EW has learned that the star of This Is 40 and fan of Mac and Me will appear alongside Scott in the latest installment of the only franchise brave enough to attempt to re-create the opening credits of ’80s TV shows. (And, yes, Jeff Probst will be returning as the host.) The first Greatest Event boasted a shot-for-shot remake of Simon & Simon‘s title sequence, the second took on Hart to Hart, and the third got a little Too Close for Comfort. No word on what classic show is up for re-enactment this time around, but Adult Swim just released the photo above to EW that should fuel the speculation game until the new special airs Thursday night, Jan. 23, at midnight on Adult Swim. Study those retro-coifs and white tees carefully before entering your best guess below.