Document Number: P0911R1 Date: 2018-03-15 Project: Programming Language C++, CWG, LWG Revises: P0911R0 Reply to: gorn@microsoft.com

Rebase the Coroutines TS onto the C++17 Standard

Introduction

The current working draft for the Coroutines TS is based on C++14. This paper proposes revising the draft to reflect the new standard.

Clause renumbering

Due to new ISO guidelines, C++17 has changed the numbers of nearly all the clauses relative to C++14. In Coroutines TS replace all clause numbers and references to stable names from C++14 based to C++17 based as follows:

Stable Name C++14 based numbering C++17 based numbering atomics 29 32 basic 3 6 basic.link 3.5 6.5 basic.lookup.classref 3.4.5 6.4.5 basic.start.main 3.6.1 6.6.1 basic.stc.auto 3.7.3 6.7.3 basic.stc.dynamic 3.7.4 6.7.4 basic.stc.dynamic.allocation 3.7.4.1 6.7.4.1 basic.stc.dynamic.deallocation 3.7.4.2 6.7.4.2 basic.stc.static 3.7.1 6.7.1 basic.stc.thread 3.7.2 6.7.2 basic.types 3.9 6.9 class 9 12 class.access 11 14 class.copy 12.8 15.8 class.derived 10 13 class.virtual 10.3 13.3 compliance 17.6.1.3 20.5.1.3 conv 4 7 coroutine.handle 18.11.2 21.11.2 coroutine.handle.compare 18.11.2.6 21.11.2.6 coroutine.handle.con 18.11.2.1 21.11.2.1 coroutine.handle.export.import 18.11.2.2 21.11.2.2 coroutine.handle.hash 18.11.2.7 21.11.2.7 coroutine.handle.observers 18.11.2.3 21.11.2.3 coroutine.handle.promise 18.11.2.5 21.11.2.5 coroutine.handle.resumption 18.11.2.4 21.11.2.4 coroutine.traits 18.11.1 21.11.1 coroutine.traits.primary 18.11.1.1 21.11.1.1 coroutine.trivial.awaitables 18.11.3 21.11.3 cpp 16 19 cstdint 18.4 21.4 dcl.constexpr 7.1.5 10.1.5 dcl.dcl 7 10 dcl.decl 8 11 dcl.fct.def 8.4 11.4 dcl.fct.def.coroutine 8.4.4 11.4.4 dcl.fct.default 8.3.6 11.4.2 dcl.spec 7.1 10.1 dcl.spec.auto 7.1.6.4 10.1.7.4 except 15 18 except.throw 15.1 18.1 expr 5 8 expr.ass 5.17 8.18 expr.await 5.3.8 8.3.8 expr.call 5.2.2 8.2.2 expr.const 5.19 8.2 expr.log.or 5.15 8.15 expr.new 5.3.4 8.3.4 expr.typeid 5.2.8 8.2.8 expr.unary 5.3 8.3 expr.unary.noexcept 5.3.7 8.3.7 expr.yield 5.20 `8.20 intro 1 4 intro.compliance 1.4 4.1 intro.defs 1.3 3 intro.execution 1.9 4.6 language.support 18 21 lex 2 5 lex.key 2.12 5.11 library 17 20 meta 20.1 23.15 over 13 16 over.match 13.3 16.3 over.match.funcs 13.3.1 16.3.1 over.match.oper 13.3.1.2 16.3.1.2 over.oper 13.5 16.5 special 12 15 stmt.iter 6.5 9.5 stmt.jump 6.6 9.6 stmt.ranged 6.5.4 9.5.4 stmt.return 6.6.3 9.6.3 stmt.return.coroutine 6.6.3.1 9.6.3.1 stmt.stmt 6 9 support.coroutine 18.11 21.11 support.dynamic 18.6 21.6 support.exception 18.8 21.8 support.general 18.1 21.1 support.initlist 18.9 21.9 support.limits 18.3 21.3 support.rtti 18.7 21.7 support.runtime 18.1 21.10 support.start.term 18.5 21.5 support.types 18.2 21.2 cpp.headers.freestanding Table 16 Table 19 lang.sup.lib.summary Table 29 Table 32 temp 14 17 temp.deduct 14.8.2 17.8.2 temp.type 14.4 17.4 unord.hash 20.9.12 23.14.15

1. Scope

Replace reference to ISO/IEC 14882:2014 with ISO/IEC 14882:2017.

2. Normative References

Replace reference to ISO/IEC 14882:2014 with ISO/IEC 14882:2017.

3. Terms and Definitions

No changes.

4. General

4.3 Program execution

Replace references to paragraph 6 to paragraph 7 to match C++17.

4.4 Lexical conventions [lex]

Move subclause 4.4 into a subclause 5.11 of clause 5.

4.5 Basic concepts [basic]

Move subclause 4.5 into a subclause 6.6.1 of clause 6.

4.6 Dynamic storage duration [basic.stc.dynamic]

Move subclause 4.6 into a subclause 6.7.4 of clause 6.

5 Lexical conventions [lex]

5.11 Keywords [lex.key]

[Editorial note: This is the text moved from section 4.4 of the Coroutines TS with references to clauses, paragraphs and tables updated to match C++17].

In subclause 5.11 of the C++ Standard add the keywords co_await , co_yield , and co_return to Table 5 "Keywords".

6 Basic Concepts [basic]

6.6.1 main function

[Editorial note: This is the text moved from section 4.5 of the Coroutines TS with references to clauses, paragraphs and tables updated to match C++17].

In subclause 6.6.1 of the C++ Standard add underlined text to paragraph 3.

3 The function main shall not be used within a program. The linkage (6.5) of main is implementation-defined. A program that defines main as deleted or that declares main to be inline , static , or constexpr is ill-formed. The function main shall not be a coroutine (11.4.4) ...

6.7.4 Dynamic Storage Duration [basic.stc.dynamic]

[Editorial note: This is the text moved from section 4.6 of the Coroutines TS with references to clauses, paragraphs and tables updated to match C++17].

In subclause 6.7.4.1 of the C++ Standard add underlined text to paragraph 4.

4 A global allocation function is only called as the result of a new expression (8.3.4), or called directly using the function call syntax (8.2.2), or called indirectly to allocate storage for a coroutine frame (11.4.4), ...

7 Standard Conversions [conv]

No changes are made to Clause 7 of the C++ Standard

8 Expressions [expr]

[Editorial note: Only clause and subclause number updates in this clause of the TS].

9 Statements [stmt.stmt]

9.5.4 The range-based for statement [stmt.ranged]

Update paragraph 1 of subclause 9.5.4 of the TS to match the structure of the same paragraph in the C++17 standard.

1 The range-based for statement

for co_await opt ( for-range-declaration : for-range-initializer ) statement

is equivalent to

{

auto &&__range = for-range-initializer ;

auto __begin = co_await opt begin-expr ;

auto __end = end-expr ;

for ( ; __begin != __end; co_await opt ++__begin ) {

for-range-declaration = *__begin;

statement

}

}

where

(1.1) — co_await is present if and only if it appears immediately after the for keyword;

(1.2) ... [Editorial note: with remaining bullets appropriately renumbered].

9.6.3.1 The co_return statement [stmt.return.coroutine]

Update coroutine-return-statement production in section 9.6.3.1 of the TS as follows:

coroutine-return-statement:

co_return expression opt

co_return braced-init-list

co_return expr-or-braced-init-list opt



Update paragraph 2 in section 9.6.3.1 of the TS as follows:

2 The expression or braced-init-list expr-or-braced-init-list of a co_return statement is called its operand.

...

where final_suspend is as defined in 11.4.4 and S is defined as follows:

(2.1) -- S is p.return_value(braced-init-list), if the operand is a braced-init-list;

(2.2) -- S is p.return_value(expression), if the operand is an expression of non-void type;

(2.1) - S is p.return_value( expr-or-braced-init-list ) , if the operand is a braced-init-list or an expression of non- void type ;

(2. 2 3 ) S is { expression opt ; p.return_void(); } , otherwise;

10 Declarations [dcl.dcl]

[Editorial note: Only clause and subclause number updates in this clause of the TS].

11 Declarators [dcl.decl]

[Editorial note: Only clause and subclause number updates in this clause of the TS].

12 Classes [class]

No changes are made to this Clause of the C++ Standard

13 Derived classes [class.derived]

No changes are made to this Clause of the C++ Standard

14 Derived classes [class.derived]

No changes are made to this Clause of the C++ Standard

15 Special member functions [special]

Replace reference to paragraph 31 of subclause of 12.8 [class.copy/C++14] with a reference to paragraph 1 of 15.8.3 [class.copy.elision].

Add new paragraph after paragraph 31 bullet to paragraph 1 .

(1.4) in a coroutine (11.4.4), a copy of a coroutine parameter can be omitted and references to that copy replaced with references to the corresponding parameter if the meaning of the program will be unchanged except for the execution of a constructor and destructor for the parameter copy object

Replace reference to paragraph 33 of subclause of 12.8 [class.copy/C++14] with a reference to paragraph 3 of 15.8.3 [class.copy.elision].

Modify paragraph 33 3 as follows:

3 In the following copy-initialization contexts, a move operation might be used instead of a copy operation:



(3.1) — If the expression in a return statement (9.6.3) or co_return (9.6.3.1) is a (possibly parenthesized) id-expression that names an object with automatic storage duration declared in the body or parameter-declaration-clause of the innermost enclosing function or lambda-expression, or



(3.2) — if the operand of a throw-expression (8.17) is the name of a non-volatile automatic object (other than a function or catch-clause parameter) whose scope does not extend beyond the end of the innermost enclosing try-block (if there is one),



overload resolution to select the constructor for the copy or the return_value overload to call is first performed as if the object were designated by an rvalue. If the first overload resolution fails or was not performed, or if the type of the first parameter of the selected constructor or return_value overload is not an rvalue reference to the object’s type (possibly cv-qualified), overload resolution is performed again, considering the object as an lvalue. [ Note: This two-stage overload resolution must be performed regardless of whether copy elision will occur. It determines the constructor or return_value overload to be called if elision is not performed, and the selected constructor or return_value overload must be accessible even if the call is elided. —end note ]

16 Overloading [over]

[Editorial note: Only clause and subclause number updates in this clause of the TS].

17 Templates [temp]

No changes are made to this Clause of the C++ Standard

18 Exception handling [except]

No changes are made to this Clause of the C++ Standard

19 Preprocessing directives [cpp]

No changes are made to this Clause of the C++ Standard

20 Library Introduction [library]

[Editorial note: Only clause, table number and subclause number updates in this clause of the TS].

21 Language support library [language.support]

21.11.2.7 Hash support [coroutine.handle.hash]

Update paragraph 1 to match the style used for hash specializations in C++17.