Will the Riverdale Three get away with murder? Last episode, The CW series finally pulled back the curtain on the moment we’ve been dreading since the Season 3 finale flash-forward: the apparent death of Jughead Jones (Cole Sprouse). With Jughead’s girlfriend Betty Cooper (Lili Reinhart) holding a bloody rock, Archie Andrews (KJ Apa) and Veronica Lodge (Camila Mendes) quickly helped her cover up the deed… Though based on Decider’s exclusive clip, it looks like they might not get away with it for long. Or do they?

In “Chapter Seventy-Two: To Die For,” written by showrunner Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa and directed by Shannon Kohli, things are picking up where we left off, with Jughead’s seemingly dead body in possession of the Riverdale PD — and Jughead’s father, FP Jones (Skeet Ulrich) on the warpath. Betty gave up Jughead’s body in order to get one up on the Stonewall Prep squad, specifically two devious students named Bret Weston Wallis (Sean Depner) and Donna Sweett (Sarah Desjardins). It was a surprising move because all the evidence points to Betty and her friends, not to Bret or Donna (even if they’re probably responsible).

Even worse, as fans know from the flash-forwards peppered throughout Season 4, Donna and Bret accuse the Core Three of Jughead’s murder, leading to FP arresting them in the middle of science class. And one could intuit based on the grilling FP is putting them through in this scene, that’s exactly what is about to happen on tonight’s “To Die For.”

“When was the last time you saw him?” FP asks Veronica, as her father Hiram (Mark Consuelos) stares angrily in the background.

“I don’t remember, exactly,” Veronica defers, to which FP shoots back, “Stonewall students say you saw him laying on the ground, bleeding from the head. Does that jog your memory?”

Hiram shuts the line of conversation down, and things stay decidedly more mum with Archie, thanks to his, er, mum, Mary Andrews (Molly Ringwald). On last episode, “How to Get Away With Murder,” Archie confessed something about the crime to his mother. What it was, we didn’t get to hear; but she’s clearly got her son as a client, going up against the town sheriff, who is investigating the death of his own son. Just another normal day in Riverdale!

“You said the same thing to the last twenty questions I’ve asked, Mary,” FP says, frustrated by lawyer Mary. “Now, I appreciate your need to protect your boy, but I need answers. He’s gotta give me something.”

“Legally, he does not,” Mary answers. “As his lawyer, I have to make sure my client is aware of his rights.”

Things are even worse for Betty, though. In a closed door/no cameras session, her mother, Alice (Mädchen Amick) tells Betty she knows her daughter killed Jughead, though naturally to a pragmatic murderer herself (Alice killed a man back in Season 2), there are no bad feelings implied.

“I know what it’s like to be driven by rage, and desire,” Alice says, “and sometimes things can just get out of hand.”

…and that’s when FP comes back with some surprising information, based on a blood covered rock Betty switched with one covered in fake blood last episode — and a line of dialogue that may seem familiar to any fans of Ulrich’s work in the classic movie Scream. You’ll have to watch the clip above to see what comes next, but suffice to say this is likely far from the final twist and turn on this week’s Riverdale.

Riverdale airs Wednesdays at 8/7c on The CW.

Where to watch Riverdale