FX

Tonight (January 7), Neil Patrick Harris will make his debut on "American Horror Story: Freak Show" as Chester, an illusionist who, of course, does not have the purest of intentions. A trailer for his first of two episodes, "Magical Thinking," shows him cutting someone in half as blood spurts out of his magician-box-thing, which heavily suggests that a main "AHS"-er will take their final bow at Chester's hand:

So, who will it be? With Elsa (Jessica Lange) out of town and Jimmy (Evan Peters) behind bars, there are only a number of available bodies. Let's break them down: