Now that the contestants on Bachelor in Paradise can’t drink non-stop from sunup to sundown, they have to find other ways to amuse themselves, and in this exclusive clip from Monday’s episode, we get a somewhat stomach-turning glimpse into how the Bippers passed the time. During a game of “Guess what’s going in your mouth?” — created by loveable dolphin-shark lunatic Alexis — a blindfolded Jack Stone must identify the foods that Alexis shoves into his piehole.

Oh, did I say foods? Let me rephrase: Foods and one dead sea creature. Yep, you read that right:

Photo: ABC More

A completely grossed-out Jack Stone lurches away from the foul object (props to the Bipper who jokingly urged him to “trust the process” from the sidelines), and when he finds out it was a dead crab “that’s been rotting in the pool for a week,” he immediately threatens revenge. “This might cost her a rose,” Jack Stone tells us. “We’ll see.”

Do you think Alexis’s prank will cost her another free week in Paradise? Post your thoughts below.

Bachelor in Paradise airs Mondays and Tuesdays at 8 p.m. on ABC.

Read more from Yahoo TV: