This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.

SALT LAKE CITY — A married lesbian couple filed a lawsuit Monday to force the Utah vital records office to recognize them as the legal parents of their child.

The ACLU of Utah and the national ACLU LGBT Project filed the complaint in U.S. District Court on behalf of Angie and Kami Roe, who seek to both be recognized as parents to their daughter, Lucy.

Under the state's assisted reproduction law, the husband of a woman who conceives with donated sperm is automatically recognized as the child’s parent. But because Angie is Kami’s wife instead of her husband, the State Office of Vital Records and Statistics refuses to recognize Angie as Lucy’s parent, according to the ACLU.

The office told the couple that they must go through an expensive and invasive step-parent adoption process to become Lucy's legal parents, the ACLU says. They argue in the lawsuit that the office’s refusal to recognize female spouses as parents violates their right to equal protection.

“Kami and I should not have to go through a time-consuming legal procedure to give our daughter the protection of having two legal parents. All we are asking is to be treated the same way that other married couples are already treated under state law,” Angie Roe said in a news release.

Kami and I should not have to go through a time-consuming legal procedure to give our daughter the protection of having two legal parents. All we are asking is to be treated the same way that other married couples are already treated under state law. –Angie Roe, plaintiff

The lawsuit names Utah Department of Health executive director David Patton and vital statistics office director Richard Oborn as defendants.

"While we have not had the opportunity to review today's filing, we have been working for several months with both the ACLU and the plaintiffs in an attempt to reach a solution. Our hope is to resolve the issue at hand in a manner that serves the best interest of all parties," according to health department spokesman Tom Hudachko.

Leah Farrell, ACLU of Utah attorney, said in light of cases such as Kitchen v. Herbert, which make clear that Utah must extend the same rights in marriage to all couples, the state’s attempt to apply the assisted reproduction law differently for male and female spouses is untenable and harmful.

“All Utah families deserve the recognition afforded to them under Utah law," she said.

The Roes have also asked the court for a preliminary injunction requiring the vital records office to recognize Kami Roe as Lucy's parent while the case is being argued.

×

Related Stories