out about Taki-sensei's past.

- Kumiko catching a cold and Reina's visit (only segment kept was Mamiko and Shuuichi's talk at the entrance).

- Reina finding out about Taki-sensei, her question regarding his wife and the grave visit.

- Shuuichi giving Kumiko a hairpin before the final competition (although the infamous hairpin magically showed up on Kumiko's music sheet stand later on).

- Reina's public confession to Taki-sensei and everything related to it.

- Kumiko's declaration of her love for Euphonium and her adoration for Mamiko to Mamiko.

- Asuka knowing about Kumiko's stubbornness when it comes to Shuuichi while returning from school.

- Club party congratulating the third years for their graduation.



Changes in Timeline:



Kansai competition takes place BEFORE the School Festival. The School Festival takes place BEFORE the training camp. These are other way around in the TV anime.



Changes in Romance:



o Nothing notable other than Riko and Gotou still dating.

o Reina's feelings for Taki-sensei and her uneasiness/troubles are completely removed.

o No development for Shuuichi's "one-sided" love for Kumiko.

o One more person is on board the ship of those who think there's something between Kumiko and Shuuichi as Natsuki teases Kumiko saying she sure gets along with Shuuichi while she caught Kumiko fist bumping with him after their performance at the school festival while Shuuichi also telling Kumiko that her mother came to see them perform. The teasing is nicely followed up by Kumiko's usual gulp, annoyance and a "Yamete kudasai".



o Nothing notable other than Riko and Gotou still dating.o Reina's feelings for Taki-sensei and her uneasiness/troubles are completely removed.o No development for Shuuichi's "one-sided" love for Kumiko.o One more person is on board the ship of those who think there's something between Kumiko and Shuuichi as Natsuki teases Kumiko saying she sure gets along with Shuuichi while she caught Kumiko fist bumping with him after their performance at the school festival while Shuuichi also telling Kumiko that her mother came to see them perform. The teasing is nicely followed up by Kumiko's usual gulp, annoyance and a "Yamete kudasai".



Overall, I really enjoyed the movie. I gave it a 9/10 despite of the fact that four fifth of the content is just recap. But the pacing is much better than season 1's recap with a lot of new contents (a fifth of new content is actually A LOT for a recap movie). I couldn't have asked for any more than this. :) ----------------------------------------OMG! Lots of lots of new scenes and I am loving it!The story as expected, primarily focuses on Asuka. But overall it looks like worth watching as it touched more on Asuka's family situation and also Kumiko's situation with Mamiko. Unlike the first recap movie, it also has significant amount of Mamiko and Shuuichi contents (including some new scenes!) although the Mamiko and Kumiko final scene is replaced by Asuka and Kumiko. A bit sad though seeing Reina having so few content.Edit: As promised, here are the reasons why you may want to consider watching the movie. To begin with there is approximatelyworth of new content or new cuts.Overall, I really enjoyed the movie. I gave it a 9/10 despite of the fact that four fifth of the content is just recap. But the pacing is much better than season 1's recap with a lot of new contents (a fifth of new content is actually A LOT for a recap movie). I couldn't have asked for any more than this. :) BBCode Modified by shanimebib, Mar 12, 2018 5:42 PM Stay Home and Wash Your Hands.

Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones.

Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus .