Paul Kohler suffered a fractured eye socket, a fracture to his left jawbone, a broken nose and bruising that left him ‘utterly unrecognisable’

This article is more than 5 years old

This article is more than 5 years old

Four burglars who took part in a raid which left a university professor “savagely” beaten have been jailed.

Paul Kohler, 55, suffered a fractured eye socket, a fracture to his left jawbone, a broken nose and bruising that left him “utterly unrecognisable” during the attack at his home in Wimbledon, south London.

His wife, Samantha MacArthur, 50, was also threatened by the intruders on the night of 11 August last year.

Pawel Honc, of no fixed address, and Mariusz Tomaszewski, of Crusoe Road, Mitcham, south London, were both sentenced at Kingston crown court to 19 years after admitting grievous bodily harm with intent and aggravated burglary.

Oskar Pawlowicz, of Pitcairn Road in Mitcham, and Dawid Tychon, 29, of no fixed address, were both sentenced to 13 years after they pleaded guilty to aggravated burglary. The four are all Polish nationals.



Sentencing the men, Judge Susan Tapping said they had targeted Kohler’s house either because they had the expectation of finding items of significant value to steal or because they chose the wrong address to collect a debt.



Kohler, who was flanked by his wife and three of his four daughters - Eloise, Beth and Saskia - held his jaw and watched the men intently as they were given their sentence.

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Paul Kohler with his family outside Kingston crown court in London. Photograph: David Wilcock/PA

The academic, who is professor of law at the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, hugged his daughters and wife and smiled afterwards.

Honc, 24, Tomaszewski, 32, Pawlowicz, 30, and Tychon, 29, all remained calm as they were sent down.

Judge Tapping said that all the defendants had been under a combination of drugs and alcohol on the day of the attack.

Referring to the witness statement Kohler gave on Thursday, she said it had shown his “generosity of spirit”.

She told the defendants: “One matter it contained was for you to explain why his family and him were targeted. This explanation would help them all but your mitigation did not help at all or was at odds with what others had said. Without this explanation he understandably questions the true value of any remorse expressed.”

Speaking outside court, Kohler said: “I feel vindicated by the sentence but I don’t want to be vindictive about it. I take no pleasure in their deservedly long sentence - and it is a long sentence, and that’s right and proper. It will be difficult for them, as it should be, but I’m not going to sit here and jump up and down looking delighted about it.

“I still feel some anger, I hope I don’t feel bitter. I hope in time that will pass.”

Kohler said he would have slight double vision for the rest of his life and that his wife still gets flashbacks.

“My daughter is still traumatised by it, as you saw in court today she burst into tears when they were being sentenced,” he added.

“But those things will pass, the family is strong and the family learns from the good and the ill that happens to it.”

The five-minute attack began when Kohler went to answer the door at around 10pm while his wife, 24-year-old daughter Eloise and her boyfriend, Geraint, were upstairs.

The four men burst in wearing scarves to conceal their identities and blue latex gloves.

Tychon shouted “Where’s the money?” and Kohler screamed “You’ve got the wrong address”, the court heard.

Kohler was pushed to the floor and Honc sat on him and repeatedly punched him in the face while another man kicked him in the head.

He was also threatened by Tychon, who held a wooden cabinet door over his head ready to swing it down on him.

Two of the burglars went upstairs, pushed MacArthur and covered her face, threatening to hurt her if she moved.

Eloise and Geraint were able to hide in her bedroom and lock the door while they called the police.

An Apple Mac laptop, an HP laptop, two mobile phones and jewellery worth around £2,000 were taken and subsequently recovered.

The court heard that, apart from Honc, all the other defendants had long criminal records in their home country, with 32 convictions between them.

Pawlowicz had also been convicted in the UK for a raft of offences including sexual assault and affray.