If you don't want to read my take on the controversy, skip to the separated line at the bottom of my comment. I must Chuckle as I read all the comments. This is one of the most controversial MLP fan pieces I have found yet. All I will say is that neither side can prove their argument, as several key elements of evidence are missing. things that one must have in order to prove this one way or another, such as what materials is Tirek actually made from. For all we know his bones could be made from a material That could support such a colossal form. However, whether this is the case or not, the simple fact is that the science is correct, using it would have made the show rather anti-climactic and dull. This comic is awesome, and of course not cannon so why should anyone care about whether or not it's scientifically accurate? So to put it simply science could play a role either way here. So could magic for that fact, since we hardly know all the rules of magic for the cannon world that is Equestria, but that's a whole seperate can of worms that I'm not going to get into.



I love the comic. It is well done. ^_^