After getting our orders wrong for months, I helped our local Dunkin’ fix a nationwide problem with their new ordering system

My wife and I like our Dunkin’ Donuts coffee. We always go with cream and a flavor swirl. Whenever you order a flavor swirl, Dunkin’ has a standard amount of pumps they add depending on the size of your drink:

3 pumps for a Medium

4 pumps for a Large

5 pumps for an Extra-Large

Know your Dunkin’ pump standards

My wife and I have operated off of these defaults for years; however, we knew something was up the first time we got coffee from the new “next generation” Dunkin’ store that opened just down the street. I tasted mine and could tell they hadn’t added the standard amount of swirl. What’s more, we were already on the road and didn’t have time to go back to get it fixed.

One of the “new concept” Dunkin’ Donuts stores opened down the road from us.

The next day we came back for iced coffees. We made our standard order, received our drinks, and didn’t taste them until we were on the road. They’d put in too little swirl again!

This experience continued in the months since they’ve opened. I’d gotten in the habit of going in, ordering my coffee, tasting it, and handing it back so they can add more swirl. I knew not to go through the drive-thru. My wife avoided this store altogether. I wondered how many other customers might be doing the same?

I’ve had my theories as to why this store always gets our order wrong, but it wasn’t until last week that I finally got things figured out. I made my usual order and tasted my coffee. Then I asked Hunter, the guy behind the counter, how many pumps of swirl he’d put in. He said, “The label didn’t say, so I had to guess. Two-and-a-half pumps maybe?” Bingo! My suspicions were confirmed! I knew what had been happening all this time…

All these next generation Dunkin’ stores are using a new ordering system. When your order gets passed to the staff, the printer spits out a label with your drink and its customizations. In my case, it had the following:

1 Ht Cof MD OrigBlnd

3 Cream

CaramelSwrl

How much “CaramelSwrl”???

The problem was there was no quantity next to the flavor swirl. Without the quantity, Hunter was just guessing. It wasn’t that he didn’t know the standard amounts. Instead he didn’t know that the new labels were specifying the standard amount when they listed a swirl without any quantity information.

This led me to call over Hunter’s manager to explain what was happening. I showed her my order on my app. It had 3 pumps of swirl specified, but the label didn’t. The system was operating off of the assumption that having a swirl for any size drink meant to add the “standard” amount of pumps unless otherwise specified.

To test this theory, the manager had me order a medium coffee with only 1 pump of swirl. Sure enough, the label printed out like so:

1 Ht Cof MD OrigBlnd

3 Cream

2 less CaramelSwrl

That confirmed our suspicions. The new labels were indicating flavor swirls based off of the standard amount. She realized then and there that she hadn’t been training her employees on how to properly fill orders based on these new labels. The manager told me she was going to call corporate to let them know about this.

The next day I came back to test things out. That store had gotten so many of my orders wrong that I wasn’t sure if my help from the day before would take that quickly.

I made my order via the Dunkin’ app while I sat in my car. Then I walked in, and much to my surprise the entire front counter staff (Hunter, the manager from the day before, and someone else I hadn’t met) greeted me by name. “Michael!” they all said. Apparently the word had gotten out.

The manager told me she had called corporate, and based on the help I’d given them, they were going to make sure that all the new stores were trained on how to properly fulfill orders with the new labels. So, the next time you get coffee from a next generation Dunkin’ Donuts with the correct amount of flavor swirl, you just might have me to thank.