AT&T, Comcast Part Of RIAA's New 3 Strikes Plan P2P Piracy goes from industry's quiet killer app, to public enemy number one... Last December, the RIAA boldly announced via the Wall Street Journal that they would be ditching mass lawsuits in favor of placing ISPs in the role of content nannies. Under the proposed system, ISPs would send offenders warning letters (something many ISPs have already been doing for years), while quietly adopting a three strikes system for repeat offenders. The RIAA has been hashing this new system out with select ISPs behind closed doors with the supposed help of New York's Attorney General, who recently made headlines for his largely ineffective war on Usenet child porn). None of the ISPs have publicly admitted to participating in the plan (though we've confirmed that Cox is).

quote: There are still plenty of details left to work out, the sources said. The RIAA has yet to address how it would help ISPs make up for the revenue they would lose by kicking people off their networks or who would pay the costs of sending take-down notices. The RIAA may disclose participating ISPs as soon as next month, according to a music industry source, adding that AT&T and Comcast are expected to be part of the group. The irony of course is that for years piracy was broadband's "killer app," quietly used by ISPs to lure dial-up subscribers to broadband. Now that the market is saturated, and carriers like AT&T and Comcast have become network operators and content companies, they've found it's in their best financial interest to clamp down on P2P piracy. Both Comcast and AT&T certainly have the financial resources to put forth a serious anti-piracy effort. CNET has discovered, not too surprisingly, that both Comcast and AT&T are among the plan's dozen or so participants, though no carrier wants to admit as much on the record. Insiders at the two companies say the carriers are "skittish" about the negative press, certainly in part because of fear customers will flock to non-participating ISPs (like Verizon). Insiders note that so far, the plan still isn't much of one -- and no formal agreements have been signed:The irony of course is that for years piracy was broadband's "killer app," quietly used by ISPs to lure dial-up subscribers to broadband. Now that the market is saturated, and carriers like AT&T and Comcast have become network operatorscontent companies, they've found it's in their best financial interest to clamp down on P2P piracy. Both Comcast and AT&T certainly have the financial resources to put forth a serious anti-piracy effort. AT&T is not only planning to participate in the RIAA's three strikes plan, they're also testing caps, metered billing and piracy filters. The entertainment industry would love it if all ISPs would follow AT&T's lead either voluntarily or by force -- but so far they've had no luck passing laws requiring that ISPs become piracy police. Without laws, ISPs are still protected by safe harbor provisions under the DMCA, allowing them to say no to their new job as babysitter. That will let some ISPs sit back and catch the fleeing pirates from participating ISPs as new customers. Even if the plan were put into law, the system raises Even if the plan were put into law, the system raises far more questions than it answers , including who pays, who tracks offenders across multiple ISPs, what happens to ISPs who don't cooperate, who'll oversee the fairness of the system, and what the grievance system is for the falsely accused. That's going to be expensive, prone to error, and would require a lot of new regulation for carriers who don't much like regulation. If piracy's history is any indication -- it wouldn't slow piracy's growth anyway.







News Jump Stark New Reality In The Telco Business: Dumb Pipes No Longer Cut It; AT&T Unveils Mix and Match Plans; + more news AT&T Extends Overage Charge Waiver; Verizon And T-Mobile Each Insist Their 5G Strategy Is The Right One; + more news War Of Words Heats Up: T-Mobile Fires Back At Verizon, AT&T; Amazon Intros Gaming Service To Take On Stadia; + more news Starlink's Network Faces Huge Limitations; AT&T Whines T-Mobile Merger Put Too Much Spectrum In One Place; + more news WISPs Get CBRS Range As Great As Six Miles At 100 Mbps Speeds; Windstream Officially Exits Bankruptcy; + more news Charter Relaunches Free 60-day Internet And Wi-Fi Offer; NCTA: FCC Should Stick With 25/3 Speed Threshold; + more news Comcast Shuts Off Internet for Subs Who Were Sold Service Illegally; AT&T, Verizon Team To Stop T-Mobile 5G; + more news California Defends Its Net Neutrality Law; AT&T's Traffic Up 20% Despite Data Traffic Actually Being Down; + more news Are The Comcast-Charter X1 Talks Dead In The Water?; AT&T May Offer Phone Plans With Ads For Discounts; + more news Europe's Top Court: Net Neutrality Rules Bar Zero Rating; ViacomCBS To Rebrand CBS All Access As Paramount+; + more news ---------------------- this week last week most discussed

Most recommended from 95 comments



ninjatutle

Premium

join:2006-01-02

San Ramon, CA 2 recommendations ninjatutle Member Whats the problem? Only the thieves should be worried.