tylerja-blog asked: To be fair to the latest contestant on Alternate Reality Blog (without trying to justify the complaint itself), I don't think anyone would have complained if Saheeli's card was instead a new or less-recently-seen character. When you printed Nahiri did people complain that it wasn't Elspeth? Or Freyalise that it wasn't Garruk? Point being, after the precedent was set in C14, people associate supplemental walkers with introductions or callbacks - and a waste opportunity if filled otherwise. (:

And other people want the planeswalkers they already know and love done as Commander-able planeswalkers. Note that this an even more infrequent opportunity as not all Commander sets have planeswalkers as commanders.

To balance the needs of all the players, we made some new ones, one old time one that never had a card and a planeswalker that has a planeswalker card but now Commanderable.

I just ask that you recognize that your wants are not universal wants and that asking that everything be the way you want it is unfair to those that want something done differently than you.