Introduction

2G iPod nano reviewed

We've reviewed the brand-new second-generation iPod Nano. Check it out!

If you're interested in seeing how the original iPod nano performed in this review from 2005, read on!

The original iPod nano

iPod nano

Manufacturer: Apple (product page)

System requirements: Macintosh computer running Mac OS X 10.3.4 or later, USB port; Windows PC running Windows 2000 SP4 or Windows XP SP2, USB port

Price: US$199 (2GB), US$249 (shop for the iPod nano)

As we all know, Apple's iPod has dominated the digital music player scene since its launch in 2001, much like an aardvark busting through a termite mound. As hard-drive-based players have gotten smaller and the price of flash-based players has dropped, Apple seized on the opportunity to dive into the flash-based market with the iPod shuffle. It was a wildly successful move for Apple, which has grabbed close to 46 percent of the flash-based player market since its inception. However, there were still many reasons for users not to get the shuffle—namely, the lack of a screen and sophisticated controls. The task for Apple was to create a music player that was somehow a marriage between the minute size of the iPod shuffle and the versatility of a regular iPod.

Last Tuesday, Apple's solution came in the form of the iPod nano, a mini-mini-version of their current iPod color line. That's right, it's more miniature than the iPod mini, and the display is color! It's clear that these two superior elements are the reasons why Apple decided to do away with the original iPod mini line; however many consumers are upset that the iPod nano's storage capacity is smaller than what the iPod mini used to be. At 2GB and 4GB, though, the capacities are higher than the current iPod shuffle line and the pricing falls right in line in between shuffles and regular color iPods.

A brief word about sound quality: the iPod nano uses the same audio codec (the WM8975) as the 4G iPods. The first and second generation iPods used the WM8721, while the 3G iPods and iPod mini used the WM8731L. Since the iPod nano uses the same audio codech chip as the 4G, U2, and iPod photo players, its sound quality will be nearly identical to those other players.

Opening the package

The out-of-box experience was nothing less than expected from Apple: excessive, high-end, and oh-so-delightful. When purchasing our 2GB black iPod nano for this review, it even came in a "commemorative" iPod nano bag.

Opening the slim nano box was pretty much the same as opening any other iPod, and the contents were laid out in a similar manner—simple, elegant, and organized.

It's when you take the iPod nano out of the box that the true experience begins. That thing is really, really nano! Photos don't even convey how small and light the iPod nano really is. In fact at first, at 3.5" x 1.6" x 0.27" and 1.5 ounces, it almost seemed too small and too light for me in my hand. The thinness is marvelous from an aesthetic and engineering standpoint, but my first thought upon holding it was don't break it. We'll get to exploring that thought later, though.

The iPod nano is so thin that it slips effortlessly into the coin pocket on a pair of women's jeans, with room to spare. It certainly makes the "thousand songs right in your pocket" example a reality, especially to women who have very little pocket space and are much more adverse to carrying bulkier electronics in those pockets than men. The iPod nano barely shows a profile in the pocket and it's easy to forget about its presence after carrying it around for awhile.

The iPod nano comes with all of the standard accessories, including the standard white iPod headphones (some people have poined out that providing black iPod nano with white headphones is a bit of a fashion faux pas, but I'll leave that rant for a different time), a USB cable, and a dock adapter for use of your iPod nano with a standard iPod dock. However, the nano's dock adapter must be too complex for us two lowly engineers, because getting it to fit with either of our regular iPod docks was (and still is) truly perplexing. After nearly thirty minutes of fiddling between the two of us, we finally gave up on the nano dock adapter altogether. Worry not, however, as the iPod nano plugs just dandily into a regular dock without the adapter—it just sits straight up in the middle of the designated iPod area instead of being flush with plastic all the way around.

Update: After publishing this review last night, we had several readers contact us with information concerning the so-called "Dock Adapter." Dan Frakes from Playlist Magazine provided us with the most information and it came straight from the marketing folks in attendance at the special event. According to Dan, the "dock adapter" is meant to be to be used with future iPod accessories so that they will be able to connect to practically any new iPod. In a utopian world, this would mean that your new iPod would instantly be compatible with any new accessory that offered support for the "universal dock adapter." See this Apple Knowledge Base article for more info.

Download the PDF

(This feature for Premier subscribers only.)