Gift 1: A blank DVD in a home-made Hannah Montana DVD case stuck between two sheets of reddit wrapping paper which were paper clipped together. Also inside the DVD case: a free sample of cologne, a sheet of paper with a picture of Trollface, and this url: http://i.imgur.com/u9CM3.png

Gift 2: A week later, I got a second package. Inside was a gift wrapped book and two envelopes, one with a red up arrow, the other with a blue down arrow. The book was The Ultimate Hitchhiker's Guide! Somehow, I have never read any of these stories, so I am extremely happy to have this book. I choose to physically upvote the gift by opening the appropriate envelope. Inside was a short note and FFFFFFUUUUUUU that ended on a happy note. I opened the downvote envelope too, which included a more typical FFFFFFUUUUUUU.

I can't believe how much effort Sixdust put into all this. Thank you very much!