User Info: Crashdashx Crashdashx 3 years ago #1 What do you prefer? - Results (216 votes) Witcher 3 56.48% (122 votes) 122 Final fantasy 15 25.46% (55 votes) 55 I'm here to view the poll 18.06% (39 votes) 39



Personally, I'm going to vote for witcher 3. Whilst I really enjoyed final fantasy 15, I felt it was very flawed and replaying witcher 3 on deathmarch made me realise how well made the game was.



- multiple choices that impact multiple endings in the game (including side quest endings).You get multiple choices frequently and so you get high replay value. In final fantasy 15, you get choices rarely and your choices often get refused... "oi, pick up this potion for me... what do you mean no? Go get it!"

- an interactive world, people are talking to each other and doing stuff with each other.. they also sleep and work and have homes. There's hundreds of items to collect.

- freedom. No invisible walls, you can swim and you actually feel like you live in this world for real. FF15 just felt bland for the most part.. no campers or travellers, few towns, mountains and trees and huge fences forcing you to walk 2 miles the other way.

- great storytelling and characters. Even if you're not a fan of the story, you can appreciate how much effort the developers put into it. No loose ends, you feel attached to most of the characters ( even side quests) and it just felt I was watching a movie. In ff15, I felt confused at times and I didn't care for any characters apart from the main 4 and maybe Iris. Characters just disappeared.

- great graphics. FF15 had good graphics for the most part but some areas were clearly rushed.

- death march made me appreciate combat more. Potions, oils, skills table etc offer a variety of ways to fight. The camera angle is consistently good. I actually enjoyed ff15s combat but the monsters often covered me, camera was bad and boss fights were just pressing O when prompted to. Yet the combat was flashy and fast. How far behind though were the developers? They didn't even put in a basic tactics menu.. I.e. defensive, offensive etc. Prompto was range but he sucked at his role.

- side quests were fleshed out and often original, had multiple endings with good dialogue. You often sympathise with the side characters. FF15 had fetch quests usually. Though I found it amusing that a farmer would demand a prince/king that he travel to the other side to collect a plant. Offering a sentence of dialogue. Let me remind you, you can't even refuse or cancel quests.

- mini games. You can do things such as gwent, where you collect cards and play against NPCs. Very rewarding and addictive. FF15 offers fishing and arcade. I enjoyed fishing but I didn't play the arcade much, so can't comment. FF15 will soon be offering limited time DLC to play more games.

- Due to the multiple endings of witcher 3 in both the main story, side quests and multi choice dialogues, there's huge replay value. Sorry, FF15 only offer new game plus which doesn't even scale the monsters or add anything new.





Despite all this I did enjoy final fantasy 15 and it was the first game I actually platinumed (how difficult that is is debatable). But I feel the witcher is superior in every department, except for maybe combat. I'm just curious on people opinions.Personally, I'm going to vote for witcher 3. Whilst I really enjoyed final fantasy 15, I felt it was very flawed and replaying witcher 3 on deathmarch made me realise how well made the game was.- multiple choices that impact multiple endings in the game (including side quest endings).You get multiple choices frequently and so you get high replay value. In final fantasy 15, you get choices rarely and your choices often get refused... "oi, pick up this potion for me... what do you mean no? Go get it!"- an interactive world, people are talking to each other and doing stuff with each other.. they also sleep and work and have homes. There's hundreds of items to collect.- freedom. No invisible walls, you can swim and you actually feel like you live in this world for real. FF15 just felt bland for the most part.. no campers or travellers, few towns, mountains and trees and huge fences forcing you to walk 2 miles the other way.- great storytelling and characters. Even if you're not a fan of the story, you can appreciate how much effort the developers put into it. No loose ends, you feel attached to most of the characters ( even side quests) and it just felt I was watching a movie. In ff15, I felt confused at times and I didn't care for any characters apart from the main 4 and maybe Iris. Characters just disappeared.- great graphics. FF15 had good graphics for the most part but some areas were clearly rushed.- death march made me appreciate combat more. Potions, oils, skills table etc offer a variety of ways to fight. The camera angle is consistently good. I actually enjoyed ff15s combat but the monsters often covered me, camera was bad and boss fights were just pressing O when prompted to. Yet the combat was flashy and fast. How far behind though were the developers? They didn't even put in a basic tactics menu.. I.e. defensive, offensive etc. Prompto was range but he sucked at his role.- side quests were fleshed out and often original, had multiple endings with good dialogue. You often sympathise with the side characters. FF15 had fetch quests usually. Though I found it amusing that a farmer would demand a prince/king that he travel to the other side to collect a plant. Offering a sentence of dialogue. Let me remind you, you can't even refuse or cancel quests.- mini games. You can do things such as gwent, where you collect cards and play against NPCs. Very rewarding and addictive. FF15 offers fishing and arcade. I enjoyed fishing but I didn't play the arcade much, so can't comment. FF15 will soon be offering limited time DLC to play more games.- Due to the multiple endings of witcher 3 in both the main story, side quests and multi choice dialogues, there's huge replay value. Sorry, FF15 only offer new game plus which doesn't even scale the monsters or add anything new.Despite all this I did enjoy final fantasy 15 and it was the first game I actually platinumed (how difficult that is is debatable). But I feel the witcher is superior in every department, except for maybe combat.