Every time the question “hammock, tent, or tarp?” arises, the answer seems to be, “it depends.” Based on my own experience and the input of other AT thru-hikers, I created this flowchart to help explain the “it depends” piece. Still, this is just a general guideline.

A few clarifications: Hammocks themselves are usually cheaper than many tents on the market, but with the additional cost of an underquilt, the hammock system is typically more expensive, and probably just as heavy as a 1-person backpacking tent. In my experience, tents allow more privacy than hammocks and tarps because it is possible to be completely enclosed. However, in my opinion, the hammock and tarp system almost always provides sufficient privacy.

Related reading: The Thru-Hiker’s Suggested Gear List

A few other things to keep in mind: always bring a rain fly/tarp when you hammock, always be sure to test out your equipment beforehand, and above all, hike your own hike.

Related Reading: Appalachian Trail Thru-Hiker Gear List