Thor and Zeus were gods, so they have the most power. Hercules and Jesus were demigods/sons of gods so they only had extra, but not full power. Moses and Muhammad were mere mortal men with no special powers.

Moses and Muhammad would get their butts kicked by Jesus and Hercules, who in turn would get their butts kicked by Thor and Zeus. That would leave the two gods to fight it out. Zeus can throw lightning bolts at will. Thor is the god of thunder and requires his hammer, therefore Zeus would pelt Thor with lightning bolts from afar until Thor was defeated, leaving Zeus the clear victor.