Adapted from a recent online discussion.

Dear Carolyn:

Among my dad’s constellation of mental-health issues, the most neglected problem is his food addiction. He makes little attempt to control his food intake, and is now diabetic and takes insulin injections. I don’t think he’ll see 60, and certainly not with all his limbs intact.

For the most part, I leave him alone about it, because he is stubborn and has an intense need to be right. But when he comes to my house (one state over) and we give him food for the road, or some of our leftovers, he always asks for dessert to go with it. I don’t have any qualms with giving him meal-type foods, because I can’t control the portions of things he needs to eat anyway. But for desserts, the correct portion for him is ZERO. Is there a way I can politely refuse to give him dessert, both for the road and generally? I feel bad depriving my stepmom and younger brother just for his sake, but he can’t be trusted. Am I right to say no, or should I mind my own business?

Enabling?

So if we’re conservative, we can estimate that he has dessert every day — 365 desserts a year. Someone who doesn’t attempt to control his food intake probably has two desserts a day, for 730 desserts a year.

Split the difference just to make it all sound more scientific and we’re talking in the neighborhood of 550 desserts a year.

Your anguished and principled stand would drop that number to 549.

I understand that anguish, completely, and sympathize with your basic need not to be the one handing him the poison he’s using to kill himself. And if you decide that that need is paramount, I suggest you be exactly that honest about it when he asks you for dessert: “Dad, I know I can’t control what you eat, but I draw the line at handing you the poison you’re using to kill yourself.”

If you decide that that need is not paramount and that you’d rather approach this as a pragmatist — i.e., he’s an adult and you’re not going to change him — put that 550th dessert in perspective as you serve it.

By the way — you’re not “depriving” your stepmother and younger brother of anything meaningful if you opt out of dessert. That’s a red herring.

Dear Carolyn:

I have been with a wonderful, kind 50-year-old professional man for two-plus years. He moved in with my daughters and me a few months ago, and I now realize he has an obsessive gum-chewing habit. He chews every waking moment, unless he’s eating or being intimate.

Now seeing him chew even with his mouth closed is a huge turnoff. I’ve brought it up at least four times now. Help! I’m nearly completely repulsed at this point.

Anonymous

If you’re to the point where it’s you or the gum (as you seem to be), then just say so. Yes, it’s an ultimatum, but we’re talking gum here; it’s only fair that he know the cost.