Somehow my rematcher knew that my cats favorite toy is the little mice. She either checked my reddit account or I just got lucky. He loves to carry these mice around in his mouth and bat them around. Along with the mice I got a crinkle tube that he can run through. I already have one of these so it's perfect that I got another one because I can tie them together and make it extra long. Thank you Santa! Try not to break your neck on the pictures. They all uploaded sideways and I can't fix them on my phone!

Edit: More gifts arrived today! She sent a scratchntv which I have never seen before but is perfect for dexter since he loves boxes. He's actually in the toy right now.

I also received a "cat charmer" which is a stick toy with a dangling piece of cloth. He loves these types of toys.

Along with those toys she also sent treats which my dog loves too :)