Rated 5 out of 5 by Anonymous from I decided to buy this eyeshadow palette after hearing a review that it was an almost exact dupe to the Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance palette. When I did have my Anastasia palette I compared it to this one and was shocked to see how similar it was. The only difference would be obviously, the formulas. The one wild one is very very creamy just like the Anastasia one however the plum red shade is a little drier than the others but it still applies very well on the eyes. Overall this is an amazing dupe especially for the price and I really recommend getting this if you’ve been having your eye on the Anastasia palette for a while. ￼￼

Rated 5 out of 5 by emilyc216 from I am obsessed with this palette and I just recently got it! I decided to try this out to see if it was a solid dupe of Anastasia Beverly Hill’s Modern Renaissance and BOY DID SHE DELIVER!!! The only issue I had with this palette was with #8 (the reddish berry shade), but with a decent blending brush, I made it work! The shimmers aren’t that pigmented, but for a nice soft glam look for $4.99, it’s worth it. All that’s needed to make your soft glam look poppin is a stunning set of lashes and your favorite celebratory snack (mine is a pickle) to celebrate the fact that you just made a $4.99 palette work just as well as a $42 one and you’re good to go!

Rated 4 out of 5 by charleaf from These eyeshadow palettes are absolutely wonderful for the price. The colors are stunning and have a ton of pigment. The issues that I have with them is that there is a decent amount of fallout (nothing crazy), and they take a little bit of time to blend. If you are willing to take a couple of minutes to blend the eyeshadow, they are definitely worth it. The colors work well together. All the shades look beautiful with one layer, but if you are looking to build them up, then they build up extremely easy and are beautiful. You definitely cannot beat the price when looking for a palette of this size. I definitely recommend these palettes!

Rated 4 out of 5 by halleyl from Got the Rosé in the Air palette because I wanted to try the new shadow formula, and also was interested in the color scheme. Have heard it’s similar color-wise to the ABH modern renaissance palette, which I’m interested in but wanted to see what the colors would look like on me without spending a fortune on a palette. This is a mostly matte palette that has a variety of midtone shades that make wearable warm looks. I’m still new to warm shadows but I’m slowly warming up to them (ha) and specifically, to this palette. I think it’s a great price, and the only slight dud are the shimmers, which are significantly better with a wet brush.

Rated 4 out of 5 by xjennyyxo from I recently bought this palette because I needed something to use for a party I was attending. I tried it out prior to the dag that I needed it and I wasn't too blown away. The shadows are pigmented and show up beautifully. But, some of the shades are hard to blend, I found. They weren't blending the best and were a bit patchy so I had to work at it to get a good outcome. In terms of fallout, there's none. At least from the neutral colors I've tried. I have yet to play with the darker and bolder ones. Overall this is a nice palette and for the price, not bad at all. Would recommend, just watch out for the blending process.

Rated 4 out of 5 by Annie38 from Shimmers in reformulated formula are not good Wet n wild please, please bring back the old formula of shimmer shadows, they are nothing like they used to be :(. They were the bomb, and in the new ones the color payoff is week, they are not as creamy, vibrant ,soft or visible. They were like high end shadows. I am so sad I throw away the old Comfort zone pallete and bought the new one. I like matte shadows and added transition shades but shimmery shades are so much worse.

Rated 5 out of 5 by Anonymous from Best pallet I own! I have never tried Wet and Wild. My mistake. This pallet is versatile, beautiful and the color payoff is top notch. The colors are creamy, vibrant and stay on all day. They blend so easily, but donât disappear. After watching several reviews, I decided to try this pallet. I havenât used a drug store makeup because when I was a teen, my skin couldnât handle the formulas. I never went back. I just canât believe the quality! All I can say is âYou have come a long way baby!â

Rated 4 out of 5 by nikidichris from I have two of these palettes, Not a Basic Peach and the Modern Renascence dupe. NaBP is beautiful. Ugh. I love it so much. That blue!!! I die. I did knock the palettes down a star because I find that some of the shimmer colors are just lacking in vibrancey. They lovely, don't get me wrong, I just wish I could make them more intense without bringing in colors from other palettes I own. They do need a light hand as well, there's a bit of kick back if you dig in too hard. Makes for really easy blending, but it can also be a bit too easy to pick up too much. Seriously though, the formula is great. The price is definitely right. And the color schemes are just wonderful.

Rated 2 out of 5 by arekucosplay from Affordability is the biggest draw in for this little mini palette with the option of having 10 different shades of which two are transition shades and a mini guide on the back. The 10 colors I was only happy with about how half of them performed. The darker transition shade Blended beautifully on the crease the lighter shade was very chalky and didn't vencill well. The blue was the biggest disappointment in this palette and this was actually drew me to pick up . did not blend well, it did not come up at all, it was very translucent, and there was so much cake back from a lot of the colors in this. If this had been more than $5 I would have been extremely disappointed.