Update (Sept. 18, 11:50 a.m.): New photos from the Emmys and the awards’ afterparties indicate that the man playing Teddy Perkins was neither Glover nor Stanfield; instead, the man in question seems to be a mysterious third option. (And no, he’s not Hiro Mirai, either.) Representatives for Atlanta told Vanity Fair they have “no clue” who came to the show dressed as the mysterious character. Which can only mean one thing: collusion.

The original post continues below.

Teddy Perkins is a stranger to the Emmys no longer. At Monday night’s ceremony, someone showed up fully in character as the creepy, Michael Jackson-inspired performer who made his debut in a standout episode of Atlanta, sitting methodically in the same row as stars like Insecure’s Issa Rae and Yvonne Orji. Gaze upon his visage and tremble in fear.

While it was initially assumed that Donald Glover, who played the character in the show, was the one dressed up as Perkins, a later cut to the crowd revealed Glover sitting comfortably in the audience. There’s no way he could have changed that quickly, right? The swift detectives of the Internet then determined it must have been Atlanta co-star Lakeith Stanfield, also in attendance at the Emmys, in full Perkins drag.

The episode, also titled “Teddy Perkins,” was nominated for three Emmys: outstanding directing for a comedy series (Hiro Murai), outstanding editing for a comedy (Kyle Reiter), and outstanding cinematography for a comedy (Christian Sprenger, who ended up winning at the Creative Arts awards). Glover was also nominated for four Emmys overall, including lead actor in a comedy.