BBC too?

It’s not every day you hear Joni Mitchell quoted in the House of Lords. But in a debate on the future of the BBC today, Lord Young of Norwood Green (a mere whippersnapper on the red benches, at the age of 77) couldn’t help citing the songwriter’s immortal line: “You don’t know what you’ve got, till it’s gone”.‌

That sentiment was echoed by speaker after speaker as peers let rip at the intimidatory noises coming from No.10 on the licence fee in recent weeks. Given the wealth of former and current BBC staff in the Lords, it’s of course unsurprising that many of them would want to circle the wagons around the Corporation.

Nevertheless, the dark warnings many of them expressed will have unnerved more than a few Conservatives. Melvyn Bragg (whose superb In Our Time series on Radio 4 really is worth the licence fee alone), Joan Bakewell, Margaret Jay and David Puttnam have seen previous attempts to bully the Beeb. But they all said they feared it was now facing the biggest ever political threat to its existence.

And the villain of the piece, cited repeatedly, was Dominic Cummings. Boris Johnson’s chief adviser was director of the New Frontiers Foundation think tank in 2004 when it produced a string of blogs that attacked the BBC. Cummings was one of just two staff at the think tank.

Bakewell quoted a passage calling for “the undermining of the BBC’s credibility and…the creation of a Fox News equivalent / talk radio shows / bloggers etc to shift the centre of gravity”. There was this prescient line too: “Effort should be diverted from Today to programmes that affect the public.” Don’t forget this was written 16 years ago. Today now does indeed suffer a boycott and sources talk of plans to ‘whack’ the BBC by axeing its licence fee income.

Several peers contrasted the BBC’s responsible reporting on the coronavirus outbreak to the way the US media (and its president) have reacted. Of course all British broadcasters, and most newspapers, have been pretty measured in their coverage, but Puttnam rammed home the Ofcom finding that the BBC has emerged as “the digital gold standard” for trusted information in an era of fake news.

What was striking today was the way it was Labour peers who got up to defend the Corporation, despite occasional disputes with this or that bit of coverage. It was a stark contrast to the way many Jeremy Corbyn supporters routinely fire abuse at the BBC as much as, if not more than, its Tory critics. I remember vividly attending a Corbyn rally in Swansea in 2016 and hearing for the first time in my life a string of ostensibly normal people telling me that ‘the BBC is the enemy’.‌

Plenty of the horrific abuse doled out to Laura Kuennsberg on Twitter is from the Left, and shameful heckles were directed at her from Labour members at campaign events in the last election.‌

One singularly low moment came last month when Dawn Butler tried to use a deputy leader hustings to attack the Tories for attacking the BBC. “Now they want to get rid of the BBC. So in a way I thought, ok, that will teach you. But then we do need to ensure that it stays in public ownership. We need to ensure that there is some independence.” Yes, ‘that will teach you’.

Of course the BBC is far from perfect. There is in fact a perfectly credible (and progressive) case for decriminalising the licence fee. HuffPost UK recently spent a day in a magistrates court and found those punished for failing to pay up were among society’s most vulnerable. Read more

Read also: UK remains committed to positive global role after Brexit, defence secretary says