Joel McHale was a guest judge this week on Fox’s totally bonkers new celebrity singing competition, The Masked Singer, alongside regular judge Ken Jeong — which resulted in a fun Community mini-reunion. (Oh, if only Donald Glover had shown up!) Community was absurdist comedy at its finest, of course, and McHale also spent years back-announcing kooky clips on The Soup. But at the top of Wednesday’s latest Masked Singer episode, even seen-it-all television veteran McHale announced, “I feel like I’m already on drugs!”

I certainly felt like I was on drugs by the episode’s end. This show is weird, you guys. And it is also addictive.

The Masked Singer — on which cosplaying mystery celebs perform karaoke for regular judges Jeong, Jenny McCarthy, Nicole Scherzinger and Robin Thicke, plus exiled America’s Got Talent host Nick Cannon — basically resembles an hourlong version of Eurotrash band’s Alacazar’s “Crying at the Discotheque” music video. And it has become such an unlikely ratings smash that Jeong is shocked. At the end of each episode, one contestant is unmasked, and the internet breaks.

The show’s first episode had us indulging in the new national pastime of figuring out the famous faces behind the facades of the Peacock, Monster, Unicorn, Deer and Lion, and this week, those characters were back at it. This week also marked the second unmasking of an NFL star, the first being Antonio Brown’s big reveal as the Hippo on the season premiere. On Wednesday, the Deer sank his teeth and antlers into Florida Georgia Line’s “Get Your Shine On” — and when he got his mask off, he was (as I’d guessed correctly) Super Bowl champion quarterback Terry Bradshaw.

This one was a fairly cinchy guess. The Deer had dropped clues about the “wild West” (Bradshaw has sung country and western music semiprofessionally before), a love of horses (Bradshaw breeds Quarter Horses), doing tons of commercials, winning multiple titles and “making a donkey of himself” (Bradshaw has a pet donkey!) — so it all led to the perfect Masked Singer touchdown.

Let’s look at this week’s four other returning mystery singers!

The Lion, “Feeling Good”

Clues: Along with Episode 1’s clues about the Lion coming from a “pride of women” and “Hollywood royalty,” this week she was seen reading a newspaper proclaiming, “Gold Found in Hailey, Idaho!” She also told the judges, “I have no gold or platinum hanging on my walls” when Jenny McCarthy asked if she had any hit records to her credit, so that rules out people like Lady Gaga, Christina Aguilera or Ariana Grande — even though the Lion’s roar on Nina Simone’s brash classic was nearly at a Gaga/Xtina/Grande level.

Judges’ guesses: Hailey Baldwin, Kelly Rowland, Emily Blunt. The judges are dumb.

My guess: I admit my previous prediction, Aubrey O’Day, was a shot in the dark and as dumb as any of the judges’ guesses. The hive-mind on Twitter has insisted ever since that the Lion is actually Rumer Willis, who has performed on another hit Fox musical series, Empire. Rumor has it that it’s Rumer! (See what I did there?) The Lion does sound like her, but this week’s key clue was the Hailey headline — Rumer’s famous Hollywood mom, Demi Moore, has a house in that small Idaho town. So Rumer is my final answer.

The Peacock, “Counting Stars”

Clues: The Peacock said being on the Masked Singer stage made him feel like he was “5 years old again,” that he “started out as a little teenybopper,” and he has gone through “different incarnations of his career.” None of that offered much beyond his previous clues. But he did confirm that he has performed in Las Vegas and has been cast in dramatic acting roles.

Judges’ guesses: Neil Patrick Harris, Criss Angel, David Copperfield, David Hasslehoff, Tom Jones.

My guesses: I previously guessed ex-teen idols Leif Garrett or Donny Osmond, both “dear friends” of Michael Jackson (a clue from Episode 1). And until this week, I was leaning toward Osmond, whose Vegas-style showmanship could easily be described as “peacockian.” But Garrett has acted in dramas (he was outstanding in The Outsiders), and this gruff OneRepublic cover didn’t sound much like Donny. (It was more than a little rock ‘n’ roll!) So, now my top guess is Leif, who did perform in a 2006 Vegas revue called “Original Idols Live!” with Barry Williams, the Bay City Rollers, the Cowsills, Tony DeFranco and Danny Bonaduce. (Damn. How did I miss that?) However, this could also be drama king/frequent feather-ruffler Corey Feldman. The Peacock performed on a 30-foot hydraulic lift in a mask (despite having a fear of heights), and that seems like the sort of stunt Corey would do. Feldman has played Vegas too.