HOW MUCH DO YOU CARE if your shoes are made in America? According to a Reuters/Ipsos poll released last July, the provenance of our clothes matters a fair bit—in principle that is. Our patriotic feelings tend to dissipate, however, when we’re asked to pay a premium for something that’s made in America. The poll revealed that while 70% of Americans find it “very important” or “somewhat important” to buy American-made goods, only 21% said they would pay 10% more for an American-made product and only 7% said they would pay 50% more. With their latest marketing campaign and product refresh, Allen Edmonds, the Port Washington,...