Sure, this season of Bachelor in Paradise was marked by drama, tears and the Corinne Olympios/DeMario Jackson controversy, which temporarily shut down production. But, through it all, one couple did find their happily-ever-after: Taylor Nolan and Derek Peth. Proposing to the mental health counselor during Monday night’s Paradise finale, Peth gave Nolan a gorgeous 2-carat diamond ring from Neil Lane, the Bachelor franchise’s go-to jeweler. “I did not actually meet with Derek, so it was important for me to better understand him and his personality – and of course Taylor’s as well,” says Lane, who got a feel for the smitten duo by chatting with the show’s producers. “What I gathered was that he was more traditional yet he also liked the idea of a romantic ring.”