First, I’m cutting the Jiminy Cricket song to even it out.

Now let’s get it on!

1. “Radioactive” v “I’m Gonna Love You“

“Radioactive” for the win. The intro, the structure and Gene’s vocal. I do not like “I’m Gonna Love You”, pretty much at all.

Gene for the win.

2. “Burning Up With Fever” v “You Matter To Me”

“Burning Up With Fever” is an over bloated mess, and “You Matter To Me” is very of-it’s-time, but there’s something so charming about it for that exact reason.

I’m going with Peter on this one.

3. “See You Tonite” v “Tossin’ And Turnin'”

“See You Tonite” is total Beatles worship (with some “More Than A Feeling”, but then again, Brad Delp was a Beatles fanatic as well), and “Tossin’ And Turnin'” is the worst kind of bloated rock and roller.

4. “Don’t You Let Me Down” v “Tunnel Of Love”

God, I love “Don’t You Let Me Down”, beautiful track with a fantastic vocal by Peter. “Tunnel Of Love”, tunnel of shit.

I’m going with Peter on this one.

5. “True Confessions” v “That’s The Kind Of Sugar Papa Likes”

Easy, “Sugar”. And yes it’s a really awful title.

6. “Living In Sin” v “Easy Thing”

Don’t like either song, but there are at least parts of “Easy Thing” I like, so I pick that one by default.

7. “Always Near You/Nowhere To Hide” v “Rock Me Baby”

For the longest time, I would have gone with “Always Near You” but “Rock Me Baby” has grown on me, so now I’ll go with “Rock Me Baby”.

8. “Man Of 1,000 Faces” v “Kiss The Girl Goodbye”

Neither one is the greatest song, but I have a soft spot for “Kiss The Girl Goodbye”, just a nice little acoustic number.

9. “Mr. Make Believe” v “Hooked On Rock n Roll”

Easy, “Mr Make Believe”. Not the biggest song, but it’s pretty good all things considered.

10. “See You In Your Dreams” v “I Can’t Stop The Rain”

I CAN’T STOP THE RAIN!!!!

Peter wins 7-3.