CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Whether you live in a blue county or a red one, Ohioans can agree on this much: we love our pizza.

But what makes a great pizza? Should the sauce be spicy or sweet? Is a thin Neapolitan crust or thick pan-style dough better? Do you prefer classic toppings or mixing it up with unusual ingredients?

Ohio's best pizza shops each have something special about them. Back in 2016, we went in search of the best pizza joint in each of the state's 88 counties. Three years later, we're back, using the same methodology of combining a restaurant's average star-rating with the number of views and reviews on Yelp to identify the top pizza spot in every county.

While some joints have held on to their coveted standing as best in county, new pizza shop champs have been crowned up and down the Buckeye State.

Did your favorite pizza shop in your town make the list?

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Snappy Tomato Pizza

ADAMS COUNTY

Snappy Tomato Pizza

112 W Mulberry St

West Union, OH 45693

snappytomato.com

Sample Yelp review: "The ranch pizza is really good!! Definitely worth the drive from Maysville. I'll definitely stop there the next time I'm in West Union." -- Jason W.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Daric K.

ALLEN COUNTY

Bella Notta's Pizza

662 S Main St

Lima, OH 45804

Sample Yelp review: "Wow. This is the quintessential example of the best kind of midwestern pizza. Soft wheat crust, quality ingredients, GREAT leftover, and just the right amount of sauce and cheese. Fantastic service, also. Don't go anywhere else!" -- Seth D.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Becky L.

ASHLAND COUNTY

Donna D's Family Pizza

1311 Cleveland Ave

Ashland, OH 44805

donnadsfamilypizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "Something about the thick provolone cheese they use, the sauce is the absolute best pizza sauce I've ever tasted out of any pizzeria, the oregano seasoning and the crispy ribbon crust are just perfect to me, and anyone I've ever got Donna's with agrees with me. It's very rare I hear anyone be disappointed." -- Derek D.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Jenn G.

ASHTABULA COUNTY

Capo's Pizza II

118 W Main St

Geneva, OH 44041

websitecapospizza2.com

Sample Yelp review: "I think this place could seriously give every Chicago pizzeria a run for its money!" -- Jenn G.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

ATHENS COUNTY

Avalanche Pizza

329 E State St

Athens, OH 45701

Sample Yelp review: "We got the "Godzilla" pizza; chicken, spinach, feta, mozzarella. The crust was great, not too thin, not too thick, not burnt, not underdone. We liked how buttery it was. It had a nice flavor, but didn't take away from the pizza. They do NOT skimp on the toppings. I love that in a pizza." -- Alyson L.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Kim N.

AUGLAIZE COUNTY

La Grande Pizza

16 S Blackhoof St

Wapakoneta, OH 45895

Sample Yelp review: "La Grande is home to me, as in it is literally where I grew up. The pizza is always good, very saucy and the ingredients fresh and there is a plethora of fried foods for you to feast on." -- Erin Q.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Pizza Milano

BELMONT COUNTY

Pizza Milano

165 W. Main Street

St. Clairsville, OH 43950

Sample Yelp review: "Possibly THE single most delicious pizza crust I've ever eaten. Wonderful texture, shreds of cheese all the way out to the edge so it cooked up crispy, just a little bit chewy but not too much, surprisingly light." -- Jeff C.

Don't Edit

cleveland.com file photo

BROWN COUNTY

Parker's Pizzeria

124 N Main St

Georgetown, OH 45121

(937) 378-6936

Sample Yelp review: "The pizzas are homemade and amazing topped with plenty of goodness. They offer hoagies, sandwiches and salads plus beer. Everything about this little restaurant is great down to the booths, TVs and free WiFi." -- Marsha B.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Nobuyuki S.

BUTLER COUNTY

Milillo’s Pizza

1010 Main St

Hamilton, OH 45013

Sample Yelp review: "The best pizza in Hamilton during my lifetime. My family still drives 20 minutes to pick up Milillo's for birthdays and other family events. The smell inside the pizza shop is one of my favorite smells in life." -- M B

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Crossroads Pizza

CARROLL COUNTY

Crossroads Pizza

218 High St NW

Carrollton, OH 44615

crossroadscarrollton.com

Sample Yelp review: "I'm not a huge pizza fan but this pizza is DELICIOUS!" -- Carmen J.

Don't Edit

CHAMPAIGN COUNTY

Cafe Paradiso

13 Monument Square

Urbana, OH 43078

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza at Cafe Paradiso was without question the best we've had since we arrived in the area. Everything about it was almost perfect and most important, the flavor was outstanding." -- Harold W.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Jennifer K.

CLARK COUNTY

Mikey's Pizza

406 W Harding Rd

Springfield, OH 45504

(937) 398-1700

Sample Yelp review: "Nice pizza. This crispy crust was just right. Cheese to the edge. Pepperoni were little cups of love holding just a little grease." -- Rich D.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by LaRosa's Pizza

CLERMONT COUNTY

LaRosa's Pizza

3780 Bach-Buxton Rd

Amelia, OH 45102

larosas.com

Sample Yelp review: "Love this LaRosa's. Excellent service and the food is served hot and great ! Pizza's, calzones, salads and more! Never had anything bad yet. My favorite is the thin crust with pepperoni.....hot and tasty." -- Gina H.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Mike H.

CLINTON COUNTY

Generations Pizzaria

100 Lowes Dr

Wilmington, OH 45177

generationspizzeria.com

Sample Yelp review: "Family owned with big flavor. Wide variety of pizza toppings. They also offer pasta, salad, and wings! Their wings are huge too. The staff is always pleasant. If you can, catch them Sunday and Monday for their lunch pizza buffet." -- Catherine G.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Mary's Pizza

COLUMBIANA COUNTY

Mary's Pizza

301 N Beaver St

Lisbon, OH 44432

Sample Yelp review: "THE BEST PIZZA EVER. All the food is wonderful and couldn't ask for better prices. Love that place. You can even get frozen pizzas if your not local with instructions on how to bake. Great for people who've moved away when they come home to visit." -- Bethy A.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Crowtown Pizza

COSHOCTON COUNTY

Crowtown Pizza

783 S 2nd St

Coshocton, OH 43812

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza for the buffet was really good. The crust I had was the crispy crust. I personally like my pepperoni cooked a little more and I am always cautious about ordering off the buffet, but this has changed my mind. The crust and sauce make this a great place for pizza!" -- Austin M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Amy P.

CRAWFORD COUNTY

Baker’s Pizza Sports Shack

224 N Sandusky Ave

Bucyrus, OH 44820

Sample Yelp review: " Consistently good. Entire menu is tasty and priced fair. Beer is always great and very cold." -- Dan C.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Michael U.

CUYAHOGA COUNTY

Crust

1020 Kenilworth Ave

Cleveland, OH 44113

Sample Yelp review: "Absolutely great place to grab a huge slice of pizza and wash it down with a special craft tap." -- Ashley M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Rapid Fire Pizza

DARKE COUNTY

Rapid Fire Pizza

1487 Wagner Ave

Greenville, OH 45331

Sample Yelp review: "This is one of my favorite pizza places. You get to pick everything from crust to toppings. I love that you watch them make it." -- Kathy M.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Colin S.

DEFIANCE COUNTY

Lefty’s Pizza Subs

1018 Ralston Ave Ste 101

Defiance, OH 43512

(419) 784-0789

Sample Yelp review: " The pizza was pretty solid. The dough was pretty good and not too many air bubbles considering they use a belt fed oven. The sauce was not really rich but it wasn't bland either." -- Colin S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Ashley E.

DELAWARE COUNTY

Amato’s Woodfired Pizza

6 S Sandusky St

Delaware, OH 43015

Sample Yelp review: "When we first moved to Delaware we could tell Amato's must be good because every time you drove by the place was packed. We tried the bruschetta and five cheese pizza. I love how their crust is thin and you get the nice crispiness from the wood fired oven." -- Cortney M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Emily R.

ERIE COUNTY

The Brick Oven Bistro

1012 Cleveland Rd

Sandusky, OH 44870

Sample Yelp review: "The pizzas had amazing thin, crispy crust and were huge, especially for the price. The toppings were clearly fresh and tasty." -- Alexandria L.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Rick G.

FAIRFIELD COUNTY

Pink Cricket Restaurant

929 E Main St

Lancaster, OH 43130

pinkcricketrestaurant.com

Sample Yelp review: "Having tried multiple pizza spots in Lancaster, this is my favorite. The pizza sauce has a sweet taste to it and the thin crust is cooked consistently and not burned but just right. It comes out piping hot and ready to eat!" -- Jeremy M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Robert V.

FAYETTE COUNTY

Streetside 62

2007 Columbus Ave

Washington Court House, OH 43160

Sample Yelp review: "It's a bit like being in a Panera Bread, Olive Garden and your favorite pizza joint all in one with their own flare added in." -- Tim B.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Lauren S.

FRANKLIN COUNTY

Harvest Pizzeria

495 S 4th St

Columbus, OH 43206

Sample Yelp review: "Oh my gosh. The photos don't do this pizza justice. Eat it slow and enjoy every bite because you'll be sad when your belly can't hold anymore. Delicious salads and pizzas. Seasonal and wonderful." -- Melissa M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Nancy I.

FULTON COUNTY

Samuel Mancino's

106 S Defiance St

Archbold, OH 43502

(419) 446-4600

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza and grinders are the best in town." -- Andy S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Richard H.

GALLIA COUNTY

Lorobi's Pizza

248 2nd Ave

Gallipolis, OH 45631

(740) 446-0300

Sample Yelp review: "I love this place! My favorite is just basic cheese pizza. Great light sauce with greasy melted cheese. Great pizza! It's my favorite place in town." -- Patricia J.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Kerry K.

GEAUGA COUNTY

Guido’s Pizza Haven & Restaurant

12809 Chillicothe Rd

Chesterland, OH 44026

(440) 729-9666

Sample Yelp review: "I've always ordered the pizza extra crisp. The pizza dough becomes a bit firmer to hold up to the sauce, cheese and toppings. Plus the crispiness of the edge crust is to die for. The corner pieces are my favorite. Don't go expecting a standard pizzeria slice. This is a completely different take on pizza that is incredibly delicious." -- Jim K.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Andrew B.

GREENE COUNTY

Spinoza’s Pizza & Salads

2727 Fairfield Commons Blvd

Beavercreek, OH 45431

Sample Yelp review: "Spinoza's is a really great place to go for a pizza with friends-- the food isn't that bad either. On Friday's they even have live music!" -- Carol W.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Kelly L.

GUERNSEY COUNTY

Galaxy Pizza

1201 Woodlawn Ave

Cambridge, OH 43725

(740) 439-0744

Sample Yelp review: "It's a thin crust pizza, cut into strips. The pepperoni are like little shells of oil. They crisp up on the ends and have a nice little spice to them. The pizza reminds me most of Donatos Pizza in taste and style. I love this pizza and am never disappointed." -- Tara G.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Brian R.

HAMILTON COUNTY

Fireside Pizza

773 E McMillan St

Cincinnati, OH 45206

firesidepizzawalnuthills.com

Sample Yelp review: "Some of the best pizza in town! Fireside Pizza in Walnut Hills is located in an old firehouse and that is just where the charm begins. This neighborhood pizzeria makes pies using fresh ingredients and baked in a wood burning oven." -- Brian R.

Don't Edit

HANCOCK COUNTY

Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria

116 E Sandusky St

Findlay, OH 45840

Sample Yelp review: "We ordered a supreme pizza and I have to say it was one of the best I've ever had! The sauce is perfect, not over powering or too spicy. And something they did that we loved? They baked the pizza, then put the veggies on top after they took it out of the oven. This left the veggies nice and crisp and so tasty." -- Collen H.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Ambrosia A.

HARDIN COUNTY

Michael Angelo’s Pizza

215 S Detroit St

Kenton, OH 43326

Sample Yelp review: "Wow! Really enjoyed the thin crust pizza we had tonight! The crust was just a little crunchy which I think is just right. Service was great as well." -- Jeff F.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Natalie F.

HARRISON COUNTY

Diangelo's Pizza

114 E Market St

Cadiz, OH 43907

(740) 942-3000

Sample Yelp review: "Great local pizza shop. Enjoy the taste because it is so different than the national chain pizza shops." -- Clint M.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

HENRY COUNTY

Hawks Pizza & Drive-Thru

402 E Washington St

Napoleon, OH 43545

hawkspizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "Best pizza in town. Healthy salad options. Burritos are huge! Clark really knows how to keep his business a success!" -- Dawn H.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Brandi W.

HIGHLAND COUNTY

24 Deli & Sweet Shoppe

144 W Main St

Hillsboro, OH 45133

twentyfourexchangeanddeli.com

Sample Yelp review: "Their taco pizza is amazing!" -- Jillian A.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Sunny I.

HOCKING COUNTY

Pizza Crossing

58 N Mulberry St

Logan, OH 43138

pizzacrossing.com

Sample Yelp review: "Probably the only pizza place I have been to with so many toppings on it. They put a lot of toppings, so choose them wisely as some of them can be overpowering." -- Sunny I.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Cassie R.

HOLMES COUNTY

Fox’s Pizza Den

42 N Grant St

Millersburg, OH 44654

Sample Yelp review: "The taco pizza was amazing! Crunchy crust with a chewy warm center, meaty and delicious!" -- Tex R.

Don't Edit

HURON COUNTY

Pizza Post

222 1/2 E Main St

Norwalk, OH 44857

norwalkpizzapost.com

Sample Yelp review: "If there is such a thing as a 'Norwalk Style' pizza this is it. It's a thinner crusted pizza with ample delicious sauce and perfectly melted cheese." -- Julie T.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Cardo's Pizza

JACKSON COUNTY

Cardo’s Pizza

19 W South St

Jackson, OH 45640

cardospizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "This is the best buffet I've found..., they are out continuously with fresh pizza every kind you could imagine." -- Danny L.

Don't Edit

JEFFERSON COUNTY

Giannamore’s Pizza

407 Cadiz Rd

Steubenville, OH 43953

(740) 264-9371

Sample Yelp review: "This is the best. It is hot pizza, served with room temp cheese and pepperoni, not melted cheese or heated pepperoni. This is absolutely key." -- Jack S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Carlos S.

KNOX COUNTY

Amato's Woodfired Pizza

668 N Sandusky St

Mount Vernon, OH 43050

(740) 393-2003

Sample Yelp review: "Great thin crust wood fired pizza! Some of the better pizza I've had in Ohio! I'm not sure what else to even write. Great service. Good craft beer selection. Clean place. Central location in Mt.Vernon. It's just great!" -- Travis S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Renee P.

LAKE COUNTY

Bada Bing Pizza

36 S State St

Painesville, OH 44077

Sample Yelp review: "The Cowboy and the Meat Monster are usually our go-to pizzas and they are so so good! We recently tried the Buffalo Chicken pizza and we were not disappointed! Their sauce has a great flavor and the pizza as a whole is not too greasey." -- Katie M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Gionvanni's Pizza

LAWRENCE COUNTY

Giovanni's Pizza

624 Park Ave

Ironton, OH 45638

giovannispizzapower.com

Sample Yelp review: "Visiting from out of town, and our family ordered several pizzas from here to share. All different toppings and types of pizza. Everyone enjoyed it, with minimal leftovers haha. Nice to have something other than a national chain while visiting. We would order from here again." -- Robert G.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Laura B.

LICKING COUNTY

Plaza Pizza

1130 Mount Vernon Rd

Newark, OH 43055

(740) 366-2511

Sample Yelp review: "I've had pizza from all over and this is the best pizza I have ever had. I have been coming here basically since I was born and have never had a bad pizza!" -- Kayla T.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Steve S.

LOGAN COUNTY

Six Hundred Downtown

108 S Main St

Bellefontaine, OH 43311

(937) 599-6600

Sample Yelp review: "Great pizza, I love the Detroit-style crust but they only make a few a day so be sure to get there early if you want one!" -- Mandy B.

Don't Edit

LORAIN COUNTY

In Forno Pizza

35840 Chester Rd

Avon, OH 44011

infornopizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "This pizza and garlic bread was so delicious! It's all fresh oven-fired Neapolitan pizza. My favorite kind of pizza ever is the thin crust floppy kind that you can fold and eat, but it still has a nice crisp to the crust. They nailed it here!" -- Allison G.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Alisa T.

LUCAS COUNTY

Pizza Papalis

519 Monroe St

Toledo, OH 43604

pizzapapalis.com

Sample Yelp review: "Some of the best deep dish pizza I have ever had, and definitely the best in Toledo area. Service was fast and wonderful. Pizza was perfectly cooked and not too doughy. Even the dessert and appetizers were deep dish. Cost of a deep dish might scare some off, but the pizza is huge and a small can feed two with leftovers." -- Alisa T.

Don't Edit

MADISON COUNTY

Cappy’s Pizza

225 Lafayette St

London, OH 43140

cappyspizza.org

Sample Yelp review: "Ordered Cappy's favorite pizza...extra cheese and pepperoni and a couple of beers...pizza was hot and delicious and came out only after a short wait, beer was ice cold. I'll be back! Very nice place." -- Bob H.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Joe C.

MAHONING COUNTY

Wedgewood Fernando's Pizza

6200 South Ave

Youngstown, OH 44512

wedgewoodpizzaboardman.com

Sample Yelp review: "Love Wedgewood pizza!! I grew up on this pizza. It is one of the best pizza places in Boardman. I love their pepperoni pizza but my favorite is their spinach, potato, and broccoli pizza. It is seriously the best! It isn't greasy at all. The red sauce is great and so is the crust. I love that you can get it in Square cut. Square cut pizza always just taste better no idea why." -- Samantha B.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Jon A.

MARION COUNTY

The Warehouse

320 W Center St

Marion, OH 43302

thewarehouseitalian.com

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza was very good (8 out of 10), but I have had better. I would definitely order the pizza again though and I am a self proclaimed pizza connoisseur eating pizza 350 days a year for 20+ years." -- Jon A.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Gregg S.

MEDINA COUNTY

Samosky's Homestyle Pizzeria

6738 Center Rd

Valley City, OH 44280

Sample Yelp review: "The spinachi pizza is an award winning pizza that holds up to its rep. With quality unique ingredients like cranberries, sun flower seeds, and feta cheese, this is a unique combination that really satisfies all your tastebuds. Don't just take my word for it. Order it for yourself ASAP." -- T.J. S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Fox's Pizza Den

MEIG'S COUNTY

Fox's Pizza Den

518 E Main St

Pomeroy, OH 45769

foxspizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "This is a great pizza place with wonderful food, service, and is super clean. Love eating outside on the patio overlooking the river." -- Barb S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Daniel H.

MERCER COUNTY

Celina Wine Store

716 W Logan St

Celina, OH 45822

(419) 586-6416

Sample Yelp review: "The owner and staff were very friendly and knowledgeable. The fresh dough pizza was crisp and delicious. This place comes highly recommended. We will definitely return." -- Dustin A.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Jessica L.

MIAMI COUNTY

3 Joe's Pizzeria & Trattoria

414 W Water St

Piqua, OH 45356

Sample Yelp review: "The pizzas are excellent. The margherita pizza is probably my favorite, the crust is so delicately crispy!" -- M M

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Sam I.

MONROE COUNTY

Beallsville Diner

52733 Ohio Ave

Beallsville, OH 43716

(740) 926-2200

Sample Yelp review: "Good food. Stromboli and Calzones are awesome. Fresh cut fries are awesome. Home cooking comfort food is excellent as well. Tons of local history on the walls. Worth the stop." -- Chris P.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Eric S.

MONTGOMERY COUNTY

Old Scratch Pizza

812 S Patterson Blvd

Dayton, OH 45402

oldscratchpizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "The pizzas I recommend are the Angry Beekeeper, Mushroom, Margherita...any of them, really. They are amazing. The crust is wood-fired to perfection and they import the flour from Italy....they aren't messing around!" -- Ellie D.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Joe B.

MORGAN COUNTY

Deano's Pizza & Subs

52 N 7th St

McConnelsville, OH 43756

(740) 962-3463

Sample Yelp review: "Great pizza! Wonderful staff! Affordable pricing! Everything you'd want in a small town pizza place!" -- Joe B.

Don't Edit

MORROW COUNTY

Purple Indian Pizza & Subs

508 W Marion Rd

Mount Gilead, OH 43338

(419) 947-4777

Sample Yelp review: "Great pizza, subs, salads, and chicken. A Morrow County staple for many years. Great quality product-- not too many pizza places make their own fresh crust on site and still shred their own cheese!" -- Sarah J.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Angela L.

MUSKINGUM COUNTY

Russo's Wood Fired Pizza

2526 Maple Ave

Zanesville, OH 43701

russoswoodfired.com

Sample Yelp review: "Absolutely awesome little spot. Make your own pizza is a quaint little idea but this joint just plain rocks. Garlic Alfredo sauce? Get out of town. It was amazing!" -- Mitch H.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Kevin W.

NOBLE COUNTY

Wally’s Old Fashioned Pizza

805 Miller St

Caldwell, OH 43724

(740) 732-4241

Sample Yelp review: "I have to say, this is one of the best pizzas that I have had in a long time. It's not flashy or trendy, just a straight forward and traditional. I especially liked how they cooked the pepperoni separately and added that with extra cheese after it was baked. This kept it from being as greasy as a lot of others." -- Ryan V.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Dan C.

OTTAWA COUNTY

Bell Mell Pizza

307 Fulton St

Port Clinton, OH 43452

(419) 732-7337

Sample Yelp review: "Bell Mell Tavern has the best pizza in Ottawa County. We love stopping here anytime we are in the area. We always get the 12" deluxe pizza. Definitely a place the locals hang, but always a great crowd. Live bands on many Saturday nights." -- Mike L.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Dominic F.

PAULDING COUNTY

Papa Oley's Pizzeria

114 S Main St

Antwerp, OH 45813

papaoleysantwerp.com

Sample Yelp review: "Delicious pizza in a quaint atmosphere. The cheesy bread was amazing. Service was fast and friendly. Menu contained not only pizza but salads, calzones, subs and pasta dishes." -- Sue F.

Don't Edit

PERRY COUNTY

The Pizza Place

100 W Broadway St

New Lexington, OH 43764

(740) 342-5123

Sample Yelp review: "Great pizza, loaded to the edge on tasty thin crust. However, crappy service for dine in." -- KL R.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Rob M.

PICKAWAY COUNTY

Pizza Cottage

23401 US Hwy 23 S

Circleville, OH 43113

Sample Yelp review: "The crust was thin and not too overloaded with sauce and the pepperoni was delicious. Very good pizza option." -- Tim Y.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Bill-Peggy H.

PIKE COUNTY

Giovanni's

513 E Emmitt Ave

Waverly, OH 45690

(740) 947-4467

Sample Yelp review: "Best pizza around! I order from Giovanni's at least once a week. Never been disappointed." -- Jim L.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Lucci's Place

PORTAGE COUNTY

Lucci's Place

405 E Main St

Kent, OH 44240

(330) 673-9833

Sample Yelp review: "Pizza is out of this world. I could eat my body weight in their pizza and still have room for more." -- Khloe S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Sherri P.

PREBLE COUNTY

Powerhouse Pizza & Subs

312 W Central Ave

Camden, OH 45311

powerhousepizzacamden.com

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza was everything we'd hoped for. The thin crust was perfect and the toppings were generously distributed over the pie." -- Amber C.

Don't Edit

PUTNAM COUNTY

Clubhouse Pizza

219 N Main

Continental, OH 45831

(419) 596-4700

Sample Yelp review: "Stopped for lunch, great pizza, nicest people! Will stop here again and try the gizzards." -- Brad B.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Leah L.

RICHLAND COUNTY

Leaning Tower of Pizza



180 Lexington Ave

Mansfield, OH 44907

leaningtowerofpizzamo.com

Sample Yelp review: "I'm sort of a pizza snob and this is solid four star pie. Good crispy edge crust, tasty cheese...nicely done." -- Robert F.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Michael B.

ROSS COUNTY

Fire & Stone Pizzeria

98 N Paint St

Chillicothe, OH 45601

(740) 771-4591

Sample Yelp review: "Best crust in Chillicothe, I find it hard to believe but fire stone makes a difference. A little lite on the toppings at times but still good pizza. Place is lively and staff is friendly." -- Scott J.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Lauren W.

SANDUSKY COUNTY

Depot Pizza

117 N Monroe St

Fremont, OH 43420

(419) 332-5510

Sample Yelp review: "One of my favorite hangout spots! You'll love the owners and staff! Plus, the pizza is amazing and they have a huge craft beer selection. This is a must stop!" -- Michelle A.

Don't Edit

SCIOTO COUNTY

Fred's Pizza Express

1920 11th St

Portsmouth, OH 45662

(740) 353-1218

Sample Yelp review: "We love the pizza and the onion rings! Cheese breadsticks are amazing as well. This is our go to pizza and it's over an hour round trip but definitely worth it." -- Shannon J.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Kathy S.

SENECA COUNTY

AJ's Heavenly Pizza

2 Main St

Tiffin, OH 44883

(419) 448-1427

Sample Yelp review: "I grew up in Tiffin so naturally I do gravitate to AJs. When ever in town like clockwork I get AJs at least once (at risk of sounding redundant). If you are in town I would recommend. The dish is some where in-between deep and NY style. To me it's a version of soul food. The sauce is ultimately the best part of a great pizza chain." -- Grant M.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Mark F.

SHELBY COUNTY

Keyhole Pizza

6621 State Rte 66

Fort Loramie, OH 45845

keyholepizzaoh.com

Sample Yelp review: "Wow! Cozy cool place. They advertise "The Worst PizzA and the Warmest Beer" but that's not what we got! Hofbrau House beer was just fine. Pizza and ingredients were well above par." -- Mark F.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Nicole L.

STARK COUNTY

Lindsey's Pizza

2827 Whipple Ave NW

Canton, OH 44708

lindseyspizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "I have eaten pizzas at Lindsey's for a few years now and never been sorry. Fresh, great flavor, texture, what a pizza should be." -- Wyckliffe H.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Sheena W.

SUMMIT COUNTY

Luigi's

105 N Main St

Akron, OH 44308

(330) 253-2999

Sample Yelp review: "Quite possibly the greatest pizza in the history of the world. They don't advertise,they don't deliver and they don't need to." -- Jake B.

Don't Edit

TRUMBULL COUNTY

Sunrise Inn

510 E Market St

Warren, OH 44481

sunriseinnofwarren.com

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza here is phenomenal. I can't say the same for the other food items here however, the pizza is fantastic -- dare I say the best in Northeast Ohio." -- Sue T.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Emily C.

TUSCARAWAS COUNTY

Park Street Pizza

215 Dover Rd NW

Sugarcreek, OH 44681

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza was amazing! You don't see cheddar cheese on pizza anymore and this mix of cheeses was fantastic!! So much flavor!!" -- Ashley M.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Shaun H.

UNION COUNTY

Benny's Pizza

968 Columbus Ave

Marysville, OH 43040

(937) 644-0881

Sample Yelp review: "Benny's is easily my favorite pizza in Central Ohio. Their crust is perfect, their cheese is great, and their sausage is amazing. I'd be eating their pizza at least once a month if they were closer to home." -- Kaoru M.

Don't Edit

VAN WERT COUNTY

Wild Willy’s

209 S Washington St

Van Wert, OH 45891

Sample Yelp review: "We went for the buffet and it ended up being a great choice. The salad bar was excellent and they brought out so many pizzas it would make your head swim. Every pizza I tried was great." -- Dr Don S.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Jeff H.

VINTON COUNTY

Percelli's Pizza

417 S Market St

Mc Arthur, OH 45651

(740) 596-5281

Sample Yelp review: "The place isn't fancy, but they strive to make a better than average pizza. The pizzas do have a real hand made crust, an that is a big plus. Toppings are plentiful and good quality." -- Jeff H.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Two Cities Pizza

WARREN COUNTY

Two Cities Pizza

202 W Main St

Mason, OH 45040

twocitiespizza.com

Sample Yelp review: "This pizza place is more than just a place to eat. Its an experience. The old building brings a feeling of a time long past and the seating is open, airy, refreshing and a great place to hang with the one you love or with a group of people watching the lastest game." -- Danielle- City Skipper Gal F.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by the Original Pizza Place

WASHINGTON COUNTY

The Original Pizza Place

231 2nd St

Marietta, OH 45750

(740) 374-4333

Sample Yelp review: "Pizza is like the kind I grew up on on the East Coast. Thin crust with lots of cheese. Great flavor and solid service." -- David C.

Don't Edit

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by D I.

WAYNE COUNTY

Coccia House Pizza

764 Pittsburg Ave

Wooster, OH 44691

Sample Yelp review: "The pizza is among the best in Ohio. I grew up minutes from Cleveland's Little Italy and still think Coccia House beats all of them. (No offense, Little Italy places. I still love you. There's plenty of room in my heart for all of you, and plenty of room in my belly for your pizza.)" -- Matt G.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Mike P.

WILLIAMS COUNTY

Wyse Guys

110 W Jackson St

West Unity, OH 43570

(419) 924-2223

Sample Yelp review: "Great buffet, newly remodeled and expanded dining room. I live in town and eat here regularly. The pizza and subs are some of the best I've had. Cool pinball machines, too! Super Mario is the best." -- Patrick B.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Lee B.

WOOD COUNTY

Campus Pollyeyes

440 E Court St

Bowling Green, OH 43402

campuspollyeyes.com

Sample Yelp review: "If I had to choose one meal before I die, I would choose Polleyes' Chicken and Cheese sticks. I kid you not, they are THE GREATEST THING YOU WILL EVER TASTE." -- Michael M.

Don't Edit

Yelp photo by Lisa B.

WYANDOT COUNTY

Don Tomasso's

123 West Wyandot Ave

Upper Sandusky, OH 43351

dontomassospizza.com

Sample Yelp photo: "It's not everyday that an Ohio pizza catches you off guard, however, this one did! Absolutely Amazing!" -- Kevin H.