There were recently rumors swirling that Britney Spears would headline the Super Bowl Halftime Show in 2018. Those rumors were quashed by key sponsor PepsiCo, so we asked our readers who they think should host the Halftime Show next year for Super Bowl LII in Minneapolis. By far the artist with the most votes was chart-topping Barbadian singer Rihanna. Check out the complete poll results at the bottom of this post.

Rihanna received 46% of the vote, so not a majority, but far ahead of any other option. She’s one of the most popular singers of her generation, so she’d undoubtedly be a draw for viewers. She’s only 29-years-old, but she has already released eight studio albums in 12 years, and she has had 14 number-one singles on the Billboard Hot 100, more than any other artist except The Beatles (20), Elvis Presley (18) and Mariah Carey (18). That includes such instantly recognizable hits as “Umbrella,” “Only Girl (In the World),” and “We Found Love.” She has also been featured on a number of other artists’ singles, so she could surely attract some high-profile guests to join her, including Jay-Z, DJ Khaled, Eminem, and Calvin Harris, to name a few.

Pink finished second in our poll with 10%, followed by Taylor Swift with 9%, but 19% of readers actually had other ideas not included in our poll. Here are some of the suggestions they made:

SIGN UPfor Gold Derby’s free newsletter with latest predictions

E.J. Griffiths: “Dave Matthews Band. It would be nice to incorporate both singing/jam sessions in a super bowl performance.”

Declan: “Jennifer Lopez is the perfect choice. She is constantly overlooked by award shows and with over 20 years in the business is still underrated. She’d hands down put on one of the greatest Super Bowls of all time.”

Jeff: “METALLICA!! If you want a real show.”

Drew: “Billy Joel. Still selling out arenas, and it’s an obvious choice.”

Do you agree with any of the above choices? You can keep voting in our poll here, and join the discussion on this and more with your fellow music fans in our forums.

DISCUSSthe Super Bowl Halftime Show with Hollywood insiders in our notorious forums