Overall

Vision Vision

Originality Originality

Technique Technique

Impact Impact

Personally I believe that even though 4K is a quality boost, it's also a steep hill. It makes flaws and mistakes more visible, is too big for the smashing majority of users' screens and is a hassle for the creator to work with. I know the last one to be a fact because I personally render my own works in 4K to help with editing. The downside of editing EVERYTHING in 4k also shows in how the fire seems a lot lower in quality than the surroundings.The idea is great, this sort of scene is a nice break from the endless stream of action and destruction most people work with (and that I'm partially also guilty for). However, the atmosphere itself feels quite weak. It doesn't feel as warm as it could've been, with the very dark shadows in places there they would be lighter (and smoother, maybe increase the radius amount as a fire is a very diffused, unstable light source), considering the amount of light that's probably bouncing around, and the lack of embers and smoke.The posing of the characters is great, it feels natural and realistic. The whole scene is obviously a scenebuild, a lot of detail and effort has been put into this which is greatly appreciated.All in all, a great scene. Way above average. Some editing changes (like the addition of bloom and some warmer effects for the fire, plus the scale down of the image itself) could fix most of the small issues I have with it. But that's just my opinion.