Gifter pretty much nailed it with so much awesome. She found that I'm a fan of Sailor Moon and located an amazing Luna scarf (squeeee) and noted that I liked skulls and found me a red skull scarf (yee). When I pulled out the Luna scarf, I jumped up and ran to my boyfriend's room to yell at him and say "LOOK OMFG LOOK!". He blinked in excitement.

And the clever gifter also included hot chocolate because what better to go with a scarf package? Thank you Redditor, you are the best!