lefix Profile Joined February 2011 Germany 1081 Posts Last Edited: 2014-06-02 19:25:39 #1



MotM May 2014 is done. The community has spoken. The winners have been chosen. And I don't want to make you read another wall of text so here they are!













1st Place was claimed by NewSunshine with his map AEM Sol Dios, which might very well become the most popular vacation destination this summer! He is going to take home 60$









2nd Place goes to Icetoad and his beloved map Nimbus! He has been with this map through good times and bad times, and it is finally paying off! He will receive 40$.









3rd Place goes to eTcetRa and his map Samsara RE, which was considered one of the favorites. But the competition was too strong. Nonetheless he will not go home empty handed, as he will receive 20$!





4th Place went to Silt by Samro2225am

+ Show Spoiler +





5th Place went to AEM Coriolis by -NegativeZero-

+ Show Spoiler +





Full results of the poll can be found here:

+ Show Spoiler +









We are also giving out a 15$ special award this month! Despite not making it into the last 5, Korhal Carnage Knockout by SidianTheBard did truly stand out in originality. With 8 spawn positions (opponent spawning in one of the 3 spawns furthest away), the map moves away from the usual main/nat setup, creating an interesting dynamic. It is concepts like these we hope to see further explored! Oh, and it is a beautifuly piece of work, too!













With that said, we are already gathering submissions for MotM June 2014!



All you need to do is to create a map thread following the publish the map on battle.net.



Please make sure you published your map correctly! Unfortunately there were some maps which were nowhere to be found and couldn't be considered. However, they will be considered in the following month once they are published correctly.









Since we had a prize pool consisting of donations from the mapmaking community, many more have contacted me asking how they could contribute as well.

So I have decided, with the permission of Plexa, to set up a paypal account people can donate to. So if you want to support MotM, send your donations towards



sc2motm[at]gmail.com



via paypal.





Starting this month, 50% of the donations will be used for the competition prize pool. The other 50% will be saved up for upcoming MotM events (Tournaments or Showmatches, still TBD)



Nothing will go into our own pockets!



is done. The community has spoken. The winners have been chosen. And I don't want to make you read another wall of text so here they are!1st Place was claimed by NewSunshine with his map, which might very well become the most popular vacation destination this summer! He is going to take home2nd Place goes to Icetoad and his beloved map! He has been with this map through good times and bad times, and it is finally paying off! He will receive3rd Place goes to eTcetRa and his map, which was considered one of the favorites. But the competition was too strong. Nonetheless he will not go home empty handed, as he will receivewent toby Samro2225amwent toby -NegativeZero-Full results of the poll can be found here:We are also giving out a 15$ special award this month! Despite not making it into the last 5,by SidianTheBard did truly stand out in originality. With 8 spawn positions (opponent spawning in one of the 3 spawns furthest away), the map moves away from the usual main/nat setup, creating an interesting dynamic. It is concepts like these we hope to see further explored! Oh, and it is a beautifuly piece of work, too!With that said, we are already gathering submissions forAll you need to do is tofollowing the forum guidelines (please include a top down overview) ANDPlease make sure you published your map correctly! Unfortunately there were some maps which were nowhere to be found and couldn't be considered. However, they will be considered in the following month once they are published correctly.Since we had a prize pool consisting of donations from the mapmaking community, many more have contacted me asking how they could contribute as well.So I have decided, with the permission of Plexa, to set up a paypal account people can donate to. So if you want to support MotM, send your donations towardsvia paypal.Starting this month, 50% of the donations will be used for the competition prize pool. The other 50% will be saved up for upcoming MotM events (Tournaments or Showmatches, still TBD)will go into our own pockets! Map of the Month | The Planetary Workshop | SC2Melee.net

The_Templar Profile Blog Joined January 2011 your Country 52593 Posts #2 Very surprising results imo. Also nice that Sidian got something here for his efforts. Moderator Starcraft 3 when

And G Profile Joined May 2012 Germany 491 Posts Last Edited: 2014-06-02 18:59:33 #3 On May 28 2014 21:00 And G wrote:

See See this excellent post from SiskosGoatee on the problems of first past the post.

On March 30 2014 00:01 SiskosGoatee wrote:

The map which is the most unlike all the others is the most likely to win because the others eat into each other's votes.

On May 29 2014 19:08 And G wrote:

4 out of 5 finalists are four player maps.

On May 29 2014 22:39 And G wrote:

I really wouldn't be surprised if Sol Dios wins this contest.

Called it.





That being said, I'm quite happy that Sol Dios won (congratulations to NewSunshine btw!) since it is actually a solid map and Nimbus would be bad advertising for the whole MOTM thing due to lack of balance not being very popular outside the mapmaking sub-community. Speaking of advertising, is there anything being done with regard to "spotlighting" maps and "giving them the attention they deserve"? Is there a news article on the winning map coming up or anything of that sort?





By the way, I think this part of the OP should be rephrased:

MotM June 2014!

All you need to do is to create a map thread following the publish the map on battle.net. With that said, we are already gathering submissions forAll you need to do is tofollowing the forum guidelines AND





Edit: Also, props for publishing the full voting results. (TLMC4 didn't do that.) Called it.That being said, I'm quite happy that Sol Dios won (congratulations to NewSunshine btw!) since it is actually a solid map and Nimbus would be bad advertising for the whole MOTM thing due to lack of balance not being very popular outside the mapmaking sub-community. Speaking of advertising, is there anything being done with regard to "spotlighting" maps and "giving them the attention they deserve"? Is there a news article on the winning map coming up or anything of that sort?By the way, I think this part of the OP should be rephrased:Edit: Also, props for publishing the full voting results. (TLMC4 didn't do that.) not a community mapmaker

RFDaemoniac Profile Joined September 2011 United States 544 Posts #4 You do not need to submit your maps in the thread by linking respective map threads, to my understanding. This seems to be popular practice but is not necessary.



Any map thread published in the month of June is eligible for the next MotM, maps that have been considered for this MotM will not be reconsidered next month, unless they are posted again with extensive/significant changes.

iGrok Profile Blog Joined October 2010 United States 5008 Posts #5 On June 03 2014 03:29 The_Templar wrote:

Very surprising results imo. Also nice that Sidian got something here for his efforts.

I made sure that part of my donation would be allocated to promote innovative maps. When lefix showed me Sidian's map, I instantly loved it. I wasn't expecting a first-month innovation prizewinner (it won't happen every month, only when merited), but I'm pleasantly surprised to say the least.



Congratulations to all the finalists, and I look forward to future MotMs I made sure that part of my donation would be allocated to promote innovative maps. When lefix showed me Sidian's map, I instantly loved it. I wasn't expecting a first-month innovation prizewinner (it won't happen every month, only when merited), but I'm pleasantly surprised to say the least.Congratulations to all the finalists, and I look forward to future MotMs MOTM | Stim.tv | TL Mafia | Fantasy Fighting! | SNSD

Big J Profile Joined March 2011 Austria 16272 Posts #6 Great winner. Though a little too standard for my liking but whatever.



Two thumbs up for the vertical/horizontal ramps. No clue why mapmakers don't use them more.

DnCL Profile Joined May 2013 86 Posts #7 Great initiative. I hope one day those maps will influence the metagame

lefix Profile Joined February 2011 Germany 1081 Posts #8 On June 03 2014 03:54 And G wrote:

Speaking of advertising, is there anything being done with regard to "spotlighting" maps and "giving them the attention they deserve"? Is there a news article on the winning map coming up or anything of that sort?

I have reached out to contacts in different organisations, as well as Blizzard, to make sure they see the results. I have also posted the results to reddit and I believe the results will get spotlighted here as well.



On June 03 2014 03:54 And G wrote:

By the way, I think this part of the OP should be rephrased:

Show nested quote +

MotM June 2014!

All you need to do is to create a map thread following the publish the map on battle.net. With that said, we are already gathering submissions forAll you need to do is tofollowing the forum guidelines AND By the way, I think this part of the OP should be rephrased:Currently, it seems to imply that any map with its own map thread will automatically be considered for the next MOTM, while I assume that you still need to submit your maps in this thread by linking to the respective map threads, right? So this should probably be made clear.

That is indeed correct. Any map with a proper map thread is being considered, provided it is also published on battle.net.





I have reached out to contacts in different organisations, as well as Blizzard, to make sure they see the results. I have also posted the results to reddit and I believe the results will get spotlighted here as well.That is indeed correct. Any map with a proper map thread is being considered, provided it is also published on battle.net. On June 03 2014 03:54 And G wrote:

Edit: Also, props for publishing the full voting results. (TLMC4 didn't do that.)

Sure thing. I am always trying to give people as little to complain about as possible

Sure thing. I am always trying to give people as little to complain about as possible Map of the Month | The Planetary Workshop | SC2Melee.net

Kasaraki Profile Blog Joined May 2012 Denmark 7020 Posts #9 Good stuff, great work everyone.

NewSunshine Profile Joined July 2011 United States 4448 Posts #10 Great work, self. "If you find yourself feeling lost, take pride in the accuracy of your feelings." - Night Vale

Faust852 Profile Joined February 2012 Luxembourg 4004 Posts #11 How do you hold blink in Sol Dios in TvP ?

moskonia Profile Joined January 2011 Israel 1448 Posts #12 On June 03 2014 09:03 Faust852 wrote:

How do you hold blink in Sol Dios in TvP ?

On first look it seemed to be pretty hard, but after further inspection you can see that the only place that you can blink from to the main is the 3/6 3rd. The minerals are pretty tight, thus having a large amount Stalker go to the blink position will take some time. Also, moving from behind the minerals to the closest different position, which is the natural entrance, would take quite a while, since the distance by ground is decently far. Yes the natural has a large open space near it, but since you only need to have your forces in the natural, it's not going to be pretty hard to hold.



Blink Stalkers will probably not be a problem on this map, although I might be completely wrong with my analysis and would love to hear any opinion that claims they will be powerful on this map. On first look it seemed to be pretty hard, but after further inspection you can see that the only place that you can blink from to the main is the 3/6 3rd. The minerals are pretty tight, thus having a large amount Stalker go to the blink position will take some time. Also, moving from behind the minerals to the closest different position, which is the natural entrance, would take quite a while, since the distance by ground is decently far. Yes the natural has a large open space near it, but since you only need to have your forces in the natural, it's not going to be pretty hard to hold.Blink Stalkers will probably not be a problem on this map, although I might be completely wrong with my analysis and would love to hear any opinion that claims they will be powerful on this map.

Cereb Profile Joined November 2011 Denmark 3382 Posts #13 Wow, these looks really really good! I'd love to have them as ladder maps asap "Until the very very top in almost anything, all that matters is how much work you put in. The only problem is most people can't work hard even at things they do enjoy, much less things they don't have a real passion for. -Greg "IdrA" Fields

lefix Profile Joined February 2011 Germany 1081 Posts #14 By the way guys, feel free to show off your june submissions in this thread Map of the Month | The Planetary Workshop | SC2Melee.net

Samro225am Profile Joined August 2010 Germany 982 Posts Last Edited: 2014-06-03 12:00:31 #15 Lefix, many thanks for organizing the new motm series. Nice competition, but I'd be happy to see a more elaborated voting system. I do not see why you hide the exact results in spoilers and also the 4th and 5th place...



Good to note that these 5 together actually create a quite good pool of various play styles.



edit: With how close the percentages are i could also imagine that another voting system (5 to 1points for 1st to 5th place) would bring different results.

neobowman Profile Blog Joined March 2008 Canada 3321 Posts #16 You know, could you guys just not hold these competitions until I'm back mid-July? That would be great, thanks.



T_T.



Congrats to the winners, the maps look great.

lefix Profile Joined February 2011 Germany 1081 Posts #17 Don't worry, we will have another one then Map of the Month | The Planetary Workshop | SC2Melee.net

Samro225am Profile Joined August 2010 Germany 982 Posts #18 what about you and TL creating another poll system?

Morrissey Profile Blog Joined April 2014 Germany 54 Posts #19 I reallay like the 1st place. better tahn some ladder maps even MarineKingPrime forever

Pino Profile Joined June 2013 1032 Posts Last Edited: 2014-06-03 13:20:41 #20 On June 03 2014 09:36 moskonia wrote:

Show nested quote +

On June 03 2014 09:03 Faust852 wrote:

How do you hold blink in Sol Dios in TvP ?

On first look it seemed to be pretty hard, but after further inspection you can see that the only place that you can blink from to the main is the 3/6 3rd. The minerals are pretty tight, thus having a large amount Stalker go to the blink position will take some time. Also, moving from behind the minerals to the closest different position, which is the natural entrance, would take quite a while, since the distance by ground is decently far. Yes the natural has a large open space near it, but since you only need to have your forces in the natural, it's not going to be pretty hard to hold.



Blink Stalkers will probably not be a problem on this map, although I might be completely wrong with my analysis and would love to hear any opinion that claims they will be powerful on this map. On first look it seemed to be pretty hard, but after further inspection you can see that the only place that you can blink from to the main is the 3/6 3rd. The minerals are pretty tight, thus having a large amount Stalker go to the blink position will take some time. Also, moving from behind the minerals to the closest different position, which is the natural entrance, would take quite a while, since the distance by ground is decently far. Yes the natural has a large open space near it, but since you only need to have your forces in the natural, it's not going to be pretty hard to hold.Blink Stalkers will probably not be a problem on this map, although I might be completely wrong with my analysis and would love to hear any opinion that claims they will be powerful on this map.



This is what i thought at first glance, making a long distance between the nat and the blinking point into the main will decrease the power of time warps preventing T units to make it to the right spot in time, and thus make blink much less powerful. I don't think will be a problem, but then again i'm not that good. Anyway i'd like this map to make it into some competitive environment.



Plus, denying completely these blink spot also prevent the T from scouting with a reaper. This way, making it difficult but still possible for blink to come in the main is favoring the T IMO with the double reaper scouting pathways. This is what i thought at first glance, making a long distance between the nat and the blinking point into the main will decrease the power of time warps preventing T units to make it to the right spot in time, and thus make blink much less powerful. I don't think will be a problem, but then again i'm not that good. Anyway i'd like this map to make it into some competitive environment.Plus, denying completely these blink spot also prevent the T from scouting with a reaper. This way, making it difficult but still possible for blink to come in the main is favoring the T IMO with the double reaper scouting pathways.

1 2 Next All