The petitioner, Software Freedom Law Center India (sflc.in), contended that in terms of the Temporary Suspension of Telecom Services (Public Emergency or Public Safety) Rules, 2017, the DCP was not the competent authority to issue directions halting telecom services.

It was further contended that as per the Rules, the Secretary of the Union Home Ministry or the Secretary of the Home Department of the relevant state government had the authority to halt telecom services. If not the relevant Secretary, an officer not below the rank of Joint Secretary could pass such an order, it was argued.

It was also contended that the shutdown of services was still continuing in parts of the city.