Samuel Reynolds once gave a teammate the cleats off his own feet during a soccer game. So it didn’t surprise family and friends that the 16-year-old from Arlington, Texas, described as “one of the most compassionate and helpful people you could ever meet,” would stand up to a bully.

But what they likely didn’t expect was that Reynolds’s decision to defend a boy who was getting picked on last week would get him killed.

Reynolds died Thursday after he was shot outside his apartment, and his family says the teenage boy behind the bullying is to blame. According to Arlington police, Reynolds’s family reported that he had intervened in a fight involving the alleged bully and “a smaller boy” just days before the shooting.


“After he broke up the fight, he started having some trouble with the suspect,” Arlington Police Lt. Christopher Cook said at a news conference Friday. While Reynolds’s family maintains he was targeted by the alleged bully, Cook told BuzzFeed News that authorities are still working to verify that information.

The suspect, identified as a male between the ages of 13 and 15 years old, was arrested shortly after the incident, which was captured on cameras around the apartment complex where both teenagers lived, KXAS reported. Reynolds’s death has sparked an outpouring of grief from the community, and authorities have condemned the shooting as “so senseless.”

By early Monday, tens of thousands of dollars had been donated to help the Reynolds family, and countless tributes remembered the high school sophomore for his “heart of gold.”

“He cared about people and he did what he thought was right,” Shay Tyes, a family friend, told KXAS.

NEW: @ArlingtonPD say family of 16yo Sam Reynolds report he’d broken up a fight days ago & believe that was reason another teenager shot & killed him yesterday.

Can’t begin to wrap my head around this one….. #WFAA pic.twitter.com/ShO9tkB2FX — Lauren Zakalik (@wfaalauren) February 7, 2020

The deadly confrontation played out Thursday afternoon outside Pinewoods Apartments, located roughly a half-mile west of the University of Texas, Arlington’s main campus.

Reynolds was seen on video walking between two buildings when the teenage suspect approached him, KTVT reported.

“He pulls out a handgun from the rear part of his pants he was wearing, points it at the victim and fires one round,” Cook told reporters Friday, according to KXAS.


Police arrived to the apartment complex just after 4:30 p.m. and found Reynolds suffering from a gunshot wound. The 16-year-old was rushed to a nearby hospital where he later died.

Cook said one shell casing was recovered from the scene, adding that authorities believe a .40-caliber semiautomatic handgun was allegedly used. The gun has not been recovered yet, BuzzFeed News reported.

Late Thursday, Arlington Police Chief Will Johnson announced that an arrest had been made, tweeting, “We have a lot of work to do on this case tonight.” In another tweet, Johnson described the shooting as “emotionally tough” on everyone involved and stressed that the investigation would look into how the young suspect ended up with the weapon.

The alleged shooter has since been moved to a juvenile detention center and is facing a murder charge, according to KXAS. It is unclear whether he will be tried as a child or an adult.

“This senseless act of gun violence has no place in society and our hometown community,” Johnson tweeted.

Cook echoed Johnson’s statement during Friday’s news conference.

“We are sick and tired of children in our community coming into contact with firearms and possessing them and using them in this type of manner,” he said. “If an adult has provided this firearm, you certainly can bet that we’re going to pursue them vigorously.”

This senseless act of gun violence has no place in society and our hometown community. This was an emotionally tough case for responding officers, investigators and medics. We will direct our attention to how a young teen suspect accessed a firearm used in the offense. pic.twitter.com/ZyLIuO6X7e — Will Johnson (@ArlingtonChief) February 7, 2020

Meanwhile, Reynolds’s family, friends and community are struggling to cope with the sudden loss.

“My partner in crime,” wrote Reynolds’s mother, Madison Fletcher, in a recent Facebook post. “He was the definition of silly. My sweet, sweet boy.”


In a statement Friday, Arlington High School principal Shahveer Dhalla wrote, “We are heartbroken.”

“He touched the lives of many of our Arlington students and teachers, and he will be missed,” Dhalla wrote of Reynolds. “We are keeping our thoughts and prayers with Sam’s family and friends.”

A large crowd of mourners gathered Friday evening in the high school’s parking lot for a candlelight vigil. Videos showed many tearfully embracing Fletcher, who encouraged attendees to share their memories of her son. Reynolds was an avid soccer player who was well-liked for “his charming personality and wonderful sense of humor,” his family wrote in an obituary. The teenager’s funeral is scheduled to take place later this week.

Russell Laniyan remembered Reynolds lending him his soccer cleats when he didn’t have any.

“He would do anything to support his friends and anyone he found close to him,” Laniyan said, according to WFAA. “I thank him for the impact that he made on my life.”

“I think this just encourages us to go out and to be like Sam and to follow the example that Sam has set for us,” Laniyan added, according to KXAS.