Are men and women categorized differently for similar sexual behavior? Building on theories of gender, sexuality, and status, we introduce the concept of precarious sexuality to suggest that men’s—but not women’s—heterosexuality is an especially privileged identity that is easily lost. We test our hypotheses in a series of survey experiments describing a person who has a sexual experience conflicting with their sexual history. We find that a single same-sex sexual encounter leads an observer to question a heterosexual man’s sexual orientation to a greater extent than that of a heterosexual woman in a similar situation. We also find that a different-sex sexual encounter is more likely to change others’ perceptions of a lesbian woman’s sexual orientation—compared to perceptions of a gay man’s sexual orientation. In two conceptual replications, we vary the level of intimacy of the sexual encounter and find consistent evidence for our idea of precarious sexuality for heterosexual men. We close with a general discussion of how status beliefs influence categorization processes and with suggestions for extending our theoretical propositions to other categories beyond those of sexual orientation.

References

Anderson, Cameron, Srivastava, Sanjay, Beer, Jennifer S., Spataro, Sandra E., Chatman, Jennifer A. 2006 . “ Knowing Your Place: Self-Perceptions of Status in Face-to-Face Groups .” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 91(6): 1094 – 1110 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Baumeister, Roy F. 2000 . “ Gender Differences in Erotic Plasticity: The Female Sex Drive as Socially Flexible and Responsive .” Psychological Bulletin 126(3): 347 – 74 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Berger, Joseph, Webster, Murray 2006 . “ Expectations, Status, and Behavior .” Pp. 268 – 300 in Contemporary Social Psychological Theories, edited by Burke, P. J. Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press .

Google Scholar

Brescoll, Victoria L., Uhlmann, Eric Luis, Moss-Racusin, Corinne, Sarnell, Lonnie 2012 . “ Masculinity, Status, and Subordination: Why Working for a Gender Stereotype Violator Causes Men to Lose Status .” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48: 354 – 57 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Coffman, Katherine B., Coffman, Lucas C., Ericson, Keith M. 2016 . “ The Size of the LGBT Population and the Magnitude of Anti-Gay Sentiment Are Substantially Underestimated .” Management Science 63(10): 3168 – 86 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Compton, D’Lane, Love, Tony P., Sell, Jane 2012 . “ Developing and Assessing Intercoder Reliability in Studies of Group Interaction .” Sociological Methodology 42(1): 348 – 64 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Connell, Raewyn 1987 . Gender and Power: Society, the Person and Sexual Politics . Stanford, CA : Stanford University Press .

Google Scholar

Connell, Raewyn 1995 . Masculinities. Cambridge, UK : Polity Press .

Google Scholar

Connell, Raewyn, Messerschmidt, James W. 2005 . “ Hegemonic Masculinity: Rethinking the Concept .” Gender & Society 19(6): 829 – 59 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Correll, Shelley J., Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 2003 . “ Expectation States Theory .” Pp. 29 – 51 in the Handbook of Social Psychology, edited by Delamater, J. New York : Kluwer Academic .

Google Scholar

Diamond, Lisa M. 2003 . “ Was It a Phase? Young Women’s Relinquishment of Lesbian/Bisexual Identities over a 5-year Period .” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 84(2): 352 – 64 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Doan, Long, Loehr, Annalise, Miller, Lisa R. 2014 . “ Formal Rights and Informal Privileges for Same-Sex Couples: Evidence from a National Survey Experiment .” American Sociological Review 79(6): 1172 – 95 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Dodge, Brian, Reece, Michael, Gebhard, Paul H. 2008 . “ Kinsey and Beyond: Past, Present, and Future Considerations for Research on Male Bisexuality .” Journal of Bisexuality 8(3–4): 175 – 89 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Douglas, Mary 1966 . Purity and Danger: An Analysis of Concepts of Pollution and Taboo. New York : Routledge .

Google Scholar Crossref

Durand, Rodolphie, Kremp, Pierre-Antoine 2016 . “ Classic Deviation: Organizational and Individual Status as Antecedents of Conformity .” Academy of Management Journal 59(1): 65 – 89 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Fiske, Susan T., Cuddy, Amy J. C., Glick, Peter, Xu, Jun 2002 . “ A Model of (Often Mixed) Stereotype Content: Competence and Warmth Respectively Follow from Perceived Status and Competition .” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82(6): 878 – 902 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Foschi, Martha 2000 . “ Double Standards for Competence: Theory and Research .” Annual Review of Sociology 26: 21 – 42 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Freese, Jeremy, Druckman, James, Principal Investigators . 2015 . Data Collected By Time-Sharing Experiments for the Social Sciences . NSF Grant 0818839 .

Google Scholar

Gamson, Joshua, Moon, Dawne 2004 . “ The Sociology of Sexualities: Queer and Beyond .” Annual Review of Sociology 30: 47 – 64 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Gorman, Bridget K., Denney, Justin T., Dowdy, Hilary, Medeiros, Rose Anne 2015 . “ A New Piece of the Puzzle: Sexual Orientation, Gender, and Physical Health Status .” Demography 52(4): 1357 – 82 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Herek, Gregory M. 2002 . “ Heterosexuals’ Attitudes toward Bisexual Men and Women in the United States .” Journal of Sex Research 39(4): 264 – 74 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Herek, Gregory M., Gillis, J. Roy, Cogan, Jeanine C. 2009 . “ Internalized Stigma among Sexual Minority Adults: Insights From a Social Psychological Perspective .” Journal of Counseling Psychology 56(1): 32 – 43 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Herek, Gregory M., McLemore, Kevin A. 2013 . “ Sexual Prejudice .” Annual Review of Psychology 64: 309 – 333 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Hipes, Crosby, Lucas, Jeffrey W., Kleykamp, Meredith 2015 . “ Status- and Stigma-Related Consequences of Military Service and PTSD: Evidence from a Laboratory Experiment .” Armed Forces & Society 41(3): 477 – 95 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Holman, Amanda, Sillars, Alan 2012 . “ Talk About ‘Hooking Up’: The Influence of College Student Social Networks on Nonrelationship Sex .” Health Communication 27(2): 205 – 216 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Human Rights Campaign . 2018 . “ State Maps of Laws & Policies ” (http://www.hrc.org/state-maps/employment).

Google Scholar

Hunt, Matthew O., Jackson, Pamela Braboy, Kye, Samuel H., Powell, Brian, Steelman, Lala Carr 2013 . “ Still Color-Blind? The Treatment of Race, Ethnicity, Intersectionality, & Sexuality in Sociological Social Psychology .” Pp. 21 – 45 in Advances in Group Processes, Vol. 30, edited by Thye, S. R., Lawler, E. J. Bingley, UK : Emerald Group Publishing .

Google Scholar Crossref

Jackson, Stevi, Scott, Sue 2010 . Theorizing Sexuality. Buckingham, UK : Open University Press .

Google Scholar

Johnson, Cathryn 1995 . “ Sexual Orientation as a Diffuse Status Characteristic: Implications for Small Group Interaction .” Pp. 115 – 37 in Advances in Group Processes, Vol. 12, edited by Lawler, E. J. Greenwich, CT : JAI .

Google Scholar

Khanna, Nikki 2010 . “ ‘If You’re Half Black, You’re Just Black’: Reflected Appraisals and the Persistence of the One-Drop Rule .” Sociological Quarterly 51(1): 96 – 121 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Klawitter, Marieka 2014 . “ Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Sexual Orientation on Earnings .” Industrial and Labor Relations Review 54: 4 – 32 .

Google Scholar

Laumann, Edward O., Gagnon, John H., Michael, Robert T., Michaels, Stuart 1994 . The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States. Chicago : University of Chicago Press .

Google Scholar

Lax, Jeffery R., Phillips, Justin H. 2009 . “ Gay Rights in the States: Public Opinion and Policy Responsiveness .” American Political Science Review 103(3): 367 – 86 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Lee, Jennifer, Bean, Frank D. 2004 . “ America’s Changing Color Lines: Immigration, Race/Ethnicity, and Multiracial Identification .” Annual Review of Sociology 30: 221 – 42 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Lucas, Jeffery W., Phelan, Jo C. 2012 . “ Stigma and Status: The Interrelation of Two Theoretical Perspectives .” Social Psychology Quarterly 75(4): 310 – 33 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Mishel, Emma 2016 . “ Discrimination against Queer Women in the U.S. Workforce: A Résumé Audit Study .” Socius (https://doi.org/10.1177/2378023115621316).

Google Scholar

Mize, Trenton D. 2015 . “ What Social Psychology Can Contribute to the Study of Sex, Gender, and Sexual Orientation .” Sociology Compass 9(12): 1066 – 81 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Mize, Trenton D. 2016 . “ Sexual Orientation in the Labor Market .” American Sociological Review 81(6): 1132 – 60 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Mize, Trenton D. 2017 . “ Sex, Gender, and Sexual Orientation in the Labor Market .” PhD dissertation, Department of Sociology, Indiana University .

Google Scholar

Mize, Trenton D., Manago, Bianca Forthcoming. “ The Stereotype Content of Sexual Orientation .” Social Currents.

Google Scholar

Moss-Racusin, Corrine, Phelan, Julie, Rudman, Laurie 2010 . “ When Men Break the Gender Rules: Status Incongruity and Backlash against Modest Men .” Psychology of Men & Masculinity 11(2): 140 – 51 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Mullinix, Kevin J., Leeper, Thomas J., Druckman, James N., Freese, Jeremey 2015 . “ The Generalizability of Survey Experiments .” Journal of Experimental Political Science 2(2): 109 – 138 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Mutz, Diana 2011 . Population-Based Survey Experiments. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Paolacci, Gabriele, Chandler, Jess, Iperiotis, Panagiotis G. 2010 . “ Running Experiments on Amazon Mechanical Turk .” Judgment and Decision Making 5(5): 411 – 19 .

Google Scholar ISI

Pascoe, C. J. 2007 . Dude, You’re a Fag: Masculinity and Sexuality in High School. Berkley : University of California Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Pedulla, David S. 2014 . “ The Positive Consequences of Negative Stereotypes: Race, Sexual Orientation, and the Job Application Process .” Social Psychology Quarterly 77(1): 75 – 94 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Peplau, Letita Anne 2003 . “ Human Sexuality: How Do Men and Women Differ? ” Current Directions in Psychological Science 12(2): 37 – 40 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Peplau, Letitia Anne, Fingerhut, Adam 2004 . “ The Paradox of the Lesbian Worker .” Journal of Social Issues 60(4): 719 – 35 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Phillips, Damon J., Turco, Catherin J., Zuckerman, Ezra W. 2013 . “ Betrayal as Market Barrier: Identity-Based Limits to Diversification among High-Status Corporate Law Firms .” American Journal of Sociology 118(4): 1023 – 54 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Phillips, Damon J., Zuckerman, Ezra W. 2001 . “ Middle-Status Conformity: Theoretical Restatement and Empirical Demonstration in Two Markets .” American Journal of Sociology 107(2): 379 – 429 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Podolny, Joel M. 2005 . Status Signals. Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press .

Google Scholar

Podolny, Joel M., Phillips, Damon J. 1996 . “ The Dynamics of Organizational Status .” Individual and Corporate Change 5(2): 453 – 71 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Powell, Brian, Bolzendahl, Catherine, Geist, Claudia, Steelman, Lala Carr 2010 . Counted Out: Same-Sex Relations and Americans’ Definition of Family. New York : Russell Sage .

Google Scholar

Powell, Brian, Quadlin, Natasha Yurk, Pizmony-Levy, Oren 2015 . “ Public Opinion, the Courts, and Same-Sex Marriage: Four Lessons Learned .” Social Currents 1(4): 1 – 10 .

Google Scholar

Rand, David G. 2012 . “ The Promise of Mechanical Turk: How Online Labor Markets Can Help Theorists Run Behavioral Experiments .” Journal of Theoretical Biology 299: 172 – 79 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 2006 . “ Status Construction Theory .” Pp. 301 – 323 in Handbook of Contemporary Social Psychological Theories, edited by Burke, P. Hoboken, NJ : Wiley and Sons .

Google Scholar

Ridgeway, Cecilia L. 2011 . Framed by Gender: How Gender Inequality Persists in the Modern World. New York : Oxford University Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Ridgeway, Cecilia L., Boyle, Elizabeth Heger, Kuipers, Kathy J., Robinson, Dawn T. 1998 . “ How Do Status Beliefs Develop? The Role of Resources and Interactional Experience .” American Sociological Review 63(3): 331 – 50 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Ridgeway, Cecilia L., Correll, Shelley J. 2004 . “ Unpacking the Gender System: A Theoretical Perspective on Gender Beliefs and Social Relations .” Gender & Society 18(4): 510 – 31 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Ridgeway, Cecilia L., Li, Yan E., Erickson, Kristan G., Backor, Kristen, Tinkler, Justine E. 2009 . “ How Easily Does a Social Difference Become a Status Distinction? Gender Matters .” American Sociological Review 74(1): 44 – 62 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Ridgeway, Cecilia L., Nakagawa, Sandra 2017 . “ Is Deference the Price of Being Seen as Reasonable? How Status Hierarchies Incentivize Acceptance of Low Status .” Social Psychology Quarterly 80(2): 132 – 52 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Rubin, Gayle 1984 . “ Thinking Sex: Notes for a Radical Theory of the Politics of Sexuality .” Pp. 100 – 133 in Social Perspectives in Lesbian and Gay Studies: A Reader, edited by Nardi, P. M., Schneider, B. E. New York : Routledge .

Google Scholar

Rudman, Laurie, Moss-Racusin, Corrine, Phelan, Julie, Nauts, Sanne 2012 . “ Status Incongruity and Backlash Effects: Defending the Gender Hierarchy Motivates Prejudice against Female Leaders .” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48(1): 165 – 79 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Rule, Nicholas O., Ambady, Nalini, Adams, Reginald B., Macrae, C. Neil 2008 . “ Accuracy and Awareness in the Perception and Categorization of Male Sexual Orientation .” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95(5): 1019 – 28 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Rule, Nicholas O., Ambady, Nalini, Hallett, Katherine C. 2009 . “ Female Sexual Orientation Is Perceived Accurately, Rapidly, and Automatically from the Face and its Features .” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 45: 1245 – 51 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Rupp, Leila J., Taylor, Verta 2010 . “ Straight Girls Kissing .” Contexts 9(3): 28 – 32 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Schrock, Douglas, Schwalbe, Michael 2009 . “ Men, Masculinity, and Manhood Acts .” Annual Review of Sociology 35: 277 – 95 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Sharkey, Amanda J. 2014 . “ Categories and Organizational Status: The Role of Industry Status in the Response to Organizational Deviance .” American Journal of Sociology 119(5): 1380 – 1433 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Tilcsik, András 2011 . “ Pride and Prejudice: Employment Discrimination against Openly Gay Men in the United States .” American Journal of Sociology 117(2): 586 – 626 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Vandello, Joseph, Bosson, Jennifer K., Cohen, Dov, Burnaford, Rochell M., Weaver, Johnathan R. 2008 . “ Precarious Manhood .” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95(6): 1325 – 39 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Webster, Murray, Hysom, Stuart J., Fullmer, Elise M. 1998 . “ Sexual Orientation and Occupation as Status .” Pp. 1 – 21 in Advances in Group Processes, Vol. 15, edited by Skvoretz, J., Szmatka, J. New York: JAI Press.

Google Scholar

Weinberg, Jill D., Freese, Jeremy, McElhattan, David 2014 . “ Comparing Data Characteristics and Results of an Online Factorial Survey between a Population-Based and a Crowdsource-Recruited Sample .” Sociological Science 1: 292 – 310 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Willer, Robb, Rogalin, Christabel L., Conlon, Bridget, Wojnowicz, Michael T. 2013 . “ Overdoing Gender: A Test of the Masculine Overcompensation Thesis .” American Journal of Sociology 118: 980 – 1022 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Worthen, Meredith G. F. 2013 . “ An Argument for Separate Analyses of Attitudes toward Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual Men, Bisexual Women, MtF, and FtM Transgender Individuals .” Sex Roles 68(11–12): 703 – 723 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI