The Possibility Theory: Is Charlotte alive?

Hello everyone! I know you guys have a bunch of questions (and by the number of anon asks, I do mean a BUNCH) so I’m going to try to answer as many things as I can while also sharing this theory I thought of last week… Which I REALLY think you’re going to like, so let’s get started. I’ve gotten a LOT of questions asking if I still think Charlotte is alive, which brings me to the theory I thought of last week. Is Charlotte alive? I think… Yes. How is this possible? Well, let’s look at a few things here.

1. Realistic looking masks have been a huge thing this season and 6B.

2. It looks as though Charlotte and Rollins both knee Charlotte was going to “die”, the books that were found in 7x01 were from Charlotte’s room in Radley but they were ALSO the bags that were seen being taken out of the Carissimi Group in 6x10…

3. Things are repeating themselves when it comes to Charlotte… The torturing of the girls, the dollhouse, the kidnapping of the blondes… Speaking of the dollhouse, that was a make shift dollhouse replacement, you can tell they had no time or money to make a new Dollhouse.

4. Rollins knew Charlotte was going to “die”, he started seducing Alison BEFORE Charlotte had even died- meaning either A. He helped murder her, or B. He was in on the plan with Charlotte from the very beginning.

And finally…. Last episode something finally clicked for me, during the scene between Hanna and “Spencer” something didn’t add up… And then it hit me, that “Spencer” wasn’t Spencer whatsoever. I think it’s quite possible that it was Charlotte in a mask.

“But Rachel, we saw Charlotte’s body!” Did we? Did we really? Or did we just see a woman’s body with a Charlotte mask on? And here’s the kicker, just who is Charlotte galavanting around Rosewood as? Sabrina the teenage bitch. Something about Sabrina just did NOT make any sense to me, like- why bring her back? She wasn’t relevant to anything whatsoever story wise… Until 6B. Something that really stuck out to me was this… Emily’s eggs. NO ONE, and I mean NO ONE knew about Emily going to the clinic, no one except… You guessed it… Sabrina. She was coming out of the clinic while Emily was going in, she was the ONLY one who knew. Another huge tell that just happened recently in 7x01 that stuck out to me, yet again, was Emily’s conversation with Sabrina. Emily is in the Brew, clearly upset, and when Sabrina inquires about what’s bothering her- Emily says that one of her friends is in trouble for something she didn’t even do… What happens next? “Spencer” goes to the dollhouse and comforts Hanna. Say, does that scene look familiar to you?

Now why would they mirror a scene where Alison was supposed to be “dead” with Spencer WHILE SHE WAS SINGING THE SONG MONA WAS SINGING IN THE DOLLHOUSE WHICH NONE OF THEM KNEW ABOUT?!

Another huge tell… Where the hell are Spencer’s bangs? Spencer has had bangs since the beginning of 6B, so- while Hanna may think it’s a dream, why would she dream of pre-bangs Spencer?

Also. I think it’s worth mentioning that when Sabrina was introduced in episode 6x04- the dollhouse flashbacks and everything started again… AND also, the Sabrina we were introduced to that episode/pre-time jump and the Sabrina we have post-time jump are two COMPLETELY different people. their personalities, the way they talk and dress… Like I’m sorry but can we just examine Sabrina before the time jump and after Charlotte’s “death”?

Before: Pot smoking, nose ring wearing, bandana in the hair, messy bun…

After Charlotte’s Death:

COME ON NOW!!

And now for who I think A.D. is, as I’ve said before, I believe A.D. stands for “Anno Domini” most people think it stands for “after death” which more ore less is correct (it actually means “in the year of the lord” in Latin) and since Charlotte isn’t dead, I think it’s quite possible it’s all a ruse for Rollins and Charlotte to continue to torture the girls under a new name. Now, why woulkd Charlotte torture her mother like this? Simple, she can’t trust her. Remember a while ago in 5x06 the black widow sent flowers to Bethany Young’s parents? If what Charlotte said about Bethany in Radley is true, what Mary did could be seen as a betrayal in her eyes

Well, that’s all I have for now… Let me know what you guys think down in the comments!

-Rachel