Contenders: Georgia, Dee, and Ninja

Dee is the most significant surprise power player. The girl tied for most daily challenge wins with Cara on WOTW 1 and followed up her excellent rookie performance by winning WOTW 2 and outperforming other elite females in the final. She also proved to be a ride or die friend whose biggest fault is being too loyal.

While Challenge fans have not taken much of a liking to Ninja Natalie, she was the top female performer of WOTW 1 and made the Final of WOTW2. She also has a 3–0 elimination record.

Georgia has a 4–1 elimination record, killed the daily challenges on WOTW 1, made the final of that season, and is poised to win a season one day.

Dark Horse: Mattie

I think Mattie would be up there with the “contenders” if she had competed on War of the Worlds 2. It’s hard to compete against three girls who have two quality seasons versus her one.

5th Place: Jenny

Jenny is a good competitor; she just hasn’t had a lot of opportunities to show it yet.

FUNNIEST COMMENTARY

The Favorite: DaVonne

DaVonne got put on the Challenge and Big Brother because of her exuberant personality and her quick comebacks. She also just happened to be a solid competitor. My favorite DaVonne moment from War of the Worlds 1 was her laughing after realizing Wes had to be her partner in a daily challenge. It was so simple, yet so iconic.

Contenders: Turbo and Zach

When Zach is not an angry misogynist grunch, he is this hilarious and charismatic guy who has consistently great confessionals. Whether it be him talking about Disney Princesses or him rolling his eyes at Team USA on this season, Zach is funny. The problem is the rest of his personality.

People began using the phrase “pussy chicken” because of Turbo, and he’s had a bunch of cute little quotes while on the show. Although, some of his jokes kind of veer on the violent side, which is problematic considering he was kicked off this season for continuing to threaten Jordan.

Dark Horses: Bear, Tori, and Georgia

Tori is good at commentary as she acts as a reliable narrator, but I’m not sure if I would categorize her as “funny.” She fills a vital role for the show but doesn’t have the zingers like the others. Bear is a high volume commentator. Due to the way he conducts himself, everything is a joke, so it’s almost a battle of quality/quantity. Similar to Tori, Georgia is more of a narrator than a commentator. However, her joke about the team being okay if Joss died early onto War of the Worlds 2 had me choking.

COMEBACK PLAYER OF THE YEAR