This research demonstrates how counterfactual thoughts can lead people to excuse others for telling falsehoods. When a falsehood aligned with participants’ political preferences, reflecting on how it could have been true led them to judge it as less unethical to tell, which in turn led them to judge a politician who told it as having a more moral character and deserving less punishment. When a falsehood did not align with political preferences, this effect was significantly smaller and less reliable, in part because people doubted the plausibility of the relevant counterfactual thoughts. These results emerged independently in three studies (two preregistered; total N = 2,783) and in meta- and Bayesian analyses, regardless of whether participants considered the same counterfactuals or generated their own. The results reveal how counterfactual thoughts can amplify partisan differences in judgments of alleged dishonesty. I discuss implications for theories of counterfactual thinking and motivated moral reasoning.

References

Abrams, D., Randsley, de, Moura, G., Travaglino, G. A. ( 2013 ). A double standard when group members behave badly: Transgression credit to ingroup leaders . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 105, 799 - 815 . doi:10.1037/a0033600

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Ames, D. L., Fiske, S. T. ( 2015 ). Perceived intent motivates people to magnify observed harms . Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 112, 3599 - 3605 .

Google Scholar Medline

Anderson, C. A. ( 1983 ). Imagination and expectation: The effect of imagining behavioral scripts on personal influences . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 45, 293 - 305 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Arendt, H. ( 1961 ). Between past and future: Six exercises in political thought. New York, NY : Viking .

Google Scholar

Banas, J. A., Rains, S. A. ( 2010 ). A meta-analysis of research on inoculation theory . Communication Monographs, 77, 281 - 311 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Briazu, R. A., Walsh, C. R., Deeprose, C., Ganis, G. ( 2017 ). Undoing the past in order to lie in the present: Counterfactual thinking and deceptive communication . Cognition, 161, 66 - 73 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Byrne, R. M. J. ( 2016 ). Counterfactual thought . Annual Review of Psychology, 67, 135 - 157 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Carroll, J. S. ( 1978 ). The effect of imagining an event on expectations for the event: An interpretation in terms of the availability heuristic . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 14, 88 - 96 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Comparing Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump on the Truth-O-Meter . (n.d.). Politifact. Retrieved from http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/lists/people/comparing-hillary-clinton-donald-trump-truth-o-met/

Google Scholar

De Brigard, F., Szpunar, K. K., Schacter, D. L. ( 2013 ). Coming to grips with the past: Effect of repeated simulation on the perceived plausibility of episodic counterfactual thoughts . Psychological Science, 24, 1329 - 1334 . doi:10.1177/0956797612468163

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Dent, M. ( 2016 , August 1 ). Sorry, Hillary: Trump actually has made a few things in the USA . Politifact. Retrieved from http://www.politifact.com/pennsylvania/statements/2016/aug/01/hillary-clinton/hillary-clinton-went-overboard-calling-out-donald-/

Google Scholar

Ditto, P. H., Pizarro, D. A., Tannenbaum, D. ( 2009 ). Motivated moral reasoning . In Ross, B. H. (Series Ed.) & Bartels, D. M., Bauman, C. W., Skitka, L. J., Medin, D. L. (Eds.), Psychology of Learning and Motivation, Vol. 50: Moral judgment and decision making (pp. 307 - 338 ). San Diego, CA : Academic Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Effron, D. A. ( 2014 ). Making mountains of morality from molehills of virtue: Threat causes people to overestimate their moral credentials . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 40, 972 - 985 . doi:10.1177/0146167214533131

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Effron, D. A., Miller, D. T., Monin, B. ( 2012 ). Inventing racist roads not taken: The licensing effect of immoral counterfactual behaviors . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 103, 916 - 932 . doi:10.1037/a0030008

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Effron, D. A., Monin, B., Miller, D. T. ( 2013 ). The unhealthy road not taken: Licensing indulgence by exaggerating counterfactual sins . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 49, 573 - 578 . doi:10.1016/j.jesp.2012.08.012

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Epstude, K., Roese, N. J. ( 2008 ). The functional theory of counterfactual thinking . Personality and Social Psychology Review, 12, 168 - 192 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Fazio, L. K., Brashier, N. M., Payne, B. K., Marsh, E. J. ( 2015 ). Knowledge does not protect against illusory truth . Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 144, 993 - 1002 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Fiedler, K., Schott, M., Meiser, T. ( 2011 ). What mediation analysis can (not) do . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47, 1231 - 1236 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Galinsky, A. D., Moskowitz, G. B. ( 2000 ). Counterfactuals as behavioral primes: Priming the simulation heuristic and consideration of alternatives . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 36, 384 - 409 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Garry, M., Polaschek, D. L. ( 2000 ). Imagination and memory . Current Directions in Psychological Science, 9, 6 - 10 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Gaspar, J. P., Seabright, M. A., Reynolds, S. J., Yam, K. C. ( 2015 ). Counterfactual and factual reflection: The influence of past misdeeds on future immoral behavior . The Journal of Social Psychology, 155, 370 - 380 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Gerlach, K. D., Dornblaser, D. W., Schacter, D. L. ( 2014 ). Adaptive constructive processes and memory accuracy: Consequences of counterfactual simulations in young and older adults . Memory, 22, 145 - 162 . doi:10.1080/09658211.2013.779381

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Goodwin, G. P., Piazza, J., Rozin, P. ( 2014 ). Moral character predominates in person perception and evaluation . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 106, 148 - 168 . doi:10.1037/a0034726

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Gregory, W. L., Cialdini, R. B., Carpenter, K. M. ( 1982 ). Self-relevant scenarios as mediators of likelihood estimates and compliance: Does imagining make it so? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 43, 89 - 99 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Hilbig, B. E., Hessler, C. M. ( 2013 ). What lies beneath: How the distance between truth and lie drives dishonesty . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 49, 263 - 266 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Hirt, E. R., Kardes, F. R., Markman, K. D. ( 2004 ). Activating a mental simulation mind-set through generation of alternatives: Implications for debiasing in related and unrelated domains . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 40, 374 - 383 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Hirt, E. R., Markman, K. D. ( 1995 ). Multiple explanation: A consider-an-alternative strategy for debiasing judgments . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69, 1069 - 1086 . doi:10.1037/0022-3514.69.6.1069

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Kahneman, D., Miller, D. T. ( 1986 ). Norm theory: Comparing reality to its alternatives . Psychological Review, 93, 136 - 153 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Kahneman, D., Tversky, A. ( 1982 ). The simulation heuristic . In Kahneman, D., Slovic, P., Tversky, A. (Eds.), Judgment under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases (pp. 201 - 208 ). New York, NY : Cambridge University Press .

Google Scholar Crossref

Koch, A. S., Forgas, J. P. ( 2012 ). Feeling good and feeling truth: The interactive effects of mood and processing fluency on truth judgments . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 48, 481 - 485 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Koehler, D. J. ( 1991 ). Explanation, imagination, and confidence in judgment . Psychological Bulletin, 110, 499 - 519 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Kunda, Z. ( 1990 ). The case for motivated reasoning . Psychological Bulletin, 108, 480 - 498 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Levine, E. E., Schweitzer, M. E. ( 2014 ). Are liars ethical? On the tension between benevolence and honesty . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 53, 107 - 117 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Mandel, D. R., Dhami, M. K. ( 2005 ). “What I did” versus “what I might have done”: Effect of factual versus counterfactual thinking on blame, guilt, and shame in prisoners . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 41, 627 - 635 . doi:10.1016/j.jesp.2004.08.009

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Markman, K. D., Hirt, E. R. ( 2002 ). Social prediction and the “allegiance bias.” Social Cognition, 20, 58 - 86 . doi:10.1521/soco.20.1.58.20943

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Markman, K. D., McMullen, M. N. ( 2003 ). A reflection and evaluation model of comparative thinking . Personality and Social Psychology Review, 7, 244 - 267 . doi:10.1207/s15327957pspr0703_04

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Markman, K. D., McMullen, M. N. ( 2005 ). Reflective and evaluative modes of mental simulation . In Mandel, D. R., Hilton, D. J., Catellani, P. (Eds.), The psychology of counterfactual thinking (pp. 77 - 93 ). Abington, UK : Routledge .

Google Scholar

Markman, K. D., Tetlock, P. E. ( 2000 ). Accountability and close-call counterfactuals: The loser who nearly won and the winner who nearly lost . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 26, 1213 - 1224 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

McGuire, W. J. ( 1964 ). Inducing resistance to persuasion: Some contemporary approaches . Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 1, 191 - 229 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Medvec, V. H., Madey, S. F., Gilovich, T. ( 1995 ). When less is more: Counterfactual thinking and satisfaction among Olympic medalists . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 69, 603 - 610 . doi:10.1037/0022-3514.69.4.603

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Miller, D. T., Turnbull, W., McFarland, C. ( 1989 ). When a coincidence is suspicious: The role of mental simulation . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57, 581 - 589 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Miller, D. T., Visser, P. S., Staub, B. D. ( 2005 ). How surveillance begets perceptions of dishonesty: The case of the counterfactual sinner . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 89, 117 - 128 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Mueller, A. B., Skitka, L. J. (in press). Liars, damned liars, and zealots: The effect of moral mandates on transgressive advocacy acceptance . Social Psychological & Personality Science. Advance online publication. doi:10.1177/1948550617720272

Google Scholar SAGE Journals

Newman, G. E., Cain, D. M. ( 2014 ). Tainted altruism: When doing some good is evaluated as worse than doing no good at all . Psychological Science, 25, 648 - 655 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Niedenthal, P. M., Tangney, J. P., Gavanski, I. ( 1994 ). “If only I weren’t” versus “If only I hadn’t”: Distinguishing shame and guilt in counterfactual thinking . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67, 585 - 595 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Pagano, S. J., Huo, Y. J. ( 2007 ). The role of moral emotions in predicting support for political actions in post-war Iraq . Political Psychology, 28, 227 - 255 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Petrocelli, J. V., Crysel, L. C. ( 2009 ). Counterfactual thinking and confidence in blackjack: A test of the counterfactual inflation hypothesis . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 45, 1312 - 1315 . doi:10.1016/j.jesp.2009.08.004

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Petrocelli, J. V., Harris, A. K. ( 2011 ). Learning inhibition in the Monty Hall Problem: The role of dysfunctional counterfactual prescriptions . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 37, 1297 - 1311 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Petrocelli, J. V., Kammrath, L. K., Brinton, J. E., Uy, M. R. Y., Cowens, D. F. ( 2015 ). Holding on to what might have been may loosen (or tighten) the ties that bind us: A counterfactual potency analysis of previous dating alternatives . Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 56, 50 - 59 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Petrocelli, J. V., Percy, E. J., Sherman, S. J., Tormala, Z. L. ( 2011 ). Counterfactual potency . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 100, 30 - 46 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Petrocelli, J. V., Rubin, A. L., Stevens, R. L. ( 2016 ). The sin of prediction: When mentally simulated alternatives compete with reality . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 42, 1635 - 1652 . doi:10.1177/0146167216669122

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Petrocelli, J. V., Seta, C. E., Seta, J. J. ( 2012 ). Prefactual potency: The perceived likelihood of alternatives to anticipated realities . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 38, 1467 - 1479 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Petrocelli, J. V., Seta, C. E., Seta, J. J. ( 2013 ). Dysfunctional counterfactual thinking: When simulating alternatives to reality impedes experiential learning . Thinking & Reasoning, 19, 205 - 230 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

The post-truth world: Yes, I’d lie to you . ( 2016 , September 10 ). The Economist. Retrieved from http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21706498-dishonesty-politics-nothing-new-manner-which-some-politicians-now-lie-and

Google Scholar

Prentice, D. A., Miller, D. T. ( 1992 ). When small effects are impressive . Psychological Bulletin, 112, 160 - 164 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Roese, N. J. ( 1997 ). Counterfactual thinking . Psychological Bulletin, 121, 133 - 148 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Roese, N. J., Epstude, K. ( 2017 ). The functional theory of counterfactual thinking: New evidence, new challenges, new insights . Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 56, 1 - 79 .

Google Scholar Crossref

Rogers, T., Zeckhauser, R., Gino, F., Norton, M. I., Schweitzer, M. E. ( 2017 ). Artful paltering: The risks and rewards of using truthful statements to mislead others . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 112, 456 - 473 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Rossoll, N. ( 2017 , January 25 ). Conway: Crowd size at Trump’s inauguration “was historic,” considering projections and rain . ABC News. Retrieved from http://abcnewsradioonline.com/politics-news/conway-crowd-size-at-inauguration-was-historic-considering-p.html

Google Scholar

Rucker, D. D., Preacher, K. J., Tormala, Z. L., Petty, R. E. ( 2011 ). Mediation analysis in social psychology: Current practices and new recommendations . Social & Personality Psychology Compass, 5, 359 - 371 . doi:10.1111/j.1751-9004.2011.00355.x

Google Scholar Crossref

Schweitzer, M. E., Hsee, C. K. ( 2002 ). Stretching the truth: Elastic justification and motivated communication of uncertain information . Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 25, 185 - 201 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Shalvi, S., Dana, J., Handgraaf, M. J. J., De Dreu, C. K. W. ( 2011 ). Justified ethicality: Observing desired counterfactuals modifies ethical perceptions and behavior . Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 115, 181 - 190 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Sherman, S. J., Cialdini, R. B., Schwartzman, D. F., Reynolds, K. D. ( 1985 ). Imagining can heighten or lower the perceived likelihood of contracting a disease the mediating effect of ease of imagery . Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 11, 118 - 127 .

Google Scholar SAGE Journals | ISI

Shidlovski, D., Schul, Y., Mayo, R. ( 2014 ). If I imagine it, then it happened: The implicit truth value of imaginary representations . Cognition, 133, 517 - 529 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline

Skitka, L. J., Bauman, C. W., Sargis, E. G. ( 2005 ). Moral conviction: Another contributor to attitude strength or something more? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 88, 895 - 917 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Skurnik, I., Yoon, C., Park, D. C., Schwarz, N. ( 2005 ). How warnings about false claims become recommendations . Journal of Consumer Research, 31, 713 - 724 .

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Tetlock, P. E. ( 1998 ). Close-call counterfactuals and belief-system defenses: I was not almost wrong but I was almost right . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75, 639 - 652 . doi:10.1037/0022-3514.75.3.639

Google Scholar Crossref | ISI

Tetlock, P. E., Henik, E. ( 2005 ). Theory- versus imagination-driven thinking about historical counterfactuals: Are we prisoners of our preconceptions? In Mandel, D. R., Hilton, D. J., Catellani, P. (Eds.), The psychology of counterfactual thinking (pp. 199 - 216 ). New York, NY : Routledge .

Google Scholar

Tetlock, P. E., Kristel, O. V., Elson, S. B., Green, M. C., Lerner, J. S. ( 2000 ). The psychology of the unthinkable: Taboo trade-offs, forbidden base rates, and heretical counterfactuals . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 78, 853 - 870 .

Google Scholar Crossref | Medline | ISI

Wagenmakers, E.-J., Love, J., Marsman, M., Jamil, T., Ly, A., Verhagen, J., . . . Boutin, B. ( 2016 ). Bayesian inference for psychology. Part II: Example applications with JASP . Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 2017, 1 - 19 .

Google Scholar