Shudder is a gift from the unholy horror gods. Where once upon a time fans of the ghoulish and ghastly had to trade tapes with fellow horror-lovers, Shudder is a well-stocked collection of scary stories that span decades and genres. The classics. Slashers. Haunted houses. Creature features. Demonic possession. You name it, Shudder’s got it, and the only problem with having such a large, genre-specific selection to choose from is the fact that…you do eventually have to make a decision on what to watch.

To give you a hand with choosing the right fright for your night, we’re providing a list of the best movies on Shudder right now. We’ll continue to update this list as new movies are added and removed from their catalog.