Who killed Ian ? Why did Ian kill himself? Why would Mona stage the note? When did Ian supposedly kill himself? (Updated based on the EW interview)



Why did Wilden kill Garrett?

Who told Wilden and Melissa to get on the train? Mona or CeCe, why?

What happened to Eddie? Did CeCe kill him?



Who is Bethany’s father?



Why was Mrs. D taking Bethany out of Radley?

What is Bethany’s story?



What about the letter Bethany wrote to Ali?

What does Rhonda know? What did Bethany tell her?



What’s up with Wren?

Why did CeCe need a visitors pass to see Mona if she was still in Radley then?

How did no one in Radley recognize CeCe when she was visiting Mona when she would have literally just left Radley a day before (or a short time anyway)?



Why was Wren coloring a family on a farm with a red coat?

Who did Jason see if it wasn’t CeCe? Was it Alison or Bethany talking to Melissa?

Who killed Mrs. D?

Who buried Mrs. D? If it was CeCe, why?



What did Mona think when she saw Alison walking down the street?

How did the Ali bracelet get on Bethany’s body? (Since Melissa buried her, not Mona.)

Why would CeCe want to recruit Tobey and Spencer to the A team?

Why was Melissa helping Shana and Jenna?

Who is Sara Harvey and why is she important at all?

Where did CeCe even meet Sara?

What mental asylum lets patients up on the roof unsupervised?



Who attacked Ali in the First Secret?



What is the real story about that “haunted” house and the Radley car outside of it that night?

Does anyone actually have a twin?



Who was that little ghost girl in the Halloween episode at the Marin house?

Who pushed Jason down the elevator shaft?

Where was Jason when he was at “rehab”?

Who called Mrs. D on “that night”? Why didn’t she want Ali out? If CeCe had been friends with Ali all summer why would she be scared she would hurt her now?

What is with the story Mrs. D had about Ali and CeCe trying on each other’s personalities? And the story about CeCe pretending to be Alison and getting sent to Radley? Was Mrs D a pathological liar?

Is Kenneth Charles/CeCe’s real father?

Why can’t you turn your back on a Hastings?

What happened to Tippi?

What was the purpose of the NAT club, that seemed so important early on and then poof never mind?

Who blew up Jenna/Toby’s house? Why?

Who’s Varjak?

Did the field hockey stick being buried mean nothing?

How much was Lucas actually involved? Why? What did he ever do to CeCe?

Did Mrs D actually sign up for the dog or did CeCe do it? Why? What ever happened to the dog?



Who did the kid in the doll shop see?



Who dug up Ali’s grave? Why?

Why send the girls body parts?

What was up with Mona and Jason’s relationship? How did Jason get injured? Why was she treating his wound?

Who blew up Meredith? Why? Was it Mona or CeCe? How did either really have motive?

What was up with creepy Harold?

Who cleaned up all of Mona’s things?

Who was under the Baby face zombie mask?

Who drugged Emily the night she blacked out? Why?

Why frame the girls for taking Ali’s body?



Why did A lash out at Jason, if CeCe is A, why attack Jason? Why put all those alcohol bottles on the porch?

Was CeCe staying at the aunt’s house? Is that why Jason couldn’t go in?

Why was Mrs. D in Spencer’s bedroom?

What agreement did Mr. Hastings have with Mrs. D about that night?

Why didn’t Mrs D say something about CeCe when she was running around town free?

Who attacked Ali that night she was sneaking in the Hastings house?

Whose earrings were in Byron’s couch if not Meredith’s? Did Ali plant them?

CeCe and Melissa Hasting’s met in CapeMay? DId they have any connections? Why didn’t CeCe go after Melissa since she and Ali hated each other?

What happned at the frat party with that girl and Ian? Who pushed her? Why?

Did CeCe really get kicked out of UPenn because of Ali? Or because of Radley?

Was Bethany the “fragile” patient on the roof with Marion Cavanagh? Was she the blonde girl Dr. Palmer told Tobey about? or was it CeCe?

Why was Eddie afraid of Wren?

Why did Tobey use Eddie’s security badge? How did he get it?



Why didn’t Wren want Eddie to see Spencer?

Why did CeCe date Jason? Even if they didn’t have sex, which it sounds like they didn’t. I’m sure they had to do some stuff otherwise why would they be together. How was it an “intense summer”? Why fake date your brother, why not just pretend you have a bf and be flirty and friendly and spend time together with out being together?



Back to Sara… did she actually run away? Why is she presumed “missing”? Is She actually Sara Harvey or is this some other girl pretending to be Sara for CeCe to get to the girls?

Why would CeCe try to kill Caleb’s mom?

Why didn’t CeCe see Shana going after the girls and try to stop it?

Did CeCe drug Shana and send her out of Rosewood or did Shana make that up?

What about the moms? Who locked them in the basement? Why? Are they going to ever get out?

What happened to undercover officer Clark at the prom?

Why didn’t the girls call anyone on the way? Like even Tobey?



Where did Caleb and Ezra go?

Why was Clark meeting Rhys?



Why the Ali masks?

CeCe said she hated the girls for being glad Ali was gone, and yet they spent their whole high school career trying to make sense of things and bring Ali home? how did that make sense to her?

Whatever happened to Ali’s anklet? How did it get in that shop? How did Garrett know about it?

Why was Garrett trying to protect Spencer? How was he trying to protect her?

Why is Melissa with so many shady guys: Ian, Garrett, Wren?



Did CeCe pull all the girls out of the fire (except Hanna)? Why did she leave Hanna? How did she not see Ali save Hanna?

What happened to Hollbrook?

How long was CeCe planning on taking the girls? How did she get that bunker built in a public park without anyone asking questions? Like that’s more than a bit shady?

Who is the beach hottie? (Board short’s is Ezra, but he wasn’t in Cape May/at the beach)



Remember that one time Jenna was almost drowned, who did that? Why?

What was CeCe planning to do with Ali when she got her to the doll house?

Why would CeCe dress Mona up as Ali and make her be Ali? Why did she want to control her sister? I didn’t get that vibe from her tonight. Had Ali shown up on a night when the girls weren’t escaping, what would CeCe have done? Tortured her sister too?

Whose body was in the barrel? Why was that even relevant?



Back to Wren again? How is he a real doctor who is supposed to be super smart but can’t spell diagnosis? Why did he come to treat Mona only?



How could CeCe approve visitation for Mona again? or was that Wren? Why would either of them do this?



Why “Nosey” bitches? CeCe isn’t british.



Why did Melissa say she saw Tobey in London when she didn’t?

Who put the blood in Spencer’s purse in London?

When did Radley shut down it’s children’s ward? Why?

Alison’s backyard was very popular that night everything went down, did no one really see Mona kill Bethany? Why would Mona just leave the body?

Why did Spencer and Emily both have “memories” of killing Ali/someone?

Where did CeCe learn how to do any of this? She performed a dental exam on Hanna to plant that clue in her mouth. Like where does one learn to do that? A doctor, like Wren maybe. but CeCe?

Also, how could CeCe get into the eye exam room to change the chart? Another medical facility?



Why spend one summer trying to get to know your family? Then spend another year trying to torture them? Then, in the end decide you want to kill yourself and them?



Who was Mrs. D’s draft email “I can’t protect you anymore” to? If it was to CeCe why couldn’t she protect her? CeCe had gotten away with Bethany’s murder. Wilden was dead. No one on earth was going to connect CeCe to Bethany’s murder. She didn’t need Mrs. D’s protection.

How did Radley just let CeCe go? So Mona got her out, but like a missing patient isn’t important?

Why did Bethany have Melissa’s riding helmet?



Why would Mrs. D buy Bethany a pony?



What did Sydney have to do with anything? A sent the girls a text based on the info Hanna spilled while drunk. CeCe wasn’t there in the cafe. How did CeCe know?

Why would CeCe put bees in Mrs. Montgomery’s car? Why go after the parents?



Why would CeCe set up Caleb’s father?

Whose cabin was Ezra watching? Why did the drawings in the cabin match Bethany’s/Wren’s?

Why did CeCe want to go to prom with Ali?

CeCe’s photo was in the yearbook. Even if the school takes a photo of a student who doesn’t go there, they wouldn’t publish it in the yearbook. How can she be prom queen if she never went to the school?

Who turned CeCe in? We saw A call the police on her.

Why dress like a man in the doll house if you don’t identify as one?

What happened to Cyrus?

If Charles/CeCe was that unstable, how did Radley let her go to UPenn? How did they not call the police when she was missing? How did they still not call the police after Mrs. D died and couldn’t pay anyone off?



How is Charles taller than Spencer in the dollhouse, yet CeCe is several inches shorter than Spencer. I think Spencer would have noticed if Charles had on heels.

What was up with Spencer’s memory of the child in Radley?

If the Charles file was written as deceased to make way for Charlotte they would need a new file. If that wasn’t the reason he was listed as dead, then what was? Who did it? What did Radley do with Charlotte afterward if they said Charles died but didn’t have a file for Charlotte. Why didn’t Aria find the file?

When Leslie was in Radley, wouldn’t Charles have been Charlotte by then?How did Leslie know Charles?Why did Leslie say Charles and Bethany were friends, when they clearly stopped being friends at least ten years prior?Why did Leslie say Bethany and Charles escaped together?

A always seemed to have OCD. CeCe has never seemed to display symptoms of OCD. Did you see her room at Radley? How do you explain this?

How did Alison pass that polygraph at the police station?

In “Taking This One to the Grave”, Ali meets her “army” at an abandoned farm… is this the Campbell Farm? If so why did she choose that location? What connection does she have to Andrew?

Who gave Cindy and Mindy the Ali masks during the winter ball? How did Ali not know about that if she and CeCe were together?

CeCe was also at the ball when A was at the house (she couldn’t have gotten to the house that fast). Was that Sara? Why were they wearing the Baby zombie mask?



If A is so smart, how could CeCe not get herself off for murder? Why didn’t she just fabricate or delete evidence so she could go home and be with Alison?

Why all the bird clues?



Why would CeCe let the Liars think Ali was A? She said she was mad at the liars for being glad that Ali was dead, but she actively let them hate her.



*** I will be updating with more questions as I remember them! I know there are many, many more.

