Mattpsychosykes said: Taurin has done his best, sorry if you didn't like it but he doesn't have Pixar or Silicon Graphics working for him. If I could do as well as he has I'd be damned happy with the results. Think you could do better????

Edgar Allen Poe once wrote, in his "Letter to B-", "It has been said that a good critique on a poem may be written by one who is not a poet himself. This, according to your idea of poetry, and mine, I believe to be false -the less poetical the critic, the less just the critique, and the inverse." Perhaps so, and, hesitant as I am to contradict a raving alcoholic, retrospectively diagnosed with depression, I would have to pose the following;

I can't make wine at all, does that mean that I can't say Sutter Home tastes terrible? If someone can't cook, does that mean they can't tell if they enjoy the taste of food or not? Is constructive criticism indicative of a lack of gratitude? I should think not.

My own conclusion? "You can't do better, so you can't criticize the work." is a logical fallacy. I would say that one's audience is of more concern than one's competition.