We hear Jason DiLaurentis say “Charlie” in the preview for the next episode, in a tone that indicates that he remembers something and it isn’t going to be normal. I have always suspected that Cece would somehow end up being Charles. We know that Cece has always had an odd obsession with Alison. Jessica DiLaurentis mentioned Cece pretending to be Ali at time, playing pranks at a mental institution in Ali’s name, and trading personalities with Ali. This is odd behavior especially from a girl so much older than Alison. Cece has always seemed a little off to me, like she’s playing both sides, isn’t a true friend to Ali and has a hidden agenda.

What if Cece became so deeply obsessed with Ali that it became abnormal? Maybe the reasons behind Cece’s obsession are not good; she could be seeking revenge for something that Ali caused as a child. I still haven’t dismissed the possibility that Cece and Jason were fraternal twins who never truly dated. Maybe Cece was in the DiLaurentis family, a version of that twin Halloween story happened and Cece was sent away to Radley as a child and “disowned from the family” at least by being given a new name perhaps against her will.

Maybe Ali was to blame for her being sent away, maybe something happened and it was the “last straw” and Ali’s parents gave HER the choice of whether or not Cece got sent away and she said yes, but does not remember this? Cece’s old name could have been Charlie DiLaurentis. Jessica could have used that manipulation technique to change Alison’s memory. Maybe Cece came back to town and threatened the DiLaurentis family, taunting them, acting like she was “dating Jason” to taunt the family because they couldn’t reveal the truth. She could have held the truth over their heads and she could have known a LOT, especially if she spent time in Radley like I’ve suspected for a long time. Cece could have met Bethany there and told her how much Ali had ruined her life.

They could have plotted against Ali. But the plan went wrong because Ali got out of the hole and faked her death. Cece threw the rock at Ali, but Ali escaped and faked her death to get away from A; Ali does not know who threw the rock but Jessica did know the truth. Jessica BURIED Ali and believed her to be dead; Cece knew that Jessica would eventually have to talk about this with the police and they would need a body to be found. Cece found out Ali was alive because Ali still trusted her and told her the truth. Cece then killed Bethany young, hitting her in the head just like she did to Alison. Melissa saw Spencer with the shovel fighting with Ali, and when Cece spoke to her, she assured her that she had nothing to worry about with the videos, ali was dead. Cece saw Spencer and Ali fighting too, we know this from Ezra’s book. She let Melissa believe Spencer killed Ali, Melissa saw Bethany and didn’t look at the face and buried her believing it was Ali.

Jessica saw Cece hit Ali but couldn’t do anything about it because of how much Cece knew about her family. They planned to blame Spencer, but Peter somehow stopped this from happening. After Bethany was buried, Cece, who had drugged Jason as part of her initial plan to kill Ali, wrote the “I know what you did note” and left it for Jason, then fled town, thinking she was off scot free. But someone saw her and Cece found that out the next day. This was Sara Harvey, and Cece kidnapped her and forced Jason through blackmail to help her with the things she did as A. When Melissa Hastings learned Ali was alive, she became uber A/ BW because she knew Cece tricked her and was dangerous to everyone, especially Spencer and the girls. Oh I like this idea. Do you?