Rated 1 out of 5 by Rozberry from Too dry and very flaky I got a free sample (black) with my last order and was excited to try it because I'm such a fan of the perversion liner. Unfortunately I'm very disappointed in this liner. It dragged across my eyelid leaving very little colour behind and I found it was flaking off leaving specks in my eyelashes which transferred into my eye, and I found many flakes under my eyes. I tried repeatedly to line my eyes with it but found I had to press very hard and draw across the same area over and over which resulted in a patchy and overly thick line which was not a good look. It didn't really hurt but my eyes were definitely red and irritated when I removed it.

Rated 4 out of 5 by 1122Katie from Trouble keeping product sharp This has excellent pigmentation and the black ACTUALLY looks black (some other brands struggle with this)! It glides on so smoothly; its so nice. The first couple uses I really loved this product but when it needed sharpening I struggled with it actually keeping that fine tip. It always seemed to break off no matter how delicately I sharpened it. As a result I had to hold the pencil at a certain angle to get it to go on not too thick, which was tricky. It would be nice if there was a way for the product to sharpen a lot easier. Unless someone has a beauty hack for how to do that, I wouldn't recommend this product unless you like to layer it on thick

Rated 5 out of 5 by TheRealEmilyCox from Black Velvet, if you please! Amaze-balls! I already own a million different black liners from competitors. This liner blows those other fools out of the water! It's so rich, velvety and smooth. The color is hard to describe but I will try. it's smokey black, truly like velvet. I like to panda smudge this and use UD's shadow, Zero, to set it and give it some extra smokiness. This product is sexy! I love everything about it. It's easy to apply, doesn't break like other cheapy liners and the color payoff is great! You won't find yourself lining it over and over to get the results you need. I'd recommend this to any newbies trying to achieve that smokey look without the fuss and muss of black shadow.