If there’s one thing Riverdale is known for, it’s dramatic tension. That’s definitely been the case for will-they-won’t-they duo Cheryl Blossom (Madelaine Petsch) and Toni Topaz (Vanessa Morgan). But it turns out that there have been clues hinting at the twosome’s potential as Riverdale’s most conniving couple — you just have to know where to look. And as it turns out, the signs have been right in front of our eyes the whole time, thanks to some of their recent wardrobe choices.

Remember when Polly Cooper was pregnant with her and Jason Blossom’s twins back in the first season? She was supposed to meet with the Blossoms at Pop’s. However, Cheryl was the only one who ended up coming, and she was wearing a sheer, floral embroidered long-sleeve top. Fast-forward to this season at the will reading of Cheryl’s father, Cliff Blossom: She brought Toni with her for support who was wearing — yep, you guessed it — that same top Cheryl wore to confront Polly at Pop’s.

Of course, true Choni fans have probably noticed that the pair has been sharing clothes a lot lately, ever since Cheryl left Thistlehouse and shacked up with Toni.

“You guys are totally on it! I am very impressed that you guys figured that out. Yes, after being rescued from the nuns, obviously, she did not go back to Thistlehouse, so Toni took her in,” Madelaine shared during a live episode of Sweetwater Secrets. “For the next, like, [few episodes] 17 and 18, Cheryl is wearing only Toni’s clothing because she’s staying at Toni’s. We don’t really talk about it at all, but it’s nice that you guys notice those things.”

While Madelaine is downplaying the relevance of Choni’s shared wardrobe, it’s definitely one more element that makes us excited to see how the future plays out for the couple. From now on, we’ll be keeping a close eye on everyone’s clothing to see if the show reveals any other plot twists. It is Riverdale after all, so anything can happen.

Get the Teen Vogue Take. Sign up for the Teen Vogue weekly email.

Want more from Teen Vogue? Check this out: https://www.teenvogue.com/story/madelaine-petsch-riverdale-fashion-secrets